P. 1
In re Orly Taitz - 2013-01-13 - #933 - PETITION for Writ of Mandamus, filed in 5th Circuit (No. 13-60024)

In re Orly Taitz - 2013-01-13 - #933 - PETITION for Writ of Mandamus, filed in 5th Circuit (No. 13-60024)

|Views: 41|Likes:
Published by Jack Ryan
In re Orly Taitz - 2013-01-13 - #933 - PETITION for Writ of Mandamus, filed in 5th Circuit (No. 13-60024)
--------
Emergency Petition Seeking to Expedite a Ruling on Motion for Default Judgment Against Commissioner of Social Security Michal Astrue.
In re Orly Taitz - 2013-01-13 - #933 - PETITION for Writ of Mandamus, filed in 5th Circuit (No. 13-60024)
--------
Emergency Petition Seeking to Expedite a Ruling on Motion for Default Judgment Against Commissioner of Social Security Michal Astrue.

More info:

Categories:Types, Research
Published by: Jack Ryan on Jan 11, 2013
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/15/2013

pdf

text

original

IN THE FIFTH CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS U.S.

COURT OF APPEA
RECEIVED lS
2013 JAN I 0 AH g:
IN RE PETITIONER ORLY TAITZ
37
FIFTH CIRCUIT
EMERGENCY PETITION FOR A WRIT OF MANDAMUS TO EXPEDITE A RULING ON A M O T I O ~ FOR
DEFAULT JUDGMENT AGAINST COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL SECURITY MICHAEL ASTRUE
UNDER FRAP RULE 21
TAITZ ET AL V DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF MISSISSIPPI ET AL
US DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI 3:12-CV-0280
PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF
DR. ORLYTAITZ, ESQ
13-60024
29839 SANTA MARGARITA, STE 100
RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA, CA 92688
PH. 949-683-5411
FAX 949-766-7603
ORLY. TAITZ@GMAJL.COM
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 1
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 1 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
EMERGENCY PETITION FOR A WRIT OF MANDAMUS
FRAP 21. Writs of Mandamus and Prohibition, and Other
Extraordinary Writs
(a) Mandamus or Prohibition to a Court: Petition, Filing, Service, and
Docketing.
(1) A party petitioning for a writ of mandamus or prohibition directed to a
court must file a petition with the circuit clerk with proof of service on all
parties to the proceeding in the trial court. The party must also provide a
copy to the trial-court judge. All parties to the proceeding in the trial court
other than the petitioner are respondents for all purposes.
(2)
(A) The petition must be titled "In re [name of petitioner]."
(B) The petition must state:
(i) the relief sought;
(ii) the issues presented;
(iii) the facts necessary to understand the issue presented by the petition;
and
(iv) the reasons why the writ should issue.
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 2
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 2 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
(C) The petition must include a copy of any order or opinion or parts of
the record that may be essential to understand the matters set forth in the
petition.
(3) Upon receiving the prescribed docket fee, the clerk must docket the
petition and submit it to the court.
(c) Other Extraordinary Writs.
An application for an extraordinary writ other than one provided for in
Rule 21 (a) must be made by filing a petition with the circuit clerk with
proof of service on the respondents. Proceedings on the application must
confonn, so far as is practicable, to the procedures prescribed in Rule
2l(a) and (b).
(d) Form of Papers; Number of Copies.
All papers must conform to Rule 32(c)(2). Except by the court's
permission, a paper must not exceed 30 pages, exclusive of the disclosure
statement, the proof of service, and the accompanying documents required
by Rule 2l(a)(2)(C). An original and 3 copies must be filed unless the
court requires the filing of a different number by local rule or by order in a
particular case.
RELIEF SOUGHT
PETITIOM:R IS SEEKING A WRIT OF MANDAMUS FOR THE LOWER
COURT TO EXPEDITE THE DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND
POST JUDGMENT DISCOVERY AGAINST DEFENDANT
COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL SECURITY MICHAEL ASTRUE
THE ISSUES PRESENTED AND THE FACTS NECESSARY TO
UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE PRESENTED BY THE PETITION
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 3
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 3 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case at hand relates to the most important breach of the U.S. National security in
the history of this nation. Complaint, 90 pages of exhibits and additional
information provided in the case entail sworn affidavits from Sheriff Joseph Arpaio
of Maricopa County Arizona, Senior Deportation officer with 30 years of
experience John Sampson, Licensed investigator Susan Daniels, Investigator Mike
Zullo, Typewriting and typesetting expert with 57 years of experience, former
NSA employee Paul Irey and many others. All of the evidence submitted to the
court shows that Barack Hussein Obama, who is about to be inaugurated as the
U.S. President in a few days is a citizen of Indonesia, who is using a last name not
legally his, he is using a Connecticut Social Security number xxx-xx-4425 which
was issued in 1977 to an elderly resident of Connecticut born in 1890 and which
was never assigned to Barack Obama according to E-Verify and SSNVS, Selective
service application allegedly submitted by Obama represents a forgery, a postal
stamp on the alleged Selective service Application of Barack Obama is a two digit
year stamp instead of a four digit year stamp, which is a forgery. All of the
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 4
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 4 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
evidence in the case points to the fact that Barack Obama is committing a massive
elections fraud and he is aided and abetted by a number of governmental officials.
Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ, petitioner herein, is a doctor and an attorney who spent four
years investigating fraud committed by Obama and fraud committed by individuals
aiding and abetting him. Taitz was subjected to intimidation, harassment,
tampering with her business, tampering with her car, she was defamed and subject
to retaliation for bringing forward to different courts and to the public at large
evidence of forgery and fraud in Obama' s IDs. Taitz filed the case at hand in
February 2012 and amended complaint in April 2012. Defendants removed the
case from the Superior court of Mississippi to the Federal court, US district Court.
First amended complaint filed in April of 2012 contained causes of action for
Racketeering, whereby Plaintiffs alleged that defendants engaged in a racketeering
scheme to defraud U.S. citizens by use of forged IDs and a stolen Connecticut
Social Security number by Barack Hussein Obama, aka Barack (Barry) Soetoro,
aka Barack (Barry) Obama Soebarkah. All of the defendants were served,
Commissioner of Social Security was served. All of the other defendants, who
were served together with the Commissioner of Social security, responded.
Commissioner of Social security never filed an answer or any other responsive
pleadings. Plaintiffs filed a notice of default and a motion for Default Judgment
against the Commissioner of Social Security Michael Astrue. Motion for default
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 5
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 5 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Judgment and post judgment discovery was filed on 12.12.2012 and a redacted
motion was filed on 12.14.2012 (exhibit 1). Plaintiff petitioner is seeking an
emergency writ of Mandamus from this court to expedite the ruling on the motion
for Default judgment and Post Judgment discovery, as it represents a matter
paramount for the U.S. National Security, it relates to Barack Hussein Obama's use
of a Social Security number which was never assigned to him and it has to be
decided and post judgment discovery has to be conducted in less than two weeks
before Obama's taking the oath of the U.S. President on January 20.213. Enormous
implication to the U.S. National Security warrants granting a motion for a WRIT
OF MANDAMUS TO THE LOWER COURT TO EXPEDITE RULING.
ARGUMENT
EMERGENCY MOTION FOR A WRIT OF MANDAMUS TO EXPEDITE
DEFAULT .JUDGMENT AND POST .JUDGMENT DISCOVERY SHOULD
BE GRANTED
8.4 Emergency Motions. Emergency motions or applications, whether
addressed to the court or to an individual judge, must be filed with the clerk
rather than with an individual judge. If there is insufficient time to file a motion or
application in person, by mail, or by fax, counsel may communicate with the clerk
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 6
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 6 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
by telephone and thereafter must file the motion in writing with the clerk as
soon as possible.
The motion, application, or oral communication must
contain a brief account of the prior actions of this or any other court or judge to
which the motion or application, or a substantially similar or related petition for
relief, was submitted.
5TH CIR. R. 21 WRITS OF
MANDAMUS AND PROHIBITION,
AND OTHER EXTRAORDINARY
WRITS
Petition for Writ. The petition must contain a certificate of interested
persons as described in 5TH CIR. R. 28.2.1. The certificate of interested persons
and the items required by
5TH CIR. R. 21 do not count toward the page limit.
In addition to the items required by FED. R. APP. P. 21, the application
must contain a copy of any memoranda or briefs filed in the district court
supporting the application to that court for relief and any memoranda or briefs
filed in opposition, as well as a transcript of any reasons the district court gave for
its action.
Writ of Mandamus to expedite is warranted, as Barack Hussein Obama is
about to be sworn in as the next U.S. President, The swearing in ceremony is
scheduled for January 20, 2013.
The issue of Obama using a Social Security number, which was never
assigned to him has to be heard before the swearing in ceremony.
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 7
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 7 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
", mandamus may be available where 'a discovery question is of
extraordinary significance or there is extreme need for reversal of the district
court's mandate before the case goes to judgment."' Ibid. (quoting von Bulow,
828 F .2d at 97). Supreme Court of the United States has granted Motions
for Extraordinary Writ of Mandamus in cases involving substantial questions of
national importance Dames and Moore v Regan 453 U.S. 654 (1981); United
States v Nixon 418 U.S. 683 (1974); Youngstown Co v Sawyer, 343 U.S. 579
(1952); Ex Parte Quirin 317 U.S. 1(1942)
This is the most extraordinary matter involving substantial questions of
National Importance: a foreign national using forged Selective Service
Certificate, forged birth certificate and a stolen Social Security number is about to
be sworn in for four more years. Writ of Mandamus to expedite Default Judgment
and Post Judgment discovery will allow a final definitive adjudication of the
matter. Plaintiffs sought production of SS-5, application for the Social Security
number, which was used by Barack Obama since 1980s, used in his tax returns as
late as 2009, while in the White House, but was never assigned to him according
to E-verify and SSNVS
If this court does not grant the motion, this court will become complicit in
the cover up of fraud and forgery in Obama' s IDs.
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 8
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 8 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Is/ Orly Taitz ESQ
Petitioner
IN THE FIFTH CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEAlS
EMERGENCY PETITION FOR A WRIT OF MANDAMUS TO EXPEDITE A RULING ON
A MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT AGAINST COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL
SECURITY MICHAEL ASTRUE
TAITZ ET AL V DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF MISSISSIPPI ET AL
US DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI 3:12-CV-0280
PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF
DR. ORLY TAITZ, ESQ
29839 SANTA MARGARITA, STE 100
RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA, CA 92688
PH. 949-683-5411
FAX 949-766-7603
ORLY.TAITZ@GMAIL.COM
CERTIFICATE OF INTERESTED PERSONS
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 9
