Poets & Writers

Getting Paid

MICHAEL BOURNE is a contributing editor of Poets & Writers Magazine.

LET’S say you’re a first-time author who has just landed an agent for your novel or memoir. Your agent has sent the book around to editors at top New York City publishing houses, and you’ve learned that at least one of those editors—and possibly more—wants to publish it. There might even be an auction, in which editors bid against one another for the right to publish your work.

How much of an advance are you likely to get? Or, since that may be hard to know until the bidding starts, how will the editors vying for your work decide how much to pay you?

The official answer is that each editor will draw up a profit-and-loss statement—universally known as a “P&L”—balancing the costs of acquiring, editing, and publishing your book against the book’s potential sales earnings. Because you are a first-time author and have no track record to fall back on, editors will calculate your book’s earning potential by looking at sales figures of comparable titles, or “comps,” as they’re often called.

If your book is a memoir about, say, a woman recovering from a divorce by taking a spiritually cleansing overseas journey, editors will look at sales figures for a half dozen recent travel memoirs by women, leaving out terrible books that didn’t sell at all and breakout best-sellers such as (Viking, 2006), the sales of which are likely too high to be a useful measure, to determine the market value of memoirs about women taking spiritually cleansing overseas journeys.

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from Poets & Writers

Poets & Writers3 min read
Furious Flower Grows in Virginia
In 1994 Joanne Gabbin, an English professor at James Madison University (JMU), organized a conference to celebrate Pulitzer Prize–winning poet Gwendolyn Brooks and African American poetics. Hundreds of people came out to hear Brooks and more than thi
Poets & Writers5 min read
Body Language
IN CHILDREN OF GRASS: A PORTRAIT OF AMERICAN POETRY, PUBLISHED BY SCHAFFNER PRESS IN SEPTEMBER, PHOTOGRAPHER B. A. VAN SISE PRESENTS SELECTIONS FROM AN EXPANSIVE, THREE-YEAR POETRY PORTRAITURE PROJECT FOR WHICH HE ASKED POETS ACROSS THE COUNTRY TO PO
Poets & Writers9 min read
AGENTS & EDITORS BEN GEORGE
BEN George’s arrival in big publishing was more of a vault than a climb, and it surprised him as much as anybody. “Being a New York editor,” he says, “was never something I was aiming toward.” Remarkably, what brought George’s editorial acumen to the