API4FDesignStudy:ASD89toLRFD05

MikeEffenberger,P.E
SathishRamamoorthy,Ph.D.,P.E.
June,2012;PN1101213

DocumentNo.SES1101213PPT001,Rev.0a

Preliminary subject to QA check

Contents

API4FWork
Background
Objectives
DesignStudyMethodology
ModelDetails
AISC05AnalysisSpecifications
Rig1DesignStudyResults
DetailedDesignResults

Rig3DesignStudyResults
DetailedDesignResults

API4F

APIFundedStudy CheckEffectofLoadFactorsforDrillingStructures
Paper CodeConversionIssuesGoingFromASDtoLRFD DraftProvided
CommentsDueJune24
FirstStudyMeeting 2222012
API4FWorkGroup
MarkTrevithick(T&TEngineering) Chair
AnthonyMannering(PrecisionDrilling)
MarcusMcCoo(NOV)
PaulLandis(LeeCMoore)
FirstLoadFactors ASCE7
ModelsReceived(last):03/05/2012
FinishWorkDate:11/05/2012

API4FDesignStudyStatus
6132012

Paper Issued as Draft (Close 6-24-2012) Issue to API End of June

Rig 1 Boot-Strap Mast Complete (Pending Review)
ASD-89 (StruCAD & SAP)
ASD-05 1st Order & ASD-05- P-Delta
LRFD-05
Rig 3 Derrick
ASD-89 & LRFD-05
Rig 2 Mast & Substructure
In progress Duplicate Plate Element Issues (Removed)
Rig 4 Dual Derrick Duplicate Element Issue (Merging Elements)
Rig 5 Workover Staad Model Transfer Issues (Working with
Designer)

Background

API4F,SpecificationforDrillingandWellServicingStructures

API4FcommitteeisinterestedingoingfromtheAllowable
StressDesigntothelateststrengthdesignAllowableStrength
Design(ASD)/LoadandResistanceFactorDesign(LRFD)
provisioninAISC36005specification.

LatestAISCspecificationisAISC36010.The2010edition
supersedesandisanupdateofthe2005edition.The2010
editionisyettobesupportedbyComputerPrograms.

statesrequirementsandgivesrecommendationsforsuitablesteel
structuresfordrillingandwellservicingoperations
API4Fspecifiesthesteelstructurestobedesignedinaccordancewith
AllowableStressDesign/Elasticdesign perAISC33589

Background

IntheLRFDdesignmethodology,designresultsare
affectedbytheloadfactorsselectedfortheindividual
loads(selfweight,hookload,andenvironmentalloads)
Forbuildingdesign,loadfactorsandloadcombinationsare
specifiedinASCE7,MinimumDesignLoadsforBuildingsand
OtherStructures

Theloadfactorsaregenerallyestimatedusingthe
statisticaldatafortheindividualloadsandreliability
concepts
StatisticaldataforHookloadisnotreadilyavailable.Therefore,
theloadfactorsgiveninASCE705willbeusedforthedesign
study(firstcaseevaluation)

Objectives
Paperdocumentingtheexperienceofother

codes/specificationwhilechangingfromASDtoLRFD
methodology
Performdesignstudyonsixstructures(workover,
mast,derrick&substructure)designedusingtheASD
andLRFDdesignprovisions.
Hookloadwillbeconsideredasliveloadwithaload
factorof1.6(ASCE7,FirstCaseEvaluation)
DecidedbytheAPI4Fworkgroupon02/22/2012

Methodology
DesignperformedusingtheAllowableStress

Design/ElasticDesignprovisionsinAISC33589will
bethebasecase.
ThestructureswillbeevaluatedaccordingtoAISC
33589ASDandLRFDdesignprovisionsperAISC
36005specification
ThedesignresultsbetweentheElasticdesignand
StrengthDesignwillbecomparedforevaluation

DerrickandMastModelsProvidedto
SESforDesignStudy
Elevation
Noof Set
fromWater
Lines Back Height
Line
Operating Unexpected Expected
(kip) (ft)
(ft)
ReferenceWindSpeed
(knots)

Model
Name

Type

Hook
Load
(kip)

Rig1

Mast

441

10

xxx

92

42

70

93

102.5

Rig2

Mast&
Substructure

750

12

500

160

32

71.7

95.6

Land Rig

Rig3

SingleDerrick

1500

14

xxx

195

50

100

115

70

DualDerrick

2500
1500
(Aux)

242

65.1

xxx

100

83.7

104

25

60

75

Rig4

Rig5** WorkoverMast

250

16
14 1750
(Aux)
6

xxx

Notes:
AnalyticalmodelsforRig1toRig4weredevelopedinStruCAD
ForRig5,AnalyticalmodelwasdevelopedinSTAAD
9

LandRig

Rig1
441kipHookLoadMast

10

Rig2
750kipHookLoadMast&Substructure

11

Rig3
1500kipHookLoadSingleDerrick

12

Rig4
2500 kipHookLoadDualDerrick

13

Rig5
250kipHookLoadWorkoverMast

14

SoftwareDetails
SAP2000Ultimate15.1.0fromComputersand

Structures,Inc(CSI)wasusedforthedesignstudy.
SAPisaintegratedsoftwareforstructuralanalysis
anddesign
P withlargedisplacements
Bucklinganalysis
DesignCodes

15

ASD89
ASD05
LRFD05
LRFD10(Laterin2012)

StruCADtoSAP2000Conversion
StruCADmodelswereimportedinSAP.Theimported

16

modelswerecomparedwiththeStruCADmodels.
Ingeneral,mostofthemodelfeaturesareimported
withoutanyissues.However,therearefewStruCAD
commands/featuresthatarenotimportedinSAP.
Thesearemanuallyeditedintheimportedmodel.
SAPtechnicalsupportanddevelopmentteamwere
notifiedabouttheimportissues.

StruCADtoSAP2000Conversion
Outstandingissues
EffectiveLengthFactorsnotimported
Effectivelengthspecified/usedintheStruCADmodelis
enteredasDesignOverwritesinSAPmodel

WindLoads/AreaCardsarenotimported
WindloadsareconvertedtoMemberandJointLoadsin
StruCADandimportedinSAP

AccelerationLoads
Discrepancyinthebasereactionsfortheacceleration
loadsintheStruCADandSAPmodels.Therefore,the
accelerationloadsareconvertedtoMember/jointloadsin
StruCADandthenimportedinSAP
17

StruCADtoSAP2000Conversion
Designissues
Cmfactor
DifferenceincalculatingtheCmfactorbetweenStruCAD
andSAP

BraceSpacing
StruCADhasoptiontoinputtothebracespacingfor
estimatingtheeffectivelength.SAPdoesnothavean
equivalentparametertomodify

18

DesignBasis
AISC1989Specification
AllowableStressDesign(ASD89)

AISC2005Specification
LoadandResistanceFactorDesign(LRFD05)

19

DesignBasis
AllowableStressDesign89

TheimportedmodelswereruninSAPandcompared
withtheStruCADresults
Ingeneral,thememberforcesarecomparabletothe
StruCADmemberforces.Forsomemembers,thereisa
smalldiscrepancyintheminorandmajoraxismoments.

