The Atlantic

Is America Undergoing a Political Realignment?

A new Democratic coalition could be coming to power—but don’t count on it.
Source: Keystone / Getty

Realignment—a decisive shift in the balance of power between political parties, creating new coalitions and leaving one party and one ideology with lasting dominance—occurs far more often in the minds of partisans than in reality. Karl Rove believed that the reelection of George W. Bush in 2004 would enshrine a permanent Republican majority. Within a couple of years the president and his party were discredited. In 2008, with the collapse of the financial system and the historic campaign of Barack Obama, some people—I was one—thought a Democratic realignment might be at hand. Obama’s victory, with big majorities in Congress, would close the book on decades of conservative ideology, anti-government politics, deregulation, the amassing of vast fortunes, the widening of vast inequalities. A new era of liberal reform was going to sweep aside the rubble left behind by the right and finally begin to solve big problems.

It didn’t turn out that way. It seldom does. The Obama movement was more personal than ideological. He campaigned as a visionary but governed as

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic5 min read
Why the People Behind Quibi Are So Confident
The video platform is backed by dozens of Hollywood A-listers and executives. But its launch during a global pandemic will be the real viability test.
The Atlantic6 min readWellness
Should You Wear a Mask?
James Hamblin and Katherine Wells discuss new CDC recommendations on the podcast Social Distance.
The Atlantic6 min readPolitics
The Coronavirus Killed the Policy Primary
What a rollout it was going to be. Joe Biden would stand next to former Representative Gabby Giffords at a big rally in Miami the Monday before the Florida primary. They’d rail against gun violence, criticize Bernie Sanders, and get a head start on t