Are you sure?
This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?
Winner of the Maryland Writers’ Association 2017 Best Book Award
It's his word against hers, and the stakes couldn't be higher.
When a teenager accuses a key official of a local charity of blackmailing her for sex—and then abruptly disappears—a mystery turns into a crisis, raising concerns about the girl's safety, the charity's survival, and the career and reputation of a man who says he is innocent.
Enter Jonas Hawke, retired lawyer and sage of Beacon Junction. Jonas has just agreed to oversee the charitable group, a friend's attempt to help Jonas move past his grief over the death of his wife. It's his job to uncover the facts and ensure that justice will be done.
Jonas is helped—and hindered—by the arrival of Dylan Walker and his eight-year-old son. Why a single dad has chosen to move to a small town in Vermont to start a new life is a mystery that tugs at Jonas, especially when Dylan develops an amorous interest in Jonas's married daughter.
Hawke's Return is the tale of a man groping his way back from the loss of his beloved soul mate, even as he struggles with an intractable dilemma.
Author
Dylan got off the interstate while they were still in Massachusetts, choosing to meander northward on the small, picturesque roads that wound through Vermont’s rustic beauty. He tried to interest Max in the scenery—the majestic mountains and tall pine trees, the green pastures dotted with cows, the farms with endless rows of corn—but Max was too engrossed in Fablehaven to do more than glance out the window.
Haven’t you read that before?
I’ve read all five of them, but I’m reading them again. You get more out of them the second time,
Max said.
But you already know what happens.
Max looked out the window for a few seconds, noticing a couple of calves that were moving toward the fence lining the road.
It doesn’t matter if you’ve read them before,
he said. They’re still good.
Dylan sighed. It was time to stop running. They’d been on the move for four days, taking breaks to visit a zoo (Max pronounced the orangutan gross
), a science museum (interesting), a miniature golf course (hard), two swimming pools (fun), and two bookstores (adequate). The kid was never without a book, read above his age level, and liked to have his reading lined up in advance. Dylan had tried to introduce him to the books he’d treasured as a boy, especially The Black Stallion series, but Max had seen the movie and was more into fantasy. As though The Black Stallion was realistic.
It had been a good trip in Dylan’s view, and they’d made a start at getting reacquainted, but he worried about Max. He was quiet, and Dylan had no idea a healthy eight-year-old kid could be so bookish. Plus, Max’s suspicions seemed to be growing. When he did talk, he kept asking questions about what they were doing and why, and he seemed less and less willing to accept Dylan’s evasive answers. That only added to Dylan’s own doubts and his gnawing sense that he was being irresponsible. He’d have to make a decision. This would be their last day of wandering.
He pulled over at a gas station and tried to use the GPS to look for a restaurant and a motel, but he finally gave up and turned on his phone.
Why’d you buy a new phone when you still use the old one?
Max asked.
I only use the old one when I have to. To get the internet,
Dylan said, as though that were an answer. What do you want for dinner? What are you in the mood for?
There was no response from the backseat, so he provided one himself. How about chicken cordon bleu with a nice Merlot? Maybe some crème brûlée for dessert.
I want a hot dog,
Max said without looking up from his book.
You had a hot dog for lunch.
Then, pizza.
No fast food tonight. We have to eat healthy for a change.
But with ice cream,
Max said.
Only if you eat some vegetables.
Thirty minutes later, Dylan pulled into the parking lot of the Shona Grill in Bellows Falls, only to find it was a carryout. He glanced at the Miss Bellows Falls Diner next door, but it was already closed for the day, and Donovan’s, across the street, was an Irish pub that was hardly appropriate for Max.
They got back in the car and drove across the short bridge into New Hampshire, though Max pointed out they could have easily walked. After driving around a bit, Dylan found a family style restaurant and squeezed into a parking space between two pickup trucks. Max put his book down and unbuckled his seatbelt but waited for his father to open the door.
