You are on page 1of 2

AffirmativeScavengerHunt

HUDL2013

Whatevidenceinyouraffirmativefilecanbeusedtosupporteachclaim?Usetheindextohelpyoufindthecardwiththerighttag,thenwritedownthepage,the citation(author&date),thedata,andthewarrant. Thefirstexerciseisdoneforyou,usethisasanexample. Forthedataandwarrant,don'tworryifyoudon'tknowthe"right"answer,therearemanypossibleanswers. Datasupportingevidenceforthe claim

Tag&Claim

Page&Citation

Warrantwhydoesthedatamattertotheclaim

PortsofEntryatthe Mexicoborderarefailing now.

P.1 Trevizo,2013

Portsofentryhavenotbeenupdated,they need$6billionforinvestment.

Lackofinvestmentinportsofentrycreatesdelaysandneeds tobefixed

Borderimprovements wouldhaveamultiplier effecttheycould stimulateeconomic growthacrossmultiple sectors

Globaleconomiccollapse causeswar.

Theplansolves expandingandimproving physicalborder infrastructureis necessarytofacilitate crossbordertrade.

AffirmativeScavengerHunt
Datasupportingevidenceforthe claim

HUDL2013

Tag&Claim

Page&Citation

Warrantwhydoesthedatamattertotheclaim

Continuedblockagesat theborderwillsuffocate boththeUSandMexican economies.

Underfundedportsof entryhurttheUS economy

Theplanwouldcreate morethana2billion dollarboosttotheUS economy.

Expandingborder crossingwouldposeno risktosecurityminor investmentson expeditingflowswould reapmassiveeconomic returns

USMexicoeconomic cooperationistheonly hopeforsustainingthe globaleconomic recovery.