You are on page 1of 25

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 1 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

RI CHARD 1FNE .I Prsne I #1 2 3 7 io rD 8 4 6 coMe 'Ce ta Ji / ns nrl al 4 Ba c tSre 41 uhe tet LosAn ee, 9 01 g ls CA 0 2 UNI S TED TATESCOURT OFAPP EALS FOR THENI CI T NTH RCUI
RI CHARD 1FI . NE, Ap eln a Peiin r p la t nd tto e,
VS .

CaeNo s .

U. DI CTCOIRT, S. STRI J Ap elea dRep n e t p l n so d n. e
SHERI OFIOSANGCLVS FF X î COUNTY

( a Pryl ltrs) Rel at n neet

EMERGE MOT ON T NCY I O I MMEDI ATELY RELEAS E APPELLANTFNEFROM I I NCARCERATI PENDI ON NG APP EAL, PERMANENTLY, OR AND I MMEDI S GRANT ATEIY T4OSTI ASY 11EWASNO IEWRI TO 1R D I T HE1 Pl'l ON ON '- ï' -E OPl 1Tl F WRI OFHABEASCORPUS, OR T DUEP ROCES WASVI S OLATED

B J DG YAF E'R F AL Y U E F S E US
TO RECUS HI ELF, E MS DUE P ROCESSWASVI OLATED BY

DI TRI COLRTJ S CT J UDGE, AND TlE MAGITRATEJJ S 4 S IDGE' REPORT& RECOMMENDATI ON D1 NOTREF T OR F D ER O OLLOW THEL ES SJ REMECOURT AT T IP PRECEDENT

T4 ACTONSO TlE I F l m MAGIT EJJ ANDTSRAT LDGE 1/ l

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 2 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

l

TABLEOFCONTENTS

2 1toleif...........................:ro!)o mélrt( s el lrtlt 1...........................1rr1ok tk1 l n ( l t O .......................... r o e . 3

4 1 é cntuin l adle a L Co nyP y nst L S pro Co rJdeDai . ç o si t a' n l gl A ut ame t o A u eir utu g vd un t o ' l P Yaf ViltdteDu PoesClueadMa dtdHiReua ........4 . fe oae h e rcs as n n ae s csl. ....... . . .. 5 6 l. -l 1lt) 1)'r (7-tkt((yzilrll)kl..-...............1) 1 11 3til 7rp i )lflg yIl s-llnsk.............-.... ( -e kitl ( / t 1llls )ns lt)( l .................. 7 11 T e sit ut oae T eDu Poes as .... rrBok r n tdfn dl 1. h DitcCorViltd h e rcs Clue...Ero! o mak o eie . r ... 8 A. Mait t Jd eWohl adJd eWatrS o l Ha eReue T e ev s rrB o makn gsr e u g ere n u g l h ud v csd hmsleEro! k r t a e
9 . . . . 1. .7tir'zutl le 2 ISr 24 ....................-.3 3 1. ltcC rAia d 8JCj 23 -......-.............1 .e sit o o t ' l ........... ......... l 0 l Reotn Reo n ainAp rv db teCou ViltdDu PoesEro! o m n t ei/ V. p rad cmmed t poe yh t' oae e rcs rrBok o t o df n 1 1 hs s sh aet t t fh lona u g so n aigu Aeeso e f 1 V. T iCaeiteL tsAt mp o teCai ri Jde t DeyMenn fl cs t 2 teCo r adPee th F iFmcinn o teCaionaJdca S se ....... h ut n rv n te ar l t ig fh l ri u iil ytm ......6 s o f .....1 1 3

l V1 1eeS)11'l rel)1eiC .............................l 4 - NcSi77-ïA jfl ;1 - ............................. $ i t ( f e ; tJ ' ..........................-..) )l e
1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1. 9 g g 2 1 2 2 2 3 : 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8

.
. . .'

.

.
.

. ,

.

.

.

.

.. .

..

.

.

.

.

! 1 i p 1
'

i i
. . .

l

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 3 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

TABLE OFAUTHORI ES TI

8 9

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 4 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

t

z

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 5 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1
2

I to cin sr du to

3
5 6 z

Apeln/eioe Rcad1Fn (eenfrTie'apaigipo pl t tinr ihr . iehriat t n',p er n r apt e ) n
hsço tmp'i rfsn t c mpywi av i a du cntuin lt re' i ç ne t n euig o o l t od n n o si to a ç d r c ' h t o '

4 p r h sb e u lwfl icreae s c Mac 4 2 0 ,nc n e u n efr e, a en na ul n acrtd i e rh , 0 9 i o sq e c o y n ise b LA S p ro Co r J d eDa i P. featrc n u t gah aig su d y u eir ut u g vd Yaf f o d ci ern e n 8 Whc o c re wi o tn t et o atn a c b Fn ,ytd rn whc Fie ih c urd t u oi o r t d n e y ie e uig ih n h c e
wa od rd t pa atr y' fe a d c ss J d Yaf t n ltrsti s ree o y tone s es n o t. u ge fe he ae a n

9 t o

l jdmet fh tu fles f io tsmoyi poonigFn dul ' l ug n O tert uns o hs wn et n n rnuc iet iy' h i n gt 1 2 mp o i eua t nwe usi s n od ug n etr o 1 o cne tfrhsrfsl o as rq et n i av i jd metdbo 3 f ot
1 po edn . 4 rc e ig
1 5

j 6
1 7 1 8

Fn'wh l ujspeia n iterslo yassetee lrl ies ol nut rdemetsh eut f er pn xmpai y y
a v ct g n meo s tx a e cas at n a d cvl r hs ise whc d o ai u r u a p y r ls ci n ii i t su s ih n o g
. .

1 scesul fre c reto a di rv me to vaiu ilg lpatcsb 9 u c sfl ocd orcin n mpo e n f ro s le a rcie y y . ' 2 L Co ny te i rcn yasf hig(n fin)t peetugswh j A u t, hn n eet er i t ad al' o rvù jd e o gn ig
2 1 weeie al rc ii s btnil o u p y nsfo LA Co ny whihwa r l g l eevng u sata b n s a me t rm l y u t, c s 2 .. 2

2 a atif n o teugst mpeiigoe sc css 3 pr n r t fh jde,k rs n vruh ae. y o o d
. .

2 4

.

.

.

'

'

2 j (nteudr igcs, ies lnsogtopeeth apoao a 1 h neln aeFn'ci tsuh t rvnte prvlf n y e 2 E vrn na l at eotER whc wa tesbet f niea vtb 6 n i metlmpcR p r(1) i sh ujco a lgl oe y o h l
2 7

21 ebroL Cutsot(Sptssutcnitnmdbt 1 8 mme fA ol'Ba $ ueirdeoot uos aeyh s - 'f -o l d v y ri b e
j

l. 1

.

I -

..