Dylan pointed to the two trucks. Which one do you like better?
he asked.
Max didn’t answer right away. His interest in trucks had waned, but Dylan didn’t know that.
The red one,
Max said finally. It sits higher on the road, and it looks like it’s been in some crashes. Is that a gun rack?
Dylan was surprised by the question. Gun racks were hardly unusual in Richmond, where Max had grown up, but still he hesitated before confirming it. He was glad the rack was empty.
Let’s get something to eat,
he said to change the subject. I’m starved.
The restaurant was crowded, a good sign.
Just a moment, boys,
a waitress said by way of a greeting. Let me clear that booth by the window and it’s all yours.
She reached to touch Max’s shoulder, but he backed away. He was cautious with strangers, shy beyond what Dylan thought was normal, though he didn’t really have much experience with kids. He was always being reminded that, as a father, he had a lot of catching up to do.
Dylan was pleasantly surprised to find they actually had chicken cordon bleu on the menu, and he ordered it for himself, just to show Max what it was. For Max, he suggested a grilled chicken breast, a baked potato, and broccoli, which was quickly negotiated down to French fries and an ear of corn.
Can we stay in a place with a pool again?
Max asked, wiping the remnants of the butter-soaked corn off his face.
I’m not sure we’ll have time for swimming. Tonight we have to pick a place to settle down in, at least for a few weeks.
Max took a second, apparently considering the implications of that.
Just the two of us?
he asked.
Just us.
Max pulled his shirt collar up over his chin, a sign, Dylan had learned, that he was hesitant about saying what was on his mind.
Will Grandma and Dave come?
he said finally.
This is just temporary. We’ll be on our own. We’ll find an apartment and get you into school.
What about my old school?
You’ll make new friends,
Dylan answered. He felt like a politician who never answered the questions he was asked.
Where will the apartment be?
Dylan considered it. He didn’t have a specific place in mind, only a rough idea. He wanted a small town, and Vermont was full of them, which was one of the reasons they’d come this way.
We’ll blindfold you and let you point to a place on the map, like pin the tail on the donkey.
Max smiled in amusement.
Jonas sat down slowly on the wrought iron bench in the gazebo and looked over the garden that Emma had lovingly nurtured in the backyard of the Sunrise. It was filled with perennials, beautifully arranged in an S-shaped pattern so you could walk around and enjoy them. They bloomed one after the other so there was color—yellows and blues and reds and purples and oranges—from early spring, which wasn’t that early in Vermont, until late fall. On this August afternoon, the black-eyed Susans, red hibiscus, and purple anemones were all in bloom, as were several other plants that Jonas couldn’t immediately identify. He wished Emma were here to remind him. No, he just wished Emma were here, puttering in the garden as she had so many afternoons while he sat and read and watched.
How he missed her.
Three months. That’s how long he’d been a widower.
In the weeks leading up to Emma’s death, he had tried to prepare himself. He’d drawn on all his inner strength to tend to her, watching her suffer from the cancer with his practiced veneer of stoicism, trying to shield their grown children, Sally and Nathan, from having to worry about him as well as their dying mother. By the end, they all pretended they were ready to accept the inevitable, that her release from misery would be a blessing of sorts.
But it was a lie. He hadn’t been ready. How could he be?
His reaction was predictable to anyone who knew him. Never one to surround himself with people, even in the best of times, he shut himself up, choosing to lock himself in his room for hours or take long walks by himself or sit brooding in the backyard or on the front porch.
Nathan understood. His father had lived his whole life in Beacon Junction, knew almost everyone, and was generous with his time and advice when asked, but his closest friends were dead or had moved away, and he lacked the social skills needed to make new ones.
It was harder for Sally, who lived in the Sunrise with her father and saw him every day. She’d left him to his solitude as long as she could, but recently she’d begun pushing much harder, telling him that being alone so much was bad for him and unfair to her. She needed him, she said, because she was grieving too. The comment struck a chord, and now he was trying to respond. He didn’t want to make the same mistakes he’d made when Lucas had died a quarter century earlier.
