Post Magazine

Film on nuns exposes dilemma of church

Every now and then, a movie comes along that makes you wonder about meaning, purpose, life itself. Novitiate, by a brilliant filmmaker Maggie Betts, is such a movie. Someone took me to see it, with much resistance from me. Who wants to watch a movie about Catholic nuns, or rather young girls preparing to become nuns?

It turns out to be highly educational, and not only that. The movie, set in a 1960s American convent, has a political subtext in that it explores the implications of the Second Vatican Council on Catholic women in general and nuns in particular.

I have already been writing about Vatican II in this space because retired cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun and his yellow-ribbon supporters have been citing its doctrine that only the Vatican has the right to appoint bishops in their opposition to rapprochement between China and the Holy See. Don't they know the party line in Rome has changed?

Retired Hong Kong cardinal blasts Vatican over claims he caused 'confusion and controversy'

The movie follows the joy, anguish and self-doubts of the novices as they train under the tyrannical Sister Marie, the alpha nun and Reverend Mother, who equates her commands with the word of God. She quietly encourages some novices to self-flagellate themselves, even though the practice has been banned by the church. She implicitly encourages anorexia by praising the main character who starves herself "for Christ".

She makes everyone kneel for hours in a circle to confess their sins and darkest secrets one by one, a routine that would even make hardcore Maoist Red Guards blush. She takes out her frustrations with one of the girls by making her crawl like a dog.

Young Catholics tell Pope Francis they want a more open church where women play a greater role

But the Reverend Mother isn't just frustrated; she has been devastated as she watches her whole world and lifelong beliefs and devotion collapse. According to the movie, nuns are no longer considered special - such as being "the brides of Christ" - any more than the laity under Vatican II. Priests, of course, get to preserve their special status. Actually, Vatican II cuts both ways: some nuns found its liberalising doctrines freed them to leave their convents and engage in social justice causes.

Maybe it's the onset of middle age or I'm just a fellow sadist, but I find Sister Marie more interesting than those nubile novices, even with an explicit lesbian scene. As I watch Marie, I imagine our own Catholic anti-communist dissidents must feel the same way being betrayed by a Vatican tilting towards Beijing.

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2018. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from Post Magazine

Post Magazine7 min readPolitics
Free From Chinese Repression, Desperate Dissidents In US Cling To Tradition Of Petitioning To Air Grievances
Chinese Vice-Premier Liu He came to Washington at the end of January for two days of negotiations and a meeting with US President Donald Trump in search of a trade war breakthrough. But Bai Jiemin, a former businessman from China now living under pol
Post Magazine4 min readPolitics
Donald Trump's March Tariffs Could Hit China's GDP By Under 1 Per Cent - But Do Lasting Wider Damage, Experts Warn
Chinese and US negotiators are facing a critical moment in the next two weeks as the two sides try to keep a lid on tensions and reach a deal to end the trade war. Officials from both sides said progress was made in the latest round of talks that wra
Post Magazine3 min readPolitics
Trade War Talks: China And US Said To Be Far Apart On Framework For Monitoring Chinese Action On Structural Reform; US Could Possibly Drop 10 Per Cent Tariffs
Chinese and American negotiators remain far apart on a key US demand meant to ensure Beijing honours any commitment to equal market access and intellectual property protection " an issue the US team sees as crucial in reaching a deal to end the month