Embed Doc
Copy Link
Readcast
Collections

CommentGo Back

Download

377

The

Report

on

an

Inquiryinto

anAllegation

of

aConspiracy

to

Pervert

the

Course

of

Justice

in

Scotland

To

theRightHonourabletheLordRodger

of

Earlsferry

QC

HerMajesty'sAdvocate

By

W

A

Nimmo

Smith

QC

and

J

DFriel,Regional

Procurator

Fiscal

of

North

StrathclydeReturntoanAddress

of

theHonourabletheHouse

of

Commonsdated26thJanuary1993

Orderedby

theHouse

of

Commons

tobe

printed

26thJanuary

1993

EDINBURGH:HMSO

The

RightHonourable

the

LordRodger

of

Earlsferry

QC

Her

Majesty'sAdvocate

Indischarge

of

theremit

set

outin

your

letter

to

usdated

18

September

1992,

we

have

the

honour

tosubmit

our

Report

herewith.

Although

it

is

submittedto

you,since

it

is

intended

forpublication

we

propose

hereafter

to

refer

toyou

in

thethird

person.

Youtook

office

on

22

April

1992,

andaccordingly

when

describingeventsafter

that

date

we

shallcall

you

"the

LordAdvocate".References

to"theLordAdvocate"priortothat

dateareto

your

predecessors

in

office.YourssincerelyWA

NIMMO

SMITH

QC

J

D

FRIEL

Edinburgh,

15

December

1992

THE

REPORT

ON

AN

INQUIRYINTO

AN

ALLEGATION

OF

A

CONSPIRACY

TO

PERVERTTHE

COURSE

OF

JUSTICE

IN

SCOTLAND

CONTENTS

Paragraphs

Page

Part

1

Our

Remit

1.1to1.171

Part

2

The

Judiciary,the

Crown

andthePolice2.1to2.158

Part

3

Homosexuality

and

the

Criminal

Law3.1

to3.7

13

Part4

Homosexuality

and

theHolding

of

4.1to4.316JudicialOffice

Part

5

The

Resignation

of

LordDervaird

5.1to5.417Part6

ColinTucker's

Statement

or

"List"6.1to6.3219

Part

7

Rumoursabout

Members

of

theLegal7.1to7.1328Profession

Part

8"Jason"the

Rent

Boy

andthe"Gay8.1to8.8

31

Judges

Scandal"

Part

9Michael

Junior's

Story

about

a"Judge"9.1to9.634

Part

10Allegations

by

Stephen

Conroy

against10.1

to

10.3336

Sheriff

DouglasAllan

Part

11

Other

AllegationsagainstSheriffDouglas11.1

to

11.1953Allan

Part

12

The

Orr

Report

12.1to12.2858

Part

13

RobertHenderson

QC

13.1

to

13.2266

Part

14

HMA

vArthurColinTucker

14.1

to

14.22

72

Part

15

HMA

vCordonMichaelMayandArthur

15.1

to

15.2479

ColinTucker

Part

16

HMA

vNeilBruceDuncanandOthers

16.1

to

16.4385Part17

HMA

vStephenMarkConroy

17.1

to

17.1696

Part

18Conclusions18.1

to

18.14100

of 00

Leave a Comment

Magic Circle Affair

"The Report on an Inquiry into an Allegation of a Conspiracy to Pervert the Course of Justice in Scotland"

Extract:
"The part of Orr's report which relates to th... (More) "The Report on an Inquiry into an Allegation of a Conspiracy to Pervert the Course of Justice in Scotland"

Extract:
"The part of Orr's report which relates to the case against May and Tucker refers to Tucker's homosexuality, states that May is a practising homosexual, and alleges that May was involved in the running of an hotel and nightclub in Thailand. According to the report this place

"is openly engaged in providing services for homosexuals particularly in the procurement of young male prostitutes or rent boys for the sexual gratification of visitors. The complex is thought to have been frequented by several persons popular on the Edinburgh gay scene, including the gay element of the legal fraternity."

We are in possession of no evidence which would support this latter allegation."

Comment: The Sunday Herald article "THE STRANGE TALE OF TRANSVESTITES, CROOKED COPS, A MUTILATED BODY AND TWO SCOTS KNOWN AS THE GAY McMAFIA" published on 05 Oct, 2003 seems at odds with the QC's (now Law Lord's) conclusion. See:

http://findarticles.co...

This piece of investigative journalism by award-winning journalist Neil McKay deals with Gordon May and a Thai gay-sex tourist hotel murder/scandal.

More recently another key player in the Magic Circle affair died in Thailand. Martin Frutin contradicted the allegations of the rent boys and his evidence was accepted by Nimmo Smith. Frutin fled Scotland and took up residence in Thailand were he became a prominent member of the local Masonic Lodge, Pattaya West Winds, as well as the gay scene. His death is reported in "FLAMBOYANT SCOT ON YARD CHILD SEX ABUSE WATCH LIST DIES IN THAILAND":

http://www.andrew-drum...

