FEBRUARY 2012 DECIDED CASES IN LABOR

1. 87% [ G.R. No. 196830, February 29, 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. No. 196830, Feb Query occured 49 time(s) in this document. ... [ G.R. No. 196830, February 29, 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. No. 196830, February 29, 2012 ] CESAR V. GARCIA, CARLOS RAZON, ALBERTO DE GUZMAN, TOMAS RAZON, OMER E. PALO, RIZALDE VALENCIA, ...of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 115851, affirming the 8 February [3] and 25 June [4] 2010 Resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) in NLRC-LAC-No. 12-004061-08. The NLRC set aside the 30 October 2008 Decision [5] of the Labor Arbiter in NLRC Case No. RAB-III-02-9779-06. The Facts Respondent KJ Commercial

2. 87%

[ G.R. No. 173882, February 15, 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G.R. No. 173882, Febr Query occured 42 time(s) in this document. ... [ G.R. No. 173882, February 15, 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G.R. No. 173882, February 15, 2012 ] JULIE’S BAKESHOP AND/OR EDGAR REYES, PETITIONERS, VS. HENRY ARNAIZ EDGAR NAPAL, * AND JONATHAN ...the Resolutions dated December 18, 2003 [3] and April 19, 2004 [4] of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) and ordered petitioners to reinstate respondents Henry Arnaiz (Arnaiz), Edgar Napal (Napal)

3. 85%

[ G.R. No. 193667, February 29, 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. No. 193667, Feb Query occured 6 time(s) in this document. ... [ G.R. No. 193667, February 29, 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. No. 193667, February 29, 2012 ] PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, APPELLEE, VS. MARIAVIC ESPENILLA Y MERCADO, APPELLANT. R E S O ...the activities within the meaning of "recruitment and placement" under Article 13(b) of the Labor Code, or any of the prohibited practices enumerated under Article 34 of the said Code

4. 84%

[ G.R. No. 167952, February 01, 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G.R. No. 167952, Febr Query occured 9 time(s) in this document. ... [ G.R. No. 167952, February 01, 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G.R. No. 167952, February 01, 2012 ] GONZALO PUYAT & SONS, INC., PETITIONER, VS. RUBEN ALCAIDE (DECEASED), SUBSTITUTED BY GLORIA ALCAIDE, REPRESENTATIVE OF ...petition for review on certiorari seeking to reverse and set aside the Decision [1] dated February 1, 2005 of the Court of Appeals (CA) in CA-G.R. SP No. 86069,

5. 83%

[ G.R. No. 187733, February 08, 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. No. 187733, Feb Query occured 6 time(s) in this document. ... [ G.R. No. 187733, February 08, 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. No. 187733, February 08, 2012 ] PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, APPELLEE, VS. TEOFILO “REY” BUYAGAN, APPELLANT. R E S O L ...died; he was not a worker

