Poets & Writers

Submit That Manuscript!

JUST a few days ago I received a rejection letter from the Southern Review. The e-mail read, in part, “Dear Joey Franklin: Thank you for sending us [your essay]. We enjoyed this piece, but we didn’t feel it was right for the Southern Review.”

How to describe the emotions wrapped up in this brief encounter? First there was surprise at the unexpected response after months of waiting. Then a jolt of anticipation as my finger hovered over the e-mail link on my phone’s screen—the possibility of sharing journal space with so many writers I admire; the schmoozing when I run into editors at next year’s AWP book fair; the kudos from colleagues who’ve been trying to get into the magazine for years—eat your hearts out! And there’s also the practical matter of money (the Southern Review actually pays cash) as well as the all-important publication line on my curriculum vitae.

Then, of course, I open the e-mail and all that irrational optimism plunges deep into the pit of my stomach. Rejection is a sickening experience, something akin to airplane turbulence or bumping into your ex while she’s out with her new fling. Neuroscientists have actually identified similarities between our response to rejection and our response to physical pain. And the more personal the rejection, the more pain we feel. A friend of mine recently told me she received two rejection letters in one day—one from a poetry

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from Poets & Writers

Poets & Writers3 min read
TALK to an agent long enough, over a good meal, and inevitably subjects will come up that are, shall we say, sensitive. As many of these agents reminded me, this is a business of relationships—one even said it’s a business of feelings—so there are st
Poets & Writers3 min read
Prize for Thrillers Sparks Debate
Be it Stieg Larsson’s The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo or Paula Hawkins’s The Girl on the Train, novels that feature violence toward women have dominated the thriller market in recent years, selling millions of copies and leading to major screen adapt
Poets & Writers3 min read
The Time Is Now
Suggested Reading: Don’t Read Poetry: A Book About How to Read Poems (Basic Books, May) by Stephanie Burt Award-winning poet and critic Stephanie Burt, who was the subject of a 2016 installment of Reviewers & Critics by Michael Taeckens, offers an ac