You are on page 1of 271

S.O.S e - Clarion Of Dalit - Weekly Newspaper On Web Working For The Rights & Sur i al Of The Oppresse! "!itor# N$%$R$&$.'.R( )O*.

+ issue.,-(( ..,/01/1.02

"!itorial # Ra3i

$ssassination & 'ur!er of &usti4e

5n this issue 6 we ha e again raise! the unanswere! 7uestions regar!ing late pri8e 8inister shri. Ra3i %an!hi. $lso 6 we ha e shown with F$CTS 6 $4tual 4ases how &u!ge8ent s are 8anipulate! 6 how 5n!ian legal syste8 is 8anipulate!. The 8anipulation starts right fro8 sele4tion of 3u!ges 6 poli4e by publi4 ser i4e 4o88ission 6 fro8 poli4e 6 publi4 prose4utors to 3u!ges. &ust rea! the great a4hie e8ents of so8e of our &9D%"S & :O*C" . This is an open appeal to the honest few in publi4 ser i4e6 poli4e & 3u!i4iary to legally prose4ute their 4orrupt 4olleagues & uphol! !e8o4ra4y.

Legislate LOKPAL Bill

With whole hearted respects to the parliament & all constitutional bodies , hereby we are appealing to the honest few in public service , honest few in parliament , honest few in udiciary & honest few in police , to legally prosecute their corrupt colleagues , to legislate ! LOKPAL B"LL# with full powers to enforce accountability of all public servants , $Ps , $LAs , Police , etc to the citi%ens of india&

'iti%ens of india are supreme in democratic republic of india& parliament , $Ps , $LAs are creations of citi%ens and are subservient , subordinate to the citi%ens of india& 'reations cann(t be supreme than the creator&

)ohra committee has officially ac*nowledged the criminali%ation of politics , parliament , legislatures& +he politicians crave for power because , while in power investigating , prosecuting agencies will be under their control , influence and they can manipulate the legal process , W-"+. WA/-"01 all their crimes& 2ust see , recently union home minister $r&'hidambaram influencing the delhi police for closing a cheating case against a builder by forcing the police to file !B# report& Politicians stoop low to such levels , to ma*e money .3 4 irregularities in purchase of coffins meant for *argil martyrs , allotment of flats meant for war widows , war veterans at $umbai&

"f proper accountability of public servants is legally enacted, independence , autonomy of udiciary & police is legally enacted , then those in power cann(t W-"+. WA/- their own crimes& +hat is the reason many political parties are opposing !LOKPAL B"LL# since decades under many prete3ts&

/ub ect to conditions , " do offer my services to the government of india & supreme court of india , to legally apprehend '5"$"0AL/ , 'O556P+ P6BL"' /.5)A0+/ , A5. 7O6 5.A87 9

&u!ges S"; Cri8e Co er-ups https4,,sites&google&com,site,eclarionofdalit, udge:se3:crime:cover:ups ,

Is CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA above LAW ??? https://sites.goog e.!o"/site/sosevoi!e#o$%&sti!e/!hie#'%&sti!e'above' a( )

Law student sexually harassed by ex-Supreme Court judge: case is not unique, but speaking out is nearly impossible

http://www legallyindia com/!"#$####%"&&/'nter(iews/sexual-harassment-supreme-court-iscommon ,

Release Irom Sharmila

‘Role of Vaiko, Karunanidhi in Rajiv assassination not probed’

