..

.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Pursuantto FederalRule of Civil Procedure pleaseanswereachof the 33, following interrogatories, separately fully, in writing, underoath,within thirty (30) days and after service,in accordance with the Definitions and Instructionsbelow. PROPOUNDING PARTY: RESPONDIN G PARTY: SET NO.: WarnerBros. RecordsInc. DefendantPlank First ROSSPLANK, Defendant. v. FONOVISA, INC., a California corporation; BMGMUSIC,aNewYorkgeneral partnership'and WARNER BROS. . , , RECORDSINC., a DelawarecorporatIon, Plaintiffs, CASE NO. CV 03-6371DT (FMOx) PLAINTIFF INC.'S FIRST SET OF RECORDS WARNER BROS. INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA WESTERN DIVISION KARIN G. PAGNANELLI (StateBarNo. 174763) ROHIT U. SHENDRIKAR (StateBar No. 200401) MITCHELL SILBERBERG & KNUPP LLP 11377West Olympic Boulevard Los Angeles,CA 90064-1683 Telephone: (310) 312-2000 Facsimile: (310) 312-3100 Attorneys for Plaintiffs FONOVISA; BMG MUSIC; and,WARNER BROS.

PLANK

..0649687.1.DOC~

I

.III I I,"""

I , '

'I

,

I.

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
MitchellSilberberg & KnuppLLP

DEFINITIONS AND INSTRUCTIONS

A.

"YOUR COMPUTER" meansthe hard drive producedto Plaintiffs.

B.

"YOU" meansDefendantRossPlank.

C.

"STATE THE BASIS" meansyou shall:

(1)

identify eachand every document(and,wherepertinent,the

section,article, or subparagraph thereof),which forms any part of the sourceof your infomlation regardingthe allegedfacts or legal conclusions referredto by the interrogatory;

(2)

identify eachand every communicationwhich fomls anypart of

the sourceof your information regardingthe allegedfacts or legal conclusionsreferredto by the interrogatory;

(3)

stateseparately acts or omissionsto act on the part of any the

person(identifying the actsor omissionsto act by statingtheir nature,time, andplace and identifying the personinvolved) which foml any part of your infomlation regardingthe alleged facts or legal conclusionsreferredto in the interrogatory;and

(4)

stateseparately other fact which fomls the basisof your any

information regardingthe allegedfactsor legal conclusionsreferredto in the interrogatory.

D.

If you cannotanswerany interrogatoryfully and completelyafter

exercisingdue diligence to makeinquiry and securethe infomlation necessary do so,please to answereachsuchinterrogatoryto the fullest extentpossible,statethe facts upon which you rely to supportyour contentionthat you areunableto answerthe interrogatoryfully and completely,
I
.. 0649687.DOC
I

11,:;;;1111

~

I

I..,.

I J

3 1 andstate whatknowledge, infomlation, beliefthatyouhaveconcerning unanswered and the 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Mitchell Silberberg & Knupp LLP I
0649687.DOC ~ ~

portionof each suchinterrogatory.

INTERROGATORIES
INTERROGATORY NO.1: Describein detail when, how, why, and by whom any and all playlists that previously were presenton YOUR COMPUTER were deleted.

INTERROGATORY NO.2: Describehow and by whom eachsoundrecordinglisted on Exhibit A to these Interrogatories was downloadedto YOUR COMPUTER.

INTERROGATORY NO.3: Describehow andby whom eachsoundrecordinglisted on Exhibit B to these Interrogatories was downloadedto YOUR COMPUTER.

INTERROGATORY NO.4: Describein detail when, why, andby whom "SpyBot Searchand Destroy" was downloaded or installed on, YOUR COMPUTER. to,

INTERROGATORY NO.5: Describein detail when, why, andby whom "SpyBot Searchand Destroy" was deleted from YOUR COMPUTER.

4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 COMPUTER. 8 9 INTERROGATORY NO.8: 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 -23 24 25 26 27 28
Mitchell Silberberg& Knupp LLP

INTERROGATORY NO.6: Describein detail when, why, and by whom "SpywareBlaster" was downloadedto, or installedon, YOUR COMPUTER.

INTERROGATORY NO.7: Describein detail when, why, andby whom "SpywareBlaster" was deletedfrom YOUR

If your response any of Plaintiff FonovisaInc.'s SecondSetof Requests Admission to for servedconcurrentlyherewith is not an unqualified admission,then for eachsu~hresponse is that not an unqualified admission,STATE THE BASIS for your response (organizedby each Requestfor AdmissionNumber).

