P. 1
House Management Report

House Management Report

|Views: 2,153|Likes:
Published by CBCPolitics

More info:

Published by: CBCPolitics on Oct 09, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





Gestion de la Cbambre

53: s
nursday, April 1, 1993
The Standing Committee on House Management, pursuant to Standing Order
108(3)(a), has the honour to present its
'i994 0 1 0 7
1BlBL!OiHEGUE DU PARi E ~ , . f N T .

ae aa \..!UIIIlDrC .,., • _.

The Colnmittee recommends that:
. . .
Members of Parliament. should more aware of the confidence
convention, and the observations of the Special Committee on Reform of the
House of Commons. With few exceptions, mo$Jons proposed by the
government should be considered as motions of conftdenc;e only when clearly
identified as such by the government. Standing Order 6 should be deleted.
z. Allotted Days and Opposition Motions
It is clear that both the Lefebvre and McGrath Committees were particularly concerned
about the fact that the reference to. confidence in the Standing Orders to the status of
voable motions moved by the opposition on allotted days, also known as "opposition days."
The Standing. Order which dealt with these ''votable days" carried over a language of ·
confidence that was more appropriate to motions concerning the former committe·e of supply
that existed before the parliamentary reforms of 1968, when the estimates were dealt with by
the whole House. Although the McGrath Report led to the removal of these inappropriate
references to antecedent procedures, there continues to be confusion, and inappropriate
application of the confidence. convention to votable motions on opposition days. ·
Recently, the Government House Leader, the Hon. Harvie Andre, rose in the House and
announced that a particular opposition day vote would not be considered a question of
confidence by the government. This was a welcome initiative on the part of the Government.
The Committee notes, however, that the McGrath Report could be interpreted as requiring
that the Government only needs to rise and indicate when it wishes to deem a vote a matter of
confidence; in other words, in the absence of any indication by the Government, it should be
assumed that the vote will not be considered a test ·of confidence.
The Committee recommends that:
2. The Standing Orders should be amended to expressly state that no vote on
opposition motion, on an· allotted day will be considered a vote of conftdenc;e
unless the government expresslY announces that it wiD treat it as such or
motion itself is explicitly worded as a vote of confidence.
Standing Order 31 was introduced in 1982 means of enabling Members who are not
cabinet ministers to speak for up to one minute on virtually any matter of national, proVincial
or local concern during the 15-minute period that precedes daily oral Question The
Standing Order provides an important opportunity for Members to voice and put on the record
the concerns of their and to raise other important issues .
Standing Order 31 is intended for the benefit of individual Members, not for political
Parties. It should, of course, reflect to some extent the party standings in the House, put it is
fundamentally a forum. for Members. In keeping with our recommendations to diminish the ..' ·
control- and perceived - of parties, we believe that the use of party lists as 'to ·
should be called upon and in what order should be SC?verely restricted. .
House Management 1-4-1993,
The Committee recommends that:
3. The Speaker should exercise greater discretion and independence hi choosing
Members to mate statements under Order .31, .Provided that each
recognized partY m_ay designate one Member wbo shall be the first· for .
such party. (This recommendation is not to affect the proportion: of ,
·statements allocated to Members of ditterent political parties.)
·It is also important that .Members not abuse ·the opportunities afforded them under
Standing Order 31. This does all Members of the House a disservice, and reflects poorly on the
House itself. Without the Speaker will be in a better position to discipline individual
Members who do not abide by the rules. The Speaker retains discretion oyer the acceptability
of each statement under Standing Order 31.
The recommends that:
· 4. The time limits regarding statements pursuant to Standing Order 31 should be·
strictly observed and enforced, so as to enable as many Members as pOssible to
avail themselves of this· opportunity, and to keep the statements within the
intent of the
Time is always scarce in the Hquse of Commons. Although there are various
opportunities for Members to raise issues and concerns, such as statements· under Standing
Order 31 and Question Period, the demand is usually than the time available.· Yet a
certain amount of parliamentary time is being "wasted/' and not used as fully as it could be.
In this regard, we note in particular the time during which the bells are being rung for a
division or vote. As soon as the bells start, the business of the House. comes to a halt. The
Committee believes that part of this time could be used profitably to enable Members to make
state.ments similar to those under Standing Order 31. This would allow topical issues, and
concerns of interest to particular parts of the country or particular groups to be raised. The
same basic guidelines would apply as do in the ca8e of Standing Order 31.
The intent of this change is not to encourage the use of divisions. Rather, it is designed to
take advantage of time that is not otherwise being It would not be available during bells
for any division on a dilatory
We believe that this ic{ea has potential. At this point, we are orily recommending that it be
implemented on an basis. We propose that initially it only be used during
30-minute bells, that statements be taken only for a period·of 15 minutes, ·calculated from when
the bells begin, and that Members be allowed to speak for up to 90 seconds.
The Committee .recommends that:
Members be allowed to make statements of up to 90 seconds durilig.the ringing
of a 30-minute division bell, except on a dilatory motion;· suclt statements to
being as soon as the bells start to ring and to continue for a .. ntaximum of 15


You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->