irsfs2 psvihD2
rehgy2
f2
xxFE2
~`bE
GEF42 IAD2E92
D2
I2
x2
XQW2
`XII~~X52
Pkgd2
F2
dD2
`FE2
cB4~2
Q2
Y`E 2 F2
`2 `92
I2
x 2
EDfYE2
he2hn2vw2pirmDp3gF2
iisixgi pyw2 fixips2 y2
92
{9W2
wrh2 RD2PHIQ2
hoketing2hivision2 he2 ronorle2 edministrtive2vw2 tudge2oy2 qF2uddy2 tte2yfe2 of2 edministrtive2rerings2 FyF2fox2IQHPS2 eustinD2exs2UVUIIEQHPS2
eX2
rnd2 i2 helivery2
her2 tudge2uddyX2
inlosed2 plese2 nd2espondents2wotion2for2ummry2hisposition2 nd2xotie2 of2 sntent2 to2 se2 hisovery2roduts2 hisposition2roeedingF2 fy2 xot2 on2pile2in22ummry2 opy2 of2this2 letterD2 e2re2 forwrding2 2 opy2of2this2 doument2to2 the2 etitioner2 through2 ounselF2 lese2feel2free2to2ontt2the2rm2 questions2 hve2ny2 t2the2numer2 ontined2ove2should2you2 or2onems2 regrding2this2mtterF2 hnk2 for2your2 time2nd2ssistne2in2this2mtterF2 you2
inerelyD2
keeldD2vegl2essistn2
u2
he2 hn2 pirm2 g2 y2 vw2 fox2SHPPU2 eustin2 exs2UVUTQ2 fx2 wwwFplinlwustinFHm @SIPA2UVWEQVWH2phone2 @SIPA2WHRESSIT2
|2 |2 |2 |2
inlosures2
uGskw2
X2
glient2@vi2eEmilA2
I2
FdFDu7PiiX7iSB2
2 2 wyid2 sjl2
IIYE2
D2
t2
XII42 `Q2 v2 F~~aa2 2 DFFF2 aF~wB~2 SIF2 DDF2 D2 S42 4E2 igD2 I3t`2
F2
F2
9i|2
F2
imlXi2
9I2
sx2rf2
F2
P2
S2
s2
ehwsxsesi2 riesxq2
hsyssyx2 ygiihsxq2
iyxhix2 wysyx2 py2 wwe2 hsyssyx2 exh2 xysgi2 yp2 sxix2 y2 i2 hsgyi2 yhg2 psvi2 xy2 sx2 yx2 e2 wwe2
y2ri2 ryxyefvi2ehwsxsesi2 ve2thqi2exh2ri2ryxyefvi2 ie2 fyeh2 yp2 xsxqX2
se2 hisovery2 roduts2 xot2 on2 pile2 in2 2 ummry2 hisposition2 roeedingF2
espondent2moves2for2finl2 deision2in2her2fvor2on2summry2disposition2ithout2evidentiry2
heringF2 espondent2 would2respetfully2show2 the2ourt2s2followsX2
sF2
IF2
ttement2of2wteril2ndisputed2pts2in2upport2of2wotion2for2pinl2heision2on2ummry2
hisposition2 nd2 xotie2 of2 sntent2 to2 se2 hisovery2 roduts2 xot2 on2 pile2 in2 2 ummry2
espondents2wotion2for2ummry2
hisposition22 ge I2
espondents2 equests2 for2 hislosureF2 his2 disovery2 is2 intended2 nd2 used2 in2 support2 of2 espondents2wotion2for2ummry2 hispositionF2 espondent2filed2the2forementioned2tthed2
ixhiit2t2the2sme2time2she2filed2her2wotion2 for2ummry2 hispositionF2 espondent2serves2this2
notie2nd2the2tthed2disovery2produts2on2 ll2prtiesF2
QF2
ll2purposes2 the2followingX2
F2
effidvit2 of2 eres2 enn2furrisD2 vFFxFD2 FxFD2 dte2 wrh2 ID2 PHIQD2
@furris2effidvitAY2
F2
F2
true2 nd2 orret2 opy2 of2 wedil2 eords2 of2 tient2 hgt2xumer2
wedil2
eordsAF2
dF2
true2
nd2 orret2 opy2 of2 porml2 ghrges2 dted2 eptemer2 SD2 PHIPD2
tthed2t2ixhiit2fF2
eF2
PHIPD2tthed2t2ixhiit2gF2
fF2
true2
ytoer2PWD2PHIPD2tthed2t2ixhiit2hFI2
gF2
I2
f2
hF2
perury2UD2PHIQD2tthed2t2ixhiit2pF2
iF2
jF2
true2
perury2PSD2PHIQD2tthed2t2ixhiit2rF2
kF2
true2nd2orret2opy2of2 tient2gre2eport2prepred2y2engel2gre2
emulne2ervieD2snFD2 with2effidvit2of2tessi2qrz2dted2perury2
IQD2PHIQD2tthed2t2ixhiit2IFP2
RF2
he2etitioner2@lso2 nd2interhngely2hereinfter2s2fordA2omplins2tht2
to2 prtie2 professionl2 nursing2 in2 n2 eptle2 professionl2