AllowableStressDesign(ASD89)
Staticlinearanalysis
With1/3rd increaseinallowablestressforexpectedand
unexpectedloadcase

20

DesignBasis

AllowableStrengthDesign05
ForRig1Only
AllowableStrengthDesign(ASD05)

Effectivelengthmethod
Secondorderanalysismethod(includesp andp)
Without1/3rd increaseinallowableforwindloadcombinations
API4Floadcombinations
Case
1a
1b
2
3a
3b*
4
5

21

DesignLoading
Condition
Operating
Operating
Expected
Unexpected
Unexpected
Erection
Transportation

DeadLoad
(%)
100
100
100
100
100
100
100

HookLoad RotaryLoad
(%)
(%)
100
0
TE*100%
100
TE*100%
100
TE*100%
100

100
0
100
0

SetbackLoad
(%)
100
100
0
100

0
100

EnvironmentalLoads
(%)
100
100
100
100

100
100

Note:Loadcombination3bisforEarthquakeloadsandwasnotincluded
inthisstudy

DesignBasis
LoadandResistanceFactorDesign05

LoadandResistanceFactorDesign(LRFD05)

Effectivelengthmethod
Generalsecondorderanalysismethod(includesp andp)
Without1/3rd increaseinallowableforwindloadcombinations
Hookloadisconsideredasliveloadwith1.6loadfactorsimilarto
ASCE705liveloads
Case
1a
1b
2
3a
3b
4
5

DesignLoading DeadLoad HookLoad RotaryLoad SetbackLoad EnvironmentalLoads

Condition
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
Operating
120
160
0
160
100
Operating
120
TE*160%
120
120
100
Expected
120
TE*100%
100
0
160
Unexpected
120
TE*100%
100
100
160
Unexpected
120

Erection
120
160
0
0
100
Transportation
120
160
0
160
100

Note:Otherloadsshouldbeclassified(forexloadsinRig3Model
22

ComparisonofAnalysisMethods
AISC05Specification
DirectAnalysis
Method

EffectiveLength
Method

FirstOrder Analysis
Method

SpecificationReference

Appendix7

SectionC.2.2a

SectionC.2.2b

Limitson Applicability

No

Yes

Yes

SecondOrder

SecondOrder

FirstOrder

ReducedEIandEA

NominalEIandEA

NominalEIandEA

Notionallateralload

Yes

Yes

Yes

Columneffectivelength

K=1

Sidesway buckling
analysis

K=1

Typeofanalysis
Member stiffness

Note:InAISC10specification,DirectAnalysisismovedtoSectionC.
EffectivelengthandFirsOrderAnalysisMethodsaremovedtoAppendix7
23

ComparisonofAnalysisMethods
DirectAnalysis
Method

EffectiveLength
Method

FirstOrder Analysis
Method

SpecificationReference

Appendix7

SectionC.2.2a

SectionC.2.2b

Limitson Applicability

No

Yes

Yes

SecondOrder

SecondOrder

FirstOrder

ReducedEIandEA

NominalEIandEA

NominalEIandEA

Notionallateralload

Yes

Yes

Yes

Columneffectivelength

K=1

Sidesway buckling
analysis

K=1

Typeofanalysis
Member stiffness

Notconsideredinthisstudy

24

EffectiveLengthMethodDetails
LinearLoadcombination
NoPDelta

AmplifiedFirstOrder

K=1
ForceeffectsareamplifiedbyB1
andB2factortoaccountforP
Delta**

EffectiveLength
Method

Nonlinearloadcombination
Pdelta

GeneralSecond
Order

EffectivelengthfromStruCAD
model(sideswaybuckling
analysiswasnotperformed)
Notionallateralloadforgravity
loadcombinationsisnot
included

**B1andB2factorsaccountfortheP andP.ForthecurrentAPI4F
study,tostudytheeffectofchangesinthespecificationformember
strength,theB1andB2factorof1.0wasused.Comparisonofdesignresults
betweentheASD05(Firstorder)andASD89willshowtheeffectofchanges
inspecifications.
25

Rig1DesignStudyResults
(BootStrapMast)
TotalnumberofMembers
347(excluding16dummymembers)

SAPclassifiesthemembers
Beams(allelementsparalleltotheXYplane)
184

Brace(allelementsnotclassifiedasbeamsorcolumns)
85

Column(allelementsparalleltotheZaxis)
78

26

Rig1
441kipHookLoadMast

Rig1

27

Rig1
Beams
184

Rig1
Braces
85

Rig1
Columns
78

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
441kipHookLoadMast

Members
withunity
ratio>1.0
Typeof
analysis

1/3rd
Allowable
Stress
Increase

28

Allowable
StressDesign
(ASD89)
StruCAD

Allowable
StressDesign
(ASD89)
SAP

Allowable
StressDesign
(ASD89)
SAP

Allowable
Strength
Design
(ASD05)
Amplified
FirstOrder
Method**

Allowable
StrengthDesign
(ASD05)

Loadand
Resistance
FactorDesign
(LRFD05)
(ASCE7)

13

14

17

14

19

26

FirstOrder

FirstOrder

FistOrder

FirstOrder

SecondOrder
(P andP)

SecondOrder
(P andP)

Yes

Yes

No

No

No

No

Note:**Theamplifiedfirstordermethodismodified(B1,B2=1)to
comparethedifferenceindesignresultsbetweenASD89andASD05
specifications

Rig1DesignStudyResults
UnityCheckStatistics
SAPModels ASD89andLRFD05

NoofmemberswithUC>1
MaximumUC
AverageUC

Beam
Brace
ASD89 LRFD05 %change ASD89 LRFD05 %change
1
2
1
7
1.16
1.05
9.14%
1.09
2.28 109.15%
0.49
0.54
9.16%
0.39
0.44
12.60%