Despite the fact that Foreign Travel Orders were introduced in 2007 to stop paedophiles visiting countries plagued by child sex tourism, such as Cambodia, Thailand and India, Frutin was able to travel between Scotland and Thailand freely. This highlights the failure of the Scottish Courts to grant a single order banning travel by paedophiles, see "COURT FAILING TO BAN PAEDOPHILES FOREIGN SEX TRIPS", Scottish Daily Express:

http://www.express.co....

The latest development is the clearing by a Thai court (judgement included in article link below) of the investigative journalist Andrew Drummond who faced jail after writing articles that dealt with Gordon May, and among other things, his trial in the Teague Homes case at Dunfermline where he was-- with co-defendant Colin Tucker-- sensationally cleared of embezzlement. Something dealt with in detail in the Nimmo-Smith/Friel Report. However the Thai court came to different conclusions regarding the £243,438.00 embezzled from Teague about which they said:"However, the income of Teague Homes Co., Ltd. was spent to open of the biggest gay sex bar in Asia. The Court saw that it presented the fact of the case. Such article was just information which is public information."

See: “LOCK STOCK AND TWO SMOKING BOYZ” at: http://www.andrew-drum...
(Less)

Download or Print

3,383 Reads

Info and Rating

Category:	Government Docs
Rating:
Upload Date:	10/02/2009
Copyright:	Attribution Non-commercial
Tags:	“nimmo smith – friel report” “lord dervaird” “colin tucker’s list” (more tags) “nimmo smith – friel report” “lord dervaird” “colin tucker’s list” “jason the rent boy” “gay judges scandal” “michael junior” “stephen conroy” “sheriff douglas allan” “the orr report” “hma v arthur colin tucker” “hma v gordon michael may and arthur colin tucker” “hma v neil bruce duncan and others” “hma v stephen mark conroy” fettesgate “ian mcfarlane walker” “tam dalyell” martin frutin pattaya west winds masonic lodge foreign travel orders teague homes (fewer)

Flag document for inapproriate content

Uploaded by

Download

Embed Doc
Copy Link
Add To Collection
Comments
Readcast
Share

×

Share on Scribd:

Readcast

TIP Press Ctrl-F⌘F to quickly search anywhere in the document.

Searching...

Result 00 of 00

00 results for result for

p.

Sections

More from This User

Related Documents

More From This User

Justice Committee Report 13 September Tom Devine

Evidence of Prof Tom Devine to the Justice Committee of the Scottish Parliame...

Never Mind the Quality 003

Editorial from the Scottish Sun December 1992

Nimmo the Dimmo002

Page one and seven from the Scottish Sun of Saturday 20 December 1992.

Common Good Obligations of Local Authorities in Scotland

Fife Common Good assets by Burgh

List of Fife Council's common good assets by Burgh, showing that about 40% of...

Solicitor Censured Dunfermline Press 1990

Gifford Bruce top Dunfermline lawyer censured and fined by a Scottish Solicit...

A Tale of Three Documents

Professor David Rudenstine, an expert on Constitutional Law and Head of the C...

Magic Circle Affair

"The Report on an Inquiry into an Allegation of a Conspiracy to Pervert the C...

Common Good Report Fife Council

Idiot's guide to common good assets by Miss Mary E Mackenzie

They belong to us all and are stewarded on our behalf by the 32 Scottish coun...

Chapter 7 of Save Our Glen website entitled Future campaigns to opp...

Chapter 7: Future campaigns to oppose commercial development in the Glen @ ht...

Chapter 6 of Save Our Glen website entitled Reflection on how the T...

Chapter 6 of Save Our Glen @ http://www.saveourglen.com tells of how the Trus...

Chapter 5 Save Our Glen Website is Pittencrieff Park Safe With a Tr...

Chapter 5 of Save Our Glen website @ http://www.saveourglen.com/ describes ho...

Chapter 4 of Save Our Glen website Harvard Business School and Seco...

Chapter 4 of Save Our Glen website at http://www.saveourglen.com deals with t...

Chapter 3 of Save Our Glen website entitled Recent history of the T...

Chapter 3, Save Our Glen website charts the changing fortunes of the Carnegie...

Chapter 2 Early history of the Carnegie Dunfermline Trust the Trust...

Chapter 2 of the Save Our Glen website deals with the original trust deed and...

Chapter 1 Andrew Carnegie and Pitencrieff Park or the Glen

Chapter 1 of Save Our Glen website deals with the life of the young Andrew Ca...

Welcome to Save Our Glen the website dedicated to saving Pittencrie...

Save Our Glen is a website dedicated to protect the Pittencrieff Park Dunferm...

Related Docuements

THE WORLD THAT LENIN SHAPED

by William F. Buckley , Jr.

HIS RHYTHMS WERE NOT OF THIS WORLD

by William F. Buckley , Jr.

Let Us Talk of Many Things (The Collected Speeches)

by William F. Buckley , Jr.

At the beginning of the her shift, Paula Rose McKenzie RN asks herself why sh...

At the beginning of the her shift, Paula Rose McKenzie RN asks herself why sh...

Breathe Not the Sins of Others

At the beginning of the her shift, Paula Rose McKenzie RN asks herself why sh...

9249781 Thrift by Samuel Smiles

From alextestscribd