The chief investigating officer of the Rajiv andhi assassination case, K Ragothaman, has alleged that the then !"K leader Vaiko, as a prosecution #itness, turned hostile and escaped the charge for perjur$ at the behest of the former SIT chief ! R Karthike$an% In his book ‘&onspirac$ to kill Rajiv andhi ' from &(I files’, Ragothaman said that during the investigation more than )** video cassettes #ere sei+ed, including a cassette titled ‘In tigers cave’ revealing Vaiko’s clandestine visit to the ,TT- area in .affna% /0e #as speaking vulgarl$ about Rajiv andhi and spitting venom on Rajiv% It is also found that he met 1ottu 2mman #hen he #as introduced to him b$ 1rabhakaran% Vaiko #as not 3uestioned on this% 2lso, he #as made #itness to speak about his conversation #ith 1rabhakaran #hile he #as kept in the 2shoka 0otel, prior to signing of Indo4Sri ,anka accord,5 Ragothaman #rote% !uring the trial, Vaiko refused to admit voice on a video clip of a meeting secured b$ investigators, in #hich, he is heard sa$ing that he told 1rabhakaran over the intercom in 2shoka 0otel that ‘Rajiv andhi stabbed him in the back and the proposed accord #as not the solution for achieving Tamil -elam%’ Soon after the meeting bet#een 1rabhakaran and Rajiv andhi, on the Indo4Sri ,anka accord, Vaiko had a talk #ith 1rabhakaran on intercom% Ragothaman has also dragged !"K patriarch Karunanidhi, #ho abruptl$ cancelled his meeting at Sriperumbudur on "a$ 67, 7887, to the centre of controvers$% Ragothaman #rote, /9hen I had collected the evidence about the cancellation of the meeting and brought to the notice of the chief of SIT to 3uestion the !"K leader on that issue, I #as told that part of investigation #as done b$ him and that ! 1 Rangasam$ had re3uested the !"K leader to cancel the meeting% 2lso, I #as chided b$ SIT chief asking me not to create such issues as I had done in Rasheed "urder case%5 Speaking to the ‘-:press’, Ragothaman said that he opposed Vaiko as #itness and told SIT chief that he appears to be a suspect% /SIT chief Karthike$an told me there #as not sufficient evidence against Vaiko% 2lso, starting point of our investigation should have been cancellation of Karunanidhi’s trip to Sriperumbudur, but Karthike$an did not allo# probe into it,5 Ragothaman said% Karthike$an, hailed as one of the most relentless investigators, vehementl$ refuted the charges authored b$ his o#n team member% /0e is flogging the dead horse% ;o #a$ can an$bod$ 3uestion the integrit$ of an investigation and nothing remains to be done% 2ll the aspects #ere e:plored b$ the <*4member team 6* $ears ago and SIT had received #ords of appreciation from t#o judicial commissions on record% The Supreme &ourt placed on record appreciation for m$ leadership,5 Karthike$an told -:press%