Column
ASD89 LRFD05 %change
12
17
1.19
1.36
14.53%
0.72
0.75
3.69%

Notes
1.SAPASD89resultsarewith1/3rd increaseinAllowableStressforExpectedandUnexpected
Storm
2.LRFD05resultsarewithout1/3rd increase.LoadfactorforHookLoadis1.6
3.Evenwithoutthe1/3rd stressincreaseforLRFD05,thereisnosignificantincreaseinnumberof
membersexceedingtheunitycheckratio
4.ThesignificantchangeinUCforbeammemberfromASD89toLRFD05isduetothedifference
intheinteractionequationfordoublysymmetricmembersinLRFDspecification
5.DetailedresultsforthehighestUCmembersforbeam,braceandcolumnareprovidedin
detailedresultssection
29

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
ASD89StruCADandSAP

ASD89StruCADModel
13memberswithUR>1.
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

30

MemberNo LoadComb UnityRatio

96
18
0.980
122
20
0.935
123
20
1.058
128
20
0.961
130
20
0.975
152
20
1.118
153
22
1.066
162
23
0.993
240
18
1.049
241
24
0.913
242
18
1.018
270
18
1.024
272
18
1.016
274
18
1.016
276
18
1.027
278
18
1.086
279
24
0.969
284
24
1.001
285
18
0.873
337
24
1.109
339
18
1.005
340
22
0.851
341
20
0.941

With1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

ASD89SAPmodel
14memberswithUR>1.

StruCADmodelImport
intoSAP2000
Designwith
AISC89specification
with
1/3rd StressIncrease

MemberNo
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD18
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20

With1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

UnityRatio
0.983
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
1.093
0.969
1.164
0.961
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
ASD89SAPModel
14memberswithUR>1.
Brace
Brace
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

31

MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD18
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20

UnityRatio
0.788
0.794
0.983
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
1.093
0.969
1.164
0.961
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482

With1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

ASD89SAP

AISC89specification
Designresults
withoutthe
1/3rd StressIncrease

ASD89SAPmodel
17memberswithUR>1.
MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD18
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20

UnityRatio
1.234
1.253
0.983
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
1.093
0.969
1.231
1.306
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482

Without1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
ASD89andASD05FirstOrder

ASD89SAP
17memberswithUR>1.
Brace
Brace
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

32

MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD18
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20

UnityRatio
1.234
1.253
0.983
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
1.093
0.969
1.231
1.306
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482

Without1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

ASD05SAPAmplifiedFirstOrder
14memberswithUR>1.

Transitionfrom
AISC89specification
toAISC05specification

MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD22
SCAD21

Without1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

UnityRatio
0.905
0.927
1.003
0.882
0.999
0.968
0.972
1.046
0.981
0.948
1.032
0.916
1.053
1.003
1.024
1.031
1.000
1.133
1.007
0.939
0.908
1.294
1.173
1.976
2.216

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
ASD89andASD05FirstOrder
ASD89SAP
14memberswithUR>1.
Brace
Brace
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

33

MemberNo LoadComb UnityRatio

31
SCAD32
0.788
32
SCAD26
0.794
96
SCAD18
0.983
122
SCAD20
0.903
123
SCAD20
1.033
128
SCAD20
0.946
130
SCAD20
0.952
152
SCAD20
1.106
153
SCAD22
1.049
162
SCAD23
1.005
240
SCAD18
1.189
241
SCAD24
1.045
242
SCAD18
1.108
270
SCAD18
1.063
272
SCAD18
1.040
274
SCAD18
1.040
276
SCAD18
1.108
278
SCAD18
1.093
279
SCAD24
0.969
284
SCAD24
1.164
285
SCAD18
0.961
337
SCAD24
1.089
339
SCAD18
0.987
340
SCAD21
0.456
341
SCAD20
0.482

With1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

ASD05SAPAmplifiedFirstOrder
14memberswithUR>1.

Transitionfrom
AISC89specification
toAISC05specification

MemberNo LoadComb UnityRatio

31
SCAD32
0.905
32
SCAD26
0.927
96
SCAD19
1.003
122
SCAD20
0.882
123
SCAD20
0.999
128
SCAD20
0.968
130
SCAD20
0.972
152
SCAD20
1.046
153
SCAD22
0.981
162
SCAD23
0.948
240
SCAD18
1.032
241
SCAD24
0.916
242
SCAD18
1.053
270
SCAD18
1.003
272
SCAD18
1.024
274
SCAD18
1.031
276
SCAD18
1.000
278
SCAD19
1.133
279
SCAD24
1.007
284
SCAD24
0.939
285
SCAD42
0.908
337
SCAD24
1.294
339
SCAD18
1.173
340
SCAD22
1.976
341
SCAD21
2.216

Without1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
SAPModels:ASD89,ASD05FirstorderandASD05
ASD89
17memberswithUR>1.0
Brace
Brace
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

34

MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD18
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20

UnityRatio
1.234
1.253
0.983
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
1.093
0.969
1.231
1.306
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482

Without1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

ASD05AmplifiedFirstOrder
14memberswithUR>1.0
MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD22
SCAD21

UnityRatio
0.905
0.927
1.003
0.882
0.999
0.968
0.972
1.046
0.981
0.948
1.032
0.916
1.053
1.003
1.024
1.031
1.000
1.133
1.007
0.939
0.908
1.294
1.173
1.976
2.216

ASD05
19memberswithUR>1.0
MemberNo
31
32
96
122
123
128
130
152
153
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341

Without1/3rd StressIncreaseforExpectedand
UnexpectedStorm

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD22
SCAD21

UnityRatio
0.897
0.919
1.111
1.028
1.109
1.021
1.032
1.116
1.019
0.966
1.089
0.968
1.098
1.020
1.048
1.069
1.088
1.261
1.108
0.992
0.961
1.346
1.222
2.082
2.327

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
SAPModels:ASD89,ASD05andLRFD05
Brace
Brace
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

35

ASD89
17memberswithUR>1.0

ASD05
19memberswithUR>1.0

LRFD05
26memberswithUR>1.0

MemberNo
31
32
96
97
122
123
128
130
152
153
160
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
277
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341
342
343
344

MemberNo
31
32
96
97
122
123
128
130
152
153
160
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
277
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341
354
355
363

MemberNo
31
32
96
97
122
123
128
130
152
153
160
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
277
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341
354
355
363

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD18
SCAD23
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD18

UnityRatio
1.234
1.253
0.983
0.911
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
0.972
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
0.994
1.093
0.969
1.231
1.306
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482
0.378
0.399
0.196

Without1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD23
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD22
SCAD21
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18

UnityRatio
0.897
0.919
1.111
1.000
1.028
1.109
1.021
1.032
1.116
1.019
0.997
0.966
1.089
0.968
1.098
1.020
1.048
1.069
1.088
0.966
1.261
1.108
0.992
0.961
1.346
1.222
2.082
2.327
0.967
0.965
0.989