Jonas sat back, slowly stretched out his arthritic knee, and reached for his pipe. He filled it carefully, tamped down the tobacco, and lit up the bowl. He looked out at the garden and suddenly remembered Emma once telling him that the smoke was bad for the plants. Was that true, or was it just part of her trying to get him to smoke less? He’d have to look it up.
He put the pipe down and let out a sigh before closing his eyes. As he sat there, he took his mind slowly through his and Emma’s history, trying to recapture single moments in each of their forty-nine years together: their move back to Vermont, the rapid growth of his career as a defense attorney, the birth of each of their three children, their first home, the kids growing into adults. He didn’t skip over the hard years in the middle—the car accident that killed Lucas, their older son, the discovery of Emma’s affair, and his own descent into depression and alcohol—but he didn’t dwell on them either. They’d gotten through it all. In some ways, the last few years had been the happiest.
Forty-nine years. His whole life. What would he do with the rest of his time? Sally had been telling him he had to think about that, that his constant mourning was a path to self-destruction. He’d given in a little, going back to some of his volunteer work, and now he had agreed to take on what could be a significant responsibility. He’d tell her about that at dinner.
Dinner. He looked at his watch. He’d promised to cook, a not-so-subtle attempt to show he was still capable of taking care of himself. But he hadn’t even thought about what he would make. He dumped his pipe into an ashtray, climbed to his feet, and headed into the house.
After dinner, Max and Dylan drove back into Vermont and took a room at the only motel in town. After they were settled, Max grabbed a towel and wrapped it around his eyes, eager to follow through on his father’s promise and pick a place where they could settle down. Dylan was true to his word and let Max point blindly to a spot, though he used a map of Vermont to limit the options.
Max circled his finger in the air and tried to imitate a drum roll, then landed on the map.
You picked nowhere,
Dylan said, studying the point where Max’s finger had landed. The closest place is called Beacon Junction. We can try that. It’s only a half hour from here.
Max took a look and shrugged before curling up in a chair and returning to his book. Dylan fired up his laptop and checked out Beacon Junction. He found six places for rent, including a couple that were furnished. And he found what looked like a pleasant bed and breakfast where they could stay while they made their decision.
Dylan called to make a reservation for the next night and then turned on the TV, flicked through the channels, and eventually found the Red Sox game. He tried to interest Max in it, but he insisted on sticking with his book. He had finished Fablehaven and had immediately moved on to Fablehaven: Rise of the Evening Star.
Dylan planned to take his time getting to know Max and tried not to draw any conclusions, but he was concerned about what he saw. Being bookish was fine, but Max used it as an escape, a way to avoid conversation and any real engagement with the world around him. He didn’t seem to have many friends, certainly none he talked about. He had plenty of energy, and at times he would wrestle with Dylan or play tag, but Max was slow and awkward and a little pudgy for a kid his age. Plus, his ears stuck out a bit too much.
When you finish that chapter, you should get ready for bed,
Dylan said, trying not to sound too bossy. It’s almost ten, and tomorrow’s a big day.
Max mumbled agreement, but it took two more reminders before he closed the book and reached for his pajamas. He seemed listless. He’d been even more quiet than usual since the map game, and Dylan guessed he was unhappy, though he wasn’t sure why.
Something bothering you?
he asked.
Max pulled his shirt collar up over his mouth and didn’t answer. Instead, he stared at his father and then got up and went into the bathroom. A few seconds later, Dylan heard a shattering crash. When he went in, he saw a glass had fallen and broken.
Don’t worry,
he said. I’ll clean it up.
He went to pick Max up and carry him out of the room so he wouldn’t step on the glass, but Max pushed him away.
Then he exploded.
Just tell me what’s going on! What are we doing here?
Dylan motioned to the door and led Max around the glass to the bedroom, trying to collect his thoughts.