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 9 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
There are no interested persons
/s/ Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ
Taitz et al v Democratic Party et al Petition for a Writ of Mandamus to expedite ruling 10
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 10 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Lila Dubert, am not a party to this case and attest that I
served all parties in above case byrrst class mail or ECF on
January 9.2013 \ \
! \
lsi Lila Dubert
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 11 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Plaintiff
Dr. Orly Taitz
Esq.
Plaintiff
Brian Fedorka
Plaintiff
Laurie Roth
Plaintiff
Tom MacLeran
Plaintiff
Leah Lax
v.
Defendant
Democrat Party of Mississippi
represented by Orly Taitz
29839 Santa Margarita Parkway, Ste.
100
Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688
949-683-5411
Email: Orly. Taitz@gmail.com
PROSE
represented by Brian Fedorka
PROSE
represented by Laurie Roth
PROSE
represented by Tom MacLeran
PROSE
represented by Leah Lax
PROSE
represented by Samuel L. Begley
BEGLEY LAW FIRM, PLLC
P. 0. Box287
Jackson, MS 39205
6011969-5545
Fax: 601/969-5547
Email: sbegley 1 @bellsouth.net
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Scott J. Tepper- PHV
GARFIELD & TEPPER
1801 Century Park East, Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067-2326
310/277-1981
Fax: 310/277-1980
Email: scottjtepper@msn.com
PROHACVICE
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 12 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Defendant
Secretary of State of Mississippi
Defendant
Barak Hussein Obama
Defendant
Obama for America
Defendant
Nanci Pelosi
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Harold Edward Pizzetta , III
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL
P.O. Box220
Jackson, MS 39205-0220
6011359-3680
Email: hpizz@ago.state.ms.us
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Justin L. Matheny
MISSISSIPPI ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S OFFICE
P. 0. Box220
Jackson, MS 39205-0220
601-359-3825
Fax: 601-359-2003
Email: jmath@ago.state.ms.us
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Samuel L. Begley
(See above for address)
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Scott J. Tepper- PHV
(See above for address)
PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Samuel L. Begley
(See above for address)
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Scott J. Tepper- PHV
(See above for address)
PROHACVICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Samuel L. Begley
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 13 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Defendant
Dr. Alvin Onaka
Defendant
Loretta Fuddy
Defendant
Michael Astrue
Defendant
Jane Does
Defendant
John Does 1-100
(See above for address)
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Scott J. Tepper- PHV
(See above for address)
PROHACVICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Walter W. Dukes
DUKES, DUKES, KEATING &
F ANECA, P A - Gulfport
P.O. Drawer W (39502)
2909 13th Street, 6th Floor
Gulfport, MS 39501
(228) 868-1111
Email: walter@ddkf.com
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Walter W. Dukes
(See above for address)
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 14 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87 Filed 12/14/12 Page 1 of 3
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI
E u._.fJL_
Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ
OEC 1 q 2012
29839 Santa Margarita, ste I 00
Rancho Santa Margarita, Ca 92688
BY
J T. NOBLIN. CLERK
DEPUTY
949-683-5411, fax 949-766-7603
orly.taitz@gmail.com
PRO SE PLAINTIFF IN MS
IN THE US DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI
Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ et al ) CASE 12-CV-280
v
Democratic Party of Mississippi et al
) HON. HENRY WINGATE
) PRESIDING
NOTICE OF DEFAULT BY DEFENDANT MICHAEL ASTRUE, COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL SECURITY
MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND POST DEFAULT DISCOVERY
1. Defendant Michel Astrue, commissioner of Social Security, was served on October 9 2012, by
professional process service through the office of the U.S. Attorney in Washington DC. He was
served together with President Obama and Congresswoman Pelosi. Service of process is
available on the docket.
2. During 10.16.2012 hearing Scott J. Tepper representing Obama, Pelosi, "Obama for America"
and Democratic party of Mississippi (Hereinafter DPM) stated on the record that Astrue was
served, but did not respond within 21 days as others, as he was sued as a federal employee,
therefore he has 60 days to respond since the date of service.
3. 60 days expired on December 8, 2012.
4. Astrue did not file an answer or any responsive pleadings and is currently in default.
5. Plaintiff Taitz is seeking a Default Judgment against defendant Michel Astrue, fees and costs.
6. Taitz is asking this court to grant her motion to compel records as part of the post Default
discovery, specifically she is seeking a Motion to Compel production of the SS-5, Social Security
application to Connecticut Social Security number xxx-xx-4425, (unredacted version of this
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 15 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87 Filed 12/14/12 Page 2 of 3
motion with the full Social Security number is provided to the court under seal) which was used
by Barack Obama in his tax returns filed on WhiteHouse.gov, which was not assigned to him
according to E-Verify and SSN\[S.,
/ / < ~ _ ( '
./ (,.. .,,,
7. /s/ DR. OrlyTaitz, ESQ
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
AS PART OF POST JUDGMENT DISCOVERY
1. Defendant Michel Astrue, commissioner of Social Security, was served on October 9 2012, by
professional process service through the office of the U.S. Attorney/Department of Justice in
Washington DC. He was served together with President Obama and Congresswoman Pelosi.
Service of process is available on the docket.
2. During 10.16.2012 hearing Scott J. Tepper representing other defendants: Obama, Pelosi,
"Obama for America" and Democratic party of Mississippi (Hereinafter DPM) stated on the
record that Astrue was served, but did not respond within 21 days as others, as he was sued as a
federal employee, therefore he has 60 days to respond since the date of service.
3. 60 days expired on December 8, 2012.
4. Astrue did not file an answer or any responsive pleadings and is currently in default.
5. Plaintiff Taitz is seeking a Default Judgment against defendant Michel Astrue, fees and costs.
6. Taitz is asking this court to grant her motion to compel records as part of the post Default
discovery, specifically she is seeking a Motion to compel production of the SS-5, Social Security
application to Connecticut Social Security number xxx-xx-4425, which was used by Barack
Obama in his 2009 tax returns, but never assigned to Barack Obama according toe-verify and
SSNVS.
7. Affidavit of Felicite Papa attests to the fact that Obama originally did not flatten the PDF file and
published the full CT Social security number xx-xx-4425 he is using on WhiteHouse.gov Exhibit 1.
Affidavit of Felicite Papa
8. According toE-verify this number was never issued to Barack Obama Exhibit 2 Affidavit of Linda
Jordan and E-Verify certification
9. According to SSNVS (Social Security Verification Systems) this number was never assigned to
Barack Obama Exhibit 3 SSNVS certification
10. Obama's use of a stolen Social Security number and cover up of this fact is the basis of the RICO
conspiracy, which included harassment, intimidation, persecution and financial damages to
Plaintiff Taitz .
11. Without a motion to compel Taitz would not be able to obtain necessary information.
Additionally, now there is evidence of defendants and their accomplices spoliating, destroying
evidence. Recently some of the RICO co-conspirators took down a website "Fogbow" with a
clear intent to destroy evidence. Similarly, Affidavits of Investigator Zullo (Exhibit 4) and Expert
Blake (Exhibit 5 ) show a pattern of obstruction of Justice, evasion of law enforcement.
tampering with evidence.
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 16 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3: 12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87 Filed 12/14/12 Page 3 of 3
12. Based on all of the above good cause exists to grant Plaintiff Taitz Default Judgment and grant
her motion to compel production of docyments in order to ascertain damages.
.. !.
(. ,-tj,/
/sf Dr. Orly Taitz ESQ
Per request of the parties, the parties are electronically via ECF
/sf Dr. OrlyTaitz, ESQ /-"' ( ('
7
) <G_____....-
AFFIDAVIT OF ORLY TAITZ REGARDING ATTEMPTS TO CONTACT DEFENDANT MICHEL ASTRUE
1. Defendant Astrue was notified about his legal action and he received the First Amended
Complaint of this action originally pending in the Superior Court of Mississippi on April13, 2012
through his attorney Helen l. Gilbert at H!J.c_Ql::_(:;lLI:l.*:'!..t@Jo!.?l2Q.l.Ji.QY. He did not respond.
2. Defendant Astrue was served by Process server Daniel Williams docketed herein as Document
54-1 Same Day Process Service, Inc.
1219llth SL,NW
Washington DC 2000 I
(202)- 398- 4200
lnll'nwl JPb 10:1>230.' Ut:!i:illhmt \,!,lie IW\ er "·'"flolllkd.
3. Due to the fact that all prior attempts to get a response from defendant Astrue failed, Plaintiff
Taitz is requesting this court to grant her Motion to compel production of documents under
FRCP 37 as part of post default discovery.
1 attest under penalty of perjury that is true and correct to the best of my knowledge
and informed belief .c/
/sf Dr. Orly Taitz ESQ { t.
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 17 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-1 Filed 12/14/12 Page 1 of 6
EXHIBIT 1
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 18 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-1
S rJ\·1 H >F Fl.OIWJA l
)S.S.
< 'OI·NTY OF llOVAL)
i
AI'I'IDA VIT
Filed 12/14/12 Page 2 of 6
I, Fe:u:ittJ l'nt>a. an1 .;ver 18 ohl and rt:.ident ul '/\79 Walden Road. Jacksonville, H. 12244 with FL
1>1. :'1'1110·245 I do• 11111 sutler lrom any mental impairment and I cumpctently aUl·•t to the
follc•winj! under the renalty ofrcrjury
I am a p1 • web devdop.:r hav mg gr.tduatcd with a ucgre.: m 11 from II r
in lndianarolis. I have over len yeHrs of experience of"' weh designs ant!
d.-vdormdl! nntll hav<: often u">Cd sotiwart' such a< Adnhe l'hlllushor and Adube lllnsrratnr
1 On Apnl I J. 2010. the Whitehouse released the 2011'1 1-onn I U40
of Income fax Return of President Barack H. Obama.
http" .'lwwvJ, whit chouse .goll/si tcs/ defaultlfi lcsirrc• ident- nhamo-20 1 ().com rl o: tc-retum rdf.
'
.I I downloaded this M-pnge p.Jf file on my computer I ohservcd that all information about the
the first lady"• soctalsecurity numhcrs were redacted All block:. or spdces for
securit) nutnbcn were blanic:, C\r .. whJte-nut "
I
4 I submit A (anachcd herewith. page 43 part of2009 hnm 1040) Fonn '/09li.S. Gift Tax
Return of tlres. Uarack Ubama. I "he space for his social •ecurily number is redacted or blank.
) 1 submit top E.xhibit B (attached hcrc:wi\h, page 49 part or 2009 Form 1040) Form '/09 U.S. Gift
Rerurn of First Lady Michelle Obama. The space for her soc1al security number;, redacted or
hlank.
t.. Thcn Adnbo: 'ollwarc, I opened lxhobil A and Band found that these two pdf
file• have t'" layers each. nul just une layer. When the top layt.'r fliT or dragged away.
the social 9ec:urity numhcrs of both pcrsuns arc revealed.
I
·1. 1 A 1 (allachc:d herewith) Form 70\1 U.S. <i1ft l"a.'\ Return ofl'rcs. Barack Ohama
with his numhcr rcv\:al<:d. fhc: folluwing onlilrmation arc revealed·
I. Rarad.. Ob<tma's
2J Michelle Obama's SSN
.l: J\n initilll MLO ""tile ,;oJe uf l'nrm "ICI'1
·II A 1:-1 inch dark >quare with m•tiltinn on 11.
5 l'rcparl-..-"• SSN or PIN l'll0570IJ7·1
£IN 'llt-270Ur.tl0
I
i l'huncnu . .1121.172-0<140
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 19 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
t...O
Case 3: 12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-1
Filed 12/14/12 Page 3 of 6
709
\ UnrteoStates GiH (and Generation-Skipptng Transfer) Return
I - --- -- -
j
-,·
.,
0.
. !
-,
"l
:i =-· 1
'·!:;.t;,.• •
..·u J:-'
··:- t:-;
''··
.,·.
,r
···!·:
. - -
··! ..
·l-
1

. ·:
-, . •: -.. '· ,, .
__
.l":
··':'-. . . ··,.
"': .
..:. •} i.;. .-..• :-: . . · ·'}
__ ]__ ____ _
·-·.