Dated:April 26, 2004

KARIN G. PAGNANELLI ROHIT U. SHENDRIKAR MITCHELL SILBERBERG & KNUPP LLP By

-

0649687.DOC ~._I ~~

/

~K k(b rt

A--

Ir

I

I I! ..

Date:

04/26/2004

File:

Rossl.pl

#1

[Files] FileO=E:\My

Documents\My

Filel=E:\My File2=E:\My File3=E:\My
File4=E:\My

Documents\My Documents\My Documents\My
Documents\My

A swinging safari.mp3 Music\Fast\Christopher Cross - Ride Like the Wind.mp3 Music\Chuck Mangioni - Feel So Good.mp3 Music\City High - What Would You Do-.mp3
Music\Bert Kaempfert
-

Music\Bugs

Got

a Devilish

Grin
-

File5=E:\My
me.mp3

Documents\My Documents\My
Documents\My Documents\My

Music\for Music\dan

kris\Julia fogelberg
-

Fordham longer
It
-

Conga.MP3 Someone to

watch

over

File6=E:\My
File7=E:\My File8=E:\My

than

(1).mp3
Be Spring.mp3

Music\Ella FitzgeraldMusic\Megaman Legends

Might

As Well

File9=E:\My Filel0=E:\My Filell=E:\My
File12=\John

Documents\My Music\Jackie Trent Documents\My Music\James Taylor - Mexico.mp3 Documents\My Music\John Mayer - neon.mp3
Mayerways.mp3 Your Body Is a Wonderland.mp3

Last Battle Physique.mp3 & Tony Hatch - The Two Of Us.mp3

File13=E:\My
mysterious

Documents\My Documents\My
Documents\My

Music\for Music\kenny
Music\Marvin

kris\julia loggins
Gaye
-

fordham & michael Sexual Diary

-

love

moves in
-

File14=E:\My
heart.mp3 File15=E:\My

mcdonald

heart

to

Healing.mp3
-

File16=E:\My
Stop Look

Documents\My
Listen To Your

Music\Bridget
Heart.MP3

Jones'

Marvin

Gaye,

Diana

Ross

-

File17=E:\My File18=E:\My File19=E:\My File20=E:\My
File21=E:\My Goodbye

Documents\My Documents\My Documents\My Documents\My
Documents\My

Music\Micheal Music\Michael Music\Michael Music\Upbeat
Music\John

McDonald - What A Fool Believes (1).MP3 Mcdonald - Minute By Minute.mp3 Mcdonald I Keep Forgettin.mp3 Sinatra\Dean Martin - C'est Si Bon.mp3 Barry - Out Of Africa The Music of Sanchez
-

(instrumental).mp3

File22=E:\My
File23=E:\My

Documents\My
Documents\My

Music\Poncho

Mambo de Cuco.mp3

Music\Poncho_Sanchez_Mongo_Santamaria-Conga_Blue-07-Watermelon_Man.mp3

File24=E:\My File25=E:\My
File26=E:\My

Documents\My Documents\My
Documents\My

Music\Prince Music\Fast\Seal
Music\Seal
-

Cream.mp3 - Bring It On.mp3 Kiss From A Rose.mp3
-

File27=E:\My

Documents\My

Music\Seal

Prayer

for

the

Dying.mp3

[Titles] TitleO=A swinging safari Titlel=Ride Like the Wind Title2=Chuck Mangioni - Feel Title3=What Would You Do [Edit

So Good
With Next Episode Interlude]

Title4=Bugs Got a Devilish Grin Conga Title5=Someone To Watch Over Me (1963 Title6=Longer Than Title7=It Might
-

Title8=Juno

As Well Be Spring Last Battle physique

Date:

04/26/2004 Two Of Us

File:

Rossi.pl

#2

Title9=The TitleiO=Mexico Titleii=Neon Title12=John Title13=Love Title14=Heart TitleiS=Sexual Title16=Stop, Title17=Steely

Mayer-

Your

Body

Is

a Wonderland Ways

Moves In Mysterious To Heart Healing look, listen (to Dan What A Fool

your Believe

heart)

(with

Diana

Ross)

Title18=Minute By Minute Title19=I Keep Forgettin Title20=C'est Si Bon Title2i=Out of Africa Title22=Mambo de Cuco Title23=Watermelon Man Title24=Cream Title2S=Bring It On Title26=Kiss From A Rose Title27=Prayer for the Dying [Authors] AuthorO=Bert Kaempfert Authori=Christopher Cross Author2=Chuck Mangione Author3=City Author4=Clint High Mansell/Kronos Quartet

AuthorS=Clooney, Rosemary Author6=Dan Fogelberg Author7=Ella Fitzgerald Author8=J. S. Bach Author9=Jackie Trent & Tony Hatch AuthoriO=James Taylor Authorii=John Mayer Author12=John Mayer Author13=Julia Fordham Author14=Kenny Loggins & Michael Mcdonald AuthoriS=Marvin Gaye Author16=Marvin Gaye Author17=Michael MacDonald Author18=Michael McDonald Author19=Michael McDonald Author20=Mireille Mathieu

Author2i=Movie
Author22=Poncho Author23=Poncho Author24=Prince Author2S=Seal

Love Songs
Sanchez Sanchez

-

Vol

2) [OS] The Music of Goodbye

-

& Mongo Santamaria

Date:

04/26/2004

File:

Rossl.pl

#3

Author26=Seal Author27=Seal [Time] TimeO=l:57 Timel=4:28 Time2=9:33 Time3=3:39 Time4=0:57 Time5=3:40 Time6=3:12 Time7=2:38 Time8=l:32 Time9=3:l0 TimelO=2:58 Timell=4:24 Timel2=4:07 Timel3=4:35 Timel4=5:22 Timel5=4:09 Timel6=2:56 Timel7=3:40 Timel8=3:28 Timel9=3:39 Time20=2:49 Time2l=3:4l Time22=6:52 Time23=3:46 Time24=4:l3 Time25=3:58 Time26=4:48 Time27=5:29

\

,"~

£x: ~ ( b [t

B
i I

II

I

iff I.

i

!

Date:
<?xml

04/l6/2004
version="l.0" encoding='

File:

musicSelection.b4s
standalone="yes"?> 3.0d --> 001">
(Tango). MP3 ">

#1

UTF-8'

<WinampXML> <!-Generated by: Nullsoft <playlist num_entries="40"
<entry Playstring=
-

Winamp3 version label="Playlist
C: \Obj

" file:

ect ion

<Name>Shakira

Objection

(Tango)</Name>

<Length>223137</Length> </entry>

<entry

Playstring="file:C:\Program
Sandoval
-

Files\KaZaA

Lite\Arturo

Sandoval

-

Mambo

Caliente.mp3"> <Name>Arturo

Mambo Caliente</Name>

<Length>206342</Length> </entry>

<entry
Bamboleo.

Playstring="file:C:\Program
mp3 ">
-

Files\KaZaA

Lite\Gypsy

Kings

-

<Name>Gipsy Kings

Bamboleo</Name>

<Length>205879</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:C:\Program - Campina.mp3"> <Name>Afro-Cuban Jazz Project <Length>228180</Length> </entry>

Files\KaZaA - Campina</Name>

Lite\Afro-Cuban

Jazz

Project

<entry
Mexico.

Playstring="file:C:\Program
-

Files\KaZaA

Lite\James

Taylor

-

mp3">

<Name>James Taylor

Mexico</Name>

<Length>176177</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:C:\Program

Files\KaZaA

Lite\John

Barry
-

-

Out Of Out of

Africa

The Music of Goodbye (instrumental).mp3"> <Name>Movie Love Songs - Vol 2) [05] The Music of Goodbye

Africa</Name> <Length>220677</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:C:\Program a Wonderland.mp3"> <Name>John MayerYour Body Is

Files\KaZaA

Lite\John

Mayer-

Your

Body

Is

a Wonderland</Name>

<Length>246942</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:C:\Program Tanga Rumba Afro Cubana.mp3">

Files\KaZaA
-

Lite\Latin

- Mambo Kings

-

<Name>Latin
</entry>

- Mambo Kings

Tanga Rumba Afro

Cubana</Name>

<Length>202794</Length>

I!