onsistent2with2puli2helth2nd2welfre2nd2violted2her2stndrd2of2re2y2filing2to2initite2
wsF2furris2filed
2
F2
F2
F2
to2re2dequtely2for22ptient2or2to2onform2to2the2minimum2 stndrds2
dishonorle2 ondut2 thtD2 in2 the2 ords2 opinionD2 is2 likely2 to2 deeiveD2 defrudD2 or2 injure 2
ptient2 or2the2 puliF2 ee2iF2yggF2
eond2emended2 etition2t2ixhiit2qF2
P2
SF2
ondut2y2 wsF2furris2in2tht2she 2
F2
F2
filed2to2initite2rdiopulmonry2resusittion2@gA2 for2
TF2
the2ptient2of2timely2resusittion2effortsF2
ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2qF2
UF2
sn2 esseneD2 the2 ford2 is2 tking2 the2 undenile2 position2 tht2 2 registered2 or2
professionl2nurseD2who2 responds2to2n2unwitnessed2rrest2of22ptient2tht2does2not2hve22vlid2
do2not2resusitte2@hxA2orderDQ2my2 not2exerise2judgment2nd2mke22deision2to2withhold2
rdiopulmonry2resusittion2 @gA2upon2n2evlution2nd2ssessment2of22ptient2y2tht2
nurse2 despite2 linil2 signs2 supporting2 inppropriteness2 or2 futile2 interventionY2 hereD 2
determintion2of2inppropriteness2or2futility2sed2upon2presumptive2nd2onlusive2signs2of2
deth2tht2 were2presentY2 the2 ltter2 eing2livor2 mortis2 nd2rigor2mortisF2 ut2nother2wyD2the2
g2
Q2
sn2response2to2iF2 F2gsF2F2 IWRFP@AD2etitioner2providesD22the2ft2tht2the2ptient2 hve2expired2 my2 prior2to2her2 wsF2furris2disovery2re2not2ftors2tht2would2relieve2espondent2of2 her2duty2to2initite2potentilly2 lifesving2interventionF2 espondent2should2hve2 lled22gode2 to2ttempt2resusittion2of2 the2ptientF2@imphsis2
F2 F2 F2
R2
ddedAF2
will2not2e2initited2in2the2sene2of22
seD2 disounts2 informtion2 lerned2 y22 professionl2 nurse2 during2 2 omprehensive2 nursing2
ssessment2nd2disounts2other2irumstnes2nd2ssessments2tht2ould2influene2 2deision2
espondent2 knowledges2tht2 the2 ultimte2 issue2 in2 this2 se2 t2 the2 ontested2
who2does2not2hve22vlid2hx2 orderEEto2withhold2resusittion2sed2on22determintion2tht2
espondent2 provides2 tht2 sed2 on2 the2 undisputed2 fts2 she2 is2 entitled2 to 2
deision2 in2 her2 fvor2 s2 2 mtter2 of2lw2euse2 the2 ford2 nnot2 ddue2 ny2 dmissile2
ee
I2
IHF2
he2mteril2undisputed2fts2of2 this2se2re2s2followsX2
F2
wsF2furris2holds22liense2s22votionl2nurse2nd22professionl2nurse2
in2the2tte2of2 exsF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QF2
hisposition22 ge S2
espHndents2wotion2 for2ummry2
yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
F2
yn2wrh2PPD2PHIID2wsF2furris2ws2employed2s2nd2s2ting2only2in2
the2 pity2 of2 2 liensed2 registered2 or2 professionl2 nurseF2
furris2
effidvit2t2xHF2SF2
dF2
yn2wrh2PPD2PHIID2wsF2furrisD2who2ws2orking2in2the2medil2unit2of2
the2illim2qF2wgonnell2nit2followed2seurity2personnel2responding2
to2n2inmte2hnging2in2the2edministrtive2egregtion2unitD2 2protetive2
wsF2furris2lerned2from2seurity2personnel2tht2there2hd2een22hnging2
involving2n2 inmteF2 furris2effidvit2t2 HF2UF2
x2
fF2
yn2 wrh2PPD2PHIID2t2HRHID2wsF2furris2rrived2t2the2ell2of2n2inmteD2
