P. 1
Tall vertical columns.docx

Tall vertical columns.docx

|Views: 16|Likes:
Published by Mas Arman Tewo
tall vertical columns vortex shedding
tall vertical columns vortex shedding

More info:

Published by: Mas Arman Tewo on Sep 27, 2013
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





Tall vertical columns: Vortex Shedding Analysis

Tall vertical columns: Vortex Shedding Analysis R. ten Broeke Dear Sirs,
Member Registered: 10/29/01 Posts: 1 Loc: The Netherlands, Geleen

For the design analysis of a high and slender vent gas scrubber, I've chosen the vortex shedding analysis to investigate a possible limited fatigue life. The vortex shedding analysis for tall vertical vessels is based on the non-dimensional Strouhal number, S = f.D/v [Bednar, p. 111]. Since I've run into design problems with this specific scrubber, I've performed the analysis in both English and metric units to check the consistency. More specific for this scrubber, the PVElite 4.2 output calculated a very limited service life, due to too high alternating stresses. I discovered that the calculation of the critical wind speed (based on the eigen frequencey f, weigthed diameter D, and Strouhal S =0.2) and the velocity pressure Qh remain both unchanged, i.e. both outcome are indentical (Vh = 117.85 m/s and 117.85 miles/hr, Qh = 41.88 N/m2 and 41.88 psf). Therefore I've the following questions: - What is the meaning of the constant 0.6818 in the PVElite output ? - How is the weigthed diameter Davg of a vessel determined, used in the Strouhal equation ? - If vortex shedding showed out to be critical for a vessel design (limited service life due to too high alternating stresses) what design variables do I have ? - Do you know the excistence of a recommended engineering guideline for vortex breakers (spiralized rafter or beams on the OD of tall vertical columns and stacks ? Kind regards, _________________________ R. ten Broeke DSM Engineering-Stamicarbon Geleen, The Netherlands

Top #6980 - 10/29/01 01:34 PM

Re: Tall vertical columns: Vortex Shedding Analysis

In metric if you just multiply the numbers the answer does not work out. Doing this however does not change the calculated loadings on the vessel (the final results). much like a plain vent stack. To my knowledge. piping and other equipment that may disrupt eddy currents that may force a damped oscillation of the structure. _________________________ Scott Mayeux CADWorx & Analysis Solutions Intergraph Process. right down to the foundation. Member Registered: 12/23/99 Posts: 310 Loc: Houston. This is of course due to the fact that typically there are platforms. In essence computer software must make the assumption that the shell is bare and smooth. I will make this more clear in the near future. Unfortunately.USA The design of tall thin cylindrical stuctures can be quite tricky.6818 is 3600/5280. & Marine Top . The average diameter is obtained by multiplying the element diameter times their respective lengths and dividing the sum of the lengths over the upper 1/3 of the vessel. The same is true for Qh. ladders. The 0. The analysis in PVElite is based on the National Building Code of Canada and papers written by Kanti Mahajan and Ed Zorilla.Scott_Mayeux Dear Sir. This is for stack design.TX. it may be necessary to alter the stiffness of the tower which will change the fundamental frequency of vibration or adding strakes or similar devices to break up the wind flow around the column. If resonance does really prove to be a problem. It is empirically difficult to estimate whether or not a tall tower will resonate. I hope this helps. The result of this calculation is always meant to be in miles per hour. the number of seconds in 1 hour divided by the number of feet in a mile. the latter has the unwanted effect of creating higher loads (shear and moment) to the entire tower. You might also check the design guideline STS-92 published by ASME. there are no highly detailed design guidelines for the typical process tower vortex shedding calculations. Power. displaying answers in both English and Metric Units.

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->