91974. VS.R. 186983. INC.. JAKOSALEM AND GODOFREDO B. February 08. 185665. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. EASTERN TELECOMS EMPLOYEES UNION. No. INC. v. No. February 15. . 7. Fifth Division.R. see: S unace International Management Services. INC. Inc.R. Febr Query occured 6 time(s) in this document. February 15. March 06. February 08.R. 2012 Query occured 54 time(s) in this document. 515 Phil... 179652.. D E . Court of Appeals.. SP No. 186983. M-008246- 10. No. SP No.. RODANTE YNSON. [ G.R... 175025.R.earning less than the current minimum wage under current labor laws.. . 175932. No. 6. 2012 ] PEOPLE’S BROADCASTING SERVICE (BOMBO RADYO PHILS. established jurisprudence only allows expenses duly supported by receipts. 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. 175932. annulling the April 28. March 06.R. 185665. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. RESPONDENT. February 08. March 06. February 15.R.. 2012 ] WUERTH PHILIPPINES.CA-G. in NLRC CA NO..R. Febr Query occured 28 time(s) in this document. No. No. No.R. 83% [ G. 185665.R. INC.R. 1994.. National Labor Relations Commission. ” The Facts As synthesized by the NLRC. February 15. FLORENDO. 179652. No.R. the facts 9. No. February 22. 2012 ] MA. N ew Life Enterprises v. PETITIONER.R. 185665.R. [ G.. No. respondent Barangan sent a letter [17] to petitioner Dulfo demanding that he and 8. 186983.Section 30 of the Insurance Code. [ G. With respect to actual damages. 2012 ] ROGELIO J. February 15. PHILAM PLANS. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G... 83% [ G..R.. PETITIONER. D E C I . .G. Febr Query occured 10 time(s) in this document. Philippines. 81% [ G. 80% [ G.R. 186983. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. PETITIONER. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G.R.R.R. No. February 15. 175932. RESPONDENT. . 2005 Resolution [3] of the National Labor Relations Commission ( NLRC ) in NLRC-NCR-CC-000273-04 entitled “ In the Matter of the Labor Dispute in Eastern Telecommunications. . No. No. No. 779. which affirmed with modification the Resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC). 175025. [16] On February 4. VS. PERLA ABCEDE AND MA. No. .. No.. 175932. 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. 82% [ G. February 22.R. Cagayan de Oro City. No. RESPONDENT. March 06. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. 179652. BARANGAN. 2012 ] EASTERN TELECOMMUNICATIONS PHILIPPINES.. DULFO PETITIONERS. 175025.. 00845.. Febr Query occured 34 time(s) in this document. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. [ G. February 22.R. ROBERTO S.). 175025. No.it was being occupied by petitioner Godofredo Dulfo (petitioner Dulfo) and his family. 179652. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. 787 (2006). VS. CELESTE ABCEDE. D E C I S I O . . VS. Inc. No. LOURDES S. No. [ G.

SP No. 2000 Decision [3] of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC). AND PAULINA T. ALEXANDER ANGELES. February 15. February 08. . LABOR ARBITER FELIPE T. Feb Query occured 47 time(s) in this document. PETITIONERS. ROBOSA. 192558. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. RESPONDENTS. AND ITS RESPONSIBLE OFFICIALS LED BY FRANKLIN . No. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G.R. THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR.. 160278. No. SP No.R. 176085. CONCHA RESPONDENT.. PETITIONERS. 00855.R.R. VS. D E . 160278. GARDUQUE II AND HILARIA CRUZ. private respondent was referred to the Metropolitan Hospital.R..R.. . [ G.. Private respondent Jandeleon Juezan filed a complaint against petitioner with the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) Regional Office No. 109975. February 08. 100% [ G. No. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION. . He underwent medical treatment until February 2001.R. 2006 [3] in CAG. 2009 Decision [3] of the National Labor Relations Commission ( NLRC ) in the case entitled Bitoy Javier v. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. No. PINTO. .R. VS. 160278. 192558. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. 13.R. February 15. R E S . DOLE REGION VII. FLY ACE CORPORATION/ FLORDELYN CASTILLO. which reversed the May 28.No.R.PETITIONER. [ G. nonpayment of service 11.1] seeking the reversal of the resolutions of the Court of Appeals (CA) rendered on February 24. 2012 ] BITOY JAVIER (DANILO P. Feb Query occured 24 time(s) in this document. No. 2006 [2] and December 14. 192558.R. 2012 ] GARDEN OF MEMORIES PARK AND LIFE PLAN.. No. . RESPONDENTS..R. THE SECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT.. AND NANETTE H. INC. CHEMO-TECHNISCHE MANUFACTURING. [ G. 185463. ) in finding that petitioner Garden of Memories Memorial Park and Life Plan. February 08.. SECOND DIVISION.. February 22. NOEL D. No. [4] 12.R.R. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. The NLRC agreed with the Labor Arbiter ( L. Febr Query occured 25 time(s) in this document.R. No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. 92% [ G. February 08..R. SP No. PETITIONER. 14. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. VII. No. VS.. INC. No. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION). 80436.. Cebu City.. Fly Ace/Flordelyn Castillo . 160278. No. for illegal deduction. ROXAS. 176085. February 08. 64569. VS. 185463. which affirmed the December 29... 176085. INC.. February 15. February 22. D E C I S I . [ G. AND JANDELEON JUEZAN. No. ROLANDO E. No. RESPONDENTS. RAMIER C. Febr Query occured 50 time(s) in this document. 185463. 2012 ] TEEKAY SHIPPING PHILS. 94% [ G. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. February 08. As he had not been . 2012 ] FEDERICO S. 92% [ G. AND/OR TEEKAY SHIPPING CANADA. PANDY.his arrival. No. VS..R.. 192558. No. 176085. FERNANDO EMBAT. VERONICA GUTIERREZ. No.R. REQUIÑO. 185463.A.. February 22.R. PETITIONERS. JAVIER).

and service incentive leave pays. 171701. [ A. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. Concepcion (complainants) praying for the disbarment of Labor Arbiter Jovencio Ll. February 27. No. . No.. Findings of the Labor Arbiter The labor arbiter (LA) ruled that there was no basis to hold petitioners liable for illegal dismissal. February 15. [ G. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ A.. NESTOR TUGUINAY...C. 42-52.the PCGG filed an amended Complaint to add Constante Rubio as defendant. 1203 dated February 17. LABOR ARBITER JOVENCIO LL. 186132.. February 22. 2012 ] TOMAS K. No. AND MARY GRACE S. February 15.. this time to include as . 182650. VS. CONCEPCION.C. PARUNGAO. No. * JJ . 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.Bersamin.R. Mayor.. 2012 ] JOSAN. 7430. 91% [ G.. 182650. or any of the prohibited practices enumerated under Article 34 of the said Code 18. JR.assessed whether he was fit to work as a 15. No. 186132. it amended the Complaint. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ A. 2012 ] PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES. WESTMONT BANK. 2012 ] REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES PETITIONER.. PETITIONER. Feb Query occured 17 time(s) in this document. [ G.. VS. COMPLAINANTS. RESPONDENT. No.. No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. 89% [ G. 190794. 7430. No. CHUA. IMELDA "IMEE" R. February 27. No. 171701. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. R E S O L U T I O . No. EDUARDO RAMOS ADUNA. [1] Rollo . 7430. R. February 08. . VS. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. Februar Query occured 38 time(s) in this document. [ G.R..and nonpayment of overtime. February 22. 89% [ G. . 91% [ A. No.R. (respondent) for alleged gross misconduct and violation of lawyer’s 17. 7430.. MARCOS-MANOTOC. .C. No. concur. 2012 ] MARTIN LAHM III AND JAMES P.. VS. No. No.R. February 15. F Query occured 8 time(s) in this document. 182650.R. APPELLEE.. No. REGISTRAR OF . February 27. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. R.. 2012. JPS. SANTIAGO CARGO MOVERS.R.. February 22.R.R. 171701. [ G.filed by Martin Lahm III and James P. 190794. MAYOR. and Perlas-Bernabe.R. REGISTRAR OF DEEDS OF PARAÑAQUE CITY. * PETITIONERS. . February 08. * Designated additional member per Special Order No. February 08. No.. . No. February 27. holiday. 13th month. pp. R. 89% [ G..R. . 190794. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R.. R.. February 27.the activities within the meaning of "recruitment and placement" under Article 13(b) of the Labor Code. 186132. 171701.C. Penned by Associate Justice Myrna Dimaranan-Vidal with Associate Justices 16. MA. No. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. 186132. Jr. February 27. 190794. APPELLANT. 182650. No. No. Feb Query occured 9 time(s) in this document. VS. 19.. FERDINAND "BONGBONG" R. Again on 9 February 1988. Febr Query occured 8 time(s) in this document. D E C I S I .R.

. . P-11-2926.. . 187122. P-11-2926. February 01.review on certiorari assailing the Decision [1] dated September 17. 79% [ G. 175558.Court of Appeals in CA-G. 2012 ] LYNVIL FISHING ENTERPRISES. [ G.R. February 08.R.. 2012 ] NEGROS SLASHERS. 2008 and Resolution [2] dated February 11 2009 of the Court of Appeals (CA) in CA-G. REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF MACABEBE. Feb Query occured 31 time(s) in this document. February 22.. 76% [ G. Febr Query occured 32 time(s) in this document. 175558.M. which is 23.. 181974. No.. 21. LTD. .. No. PETITIONERS.R..M.R.D. No. February 01. No.defendants Nemesio G.R. NATHANIEL DOZA. except as to the award of attorney's fees. No. 175558.R. [3] This arose from consolidated labor case [4] filed by seafarers Napoleon De Gracia (De Gracia). PETITIONERS. 2012 ] JUDGE LUCINA ALPEZ DAYAON. BRANCH 54. the Decision of the Labor Arbiter is hereby REINSTATED .R. 174941. INC. In lieu thereof. 181974. February 22. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. P11-2926. The dispositive portion of the assailed decision reads: WHEREFORE. . RODOLFO C.M. COMPLAINANT.R.R. No. AND/OR ROSENDO S. No. February 01.. Alcovendas. PETITIONERS. February 01. Nos. SP No.R. No.R. February 01. . ANDRES G. VS.. 88% [ G. 2004 rendered by the National Labor Relations Commission is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE . 181974.R. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ A. the Decision dated March 31. February 22. No. SP No. 174941. [ A. ALVIN L. No. No. 2012 ] SKIPPERS UNITED PACIFIC.R. RESPONDENT. No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. VS. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. the OCA found De Leon habitually absent for incurring unauthorized absences for the months 24. premises considered. . INC. 187122.judiciary for 18 years. Lata (Lata).R.. PRESIDING JUDGE. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. No. 77% [ A. INC. TENG. Jimmy B. 187122. VS. ARIOLA. ALVAREZ AND VICENTE TAN. Nos. 181974. 187122. . Co and 20.. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ A. Calinao and Leopoldo Sebullen thereby reversing the Resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC). [ G. INC.R. The OCA's Report and Recommendation In its Report dated 10 February 2011. PAMPANGA. DE BORJA. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. 175558. No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. Charlie 22. February 08.R... No. Feb Query occured 40 time(s) in this document. February 01. 88148.. Isidro L. NAPOLEON .. AND SKIPPERS MARITIME SERVICES. P-11292 Query occured 7 time(s) in this document.M. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.. [ G. 00817. 79% [ G.. No. February 08. February 01.. .

February 15.R. 173291.R. No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. Febr Query occured 25 time(s) in this document.. February 01. REPRESENTED BY THE PRIVATIZATION AND MANAGEMENT OFFICE (PMO).R. through Baldemor’s reply to the labor arbiter’s summons.. PANTRANCO . No. .R. 2006 Resolution [3] of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)... No. February 08. February 15.. February 15. RESPONDENTS.” [9] Cityland.end their opposition to the liquidation proceedings upon the execution of the Agreement [24] dated February 10. February 15.F Query occured 43 time(s) in this document. VS. No. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. 179469. ROCHA.. on the basis of which the parties moved for the dismissal of G. 2012 ] ANTONIO P. RESPONDENTS. INC.R. [ G. VS.R.R. [ G.R.R. . 174941.R. No. AND JOHN J. [10] denied liability for Galang’s money claims. D E C . 161771. February 01. February 15. 174941. 179469. 173291.. .. No.Management Office (PMO) to set aside the September 27. PETITIONERS. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. No. . No. The CA ruled that the petition was premature since petitioner did not 28.comprehensive examination of the accusation against complainant. No.R. No.R. No..R. 26. 178593. AND VIRGILIO BALDEMOR. .F. No. 2004 are ANNULLED and SET ASIDE 25.R.. D E . 74% [ G. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. 178593.R. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G.R. February 08. AS SUCCESSOR-ININTEREST OF FAR EAST BANK AND TRUST . The assailed resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission dated September 10. 2003 and January 21. No. the original and supplemental petitions are GRANTED . February 15.R. COURT OF APPEALS AND CLARK DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION. 2012 ] ROMEO A. [ G. CITYLAND SHAW TOWER. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. 73% [ G.. 178593. Nos.. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G.. 161771.. 173291. PETITIONER. 161771.. PETITIONERS. February 15. INC..an Order . February 15. Nos. 179469.. February 15.premises considered.. [ G. 2012 ] BANK OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS. No. 2003. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. Feb Query occured 27 time(s) in this document. February 08. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. 173291. No..R. Febr Query occured 7 time(s) in this document. 2012 ] REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES. 75% [ G.. 179469. [ G. VS. maintaining that either the 27. Feb Query occured 8 time(s) in this document. 178593. SHARP & CO. 2012 ] C. PETITIONER. VS. PIONEER INSURANCE & SURETY CORPORATION. SALENGA AND NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION. . 75% [ G. No. GALANG. 161771.