We’re trying to start a new life,
he said evenly.
Why can’t I stay with Grandma and Dave?
Grandma is getting old. She doesn’t have the strength to raise you.
But she wants to.
Besides, it’s my responsibility. And it’s easier for everyone if we get a fresh start in a new place.
I don’t want to.
He drew out the words in anger.
Dylan sighed. "I’m sorry, but you don’t have a choice. Check that, we don’t have a choice. There’s no other way."
I don’t want to,
Max repeated, beginning to cry.
Dylan tried to hold him, but he pushed him away, so Dylan left him and went to clean up the bathroom. When he returned, Max was in bed with his book.
I know it’s hard for you to understand,
Dylan said. You just have to trust me.
Max shut his book and pulled the covers over his head.
Since her mother’s death, Sally had made it her business to keep a close eye on her father, which wasn’t hard given that they lived together at the Sunrise, a bed and breakfast that Jonas and Emma had purchased for Sally to manage. Jonas and Emma had occupied a suite on the top floor, while Sally and her husband, Jake, lived in rooms on the ground floor.
Though they saw each other every day, the two couples had rarely eaten dinner together, mindful of each other’s need for privacy—though Jonas had often joked to Emma that it didn’t seem to do much good, seeing there were still no grandchildren.
That night he had agreed to have dinner with them, but only on the condition that he be allowed to cook. He’d prepared simple salmon
—the salmon smothered in dried herbs and thrown in the oven for twenty minutes, with a boxed rice mix, steamed broccoli, and a salad—a truly simple and virtually foolproof meal he pretended was his own invention.
Jonas’s decision to cook gave the evening a bit of a festive—or at least, an unusual—air. So, too, did Jake’s presence. Since he’d become an insurance agent a few months back, a big step up from his previous job doing estimates for a roofing and construction company, he was rarely home for dinner, a fact that Sally often complained about to little avail.
So, I got a new job,
Jonas announced after he’d received the obligatory compliments on the dinner.
What job?
Sally and Jake asked in unison, Jake with amusement and Sally with concern.
Nancy wants me to administer the partnership.
I thought Michael was doing that,
Sally said.
He was, but Nancy says it’s too much for him, being in Chicago and having a busy day job.
That’s good,
Jake said. It makes sense for you to do it.
Jonas shrugged. I think she mostly wants to help me keep busy, but I don’t mind. It’s a good cause. I’m glad to help, and it’s only part-time.
Nancy had established the Hargrave Partnership—which aimed to help older foster kids make the transition to living on their own—as a way to honor her late husband, Frank Hargrave, Jonas’s long-time partner and close friend. Michael, Nancy and Frank’s son, had originally agreed to oversee the project.
I’m sure Nancy appreciates your help,
Jake said.
But won’t it mean a lot of work?
Sally asked.
I don’t think so. Won’t know until I start.
Sally took a bite of salmon. I guess it makes sense. You’re always happier when you’re involved with something important. Just don’t overdo.
Jonas looked at her with a curious smile. The way she’d reacted—first hesitant and now enthusiastic—made him wonder whether she’d put Nancy up to it.
Certainly makes more sense than that mayor idea,
Sally added.
Jonas had been asked to run for the town’s top job when Ed Riley, the previous mayor, suddenly pulled up stakes and moved to Upstate New York. Jonas had quickly decided against it. It would have meant no end of problems for Nathan, who was the editor of the only newspaper in town. He’d be constantly facing conflict of interest issues if his father were the mayor. The partnership job could pose a few of those too, but probably not many.
When they finished eating, Jake excused himself. Need to make some client calls,
he said.
Jonas let Sally do the dishes and went out on the porch equipped with his pipe, a worn paperback copy of Madame Bovary, and a can of mosquito repellent. He was in no hurry to go up to his empty bedroom.