J •
I 5'--------- IJ '
,_! __
;B.8!H'i.
---· ··----------v
- .
_; ____ _
..
- 2 ______ -
.,
..

-'------
"J : ___: ______ _
• • 709
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 20 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
,-... ....o
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-1
Filed 12/14/12 Page 4 of 6
709

- J-···.

·.•_, .... - . , ..

: - .r -- .

'1
ii
;--.,
;::
"'

..

.,
::- ..
. )

:•
-
Stales Gitt (and Generation-SkipPing Transfer) Tax Return I
t-2-oo9--
I
I
'.1
... :;
.C.---'----- .. -··--
.:.. -.
: 1-·
·1·. - •t.,;
. +'
0. !:· .. , ;
. · I : ... , ·: · ·, ,. , ·"
j·.
'
... .:
. •,.:
:-.
·1 , .•
. to:'' nt.:' :y r., .... u•
___ ... I I u;: __
-: . -
··1-:- _______
• :-· : • j • : •.'
S7ATES
--
___ X_j__

_, __________ ..,o_.
.
.
_!_,.___ 'I •
___ ,.:s.aiJrJ .

ns.ao5a.
·- ----- ---
I..
·- -----0.
'J
..


'i
• -· J •
--------- ---·-·-·· --·
. .,. l -··.
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 21 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-1
Filed 12/14/12 Page 5 of 6
709
;
"l
..
t"1-
. ·- J ,. -
.:."J:"
.,
I
I
T nsferJ Ta• Return !Jn,h!d States Gt!t (and Gene·atton-Sktpptng ra
I
I-
t
. l-
1
. '
-:.:.- J. ::.... • :;_:__
1- ·-
•.· t•
:. ·'t-
2009--
:·: ... 1 \0._ tt
----
5 •,: ..
---------- ________ ...,.... • , •• 0
•• -;jo"
- --·
'
---------
.!· ..
------ ------ -

J.ls.3ce.
---- ·--::-:--
. ----------
.,
•I


709
------------
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 22 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-1
Filed 12/14/12 Page 6 of 6
u

"
709
t
Unrte<l States Grtt land Generation Skipping Tran:;ler) Tax 11eturn
2009
---·.'·. J

-------
J.l.' ·-· :.- ••
. I:..LINOI 3

'
;·iASHI -:. -..1-fiTED STATES
. ---- -.-.----·_··------------.. -----.v- __..
f .. ···:···'" -- -. -.. ;,. ' -·· -.. , ....
c .,
------------- ----- ·------ ----.
1 -- ...
--------
.· .
.' ._ ':J : . _- .·
----y
2'
:11

;
'
c.
·'
M
,.:
-;
'l
,:o
.,
"-
'5
·;
..

'

•.•.:-
! ·- '! -... ..
; .. - •· .!
•••• j
._ --·.-:..: . .:;: . f': :
:I
- . ·-- -- :·,-.... • • • r • - •
'-
l
I
I
-·r: ··- ..
: ... - -
: !':' :." •• ·-"': -. t". .•••
..... 0:-AD
l
·------
.c
,.
.. 2.,
l
'4 I
--. : ,. - . -. . ..
. ,._.,_, .. ... -. .-_ •':J
.• ··o-: , •.. - . "· ........
--.:- ·'(·· .X.. 'l'cs "' ._,o
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 23 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-2 Filed 12/14/12 Page 1 of 4
EXHIBIT 2
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 24 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-Oq280-HTW-LRA Document 87-2 Filed 12/14/12 Page 2 of 4
. I.'
if ChecK.
• 1...,
U'il)g i i l t ~ ; l\ll[!( i: 'NIIIl you \IVIH:n Y()ll Vl'·'.tt s:-:>A
ror SSA Field Office Staff. Do uot w;e EV STAH: Se1: POMS RM 102!i0.00lltt
: , •1. '•.• . 'I l I '
r_-1,
...... ;.:,·'
. I.
t .• I ·., ·,1: 'l
SSN dncc; not lll.ltch. I ,.- .I '·J• r·' :.- I ~ •... J ' • I /.•1 j
,}II ···- I I ; , . if i ( ~ ; :J t_ .. ! ! I • ': 1 , -;, ! , . '' ~ ; . I ~ ·- •: ·, • '
I l . • I i I ; ·, t - ~ : l I • f ,\ .... !.:.-,. l
:'':..:..
, • ~ r '
'··
:,·:.
,.
-,l. I \',1
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 25 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3: 12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-2
Filed 12/14/12 Page 3 of 4
'I"
1
.1 I II:.·
I.! '1 1:·
lr.:<..· pc··:,,:· . .J '· 'tl\\1 ·d ·,·
'! t. i.., ,, I' ·• I': r>
'
t' Ui. ; .' •i
',.' 1 • I , \ l! I I(: i. t_' \ ! . I! \..'
.. _.,I :: [,'
.:1
t l\ r.:rlt 1 rtl:
li.tt.t. :. II t l···.:t
\ 't'\ ....... l. · .. I i' I . . ...
:. ·-. ... ·.: 'ct:
' '. I i .. : /1 .. • • I ! \ I j ....: \ '1. I i . f. ' ·, \ i ; \ . "1 -.., . ·-. ( ) I I : ' . . :
0
h : • ' ' • • •
' .. • f
., ,, ll.
I
II:.._! .1. I . .. ·! j t { \j' \ : l. j)l \: :.'. .. '': I i : .J i \.: ... :· ' I. II l'
. d .f.
,., ,,_.,: ·,. ,,: ...
' ·: ·, \ r_' 1._' I \ ., . I I ., 't•l
I
, .. 1 ·'' l '- ..
_:, ..:_{', :,)
·< '-'11 ... • \\ :r.L dh: ..::' .. t. r ... ·P••:· .. .. lilt. 1..1 :t:· j'\
..... _ , , · , : · .__ '...'l \ _., , , ; :, : ·.: - : 1 :, ' ••• i:.. · ._ t i \ • : 1·r· \.! . · ' :. ,..:. : ·· 1: 1 ) l ....
·._,,:,!.-
': '\ I ': f • l• ·I ! ; l ! 1 \
··,_\ ,·.!
,J :!
, j l;' • l; j \, • :I '
t ti},
• • • • t 'ntltt>i -\,t 1•. II!;.;;
-! ".· .. :.I . I I' ., !. . . i I;. • i' . •,'
... ,
I , · 1 -
,,,
\' ,. ,., :i·,· ..: \'•ill' . . . :
'-,·
: '·"·'
. "" ·,_
d ,'j
I "I '•.,
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 26 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-2 Filed 12/14/12 Page 4 of 4
I
I
tl:, ',, '• 1: lt:;._c: .•• ,:.!· .. q:·t
1
·.:l \, ... :.·:· •
I I . ! I I t) I I· .
1
:. ' .... htlt' ·, \
._'J, :·.,::.t...·: : ....... r h: ,
\ · ._· r: : i, · :: :. " ! I , 11 · lu' h.:,·: 1 • 111:: I •! ,· 1 o ! , ,, .. tl<' ' >II• • (i 11 < I h;! lll:l .
tl;
1
\r. __ L···! J··.,·:,:b;·:"'''• : ... r \,·t·:.· .. ,,.J'>t'•::t:,!·:.!'<'. <t:,t:l
1
:c",'
r- I
\' •• 1 .. • .. : • "-..-..·r\ \·:: ·.• .. •·· :thlr.· ·.t· ...J.It;tli·· .. .. ' ..: ... :·.i· ...·:· ·.: .\.,.·
'
,, ... , ::.:. :.i: ;:>1. :·;":· ,·.: ;;-1· :!
1
····f\ I ,"·tt-r.·t! r':;:- 11 II"(• lhr::• \!I
c ll•;\llt.t. l•n:h dLtk .\'.l:'.lhl I. f'Jc,j and :--s;.,.. 41 '-\. l nt-.. ci:t;:l ''"'
..:•·::·c··<:-. I .1.· i ·.,._(. !:·,q :.h.:._,._,_\ t·;,!itl!,·,: _, '·"ti,·,· , . .,
\l;·.,l •. l ,·it 1\;: ·l·""..:i .. l \,·,· .. 111\
I '