Without1/3rd StressIncreaseforExpectedand
UnexpectedStorm

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD22
SCAD21
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18

UnityRatio
0.911
0.939
1.192
1.027
1.043
1.135
1.045
1.040
1.157
0.999
1.030
0.980
1.119
0.987
1.117
1.047
1.109
1.146
1.166
1.009
1.361
1.150
1.017
1.058
1.288
1.190
1.990
2.278
1.021
1.020
1.053

Rig1 DesignStudyResults
SAPModels:ASD89,ASD05andLRFD05
ASD89
14memberswithUR>1.0
Brace
Brace
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Column
Brace
Brace
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam
Beam

36

MemberNo
31
32
96
97
122
123
128
130
152
153
160
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
277
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341
354
355
363

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD18
SCAD23
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD21
SCAD20
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18

UnityRatio
0.788
0.794
0.983
0.911
0.903
1.033
0.946
0.952
1.106
1.049
0.972
1.005
1.189
1.045
1.108
1.063
1.040
1.040
1.108
0.994
1.093
0.969
1.164
0.961
1.089
0.987
0.456
0.482
0.993
0.986
0.989

With1/3rd StressIncreasefor
ExpectedandUnexpectedStorm

ASD05
19memberswithUR>1.0

LRFD05
26memberswithUR>1.0

MemberNo
31
32
96
97
122
123
128
130
152
153
160
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
277
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341
354
355
363

MemberNo
31
32
96
97
122
123
128
130
152
153
160
162
240
241
242
270
272
274
276
277
278
279
284
285
337
339
340
341
354
355
363

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD23
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD22
SCAD21
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18

UnityRatio
0.897
0.919
1.111
1.000
1.028
1.109
1.021
1.032
1.116
1.019
0.997
0.966
1.089
0.968
1.098
1.020
1.048
1.069
1.088
0.966
1.261
1.108
0.992
0.961
1.346
1.222
2.082
2.327
0.967
0.965
0.989

Without1/3rd StressIncreaseforExpectedand
UnexpectedStorm

LoadComb
SCAD32
SCAD26
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD20
SCAD22
SCAD23
SCAD23
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD18
SCAD24
SCAD19
SCAD24
SCAD48
SCAD42
SCAD24
SCAD42
SCAD22
SCAD21
SCAD24
SCAD24
SCAD18

UnityRatio
0.911
0.939
1.192
1.027
1.043
1.135
1.045
1.040
1.157
0.999
1.030
0.980
1.119
0.987
1.117
1.047
1.109
1.146
1.166
1.009
1.361
1.150
1.017
1.058
1.288
1.190
1.990
2.278
1.021
1.020
1.053

Rig1
DetailedDesignResultsforSelected
Members

37

Rig1
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

38

Rig1
DetailedDesignResultsMembers

Rig1
Column
Member#274

Rig1
Brace
Member#285
39

Rig1
Beams
Member#313

Rig1
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

40

Rig1
BeamMember313LoadsandDesignCalculations
Design
Option

Combo
Text

ASD89*
27
ASD89 SCAD27
ASD05** SCAD27
ASD05 SCAD27
LRFD05 SCAD27

Location
in

Pr
Kip

0
0
0
0
0

1.844
1.882
1.882
1.944
3.290

MrMajor MrMinor VrMajor

Kipin
Kipin
Kip

95.618
96.597
96.597
98.586
160.765

4.244
4.116
4.116
4.134
6.732

1.792
1.812
1.812
1.851
2.991

VrMinor
Kip

Tr
Kipin

0.03
0.027
0.027
0.033
0.086

1.7
13.301
13.301
13.927
22.41

Equation TotalRatio
Text
Unitless

PRatio MMajRatio
Unitless
Unitless

(H13)
(H13)
(H11b)
(H11b)
(H11b)

0.0170
0.0169
0.0116
0.0120
0.0135

0.3300
0.3338
0.3525
0.3595
0.3905

0.2940
0.2982
0.3188
0.3254
0.3530

MMinRatio
Unitless

0.0190
0.0187
0.0221
0.0222
0.0187

*StruCADresults
**FirstOrderResults(noP)
ASD05andLRFD05resultsarewithoutthe1/3rd increaseinallowablestress
Member313
JointA:172
JointB:173
Section:T8D

41

Rig1ASD89StruCAD
BeamMember313,U.CRatio=0.33
MemberNo.313172 173
GRUP
T8D
Section TS8X4X3/16
TotalLength
7.5
LoadCase
Distance
Segment
DesignCode
Amod
Cmy
Cmz
Cb
YieldStrength
SkipLocalBucklingChecks
BasicProperties
SectionType
AxialArea
Tors.Constant
Max.UnbracedLength
Max.UnbracedLength
Sect.ModulusTop
Sect.ModulusBot
Sect.ModulusLft
Sect.ModulusRht
Slendernessratio
Slendernessratio
Col.SlendernessRatio
InteractionCoefficient
InteractionCoefficient
BendingCoefficient

42

27
0
1

0
0.9
0.9
7.5
11
7.5
7.5

SA9
1.333
C
C
B
46

J
Lc
Lu
Syt
Syb
Szl
Szr
Kl/ry
Kl/rz
Cc
Cmy
Cmz
Cb

JointThickness
Slendernesscoeff.Ky
Slendernesscoeff.Kz
EffectiveLengthLy
EffectiveLengthLz
BraceSpacing
Tub.Mod./Stiff.Spacing

BOX
4.27
29.1
7.473
0
8.825
8.825
6
6
28.125
70.714
111.554
0.325
0.236
2.3

Forces&Moments
AxialForce
ShearForce
ShearForce
TorsionalMoment
BendingMoment
BendingMoment

Fx
Fy
Fz
Mx
My
Mz

GoverningEquations
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable
CombinedUnityRatio

Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz
Uc

1.844
0.03
1.792
13.587
95.618
4.244

(SECD1)
(E21)
(F33)
(F33)
(F33)
(F33)
(F41)
(F41)
(H13)

ActualStresses
AxialStress
BendingStressTop
BendingStressBot
BendingStressLft
BendingStressRht
ShearStress
ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
CombinedShearStress
WarpingNormalStress
CombinedStress

fa
fbyt
fbyb
fbzl
fbzr
fvy
fvz
fvyt
fvzt
fv
Fbztr
fcomb

0.432
10.835
10.835
0.707
0.707
0.02
0.597
1.216
1.216
1.814
0
11.974
0

AllowableStresses
EulerStress
EulerStress
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompres.Allow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable

F'ey
F'ez
Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz

251.65
39.808
0
36.791
26.167
36.791
36.791
36.791
36.791
24.527
24.527

UnityRatios

AxialComponent
BendingComponent
BendingComponent
ShearComponent
ShearComponent
CombinedUnityRatio
CriticalUnityRatio

Ua
Uby
Ubz
Usy
Usz
Uc
Uc

0.017
0.294
0.019
0.05
0.074
0.33
0.33

Rig1ASD89SAP
BeamMember313,U.CRatio=0.334

43

Rig1LRFD05SAP
BeamMember313,U.CRatio=0.391

44

Rig1
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

45

Rig1
BraceMember285LoadsandDesignCalculations
Design
Option

Combo
Text

Location
in

Pr
Kip

ASD89*
42
ASD89 SCAD42
ASD05** SCAD42
ASD05 SCAD42
LRFD05 SCAD42

189.268
189.268
189.268
189.268
189.268

118.991
114.886
114.886
116.006
175.461

MrMajor MrMinor VrMajor

Kipin
Kipin
Kip

27.187
27.223
27.223
42.24
122.862

51.65
51.711
51.711
80.279
194.322

0.003
0.002
0.002
0.087
0.212

VrMinor
Kip

Tr
Kipin

0.003
0.002
0.002
0.157
0.39

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

Equation TotalRatio
Text
Unitless

PRatio MMajRatio
Unitless
Unitless

(H11)
(H11)
(H11a)
(H11a)
(H11a)

0.6000
0.6131
0.8270
0.8351
0.8404

0.7190
0.7905
0.9084
0.9614
1.0580

0.0410
0.0612
0.0281
0.0436
0.0843

MMinRatio
Unitless

0.0780
0.1162
0.0533
0.0828
0.1162

*StruCADresults
**FirstOrderResults(noP)
ASD05andLRFD05resultsarewithoutthe1/3rd increaseinallowablestress

Member285
JointA:3
JointB:246
Section:T8A

46

Rig1ASD89StruCAD
BraceMember285,U.CRatio=0.719
MemberNo.2853 246
GRUP
T8A
Section TS8X8X3/8
TotalLength
31.545
LoadCase
Distance
Segment
DesignCode
Amod
Cmy
Cmz
Cb
YieldStrength
SkipLocalBuckling
Checks
BasicProperties
SectionType
AxialArea
Tors.Constant
Max.UnbracedLength
Max.UnbracedLength
Sect.ModulusTop
Sect.ModulusBot
Sect.ModulusLft
Sect.ModulusRht
Slendernessratio
Slendernessratio
Col.SlendernessRatio
InteractionCoefficient
InteractionCoefficient
BendingCoefficient

47

42
15.7723
1
SA9
1.333
C
C
B
46

J
Lc
Lu
Syt
Syb
Szl
Szr
Kl/ry
Kl/rz
Cc
Cmy
Cmz
Cb

BOX
11.1
170
14.946
0
26.5
26.5
26.5
26.5
104.854
104.854
111.554
0.6
0.6
1.75

JointThickness
Slendernesscoeff.Ky
Slendernesscoeff.Kz
EffectiveLengthLy
EffectiveLengthLz
BraceSpacing
Tub.Mod./Stiff.Spacing

1
1
1
27
27
31.545
31.545

Forces&Moments
AxialForce
ShearForce
ShearForce
TorsionalMoment
BendingMoment

Fx
Fy
Fz
Mx
My

118.991
0.003
0.003
0
27.187

BendingMoment

Mz

51.65

GoverningEquations
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable
CombinedUnityRatio

Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz
Uc

(SECD1)
(E21)
(F33)
(F33)
(F33)
(F33)
(F41)
(F41)
(H11)

ActualStresses
AxialStress
BendingStressTop
BendingStressBot
BendingStressLft
BendingStressRht
ShearStress
ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
CombinedShearStress
WarpingNormalStress
CombinedStress

fa
fbyt
fbyb
fbzl
fbzr
fvy
fvz
fvyt
fvzt
fv
Fbztr
fcomb

AllowableStresses
EulerStress
EulerStress
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompres.Allow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable

F'ey
F'ez
Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz

10.72
1.026
1.026
1.949
1.949
0.001
0
0
0
0.001
0
13.695
0

UnityRatios
18.105
18.105
0
36.791
17.872
36.791
36.791
36.791
36.791
24.527
24.527

AxialComponent
BendingComponent
BendingComponent
ShearComponent
ShearComponent
CombinedUnityRatio
CriticalUnityRatio

Ua
Uby
Ubz
Usy
Usz
Uc
Uc

0.6
0.041
0.078
0
0
0.719
0.719

Rig1ASD89SAP
BraceMember285,U.CRatio=0.719

48

Rig1LRFD05SAP
BraceMember285,U.CRatio=1.058

49

Rig1
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

50

Rig1
ColumnMember274LoadsandDesignCalculations
Design
Option

Combo
Text

ASD89*
18
ASD89 SCAD18
ASD05** SCAD18
ASD05 SCAD18
LRFD05 SCAD18

Location
in

Pr
Kip

0
0
0
0
0

189.804
189.107
189.107
193.827
308.857

MrMajor MrMinor VrMajor

Kipin
Kipin
Kip

19.262
18.501
18.501
28.402
53.951

41.109
41.128
41.128
39.381
64.647

0.268
0.26
0.26
0.703
2.381

VrMinor
Kip

Tr
Kipin

0.945
0.95
0.95
0.953
1.484

13.102
11.482
11.482
26.752
53.211

Equation TotalRatio
Text
Unitless

PRatio MMajRatio
Unitless
Unitless

(H11)
(H11)
(H11a)
(H11a)
(H11a)

0.9530
0.9500
0.9261
0.9492
1.0063

1.0160
1.0399
1.0315
1.0690
1.1458

0.0360
0.0635
0.0327
0.0502
0.0634

MMinRatio
Unitless

0.020
0.0264
0.0727
0.0696
0.0011

*StruCADresults
**FirstOrderResults(noP)
ASD05andLRFD05resultsarewithoutthe1/3rd increaseinallowablestress

