Literary Hub

The Time I Drank with Borges in a Scottish Pub

jorge luis borges

I can smell Borges in my dreams, and I dream about him often. He reeks of age, with the mustiness, the sourness of years. And the odor gives off a peculiar sweetness, too, as if he has smoked ripe old tobacco in a pipe for many decades, although I suspect he didn’t.

A writer of poems and brief, enigmatic stories, and provocative essays that were also stories, Borges moved easily between fact and fiction, and his wild inventions became truths. It was all fiction for him, as in the title of his most celebrated volume, Ficciones, first published in the early 1940s. Fiction means, in its Latin root-word, “shaping.” And Borges was always shaping realities, even making them.

I called him Mr. Borges the first time we met, and he corrected me. “Just Borges, please.”

He had been translated by Alastair Reid, the Scottish poet and essayist, who was my mentor and close friend during my seven years in Scotland. Alastair lived at Pilmour Cottage, on the edge of the Old Course in St. Andrews, with a view of the North Sea through his kitchen window. I had met him at the suggestion of my history tutor, Miss Anne Wright. When I told her that I wrote poetry, she said, “In which case you must meet Alastair.”

She phoned him from her study in Hamilton Hall at the University of St. Andrews, where I had weekly tutorials with her in 19th-century British history. A stickler for facts, she had me recite the kings and queens again and again. “Get it right this time!” she would say. “The world is built upon facts!” It was arranged for me to meet Alastair at the Central Tavern, on Market Street, the following afternoon.

Standing at the bar, talking for two hours or more, Alastair and I became friends at once. He asked me to show him a few poems, and I happened to have a number of samples in my rucksack. After a quick perusal, he invited me to Pilmour for tea a few days later, suggesting that I bring a new poem in rough draft for him to “correct,” as he put it. The term slightly unnerved me, as I didn’t imagine I needed anyone’s correction.

On the appointed day, I pedaled to his cottage along the West Sands on my bicycle, through a cold slantwise drizzle. Gingerly, I put my damp poem on his kitchen table, between mugs of tea and jam pots, and sat beside him. Not a word was exchanged between us as he crossed out words and added others, with a sharp pencil. He moved stanzas around. A fresh title was applied to the poem with a question mark.

“Go away and revise it,” he said. “Come back tomorrow with a new version.”

He understood my puzzlement and said, “Graves did the same for me. It’s the only way to learn how to write.” He told me that he had learned his craft sitting beside Robert Graves in Majorca, where he had gone to work as secretary to the older writer after he left university. He was translating, for Graves (who had the commission from Penguin), Lives of the Noble Caesars by Suetonius. The idea was that Alastair would provide a rough draft of the classic work, and Graves would “correct” his pages, day by day. He had himself, he said, winced to hear that word, “correct.”

“We made an eccentric couple, the elderly blind writer from Argentina and the young American. Neither could imagine the other.”

He watched with considerable awe, however, as Graves took the work that he had thought beyond reproach and improved it, crossing out gaudy adjectives while putting in stronger nouns, eliminating adverbs, finding stronger verbs. The passive voice disappeared almost completely, and the syntax strengthened. The inner music of each sentence emerged, and the pages sang.

“Borges is coming next week,” said Alastair one day, in an admiring tone that surprised me, as he rarely seemed impressed by anyone. “He will be staying for a while. You will learn something.”

I had never heard of Jorge Luis Borges, and could find nothing of his in the local bookstore. But soon the old writer appeared before me: rumpled, blind, with a huge head and skinny legs. He seemed oddly powerful, however, and sat with his hands folded on his cane. His suit was ill-fitting and out-of-date, with a gold watch chain across his waistcoat. I suspect the suit had been tailored in Argentina, probably decades before. It was frayed, cuffed, made of indestructible wool with a flat sheen and moth-holes in the sleeves. His soiled white shirt had a high, stiff collar, like something from a photograph from the previous century. I thought of his tie as a palimpsest of many previous meals.

His deep voice boomed, beautifully controlled, almost theatrical. The accent was slight: his grandmother had been English, and he had grown up with the language. He read Shakespeare and Wells, Stevenson and Chesterton, Wilde, and any number of obscure poets in English. “I adore Chidiock Tichborne,” he said to me. “Don’t you?” He could recite long passages of Anglo-Saxon verse from memory.

One day Alastair asked me to “babysit” Borges, as he had to go out of town.

And I agreed, of course. Anything for Alastair, whom I had come to adore.

Borges wanted to “see” the East Neuk of Fife, he told me, when Alastair was gone. So I borrowed a car from a friend and took off with Borges in a rusty Morris Minor, which I barely knew how to drive. We made an eccentric couple, the elderly blind writer from Argentina and the young American. Neither could imagine the other.

One of several scenes that hang in my dreams occurred in a pub along the coast, near the fishing village of Anstruther. Borges wanted to experience a Scottish pub “in its full glory,” he said. Drinking in Scotland is, indeed, something of a religion, but it’s strictly low church. We stopped at a sawdust-floored, concrete-walled pub in the middle of the village, and I recall leading Borges into a basement room, the walls sweating, the place so dark that even a blind man needed help to get around the large wooden tables.

Borges asked for beer, and I brought him a pint of Export, the flat, warm beer that everyone drank in those days. I can see him bending over the glass, both hands around it. He sniffed the foamy head of the brew, and approved, stirring it with one finger, which he then licked clean. He took a long slow drink and smiled. He wiped the foam from his lips on the sleeve of his jacket. The big blank eyes rolled in his head.

I needed to make conversation and said, “Alastair tells me you’re a writer.”

“Oh, that,” he said. “Alastair exaggerates. He is a very good friend.”

I was unsure of myself now. “Have you ever written a novel?”

“Good lord, no. I write only the smallest of stories. Tiny things, some of them only a page, or less than a page.”

I grew very suspicious and asked, “So you haven’t written any novels?”

“No, no, my dear boy,” he said. “But you must know: I have my whole life dreamed of writing a novel. For many decades I planned to write an epic story of the Pampas. There would be gauchos and whores, and so many criminals. It would be a large and panoramic saga of family life over many generations, with failed love affairs, and incest, and spectacular achievements, too. Wars would come and go. There would be fratricide, and matricide. The volume would require perhaps a thousand pages to encompass everything I must say.”

I leaned forward. “And what happened?”

“The novel never came, dear boy. It was so frustrating. And then, after many decades, I woke early one day and went to my desk. There I wrote a one-page review of this great novel, and that satisfied the impulse.”


New England Review

This essay originally appears in Vol. 39, No. 1 of New England Review.

More from Literary Hub

Literary Hub7 min read
Can Humans Read Animals’ Minds?
Humans are good mind-readers. So good, in fact, that we even manage to read thoughts where there are no thoughts to be read. In a well-known psychological study from the 1940s, 34 subjects were shown a short film of a surface where a large triangle,
Literary Hub9 min read
Gun Island and the Stories That Survive a Changing Planet
Along the melting edges of Canada’s Teardrop glacier, evolutionary biologist Catherine La Farge and her team spotted a species of moss that was presumed dead for centuries. Rising temperatures that caused the glacier to shrink exposed vegetation, slu
Literary Hub4 min read
Neil Gaiman On The Good Kind Of Trolls
I keep trying to write a measured and sensible introduction to this book, and I keep failing. I keep failing because in order to find out what I think I pick up the proofs and start to read—or rather, at this point, to reread and to rerereread—any on