Dylan sat quietly on an old lawn chair outside the front door of their room, waiting long enough to convince himself that Max was asleep before digging out a cigarette and lighting up. One of his new rules was never to smoke in front of his son. That kept the count down, and soon he would quit altogether. But not yet. There was too much thinking to do.
He and Max had hit the road abruptly, and Dylan was still trying to formulate a plan that made sense. Unfortunately, nothing did. He had a little more than three thousand dollars in cash, which wouldn’t last long. He could borrow some from his aunt, but the logistics of getting it without giving away his location would be a challenge. But, then, everything was going to be a challenge.
He’d made a vow to himself that he would change, for Max’s sake, if not for his own. He had spent a good part of the last three years sulking about his bad luck, but Julie’s illness made him realize, with help from a shrink, that he had to step up and take some responsibility for his actions. No willpower, that was his problem. He made good decisions; he just didn’t stick to them. He had suffered because of it. So had Julie and Max.
He’d have to get a job as quickly as he could, but that wouldn’t be easy. He’d lined up a few old colleagues who’d give him discreet references, but he had to find a place that wouldn’t look too hard at his background. More important, he had to settle into a job and a home without leaving a public footprint that would allow anyone to find him. He was hoping a small employer in a small town wouldn’t go to a lot of trouble checking him out.
It would be difficult, no doubt about that. Difficult for Max too, but getting out of Virginia was the only option that made sense.
He crushed his cigarette stub and flicked it into the parking lot, then felt guilty and retrieved it and walked to the dumpster behind the motel. He wanted another, but he wouldn’t let himself. Apart from wanting to quit for Max’s sake, smoking was a habit he could no longer afford.
August was turning into a slow month at the Sunrise, so Sally was pleased to report they had a new guest—a father and son, who had taken up residence in the Orchard Room.
How old is the boy?
Jonas asked.
Eight. He’s kind of shy, not at all talkative. Best I could get out of him was that his name is Max.
On vacation? Just the two of them?
Actually, the father said they might stay if he could find a job. He asked a lot about Beacon Junction. I gave him Sylvia’s number and said she’d know what was available.
Jonas was puzzled. When was the last time Beacon Junction was blessed with a new resident who wasn’t born there or related to someone who was? New people, mostly researchers, were recruited and moved there to work at Harrison Health, the big medical device maker in town, but no one came just on the hope of finding a job.
Seems odd,
he said. What about the mother?
I didn’t ask, but I got the sense there isn’t one. Maybe you could come down to breakfast tomorrow and meet them.
Jonas smiled. You want help sizing them up?
They both knew that once would have been a job for Emma.
I just think it would be the polite thing to do. There’s no one else staying tonight, so they won’t have anyone to talk to. Maybe you could give him some advice on finding a job.
What kind of work does he do?
I didn’t ask. You could, though. Give you something to talk about.
Jonas frowned. Small talk wasn’t his strength, but he didn’t like it when anyone pointed it out by giving him suggestions on what to say.
Maybe,
he said. We’ll see.
Later that afternoon, Jonas cut one of the yellow James Galway roses that Emma was so proud of and set off for the cemetery. In the early weeks after her death, he’d felt silly plodding through the streets with flowers in his hand, but he’d gotten over that. He’d been going almost every day, choosing a different flower—sometimes making up a small bouquet—and laying it on Emma’s grave.
When he arrived, he spotted an old acquaintance in the cemetery, but rather than say hello, he just waited. He preferred to be alone. When he was, he placed the rose at the foot of the grave and picked up the flower he’d left yesterday, discarding it in a nearby bin. Then he just stood at the grave, his head bowed, his eyes closed.
He felt a tear forming in his eye and fought it back, then wondered why. A part of him believed he needed to be strong, but another part couldn’t see that it mattered. Be strong for whom?
He looked at Emma’s grave. The first few times he’d come, Jonas had tried talking aloud to Emma, but it felt foolish. Now he just spoke to her within his head. It wasn’t that he thought she could hear him; it was just a way of missing her a tiny bit less. He could use her counsel today. He was beginning to toy with the idea of moving out of the Sunrise. It would give Sally some space. She could use it. So could he. She felt too responsible for him, which was a burden for both of them. Better to move out and live on his own while he still could.
