The Atlantic

The Conversation

Readers respond to our January/February 2019 cover story and more.

Don’t Call Me LGBTQ

In the January/February issue, Jonathan Rauch made the case for adopting one overarching designation for sexual minorities. He proposed using a single letter: Q.


What a relief to read something about the absurdity of the “alphabet soup” designation for gay people. I totally agree with Jonathan Rauch that it has become a symbol “for the excesses of identity politics,” which have fueled animosity and intolerance toward homosexuals. I’m amazed that anyone would add more letters to this train wreck.

You will never promote more tolerance and peace in the world by diminishing individuals into ever more exclusive and reductive parts. Large, broad categories are much more efficient and easy to understand.

Patricia McAnulty


No, a thousand times, no!

Jonathan Rauch makes a valid point about the awkwardness of as a term to represent sexual minorities, but to substitute simply would be a huge error. While Rauch mentions the baggage of the word (which would inevitably reference), he gives no sense of the fact that was the primary name assigned by society to homosexuals before came into was not descriptive in a positive way. It was ugly, hateful, pejorative, demeaning, and diminishing. It is the right word with which to be labeled, if one must be labeled.

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
The Window for Brexit May Already Have Closed
Parliament is delaying Johnson’s plan—and generational replacement has undercut its support.
The Atlantic4 min readPolitics
The U.S. Is Abandoning Its Interests in Brexit
Gordon Sondland is a busy man. He recently testified to Congress about his role in President Donald Trump’s attempt to extort campaign dirt from the government of Ukraine. That testimony follows from Sondland’s previous deft maneuvering to insert him
The Atlantic8 min read
It Isn’t About Your Love Language; It’s About Your Partner’s
A framework meant to help people become more attuned to their partners now gets treated like a personality test.