PERSONAL AND CONFIDENTIAL MINNESOTA SENATE ATTN: JOANNE ZOFF 231 STATE CAPITOL 75 DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR.

BLVD. ST. PAUL, MN 55155

Invoice Number Invoice Date File Number

630500 05/21/13 35256.00000

Re: BRODKORB VS. MINNESOTA SENATE FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED: FEBRUARY 1, 2013 THROUGH APRIL 30, 2013 (3 months) Date 02/13/13 02/14/13 02/14/13 02/14/13 Tkpr DWN CJH DWN RJR Hours 1.50 0.70 0.90 2.40 Value 495.00 231.00 297.00 504.00

02/15/13 02/15/13

DWN RJR

02/19/13

CJH

02/19/13 02/20/13 02/20/13 02/20/13

DWN CJH DWN RJR

02/21/13

CJH

Telephone conference with T. Bottern; review court order; telephone conference with Associated Press Review decision on Rule 12 and 21 motions; outline possible Rule 11 issues Telephone conference with T. Bottern Analysis of procedures for answering complaint after partial motion to dismiss; analysis of relevant caselaw concerning timing of response and content; confer with D. Nolan regarding same Call Judge Nelson's office; draft letter; telephone conference with T. Bottern Continue analysis of procedural steps for answering complaint after partial motion to dismiss; examine exemplar motions and judge's orders; confirm lack of applicable rules or standards; confer with D. Nolan regarding results of search Office conference with D. Nolan regarding status, procedural issues, tactics (1.10); research various appellate issues, Rule 11 issues and discovery scope issues (2.10) Office conference regarding projects and research necessary; review research; telephone conference with T. Bottern Office conference with D. Nolan regarding answer; draft answer to complaint; review law on GERA preclusive effect Office conference with C. Harristhal regarding drafting answer Analysis of effect of partial dismissal on remaining parties; investigate applicable caselaw and Local Rules concerning motions to reconsider; report to D. Nolan regarding results of investigation Revise answer (.80); conference call with client (No Charge)

1.00 1.10

330.00 231.00

3.20

1,056.00

1.10 2.20 0.40 2.40

363.00 726.00 132.00 504.00

0.80

264.00

35256.00000 MINNESOTA SENATE May 21, 2013 Date 02/21/13 02/22/13 Tkpr DWN CJH

Invoice Number Page 2 Hours 0.80 1.50

630500

02/22/13 02/24/13 02/25/13 02/26/13 02/26/13 02/28/13 03/14/13 03/15/13 03/22/13 03/22/13 03/27/13 03/27/13 03/28/13

DWN CJH CJH CJH DWN CJH DWN DWN CJH DWN DWN DWN CJH

03/28/13 03/29/13 04/03/13 04/03/13 04/03/13 04/03/13 04/04/13 04/05/13 04/06/13

DWN CJH CJH DWN JAK JYJ CJH CJH CJH

Telephone conference with T. Bottern, et al. Call to Judge Nelson's chambers (Lynn Holden) regarding our correspondence (.10); office conference with D. Nolan regarding letter drafts to Plaintiff's counsel, memo to client and revisions to answer (.70); draft letter to G. Walsh regarding sanctions (.70) Telephone conference with T. Bottern; revise answer; office conference with C. Harristhal regarding strategy on answer Partial draft of memo for client on sex discrimination and similarly situated analysis Compile memo for client on gender discrimination theory and burdens of proof Revise answer to original complaint; review letter from P. Villaume; call to court Office conference regarding paragraph 7 of answer; review P. Villaume letter; office conference regarding call to court Office conference with D. Nolan regarding Rule 11 letter (No Charge) Review amended complaint; office conference regarding comparison; telephone conference with T. Bottern Telephone conference with T. Bottern Review amended complaint; draft answer to same; review privilege and immunities research for same Telephone conference with T. Bottern Do final review of and revisions to answer Telephone conference with T. Bottern Office conference with D. Nolan; email for clients regarding process and timing; review order from court on scheduling, email to client regarding same (0.70); telephone conference with T. Bottern and D. Nolan (.20) Review order and memoranda regarding scheduling; telephone conference with T. Bottern Call from P. Villaume regarding 26(f) conference Office conference with D. Nolan regarding 26(f) report and disclosures, outline responses for 26(f) report Office conference regarding Rule 26(f) conference and report issues; telephone conferences with T. Bottern Research and analysis of federal constitutional issues regarding Minnesota Human Rights Act Draft Rule 26(f) report Prepare draft 26(f) report and confidentiality stipulation Revise protective order and 26(f) report draft; email same to plaintiff's counsel Emails from P. Villaume; review his 26(f) report and news clippings regarding Villaume protective order admissions