tient2gFwF2or2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQF2 furris2efdvit2t2xHF2
VF2
gF2
eurity2or2nonmedil2personnel2ere2lredy2present2in2nd2outside2the2
ell2of2 tient2
hF2
eurity2personnel2hd2ut2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2down2prior2to2
wsF2furris2rrivlF2 furris2effidvit2t2xHF2IHF2
iF2
eurity2 personnel2 did2 not2 initite2 ny2 resusittive2 efforts2 on2 tient2
hisposition2E2 ge T2
espHndents2wotion2 for2ummry2
jF2
t2xHF2IPD2PIF2
kF2
lF2
sIF2
wsF2furris2hd2diffiulty2moving2tient2hgt2 xumer2VPVISQ2euse2
of2rigidity2 nd2stiffness2 nd2she2 ould2 not2move2his2 rms2whih2were2
ehind2his2kF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2ITF2
yF2
wsF2furris2oserved2the2followingX2 ligture2mrks2t2the2inmtes2wristsD2
nekD2 nd2 nklesY2 inmte2 ws2 ynotiD2 mottledD2 his2 rms2were2 rigid2
wsF2furrisD2during2the2evlution2nd2ssessmentD2sw2 wht2tient2hgt2
xumer2VPVISQ2looked2like2up2loseD2felt2his2skinD2oserved2the2olor2nd2
depth2of2the2ligture2mrk2on2his2nekD2nd2oserved2the2tul2olor2of2
his2skin2toneF2 furris2 effidvit2t2xoF2IVF2
qF2
espondents2wotion2 for2ummry2
hisposition2E2 ge U2
yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
presene2of2rigor2mortisF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PHY2wedil2eords2
ixhiit2eD2t2ppF2QD2UD2IID2ITF2
s4
F2
wsF2 furris2 noted2 these2 linil2 signs2 in2 the2 medil2 reordF2 furris2
effidvit2t2xosF2QRD2QSD2QTY2wedil2 eords2ixhiit2eD2pF2IIF2
F2
he2presumptive2signs2of2deth2inludeX2
@IA2ptient2unresponsiveY2@PA2no2
respirtionsY2 @QA2 no2 pulseY2 @RA2 pupils2 re2 fixed2 nd2 diltedY2 @SA2 ody2
xoF2IS@gAY2etitioners2pirst2esponse2to2espondents2equests2for2
hislosure2@referening2osition2ttement2ISFPHA2ixhiit2iF2
tF2
tient2
seondry2to2hnging2nd2livor2mortis2ws2present2on2initil2 ssessmentF2
furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PIF2
vF2
wsF2furris2oserved2nd2determined2tht2the2ptient2presented2with2rigor2
mortisF2furris2effidvit2t2xosF2PPD2PQY2wedil2eords2ixhiit2eD2
pF2IIF2
espondents2wotion2for2ummry2
hisposition22 ge V2
yer2 hoket2xHF2SHUEIQEHUPU
F2
e2onlusive2 sign2 of2 deth2 is2 the2 presene2 of2 livor2 mortisF2
furris2
lood2following2deth2tht2uses22purplish2red2disolortion2of2the2skin2
xo2IWF2
F2
F2
igor2 mortis2 is2 postmortem2 rigidity2 due2 to2 uildup2 of2lti2 id2 nd2
using2myosin2nd2tin2 to2 hrdenF2 smmeditely2 following2dethD2 the2
F2
F2
ddF2
xoF2IUF2
eeF2
ffF2
gVE2
e2 do2not2resusitte2@hxA2is2 2medil2order2tht2must2e2given2y 2
physiinF2 fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PVF2
hhF2
furris2effidvitF2
wsF2furris2withheld2inititing2gF2 furris2effidvit2t2xosF2PSD2PVF2
efter2wsF2furris2hd2determined2tht2there2were2two2onlusive2signs2of2
jiE2
kkF2
g2 ws2initited2on2the2ptientF2 wedil2eords2ixhiit2eD2ppF2PD2
QD2IID2ISF2
llF2
srssIF2
sIIIF2
he2exs2xursing2rtie2et2defines2the2 sope2of22nurses2prtieF2
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IQF2
yer2 hoket2xoF2SHUEIQEHUPU
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IRF2
vong2
erm2
gre2
pilityD2
found2
provides2
t2
hplGGFsIFiilsTF9FpI9glYIgGpylllysIGhiflllD2
nd2
nursing2 ssessmentEEwould2 e2
futile2
esponse2
to2
ttement2ISFPHA2ixhiit2iF2
here2 is2 no2 indition2 for2 g2in2 2 ptient2 tht2 is2 onlusively2 dedF2
fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2PIF2
v2
he2hour2of2 deth2ws2 HRQHF2 tient2gre2 eport2 ixhiit2sF2
e2 ptient2who2 presents2with2rigor2mortis2ndGor2other2onlusive2signs2of2
deth2 suh2 s2 livor2 mortis2 nnot2e2 exposed2 unneessrily2 to2 risk2 of2
furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QPY2fellow2 efdvit2t2xoF2PRF2
F2
mortis2ndGor2hs2other2onlusive2signs2of2deth2suh2s2livor2mortisD 2
ptient2nnot2inur2risk2of2hrm2or2injuryF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QID2
QPY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xosF2PQD2PRF2
F2
e2 ptient2who2presents2with2rigor2mortis2 ndGor2hs2nother2onlusive2
sign2of2 deth2nnot2e2stilized2or2e2exposed2to2omplitionsF2 furris2
effidvit2t2xoF2QQY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xosF2PQEPSF2
E2
yn2wrh2PPD2PHIID2wsF2furris2ws2ertified2 in2edvned2grdi2vife2
upport2@egvAF2 furris2effidvit2t2xoF2PTF2
QFQPIF2
emergeniesF2
effidvit2t2xoF2QUF2
F2
e2withheld2for2situtions2involving2sfety2of2the2providerD22vlid2do2not2
resusitte2orderD2or2rigor2mortisF2 furris2 efdvit2t2xoF2PVF2
dddF2
eeeF2
fffF2
wsF2furris2reD2doumenttion2of2 her2ondutD2nd2linil2oservtions2
were2limited2to2 tient2hgt2xumer2VPVISQD2ws2doumented2on2one2
osion2 of2 wrh2 PPD2 PHIID2 nd2 she2 doumented2 ondutD2 linil2
oservtionsD2 nd2 re2 tht2 ourred2within2 2 spn2of2severl2 minutesF2
furris2efdvit2 xoF2QIF2
sF2
espondent2is2 entitled2 to2 summrv2disposition2euse2the2sttute2uthorizing2disipline2 requires22showing2of2ondut2tht2exposes22ptient2 unneessrilv2to2risk2of2hrm2 nd2ondut2tht2is2 likelv2 FF2 hese2elements2do2not2require 2 to2injure22ptient2 determintion2 on2the2proper2stndrd2of2nursing2reF2 es22mtter2of2lwF2 there2is2 no2
F2 F2
espondents2wotion2for2ummry2
hisposition2E2 ge2IQ2
nd2rigor2mortisF2
IIF2
yers2summry2disposition2rule2sttes2tht2n2evt2my2issue22nl2deision2
evidene2 shows2there2 is2 no2genuine2 issue2 s2 to2 ny2mteril2ft2 nd2 2 prty2 is2 entitled2 to 2
deision2in2its2fvor2s22mtter2of2 lwF2 ee2I2iF2 ehwsxF2
IPF2
rehed2her2stndrd@sA2of2re2s22registered2or2professionl2nurse2for2whih2the2ford2hs2
uthority2 to2 initite2 disiplinry2 tionF2 ee2etitioners2 eond2emended2porml2 ghrgesD2
gorpDIIU2fFFQd2RHRD2RHW2@exF2eppF2
is2
2 ort2orth2 PHHQD2no2
qrnry2rospitl2
petFAF2
ixpert2medil2testimony2
required2 to2 estlish2 ht2 eh2 governing2 stndrd2 of2 re2 is2 nd2hether2 it2 hs2 een2
rehedF2 ee2 rood2 vF2 hillipsD2 SSR2FFPd2ITHD2ITSDITT2@exFIWUUAY2 vgroixD2WRU2FFPd2t2 WSHY2wgomsD2I2 FFQd2t2PSWY2eed2 vF2 qrnury2 rospF2gorpFD2 IIU2FFQd2t2RHWF2
