The Amish pool resources for their medical care. A budget-busting gene therapy puts them in a bind

The Amish community pays for medical treatments together. Does that leave the country's priciest medicine out of reach?

The meeting could determine whether the two young siblings would keep going blind. The doctor knew that going in, but he was feeling good. He’d negotiated huge discounts before, allowing patients to get complex surgeries or budget-busting drugs they otherwise couldn’t afford. And his last two conversations with Spark Therapeutics had been promising.

Then again, at $850,000 a person, Luxturna was more budget-busting than just about any other drug. Spark had proposed a few different ways of helping insurers to cover the gene therapy — but Dr. Kevin Strauss’ patients tend not to have insurance. As the medical director of the Clinic for Special Children, on the outskirts of Strasburg, Pa., he mostly sees members of the Plain community: Old Order Amish and Mennonite families, who believe that caring for the sick and the elderly is a community’s responsibility. Relying on governments or private companies to step in is considered a serious moral breach. They don’t want medicine for free. They just want to pay the reduced prices that government and private insurers often do.

That’s the kind of discount Strauss was trying to negotiate for the siblings’ family. The two Amish girls have a mutation in the RPE65 gene, causing the specific form of retinal blindness that Spark’s therapy is designed to treat. There is no way the parents would get Luxturna for only one of them, while letting the other’s vision fade even further. But asking their congregation for $850,000 would already be a stretch; asking for $1.7 million would be unimaginable. The community just doesn’t have that kind of cash lying around.

“It puts the family in a tough position,” said Strauss. “They know that that is communal money —

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from STAT

STAT4 min readSociety
In A ‘Wild West’ Environment, Hospitals Differ Sharply In What Patient Data They Give Google
Under existing law, hospitals and tech companies have broad latitude to exchange data without the knowledge or consent of patients.
STAT5 min read
Exercise Helps Astronauts Cope With Side Effects Of Spaceflight. Could It Help Cancer Patients Too?
Exercise seems to help astronauts stave off effects of space flight, and cancer patients, who go through similar physiological changes, may also benefit from physical activity, researchers say.
STAT3 min read
Opinion: Today’s Insulin Isn’t What Banting And Best Developed. It’s Far, Far Better
Headlines like "The U.S. Insulin Crisis — Rationing a Lifesaving Medication Discovered in the 1920s" imply that insulin hasn't changed much. That's wrong.