Republic of the Philippines SUPREME COURT Manila EN BANC

JAMES M. IMBONG AND LOVELYANN C. IMBONG, ET AL. -versusHON. PAQUITO N. OCHOA, JR., EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, ET AL.

G.R. No. 204819

G.R. No. 204934 ALLIANCE FOR THE FAMILY FOUNDATION PHILIPPINES, INC. (ALFI), ET AL., -versusHON. PAQUITO N. OCHOA, JR., EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, ET AL. TASK FORCE FOR FAMILY AND LIFE VISAYAS, INC. AND VALERIANO S. AVILA -versusHON. PAQUITO N. OCHOA, JR., EXECUTIVE SECRETARY ET AL. G.R. No. 204988 SERVE LIFE CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY INC. ET AL. -versusOFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT ET AL. EXPEDITO A. BUGARIN, JR. -versusG.R. No. 205003 OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, ET AL. G.R. No. 204957

JR. OCHOA. TATAD AND MARIA FENNY C. 205720 PRO-LIFE PHILIPPINES FOUNDATION. 205478 REYNALDO J ECHAVEZ. MD.R. ET AL.R. · G.R.. 205043 G. ET AL.Comment-in-Intervention Page 2 of 6 EDUARDO B. ET AL. ONA. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY. ET AL. No. PAQUITO N. ET AL. 205138 PHILIPPINE ALLIANCE OF XSEMINARIANS. ET AL. G. TATAD. OLAGUER AND THE CATHOLIC XYBRSPACE APOSTOLATE OF THE PHILIPPINES -versusDOH SECRETARY ENRIQUE T.. G. ET AL.. No. No. No. No. -versusHON.R. -versusOFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES G. . PAQUITO N. INC.. 205491 SPS. -versusOFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT. JR.R. FRANCISCO S. -versusHON. INC. OCHOA.

Jamie Galvez-Tan. Makati City for Manila. PRAYER WHEREFORE. (collectively referred to hereinafter as “Intervenors”). Jr. In view thereof. medical professionals.Intervention. Intervenors are former Secretaries of the Department of Health (hereinafter “DOH”). . The issuance of the status quo ante order. 9 May 2013. temporarily stopping the government from implementing the above-mentioned law has jeopardized the interest of the Intervenors. 2. premises considered. citizens and taxpayers have a clear legal interest in the implementation of the Responsible Parenthood and Reproductive Health Act of 2012. it will prevent multiplicity of suits. On the contrary. Alberto G. Cabral. 4. through the undersigned counsel and unto the Honorable Court respectfully ask for leave to intervene. The rights of the Intervenors will not be fully protected in a separate proceeding and allowing herein Intervenors to intervene will not unduly delay the adjudication of the case. Romualdez. Intervenors respectfully pray for leave of this Honorable Court to intervene in the instant cases and for admission of the attached Comment-in-Intervention. Esperanza I. Intervenors respectfully pray for other just and equitable relief under the premises. and Dr. and allege that: 1. Dr.Comment-in-Intervention Page 3 of 6 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE AND TO ADMIT COMMENT-IN-INTERVENTION Intervenors. Dr. 3. Intervenors respectfully move for leave to intervene in the instant cases and for admission of the attached Comment-in.

1327231 (1/8/13)-MAKATI CITY MCLE COMPLIANCE NO. Fax No: 887-3893 By: HERMINIO HARRY L. 924436(1/10/13)-ORIENTAL MINDORO PTR NO. 59686 IBP NO. IV-000513 (2/15/13) ROMEL REGALADO BAGARES ROLL NO. III-0002218 (10/25/12) (MCLE IV Compliance Certificate In Process) . ROQUE ROLL NO. 924439 (1/10/13)-SOCSARGEN PTR NO. Salcedo Village Makati City 1200 Email: mail@roquebutuyan. IV-0005346 (2/15/13) ETHEL C.Comment-in-Intervention Page 4 of 6 ELIZABETH AGUILING-PANGALANGAN ROLL NO. AVISADO ROLL NO.com Tel. Nos. 49518 IBP NO. 3692460 (1/18/13)-MAKATI CITY MCLE COMPLIANCE NO. 369262 (1/18/13)-MAKATI CITY MCLE COMPLIANCE NO.DAVAO CITY PTR NO. 9033690(9/17/2012). (4/7/2012) ROQUE & BUTUYAN LAW OFFICES 1904 Antel 2000 Corporate Center 121 Valero Street. 33032 IBP LIFETIME MEMBER 3506 PTR 8278651B (5/6/13) MCLE EXEMPTION NO III-000940. 3692464 (1/18/13)-MAKATI CITY MCLE COMPLIANCE NO. IV-0011822 (2/15/13) GEEPEE ACERON GONZALES ROLL NO. 56254 IBP NO. 887-4445/887-3894. 36976 IBP LIFETIME MEMBER PTR NO.