I

.. I

I

Date:

04/26/2004

File:

musicSelection.b4s

#2

<entry

Playstring="file:C:\Program
-

Files\KaZaA

Lite\Latin

Jazz

-

Poncho

Sanchez - Conga Blue.mp3"> <Name>Poncho Sanchez
<Length>451874</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My My Life (Live) (1).mp3"> <Name>[Frank Sinatra]

Conga Blue</Name>

Documents\My For Once in My Life

Music\[Frank (Live)

Sinatra]

For

Once in

(l)</Name>

<Length>176023</Length> </entry>

<entry
belief.mp3">

Playstring="file:E:\My

Documents\My

Music\07

-

back to the rivers

of

<Name>ENIGMA- Back to the Rivers
<Length>632354</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My it on.mp3">

of belief</Name>

Documents\My

Music\Al

Green

- Let&apos;s

get

<Name>Al Green

-

Let&apos;s

get it

on</Name>

<Length>240767</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My Love.mp3">

Documents\My

Music\Art

Of Noise

-

Moments In

<Name>Art Of Noise
<Length>414198</Length> </entry>

-

Moments In Love</Name>

<entry
Like the

Playstring="file:E:\My
Wind.mp3">

Documents\My
-

Music\Christopher

Cross

-

Ride

<Name>Christopher

Cross

Ride Like

the Wind</Name>

<Length>267648</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My Sailing. mp3 ">

Documents\My
-

Music\Christopher

Cross

-

<Name>Christopher

Cross

Sailing</Name>

<Length>254605</Length> </entry>

<entry
Away.mp3">

Playstring="file:E:\My Cross
-

Documents\My

Music\Christopher

Cross

-

Swept

<Name>Christopher

Swept Away</Name>

<Length>263048</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My Good.mp3">

Documents\My
-

Music\Chuck

Mangioni

-

Feel

So

<Name>Chuck Mangione
<Length>572976</Length> </entry>

Chuck

Mangioni

-

Feel

So Good</Name>

!I

I.

;"

~

I

'

Date:

04/26/2004

File:

musicSelection.b4s

#3

<entry
to watch

Playstring="file:E:\My
over me.mp3">

Documents\My
-

Music\Clooney,

Rosemary

-

Someone

<Name>Clooney,

Rosemary

Someone To Watch Over Me (1963</Name>

<Length>220325</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My Really Love To See You Tonight.
-

Documents\My mp3">

Music\Dan

Fogelberg

-

I&apos;d

<Name>Dan Fogelberg
<Length>157983</Length> </entry>

I&apos;d

Really

Love To See You Tonight</Name>

<entry
Into

Playstring="file:E:\My
-

Documents\My Crash Into

Music\Dave

Mathews Band

-

Crash

Me.mp3">

<Name>Dave Mathews Band
<Length>316074</Length> </entry>

Me</Name>

<entry
(acoustic)

Playstring="file:E:\My
.mp3">

Documents\My

Music\Dave

Mathews Band

-

Crazy

<Name>Dave Mathews Band - Crazy
<Length>270346</Length> </entry>

(acoustic)</Name>

<entry
Crush.mp3">

Playstring="file:E:\My Band
-

Documents\My Crush</Name>

Music\Dave

Mathews Band

-

<Name>Dave Matthews
<Length>488237</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My As Well Be Spring. <Name>Ella mp3'1> Fitzgerald-

Documents\My It Might As Well

Music\Ella

Fitzgerald-

It

Might

Be Spring</Name>

<Length>158777</Length> </entry>

<entry
lust.mp3">

Playstring="file:E:\My
-

Documents\My of Lust</Name>

Music\Enigma

-

principles

of

<Name>Enigma

Principles

<Length>708057</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My Being In Love.mp3">
-

Documents\My

Music\Frank

Sinatra

-

Almost

Like

<Name>Frank Sinatra
<Length>123823</Length> </entry>

Almost

Like

Being

In Love</Name>

<entry
In

Playstring="file:E:\My
-

Documents\My It

Music\Frank

Sinatra

-

It

Happened

Monterey.mp3">

<Name>Frank Sinatra
<Length>157526</Length> </entry>

Happened In Monterey</Name>

,,

I

I

j ! IIi

i

I

Date:

04/26/2004

File:

musicSelection.b4s

#4

I(

<entry Playstring="file:E:\My Documents\My <Name>Herb Alpert - rise</Name>
<Length>456152</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My Girl.mp3">

Music\Herb

Alpert

-

Rise.mp3">

!

Documents\My

Music\Jamiroquai

-

Cosmic

<Name>Jamiroquai

-

Cosmic Girl</Name>

<Length>244480</Length> </entry>

<entry

Playstring="file:E:\My <Name>Jamiroquai - Little

Documents\My L</Name>

Music\Jamiroquai

-

Little

L.mp3">

<Length>295270</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My bottle.mp3">

Documents\My Message in

Music\john

mayer

- message

in

a

<Name>John Mayer

-

(Cover)

a Bottle</Name>

<Length>262512</Length> </entry>

<entry
Skyline.mp3">

Playstring="file:E:\My Fordham
-

Documents\My Manhattan

Music\Julia

Fordham

-

Manhattan

<Name>Julia

Skyline</Name>

<Length>290304</Length> </entry>

<entry
of the

Playstring="file:E:\My
Loggins
-

Documents\My Conviction

Music\kenny

logging

-

conviction

heart.mp3"> <Name>Kenny

Of The Heart</Name>

<Length>413574</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My

Documents\My

Music\kenny
-

logging

&amp;

michael

mcdonald - heart to heart. <Name>Kenny Loggins
<Length>322490</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My In Tunisia.mp3">

mp3"> &amp; Michael

Mcdonald

Heart

To Heart</Name>

Documents\My
-

Music\Maynard

Ferguson

-

A Night

<Name>Maynard Ferguson
<Length>877841</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My -Brak - Eating Bugs.mp3">

A Night

in

Tunisia</Name> r

Documents\My

Music\Space

Ghost

Coast

to

Coast

<Name>Brak

-

Eating

Bugs</Name>

<Length>43583</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring="file:E:\My

Documents\My

Music\Space

Ghost

-

Brak - Poo

Poo Poo Platter.mp3">

'I

I,

i.

I

, I

I.

(

Date:

04/26/2004 <Name>Space Ghost
-

File:

musicSelection.b4s

#5'

Brak

-

Poo Poo Poo Platter</Name>

<Length>74565</Length> </entry>

<entry

Playstring="

<Name>Calypso

file: E: \My Documents\My - Limbo song</Name>

Music\Calypso

-

Limbo song. mp3">

<Length>157545</Length> </entry> <entry Playstring=" file:

E: \My Document s\My
-

Mus ic\zap

mama

-

iko

iko.

mp3 ">

<Name>The Belle

Stars

Iko

Iko</Name>

<Length>172808</Length> </entry>

<entry Playstring="file:E:\My Documents\My Music\Disney Soundtracks - Jungle Book - I WanDa Be Like You. mp3"> <Name>Disney Soundtracks - Jungle Book - I WanDa Be Like You</Name>
<Length>190891</Length> </entry>

<entry

Playstring="file:
-

<Name>The Merrymen <Length>170475</Length> </entry> </playlist> </WinampXML>

E: \My Documents\My Bum Bum</Name>

Music\Merrymen

-

Bum Bum. mp3">

,!

I

i I

~

I

.( J

.,
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16

. PROOF OF SERVICE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

1

I am employedin the county of Los Angeles,Stateof California. I am over the ageof 18, and not a party to the within action; my businessaddress Mitchell Silberberg& Knupp LLP, is 11377West Olympic Boulevard,Los Angeles,CA 90064-1683. On April 26, 2004, I servedthe foregoing document(s)describedas PLAINTIFF WARNER BROS. RECORDS INC.'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT PLANK on the partiesin this actionby placing a true copy thereofenclosed in sealedenvelopes addressed follows, and taking the action describedbelow: as JasonSchultz,Esq. Wendy Seltzer Electronic Frontier Foundation 454 Shotwell Street SanFrancisco,CA 94110

0 0

BY FAX: Insteadof placing a copy of the documentin a sealedenvelope,]I senta copy of the above-described document(s) telecopierto eachof the individuals setforth via above,at the following facsimile telephonenumbers: BY OVERNIGHT MAIL: I depositedthe above-described document(s) with - in the ordinary courseof business, depositingthe document(s)in a box regularly maintained by by or delivering the document(s) an authorizeddriver for the carrier, in an to envelopedesignated the carrierwith delivery feesprovided for, addressed shown by as above. BY PERSONAL DELIVERY: I caused personaldelivery by of the document(s) listedaboveto theperson(s) theaddress(es) forth above. at set

17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Mitchell Silberberg& Knupp LLP

0

I

[8J BY PLACING FOR COLLECTION AND MAILING: i sealedandplacedthe envelope(s) collection andmailing following ordinary business for practices. I am readily familiar with the firm's practicefor collection andprocessingof correspondence for mailing with the United StatesPostalService. Under that practiceit would be depositedwith the U.S. PostalServiceon that sameday with postagethereonfully prepaidat 11377West Olympic Boulevard,Los Angeles,CA 90064-1683in the ordinary courseof business. Executedon April 26, 2004, at Los Angeles,California. I declarethat I am employedin the office of a memberof the bar of this court at whose direction the servicewas made. Michele Collins