Member274
JointA:124
JointB:128
Section:T6U
51

Rig1ASD89StruCAD
ColumnMember274,U.CRatio=1.016
MemberNo.274124 128

JointThickness

GRUP

Slendernesscoeff.Ky

AxialStress

fa

Slendernesscoeff.Kz

0.9

BendingStressTop

fbyt

EffectiveLengthLy

9.1

BendingStressBot

fbyb

1.389

EffectiveLengthLz

BendingStressLft

fbzl

2.958
2.958

T6U

Section TS6X6X3/8
TotalLength

7.443

ActualStresses
23.491
1.389

LoadCase

18

Distance

BraceSpacing

7.443

BendingStressRht

fbzr

Segment

Tub.Mod./Stiff.Spacing

7.443

ShearStress

fvy

0.21

ShearStress

fvz

0.059

DesignCode

SA9
Forces&Moments

Amod

AxialForce

Fx

189.804

Tors.ShearStress

fvyt

0.552

Tors.ShearStress

fvzt

0.552
0.762

Cmy

ShearForce

Fy

0.945

CombinedShearStress

fv

Cmz

ShearForce

Fz

0.268

WarpingNormalStress

Fbztr

Cb

TorsionalMoment

Mx

13.102

CombinedStress

fcomb

50

BendingMoment

My

19.262

BendingMoment

Mz

41.019

YieldStrength
SkipLocalBucklingChecks

0
27.838
0

BasicProperties
SectionType

BOX

AxialArea

GoverningEquations

8.08

CriticalBuckling(API)

AllowableStresses
Fxcr

UnityRatios

EulerStress

F'ey

64.529
134.635

Tors.Constant

68.5

TensionAllowable

Fat

(SECD1)

EulerStress

F'ez

Max.UnbracedLength

Lc

9.75

CompressionAllowable

Fac

(E21)

CriticalBuckling(API)

Fxcr

Max.UnbracedLength

Lu

BendingTensionAllow.

Fbyt

(F31)

TensionAllowable

Fat

30

Sect.ModulusTop

Syt

13.867

BendingCompressionAllow

Fbyc

(F31)

CompressionAllowable

Fac

24.643

Sect.ModulusBot

Syb

13.867

BendingTensionAllow.

Fbzt

(F31)

BendingTensionAllow.

Fbyt

33

AxialComponent

Ua

BendingComponent Uby

0.953
0.036

Sect.ModulusLft

Szl

13.867

BendingCompressionAllow

Fbzc

(F31)

BendingCompressionAllow Fbyc

33

BendingComponent Ubz

0.026

Sect.ModulusRht

Szr

13.867

ShearAllowable

Fvay

(F41)

BendingTensionAllow.

33

ShearComponent

Usy

0.038

Slendernessratio

Kl/ry

48.106

ShearAllowable

Fvaz

(F41)

BendingCompres.Allow

Fbzc

33

ShearComponent

Usz

0.031

Slendernessratio

Kl/rz

33.304

CombinedUnityRatio

Uc

(H11)

ShearAllowable

Fvay

20

CombinedUnityRatio Uc

1.016

Col.SlendernessRatio

Cc

106.999

ShearAllowable

Fvaz

20

CriticalUnityRatio

1.016

InteractionCoefficient

Cmy

InteractionCoefficient

Cmz

0.24

Cb

1.892

BendingCoefficient

52

0.548

Fbzt

Uc

Rig1ASD89SAP
ColumnMember274,U.CRatio=0.182

53

Rig1LRFD05SAP
ColumnMember274,U.CRatio=1.146

54

Rig3DesignStudyResults
(Derrick)
TotalnumberofMembers
1420(excluding125dummymembers)

SAPclassifiesthemembers
Beams(allelementsparalleltotheXYplane)
949

Brace(allelementsnotclassifiedasbeamsorcolumns)
231

Column(allelementsparalleltotheZaxis)
246

55

Rig3
1500kipHookLoadSingleDerrick

Rig3

56

Rig3
Beams
949

Rig3
Braces
231

Rig3
Columns
246

Rig3DesignStudyResults
UnityCheckStatistics
SAPModels ASD89andLRFD05

NoofmemberswithUC>1
MaximumUC
AverageUC

Beam
Brace
ASD89 LRFD05 %change ASD89 LRFD05 %change
2
0
4
1
1.18
1.00
15.05%
1.34
1.06 21.18%
0.53
0.48
8.97%
0.28
0.26
8.02%

Column
ASD89 LRFD05 %change
8
34
1.26
1.37
8.59%
0.41
0.47
15.67%

Notes
1. ASD89resultsarewith1/3rd increaseinAllowablestressforExpectedandUnexpectedStorm
2. LRFD05resultsarewithout1/3rd increase.LoadfactorforHookLoadis1.6
3. ForLRFD05,withoutthe1/3rd stressincreaseforLRFD05,thereisanincreaseinnumberof
columnmembersexceedingtheunitycheckratio
4. DetaileddesigncalculationsforthehighestUCmembersforbeam,braceandcolumnare
providedindetailedresultssection

57

Rig3 DesignStudyResults
SAPModels:ASD89andLRFD05
ASD89
14members
withUR>1.0

With1/3rd Stress
Increasefor
ExpectedandUnexpected
Storm

58

MemberNo
3
4
5
6
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
17
18
21
22
23
24
68
463
948
962
963
964
965
975
990
994
1009
1010
1011
1012
1013
1015
1021
1022
1023
1080
1468
1484
1485
1486

LoadComb
SCAD93A
SCAD95
SCAD93A
SCAD95
SCAD93
SCAD95
SCAD95A
SCAD53
SCAD93A
SCAD55
SCAD53
SCAD55
SCAD55
SCAD65
SCAD55
SCAD55
SCAD55
SCAD95
SCAD93
SCAD55
SCAD53
SCAD53
SCAD64
SCAD64
SCAD53
SCAD62
SCAD62
SCAD53
SCAD53
SCAD55
SCAD55
SCAD53
SCAD65
SCAD65
SCAD63
SCAD55
SCAD64
SCAD64
SCAD51
SCAD57
SCAD51

UnityRatio
1.063
1.056
1.015
0.974
0.976
0.829
0.917
1.016
0.859
0.877
0.983
0.907
0.905
0.729
0.858
0.856
1.002
1.177
1.146
1.001
0.849
0.904
0.833
0.939
0.718
0.767
0.711
0.899
0.796
0.921
0.803
1.032
0.982
0.806
0.899
0.953
1.074
1.264
1.214
1.005
1.340

MemberNo
3
4
5
6
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
17
18
21
22
23
24
68
463
948
962
963
964
965
975
990
994
1009
1010
1011
1012
1013
1015
1021
1022
1023
1024
1025
1026
1027
1028

LoadComb
SCAD83A
SCAD85
SCAD83A
SCAD85
SCAD83
SCAD85
SCAD85A
SCAD53
SCAD83A
SCAD85A
SCAD53
SCAD55
SCAD55
SCAD65
SCAD55
SCAD85A
SCAD55
SCAD75
SCAD83
SCAD55
SCAD53
SCAD52
SCAD54
SCAD54
SCAD53
SCAD57
SCAD57
SCAD53
SCAD53
SCAD65
SCAD55
SCAD53
SCAD65
SCAD65
SCAD63
SCAD55
SCAD94
SCAD74
SCAD77A
SCAD70
SCAD70