emong2
the2 resons2 expert2 testimony2 on2the2 stndrd@sA2 of2re2 is2 essentil2 is2 tht2 the2 nture2 of2the2
IQF2
he2fordD2s2it2 is2required2to2doD2must2estlish2nd2prove2eh2nd2ll2essentil2
sn2 this2 seD2 etion2
elements2 of2 the2 lim2 for2 ondut2 in2 order2 to2 impose2 disiplineF2
QHlFQSP@A@IHAD2@IQAS2nd2ford2rules2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@gAD2@wAD2@QA@eA@ivA2nd2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAF2
gritil2
he2 essentil2 element@sA2 isGre2 required2 to2 e2 estlished2 nd2 nnot2 e2 ltered2
irrespetive2of2 wht2the2minimum2stndrds2of2nursing2re2my2or2my2not2eF2
yn2 this2pointD2
expert2 opinionD2 lthough2 instrutiveD2 is2 not2 needed2with2 respet2 to2 determining2 hether2the2
essentil2 element@sA2hsGhve2een2metF2
he2ford2nnot2meet2n2essentil2element@sA2sed2
on2the2 provisions2 tht2 it2 ites2 whih2entitles2 wsF2 furris2 to2 2 finl2 deision2 in2 her2 fvor2 on2
summry2disposition2ithout2n2evidentiry2heringF2 sn2shortD22violtion2nnot2e2estlished2
s22mtter2of2 lwF2
he2element2tht2requires2the2estlishment2of2exposure2of22ptient2unneessrily2to2risk2 of2 hrm2 E2 his2 element2 is2 pproprite2 for2 onsidertion2 here2 nd2 does2 not2 require2
rehing2nv2 determintion2on2the2generlly2epted2stndrds2of2 nursingprtieF2
IRF2
etA2providesX2
to2the2minimum2 stndrds2of2eptle2nursing2prtie2in22mnner2thtD2
risk2of2 hrmF2
S2
etion2QHIFQSP@A@IHAD2@IQA2hs2lso2een2 ited2for2ghrge2ss
F2
he2ford2hs2exlusively2limited2ghrge2s2 in2this2se2to2speifi2ondutD2the2
ee2 etitioners2 eond2emended2porml2 ghrgesD2
ITF2
IUF2
wsF2 furris2 oserved2 the2 following2 linil2 signs2 upon2 her2 evlution2 nd2
ixhiit2eD2t2ppF2QD2UD2 IID2ISD2ITF2
IVF2
er2wsF2furrisD2the2presene2of2livor2mortis2ws2oserved2nd2onfirmed2y2wsF2
furris2 during2 her2 initil2 ssessmentF2 ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xoF2 PHD2 PIY2 see2 lso2 wedil2
rs2feguF2
lood2in2dependent2ody2prts2using2purple2disolortion2of2the2skin2whih2does2lnh2with2
pressureF2
ee2 etitioners2
pirst2
t2
ixhiit2 iD2
referening2ford2osition2ttement2ISFPHY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IVF2
he2presene2of2livor2
xoF2QIF2
IWF2
tient2
on2
initil2
@used2the2term2rigor2mortisAF2he2rigor2mortis2ws2onrmed2upon2wsF2furris2 ssessmentF2
ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xHF2PHY2 wedil2eords2t2 ixhiit2eD2t2 ppF2 QD2 UD2 IHD2 IID2 ISD2 ITY2
engel2gre2emulne2ervieD2snF2tient2gre2eport2t2ixhiit2sF2
PHF2
t2ixhiit2xoF2PRY2fellow2 effidvit2t2xoF2IUF2
PPF2
feuse2of2the2presene2of2livor2mortis2nd2rigor2mortisD2two2onlusive2signs2of2
deth2onfirmed2y2wsF2furris2upon2n2ssessmentD2the2ptient2ws2dedF2 ee2furris2effidvit2
xosF2PHD2PID2PPD2PQD2PRD2PSY2wedil2eords2ixhiit2eD2ppF2P2@rms2ehind2himAD2QD2 U2@no2
emulne2ervieD2snF2tient2gre2eport2t2ixhiit2s2@rigor2mortis2expressly2notedAF2
PQF2
tht2the2ptient2presented2with22onlusive2sign2of2 dethD2rigor2mortisF2