Value 264.00 495.00

1.10 1.00 0.70 1.20 0.50 0.00 0.60 0.25 1.50 0.30 0.30 0.60 0.90

363.00 330.00 231.00 396.00 165.00 0.00 198.00 82.50 495.00 99.00 99.00 198.00 297.00

0.40 0.50 1.00 1.10 0.20 0.30 1.20 0.80 0.30

132.00 165.00 330.00 363.00 41.00 52.50 396.00 264.00 99.00

35256.00000 MINNESOTA SENATE May 21, 2013 Date 04/07/13 04/08/13 Tkpr CJH CJH

Invoice Number Page 3 Hours 1.00 4.10

630500

04/08/13

DWN

04/09/13 04/09/13 04/11/13 04/11/13

CJH DWN CJH DWN

04/15/13 04/16/13 04/16/13

CJH CJH DWN

04/17/13

CJH

04/17/13

DWN

04/18/13

CJH

04/18/13 04/18/13

DWN RJR

04/19/13 04/19/13 04/20/13 04/22/13 04/23/13

CJH DWN CJH CJH CJH

Revise interrogatories and requests for production of documents to comport with amended complaint Revise 26(f) report with Plaintiff's proposals; attend 26(f) meeting; office conference with D. Nolan (2.25); issue notice of deposition for Plaintiff; telephone conference with T. Bottern and D. Nolan; draft statement regarding protective order for client; revise protective order (1.90) Office conference regarding results of Rule 26(f) conference; review draft report; telephone conference with T. Bottern; office conference with C. Harristhal Email to client regarding protective order Telephone conference with T. Bottern Telephone conference with client regarding status, 26(f) report and disclosures Telephone conference with T. Bottern; gather materials for conference call; telephone conference with committee; telephone conference with T. Bottern Create initial disclosures form Prepare initial disclosures Revise letter to Plaintiff's attorneys regarding dismissal/sanctions; review database for documents to include in Rule 26(a)(1) disclosures Revise disclosures (.30); review deposition notices (.10); telephone conference with T. Bottern and D. Nolan regarding same (.10); review rule on filing discovery and issues in same (1.0) Review notices; office conference with C. Harristhal; telephone conferences with T. Bottern; telephone conference with C. Ludeman; telephone conference with C. Gerlach Revise disclosures (.40); direct procedural research regarding deposition notices (.40); office conference with D. Nolan regarding disclosures (.30); review results of Rule 45 research (.30) Office conference regarding Rule 26(a)(1) disclosures; revise same Analysis of issues surrounding notices of deposition and requirements for service of subpoena; confer with C. Harristhal regarding the same; create and revise memorandum outlining findings; transmit memorandum to D. Nolan and C. Harristhal Office conference with D. Nolan regarding deposition issues Telephone conference with T. Bottern regarding Rule 26 disclosures; review Plaintiff's letter and cases cited Draft letter to counsel regarding improper deposition notices Review letter from Counsel; revise letter to counsel (.50); draft letter to Judge Boylan (1.50) Office conference with D. Nolan; draft letter to G. Walsh regarding deposition