UnityRatio
0.969
1.250
1.043
1.171
1.206
1.101
1.229
1.059
1.188
1.175
1.034
1.262
1.118
1.017
1.103
1.178
1.230
0.919
1.056
1.322
1.121
1.001
1.087
1.022
1.018
1.039
1.128
1.021
1.004
1.240
1.223
1.363
1.373
1.199
1.014
1.239
0.013
0.403
0.333
0.522
0.617

LRFD05
35members
withUR>1.0

Without1/3rd StressIncrease
forExpectedand
UnexpectedStorm

Rig3
DetailedDesignResultsforSelected
Members

59

Rig3
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

60

Rig3
DetailedDesignResultsMembers

Rig3
Beams
Member#796

Rig3
Brace
Member#87

61

Rig3
Column
Member#15

Rig3
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

62

Rig3
BeamMember796LoadsandDesignCalculations
Design
Option

Combo
Text

ASD89*
64
ASD89 SCAD64
LRFD05 SCAD64

Location
in

Pr
Kip

MrMajor MrMinor VrMajor

Kipin
Kipin
Kip

168.936 66.906 128.458 14.609

168.936 67.097 125.073 14.867
168.936 100.348 141.183 21.329

0.938
0.907
0.958

VrMinor
Kip

Tr
Kipin

Equation TotalRatio
Text
Unitless

0.023
0.021
0.173

0.002
0.002
0.001

(H11)
(H11)
(H11a)

0.777
0.957
0.752

PRatio MMajRatio
Unitless
Unitless

0.651
0.654
0.646

0.070
0.136
0.059

MMinRatio
Unitless

0.056
0.167
0.047

*StruCADresults
**FirstOrderResults(noP)
LRFD05resultsarewithoutthe1/3rd increaseinallowablestress

Member796
JointA:135
JointB:92
Section:GS2

63

Rig3ASD89StruCAD
BeamMember796,U.CRatio=0.777
MemberNo.796135 92
GRUP
GS2
Section W14X30
TotalLength
14.08
LoadCase
Distance
Segment
DesignCode
Amod
Cmy
Cmz
Cb
YieldStrength
SkipLocalBucklingChecks
BasicProperties
SectionType
AxialArea
Tors.Constant
Max.UnbracedLength
Max.UnbracedLength
Sect.ModulusTop
Sect.ModulusBot
Sect.ModulusLft
Sect.ModulusRht
Slendernessratio
Slendernessratio
Col.SlendernessRatio
InteractionCoefficient
InteractionCoefficient
BendingCoefficient

64

64
14.078
1
SA9
1
C
C
B
50

J
Lc
Lu
Syt
Syb
Szl
Szr
Kl/ry
Kl/rz
Cc
Cmy
Cmz
Cb

WF
8.85
0.38
6.028
9.29
42.052
42.052
5.825
5.825
58.965
113.38
106.999
0.506
0.294
2.012

JointThickness
Slendernesscoeff.Ky
Slendernesscoeff.Kz
EffectiveLengthLy
EffectiveLengthLz
BraceSpacing
Tub.Mod./Stiff.Spacing

0
1
1
28.156
14.078
14.078
14.078

Forces&Moments
AxialForce
ShearForce
ShearForce
TorsionalMoment
BendingMoment
BendingMoment

Fx
Fy
Fz
Mx
My
Mz

GoverningEquations
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable
CombinedUnityRatio

Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz
Uc

66.906
0.023
0.938
0.002
128.458
14.609

(SECD1)
(E22)
(F15)
(F16)
(F21)
(F21)
(F41)
(F41)
(H11)

ActualStresses
AxialStress
BendingStressTop
BendingStressBot
BendingStressLft
BendingStressRht
ShearStress
ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
CombinedShearStress
WarpingNormalStress
CombinedStress

fa
fbyt
fbyb
fbzl
fbzr
fvy
fvz
fvyt
fvzt
fv
Fbztr
fcomb

7.56
3.055
3.055
2.508
2.508
0.007
0.251
0
0
0.251
0.003
13.126
0

AllowableStresses
EulerStress
EulerStress
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompres.Allow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable

F'ey
F'ez
Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz

42.949
11.617
0
30
11.617
30
26.756
37.5
37.5
20
20

UnityRatios

AxialComponent
BendingComponent
BendingComponent
ShearComponent
ShearComponent
CombinedUnityRatio
CriticalUnityRatio

Ua
Uby
Ubz
Usy
Usz
Uc
Uc

0.651
0.07
0.056
0
0.013
0.777
0.777

Rig3ASD89SAP
BeamMember796,U.CRatio=0.957

65

Rig1LRFD05SAP
BeamMember796,U.CRatio=0.752

66

Rig3
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

67

Rig3
BraceMember87LoadsandDesignCalculations
Design
Option

Combo
Text

ASD89*
90
ASD89 SCAD90
LRFD05 SCAD90

Location
in

Pr
Kip

MrMajor MrMinor VrMajor

Kipin
Kipin
Kip

184.391 174.145 168.961 15.378

138.293 174.681 126.475 18.318
138.293 176.267 145.398 19.563

0.967
1.004
1.203

VrMinor
Kip

Tr
Kipin

Equation TotalRatio
Text
Unitless

0.093
0.069
0.238

0.046
0.034
0.043

(H11)
(H11)
(H11a)

0.680
0.690
0.598

PRatio MMajRatio
Unitless
Unitless

0.624
0.629
0.558

0.030
0.022
0.028

MMinRatio
Unitless

0.026
0.039
0.012

*StruCADresults
**FirstOrderResults(noP)
LRFD05resultsarewithoutthe1/3rd increaseinallowablestress

Member87
JointA:140
JointB:68
Section:B4S

68

Rig3ASD89StruCAD
BraceMember87,U.CRatio=0.680
MemberNo.87140 68
GRUP
B4S
Section W14X61
TotalLength
23.05
LoadCase
Distance
Segment
DesignCode
Amod
Cmy
Cmz
Cb
YieldStrength
SkipLocalBucklingChecks
BasicProperties
SectionType
AxialArea
Tors.Constant
Max.UnbracedLength
Max.UnbracedLength
Sect.ModulusTop
Sect.ModulusBot
Sect.ModulusLft
Sect.ModulusRht
Slendernessratio
Slendernessratio
Col.SlendernessRatio
InteractionCoefficient
InteractionCoefficient
BendingCoefficient