S!1I demands re4opening of probe into Rajiv andhi’s assassination case

(hopal= The Social !emocratic 1art$ of India, >S!1I?, has demanded the re4opening of the probe into former 1rime "inister Rajiv andhi’s assassination case after 67 $ears follo#ing a sensational disclosure that a crucial video of the assassination #as suppressed b$ the then I( >Intelligence (ureau? &hief and no# 9est (engal overnor "% K% ;ara$anan% S!1I national president "r% -% 2bubacker in a statement said that the allegation is serious% /If there such a video as claimed b$ the investigating officer, then it #arrants another probe% The matter should be looked into,5 said, "r% 2bubacker% "r% 2bubacker said that it is learnt that #hen ne#s4hounds tracked "r% ;ara$anan, #ho is no# in "elbourne on a visit, reportedl$ avoided direct 3uestion but at the same time there #as no denial% ;ara$anan claims all evidence is alread$ present #ith the investigating agenc$% The statement stated that the chief investigating officer of the Rajiv andhi assassination case, K% Ragothaman in his just4published book, /&onspirac$ to kill Rajiv andhi ' @rom &(I files5, has claimed that the tape, #hich had been taken from the videographer b$ I( the da$ after Rajiv andhi had been blo#n b$ !hanu on "a$ 67, 7887, #as never shared #ith the Special Investigation Team, >SIT?, in the investigation of the assassination% In the book Ragothaman said that although a /preliminar$ en3uir$5 had been conducted in connection #ith the missing video, ;ara$anan had been /allo#ed to go scot4free5 b$ the SIT chief !% R% Karthike$an% Similarl$, the statement said that 2dv% S% !oraisam$, #ho pleaded for ;alini, one of those convicted in the Rajiv andhi assassination case, has #ritten a book, claiming to unravel the m$steries and nail the bungling b$ the SIT chief Karthike$an% The soon4to4be published book, tentativel$ titled /"$steries and Secrets (ehind the Rajiv andhi "urder5, alleges a larger conspirac$% S!1I chief #ondered that a nation’s leader is assassinated and even that has to be suppressed% /So much for freedom of speech and e:pression and national securit$% !ig deeper, $ou #ill get to kno# be$ond ,TT- in Rajiv’s assassination% There are too man$ loop holes, convenient decisions taken in finishing Rajiv’s case in order to frame ,TT- and put a full stop% "an$ facts #ere not properl$ investigated% "an$ issues #ere suppressed, as the book sa$s, b$ ;ara$anan and Karthike$an% Rajiv andhi #as killed not onl$ b$ the ,ankan Tamils but also allegedl$ b$ some &ongressmen,5 he added% 0e pointed out that the alleged manipulation, according to Ragothaman, #as meant to erase video evidence of the kind of people !hanu had interacted #ith at the venue, thereb$ sparing embarrassment to the &ongress part$ in the middle of the 7887 ,ok Sabha elections% The author asked= 9ould ;ara$anan have dared /to damage the goal of the &ongress part$, irrespective of his personal affiliation to Rajiv andhi’s famil$A5 2s such ;ara$anan’s connections are of doubtful nature and can be probed into to unravel the truth% 0e said that 2dv% !oraisam$, #ho reportedl$ in an intervie# remarked= /I have the evidence to prove that Rajiv andhi murder #as an inside job% (ut the SIT headed b$ then Inspector eneral of 1olice Karthike$an never pushed the investigation in the right direction5, re3uires a serious attention and should not be #ished a#a$% "r% 2bubacker said that in vie# of the revelations made in the t#o books the unpleasant facts should not be s#ept under the carpet but thoroughl$ investigated to unmask the real conspirators and the culprits so that the people at large kno# the faces #ho eliminated the former 1rime "inister for their vested interests% @ollo#ing the assassination of Rajiv andhi m$sterious forces like 1% V% ;arsimha Rao took the top slot of Indian administration% Since Rao’s era India’s cooperation #ith Israel has increased manifolds at the cost of struggling 1alestinian’s #oes% The influence of the Bnited States of 2merica also increased on the Indian administration, he added%