- I
L
··.
.
) • '! \ . . J
!l) -..;,,
I
1:· I ilL
ll
II:
...... ,•
... l.'.
\\'
i
.• !It II: lh ....· ',,,t,,;·\
I >:11<"
I
)
;;•!!
"'
'-:.: .. \'.1.· \\ \
'l:O.
!
I :.: 21lf,
.• ... hJ -·
.. • I
I 1 .. !1: Ill
\\: ! ... i:.
\ .
'•: I
'
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 27 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-3 Filed 12/14/12 Page 1 of 3
EXHIBIT 3
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 28 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3: 12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-3
Filed 12/14/12 Page 2 of 3
l:;Rf:::G HOlLISTER- qreq __ holilster@ntsn cum.· \tVeci. i e!J 2D i 1 ;1l 5
TCJ. or·y tart.r.@wnail•::orn
C•: "_:rJhn '·lem,_•nway (;c: Co,tqcJI" net-·. U:Hry Ugin
iae@gn1a:', con1 SL1SCH1 r'nvatt; invest!gatot LH1na !Jt:nt.
)N(JR/\\J NF:'/t'S' CO!il>
hcn .. (;r·.u y-.;u1 l.:::ffc,rt!! dt a :JH.: eilq1bi!lty ut : .. t!rvf'
035
POlUS :see lhnt you are now fri:ng SUit reference hs m<-tny SSNs.
I havr: a <.opy ot Dbama's sclecitve set vtcf• cat cl wtth the !:>SN <1ffrxeo. I. as d snwll t>usim·:ss uwner
ildVI; acr;,;;;s \U t'lf; so.;:<l! SeC .. H!ty Nunli)tcf Veni.catron i\S a :·psult. ! chet:kc:d tltc for
ll:e used iur registering with Service. The SSNVS searcit resulted in a rep:Jrl
s!att:s tnat OiJa!Yli"'! dSe(l LO in1 ·.vas never
Let me !Jc at:,)r;r .. ; have nol a3rc:ed \'Jiih metr.y uf your tadrcs rn thrs endeavor. fio·Nn·er ! ravH
,·ont,-,L.ec to tn!iov.' )'Our efforts t'J seP. thNe r•tay tJe syneryy and tbs is one
: if wilj he helpful pft'?dSB le! n1e know anc1 : vvdl yuu the ;:.;:_)f:
files for both ll'e Selective Servtce Catc! ami the SSNVS repurt that tilat SShl was
'!iSdt:cJ.
:;_ f tJ:),::.,f. ·:-;d
i I
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 29 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-3
HSC l - SS \ cri lication Rt.>sulls
Filed 12/14/12
Social Security Number Verification System
_______ _
SSNVS Help "ij
l:IH
f<ecord!> Subrntt!ed
Fa1led
Ver>f,ed Re<of\is
1
1
0
SSN Results
1
ije laD-e C:SC·oh s ';J .., · swc,·n COlumn f the recorc

Gf Pi11[)1CY!te 0€"(--t:::dSeC! i!le hS! flve of tfl€ Wtll l)e masJo..ed for vt-nfu?d
afld reco·cs a •/er
1
:cat·o•1 results cooe ot 2 "3 4 or F;
• Failed- d'-'"-"5 r ··.: Secunty rpcorcis Se1ect
fo, 111orc !rtorrnatton
• Deceased Ja!a rrat:f'es So: a; • .. 1eccrds tnd!cate tt1at
tne p.e,.sc•'1 s. ;,-.,:r(" mfor711af;Q'1 r:(v--.tatt ,Ju• geqcrd· .. l1ne
at 1-800.-7:· ·:.:L:, 1 ··y ··800 325-07
7
8; yo1..r a Secur·:
1
r··eid ott:ce S'e"e::'t
to hna ttle ofhce nearest
Have a questmn" Mon - Fri 7AM to lPM Eastern T1me to speak w•th Employer Customer Serv•ce personnel For
TDDITIY ca111-800-325-0778
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 30 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-4 Filed 12/14/12 Page 1 of 4
EXHIBIT 4
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 31 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-4 Filed 12/14/12 Page 2 of 4
AFFIDAVIT
Henry Blake, being first duly sworn, do hereby state under oath and under penalty of pc1jury
that the following facts are true:
I. I am over the age of 18 years old and am a resident of Tennessee. The information
contained in this affidavit is based upon my own personal knowledge and, if called as a
witness, I could testifY competently thereto. I attained higher education as follows: BS
Mechanical Engineering, MS & PhD in Engineering Mechanics. I have over 40 years
experience with a variety of computers including: Personal Computers, Work Stations,
Mainframes and Super Computers.
II. I have general kno\vledge of foregoing legal filings in the Federal District Court Case
3: 12-cv-00280-HTW -LRA and have specific knowledge of the digital images of copies of
President Obama's purported Long-Form Certificate of Live Bilth (LFCOLB) appearing
within the case filing documents.
Ill. 1 have examined the two image copies of the purported LFCOLB which exist as digital
electronic page documents, namely
05/04/2012 15 MOTION for Judgment on the Pleadings by Democrat Party ofMississippi
(Attachments: # I Exhibit LFBC ti·om White Bouse, # 2 Exhibit COLB fi·om
Campaign,# 3 Exhibit DOH Verification re White House BC, If. 4 Exhibit Hawaii
Gov April27 2011 News Release,# 5 Exhibit DOH White House Correspondence,
# 6 Exhibit DOH 08-93 News Release,# 7 Exhibit DOH 09-063 News Release, ff
8 Exhibit CDC Report reBirth Cettificate History)(Begley, Samuel) (Entered:
05/0412012) [.pdf(page 8)]
and
06/06/2012 35 MOTION to Supplement Counsel for MDEC's Response 30 in Opposition to
Plaintiff Taitz's Motion for Sanctions 25 re 30 Response to Motion, by Democrat
Party of lVfississippi (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit MDEC Counsel Request to HI
DOH for Verification of President Obamas Hmvaiian Bitth Cett, # 2 Exhibit
Hawaii DOH Verification of President Obamas Hawaiian Birth Issued May 31
2012)(Begley, Samuel) (Entered: 06/06/2012) [.pdf(page ll)j
see also comt document
I0513240131.pdf 05/26/2012 Re: Request for Verification of Vital Records Pursuant
to Hawai' i. Rev. Stat. § 338-14.3 and 338-1 8(g)(4) [.pdf(page 4)]
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 32 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-4 Filed 12/14/12 Page 3 of 4
and which were filed by the Mississippi Democratic Executive Committee (MDEC), as
well as the original PDF image of President Obama's LFCOLB, which was posted on the
White House web site on Apr. 27, 2011,
hHp://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/filcs/rss_ viewer/birth-certificate-long-form. pdf
and have found significant alterations were made to the original White House LFCOLB
PDF image file. Specifically the copy of the LFCOLB appearing in the second and third
documents above differ significantly from the copy appearing in the first document and
from the original copy posted on the White House website.
Page S of the first document above is nearly identical to the white House LFCOLB PDF
image file. Page II ofthe second above document is identical to page 4 of the third
document. For convenience I will denote the two copies that I recently examined as
(page 8) and as (page 411 1).
IV. The alterations made to the White House LFCOLB PDF image to create the (page 8)
image copy are incidental.
1. The (page 8) image copy is otherwise identical to the white House image except for the
"Case Label" added at the top margin.
2. Only the Case label is selectable by mouse and cursor on (page 8)
3. The (page 8) image copy was altered to make the (page 4/11) image copy.
V. I found that the alterations to the (pageS) image copy to create the (page 4111) image
copy are extensive as follows:
1. A second Case Label was added
2. The (page 8) image \Vas "flattened, rasterized and green color was added
3. The color of all text was changed from near-Black to Black-Green
4. Numerous torm lines were repaired or replaced entirely
5. The basket-weave background was softened and touched up
6. Specific words were made selectable by mouse and cursor in Adobe Reader
7. Hidden editing was applied (see 8.- 11. below):
8. Ten Line Objects were added
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 33 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-4 Filed 12/14/12 Page 4 of 4
9. Two Green Color objects were added
IO. Two Broad-line Strikeouts were applied, one to the words "Kapiolani Matemity &
Gynecological", and the other to the word "August"
11. Seven Rectangular Black Redaction Box Objects were added which altogether cover
nearly all of the typed text
VI. The remaining typed, stamped (or form) words left unsttuck or umedacted and appearing
on the hidden image of (page4/ll) are:
l. Both Case Labels
2.
3.
State of Hawaii Certificate of Live Birth
61 10641 (file number 151 is redacted)
Department of Health
4. Barack Hussein Obama, II ("X" in single-birth box)
5. Honolulu (in two places)
6. 6085 Kalaianaole Highway
7. Labels for ten form-boxes
8. State Registrar's date and signature stamps
VII. Words which can be selected on (page 4/11) by mouse and cursor in Adobe Reader are:
1. Both Case Labels
2.
2.
State ofHawaii Certificate of Live Bhth
61 10641 (File number 151 is non-selectable)
3. Bm·ack Hussein Obama, II
4. Honolulu
5. Kapiolani Maternity & Gynecological Hospital
6. 6085 Kalanianaole
7. Hussein Obama
8. University
9. State Registrar's date and signature stamps.
I attest to this under penalty of perjury.
f?47?
Henry /
11/09/2012
· Department of Health
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 34 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 1 of 16
EXHIBIT 5
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 35 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 2 of 16
AF
I, the um1ersii!,;ted, being first duly ::"':or•1, do l1ercby state LJDde;- o;..lth under
nenalty of perjLH'Y Lhal. the ':ollm\·ing facts are tme:
L l an·, OYC'l' i.hc age of t8 and arn <J of /1 rizonn. The iilformnhon
coniained in this affidm-it is bnscd upon my mn1 persond knowledge <md,
if called as a witness, ·\ conld i:e::;tify competcntb· thereto. r am a fcnner
swom law enf{m:ement officBr and criminal iJn·estigator. Since I
ha\'e been duly nppointco ;Jy the eJected Sheriff of Maricopa Com;·rv,
Arizona, ,Joseph Arpaio, as tbt: chier :nvestigator oJ.' his Cold Case Fot'sc.
[;.lder the ,4rii:oi13 Cnnsiittli·ion P.nd Ari:wm: Rf:'\'ised Statutes, the Sheriff
has the authority to reqvest assisrancc from a \'olunteer posse ("the Cn!d
Case Posse"), fixe-member team of experienced investigato•·s
te::un depu1-h:ed by the Shel.'iff include0 fo:.·me1· police
and attomcys who work ·mhmtar!.ly and nL no e11K:nse
to the taxpayer the Sheriff authorizes fm im-Pstigation to
any issue as the Sheriff deems appropriate.
fn ii.ur,ust 20n, a group of :.:itizens from the Arizona Tea i
1
a1ty
orgnniza1:cm ca1lcd upor: the Sheriff iJ.J his offiee n':d J.Te:_;c;llt:d a pci:itiun
signed hr approximately 250 1·esidents of MnricopH Couui}, rcquc::;tbg Lhe
Sheriffs Depmtment to invesj:itnie whether a docurnent

on the
official of the V\'hitc lloi.lse on 'Y.'7 AJFil201' nncl ,J1:,rpm-Ung on !ts
to be an electronic of tl:;_e "long--form" or original Ha>\·r,iiD.n
b;1·i:h cerl.Hicate of President Bamcl.:: Obama \'.ao genutn<:'.
4-· 1 f i-Lc or the 1)irth J.Jot tb<:: questio11
m·ise 1\·hether Mr Obama hac] lJ.:;cr; burn \dthin the of tl•c
TJr:.:r.:?cj Sn:tt;:-s ·t:hcre
1
,;y (_:\JEllJliecl :;·equi!.."C!J.J.cn·;· /:_:·ttcle T'.
of the U.S. Constitution ch; Pi·csident be ;J. "uaLm;.li--1)01'!1 citizen".
t;, Tl1e lJetitioners cxvrcssed tJ·u:i·r th<rt poi11l:o no ln'.V
..Gad :.:;-\-C?I.' 0!1 rts thu..: it
. • ' . i I" , , ' 1 't ,, .. l , ('I
or '.vas
1
,\'l llPf. JH\"CS _tgclce ,.\·.net ,jjJan1H
eligiL>ie to ·!1oid. ills oLfic<....!.

sai(:. cf
jnrisctir:tional challenges llao L1 !1 <'.tl.l :;uch cbe-,-,·herc.
6. Sherjff .:l.l'pD.io F'os::c: die
'!.hr-; )r1nc1prd ·f()CPS of rh?
i11vestigation is the docutrle oj;

li.Otlse
PrPsicieni· h.n.d tl1c· inl<l.g() of h1s Jonp;-forn1 ;JlrL-Ll
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 36 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3: 12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5
Filed 12/14/12 Page 3 of 16
. .-tn ',· .. ,·.. -,-· ..