No. 2009 and the resolution [3] dated February 10.. No. No. 192274. Sharp guilty of violation of Article 34(k) of the Labor Code. 191288 & 191304. CONTRARY TO LAW. VS. PETITIONER. 188722. No.. the respondent. February 28. February 08.. 192984..VS. 2012 ] ROLANDO D. No.: Nature of . 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. VS.R. February 28.R. 188722. PETITIONER.R.R.R.. 71% [ G.R.R.. 188722. February 29. peasant. 170098. February 28 Query occured 8 time(s) in this document.. SP. VS.R. J. February 29.. PETITIONER.R. No. ROMMEL J. February 08. and such other sectors as may be 32. 170098. Nos. Febr Query occured 8 time(s) in this document. 71% [ G. after the trial had started. PETITIONER. 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. February 29. [ G.list representatives shall be filled. Pampanga. 170098. No.R. PETITIONER. Feb Query occured 20 time(s) in this document. 31. Febr Query occured 13 time(s) in this document.. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R... No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. INC. Nos. [ G. to 30. by selection or election from the labor. February 29. February 01. 71% [ G.seeking to annul the decision [2] dated August 25.R. RESPONDENTS. JAN CARLO GALA. D E C I S I O N REYES. youth. Nos. MARIANO VELARDE (ALIAS “BROTHER MIKE”) AND BUHAY . No. MANILA ELECTRIC . 2010 of the Court of Appeals (CA) rendered in CA-G. 2012 ] BANK OF LUBAO..R. [4] On February 12. 73% [ G.Corporation. 191288 & 191304.. VS... No. No. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. [ G. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G.R.R. LAYUG. 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. In the said complaint. as provided by law.. . Lee filed his Motion for Document and Handwriting 33. Query occured 18 time(s) in this document. .R. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G.R..finding C. 2012 ] NORBERTO LEE. . urban poor.F. . 2007. women. 192984. D E C I S I . 192274. 170098. No. [ G.filed a Complaint [3] for illegal dismissal with the Regional Arbitration Branch of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) in San Fernando City. 191288 & 191304. . February 08. 192274. 2012 ] MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY. 70% [ G. February 01. PADUATA.R. [ G.R.R. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES AND ALLIED BANK. Nos. No. 192984. herein represented by Ketty Uy in the aforesaid amount. 2012 ] DANIEL O. 192984. February 29. D E C . RESPONDENT. February 01. 192274. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. February 29. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. 188722.. Nos. which makes it unlawful for any entity “to withhold or deny travel documents from 29. RESPONDENTS. February 28. indigenous cultural communities. No.. MANABAT AND THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION. No. No.