Rajiv 2ssasination ' Bnans#ered 3uestions

Rajiv andhi assasination ' leaves man$ unans#ered 3uestions ' Bnsolved pu++les% @or #hom did Rajiv andhi got assisinated A Sudhangan raised various 3uestions #hich didn’t get ans#ers till 6**8% 0ere are those 3uestions that are unans#ered= 7? Cn 67 4"a$47887 Rajiv gandhi started from !elhi for election campaign and reached &hennai through the route Crissa and 2ndra 1radesh% 0o# did he accepted that midnight meeting at Sriperambuthur #hich #as not in the agenda of Tamil;adu &ongress committe% A 6? Is there an$ plan made some#here to bring Rajiv andhi to Sriperambathur some ho# A D? The Securit$ official "r C%1%Sagar #as there #ith Rajiv andhi #hen he campaigned at (hubanesh#ar and Vishakapattinam% (ut he didnt come to chennai along #ith Rajiv% 9h$ A <? (ulgarian television journalists came along #ith Rajiv during his visits to record his campaigns% The$ #ere #ith Rajiv in Crissa and 2ndha 1redesh but didnt come for the ne:t meeting% The$ sta$ed in a lu:ar$ hotel at Vishakapatinam along #ith their special flight pilot% In that case #h$ did the$ came A )? 9hen Rajiv #as about to start, there #as a problem in the flight% So he #ent back to circuit house from the airport% 2fter the problem in flight got fi:ed, the chief minister of 2ndha 1radesh "r%Vija$a(haskar Redd$ informed Rajiv to get back to airport and Rajiv #ent to airport% !uring this time the t#o (ulgerian journalists took the securit$ official Sagar along in their car and arrived at airport late% So the securit$ official could not go along #ith Rajiv gandhi% 9h$ did such an e:perienced securit$ official #as made not to travel #ith Rajiv A E? The securit$ official of Rajiv at chennai 1%&% upta #as #aiting at chennai airport for Rajiv% 1%&% upts is suppose to get the gun from Sagar #ho #as e:pected along #ith Rajiv% Since Sagar has not come along #ith Rajiv, 1%&% upta #as made to go #ith Rajiv #ithout gun% Is there an$ intenton behind this A F? 9hen Rajiv started from "eenambakkam, t#o ladies claiming as journalists got inside his car at Ramavaram% !id their identities verified A 9h$ did the special investigation branch didnt en3uire on them A G? 9ho are the (ulgarian journalists A 9here did the$ #ent A 8? 9ho are those t#o lad$ journalists A 9here did the$ #ent A 7*? Those t#o lad$ journalists intervie#ed Rajiv andhi% (ut Tamil;adu political part$ people, Tha% 1andi$an and "aragatham &handrasekar #ere telling the$ didnt kno# #hat Rajiv spoke #ith the journalists% 9hat are the hiding A 77? .ust one hour before his murder, Rajiv told it #as &I2 that killed the pakistan president Hia4ul40a3% 9h$ shoud he tell that A 9hat made him to tell that A !id he kno# if there is some plan like that against him A 76? .ul$47887 ' The central home minister S%1%&ha#an made a statement that apart from ,TTthere are other international organi+ations and po#erful e:ternal forces involved in the background of Rajiv’s murder% 9ho are the$ referred here A 7D? 9h$ didn’t the special investination branch en3uire on the above home minister’s statement A 7<? !uring the gulf #ar India helped fueling BS aircrafts% Rajiv gandhi seriousl$ condemmed this help #hich #as done b$ primie minister "r &handrasekar during that time% 9h$ didnt the special investigation branch en3uire on &I2’s hands on this murder, as BS #as not happ$ #ith Rajiv for the above reason A 7)? 1alestinian ;ational 2uthorit$ president, "r% Iasser 2rafat informed to the indian prime