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 6 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 d v lp rt eeto cmp in o Bo r me r,a n s oh rti s Th e eo e o lcin a ag s f ad mbes mo gt te hng . e
2

3 et o teug n apo igteERflwe apoe ptr whri L nr fh jdmetp rvn h 1 ol d rvn aen een A y o t 4 ConySpro Corjde weefudt hv cnitnl dcddcssi ut ueir utugs r on o ae osset eie ae n y
5 6

fv r o LA Co ny al te whl p c eig sbtnilie a p y ns ao f u t l h i o k t u sat l g l a me t e n a l

7 atoie b C ut Spri r. uhr d y ony u evs s z o)
8

9

Anotcroftec utFiewa s r a do lg dt riea dp ru fie h o r, n s won n bie o as n use

1 teise d srb dh ri. Rahrta otiigjsc adfiadhns 0 h su s ecie een te hn bann ute n ar n o et i 1 1 s 1 srie frtx a es h we e,hs efr h v ise d b e mac e b 2 evc s o a p y r, o v r i fot a e nta en th d y

1 jdcaosrcincnel n,eiln rtlto. 3 uiilbtut ,ocametdnaad eaiin o a
1 4

1 5 Fiesat n , o v rhv jsrcnl be Wh l eoeae b t n ' ci sh we e, àeuteet en ol xhrtd y wo o y y 1 hg e 6 ih rordcsos () trenvC utt-t A glsif , ihll cut ei n: lSugo . onypfp nee,nr whc a d i /v, s a e 1 7

1 ta ol teSaelgstr ma sttecmpnaino jd e,ad() 8 ht ny h tt eiaue y e h o est .fu gs n 2 l o
1 Ca etnv A. MasyCb? Co,nc,i r,whc c nin du e uv c l 9 p ro . T se ) .I . nfa ih o f e n q io al / n y
2 0

2 ta jde rciigmoisfo prisi cssbfr te mutrcs 1 ht ugs eevn ne rm at n ae eoe hm s eue e
2 te ev s 2 h msle.
2 3

.

.

.

.

2 4
2 5 2 6

No po e c retby n a y d u t Fi si rman ic reae w rv n orc e o d n o b, ne tl e is n acrtd l

'

whl tecnltdUS jde hv cnpcosyaoddi lmetù i h o fce DC ugs ae osiuul vie mpe nig e i

ut rcd ns v n n he a e f no p st o nes 2 teU. Su rmeCo r pee e t,e e i t fc o no -p oiint Fi ' 7 h S. pe o

a! a1
( ( t 1
i 1 .

j
-' ? .
.

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 7 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

l Ptin frWr o HaesCopsf m teRepnet(hrg teL eio o i f ba ru r h sodn Sei , h A t t o f g ' 3 Spr r or adteug wh cnutdte otmppoedn . u ei C ut n h jd e o odce h cne t rceig o ,
4 5

l adt n t myidrao sa d go n sstfr h rib lw whc n d io o ra e sn n ru d e ot een eo ih i h

6 ru dy sp oth ga to ti E re c Moin i so l b n tdta o n l u p r te rn f hs meg n y t , t h ud e oe h t o 7 US J d eJ h F Watra dMa itaeJ d eCal M.Wohl cald DC u g o n . l n gsrt u g ra e ere rf e
8

h i c mme d t n d r ep ciey to t ve ninn h o 9 terRe o n ain a d Ore,rsetv l, wih u e n me to ig te 1 a pia it o C p ro ,ifa d si teri l rcit f n o p ru i t 0 p l bly f a etn nr, ept h it y e ep o a d p o tnt o c i e me y
) 1 1 2
1 . 1 1 5 1 6 1 7

rve c n ie a dfl w sme a dd si J d eWatrsasrino aGe e iw, o sdr n ol a , n ept u g l ' set f G o e e o d p n igMoint S t ieJ d me ti teq s rltdt hsS ib r n ' e dp t o e Asd u g n n h ae eae o i i same f, o d
ifa wi n rao gi nfrteo vi sL od'ttso h c s. nr, t o esn ve o h b ou t l'sau fte ae h h I i èertéeoe ta gi ntercn p biaino d cso whc t b la,h rfr,h t ve h ee t u lcto f e iins ih . d tr nete o to a d c n e u n e o t ilg lat ofLA S peir eemi h ucme n o sq e cs f he le a cs u ro
. '

1 n v 'rviw o teetr rc r Th US as rf e t rl o Fie' 3 o o' e e f h nie eod. e DC lo euss o ue n n s

1 8
' 2 0 2 1
2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 z y

1 e o eaeFn ,telwe c ut aeu pe ae ,u wiig o smpy ari t 9 x n rt ie h o r o rs r n rp rd n ln r i l fad o l

2 C utugsadL C ut iefb adtruhi Bor o Spri r, 2 orjde n A ony t l y n hog t ad f uevs s s, s o
p sigtedfiut r o wada du t ti Co r. asn h i c lwok n r n p o hs ut f
. . . . . '

.

' .

'

Men i ,Fi c niu s t b u a ul d nid hs fed m, a d a whl ne o tn e o e nlwf l e e i ke o n e y i o el twatd fo er n a y i o , rs tn i e te fnnca mprp ry h re rm anig n nc me eulig n xrme ia il

2joslnetha 8 cnyu c ei. ye s n
1 1 t i

l
.
. .
.

1

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 8 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

l
2 3 5 6 7

T i Co r i teeoersetul mo e t tk u te ma t a d hs u t s h rfr ep cfl v d o a e p h nl n y e ac mpi tewoktelse c ut h v a ad n d a d big menn fl co l h h r h esr o rs a e b n o e , n rn a igu s miinCaiona siwa itn e t sre lo l rin t sne d d o ev. l f
1 ç o tt ina'an llg lLA Co nt Pa nst LA Sup ro . é nsiuto l d le a unc ' u y yme t o e ir Co tJ geDa i P.Yaf Viltd te Due Pr cs Cl s an ur ud vd fe oae h o es aue d M a ae Hi Re u a nd td s c s l Thsi acs wh r LA S p ro Co r Jd eDa i P Yaf rcie i s ae ee u eir ut u g vd . fe e ev d

4 acs t tecutb rtmigafiadhnsjdca sse t te3 ces o h or y eu n ar n oetu i l ytm o h 8 s i

8 9 1 0
1 1 1 2
1 4 1 5

ç n o si t n l a die a p y nsfo L Co nywhl teCo nywa é c nt ui a' n l g l a me t rm A u t i h u t s u to ' l e
tn n ilitrs sae nsrq ie t b fldwihteSae Hete deie i a ca neet ttme t e urd o e i t h tt. h n cd d e

1 a p ry a p ai b fr hm. He dd n tdsls sc o hsFom 7 0 3 at p erng eoe i i o icoe u h n i r 0

, cssi fvro L Cony (e 1/20 ReotrsTasrp o tsi n 6 ae n ao f A ut. Se 22/8 pre' rncit fet y mo
.l 8

1 9 Jd eYaf, tce t P tinfrWr o HaesCop s) Heddnt V f u g fe al hd o eio q i f b/ ru . a t t i o
.
1 9

rc s hi efi ete tecsso teltrcne tpoce.ig wheeh eu e msl n i r h ae r h ae o tmp r edn , r e h .
. .'
' .

. .

. . .

2 jd e hs wnatn; 0 ugd io ci s o
2 1

2 2
2 3

Th LA Co nyp y nso apo i tl $ 63 0pry a weehl t e u t amet f p rxmaey 4 ,0 e er r ed o voaeAril VlS c 1 , fh CaionaCo si t ni tecs o Sug o ilt t e , e . 9 o te l ri ntui n h ae f tre n c f to

2 v Co n 0'T Anee,l7Ca.p .t60(08,e.dne 1/30 . 5 . u% /Ll gls 6 t p4h 3 20)rv eid 22/8 s A
2 Saepy nsa u tdt apo i tl $188 0pe y a, vn hm attl 6 tt amet mone o prxmaey 7 , 0 r ergiig i oa
2 7 cr : .
.

! j
.

.

.

' . . .

.. .. . .

' .

.

. ' ' ' .

.
.

( ..
. .. .

j
j

1 1 j 1 t
j .

. . ' .
' .

1 * ! ;

.