;·,u -,1. "•· .... ·• ·- .. - ..... ·J·-
--------' __ .,_ _ • • __ · ___ , __
\rVhite Honse press conference OlJ J..jJi'il 27, 2011, 1.dwn he b.ad S<lid; "\·V·e
pre:' idc:
1
r.dditim,a] !:],.-' of m,- birth .... Yes. m
tact, [was born in llawaii, Augns\.4, 1901, in Kapl'olrmi .
7. For i'/ years Crmn 1991 ·Lmtil yeHr be[ore [:1e Presidential election of
2008, the bogrrrphy iiTii:ten by ivlr Obmna aud eirculutcd
b,- his agents had contained the words "Baradz Obama, the fir&t
.. cf U.}c.:\ J.'-tc::·ucn,ci \\ ..t.-ts . .>:J''n
and rniseri in lndonesia mu.l Hawaii."
8. The oftkiai )Jarlianwniury Dehutes oi: i·iw Kcnv<111 r'Jationnl Jc1
25 l\ti:,p·d, ''o.:.o rec.ords thrrt :vir Urengo, the lVflnisi.er for Lnnds, snicl: "i:f
!;J.s n slate .:;r n.ation, eo1.1ld c.
young man born hen: in Kcnyn, i:.; Eot even a nalin· American,

9. ThP- inYesi:lgation has closely ex<,mined the procedu-e_; far rcgistratlou of
biri.hs ai the Hawaii Depmtment o' I-Iea1th c:<.nd vadous statements made
by of Ea'.\'<di i?P''Cnm:er.i: cTer the ktsL fi,·c year'' in conn/;ction
Fith the authentidiy of Mr b:irlh records. \Vo haYe d:ronieled a
t::, \·:::_r}cns officinls
of the g.o,:c:nPncnt of H::nvaii have mude since 200'/ on :-lw question. \\hat
original birtb. rc\?ords, if ::1

8 l'e Ly \.'--r1;
iO. In Februhry I rcportcc] t<i Sheriff 1\.1:paio tlw.t there \\Tr; probable
..... a:· 1;j:p·J1
ecrUfknlc \'/as a forgery, and specificu1ly th;c1t i< wa.s not 8 tn•.e al1d ar::u;,rate
photographic image of ::1 gen11ine birtll record. J <:t<.h·ised the Sheriff that
the f-m·gers had proba;)ly comrnittc::i two eli mcs: fir':_;L, fraudulently

F ..
7
-lrr :.sc J'Jtd c}_;_p_i·nc.terized ... o1·
U'lkno\,·hgly., us • offlciaHy-pToduccd goYel·n1.11enial bi1t11 ;·pcord; and
secondly, {:raudukntly presenlinr; to the residents of Cour;ty and
tn ,:,,rnc;·ic;-:p p11blic at lm·ge ;J forgery thal the V\Thitc Eoc;sc had
n.s ! •. n·cof •._;!.
1-la\\·aiia.n ioitg--for!r: :)ilt:1
, , T;lf'SP condnsions ·were reinforced by lnpnt frmn nu.tnercus ex;Jeri:l:> m tilt.::
fields of t:ypewl'iting,
forensic a11aly!;;.S and i\dobe COl!lpnter .J?J:ogranls, .1s

1 ;1s
cct:ti:'D.:·i:)cL:; ...·1:hr:-r 1'2CO• cl.s AJ1d. G"XJJert. re·viev:.s
I-I8 hl.\ \' ar1.d. of thf; .3.11d lYi·oced t :1*e5 the
I·i·a\vaE Depcu.traer..·t oi· :-Tr.alth.
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 37 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 F'l d 12/14/12
1 e Page 4 of 16
12. · J.'lte ir1Yestiguli011 fL1rLhe1 cieL<::fiFi 1 tha:. ·d1e: ',,:rji
I
.- ', ' 1 1 • • · · 1 n 1 · · · ' 1 1 · ·
·H':Htlll engu.gen 1n ';.:;;,::[ i.,:P ·>llerm: s nwesngators )e 1eve 1::.; n
sy.sLcmatir effmi: tc bide from ;;n; m1d the public wl:ateYer
orig;n::t1 1961 bi1th records the :..:;m\·aii Department of Health may h<ne in
its possession. The Fosse cclso accmnu1atcd e'i'id.ence that d.a11'ni i
gOYCflJll1errl ElllCl i:nC: iD
a man:wr C<llcu1at(>d tc hinder ow· 1m\·· enforcetnent investigation.
ln furtherance of the investigation, which has now c:ontlnueu fer i.nore
first oceasion, a J\lf.aricop:_\ C81..mty Sheriffs Oitke Detective and J
presented our credentials to t:hE' ofiic,•s of the l·h,\'?,ii I>cpa<·Lroen\: of
Health <1nc1 ;·C'quested to speak to Mr A1Yin Onnk2., the chi.ef of
births, 8. simulacmm of 11·hose sie;na111re-stnmp had hppcarcd
e:ecb;Gi;: dc'"Enr::-::t thP
1
/':'hi":e Eou.'w:

·we hud hoped tc nsk l\lir
C1n&b. if he .-;c:1!.-l the ?trrher;tidty or the \Vhltc House released
doeument and to the 1eF,itintr:ey of the registrar'.,,; :::A8mp hea:·ing Lis
.sie:!l:::ture. Add1tion;1liY \\C hoped to ask him ·::o niim\· us, for h<.\\··-
reaSUllS, Lo inspect origi nnl docl1 tnGD.t tHl(l, c..-tuc
-;:o ·--
--:· .--., ..:::. ., - . ' ·-··>;.
•,t·;_
-_-_. r. ;_
lb._: : • • t -. '·. -. ('

1
.r
rc{r:se-d ;:lJ.:.." of ;:i-JE ril.c ty.·
.. .. , !';Jet
"

16.. . -
·,·,I.
·- ' i-;
. ,_;·
1---:,::.:-.
. ·,_'
·'I I_; ;- '
·. J-
,, .
;_;--
1
1
/. 'l.'c als.J the I-!.os_pitai, \Vl.
1
icll doc·u1nent on the V\th:te
f-{Gllt:.;f-" i:hc place o.Y IVir CYbar·Jr:.-s l;ir·i:lL had
disc:oYel·ed a::J " rr;st.llt of cur ·Lhnt the hospit<\1, ;.rt Lhe
bme, had maintainc:c: a scparc:te ,·ecorcl·1;;ce
1
)ing by \o..·hich birLk;
{Jt is storetl in ;_:cspital
.. f'hese a::ebives nre acccssj.iJle ·co tl1c
'I
_)
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 38 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 5 of 16
permissiol1. Vl/e asked to see UH' iWS).:ilLa1's birth recon.b J.'uJ" 1961 [)lti ,o;er;::
less Lh.nn politely :·e:fus,:xl. 1\t no cEci Kapi'olani Hospitnl encr cunfirrn
thai: Il/!r Obama in Cnd born k the hospil:al. Nor did they confirm that
7"\ \'· !(! 0f :)i;
·1 tc thP ; 1\-e fro111 the State
of a11d 11pon 8){fl1.l1.Htc:;tion of .. r;.: ;.s l1"].}'
investigational opinion, shareci by Sheriff, that forgcTy and. {mud
been :n key ideiTdi:y records, 1nclP.ding President Obama's
bug-l'crm biith c.ertiflcatc; Us cctnpuier;zcd short -fonn birth Dis
.Selective .Sc:)nice Registration care\.
19, 'fhe ·Cold Case Posse !1as alsc ucted that iJbnrna· s fi!_·st l"IYc 0 rdt:l';
i.f>SU.cct h·is HS to •:;tf
',·o.,ords Cr0n
1
j)llhlic StT\.Ttiny. Documeni:ation that is not :wailable for !vlr
in..;:_'lH .. L2·
1
:: .UUi Glll_;-' J.iiS J:jr;
rr:;rorc1s, J,]c; ;1doption records, hi,:;; kii1dergarten records, his Pl:nahou
scl1ool i.·ccor(.:ls, hts ()c.cidettta: \:;(;liege reLo1·ds, .cds
records, his Cobmbia U;;ivcrsity []lcsis, Jds Law record:.;,
his Harn;.rd Law ::tevie1v artide.s, his scholr.rly arddcs fJ:o1n U1e lki•;ersity
OJI: t'i.1l.('r.l''' J.!-ds ')C'""l'CJ+<;; h'r '1!"'dli''"i ror•ol'O" 't·li'· -1"rom i1J's ''1";'1'0: '
1
"" ''\1 \...· _t.l.
0
1_,.., .J.-• 1-0:1:'-''' J .t.. Lv; ... _J_•:J L ......\.; •. -<....(.t .._..... -·"-'; •.•• ) •• ,_, __ ....... "- ·'- j "-!..- u (• 1:J !!
l1linois Senator, his Stnte BaT Association recol'C:s.
!_'he t1l.eH. H.ef)tlbliceJI ; __jngle, statPd. (lt.trillg ac
Oi.l Ne>.\. Yorh.'s \VABC Ladio iJ.J. 2.co8 in an i:o quell the Hirth
Cerdfic<.:i:c issue she liad the Dirth Certi.tiente i.nspected by the sh:.lc's
(f.
:2. t. Liugle i.s I had !H:: l.1.eai.th (l!l'PecorJ !S a pi1) sician. !Jy
go \'ieY·: LLc 1Ji.eUI rceord:1 of
the Depiutm.ent of Health, <:,nd we issued a Dews rel.ease <lt time
sa\'"hH:r tl1c pre::>ident '\\
1
rtS i11 :rL :-fc.:;pi.tnl 1n
l-la··.\'UiL 's j L:si. a r{JCL yet con.til1U.e to ca1J ll1J
Rnd e-luail a:).d \\·ant to aw.te it r.n 1ssne and T ir's again a horrible
{c-:-.:..· __.- _ \'.'be
()ctober 3.1. :2cc8, \be
statement: '"L'here have been nur..1erous rec:uest:; for ,':Jen. l3arac.k
()bcJ!l1a's officiai 1)i£tl'l h_1\'\'" (_:. -1 a,.vni'l l:Zevised
§;:)38 .. J8) prohibits the of:', bi.rth ccrtitlc;Yl'C i-c pcrso;.1s \\hO
do 11ot haYe CL te.t1gibie iJJ.tere.st irl t:hc y1tat T1"Jerefore:. :
·