minister during the time "r %&handrasekar that ‘Rajiv andhi’s life is under threat’% @rom #here did 2rafat got this information A 9ho is threatening Rajiv A 9h$ did special investigation branch didnt en3uire on this A 7E? 2rafat could have got this information if the assasination #as planned at #estern -urope or middle eastern countries% 9h$ is this not probed A 7F? "aragatham &handrasekar came to attend that meeting #ith Rajiv andhi% 0er daughter, ,atha 1ri$akumar came #ith her husband and advocate "ahendran from 2rakonam% (ut it #as unkno#n from #here did her son ,alith &handrasekar and his #ife Vinothini came from% Though it is kno#n that Vinothini is daughter of .a$avarthane from Sri ,anka, the$ didn’t en3uire on her% Infact the$ didnt en3uire their famil$ #ho #as there at the meeting% #h$ A 7G? Sivarasan’s mother and Vinothini’s father are sinhalas from Sri ,anka #ho #ere present at the incident% It is possible that the$ #ere sent b$ Sri ,ankan president 1remadasa as messangers% 1remadasa is not happ$ #ith Rajiv on sending the Indian peace keeping force >I1K@? to Sri ,anka% 9h$ #as the investigation not done in that angle A > 2lso #e should note here a Sinhala Sri ,ankan arm$ person hit Rajiv andhi #ith a gun during his visit to Sri ,anka ? 78? (oth ,TT- and Sri ,anka hate Rajiv gandhi as he is the reaon for sending Indian peace keeping force >I1K@? to Sri ,anka% 2dvocate "r &handrasekar challenged special investigation branch that, if the$ could prove Vinothini and her famil$ are innocent then those #ho did the crime #ill accept it on their o#n% (ut the special investination didnt accept his challence and not en3uired those #ho is related on this% #h$ A 6*? Kamini !isana$aka, 2thulath "uthali, 9ickramasinghe are prominant politicians in Sri ,anka% 9hen all those people are murdered president 1remadasa #as pointed% 9h$ did’t the investigation didnt happen in this angle A 67? 9h$ dont Sivarasan, !hanu and Subha did this murder due to pressure from e:ternal forces% .ust because the$ are Tamils from $arlpanam, did the investigators linked them #ith ,TT- and closed the case A 66? 9hat is the strong evidence that links ,TT- and its head 1rabhakaran to Rajiv’s assasination case% A 6D? 9hat is the proof that Srivarasan spoke to 1rabhakaran thro a radio% 9h$ is this not an assumption A 6<? It is ver$ much possible that politicians #ithin the congress could have considered Rajiv andhi is blocking their development #ithin the part$ and could have hired some group to assasinate Rajiv% This motivation cannot be denied% 6)? Various international business people specificall$ those selling #eapons #ould have been in contact #ith Rajiv as a prime minister% The$ could have hired the assasinators to do this murder% !id investigators probed this A 6E? 9hat if Sri ,anka did this, thinking India might send the Indian peace keeping force again to their countr$ and didnt like a strong leader emerging from India A 6F? &I2 al#a$s had interest in erradicating leaders in all third #orld countries% !id the same kind of interest got applied on Rajiv A 6G? Rajiv andhi is the onl$ leader #ho prevents the other prominant political part$ in India (.1 to get into po#er% It is possible that the indian parties like (.1 and RSS could have used the ‘0indu favourable’ ,TT- and Sri ,ankan tamils to do this assasination% 68? 9hen other major &ongress part$ members in Tamilnadu like Va+hapaadi and "oopanar didnt take interest in getting Rajiv to this meeting, "aragatham &handrasekar traveled to !elhi and forced Rajiv to come for this meeting at Sriperambuthur% Is that #ithout her kno#ledge she become one reason for Rajiv’s murder A D* ? 9ho is 1ottu 2maan A Is there a person like that A ,TT- sa$s there #as a senior person b$ name 2maan #ho died #ar and the onl$ person there is 1ottu% 0o# did the special investigation branch stamped someone #ho is not alive as second criminal in this case A D7? There are man$ parallels bet#een the murder of 1admanabha and that of Rajiv andhi%