.R. Paguia Counsel for Petitioners in G. Happy Valley.R...R. Quezon City Attys.R. Executive Secretary Premiere Guest House Malacanang. cor Jade St. Manila Senate of the Philippines c/o senate President Juan Ponce Enrile GSIS Bldg. Cruz. Quezon City Hon. Pasig City Philippine Commission on Women c/o Chairperson Remedios Ignacio-Rikken 1145 J. Rufino Policarpio III. Manila Secreatry Armin A.D. Bugarin. (reg) Petitioner in G. Lourdes Drive. Manila Astral Tower Taft Ave. Legaspi village 1229 Makati City Copies of the following to be provided to the Office of the Solicitor General: His Excellency Benigno Simeon c. Loyola Heights Quezon City Atty. Alcantara Petitioner-in-Intervention th Suite 1402.R.. 205491 Unit 412 Corporate 101 Building 101 Mother IGnacia St. No.Banilad Cebu City Atty. Gambe and Marion I. Noel A.. Pasig City Secretary Manuel A. Pasay City House of Representatives c/o Speaker Feliciano Belmonte.R. Diliman. Manila Secretary Enrique T. San Miguel. 36-B Madasalin St. Montes and Jeremy I.. Batasan Hills Diliman. 205478 Unit 1903-A. Luistro. Makilito B. Quezon City Atty. San Miguel Ave. 206 Reza Building. M. Ermita Manila Attys. Ona. 19 Country Club Village. Sikatuna Diliman. St. Mahinay (reg) Counsel for Petitioners/G. 205003 No. Ortigas Center. San Miguel.P. Ricardo M. No.. Aurora Milestone Tower 1045 Aurora Blvd. 205043 Penthouse. 12 saint Josemaria Escriva Drive. Mapagmahal St. J. Sta. Cedro Counsel for Petitioners in G. Francisca Village th 6 St. Ibarra M. Ochoa Jr. 204957 Diamond St. Imbong and Jo Aurea M. Expedito A. Samson A. 1605 Pasig City Atty. Howard M. FSC Department of Education DepED Complex. Diliman. Noche Counsel for Petitioners/G.R.. Cor. Jr.R.R. cor P Faura St. Laurel Sr. Ortigas Center. Manila Secretary Florencio B.P. Solano St. James M. Financial Center Roxas Blvd. Manila Philippine Health Insurance Corporation c/o President Eduardo Biazon . Calleja and Ramon Andre F. 205720 Policarpio and Acorda Law Office 903 Richmonde Plaza. 204934 MCS NOCHE LAW OFFICE 91 Melchor Street. Imbong Imbong and Castro Law Offices Counsel for the Petitioners/ G.. Laurel St. Cebu City Atty. South Triangle 1103 Quezon City Atty. West Tower. Paquito N. 204819 Unit 304 Senor Ivan de Palacio Building 139 Malakas St.. Brgy. Torrevillas Counsel for Intervenors Ana Theresia “Risa” Hontiveros et al. Abad Department of Budget and Management Gen. Jardeliza Office of the Solicitor General 134 amorsolo St.Comment-in-Intervention Page 5 of 6 Copy Furnished: Atty. Quezon City Solicitor General Francis H. Balisacan Socio-economic Panning Secretary and NEDA Director-General. Jr. Batasan Bldg. ortigas Center. Maria Concepcion S. Upper Macasandig Cagayan de Oro City Atty. Allan F. Clemente Counsel for Petitioners in G. Quezon City Hon. Yap (reg) Counsel for Petitioner in G. Ribo Counsel for Petitioners PAX in G. Aquino III Office of the President Malacanang Palace. 1318 Quezon Ave.. 204988 Gambe and Yap Law Offices Mandumol. 205138 Rm. Roxas II Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) EDSA cor. No. Quezon City Attys. Arsenio M. 1605 Pasig City Atty.. Meralco Ave... Cristina A.. PSE Centre Exchange Road.. Guiterrez III & Juan Alfonso P. 14 Flr. Brgy. Gatdula Counsel for Petitioners in G. Earl Anthony C. Department of Health San Lazaro compound.R.

Cubao. Lazo Food and Drugs Administration EXPLANATION Due to the shortage of messengerial services and lack of time. quezon City League of Municipalities of the Philippines c/o President Donato Marcos nd 2 Flr.. 1603 Pasig City League of Cities of the Philippines c/o President Oscar Rodriguez th 7 Flr... Delos Reyes Deputy Clerk of Court and Chief Judicial Records Office Supreme Court Hon.. Unit J & K. 265 Ermin Garcia St. Ortigas Center. Quezon City Civic Drive. LMP Building. Suzette H.Comment-in-Intervention Page 6 of 6 Citystate Centre. 709 Shaw Blvd. CyberOne Bldg Eastwood Barangay Bagumbayan. ETHEL C. Rule 13 of the Revised Rules of Court. copies of the foregoing are being served to the other parties by registered mail in accordance with Section 11. Corazon D. 1781 Muntinlupa city League of Provinces of the Philippines c/o President Alfonso Umali Unit 1510 west Tower. Pasig City Public Information Office Supreme Court Atty. filinvest Corporate City Alabang. Philippine Stock Exchange Center Exchange road. AVISADO .

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful