The Atlantic

Letters: Would Democratic Socialism Really Threaten Minorities?

Readers debate the possible outcomes of an American move toward democratic socialism.
Source: Alvaro Barrientos / AP

Democratic Socialism Threatens Minorities

Earlier this month, Conor Friedersdorf wrote a critique of democratic socialism as defined by a recent article in the leftist magazine Jacobin. “Socialists,” he argued, “are attuned to the ways individuals are vulnerable in capitalism but blind to ways that it frees us from the preferences of the majority. Nearly all of us would hate abiding by the will of the majority on some matters.”


I read Conor Friedersdorf’s article on young people and socialism with great interest. In assuming that the only way for marginalized groups to access needed goods and services is to pay for them, he reveals his blind spots. One, he doesn’t engage with the fact that markets are frequently coercive, with different prices and expectations depending on your gender and race (just look at the wealth of research on job discrimination against applicants with “black names,” for instance).

More importantly, he seems not to realize that other options besides buying things exist. He presents a false dichotomy between dystopian majority control and “free” markets. But there are real historic and present possibilities for the production” to Wikipedia’s open community of editors to groups like the Four Thieves Collective that make their own medicines in resistance to Big Pharma. These aren’t market solutions. Indeed, they will continue to thrive—and, quite likely, thrive better—in a society with a strong social safety net for all its citizens.

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic5 min readPolitics
Donald Trump Has One Problem
False statements and West Wing disorder are not only inseparably linked; they’re mutually reinforcing.
The Atlantic4 min readSociety
The Grammys Controversy Is Bigger Than Any One CEO
The picture of the Recording Academy that the former head Deborah Dugan paints is of an organization encrusted by years of self-dealing and mismanagement.
The Atlantic6 min readPolitics
Hong Kong’s Protesters Finally Have (Some) Power
Newly elected representatives are among those trying to turn the demonstrations into a permanent prodemocracy movement.