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 9 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 an a cmpnaino apo i tl $ 4 ,0 prya icu ighsSae n ul o e st f p rxmaey 2 90 0 e er nldn i tt o
2 3 4 5
7 8

h at,ei me t n oh r e eh . el rt e n a d te b n fs h r

T eL C ut py nsad a1cut py nst jde wee h A ony amet n l ony amet o u gs r
whc gv rtociei nt fo gr nlpoeuin gii lbly ih ae erat mmui rm ci al rsct ,cvl i it v y mi o qa i

6 lgsae a ie a a dci n l n e S n t Bi $ BX21 ' e atd22 /9 e iltd s l g l n rmia u d r e ae l ç l lS 15 n ce /00 , ,
nd icpiay cin o o en na niis r fcr r mplyes f 9 a dsiln r ato t g vrme tle tte, o ofieso e o e o 1 g v rme tle tte, beueo bnfspoie t ajd eo tegons 0 o en na niis eas f eet rvdd o ug n h rud i
1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4

ta toeb n ft ween t uh rzdu d rlw. h th s e ei r o a toie n e a s T e LA Co ny py ns cmme c d i te 1 8 s a d h v b e h u t ame t o n e n h 9 0 n a e en

'
.

1 cùiuu.(treh sïr. Py nsb öh?cute tjde eitdi 5 ot os Sugo ,t a) amet y te onisou gs xse n n p 1 6 alCai ri c u t s e cp S n l a cso Medcn ad Yoo (a l lona o ni x e t a ' n ic , noio n l. Sn f e a r l 7 radù r k rie u t ma a e é et t p d h lp yn nk) d e yo j Beni ioaf Riesd Co nis yh v renl s p e ter aiet. a
1 9 7 n
2 2 2 3

.

.

.

J d e rc iigp y nsfo c u te,wih fw e cpin,h v n t u g s e evn a me t rm o nis t e x eto s a e o n tdslsdtepame t o terFom 7 0 fn n ildslsr sae nt. o icoe h y ns n h i r 0 ia ca icoue ttme s

,

2 r.c e te ev si c sswh r tec u't i'apat b fr te a dh ve 1 eusd h msl.e n ae ee h o ny s ry eoe h m n a ' ' ' '

2 F rh r i LA Co ny teCo nyCo ne' An u l t ainRe ot frF 4 u te,n u t,h u t u sl n a Lig t p rs o Y s i o
2 5 2 6 z z
.

2 0 -0 6 a d 2 0 -0 7 so ta n to ep ro wo a cs a an tLA 0 52 0 n 0 62 0 h w h t o n esn n ae g is

C ut whnaL Spr r u'jdedcddtecs.( cmet wee ony e A uei Col ug eie h ae Dou ns r o t
.
'. .

2laopaisnotatl 8l l fldgicnnt-. p- e n epJ ) t i a
' ' . .

. .

.

. ' . .

.'
' '

. . .' .

.
'

'

l
.

' ..

.

' ..

.

.

l 1

' -

l

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 10 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1
2 3
5

Jd eYaf, teL Spr rC ut n C lo ajde voae te u g fe h A uei or ad ai mi ugs il d h o f t

Cai ri Co eo J dca Etisa dted epo esca s b n trc sn lona d f u iil hc n h u rc s lu e y o e uig f

4 te ev s h msle.

6
7 8 1 0

C nn2o teCai riC d oJdcaEhc s tsht dug sa ao fh lona oe fuiil tis te taajd e hl f a l aodi rpit adteapaac o i rpit i alo tejdes vi mpor y n h perne f mpor y n l f h u g, e e

9 atvte' ciiis' *

. .

1 1 T eqet nint e e tejdeiatal bae, u k ehra h uso s o wht rh u g s cul isd btç te i h y wh 1 pro a r o tefcs gtesnbyduth jd e udb alt at 2 esn wae fh atmihraoal ob teug wo l e beo c 1 3 t n gi, mprii n o eec' eg, e l . re, 9 h t t at ' 1 wi i ery i at ly ad cmptne (.. SeHalv Hàkr 6 1 . 1 C:.Ap .l86 8 1(99.F r e, P j101a()ststa ajd e' ' 5 l p4l 3 , 4 19) ut rCC t 'h ' 7 .()3 t e ht ug ' a 1 6 mut edsulidih o seda atnnilneetitesbet tri sb iqaie f e rh t s 'acaitrs n h ujcmat n f h i e 1 7 n ' t n, z x y ' . l . Poed j rnay ay o h Joed g , h j .sp o coljd e. 8 a rcei b i n Pl t te rcei . T e y uuy utggs
1 rcie apo i tl $ 0miinprya fo LA Co ny o a po maey 9 eev d p rxmaey 2 lo e er rm l u t, r p rxi tl . 2 0 . . l n 2 $ 0 miins c 1 8 . 1 3 0 lo i e 9 8
2 2 2 3
2 5 2 6
'

Th U. S pe Co l pee e t h l ta t fi r t re eo eef e S. u rme u' rod ns od h the al e o eus n sl t u

2 i ad na o d epo es T eron d cso o Ca etn e a, . T Mà sy. 4 s e il f u re s. h eet eiin f p ro , t IvAL se
Co Co.ft.e al5 6U.S (09 dcdd680,edtaee alre al ,/ , t , 6 . 20) eie //9 hl htvn ag c 2 cmp inc nrb to fo ap ro wi ap tnil aeb fr ae utt a 7 a ag o tiuin rm esn t oe t c s eoe o r o h a

2(api cl ieuprnt eqooaugtt cu,siitI 8 c anomt spoi h ltnfj eoh prAdtc m g a t tg e ei d e t sn e
.

j t 1
1 1

t ' -

.

.

J
l

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 11 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

t f m adrccnr uint teug'cmpin rqi sh jdet rcs r i t otbt o h jdes a ag,eur teug o eue o e i o e
2 3 5

hmslfo tep rysc s.T i it d gesfr e rmo e fo adrd i efrm h at' ae hs s wo e re ut r e v d rm i h e

.

4 py nt teug,s curdwi tecutpy ns ametoh jdea ocre t h ony amet. h
6 T eLA Conypy nsadohrcut py nst jde rqie h ut amet n te ony amet o ugs eur 7 rcsl neteojciesadr a s tdi Wi rwvL ri,2 U..5 euaudrh bet tnad ste n t o . akn4 1 S3 , v a h 8 9 4 (95 -i' poait o ata ba o tepro teug o dcs n 7 17) sh rbbly f cul is n h at fh jde r eii -e f i o
1 ma e itohg t b c n tuin l tlrbe' Cie i Ca ro spr, t 0 k r s o ih o e o si t al oea l.' td n petn,u a a to y
1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4
'

Si Opno p g 1 l iin a e . p
Th Co l i Ca ro spa sae a Sl Opno p g 6 ctn I Re e u' n petn, u r, ttd t i iin a e , i g n t p i rqurme ofd eprc s' Ciig Muc io , spr,3 9 U. a 1 6 i e ie nt u o es' tn rhs n u a 4 S. t 3 , t .
. . .

1 'Nùcio, 4 U..13 16(9 5:tA.fitiln'fitiu aiabjc' 5 lrhsn 39 S 3,3 15) ç jarrai a arrbnls ai g
1 6 1 7
..1 9

l sae:< la chb au g ih. o . cs. B ttd .< t n a e jden i wn ae' s ' . No z
.
. . . .

. ,
..

.

2 0

Ass e i Ca etn spa a Si Opno p g 11 utd n p ro ,u r, t lp iin a e :
teeia u o siuina t tnilo bis. h r s n nc nt to lpoeta fr a ' t

2 1 k'ecutssntwhte tejdeiatal,ujcieybae, u kh orak o ehrh ug s cu l sbet l isd bt r l y v 2 Fhte teaeaejdei lspsini tkl'ob nurlo whte 2 ehrh vrg u g n i oio s ley t e et , r ehr i t l a
2 3

T qcutfr e tf e teojciesadr a fl wsa l. Sl h or ut r l i d h bet tn ad s ol t d i h en v o 2 4 p 2 Opno p g 1 5 iin a e 3:
2 6

2 7
.