oi" -;erSU ... \
l
,,,_!)''"tJ-'r. 1•1· '...fn·.' ,1'-]1 ],.,,. ('"'!' ;-.J,,I)rl "' ·· r,1 .• ;aina
1
hirth ecr •ificat"' record
./o:.._.<,l .. •. · ... /..}.'-''-!. t .re-t•:'> I.)\.· L.\ .C..J! .•. •• 1 .... ··•····· · ._ . .._ __
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 39 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 7 of 16
:.>9. "It \\'!"IS \\TilteD, f mn told, this is what our im estigation i$
shm-.ing, it acttmlly ex1o;;ts in the archives, \\'rittcn down," Abercrombie
SUld.
30. the Yet-undisdosc'<i birth m the s tate archives thal
Al1ercrombie saic had 'Jecn discovered may lw:ve come h·mll th8
grand parents registering Obama'.s biri.h, ci:eni: that <mtmnatici:
1
lj
have triggered both the birth announcements and m·ailabilit-y
of " Ce1tificatim, of Live niri:h, even if no long--form bi•tb ceititlcatc

?,1. 0•!1' i1wes-tigation has re•:ealed that in 1961, as Hawaiian law then stood,
Obama's grandparents, Stanley and Madelyn Dunham, could la•.\fLtily haYe
-nadc t.i.1l :11-pcrson report oi H:m-niian ;Ji;ti1 if the ini'ant ?,nrack
Obama ,Jr. oeen foreign-Lorn.
32- Tb::: newspaper annOl'!lcemcnts of :Mr Obama's birth dc1 not prm c l,.e v .. as
born in Hawaii, since they could bave l1ecn triggered by the gra'ldparents
regisi.cring the birth as Hawaiian. They might then have paid fr)r the
ani!ClE1C<.''1'emc
33. HowcYel', n-e have leamcd i:hat it was not uncommou for Joc.:1.l newspapers
to publish birth announcement puid for by individuals reporling the birth
in the lom.l f)aper, e\·en if the c.hild was born elsewhere. If so, the
rcgish·ation of an out-of-country birLb as Hawaiian would have been
reporlec in the same wa_) as ti-,e o-r an :!1- cou:i.1:!'y birth.
Neither of the two ad,·e1tisemcnts states that Obam;:; born in a
particulm· hospital. Both gh'e limiter i.1formution.
34. To dal::: the purpmted undiselosecl birth record in the state archh'es th<.'t
Abercrombie has claimed to bavc discovered and has described as being
"actunlly w;·ittcn'' has never been i.11ad.c pllblic. tieing locai.cd in the state
Ei.'ch:,-i:'!.>, this should be available tor inspection by i:he general
public '.lithout restraint.
36· From Abercrombie's admission, it is legitimate w infer thai: l:nis recon.t, ii'
it indeed exists, was not h1 the possession of i.he Hawaii Department of
Health, \\hich haYe hau no reco:·cl. of i he. in-cmcni:ry birth of l\llr
Obam;_1 either i.n hard copy fnrm, such as long foi.· rn bhth cerlificalc,
prc:SCl\'ed b. Ls \'tult ns rlescri'J::c: :.>y ::::-:.· C,
1
·ym!,i.:! Fddilo. ' f a
document had existed, Abercrombie \mulcl have had it within minui:es of
his request.
c.
v
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 40 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 8 of 16
36.1V!.r 0h.m:t's lon!:';-form birth "·mild have been preserved in a
hard·em·ered bound ,·olu1ne along '.dth the othe: long form iJirth
certificai.es of that period. rhis record wonld ha\'e beer easily accessible to
the ')cpartD't>ni· of lenlth upon lhc GoYernor's request, had i'· existed.
Dr. Cbiyome Fukino also gave an intervie,,· to C:NN on Apri1 26, 0.011, in
\\1 ic 1 she statr:d d1at s ;<' simply <\eHt r· ,lo '·ne vm,lt ta;C ;ilsp::ctec1
Obama's origi 1at 131t'Lh 2crtificnte. i';.i·eren'i:ia 1y, L sh(mld h<'Ye ))eeP thnl
easy for Governor Abercrombie to lor.atc it as well.
38.'fhis circumstance also suggests that the birth i'ccord of Mr Obama "as
not at that time recorded in the Dcparlrncnt of Health's computerized
database thal has been in usc since :w01.
39- Tn March 2012, Sheriff .Arpaio held a Press Conference during wbicn he
ancll p•·esentcd an outline of those as peels of the investigation thnt v,·ould
not compromise the safely of witnesses or the integrity and futnrc course
ol Lhe inYestigatiO<l. At th<1t time, we had conclnded that thel'c was
prou<>.b'c ti'::'.t ,_.argery anr1 r,·:mcl had been conL:.Jiti:cd in respect of
fou; doc.uments: the long-form ot o1iginal birth certific1tc :for !.tli' Cbam<1,
which contained multiple errors and anomalies, many of them scr.ious; the
short-form computer-generated abstract of Mr Obama's biJth rec<w1 thai:
the Democ.:-atic <>:.trty hnd published b '.W07, \'.'hid: "·as printerl Lising a
foi'm cf ... o,·cls net -::nrrcnt at the relevant date; the selectivc-serviee
document for 1\IIr Obama, which coni aine<i a two-digit yem-stamp contrary
tc written by the :)e!1<Ltment of Defence to the effect
the year of issnc should be expressed as four on 'i:hc stamp, anc:
contr8:·y to any othe; sclertin•-setTit.:e t'egistrCJtion documePt thnJ wP- l'..a\'e
able to exe:,cuir c; and ···c <.l.J'e <'.wDre tm·.·. Uie soda'
w} ic11 has a prefix that at the date o.C issue was uniqne to Connecticut cYen
though "·;ir Obama has 11e\·er resided in that State.
40.In an attempt l:o \'erify ;dwther Mr Obama and his mol.het· bad anh•eclm
the ULited States at or around the alleged c
1
ate of
1
115 bi1th, we
the i·ational Archives to obtain micmfilms of the I-94 immigration
landing records for the year 1961. All sad. ,·ecoi·ds were a•1d ai'C m'nilaole
fo1· entire year 1Q6J, cxcepl for those on the alleged date ofJVlr Obama's
birth V•ug;us·;: 4), th ·ee da) S before ·'!a·i: Ciate, cUd. i·h<'C? day::; <rrtei" i.htti:
d:.1te. The Archi\'ist and his staff did not: tell ns how the missing records
•.::om.e to be 1ost, r:nd offered nc that would ever come to
li3ht.
11. Aftf'r three :nonths of further investigation, the Sherif/ held a second pn'ss
confere:r;.:.:e w acnoun:..:e, with sup}Jort, 1t 1V 1o.1ger r qLtes:ion
of probB.ble cause: it was now certain that the document on the vVhiLe
7
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 41 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page g of 16
House wns a forgery. Sheriff also mmounced that the
in \ 'Ol,;Ci co;1tiime: it he.!> conti.1neL' eve! si:1ce.
The purpose of ltolding press conferences was and ii> i:o uotif)· the
1
Jublie
thul UJl is lll wilh the ajm obtaining ad•i.itiono.l
information that might De helpful to the investigators in reachi•1g the
As a re_;u:t of hoi:i1 p::ess confc'l'cnccs, addi.t1cll.r"' JP.aterir I of
ldnc
1
bernme to us.
43· Our investig<ttion concludes that ..:'resident 0bmna's lung-form birt:1
certi(icale is a computer-generated document; that ic was ma'mtactured
ylecemenl ann cmd that it d1d l•l't orig
1
1H1tc as f, copy of a
c:·ue paper frcm_ <'- ,·olume, :1::; chmneci the "Vhitc House
and by the Governor of Ha\\aii <nd hy the director of tl1e Healih
Depan·nent, cited in a press release issued April 2'1, ·w 11, by the Governor
to v.ith the publication of the documcnl on Lhc V{hile House
\\·ebsitc.
44. Most importantiy, "registrar's starnp" in the C'omputer-gcnemted
document re1eased hy V
1
lhite House and posted OL the \Vhite House
website have been impori:ed from another unknown source
doc1:mer•L The fact that the stamp cannot have been placed ou the
• pul'..:Lt'"l. · u si.alc and ir,YS is one of m.£my
that the document is a torgery aud, Lltercfore, Ll1at it cr.nnot be reE::d. upm1
as" crifiration, or othcnvise, of the date, place or circumstances of ?v'!r
Ollama's birth.
4 . ...;. The date-stamp exhibited a similar grave anomaly, allowing it
lo LG tOYed a the docnnent- \\ :1icl. \'.o .. tl•J have
been impossibk 1ftnc document were t11.e scanned cerc;.fied CO:i_)Y that
official stateme',ts profess ii to be. The Registrar's signature-stamp und
date-si:amp i,-erc computcr-ge11erated images that ·we•·e imported into the
document. T1·ey were not e1ectro:·Ic Image'" of actual rubber-stamp
imprints inked by hand or machine 011 to a paper document. According!;,
the documPnt on the vVhite Ilouse website is, at a minimum, m.h;leading i:o
th2 public in that it hr1s no legal import P.l!d. eanuot be .·elied _ljJon as a
legal doeuo.ent carrring the full faith and credit of the State of Hm·-aH and
the date, place and other circumstances of Mr Obama's birth ... \.
photograph of the Registrar's cbte-stamp is exhibited and marked
L!6. These and numerous other errors and anomalies obse•Tecl afler cxtcnsiYc
forensic scrutiny of the elcci.ronic in1age dnwnloaded from the Whi:e
Hm1sc website were inconsistent \\ith fealwes to he expected when a
papel' dccument is placed 011 the g1r.ss plate of a scanner so that it can be
captured as an electro-photographic image, or when iL is scanned and then
8
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 42 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 10 of 16
processt'd either to enhance i:he dm:ii.y of ·i:he image by opncD' dmi«cte·,·
rccogeilion or to reduce file--size by file-comprc:-;si0n. or optimizn.tion.
47· Furthe:·h1g the investigation, l returned to for a secomi time. I met
Mr Duncan Sunahara, lhe brother of Virginia S1mnhara, nn infant born in
Hawaii on August 4, the alleged date of Mr Obama's birth there. Ivis
Sunahara di.ed the follo\dng clo.y; !.•.Llgust &, bl'eathi;Ig difficulLies.
\A/hen I met M" Sm1E1hara he had recently apphcd to the Department of
Bea\1"11 i:1 Ha1 ·aii i:or r· ot hts oeceased s1ster's cerl.i.ficate. He
lold me ihe Depmtment had gone to great lengths Lo deny him a copy cf
the original long-form birlh certificate that a close :·dative is entitled
law to request a nil tl e Jepartment is obliged by law to supply. The Cold
Case Posse is compelled lo consider the question why this little girl'::; 1961
long-fo.cm birth ce1tificate ,,·as so disconcerting to the Hawaii Department
of He2.lth that ii: did not "ish I o issue a copy to Mr Sunahara upon request.
48. I obi:ained from Mr Sunaharu a copy ot in the Circuit Court of
the Circuit, State l-'nwaii, 111 ''hich ··-he Deputy Attomt=.) General,
Ms r
7
agam!ne, appeared before fudge Rhonda rJJ::;himura on Marcil 8,
2012, to argue that Mr Sunahma .ms nol e1rLit1ed under Hawaiian statute
law to see, still less obi:ain, a certified copy of his deceased sister's original
1961long-form certificate.
49· During the prut:eedings, tbc Attorney General ilnplied. Mr Sunahara's
request arose from an uuderl. ing imerest in obtainmg e\ ideucc that
assist in deten,1ini;1g '-'·hether the documenl on the \Vhii:e House websi"'.:e
is indeed n forgery. .\Jagamine said lVIr S1.wahura ought: to be satisHed
\\ a sho'·'·-f·m:l of the lJi!'i.h reeorrl rather J·ban a long-form
printed image of the original copy in the bounil Yolume for 3 96 t in tlte
vnults ofthc Health Depa:tment.
so.M::; l\'"agamine also said that the \'oh. me of birth ce1tificates
inferentially contabing not only Ms Sunalumt's 1ong-for:n bi1-th
ce1tiftcate Ot..L abo those of t\\ins born at about the same date had been
remo\'ecl to a special, seeurc lceation 'ii"ith very lb1itcd access. I do not
know what purpose the Depmtment o: Hedth had in presen·ing these
records at ail, unicss it '.\as w sho ,, upon n::t
1
L,cst i:o ITle.nbe:;:;
< nd others - such as hl\\ enforcement - ·wi.;.;, a lr,gitimatc and stai.ulor:.
interest in the doclll!lcni.s.
SL ·Vis 1Jagamine said that accessing i:he origmal biiti·J ecord::, 1.<: ·:; Cli{liccllt
and cxucns1ve. lim\-e\·er, i.rt Dr. Chiyomc Fnkino's with CN. r she
stated that she simply went into vault ;mel inspected Obama's original
Birth Cettificai.c. r am told by Mr Snnnhara thai: he was l.o p8y any
·r·r .sm1:.1blc fee i:c coyc=:r tl1e cost. Onr im·esligalion indicates that the
9
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 43 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 11 of 16
Health Deportment's fee is not great: attomeys for Obama had paid SIO
for a certified copy and S4 for a second certified copy. Inferenlially, sucb
small fees are an indicstion thai the difficdty of consulting Prchives
and generating cettified copies is not great. An<.l I have come across furlhcr
eYidPnce that the difficulty of consu ting the records is not very great: for
they are normally in bound volumes on spcciaHy-dcs1gned shelves
lmown to libr<>.rians as "stacks". i\. picture o.f: Mr Onaka pulling ot,t a book
of birth records from 1972, just nine years aft-er the year th..-.t is of interest
to our im·estigatiotl, shows hm\· smail the difficulty in commlting the
records js likely to be. The photograph is marked ":VlZl'', annexed and
signed as relatiYe hereto .
.52. The
1
'C:'8son "·hy investigators Hrish to cx<:J T · ne 'ltc
ot'iginallong-form birth ccL'ificate of 1vJs Sunahnm to tbe practice
c< the