ee2wedil2eords2of2
ixhiit2 eD2 ppF2 P2 @werle2 F2 willerD2 FxFAD2 lS2 @wri2 wnfrediD2 vFFxFAY2 engel2 gre2
ee2fellow2effidvit2t2xoF2QIF2
PRF2
he2ford2must2prove2tht2when2wsF2furris2filed2to2initite2 rdiopulmonry2
resusittion2@gA2for2tient2gwD2
F2
F2
hg2 xumer2VPVISQ2
F2
F2
F2this2ondut2 exposes22ptient2
F2
estlished2 tht2 she2 ws2 or2 ws2 not2 within2 the2 generlly2 eptle2
stndrds2of2nursing2prtie2in2withholding2resusittive2efforts2sed2on22sitution2involving2
futility2 of2reD2 ould2 not2 hveD2 on2its2 feD2 exposed22ptient2
F2 F2 F2
hrmF2 ee2 iF2 yggF2gyhi22 QHIFRSP@A@IQAY2 ee2furris2 effidvit2 t2 xoF2 QIY2 fellow2
effidvit2t2xosF2PQEPSD2QREQSF2 purthermoreD22ptient2who2 presents2with2onlusive2signs2of2
F2
F2
F2
of2 timely2resusittion2effortsF2
y2rigor2mortisAD 2
ursunt2to2 ghrge2sD2 the2 fords2rules2 ited2 y2etitioner2 in2 its2 pledingsD2 PP2
iF2ehwsxF2gyhi2 2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@gAD2@wAD2@QA@eA@ivAD2nd2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2fAD2re2ll2ited2
to2prove2misondutD2ut2re2speilly2nd2exlusively2relted2to2 2filure2 to2 initite2 gF2
lwF2 his2is2 espeilly2true2in2light2of2the2immutle2ft2tht2the2only2ondutU2tht2hs2een2 lleged2 reltive2 to2 these2 provisions2 fous2 exlusively2 on22filure2 to2 initite2 g2 for2 tient2
hgt2xumer2VPVISQF2
g2@s2
opposedD2for2exmpleD2to22filure2to2perform22omprehensive2nursing2ssessmentAD2no2 violtion2
n2e2mde2 under2PIUFII@IA@eAD2@gAD2@wAD2@QA@eA@ivA2nd2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2fAF2
nprofessionl2 or2 dishonorle2 ondut2 llegtion2 nd2 the2 element2 tht2 requires2 the2 estlishment2of2ondut2likelv2to2 injure22ptientF2 his2element2is2 pproprite2for2 onsidertion2 here2 nd2 does2 not2 require2 nv2 determintion2 of2expert2 opinion2 on2 the2 generlly2epted2stndrds2of2nursingprtieF2 es22mtter2of2lwD2there2is2 no2likely2
F2 F2 F2
U2
eferening2ghrge2s2 speifillyF2
iniurv2 to2 2ptient2whereD2without2disputeF2 2ptient2is2 ded2s2 indited2 y2onlusive2 signs2of2 dethF2livor2mortis2nd2 rigor2mortisF2
PUF2
etA2providesX2
injure 2
FF2
emended2porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2sD2 t2ixhiit2qF2
likely2 to2 deeiveD2 defrud2 or2 injure2 2 ptient2 or2 the2 puli2 inludesX2 @eA2 relessly2 filingD2
PWF2
minimum2stndrd2 of2nursing2 re2 nd2 the2 determintion2 of2smeD2 ut2 rtherD2 initillyD2 the2
undisputed2ft2tht2the2ptient2presented2with22onlusive2sign2of2dethD2rigor2mortisD2nd2ws2
V2
ford2ule2PIUFIP@IA@eA2providesX2
grelessly2filingD2repetedly2filingD2or2exhiiting2n2 inility2to2perform2 or2 votionlD2registered2 dvned2prtie2nursing2in2onformity2with2the2stndrds2of2 minimum2 eptle2level2of2 nursing2 lF2 prtie2set2out2in2ule2 PIUFI2
ford2rule2PIUFIP@IA@fA2providesX2
settingsF2
dedF2
lso2 fellow2effidvit2 t2 PQEPSD2 QREQSF2 rereD2 etitioner2 ontends2 tht2 wsF2furris2 my2hve2
this2seD2tht2the2ondut2of2 filing2to2initite2