Value 330.00 1,353.00

1.40

462.00

0.30 0.50 1.20 2.40

99.00 165.00 396.00 792.00

0.30 0.90 3.10

99.00 297.00 1,023.00

1.50

495.00

2.50

825.00

1.40

462.00

0.50 2.30

165.00 483.00

0.30 1.50 0.50 2.00 0.90

99.00 495.00 165.00 660.00 297.00

35256.00000 MINNESOTA SENATE May 21, 2013 Date 04/23/13 Tkpr DWN

Invoice Number Page 4 Hours 2.20

630500

04/23/13

RJR

04/24/13 04/24/13

CJH DWN

04/25/13 04/25/13

CJH DWN

04/26/13 04/26/13 04/26/13 04/27/13 04/29/13 04/29/13 04/30/13

CJH DWN RJR CJH CJH RJR CJH

04/30/13

DWN

04/30/13

RJR

Review media reports; telephone conference with C. Nauen; office conference with C. Harristhal regarding Protective Order issue; telephone conference with T. Bottern Research and analysis of caselaw concerning protective orders protecting privacy of third-party witnesses; confer with C. Harristhal regarding the same Revise letter to Judge Boylan; review letter from Plaintiff's counsel; review protective order research Review protective order research; finalize Boylan letter; office conference regarding chart and prepare notes; telephone conference with C. Robling Review Plaintiff's initial disclosures; telephone conference with Judge Boylan; telephone conference with T. Bottern Telephone conference with T. Bottern; revise letter; telephone conference with C. Harristhal; review disclosures; telephone conference with Judge Boylan's clerk; telephone conference with Judge Boylan; telephone conference with T. Bottern Office conference with D. Nolan; outline research project; review press on disclosures Review Plaintiff's Rule 26(a) disclosures; telephone conference with T. Bottern Continue research and analysis; investigate 8th Circuit caselaw regarding same and perform broader nationwide search Review discovery research and disclosures; review Senate's final disclosures Revise letter to Judge Boylan (.40); review protective order research, outline issues for presentation of same (1.10) Continue analysis of research; locate Rule 30 cases; transmit email to D. Nolan and C. Harristhal regarding findings Review additional research, draft proposed protective order (.90); office conference with D. Nolan regarding same and strategy for hearing (.50) Office conference with C. Harristhal; telephone conference with T. Bottern; revise list; office conference with C. Harristhal; email Judge Boylan; office conference with C. Harristhal Analysis of cases under Rule 30

Value 726.00

2.70

567.00

0.60 2.30

198.00 759.00

1.20 3.70

396.00 1,221.00

0.60 2.90 1.80 0.60 1.50 0.90 1.40

198.00 957.00 378.00 198.00 495.00 189.00 462.00

3.10

1,023.00

0.40

84.00

Litigation Support Technical Services
Date 02/19/13 02/19/13 03/04/13 03/04/13 Tkpr DLG KES DLG KES Hours 0.50 0.40 0.10 0.20 Value 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Document coding in Summation database (No Charge) Scan document images and load same to Summation database (No Charge) Document coding in Summation database (No Charge) Scan document images and load same to Summation database (No Charge)

35256.00000 MINNESOTA SENATE May 21, 2013 Date 04/04/13 04/04/13 04/15/13 04/15/13 04/19/13 04/19/13 04/26/13 04/26/13 Tkpr DLG KES DLG KES DLG KES DLG KES

Invoice Number Page 5 Hours 0.20 0.30 0.10 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.30 0.40

630500

Document coding in Summation database (No Charge) Scan document images and load same to Summation database (No Charge) Document coding in Summation database (No Charge) Scan document images and load same to Summation database (No Charge) Document coding in Summation database (No Charge) Scan document images and load same to Summation database (No Charge) Document coding in Summation database (No Charge) Scan document images and load same to Summation database (No Charge)

Value 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

TOTAL HOURS TIMEKEEPER SUMMARY Timekeeper C. J. HARRISTHAL D. W. NOLAN R. J. REDING J. A. KVINGE J. Y. JAHN Title SHAREHOLDER SHAREHOLDER ASSOCIATE ASSOCIATE PARALEGAL CURRENT FEES TOTAL DUE UPON RECEIPT Hours 37.80 36.95 14.00 0.20 0.30 at at at at at Rate 330.00 330.00 210.00 205.00 175.00

92.35

Value = 12,474.00 = 12,193.50 = 2,940.00 = 41.00 = 52.50 27,701.00 $27,701.00

1458079.1

PERSONAL AND CONFIDENTIAL MINNESOTA SENATE ATTN: JOANNE ZOFF 231 STATE CAPITOL 75 DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BLVD. ST. PAUL, MN 55155

Invoice Number Invoice Date File Number

630500 05/21/13 35256.00000

REMITTANCE COPY
Re: BRODKORB VS. MINNESOTA SENATE FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED: FEBRUARY 1, 2013 THROUGH APRIL 30, 2013 CURRENT FEES CURRENT EXPENSES TOTAL DUE UPON RECEIPT 27,701.00 0.00 $27,701.00

PLEASE RETURN THIS PAGE WITH YOUR REMITTANCE

 Pro #: 313325

Master your semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Special offer for students: Only $4.99/month.

Master your semester with Scribd & The New York Times

Cancel anytime.