:.o !lnnbcr c···ch birth r:cJtifkatc sequcntinll\·
with the last hm digits of the yem follmvecl by a iiYc-digit number
1tir. ·)y :.1 dr.tc-si:a1:::p thnt the coulter by .,
a{'t'3r "'VE'ry shnnuing. At (hat time, 8.pproximately 48 lmths occurred evety
rlay m Ihw;D;J, and \\·ere required to be registered. '.'l1ey \\'C''e sequentiaHy
ill of cl ·-.. _te cfl)iri·h.
;;3. nhotostat il·1ages of the Long-form birth certific<ltes of t\\in
daughters born to Eleanor Nordyke at Kapi'olani flospital August 5, 1961,
one da·· after the alleged birth of M1· Ohan1a at the sr me ]'.ospital, hr-rre
bee'1 drr,wn to the Cold Case Posse's attention. They had been pHoJished in
···he LdYertiser. As a rc:mli uf 8YC-l.l11llli'lg Lhese images, the Cold
Case Pusse :m.s reason to suspcci. thai the sequential nmnl)el' on Lhc
shmt-form abstract that the Heaith Dcpmtment
released to the fmhily is noi lhe same as that whkh appears on the wng-
form original bi1th ce1tifi.cate that issued Mt> Sunahara.
54. Examination of the certificates issuec.l to the parents of 'he Nordyke
twim .., shows tlwl their l·egi:stration numbers, 6
1
/10637 and. :0638,
precedrcl the number on Mr Obama's shori..-form and long-form
certificates, ·which is shmm as 61/W641, even though he ,,·as born a day
earlier than lhey were. Ms Sunahara \n1s born A<.igust 4, 1961, and
c.eJ.tificate \Yas stamped b" · the Hawaii registrar August 8, bvi. her number
no8·:). T.l1c -:;,lrtmarizes the positio_1:
N::::.ne of "hild Da·i:e and time born Registered Certificate #
Barack Obanw 1\ng 4 at pm J\ng 3 10641
Virginia Sunaham Aug 4 at 9:16pm Au[,:;O 11080
Susan Nordyl-e Aug 5 <ll 2.:12 pm Aug i 10637
Grelchen Nordrke Aug 5 at 2:17pm 1\..ur, 11
10
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 44 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 12 of 16
55· Mr Obama's birlh certificate' W<1S registered August 8, ·1961. The Nordyke
twins' birth ce1tifice1te was ··egistered August 1 1, .. 96 '· Even if the
sequential numbering had followed date of registralion rather t'wn the
date of bi.rth, iv1r Obama's certificate should haw been automajeally
assigned u number wwe., noi. higher, i.hm. tnc number:; allocated ·c ·:he
certificates of the Nordyke t\'lins. And the number currently assigned 'Co
Ms Sunah; ra is enl.irdy Ol.il of sequence.
56. One possible explanation for the out-of-sequence sen al numbers mig hi.
have been that several serialized piles of birth ceJ'tificates were registered
P.t cif'erent hospitcis. Howe\·er, Ms Verna K. Lee, <m offieial responsible
for the recording of births in Honoluln in ·961. when intcnie\\·ed by a
rcpo•t<Cr fm 1md.com, said that this was not the case. lvfs Lee m=ts the local
wno sigl1ed. the docllmenl on U:e N 1 · i.(' ·-lOuse \\·ebsi·t:e
1s possible
7
h<.t t·he l1fted her from au.u'hu· b; Lh
certificnte and inserted it electronically into the compilation
that is now on the White douse wcbsile).
s;. Lee was surprised that the numbers were mtt of sequence. Ivh,. Lee
made recorded statements to a W"ND reporter durint.; a phone intervie,-.. I
hm·e :;_'ersonall.y
1
istencd to Lhosc recordings. On i.hc recorded
conversation Ms. :..ce said that all of the birth ceitii1ca.tes received in a
1:-.opth o'·dered chronologically by date and time o·i bil··i:h and.
numbered sequentially at the end of each mom:b. 1.-.e onl.,· exeep-i·i.-m- not
relevant in the present case- was that birth cerdfica.tes received fTom i:he
islRnds and from one local out-si.ai:ion in Oahu 'vere t,rm:ped :sevarai.dy, so
a8 not to under-represent births out8idc Honolul\.1 or tmaiteudc0. births
oc•..:t :rrin;_, a[ t, so% sum;les by "·hich. e\'en-
numbcrccl ·sere to the Fecteral as iJ'ard2tcd
hythe C.S. Oft1ce ofVital Statistics.
58. Lee has said that biri:h certificates from the hospitals in Oz.na '' cl'c sent
::iirccdy t<' i.:l:r:o ''l' office or the Dcpnrtn:enL HerJi:h h: Mo:10lu!t!. The
birth cert;ncnta.s y.·ere all numbered at the end or woui.h 0112
person. vVhcn rvis was asked " ·hethcr there mighl have been mistakes
in numberL1g i.he b11 lh certificates, she insisted tht t they \'.·ere numbered
cotTectly nnd in sequence. The long-form original ccrtiHcatcs were
inspccl:c·d :vr:v:: r"or nccnrac.\· h\-":.'':'o ._·Efferent r:leri<.s o..:1d i.hcn

":w
registrar. They were kept iogethel' secured in a ce1tain room until tbcy
\'-·c1·e a• IH'liibered :E i·h2 end ':he mont:1. They ncJ::; Pot to
bPcome out of ol'dcr and were noi· numbered iw.:o•Tedl_y. (il sllou.obc
noted tll<Yi: the 1
1
ordyke t"\\'ins ·were born minutes apart and their respective
c.:ertificate numbering was based not only on clatL: but or timt: as· _.e;l.
indicates i:hc clcrl\ scrutinized the documents prior o pb.cinr; them iil
chror.ological order for proper mnnbering.) Based on l\'Is Lee's
rep1·esentatim., considci' it highly uniike1y thai. a biri.h certificate so far
II
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 45 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 13 of 16
out of se<-lttcnce as that which now appears on Ms Sunahara's sho1t-form
bi r Lh could haYc b2.en accepted at a rcgistl'rtr's office managed by
• K. L'?e.
59· It is also possible that are being misled into CleYoting
attention to i.:he number Oit !vJ._, 0unahara's o'·ig:.m:l Wrlg- foT1
c:etti ncr. i:e, 1•:hici1 m<:y .Jtcr al1 turn out to be c_f from tbat of Mr
Obamn and .identical to that which appears on her shott-form computer
abstract. For that reason among others, inYesbgators wou:d 1tke to iuspcct
and, in clue course, forePsically to examine the volumes of long-form
certificates for 1961, ;,- nd specifically t11e Jong-form birth
celiificates for Ml' Obama, forMs SunahHra, and for the Nordykr-> t\\'ins.
6o.A possibilily that the investigators arc ·trainP-cl to uear in mind, given
the mnncrous other defects in the document on the White House
is ·rhpt the nmP bcr on that document is not a genuine registratio• number
assig.1ed to ]1is birth certificate m 1961, but was issued when the short-
form document \\as gcncrr.tcd rhring the ?008 campaign. lt
is possible that t'.1e Health Depar'.:mcnt does i10t y,.·ant the public to see Lhc
original ·.gvl bi.Th ·ccc;r's becam:P -:-orens1c examil,<.lttml 111igh' c:::t8.l:dsh
that the forgers had made a mistal ...e in assigning to the forged long-form
document on the '·Vhil:e House wel)site a mu11 bcr that was out of seq11cnec
,- nd thc:i: mr.;' (m- 11?Y not) be i.dentical with the nu.mbcr on

long-form
or:ginal birth certificate of Ms Snnahnra. This is one reason why U1e
inwstigators have asked to see the origi!1al brmnd volt. nes from the
stadzs.
() 1. T :-H--t -:,fic;iLionally i:ba!: :
1
··e --a waii 1>::•;ui.ment cf l.'-Iea!i.:i: not
offered any testimony that. the filode;_n compL i..e;:ized now nsed co
the short-form abstracts have bee11 safcgun;·derl from numerical
or otncr data me:uipnhi:io,1 . ..;:1 tLrt the AttOi.',1e) 8cncr2.i uf 1'<:--. clii
offered to the Mc\J'icopa County Sheriffs Office fiS proof that Mr Obnma
was bon1 in llawai1 was a computel·-genewLet: list :.:;r .·pgi;-;",-a-;lons
that \\as contained in a ring-biL<.ier. Pages could easily be .o,:cc, added,
or rem.oved, altered ai1Cirei::.1serted ut wilL There "as no level of security
other than closing the rings of the holding the pages i:ogcther.
62.The in·:cstigators ha\'e obtained au affidavit from an indiYidual wno ·went
tc t he Depa _, l:•c;'t ')l I realth v:hen :.-::on!e of the t1
1
'St questions \'\Cl'C being
raised about M r Obama's bil th ce1tificate. That indhidual states tl1<t:L w .1en
he fits'i.: \\·e·1: 'u' -: ··p r:."ain olii;:'.:' of t1•P
1\'fr Cba111<)'s nr Tie did noi: nppe:.u· ;;1 J:'.,e colnp;_li:2d 7.eci
reg1stratwn lisl in the ri11g iJiauer, but when he: wen'· approXItllatc:y
14- days later to re-examine th, .same list he '.vas sur;)l'Iscd to see that :\1r
Olnmw.'s na!!lC HC\\. or; it.
12
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 46 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 15 of 16
anginal birth certif1cates or l9ti1 ;:nod the birth records kept by
Kapi'olnni Tlospi-i:al Fm that year. Ii: shou1d be noted that forensic :->.xperts
are trilin<>d in ;-l,e matmgeliie,tl. and prescrYation of papt>r records, and
\\'ou1d cs.1 ...,e PO c1anEt;5e to i:nc rB"<WOR L1 G:c cou1sc o · i'1ei:·

daycf
2.012,
in Maricopa CountY, Ari7ona.
/
.::=------·-
Michaei Zullo
Sworn to and subsrTibed before me
}0!2
this
' C J;\Gi(Sot'
' '· - ""' .. .. . .

': r.ot_••l' Fubl:c- A
.. lari".op;; Counly
_,..9' 'Ay Gromn. (r.pirrs Jun 3. 2015
14
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 47 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5 Filed 12/14/12 Page 14 of 16
6:1 '-Totwithstflnding this aftida,it, it 1s plausible Lhal an original birth record
for Mr Obama exisi:s in Hm\:1ii. 011r '1
1
Vestigation has discovcied i.hai: at
thnt tirr.c l-!a\',;aiian l?.''' a specific prmision that permitted a
Hawaiian parent of a child born any1vhcrc in the

or any adult
!Wrporti'lg to represent that the right to regisLer the child CJS
Hmraiian-born. It is for iliis reason that t·wo entries in the colu1nn
L.i.' i·h._,

!1)Ppr!rs at the t:r•l:: Jo n.ot constitute evidence that
Obama 1vas born in Hawaii. They are merely 8Vidcnce snggesting that a
birth ce1tificate ,\·as issued for him in and they (ell liS I<oi.hing
a'Jo:..::: • or not he was bor11 l' parti-:!nlar t' ev cio not- as the
Et:ousc clocw 1c>nt purpmts to de;- idei1ii l)' th2 hos1)hal of IJif:h.
64.If lVn· Obama had not in fact been born in Ilawah, the long-form original
ce:tificr,tc ',1."01..11(
1
!iOL
1
H'c ·r, stned tiwt 11c lind be::c :.>ur11 in a
pcnt1cnlar hospital at ,, time, and wc:uld not hnve ;_orne :he
signatures of the at.Lcnding physician and registrar. The newspaper entries
'\'OUld ha\'C been identical whei.her he hac: in Ol"
elsewhere in the world; .:mt the 1 ecords 'muld not been
identical
65. The existe11Ce of this law permitting out-of-country births to be reg1s'ccrcd
as though they were Hawaiian bhths is a furthel' ·ec1son wit.> t.he 3heriff
wishes his forensic to be given access to the ol'iginal hmmd
YohnTtes o: bitth certificates for 1961, and to be permitted to carry out
forensic sc1Ltiny of the vollllnes a:1d of ceetain indhiduai cenific:at,.;s,
includmg that of l.Vlr Obama.
66. For these reasons, it b for ttle investigators to bca1 ill mind the
possib:Iit.l' that the intention of the Bmvmi Depmtment of Health in
refusing to allo''' ivi r hz.ra to haYe a cer:ified copv of the original bi1th
cert.ificat<" of his deceased sister is to conceal foi'gery and ,,-itl1in tl1e
De!JRI :·mcnt itself.
67. T71e Cold Case Dosse's law-enforcement investigation iuiu Mr Obanw's
butl1 ce:t C01ltL11 es, t:1ki 1tg ae.:.:oLEll. the additicna1
obtained iJoth as a result of t:H; Cold Case Posse's o;,m enquiries a.-td as a
rcsull of assistance from the public following the publication o1 some of
011r results b) the Sheriff al the Ivwrch and July 201? press conferences.
68. The 1aw-.enforcement ill':csLigalion by and 011 be:1alf of the Sheriff of
lVTaricopa County, Arizona, would be nssisted, and could be
brought S\\ iftly, inexpensively, and decisiYely to c.n end, if the D<"p8;·tmeat
of Health and the managcll1ent of i:he l(01piola11i Hospital were nilling to
allow comt-recogni7.ed hrensic. experts selected by Lhe Sheri.ff of Maricopa
County to inspect and forenskally exatl'inc the \'Olumes of long-form
J 3
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 48 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m
Case 3:12-cv-00280-HTW-LRA Document 87-5
J\t1Z2
I
I
I
I
I
I._
• .: •. • .L
J ... _.!.
, -
.... ....,
. ""
' ..
..... .... -.----
,. ·:- .
..
.
.. ,.,,
...
•_! !:.""'
I
. .c, , , r
...............
. ,
Filed 12/14/12 Page 16 of 16
.;."\·r •
..
- 1
I
..
·-
-,_
. --
LJ
,-,
' '
....
__j
Thi< is the imngt:. r..:ll:rrcd to in !11) aftidavit in SziJ;ulwr(l!'. Hc•ll'aii. ot' the ·•long-form b'nll cenilicate·· for
:\rlr Obama. l"ith the •c!!,btrar·s signc.ll<rc-sLHl p illlll. separ<!lely. t;1c r.::gistrar'<; t.lal-:-sH'l!ilp n'o\ ed li'Oil1
their originnl ln:mions 0;1, 1'lt: .. CCitific'lte". which indicated 0) \·.:lit.: ghost imuges towards the "oot or
the paper on io 1·:hich rhc i'abric<llcl' h<1d been elecmmtcal'y Thm
Crttc stWltp t!n ..· .. s texu c·\:ated r-o
vbj..;cls into ()bc11iil1 t1ir7il • on ·.1e ··J L11,_5·· f1"'11ioJl i·1
the ''\Vintlm-.·· mem; in .:\tlnb.; I.Iustrator. ., he inset imagt: at top right is tile list or lin!<<; that ili-JjJCilrs 1,\'hCrl
tim, option is <wh·;nccl. [vidence thtl !lit.. . '' o r.:gislrar stamps are external obiects impmiec1 into tho.: Ob<:ma
.. binh docu•ncnt'· can he in that tht: rcgistmr's dale swmp anJ stamp can c•asily :11td
he PlOYed. rotated at" 'I!. lt:rncd

or c\ell up.;ide-do\\,1. ant: r.;p<'sition.:d
anywher.: OJ! ill•: \one u'· scvc.-al humlr.:d soti:'sare for ;nc nutonmtet! optir·;d-
charactcr n.:cognirion. in age enl•ancement. "il.:: or npii1l'izario:1 or an clcc:ro-pho•ographic
image oJ an nrigim:l paper documt>m ,hat \\.:rc 'tuuicd and hy ''-.:pen cu!lsullams "'the in•:.:stigativc
team was capable ,,r the elecn·onic data the image i:J suet· " numnet as to store
data reprl!senting either or the tl•.o on a single .. layer" so as 10 ullow stamp' to be mo\cd abou:
l1 '· '.' i ! I.
Michael Zulto.---·-?
(/ - ,9 --<

Date
16
Case: 13-60024 Document: 00512108933 Page: 49 Date Filed: 01/10/2013
F
r
i
e
n
d
s

o
f

T
h
e
F
o
g
b
o
w
.
c
o
m

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->