g2 is2deeptive2or2one2 tht2defrudsF2
QHF2
eny2ondut2tht2 is2 likely2 to2 deeive2 or2 defrud2 2ptient2 @or2 the2 puliA2
ee2
gyhi2 2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAY2ee2lso2etitioners2eond2
emended2 ghrges2t2ixhiit2qF2
QPF2
he2requirement2of2 reless2or2repetitive2does2not2enompss22nurses2re2
provided2 to2 one2 ptient2 on2 one2 osionD2 within2 2 spn2 of2 severl2 minutesF2 he2 resons2
hrmD2 eqully2 pplies2 nd2holds2 true2 hereF2 ynes2 ondut2 of2not2 inititing2 g2nnot2e2
onluded2s2reless2upon2determining2tht2the2ptient2presented2with22onlusive2 sign2of2
deth2s2well2s2presented2with2other2presumptive2signs2of2dethY2the2former2onsisting2of2livor2 mortis2nd2rigor2mortisF2 he2term2reless2is2 dened2s2not2pying2enough2ttention2to2ht2
one2doesF2
@IWVVAF2
ri2exhyw2ryi2gyvviqi2hsgsyxe2isih2ihssyx2PHR2
espondent2ws2reless2
st2is2 signint2tht2etitioners2pleding2is2not2lleging2tht2
euse2she2filed2to2perform2n2ssessmentD2tht2she2ws2reless2euse2she2did2not2know2
the2 xursing2 rtie2 et2 nd2the2 ords2 rules2 nd2regultionsD2 or2 tht2 she2 ws2reless2
W2
under2PP2 iF2 ehwsxF2 gyhi2 etitioners2eond2 emended2 porml2ghrgesD2ghrge2 2PIUFIP@IA@eAD2@fAF2 ee2 qF2 ssD2 t2ixhiit2
hve2een2 exposed2 nd2ws2not2 exposed2 unneessrily2 to2 risk2 of2hrmD2 it2 follows2 tht2 the2
ondut2to2detennine2tht2g2 ws2inpproprite2or2futile2 interventionD2 one2it2 ws2determined2
tht22 ptient2hd2 2 onlusive2sign2of2 dethD2ould2 not2hve2een2reless2or2tht2it2ould2 hve2
resulted2 in2 n2 injuryF2 woresoD2 one2 2 ptient2 is2 dedD2 there2 re2 no2 pproprite2 nursing2
gyhi2 2PIUFII@IA@wAF2
wsF2furris2
pledings2on2this2point2mke2ler2tht2the2limited2ondut2it2 lims2to2e2in2violtion2ws2tht2
ixhiit2qF2
QRF2
ws2dedD2lthough2likely2to2e2disputed2y2etitioner2in2its2response2with2respet2to2n2ttempt2
to2 rise2 ft2issues2tht2would2e2pproprite2for22ontested2se2heringD2re2not2rehed2nd2
need2not2e2rehed2or2determined2for2purposes2of2this2motionF2 wke2no2mistkeD2this2will2e2
etitioners2gol2in2its2 responseF2
roweverD2ft2issues2tht2re2in2disputeD2ut2fter2the2 ft2do2
not2hnge2the2undisputed2ft2initilly2tht2the2ptient2ws2ded2nd2sed2on2thisD2 etitioner2
gyhi2
QSF2
edditionl2 issues2 or2 fts2 tht2 etitioner2 my2 rise2 in2 its2 response2 to2 this2
yer2 evt2s2they2re2likely2to2touh2upon2the2generlly2
epted2stndrds2of2 prtie2or2events2tht2trnspired2fter2wsF2furris2ssessment2nd2one2it2
motion2for2summry2dispositionD2espeilly2given2the2elements2of2the2provisions2tht2etitioner2
hs2lleged2nd2lsoD2given2how2 limiting2in2nture2the2fords2porml2ghrges2re2with2respet2
to2 the2 speifi2 ondut2limed2to2 e2in2 violtion2 @iFeFD2 filure2 to2 initite2 gAF2
yne2moreD2
yer2evts2
QTF2
g2following2 her2 ssessment2 fell2 elow2 the2 stndrds2 of2 minimum2 nursing2 reDII2 the2
hrteriztion2 y2 etitioner2 tht2 wsF2 furris2 ondut2 to2 withhold2 g2ws2 2 reless2 or2
repetitive2 filure2 for2 2 ptient2 who2hd2 presented2 with2 livor2 mortis2 nd2 rigor2 mortisD2 oth2
