The Atlantic

If Porn Could Be Banned, Why Not AR-15s?

People willing to discuss regulations on sex-related media should conceivably be open to discussing further regulation of firearms.
Source: Rich Pedroncelli / AP

Pornography is officially a “public-health crisis” in Utah, according to 2016 legislation. The Republican representative Todd Weiler, who championed the bill and told me at the time that he sees a lot of porn in his Twitter feed, has been working to make it illegal for internet service providers to provide internet that contains porn.

When I covered this story it felt like a fringe movement, born of conflicting ideas about the role of government in public health. Banning porn means expanding government oversight in a way that infringes on personal liberties and squelches an enormous industry that creates wealth and jobs. These tenets seem contrary to many conservatives’ stated objectives and free-market approach, yet it was conservatives beating the drum.

This week, the columnist Ross Douthat took the argument mainstream with his “Let’s Ban: “Porn oppresses women, eviscerates manhood, destroys marriage, robs children of purity, and enslaves people in private morose self-indulgence. Ban it indeed.”

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic5 min readPolitics
The Migration Driven by Developed Countries
Migration can be driven both by a richer country’s doing, as well as a poorer one’s undoing.
The Atlantic7 min readPolitics
College-Educated Voters Are Ruining American Politics
Many college-educated people think they are deeply engaged in politics. They follow the news—reading articles like this one—and debate the latest developments on social media. They might sign an online petition or throw a $5 online donation at a pres
The Atlantic6 min readPolitics
Progressives Warn of a Great Deflation
“Please don’t make me vote for Joe Biden!” a flock of teenagers pleaded in a series of videos posted to the social-media app TikTok earlier this month. But as the Iowa caucuses draw closer, a Biden nomination is looking more likely by the day. Lefty