• Embed Doc
  • Copy Link
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
 
1
BINGHAMMCCUTCHEN
LLPDanielAlberstone(SBN105275)2RolandTellis(SBN186269)SaraJasperEpstein(SBN240577)
.3
The
WaterGarden
FOUlih
Floor,North
Tower
4162026thStreetSantaMonica,
CA
90404-40605Telephone:310.907.1000Facsimile:.310.907.20006Email:dan.alberstone@bingham.comroland.tellis@bingham.com
7
AttorneysforDefendant8ScreenActorsGuild
CONFORMED
COpy
OFORIGINALFILED
L,,,
< \ n ~ e l c s
SuperiorCourt
/-Irr\
062009
15
AdamArkin,etaI.,16Defendants.
SUPERlORCOURT
OFTHESTATEOFCALIFORNIA
COUNTY
OFLOSANGELES
CENTRALDISTRlCT
910
11
12
13
1417
18
1920
21
22232425262728AlanRosenberg,etaI.,Plaintiffs,
v.
No.BC406900[AssignedtoHon.Judith
C.
Chirlin,
Dept
19]
DEFENDANTSCREENACTORS
GUILD'SANSWERTOPLAINTIFFS'UNVERIFIEDFIRSTAMENDEDCOMPLAINT
ComplaintFiled:February3,2009TrialDate:Noneset
DOCUMENTPREPAREDONRECYCLEDPAPER
DEFENDANTSCREENACTORSGUILD'SANSWER
TO
PLAINTIFF'SUNVERIFIEDFIRSTAMENDEDCOMPLAINT
•
,""
..
"
...,
.....
'"
"''''''''0
1f\
""""',]"7'1f'l"
 
IDefendantScreenActorsGuild("SAG"),answeringforitselfandnot
on
behalf
of
2anyotherdefendant,herebyanswerstheunverifiedFirstAmendedComplaint("FAC")of3plaintiffsAlanRosenberg,Anne-MarieJohnson,DianeLaddandKentMcCord(collectively,4"Plaintiffs")asfollows:5
GENERALDENIAL
6
L
Pursuant
to
CaliforniaCode
of
CivilProcedureSection431.30(d),SAGdenies7generallyandspecificallyeachandeveryallegation
of
theFAC,andfurtherdeniesthatPlaintiffs8havesufferedanydamageorinjuryorthatPlaintiffsareentitled
to
anyrelief9Asseparateaffirmativedefenses,SAGallegesasfollows:
10
AFFIRMATIVEDEFENSES
II
FIRSTAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
12
(Failure
to
StateaClaim)TheFACfails
to
statefactssufficienttoconstituteacause
of
actionagainst
.
3
14
SAG
15
SECONDAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
16
(LawfulConduct)
17
3.
Atalltimespertinent
to
thisaction,SAGactedlawfully,includingwithrespect
18
to
thestatutesandprovisions
of
SAG'sBylawsthatarecitedintheFAC.
19
THIRDAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
20
(Mootness)
21
4.
TheFAC
is
barredinwhole
or
inpartbythedoctrineof
moot
ness.Plaintiffs'
22
twocausesofactionpurport
to
challengethevalidity
of
awrittenassentapprovedbyamajority
23
of
SAG'sBoard
of
Directors(the"Board")
on
January26,2009(the"WrittenAssent").
24
However,onFebruary
8,
2009,thesameactspreviouslypassedbytheWrittenAssentwere
25
lawfullyreaffirmedandreadoptedbyamajority
of
theBoardatadulynoticedmeeting.
As26
such,theFAChasbeenrenderedlegallymoot
by
subsequentevents.
27
III
28
III
DOCUMENTPREPAREDONRECYCLEDPAPER
DEFENDANTSCREENACTORSGUILD'SANSWERTOPLAINTIFF'SUNVERIFIEDFIRSTAMENDEDCOMPLAINT
A
''''''''"'"10'1:
1I'H'l"OQH\.nonnl1.i'H"I,f
 
2
3
5.
FOURTHAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
(AdvisoryOpinion)TheFACisbarredinwholeorinpartbecauseitimpemrissiblyseeksan4advisoryopinionfromthisCourt.Plaintiffs'twocauses
of
actionpurporttochallengethe5validity
of
theWrittenAssentdatedJanuary26,2009.However,onFebruary
8,
2009,thesame6actspreviouslypassedbytheWrittenAssentwerelawfullyreaffirmedandreadoptedbya7majority
of
theBoardatadulynoticedmeeting.Becausethereisnolongeranyjudiciable8controversybetweenthepartiesthat
is
capable
of
specificrelief,theF
AC
seeksnothingmore9thananacademicandhypotheticaldecision.
10
FIFTHAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
II
(JudicialAbstention)
12
6.
TheF
AC
isbarredinitsentirety
by
thedoctrine
of
judicialabstention,which
13
providesthatCourtsshallnotinterfereintheinternaldisputes
of
unionsandothervoluntary
14
associations.
15
SIXTHAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
16
(Preemption)
17
7TheCourtlacksjurisdictionoverthesubjectmatter
of
thecauses
of
action
18
alleged
by
Plaintiffs,whicharepreemptedinwholeorinpart
by
theLaborManagement
19
ReportingandDisclosureAct,29
US.C
§§
401etseq.20
SEVENTHAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
21
(FailuretoComplywithPre-FilingRequirements
of
Code
of
CivilProcedure§425.15)
228.
No
reliefmaybeobtainedundertheFACbyreason
of
Plaintiffs'failureto
23
complywithSection425.15
of
theCode
of
CivilProcedure.24
EIGHTHAFFIRMATIVEDEFENSE
25
(UncleanHands)269.
By
reason
of
theirwrongfulandunfairactsandomissions,Plaintiffshave27uncleanhandsandarebarredfromassertingany
of
theclaimsassertedinthe
FAG
28
2
DOCUMENTPREPAREDONRECYCLEDPAPER
DEFENDANTSCREENACTORSGUILD'SANSWERTOPLAINTIFF'SUNVERIFIEDFIRSTAMENDEDCOMPLAINT
•'''·'''''''''n.,r
"'''''''0
,n
nr.nl1'}'}.,'lt'l"
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...