F2 nnot2 e2
deemed2or2hrterized2s2reless2or2repetitive2sed2
on2the2undisputed2fts2nd2is2inonsistent2with2the2pplile2uthorityF2 ee2PP2iF2ehwsxF2
II2
s2
he2 hnge2 to2 this2 rule2 nd2 the2 imposition2 of2 this2 dditionl2 requirement2
eptemer2 PUD2 PHHRD2 does2 not2 enompss2 2 nurses2 re2 provided2 to2 one2
susequent2 to2
osionD2 within2 2spn2of2severl2 minutesF2 imilrlyD2 the2 sme2 resoning2lso2 pplies2 to2 PP2
revision2 in2
ws2not22repetitive2filure2nd2ws2 not2relessF2
ith2respet2 to2 ghrge2ssD2 espondent2is2 entitled2 to2 summry2disposition2 euse2 it2 is2 undisputed2tht2wsF2furris2doumented2her2ndings2of2 rigor2mortis2nd2 lso2the2initition2 of2g2 when2it2 ws2ordered2to2e2initited2v22hrge2nurseF2 his2ondutF2s22mtter2 of2 lwD2nnot2e2deemed2 to2e2 flseD2deeptiveF2or2 misledingD2
QUF2
tht2wsF2furrisD 2
filed2to2 ompletely2nd2urtely2doument2the2nursing2re2rendered2
F2 F2 F2
F2
PIUFII@IA@eAD2 @hAD2 2 PIUFIP@IA@eAD2 @fAD2 T@rAF2 wsF2 furris2 doumented2 tht2 tient2 hgt2
xumer2VPVISQ2s2in2rigor2mortisF2 ee2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QSY2see2lso2wedil2eords2
t2ixhiit2eD2 pF2 QEIRD2 ITF2
wsF2furrisD2when2g2 ws2ordered2y2the2hrge2nurseD2ut2fter2
g2nd2doumented2this2into2the2reordF2 ee2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QSY2wedil2eords2t2
ixhiit2eF2 pF2QEIRD2ITF2
IP2
rereD2the2ondut2pplies2to2oth2the2filure2to2initite2g2 nd2to2
wsF2furrisF2
gyhi2 2PIUFIP@RAD2ut2this2provision2hs2
doumentF2
QVF2
for2engging2in2unprofessionl2ondut2whih2is2 defined2to2inlude2unprofessionl2ondutD2ut2
more2speillyD2misondut2tht2inludes2providing2informtion2whih2ws2flseD2deeptiveD2
or2 misleding2 in2 omqetion2 with2 the2 prtie2 of2 nursingF2
ri2exhyw2ryi2gyvviqi2
judgmentF2 sdF2t2VSRF2
QWF2
wsF2furris2doumented2her2ssessmentD2findings2s2to2rigor2mortisD2other2linil2
wnged2 gre2 xursing2 rotool2 for2 xervous2 ystem2 gomplintsF2 ee2 wedil2 eords2
ixhiit2e2 t2ppF2QEIRD2ITY2furris2effidvit2t2xoF2QSF2
RHF2 rior2to2mking2 her2findings2nd2ondut2in2the2notesD2she2 ny2doumenttion2of2
wfEgwg2
RIF2
nd2wsF2werle2willerD2FxFD2doumented2their2linil2oservtions2nd2re2provided2to2tient2
hgt2 xumer2 VPVISQ2 s2 prt2 of2 their2 reporting2 nd2 doumenttion2 nd2 lso2 provided2
yer2 hoket2xHF2SHUEIQEHUPU
I l2
F2
on2undisputed2fts2nd2s22mtter2of2lw2when22ptient2presents2with2rigor2mortisD2is2 expiredD2
exhiits2presumptive2nd2onlusive2signs2of2dethD2 nd2hs2irreversile2dethF2 imilrlyD2s 2
ites2 sed2 on2 the2 undisputed2 ftsD2 inluding2 ghrge2 ss2 regrding2 doumenttionD2 whih2
entitles2
wsF2 furris2 to2 2 finl2 deision2 in2 her2 fvor2 on2 summry2 disposition2 ithout2 n2
mkes2 herself2 ville2 for2 2 hering2 if2 the2 yer2evt2elieves2 this2 would2 e2 helpfulF2
espondent2 further2prys2for2ll2other2relief2to2whih2 she2might2 e2entitledF2
espetfully2umittedD2
G2
ry2
tte2fr2 xoF2PRHIHSVV2
QQQ2qudlupe2treetD2uite2QERTH2
x2