69

90
15.3659
1
SA9
1.33
C
C
B
50

J
Lc
Lu
Syt
Syb
Szl
Szr
Kl/ry
Kl/rz
Cc
Cmy
Cmz
Cb

WF
17.9
2.2
8.952
15.471
92.153
92.153
21.411
21.411
46.252
112.892
106.999
0.585
0.671
1.789

JointThickness
Slendernesscoeff.Ky
Slendernesscoeff.Kz
EffectiveLengthLy
EffectiveLengthLz
BraceSpacing
Tub.Mod./Stiff.Spacing

0
1
1
23.049
23.049
23.049
23.049

Forces&Moments
AxialForce
ShearForce
ShearForce
TorsionalMoment
BendingMoment
BendingMoment

Fx
Fy
Fz
Mx
My
Mz

GoverningEquations
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable
CombinedUnityRatio

Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz
Uc

174.145
0.093
0.967
0.046
168.961
15.378

(SECD1)
(E22)
(F15)
(F16)
(F21)
(F21)
(F41)
(F41)
(H11)

ActualStresses
AxialStress
BendingStressTop
BendingStressBot
BendingStressLft
BendingStressRht
ShearStress
ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
CombinedShearStress
WarpingNormalStress
CombinedStress

fa
fbyt
fbyb
fbzl
fbzr
fvy
fvz
fvyt
fvzt
fv
Fbztr
fcomb

9.729
1.833
1.833
0.718
0.718
0.011
0.186
0.009
0.005
0.191
0.005
12.276
0

AllowableStresses
EulerStress
EulerStress
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompres.Allow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable

F'ey
F'ez
Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz

92.842
15.584
0
39.9
15.584
39.9
39.9
49.875
49.875
26.6
26.6

UnityRatios

AxialComponent
BendingComponent
BendingComponent
ShearComponent
ShearComponent
CombinedUnityRatio
CriticalUnityRatio

Ua
Uby
Ubz
Usy
Usz
Uc
Uc

0.624
0.03
0.026
0.001
0.007
0.68
0.68

Rig3ASD89SAP
BraceMember87,U.CRatio=0.690

70

Rig3LRFD05SAP
BraceMember87,U.CRatio=0.598

71

Rig3
DetailedDesignResultsforSelectedMembers

Beam
Brace
Column

72

Rig3
ColumnMember15LoadsandDesignCalculations
Design
Option

Combo
Text

ASD89*
53
ASD89 SCAD53
LRFD05 SCAD53

Location
in

0
0
0

Pr
Kip

MrMajor MrMinor
Kipin
Kipin

841.632 273.164 72.421

841.630 155.783 136.703
1217.513 229.648 193.919

VrMajor
Kip

VrMinor
Kip

Tr
Kipin

Equation TotalRatio
Text
Unitless

3.027
0.660
0.161

0.34
1.745
1.446

0.247
0.252
0.363

(H11)
(H11)
(H11a)

0.942
0.983
1.034

PRatio
Unitless

MMajRatio
Unitless

MMinRatio
Unitless

0.893
0.892
0.978

0.013
0.024
0.023

0.036
0.066
0.034

*StruCADresults
**FirstOrderResults(noP)
LRFD05resultsarewithoutthe1/3rd increaseinallowablestress

Member15
JointA:66
JointB:70
Section:1LG

73

Rig3ASD89StruCAD
ColumnMember15,U.CRatio=0.942
MemberNo.1566 70
GRUP
1LG
Section W14X120
TotalLength
15
LoadCase
Distance
Segment
DesignCode
Amod
Cmy
Cmz
Cb
YieldStrength
SkipLocalBucklingChecks
BasicProperties
SectionType
AxialArea
Tors.Constant
Max.Unbraced Length
Max.Unbraced Length
Sect.ModulusTop
Sect.ModulusBot
Sect.ModulusLft
Sect.ModulusRht
Slendernessratio
Slendernessratio
Col.SlendernessRatio
InteractionCoefficient
InteractionCoefficient
BendingCoefficient

74

53
0
1

0
1
1
15
15
15
15

SA9
1
C
C
B
55

J
Lc
Lu
Syt
Syb
Szl
Szr
Kl/ry
Kl/rz
Cc
Cmy
Cmz
Cb

JointThickness
Slendernesscoeff.Ky
Slendernesscoeff.Kz
EffectiveLengthLy
EffectiveLengthLz
BraceSpacing
Tub.Mod./Stiff.Spacing

WF
35.3
9.37
12.528
28.859
190.608
190.608
67.485
67.485
28.846
48.128
102.019
0.251
0.848
2.3

Forces&Moments
AxialForce
ShearForce
ShearForce
TorsionalMoment
BendingMoment
BendingMoment

Fx
Fy
Fz
Mx
My
Mz

GoverningEquations
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable
CombinedUnityRatio

Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz
Uc

841.632
0.34
3.027
0.247
273.164
72.421

(SECD1)
(E21)
(F15)
(F18)
(F21)
(F21)
(F41)
(F41)
(H11)

ActualStresses
AxialStress
BendingStressTop
BendingStressBot
BendingStressLft
BendingStressRht
ShearStress
ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
Tors.ShearStress
CombinedShearStress
WarpingNormalStress
CombinedStress

fa
fbyt
fbyb
fbzl
fbzr
fvy
fvz
fvyt
fvzt
fv
Fbztr
fcomb

23.842
1.433
1.433
1.073
1.073
0.018
0.354
0.002
0
0.354
0.034
26.314
0

AllowableStresses
EulerStress
EulerStress
CriticalBuckling(API)
TensionAllowable
CompressionAllowable
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompressionAllow
BendingTensionAllow.
BendingCompres.Allow
ShearAllowable
ShearAllowable

F'ey
F'ez
Fxcr
Fat
Fac
Fbyt
Fbyc
Fbzt
Fbzc
Fvay
Fvaz

179.463
64.469
0
33
26.704
33
33
41.25
41.25
22
22

UnityRatios

AxialComponent
BendingComponent
BendingComponent
ShearComponent
ShearComponent
CombinedUnityRatio
CriticalUnityRatio

Ua
Uby
Ubz
Usy
Usz
Uc
Uc

0.893
0.013
0.036
0.001
0.016
0.942
0.942

Rig3ASD89SAP
ColumnMember15,U.CRatio=0.983

75

Rig3LRFD05SAP
ColumnMember15,U.CRatio=1.034

76

ContactInformation
MikeEffenberger,mike.effenberger@stress.com

SathishRamamoorthy,sathish.ramamoorthy@stress.com

StressEngineeringServices
13800WestfairEastDrive
Houston,Texas77041
Phone:(281)9552900
Fax:(281)9552638
www.stress.com

77