2jscai oauli opjge tt erte u bfbdnf 8juh rkfcabsrru mnh t pccms eoiei1 s t a ed t ah ai t rd
. . . . '.

ûnd f igteesa drstec ut a ak dwh te,ûn e araitc û ei n h s tn ad h o r h s se eh r u d r e lsi l n a maslo py h o ia tn e ce a dh ma wek es'teitrs ç ss p ia f sc olgc le d n is n u n a n s, h neet poe
. . . .
.. . .

.

. J

.

'

. . . .

. .

..

.

'

'
. .

'

. '

.s

'

''

I .. j ( j

t j

.; 4 .
' . .

j
.

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 12 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 teg aateo d ep o esi t b a e utl i lme td' Wi rw,4 h u rne f u rcs s o e d q aey mpe ne . t o 21 h 2 U. , t4 . S.a 7' ' 3 Th Co l, i Ca ro spa frh rsae a pa e 1 t.. ojcie e u' n petn, u r, ute ttd t g 6:ç bet t . v
4 5

sa d rsma as rq ierc slwh te o n tata ba e i so cnb tn ad y lo e ur eu a eh r r o cu l is xs r a e t

6 so d Du poesç ysmei s a tajde wh hv n ataba hwe. e rcs ma o t brrlugs o ae o c l is me i u 7 adwh wol d ter eybst weg tesae ojsieeul bt e n o ud ohivr eto ih h cls fut qal ewen c y 8
9 c ne dn p ris. Mu c io 3 9 U.S a 16. The fiue t cnsd r o tn ig at ' rhsn, 4 e .t 3 alr o o ie
1 0 1 1

ojcies nad rqin rcslint oss n wi tei eaie o bet t drs eur g eua s o cniet t h mprt s f v a i t h v

1 d ep o es Wefn Bln e si' sg icn a ddsrp ro aeit e c 2 u rcs. id a k n hps inf a t n ip o ot n t nl n e i i u 1 c u ld wi tetmp rlrlt n hp bt e teeeto a d tep n ig 3 o pe t h e oa eai si ewen h lcin n h e dn h o

l c s .. frap sil tmpaint tea ea e...jdet ..çdhm nto j ae .ofç ojbe e tto o h v rg u g o .la i o. t
1 h dteb ln e nie cera tu .'Aen 1ï Isrn eCo vL vi, 7 6 ol h aa c, c , la nd re ta / nua c . . aoc 4 5 è 1 U.S 83(96,t85(ut gWadv Vlg o Moreie 49U.. 7 7 . 1 181a 2 qoi r . iae f povl , 0 S 5 n l l
.
. '

1 4

.1 8

.

,

1 (92 a6,ntr qoigTme vO i,7 U.. 1 (97 a52. 9 17) t 0i up ut u v . ho23 S50 12) t3)' n '
. .

2 0

'

.

2 1
2 3 2 4 2 6 2 7
..

l tei tn cs, u g Yaf rc i dt C n o ttto a'ilg lLA n h nsat ae J d e fe e eve he s c nsiuin l l a u 'e
Hà o r.Aso it v Co nvolo An ee, AS CaeNo BS19 2 . me wnes s cai . u. f 's g lsL C ' . 0 4 0 on . t s

2 Co ny p y ns i te u d ryn c j o Mà ia srzt Coo v 1 2 u t a me t n h n elig ae f rn 't / ln 1 /n
'

2 Heddn trc s hi ef On 180 , fe Fn h dlf tec s,heod rd 5 i o eu e msl. //8 atr ie 4 et h ae ree Fiet p yatre n te a c sst LA Co nya isc -p iattra n o a ton ys - s nd ot o e u t nd t oa pl n - n c o
' . '

t 21Envionmentil actRepor, Dl e Sosot eteadDl e t 81 r a mp eRy hr Ji Vnr n eRy e n u
. . '
. .

.

' .. .

.

1 / 1
1 1

8 -

.

! 1

.

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 13 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 Soe Jit nue r (DeR ySoe'.Sc 180 odr iltdte hrs on VetrNot C l e hrs) uh //8 re voae h hç '
2 3

Cai r i P bcReo re Co e l as voae ted epo esca s a i lona u i sucs d . t lo iltd h u rc s lu e s t f

4 wa gvnwi ot oi o Fn bigpeetth haig (e Til xii s ie t u nte r ie en rsn ate er . Se r E hbt h c n a 5 I atce tPtin) A t hdo eio. a t 6
7 8

JdeYaf wa sbeunl dsulidfrntepnigt aCCPj ug fe susqet iqaie o o rsodn o y f 9 103Obet n (e Til xii2 atce tPtin) 7. -ci . Se raE hbt 1 tahdo eio. j o t
1 0

1 1

Dept s c dsu l iain De Re S oe po ed d t atmp t si u h iq aict , l y h rs rc e e o t t o e f o e

1 efre a vi jdmetfratre' fe ad cs otie at te 2 noc od ug n o t nys es n ot band fr h , o s e 1 3 s ic i r i h e t 1 d qaf ao truh dbo'ea nt nowhc Fn ojc d adle 4 i uli t nhog a et s xmiao t i ie bet ,n a r
.

1 acné t rceigb fr JdeYaf. 5 o tmp po edn eoe. g fe u
1 6

'

'

.

' '

' .

..

I g
1 8 1 9

Fiec aln e Jd eYaf' prsdn a tecne tprc e n a a n h l g d u g fes eiig t h o tmp o edig s e

voaino depoeso tegonsta aciczdjdecudntug il o f u rcs n h rud ht ri e u g ol o jde t ti . 2 hso cnutta ajdecudntug hso at n,adta te 0 i wn odc,ht ug ol o jde i wn ci s n hth o
2 rc it f h C n o si t n l a die a L Co nyp y nsrq i dJ d e 1 e ep o te i cn tui a' n l g l A u t a me t e ur u g u to ' l e
. '.

2 2 . Yaf t rc s hmsl. fe o e ue i ef 2 3 ' 2. . . ' 4 .. . . . . .. . . . . Jd eYaf'rfslorcs hmslfo b t teVaiaSrn cs u g f s eua t eue i efrm oh h rn ta d ae e 2 5

a ad t c ne tpo edn voae te d e po es ca s a sown b 6 n he o tmp rce ig iltd h u rcs lu e s h y
2 7

..

21aymentofapprxi tl of28% ofhi stt slr by acourt whih i a l 8p o màey j ae aày i c s y
' .

Cq etn spr, n tec ssctdt ri. Th :n o ttto a,a tkjg j p ro , u a a d h ae ie heen e ( c nsiuin l njje a , u
. . . . . .
.

,

.

.

' .

.

.

'.

l l @ t

-( ?

I !

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 14 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 p r b fr hm,c mbn d wi rto cie i nt fr rciig s c at eoe i o ie t erat mmu i o eevn u h y h v y
2 3 5

p y ns Ee d hm n tt h l teb ln e nc , la a dtu ' Ca etn a me t,ç a s i o o od h aa c , ie ce r n re. - ro l p

4 Si Opno p g 1 a c ssctdt ri. l iin a e 3 nd ae i heen p e 6 l.Th PeiinFo W rto Ha a Co pusiUn poe l e tto r i f be s r s op sd
7 8

Thi i a a p a o a u o oe Peio frWrtofHa esCop s s s n p e l f n n pp sd tt n o i i b a ru

9jtetn)id31/ .O 4 19t Rsodn(hrgm vdtb ( ti 'fe / 0 n / / ,h e netSei oe o e % i ' l 99 20 e p p o f
l dimisda Rep n e to,i teatraie ta teMa itaeJd e; ie , O s se s so d n r n h l n t ,h th gsrt u g ( rd . ; ) e v d
1 1

1 teLA S peirCo r a J d eYaf t a s r a dt iet De Re Sh rs 2 h u ro u t nd u g fe o nwe, n t rc' l y oe d '
1 t a s r Th Ma srt Jd eç ietd's c a s r o 42 /9 3 o n we. e gi ae u g i rce 'u h nwes n /30 . t d
1 z l

1 5
1 6 1 7 1 9

On62/9 teDitii utu g hl tateS ei s42/9Moin /90 ,h sr Co rJd e ed h th hrf /10 t c f o

t Dimis( ce#1) s eida motn tateDeRe Soe 580 o s s Dokt 2 wa dne s o ad hth 1 y h rs //9 1 ExPreAp laintltreewa dne a mot 8 at pi to p nevn s eij s o. c
2 0 Th S eifdd n tfl ay a s rt teP tin On 510 , t LA e h rf i o i n n we o h eio . e t //9 he 2 S p ro Co r a dJ d eYaf fe amso s t teP tinFhc ddn t 1 u eir ut n u g fe ' d p p e o h eio ih i o i l t
2 2

2 a des o p s o c neta yo t sv ngo n s fdso camsstfrhi 3 d rs, p oe r o ts n fhe e e ru d , a r li e o t n

2 teP tin T e as ddn t i amoino e p lea piaint itre e 4 h eio . h y lo i o fl t r x a' p l t o nev n t e o t co
2 5 2 6

o an t eo itrse p ris n rdd te S eifn mete a itfse r oi f neetd at , o i h h ff a h m s neetd c e

2 p risi hi Noieofltrse Pate fld4210 . Ho v rted na o : ate n s tc neetd ris'e / /9 we e,h e il f i
. .

,1 81
.

' '..

' .

.

.

' ..

)

. '

l I l I l 1

'

.. , ( ) -

( l .

.

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 15 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

l 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1 0 1 1 1 2
1 4

teSei sMoint Dimis( ce #1)rnestersos o teL h hrf to o s s Dokt 2 edr h epne fh A f
S p ro Co ra dJd eYaf menn ls a dv i. u eir utn u g fe a iges n od

T e lc o o p s in wa fr e e h szd b te fi r o te h ak f p o io s ut r mp aie y h al e f h t h u Ma irt J d et h l a yh aigrg riga yfc i tePeio dsue gs ae u g o od n er e adn n atn h tin ip td t n t

itertr,seurdudr2 U.. j24 . nh eunarqie ne 8 SC. 23
11 Th DititCo tViltdTheDu Pr c s Clus 1. e src ur oae e o es a e A.M a itae Jud e W o hre a Ju e W atr Sho l Ha gsr t g e l nd dg le ud ve Re u e Th msl s c sd e eve Asso a o e o o t b scise i ti c s i ted na ofd h wn b v , ne f he ai su s n hs ae s h e il ue

poesdet terfslo teL Spro Co rjde wh rcie rcs u o h eua f h A ueir ut ugs o eevd
ç n o si to a'a dilg lpyme sfo LA Cou yt rc s t msle i s c n tuin l n le a a nt rm u t ' nt o e ue he ev sn c sswh r LA Cou t i ap ryo h sa itrs. ae ee ny s at r a n neet

1 6 1 8

BohMa it t J d eWo hl a dJ d eWatrh v a kneetn1e t gs ae u g e re n u g l a e n ç trs i h r e i

o tö o ti cs' E c o te i afr rci n l ee s atre wh uc me fhs ae' ah fh m s ome r a d fn e t n y o . mi o
2 2
2 4

ap a di teLA S p ro Uo r l sc cp ct,hyddn tas ted e p em n h u eir ut n uh a ai te i o rie h u . y
po esis eo ti c s i d fn igterci p l l nsi c sswh r te rc s su f hs ae n ee dn h i r a ci t n ae ee h mi e
LA Co nyDititAto ywa t poeuo .Th t yaebae a is u t src tme s he rsc tr us he r isd gant

2 6 2 7

d cdigted epo esis ei Fiesfv r F rfh yd ,h ysa dal 0 e i n h u rcs su n n ' a o. o ite o te tn 0 %

p bbiohvga artelmtdbao ecetv lti raiy fai) mlai.ci'' y fmrlrvoo h o l n pcc a i t l e r i r s s1 âh .
aein wl.wa n thp ywi hspe branfrtern th vn' . l t t s o ap t i la agi x. h i . aig e o h o o

f
(

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 16 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 ri dtedepoesiu aa steL Spr rC utug i tercs as h u rcs s e gi th A u ei o rjde n hi ae e s n o
2 3 4 5 7 8

a do tie ac a g o v n e n ban d h n e f eu .

F rh r Ma itaeJ d e Wo l l h sn tdslsd ta L S p ro ute, gsrt u g ele a o ico e h t A u eir r
mare t o eo i p rn r. S ewa teewhl Ma itaeJd eWo hl rid o n f t ates h s h r i gsrt u g e re s e

6 C utug Mai E Srt niafr r soit o hrfr rlw fm ad orjde r . t t s ome ascae f e ome a i n a ao r
s h r n h y r ot g e . i ud n ae e e ua. e 9 wa teeadte weec t a u s Thswo l ma d t h rre sl USDC 1 J d eWurc sdhmsl fo tecs b cu eh wa afr rL S p ro 0 ug eue i ef rm h ae ea s e s ome A u eir
1 1

1 Corjdeadatolau'o JdeYaf.US JdeFshrrcsd 2 utu g n ç l ge f ug f DC u g i e eue ce ' e c 1 hrefrmterltdcs CV-8096JW ( oedyatr iemo e 3 eslfo h eae ae 0-20 F CW) n a f Fn vd e 1 4 t rc s hrbcuesewa atr ' LA S pro Co r jd'ç adh' . o eue e' ea s h s bme . . u eir ut*u g' n a r d ' '. ' 1 . 5 1 rcie te LA Co ny pa me t. (-e i u i sc cs i te 6 e ev d h u t y ns 74 s e n uh ae s h l s ' c nsi tnly o CaionaBuiesad PoesosCoej 60.a d V o tt i ai f l ri sps p rf>ip d j 16 p uo t f
1 8
.
' '

.
. ' '

.

1 60 ()4 adteba o C lonaSpe C utJscswh rcie 9 07c() n h is f ai ri urme or ut e o eevd f i
2 cu t py nsadwh wrt Snt Bi C BXZ1' T e dne aptin . 0 o ny amet n o oe eae l .S lG 1. hy e id .eio ' t. 2 1 frrve i t ds ame t( Fie frbigng Fe ea cvlrg t c ss o e iw n he ib r n ) n o rn i d rl ii ihs ae f
2 2
.
'. .

2 caln igteL Conypy nstjde a avoaino ArilV1Sc 3 hl gn h A ut amet o ugs s ilto f t e , e. e c
2 5 2 6 2 7

2 1 , of te Caiona Co si t n te d e po es ca s,a d te Fi t 4 9 h lfri ntt i , h u rcs lue n h r uo s

.

Ame d n, n rf e t rc s te ev s n me ta d eusd o eue h msle.

' 2! 81
1

.

'

.

.

.

.

'.

.

l

.

. .

i l ! ! 1 .

.

.I p
.

.

i I
7 1

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 17 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1
2 3

Addto al,Ma irt J d eWo hl ddn t icoeta sei o te iin ly gs ae u g e re i o dsls h t h s n h t

Bo r o Go en r o teLo oaLa S h o Almn Aso it n whihrie ad f v ros fh y l w c o l u i s cai , c ass o

4 moe fo auni LooaLa Sho hs20jd e a au i Mairt ny rm lrn. y l w col a 5 ugs s lmn. gsae t 5 JdeWohlhs odslsdwhc o teeugs r fed,olaus r ug er ant i oe ih fhsjde aer n scl ge o e c i e 6
7 8

b iesascae i t sfndasnge ev r usn s so itsn hi u rii nd a o.

9
1 1

Jd e Watr wh i as a au u o Lo oa La S h o, dd n t u g l , o s lo n lmn s f y l w c o l i o e

i dsls whc o te 5 jde aefi d,ol ge o bs es soits 0 i oe ih fh 20ugs r rn sclaus r ui sasca . c e e n e
1 2
1 3 1 4

Moin t Reu eMa itaeJ d eWo hl adJ d eWatrweefe to s o c s gsrt u g e re n u g l r i d e l

i CaeNo CV-9t1 JW ( adCaeNo CV-820 JW ( , n s . 0-94 F CW) n s . 0-9 6 F CW) 1 prunt F Ruè6()2,4 ad() 5 usato RCP l 0b()()n 6.
1 6

1 7
.

B.Th Ditit ut oae 2 US j24 e srcCo rViltd 8 C 23 .

'

1 8

19 . . . 8 C 23 y in ni //9 1 asbfr rei h hrfo t l n i x 2 US j24 b waigut 470 (9dy) èoeodt gteS eft

Th P tin wa fe o 31/9 MaitaeJ d eWo hl voae e eio s i d n /90 . gsrt u g e re iltd t l

2 al r Th s eifvoqe tesaueb n t et yn terao fr n ' 1 lWe. e hrf iltd h ttt y o cri ig h e sn q Fies s f
.

.

2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 7
.

.

'

d tnina n t nweig. ee to nd o a s rn

.

Th Ma itaeJ d evoae t saueb etn n tetmefrteLA e gsrt u g iltd he ttt y xe dig h l o h Asso aov ,terrso s -zsvod du t te d na ofte S eits h wn b e h i ep n eva i e o h e il h h rfm

2 Su ro Co ra dJd eYaf t a s rt by n te20d ylmi t 510 . 6 peir ut n u g fe o nwe o eo d h -a i to //9

21 .1 8
.

..

..

MointDimis n62/9(o.k't t) t o . s so /90 l ce# 2. o j ' . . . . -) ,!
.

.

.

'. . .

l
l '
i

'

.

: .,

.

I 1
I

l

, ,

.

j

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 18 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1
2 3 5 6 8

I teMa itaeJ d efu dadsueo fcs sewa b u dt h v a fh gsrt u g o n ip t f at, h s o n o a e

h aig b 560 . S e dd n th v s c a h aig tee y la ig o l ern y //9 h i o a e u h ern , h rb evn ny
teea n t n a s rteecudn t eadsueo fcswi to estfrh h r s o a y nwe,hr o l o b ip t f at t h s e o t h

4 q eto so lw t b deie b sdu ontefcsstflhi t Peiin. As u sin fa o e cd d ae p h at e o' n he tto t 7 i tePeiin. n h tto
9 I Re r a Reo ndain Appr v d b t Co tViltd Du V. po t nd c mme to o e y he ur oae e Pr c s o es 1 0

1 ,
1 2 l 3

T eO jcin t teMairt Jd esReotadR cmmedt n h bet s o h gsae ug' p r n eo n ai o t o ; ; ' (Reot)efrhi dtited sce ce i teRe ot pr' stb t n ealh e in isn h p r.
. . .. ,

1 1 .
'

'

l j

1 smmay Ma it t J d eWo hl a dJd eWatrddn t edte 1 u r, gsr e u g e re n u g l i o ra h 1 a e
. . . . . ' ' . '

.

. . .

1 flPeii o teCa ro cs ofwhc te ween tfe ted yb fr t 6 ul tt r h petn ae on ih h y r oiid h a eoe he
1 Re ot sise . 7 p rwa su d
1 8

1 9
.

2 7

On t Fie lddntadestesàtneo GrudFie lngetdt e o v. t i o drs h usac f on v. t elce o 2 rcg ieta Fn wa cigdwi ci n lcne t i.voaigB&P 2 eo nz ht ie s hre t rmia o tmp; ., ilt h e n 2 3 Coej60 (e pg 3prgah1 o teOret So Cas atce t d 16 se ae ,aarp 6 fh dro hw ue t hd o a 2 4 a tePtin.Thsi dsusosi GrudF u ta Fn wa ntcagd j h eio) u t icsin n on orht ie s o hre t s 2 6 wi ei nlcne tadGrud' reta n r h t ajr tileitd t l a otmp,n on r e ht o i to uy ra xse h -mi h g
' . .. . . .
. . . ' . ' ' ' ' ' '

2 0 2 1

T ep t in h d sv nGru d . Th Re oto l me t h d Grt s ' h eio a e e o n s e p r ny ni e omd . t o ' 5 ' ' '

' '

:1becaus nocrmialcontmptchareexitd,wrbtwog .1 e i n e g se e o r . ' 8 eh n
.
.

j
'

' ' '

'

.

' ' .

'

.

''

.

j l

l l

., !. (

S

k i

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 19 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1
2 3 5

Isdsu so a dc n lso i Gru d On a dT ta J d eYaf t ic sin n o cuin n o n s e n wo h t u g fe s o l n trc s hmsl weeas wrn a terp r ddn te e ct t h ud o eu e i ef r lo o g s h e ot i o v n i o e

4 Ca etn,u r, rme ini. p ro sp a o nto t 6
7 8

Ev n moe e rgo s a pa e 1 ,prga h 1 te Re ottk s te e r ge iu, t g 8 aarp , h p r ae h

p sinta n jdewh hsrcie a dnosttnl iea cut oio ht o ug o a ee d n k cntui a' lgl ony t v u i o 'l
a in rn eo tesrcueo g v rme t ye u t gacu t wi fd rl n g oa c f h tu tr f o en n b q ai o ny t e ea n h

9 p y n so l rc ehmsl esl.At on t 1 ,heRe ot e ntae a me t h ud eus i efh ref Fo toe 0 t p rd mo srts
1 0 1 1

1 adsaegvrmetwhc hv eeuie lgsaieadjdca bace, 2 n tt oen ns ih ae xct ,eilt n uiil rnhs v v
1 a dasme ta ac u t i o tesmelv l sasaeo fd rl o en n, 3 n su s h t o ny s n h a e e a tt r e ea g v rme t
1 4 1 5 1 7

a , ta cut py nkos tjd e a tesmça s tp y nsos t pd ht ony amet t t e u gs m h a s t e ame tt t e a a a

1 jde a pro tesaepyn ijdcabac. 6 ugs s at fh tt aigt uiilrnh s
1 8
1 9 2 0

Ad io al,terp r ctst d c me t whc aen te hbf i te dt n l h e ot i o o u ns ih r o x ii n h i y e s c ne t til d c me t whc ae n tp r o te ieod'whc te o tmp ra, o u. ns ih r o at f h ç.c r' . ih h r

2 mairt jdefu di hridpnetrsac adctst nneitn 1 gsae ùg on n e needn eerh n i o o-xset t e
2 (at' a p r'fteçeo d' wi o tay suc i tè(eod'frs c . 2 d cs s ato h ç cr' t u n o re n h d c r' o u h f ' r 1 h r
2 3 sni. h gsrt ud e d e p he eod'o ut e n e s al y ma 2 .Ese t l teMa itaeJ g d d u t rc r't sihr e d . 4 2 5 Jd eWatrma ea J n v rve o teetr rc r a daepe ug l d e c oo e iw f h nie eod n ee td 2 6

L

. ' . . '

2 teReot (e 62/9O1e. On hst qet ntevrct o teOre 7 h pr. Se /90 ' r e a o usi h eai fh dr d) o y 21antugetie teaoeadoed'ie obetos 81 l dmngvnh bv n eald jcin. J , l, t , . .
' . . . . . . . . . ,

.

'

.
.

'

' '

1

.

l

î

2 9

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 20 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 V. Ths Ca e i t LaetAte o te Caior i J e t De y i s s he ts tmpt f h lf na udgs o n 2 Me nigu Acest teCo t a Prve t FarFun to n o a n fl cs o h urs nd e nt he i cinig f t Caio ni Judcal y tm he l r a ii S se f 3

4

l Jl 19, iewo a i ucinwhc coe teC lonaSae n uy 98 Fn n n n nt ih lsd h ai ri tt j o f 5 gvmmetn s p e al amet,n dn teu gsslr sdr gte oe n ad t pd lpy nsiduig h jde,a i ,ui h o ae n 6 7 bde cii.Thscetdai st i tejdcayadrsldi rtltn ugt rss i rae nmoi n h uiir n eut n eaii y e ao 8 aant ieb ugsadcuto sinr. gisFn yjde n orcmmisoes
9

' D
1 1

Co n ig i 19 , Fn b cme a r o po lms wi te LA mme cn n 9 9 ie ea wae f rbe t h h

1 Spr r oljde i csswhr L C ut wa apr .B 2 0,t s 2 uei C u'ugsn ae ee A ony s at y 0 0iwa o t y
1 e ie tta teLA Co ny p yme t weeteprblm wh n Che J t e 3 vd n h t h u t a ns r h o e e if usi c
1 4 1 5

Ge retl teCai ni J d e Aso ito o 91 /0a tercnvnt ni og od h lbf a u g s scain n /50 t h i o e i n t o

j Sn Dig ta te cut py nst jde weewrn ad ma b : a eo ht h ony amet o ugs r og n y e
1 u c nttto y,a rp re i teMerp ltnNe . 7 n p si in l s e o td n h to oia ws u
1 8 1 9
.

Fn rie teis èi ap l t bif i 2 0 .a d2 0 a dt F d rl ie asd h su n p el e res t 0 0 n 0 1 n wo e eà a l
'

.

7 0

2 casato cssi 2 0 . TheLA Su ro Co l rtlae wi c ne t 1 ls cin ae n 0 6 peir u' eaitd t o tmp t h 2 po edigsrmo a ofFi fo cssa dcmplit t teSaeBa se i 2 rce n ,e v l ne rm ae n o anso h tt r e kng
2 3 2 4

Ft ' dààmel frc aln ig teLA Co ny p y nsa d c aln ig ies ib t f t h l gn h t ti e . u t a me t n h l gn e .
. .

2 jdcaot es ohv rcie sc. 5 u iilfcrwh aeee d uh i v
2 6

2 7

Thec miain i ta Fieh sb e dsa e frfl g Fe ea cvi ul n to s h t n a en ib n'd o ii d rl i l n
-

21rl I ssrii ytteJ,-coupt payseosvilt Aril vl see.l 81ia q u yln ta h -. y z oae tqe , gt w i la ga A j ar ?

j j
1 l

.

.. -I 6

i

1 .

N !

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 21 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 l , fteCaio aCo tuin d epo esa dteFrt n me ta dfr 9 o h l mi nsi to , u rcs n h is Ame d n,n o f t
2 3 5

ma igtuh u sae nswhc aecretu drsbtniea dpo e ua kn rtfl ttme t ih r orc n e u sa t n rcd rl v

4 lw,n i cu t a eswhc aepoetdb teFrt n me t a a d n o rp p r ih r rtce y h isAme d n.

6
7 8 9 1 û

Fn h s b e u lwfl icreae s c 340 fr cret ie a en na ul n acrtd i e //9 o orcl y n y

caln igteL Conypy nsote ASpr r orjd e. hl gn h A ut amett h L u ei C utugs e o
Duig ti sme tme p ro te LA Su ro Co r bou h t rn hs a i eid, h , peir ut r g t wo

1 cne t rc eig .T ef s wa v ie a da n l datr h U.. sr t 1 o tmp po e dn s h i t s od d n n ul f te S Diti r e e c 1 Co r etrd asa ofeeuin a d OS r ga tn ha e sc p srl f 2 u t nee ty x c to n C e rnig b a oru ei e
1 3 1 . 1
.

wi o th aig.7h scndb c mev datrteLA Su eirCo r di n t t u ern -e e o ea oi fe h h p ro ut d o
' .

.

1 rsodt aCU j103Obet nsaigta h àtdi cnetwi a 5 ep n o P 7. ici tt ht e ce n ocr t o n h
1 6 1 7

cmmi inrt fl l i ps tejrdcino tecuta ns ohr o soe o as y r oe h ui it f h or mogt te s e n s o ,
. .
' '

1 tn . 8 higs
1 9
.

.

2 0
2 1 2 2 c ? 2 4

l 2 0 ,teL S p r rCo r bo g tSaeBà c ag swhc Wee n 0 3 h A u ti u t ru h tt r h r e ih 'f o
.

'

.

ds se b teSaeBa kptef/ eac o.jsie' nteeeo.tili i sd y h tt rç h u hrne fut 'o h v fra n mi i c
2 0 .Th LA S p ro Co rflda oh rCo ant 0 4 e u eir utie n te mpli .
. .

: 5
2 6 2 7
..

l 2 0 , n fldfr e dsu l iain o teLA S p r r ut t n 0 5 Fie i ut r iq aict s fh e h f o u ei Co r wi o h
rs c t tetln of Co nypa me t a drq etdrmo lo tecss epeto h at g LA u t y ns n e u se e va fh ae i
.
. . .. . .

t ; e t e e 21oSatFrneiko.Theserquesswer denid Feid winhCt o1 8 t ' a s' i f a rit or f nl t e t e t
, .
,.

.

. '. .

.

' .

'

.

l 1 I l 1
p . t

-. ! ?

I

j 1

: . '

;

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 22 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

l Ap el ihwa smmai d ne ,a dap tinfr e iw i teCaio a p a whc s u rl e id n eio o rve n h l mi y t f
2 3 4 5
7 8

S pe Co rwhc wa smmai d ne . u rme u t ih s u rl e id y

l 2 0 ,h SaeBa bo g th c re tSaeBa cs, ae u o te n 0 6 te tt r ru h te urn tt r ae b sd p n h
rman Ofh s,woweerisae atrb igds se ,nvoaino d e e i. tee t r en ttd fe en imisd i ilto f u
vn iae b Str o ,u r, fiui tevoainso Aril Vl S c l , f idctd y uge n spa afn ng h ilto f t e , e . 9 o c

6 2 0 c mpli o teLA Su eirCo l.Thecs satdwi 2 c u t. Te 0 4 o ant fh p ro u' t ae tre t 2 o ns n h 9 po esa dt SaeBa RueNo 3 ,wi u n tc o h ai . The ae rc s n he tt r l . 05 t t oie r erng re r ho
1 0 1 1

1 t Caiona Co si to a aloft eg tae poetd b te Fis 2 he lfri ntt in nd l he ih r rtce y h rt u 1 Ame met Efetv l,h SaeBa c s i as m. 3 nd n. fciey te tt r ae s ha
1 4
.

1 5
1 6 1 7

.

.

A teio frWrto Cet rr i peet b fr teU.S.Su rme àtin z i f roai s rsnl 'oe h t ' o i ye pe

. .

.

l , .

.

'

'

'

Co t i t dibame tc s. Oneo teis e i whte d epo eswa u' n he s r n ae t f h su s s eh r u rc s s

.

1 dne whn fu C lonaSpe C utkscs wh rcie iea 8 eid e or ai ri u rme or ute, o eevd lgl f i l 1 . 9 . cut py hswhnte .weeSpr r. utugsadhv rcie ony amet e hy r u ei'Corjde n ae eevd o é n
3 . .2

y, 2 rtoatv i nt di n trc s te ev s a d wh te t Caiona t er cie mmu i d o eu e h msle, n eh r wo lfri 2 s Pe Co r J tc swh weeo teJ dca Co n io Caiona whc 2 u rme u t usie o r n h u iil u cl f lfri, ih

2 wrt S. a Bi çB . 1 whc gv tejdé rt .éléi nt, i 4 oe e t l ç X21' ih aé h u. s erat mmu i dd n e lS ' g o y y
2 n trc s te eve. 5 o eu e h msl s
2 6

.

.

.

.'

'

2 7
''

Fute,aMoin t S tAsd t Jdg n o Abtnin i CaeNo rh r to o e ie he u me t f se to n s .
.

2l &(s(Jv(. hsntbe opsdb tecai risaeBa,ta.l 51 r-:96pfcv) a o en poe yh lt na tt re l c,)2) - . o
.
'

i t l
I 1 .

-1 X

%

t

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 23 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

1 T ec s se st d caeu cntuin l at ftemoa tri d lw,B&P h ae ek o elr n o si t a p r o h rlupt e a to u
2

3 C d j60,n teivlnayerl n lw, &PCoej60() ) T e oe 16adh noutr nol ta B d 07c( . h me 4 4 gonsostsd teug n aetateC lonaSpe C utute ru d t eaieh jdmet r hth ai ri urme orJscs f i
5 6 7 8

aebae , sso a o e r isd a h wn b v . Ass o h ri, ept teh lig i Sug o ,u r, petn spa h wn een d si h odn sn tr e n spa Ca ro ,u r, e y ast so Fn fo bign menn fla c s t te c ut a d a fi er o tp ie rm rn ig a igu ces o h o rs n ar

9 adtecssctdteenteLA Spro Corjde hv pritdfrtn n h ae i hri,h e ueir utugs ae esse o e
1 O 1 1 1 3

1 fnt nn jdcasse t 3 miinC lonas 2 uci iguiilytm o 8 lo ai rin. o l f
1 Vl Neest f Emeg n yReif 1 . c siy or re c le
.

Fieh sb e u lwrl' .n acrtd fro e fu mo ts Asso n a en na f l icreae o v r o r nh . uy h wn 1 6 h ri,n o p sto e it t tePeiina ddu po esh sb e d ne ,as een o p o iin xss o h tto n e rc s a e n e id 1 7 1 $ 1 so b S pe Co rpe è et adsauoyvoain . 8 h wn y u rme ut rcdns n tttr ilt s o
'

''

'

'

'

.

1 9 2 ' 0

.

T eein q et nta'Fn wi pe al nteP tini'tea' el h. s o u si h t ie. l' rv io h eio n h ' p a. r o l' t . p '' . .
Bu frt rf a o Ma srt Jd Wo hl a d J d e W atrt t o he eusl f gitae u ge e re n u g le o

'

2 1
.

2 rcs te evsadterrfsloo e 2 US j24 adS pe Cor 2 eueh msle,n hi euat by 8 C 2 3 n u rme ut
2 3 .

N leeetFn wolhv be strenA r. p ùdn, ie ud ae en ef i ji r e l
2 5
2 6 2 7

'

.

.. ,

.

.

.

. .. .

, , .

.

,

Fn n w rs etul rq et ta teeerr b i daeyc rd t t ie o ep cfl e u ss h th s ros e mme itl ue , ha y
h b stfe a dta 3 mil nCaiona b rsoe t menn tla c s e e e re n h t 8 li lfr ins e etrd o a igfl ces o
' . .
. .

.

' .. ' .

ajohcusnai,nii jiassm s tt orad fr'con utl t . e t l f tng dl ye iu i
! 1 l 1 1 1 .) -. J ( . .

j
! . I

.

.

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 24 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

r A u ) Dt ts.4a oyya( adh //.yj l (j e it -a - , ))
BY:

Rep cfl sb t d se tul u mie , y t
m R ..+ S . .ZM

RI C 1FNE .I , l Pr Pe n o r

2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4
2 6 2 7 2 8

Case: 09-56073

07/10/2009

Page: 25 of 25

DktEntry: 6988781

P ROOFOFS CE ERVI

S ATEOFCALF A, T IORNI COUNT OFL ANGEL Y OS ES la Grg Mc he My b sn s adesi 2 5 N.L k Avn e P 2 7 m e p e. uies drs s 4 0 ae eu , MB 2 , Al d n, 9 0 1 t ea CA 10 . a On Jl 9 2 0 ,lsre te frg ig d cmetdsr e a EMERGENCY uy , 0 9 evd h oeon ou n eci d s b MOTI ON TO I MMEDI ATELY RELEAS APP E ELLANT F NE FROM I I NCARCEM T ON P NG APP I ENDI EAL, OR P ERMANENTLY, AND I MMEDI ATELY, NTTHE WRI ASTHERE WASNO OP I ON TO T GM T POSTI HE P TI F WRI OF HAB CORPUS DUE P ETI ON OR T EAS , ROCES WAS VI S OLATED BY J UDGE YAF E' REF AL TO RECUS HI ELF,DUE P F S US E MS ROCES WAS S VI OLATED BY THE ACTI OF THE MAGITRATE J ONS S UDGE AND THE DITRI COURT J S CT UDGE,AND THE MAGITRA J S TE UDGE' REP S ORT & RECOMME NDATI Dl NOT REF TO, OR F ON D ER OLLOW T LATES HE T S UPREMECOURT P RECEDENT o itrse p re i tiat nb dp st gatu n neetd at sn hs ci y eoin le i o i ' cp teef whc wa ecoe i asae evlp , t p s g fl pead i te o y hro, ih s n lsd n eld n eo e wi ot e ul rpi,n h h a y UntdSae Mala desda fl ws i tts i drse sol : e , o
Aao MihlFnaa rn t el ot c n KeiM. c r c vn Mc omik Pu B. ec al B ah B N ON, R, E T OR DUVAL&B KF HAM UC NG L AWRE EB AC AL E &C ,C 3 N. ai riSre NC E H L N HOIP 9 C lona t t f e 10Wet rawa,t.20 0 sBod ySe 10 PO. o 17 . B x 18 Gln a , A 92011 edl C 11-29 e Vetr, A 902 nuaC 30 Wi cuts cpe hn-eiee ttecut o o: t or y oi addl rdoh oloms f h e s v r Jd eonF Wat ug Jh . lr e MairtJdeC r M. er gsa ug al Wohl te a e USDirt or C ut o 1 s i C ut orom 6 tc , r USDir t or R yaBlg Ct 60 si C ut obl d, rm 4 tc , r 32N.pigSre 1 Sr t t n e 25EsTmpeSre 5 at e l t t e L s glsC 902 o Anee, A 0 1 L s nee, A 9 02 o A glsC 0 1

1etyad eleudreayoprrudrh l ote idSas f crf n dcr,nepnl feuy netea fh Unt tt o i a t j ws e e
AmeiaadteSaeo Cai l atatefrg igit eadcret r n h tt f lomi,hth oeon snl n orc. c f

Eeueoti9 dy fuy20,tldn Clon . xct nhst aoJl 09aAtea afri d h , a2 i a ( ;.p ' . . ,. - t p . ; - v6 k % è E y PIE RG t E

Related Interests