Are algorithms a fair way to predict who’ll skip bail?

Algorithms help some judges determine who gets out on bail. "Algorithms are good at narrowly estimating risk, but they can't set policy," says Sharad Goel.

Simple, statistically informed decision rules can dramatically improve judicial determinations, says Sharad Goel. But, he cautions, algorithms are not a complete fix.

Courts nationwide are making greater use of computer algorithms to help determine whether defendants should be released into the community while they await trial. The idea is to accurately determine whether a defendant poses a flight risk or a danger to the community, and reduce the potential for human bias.

San Francisco and Chicago are among the jurisdictions actively using pretrial risk assessment algorithms, says Goel, an assistant professor of management science and engineering at Stanford University.

Goel has studied the use of algorithms in complex decision-making and examined the fairness of such tools and is coauthor of a recent Harvard Business Review article on the topic.

“Algorithms are good at narrowly estimating risk, but they can’t set policy,” Goel says. “They can’t tell you how many people to detain, or whether we should end money bail altogether, as some cities have done. They can’t tell you how much to invest in pretrial services or what those services should be. And they can’t incorporate every factor in every case, so we still need humans to make the final decision.”

Goel recently discussed some of the benefits and complexities of using these algorithms with Vignesh Ramachandran of Stanford Engineering. Here are excerpts from that conversation:

The post Are algorithms a fair way to predict who’ll skip bail? appeared first on Futurity.

More from Futurity

Futurity3 min readSelf-Improvement
Older Adults Better Handle Stress Of Type 2 Diabetes
Age plays a critical role in the well-being of people newly diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, researchers report. A new study finds younger patients more susceptible to psychological distress, resulting in worse health outcomes. “We found we can evalua
Futurity3 min read
Supercharged Trash Gas Could Produce More Green Energy
Synthetic compounds called “siloxanes” from everyday products like shampoo and motor oil are finding their way into landfills and supercharging the biogas those landfills produce, researchers report. While it’s a problem today, the researchers say it
Futurity3 min readSociety
Doctors Give Electronic Health Records An ‘F’
Electronic health records may improve quality and efficiency for doctors and patients alike—but physicians give them an “F” for usability and they may contribute to burnout, according to new research. By contrast, in similar but separate studies, Goo