He tried to imagine a conversation with Emma about it. What would she tell him?
He knew the standard advice—that he shouldn’t make any important decisions so soon after her death—but he also knew that a new chapter in his life was beginning. A not-very-happy chapter. Each morning he awoke with a gaping hole, an emptiness that overshadowed everything else. Sometimes he’d wander through the day, not knowing where to put himself. Nothing was quite the same. He didn’t need to do that in front of an audience.
His knee began to bother him, and he walked over to a bench where he could sit and still see Emma’s grave. He took out his pipe, filled it with a blend of Black Cavendish and Latakia, and took a long puff.
What was left for him? Only his children. Nathan was making a success of the newspaper and having fun. He’d finally married Carol, his longtime girlfriend, and settled comfortably across the border in New Hampshire. Jonas suspected that children would soon be joining the family. That was something to live for. How Emma would have loved that.
But Sally was childless, and she still clung to him. Why was that? And what should he do about it?
She was hurting. He knew that. She’d been so close to Emma, and now she was focusing on him, almost as an escape from her own pain. That couldn’t be good. Still, he didn’t want to just disappear on her like he’d done after Lucas was killed, wallowing in self-pity and drowning in alcohol. He didn’t want to let her down again.
Sally had been urging him to end his solitude, to be with other people, and to get back to doing something constructive. That’s why he’d quickly accepted Nancy’s request that he oversee the partnership. He knew he’d lost purpose and that this was dangerous, though he wasn’t sure the partnership was the answer.
Jonas stood up and walked back to Emma’s grave. I’m going around in circles,
he said, speaking aloud.
He sighed, took a last look, and turned to go back to the Sunrise, feeling lonelier than when he’d arrived.
Jonas was on his second cup of coffee the next morning when Dylan and Max came downstairs. Jonas said good morning with as much cheer as he could, and Dylan introduced himself. Max nodded a hello under pressure, then opened the book he had with him.
Jonas was a little surprised by Dylan’s appearance. With an eight-year-old, Jonas had assumed he’d be in his early thirties, but he looked at least ten years older. It was the lines in his face and the thinning hair. He had a wiry frame, but not the kind you got from exercising and being healthy. Still, when he smiled, his face took on an inviting look. Not quite handsome, but friendly and open.
Nice room,
Dylan said, admiring the big windows and the hanging plants that flourished in the bright sunlight.
The Sunrise was a large, stately colonial, more than one hundred and fifty years old, that Sally and Jake had fixed up nicely. The kitchen had new appliances and granite countertops, the wood floors had been refinished, and all the bathrooms, plumbing, and electricity had been upgraded.
That looks great,
Dylan said when Sally came in with a plate of blueberry pancakes smothered in syrup for Max. Dylan and Jonas had both chosen oatmeal.
So what brings you up this way?
Jonas asked.
Dylan hesitated before answering. To be honest,
he said, we’re looking for a new start. Max’s mom passed away a couple of months ago, and I thought it might be easier to adjust to being on our own if we were in a different place. We need a small town. Not that Richmond is large, but I’d rather try something more homey.
Jonas watched Max, who was staring and listening intently, as if he, too, wondered why they had come to Vermont.
I’m sorry about your wife,
Jonas said. He struggled for something more to say, but looking at Max, he decided not to ask any questions. It’s a nice town. You can be happy here.
Then he noticed Sally standing in the doorway and gestured to her.
It is,
she said. Folks can be very friendly. We are small, though, only six thousand people, so finding a job can be tough.
Small is what we want,
Dylan said. Max would rather go to a small school.
Actually, the school is mid-sized,
Sally said. It serves two neighboring towns as well. I’m sure Max will have plenty of friends.
She smiled at him, but he looked away.
This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?