172223. 185572. 194306. . 1995 affirmed the Labor Arbiter’s ruling.. dated October 25. No. Feb Query occured 12 time(s) in this document. February 08. 172223. JR. 1992 he filed a complaint for illegal suspension and underpayment against MERALCO which the Labor Arbiter decided in his favor on October 8.. No. [8] On 26 February 2004. No.R. 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. 172223. (GROUP). Feb Query occured 19 time(s) in this document. 2001.R.. BART Q. 2012 ] BRIGHT MARITIME CORPORATION (BMC)/DESIREE P.050.. February 08. 63% [ G.. February 07. In a letter [8] dated February 16.R. 2012 ] CANADIAN OPPORTUNITIES UNLIMITED. the Philippine government and EXIM Bank entered into a counterpart financial agreement – Buyer Credit . VS. 194306. Dalangin claimed that Abad issued a memorandum [8] requiring him 37.R.COMPANY (MERALCO)... 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. RESPONDENT.R. Bernardo recommended to Cruz and 36. PETITIONER. No.. No.. No. February 06.R. February 06. 165935. 70% [ G. 172223. Fantonial was illegally dismissed. No.. 1993.. [ G. PALACIO DEL GOBERNADOR CONDOMINIUM CORPORATION AND/OR OMAR T. PETITIONERS. Based on this. D E C I .No.. 185572. OASAY.R. No. 2012 ] CHINA NATIONAL MACHINERY & EQUIPMENT CORP. FANTONIAL. IN HIS OFFICIAL . RESPONDENT. Febr Query occured 20 time(s) in this document. 69% [ G. 185572. . .14. 2006.000.the function of the Bids and Awards Committee of PDGCC. reversing and setting aside the Decision of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC). [ G. 2012 ] THIRD DIVISION [ G. 185572.R. except under circumstances provided in Article 89 of the Labor Code. [ G. February 07... MERALCO reinstated Paduata on its payroll on October 10.price for the Northrail Project was pegged at USD 421. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. February 06. No. No.R. HON. 2012 ] EN BANC [ G.R. MERALCO appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC).R. No. 165935.R. RESPONDENT. DALANGIN. [ G. Atty. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.. 2012 ] SEBASTIAN F. February 08.R. INC.R. VS. VS.R.. TENORIO. 34. which on August 14. No. February 06. February 06. 165935.. 194306.. 2004. and reinstating the Decision of the Labor Arbiter finding that respondent Ricardo B. No. PETITIONER.. February 07. after investigating the allegations against the petitioner. PETITIONER. No. February 06. 194306. 165935. 67571. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G.R. VS. SANTAMARIA. February 07 Query occured 17 time(s) in this document. On October 26. No.in the office beyond office hours. . RICARDO B. D E . No. 2012 ] SECOND DIVISION [ G. CESAR D.. 65% [ G. but the Court of Appeals 35. . JR. D E C I S .

February 14.R. BENNY CABTALAN.R. No. PETITIONER.00 is hereby AFFIRMED.R. 2012 ] Query occured 16 time(s) in this document. RESPONDENT...the victim in this case . 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. . 2012 ] EN BANC [ G. 2003.. 2012 ] ARTEMIO VILLAREAL. No. ACCUSED.R.R. D E C I S . RESPONDENT. 151258. 2008-006 dated February 18.R. VS. Accordingly. 2012 ] [ G.outrage over the death of Leonardo "Lenny" Villa . [ G. 61% [ G. VS.. February 14 Query occured 18 time(s) in this document. No. [ G. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. the Board of 40.. No. February 14.38. VS. 194710. Febr Query occured 11 time(s) in this document..R.if he is either “(1) self-employed earning less than the minimum wage under current labor laws. . No. February 01.R. ADRIANO CABRILLAS. [1] Due . 56% [ G.R. 2012 ] FIRST DIVISION [ G. COMMISSION ON AUDIT. NO.R.. [2] Factual Antecedents On July 30. APPELLANT. and judicial notice may be taken of the fact that in [his] line of 39.. February 15. . 151258. No. February 01.000. 175980. No. 60% [ G.. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES.R. PETITIONER.R.. 2012 ] PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES.790.P44. 151258. No.R. LAO -Corporate Decision No. 175980. 154954] PEOPLE OF . [G.. 175980. 151258. No. 175980. [ G. No. 194710.on 10 February 1991 led to a very strong clamor to put an end to hazing. February 01. February 01. 194710. 2008 is hereby AFFIRMED. D E C . February 15.APPELLEE. 2012 ] MANILA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY. February 15. 194710. February 14. No. 2012 ] [ G.. No.

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful