You are on page 1of 21

Plaintiff argues that this is indeed the case.

II. THE LAW


Listed below are the relevant portions of the statutory provisions at issue in this

case.3 Together, the statutes create a non-discretionary obligation on the part of the Board of
Elections to review, prior to certification, all source code “relevant to functionality, setup,
configuration, and operation of the voting system” for nine characteristics.

!§! !1!6!3-1!6!5!.!9!A!(!a!).! E!v!e!r!y! !v!e!n!d!o!r! !t!h!a!t! !h!a!s! !a! !c!o!n!t!r!a!c!t! !t!o! !p!r!o!v!i!d!e! !a! !v!o!t!i!n!g!
!s!y!s!t!e!m! !i!n! N ! !o!r!t!h! !C!a!r!o!l!i!n!a! s! !h!a!l!l! !d!o! !a!l!l! !o!f! !t!h!e! !f!o!l!l!o!w!i!n!g!:! !(!1!) !T!h!e! !v!e!n!d!o!r! !s!h!a!l!l!
!p!l!a!c!e! !i!n! !e!s!c!r!o!w! !wi! !t!h! !a!n! !i!n!d!e!p!e!n!d!e!n!t! !e!s!c!r!o!w! !a!g!e!n!t! !a!p!p!r!o!v!e!d! !b!y! !t!h!e! !S!t!a!t!e!
!B!o!a!r!d! !o!f! !E!l!e!c!t!i!o!n!s! !a!l!l! !s!o!f!t!w!a!r!e! !t!h!a!t! !i!s! !r!e!l!e!v!a!n!t! !t!o! !f!u!n!c!t!i!o!n!a!l!i!t!y!,! !s!e!t!u!p!,!
!c!o!n!f!i!g!u!r!a!t!i!o!n!,! !a!n!d! !o!p!e!r!a!t!i!o!n! !o!f! !t!h!e! !v!o!t!i!n!g! !s!y!s!t!e!m!,! !i!n!c!l!u!d!i!n!g!,! !b!u!t! !n!o!t! !l!i!m!i!t!e!d!
!t!o!,! !a! !c!o!m!p!l!e!t!e! !c!o!p!y! !o!f! !t!h!e! !s!o!u!r!c!e! !a!n!d! !e!x!e!c!u!t!a!b!l!e! !c!o!d!e!,! !b!u!i!l!d! !s!c!r!i!p!t!s!,! !o!b!j!e!c!t!
!l!i!b!r!a!r!i!e!s!,! !a!p!p!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !p!r!o!g!r!a!m! !i!n!t!e!r!f!a!c!e!s!,! !a!n!d! !c!o!m!p!l!e!t!e! !d!o!c!u!m!e!n!t!a!t!i!o!n! !o!f! !a!l!l!
!a!s!p!e!c!t!s! !o!f! !t!h!e! !s!y!s!t!e!m! !i!n!c!l!u!d!i!n!g!,! !b!u!t! !n!o!t! !l!i!m!i!t!e!d! !t!o!,! !c!o!m!p!i!l!i!n!g! i! !n!s!t!r!u!c!t!i!o!n!s!,!
!d!e!s!i!g!n! !d!o!c!u!m!e!n!t!a!t!i!o!n!,! !t!e!c!h!n!i!c!a!l! !d!o!c!u!m!e!n!t!a!t!i!o!n!,! !u!s!e!r! !d!o!c!u!m!e!n!t!a!t!i!o!n!,!
!h!a!r!d!w!a!r!e! !a!n!d! !s!o!f!t!w!a!r!e! !s!p!e!c!i!f!i!c!a!t!i!o!n!s!,! !d!r!a!w!i!n!g!s!,! !r!e!c!o!r!d!s!,! !a!n!d! d! !a!t!a!.! [emphasis
added]

!§! !1!6!3-1!6!5!.!7 (!a!)(6)!. W!i!t!h! !r!e!s!p!e!c!t! t! !o! !a!l!l! !v!o!ti! !n!g! !s!y!s!t!e!m!s! !u!s!i!n!g! !e!l!e!c!t!r!o!n!i!c!
!m!e!a!n!s!,! !t!h!a!t! !t!h!e! !v!e!n!d!o!r! !p!r!o!v!i!d!e! !a!c!c!e!s!s! !t!o! !a!l!l! !o!f! !a!n!y! !i!n!f!o!r!m!a!t!i!o!n! !r!e!q!ui! !r!e!d! !t!o! !b!e!
!p!l!a!c!e!d! !i!n! !e!s!c!r!o!w! !b!y! !a! !v!e!n!d!o!r! !p!u!r!s!u!a!n!t! !t!o! !G!.!S!.! !1!6!3-!1!6!5!.!9!A! !f!o!r! !r!e!v!i!e!w! !a!n!d!
!e!x!a!m!i!n!a!t!i!o!n! !b!y! !t!h!e! !S!t!a!t!e! !B!o!a!r!d! !o!f! !E!l!e!c!t!i!o!n!s!;! !t!h!e! !O!f!f!i!c!e! !o!f! !I!n!f!o!r!m!a!t!i!o!n!
!T!e!c!h!n!o!l!o!g!y! !S!e!r!v!i!c!e!s!;! !t!h!e! !S!t!a!t!e! !c!h!a!i!r!s! !o!f! !e!a!c!h! !p!o!l!i!t!i!c!a!l! !p!a!r!t!y! !r!e!c!o!g!n!i!z!e!d!
!u!n!d!e!r! !G!.!S!.! !1!6!3-9!6!;! !t!h!e! !p!u!r!c!h!a!s!i!n!g! !c!o!u!n!t!y!;! !a!n!d! !d!e!s!i!g!n!e!e!s! !a!s! !p!r!o!v!i!d!e!d! !i!n!
!s!u!b!d!i!v!i!si! !o!n! !(!9!)! !o!f! !s!u!b!s!e!c!t!i!o!n! !(!d!)! !o!f! !t!h!i!s! !s!e!c!t!i!o!n.

!§! !1!6!3-1!6!5!.!7 (!c!)!. !P!r!i!o!r! !t!o! !c!e!r!t!i!f!y!i!n!g! !a! !v!o!t!i!n!g! !s!y!s!t!e!m!,! !t!h!e! !S!t!a!t!e! !B!o!a!r!d!
!o!f! !E!l!e!c!t!i!o!n!s! !s!h!a!l!l! !r!e!v!i!e!w!,! !o!r! !d!e!s!i!g!n!a!t!e! !a!n! !i!n!d!e!p!e!n!d!e!n!t! !e!x!p!e!r!t! t! !o! !r!e!v!i!e!w!,! !a!ll! !
!s!o!u!r!c!e! !c!o!d!e! !m!a!d!e! !a!v!a!i!l!a!b!l!e! !b!y! !t!h!e! !v!e!n!d!o!r! !p!u!r!s!u!a!n!t! !t!o! !t!h!i!s! !s!e!c!t!i!o!n! !a!n!d! !c!e!r!t!i!f!y!
!o!n!l!y! !t!h!o!s!e! !v!o!t!i!n!g! !s!y!s!t!e!m!s! !c!o!m!p!li! !a!n!t! !w!i!t!h! !S!t!a!t!e! !a!n!d! !f!e!d!e!r!a!l! !l!a!w!.! !A!t! !a!
!m!i!n!i!m!u!m!,! !t!h!e! !S!t!a!t!e! !B!o!a!r!d!'!s! !r!e!v!i!e!w! !s!h!a!l!l! !i!n!c!l!u!d!e! !a! !r!e!v!i!e!w! !o!f! !s!e!c!u!r!i!t!y!,!
!a!p!p!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !v!u!l!n!e!r!a!bi! !l!i!t!y!,! !a!p!p!l!i!c!a!t!i!o!n! !c!o!d!e!,! !w!i!r!e!l!e!s!s! !s!e!c!u!r!i!t!y!,! !s!e!c!u!ri! !t!y! !p!o!l!i!c!y!
!a!n!d! !p!r!o!c!e!s!s!e!s!,! !s!e!c!u!r!i!t!y!/!p!r!i!v!a!c!y! !p!r!o!g!r!a!m! !m!a!n!a!g!e!m!e!n!t!,! !t!e!c!h!n!o!l!o!g!y!
!i!n!f!r!a!s!t!r!u!c!t!u!r!e! !a!n!d! !s!e!c!u!r!i!t!y! !c!o!n!t!r!o!l!s!,! !s!e!c!u!r!i!t!y! !o!r!g!a!n!i!z!a!t!i!o!n! !a!n!d! !g!o!v!e!r!n!a!n!c!e!,!
!a!n!d! !o!p!e!r!a!t!i!o!n!a!l! !e!f!f!e!c!t!i!v!e!n!e!s!s!,! !a!s! !a!p!p!l!i!c!a!b!l!e! !t!o! !t!h!a!t! !v!o!t!i!n!g! !s!y!s!t!e!m!.! [emphasis
added]

3
Session Law 2005-323 is included as Exhibit A.