The Atlantic

Who Would the Founders Impeach?

As discussion of removing Trump ripples through the political world, a legal scholar argues that impeachment is both an essentially American tool and widely misunderstood.
Source: Ian Wagreich / The Aspen Institute

It’s hard to find defenders of impeachment—or at least, it’s hard to find good faith, consistent defenders of impeachment.

Just look at former House Speaker Newt Gingrich, who once voted to impeach President Bill Clinton for obstruction of justice, only to recently assert that it’s impossible for a president, and in particular Donald Trump, whom he supports, to obstruct justice. Most of the hypocrisies are more garden variety. When Republicans seek to impeach a Democratic president, Democrats howl that it’s unscrupulous naked politics; when a Republican is in the White House, Democrats rediscover the value of impeachment, while the GOP suddenly recognizes its recklessness.

Recent debates

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic5 min read
Error and Trial
As the Senate impeachment trial droned on Thursday afternoon, Representative Jerry Nadler, one of the House managers prosecuting President Donald Trump, launched into a long, scholarly lecture on the constitutional remedy for presidential “abuse, bet
The Atlantic3 min readPolitics
Obama’s 2016 Warning: Trump Is a ‘Fascist’
The newly revealed comment is one of the former president’s strongest known critiques of his successor.
The Atlantic3 min readPolitics
Hillary Clinton: Mark Zuckerberg Has ‘Authoritarian’ Views on Misinformation
Facebook has traded moral accountability for commercial gain, the former secretary of state tells The Atlantic. Its founder’s reasoning is “Trumpian.”