The Millions

How to Have an Opinion: The Criticism of Martin Seymour-Smith

was a grumpy fellow. A promising poet who took up writing big reference books of literary criticism, his highly idiosyncratic 1977 survey is deliciously highbrow junk food. But like strawberry Pocky or matcha Kit-Kat, Seymour-Smith isn’t for everyone. His effort to catalogue the literary scene is full of curiously gleeful put-downs and undercooked psychoanalysis. He pronounces “by no means intelligent … seriously overrated,” sums up as “a distinguished lepidopterist” and “a minor writer of distinction,” and tenderly humiliates ’s as “brilliant … but too much so.” would be an impossible book to write today: Seymour-Smith is skeptical of literary personality at its core. The entries on particularly mythic writers like Hemingway and show a dogged commitment

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

Related Interests

More from The Millions

The Millions4 min read
Am I a Bad Feminist?
“How could you publish this novel?” That’s what I heard after I chose to write about a girl falsely accusing a man of sexual assault during the #MeToo era. The post Am I a Bad Feminist? appeared first on The Millions.
The Millions3 min read
We’re in a Rough Place in History Right Now: The Millions Interviews Carmen Maria Machado
The award-winning author of ‘Her Body and Other Parties’ on writing fiction for today, the tyranny of genre, and reading outside of our comfort zones. The post We’re in a Rough Place in History Right Now: The Millions Interviews Carmen Maria Machado
The Millions1 min read
Trippingly on the Tongue: Featured Poetry by Maurice Manning
The latest from Pulitzer Prize-finalist Manning is written entirely from the point of view of Abraham Lincoln (who, it turns out, is a great poet). The post Trippingly on the Tongue: Featured Poetry by Maurice Manning appeared first on The Millions.