The Atlantic

The Utility of Precision in Opposing Injustice

Building a successful coalition requires engaging with the complexity of racism, bigotry, and systemic disadvantage.
Source: Ricardo Arduengo / Reuters

Over the years, I’ve heard well-meaning people argue that events including the LAPD’s beating of Rodney King, the questioning of Barack Obama’s birth certificate, and the slaying of Trayvon Martin have nothing to do with race or racism. The impulse to deny or minimize racism, to contrive any other explanation (Occam’s razor be damned) for even the most racially charged incidents, is an ongoing, pernicious feature of American life. And it provokes a necessary backlash from folks who want fellow citizens to see what is in front of their noses.

Anti-racism has its own excesses at the opposite extreme—that Oberlin’s dining hall serves inauthentic sushi, for instance, is not an example of racism in American life, and such claims only make it more difficult to win hearts and minds.

But those excesses do nothing to alter more important realities: that police culture in cities like , and , has disproportionately harmed and brutalized African Americans for decades; that Joe Arpaio spent years of Hispanics in Maricopa, County, Arizona; that innocent Muslims are in hate crimes, especially after terrorist attacks; that most Jewish journalists I know are taunted with anti-Semitism on Twitter; that white supremacists have recently slaughtered people at and an ; that many African Americans continue to feel the burdens of that plundered their wealth; that the president of the United States lashed out at Mexicans, Mexican Americans, and Muslims in a campaign where

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic6 min read
The Unseen Pandemic
Refugee camps such as those in Bangladesh are a tinderbox for the spread of the coronavirus.
The Atlantic7 min readPolitics
Common-Good Constitutionalism Reveals the Dangers of Any Non-originalist Approach to the Constitution
Here are three of the most common criticisms of originalism made by non-originalists: (1) Originalism does not provide a determinate answer to contested questions—anything beyond, say, how many senators a state gets, or how old a person must be to be
The Atlantic5 min readPolitics
The Economy Is Collapsing. So Are Trump’s Reelection Chances.
For Donald Trump’s reelection campaign, many numbers matter: the number of Americans who get sick and perish from the coronavirus. The number of months before the economy begins to reopen and rebound. The number of Americans who lose their health ins