1admanabha’s murder #as investigaed b$ Tamil;adu 3ueue branch police and Rajiv andhi’s murder #as investigated b$ special investigation branch% (oth the investigators are telling the murder #as planned at Iarlpanam, Sri ,anka% Sivaraasan #as identified as the prime criminal in both the 1admanabha’s case as #ell as Rajiv’ case% 1rabhakaran #as considered criminal in Rajiv’s assasination case bur #as not in 1admanabha’s case% 0o# come A It sho#s adding 1rabhakaran’s name came out of political decision rather than that came out from investigations% It is clearl$ an effort taken b$ special investigation branch to to give life to their case intentionall$% D6? 2 famous Sri ,ankan tamil poet Kasi% 2nandan met Rajiv at the airport% 9hat message did he got from 1rabhakaran to Rajiv gandhi A If 1rabhakaran seeked Rajiv’s help in the freedom struggle of Tamil -elam through Kasi 2nandan, #h$ #ould 1rabhakaran murder Rajiv andhi A DD? 1rabhakaran kno#s it is from India and Tamil;adu that he can get support and s$mpath$% !id 1rabhakaran done such a foollish activit$ b$ killing Rajiv, to loose all the support of Indians and also get the organi+ation banned A D<? ,atha Kannan stopped Rajiv and read a poetr$ for him% That enabled !hanu, a suside bomber standing ne:t to her, to burst the bomb% 9h$ is her name is not included in the criminals list A !hanu used onl$ ,atha kannan to get inside% 9hen 0ari(abu #ho got killed in the blast got included in the criminal’s list #h$ not ,atha Kannan A 9h$ is special investigation branch sho#ing softness to#ards congress members A D)? (efore getting to Sri1ambuthur, Rajiv spoke at t#o roadside gatherings% Va+hapaadi Ramamurth$, the Tamil;adu congress leader #as #ith him in those t#o places% (ut at Sri 1erambuthur meeting he #as standing ver$ far from Rajiv% 9h$ so A DE? "an$ innocent people and securit$ personnels died along #ith Rajiv andhi% (ut nothing happened to an$ of the congress part$ members not even minor injur$% 0o# A DF? It #as believed that ,atha Kumar #ho brought Sivarasan, !hanu and Subha to Sri1erambuthur% She took them specificall$ to ladies section and told ,atha Kannan to take care of them% (ut ,atha Kumar’s name is not in the criminal’s list% 9h$ A DG? 0o# can #e sa$ 1rabhakaran is involved just based on an old photograph of Sivarasan #ith 1rabhakaran A D8? 9h$ is it not possible that Sivarasan, !hanu and Subha are e:pelled from ,TT- and the$ have been hired b$ #estern, -uropean, "iddle -ast or India as professional assasinators% <*? Ranganathan confessed that it #as based on re3uest b$ "argret 2lva that he gave his house at (angalore for rent to Sivarasan% !id the$ en3uired ho# far this is true A <7? Is there an$ investigation done on involvement of &handra S#ami, Subraman$am S#am$ , &handrasekar and arms business person Kasoki in this murder A <6? 9hat kind of benifit ,TT- get b$ murdering Rajiv andhi A !id super po#ers like BS helped them b$ arms through &I2 A <D? 9h$ do #e need &(I J Special Investigation branch #hich find fe# people the$ prefer to get the reports A Bnless all these confusions are clarified, the real culprit #ill be hiding behind some po#erful forces% &ontinue reading at ;o#1ublic%com= Rajiv 2ssasination ' Bnans#ered 3uestions K ;o#1ublic ;e#s &overage http=LL###%no#public%comL#orldLrajiv4assasination4unans#ered4 3uestionsMi:++62$g8VIF<

1eople at the helm are protecting Rajiv murder accused’

@ormer &entral (ureau of Investigation’s former chief investigating officer K Ragothaman has claimed in a recentl$ published book N &onspirac$ to kill Rajiv= @rom &(I files ' that a lot of facts pertaining to the former prime minister’s assassination #ere either suppressed, or #ere studiousl$ ignored% Ragothamam #rites that there #ere attempts made to protect the ,iberation Tigers of Tamil -elam from being called the conspirators behind Rajiv’s killing% In this intervie# #ith rediff%com’s Vick$ ;anjappa, Ragothaman speaks about the conspirac$ and the hurdles that #ere faced in a probe in #hich man$ aspects #ere hushed up% 0o# has $our book been receivedA That is too earl$ to tell% It is just out, but is under debate% ,et us #ait and #atch% Iou #rite that !ravida "unetra Ka+hagam chief " Karunanidhi’s O Images P scheduled public meeting in Sriperumbudur on "a$ 67, 7887, the da$ Rajiv #as killed, #as abruptl$ cancelled% Karunanidhi #as to address a meeting at EQC clock that evening, t#o hours before Rajiv’s meeting% The police had made all arrangements% Then there #as a telegram from the 2nna 2rival$am postal office jurisdiction that the meeting #as cancelled% I probed the sender of that telegram% I #as told to ask Karunanidhi about the same% 0o#ever, I could not investigate him directl$% ,ater, I #as told b$ m$ superiors that the matter #as being looked into, and I should remain 3uiet% I #as also told that it #as a director general of police, Rangas#am$, #ho had advised that the meeting be cancelled% 0o#ever, #hen I looked at the Rangas#am$ affidavit, it read that he had ordered as much police force as possible in vie# of this meeting% I also attended the .ain commission in3uir$ in #hich Karunanidhi #as e:amined% 0e had said then that it #as the then governor, (hishma ;ara$an Singh, #ho had told him to cancel the meeting% ,ook at the contradictions% 9ho according to $ou #as the one #ho advised cancellation of the Karunanidhi meetingA 1robabl$ it #as "arumalarchi !ravida "unetra Ka+hagam leader Vaiko #ho telephoned and sought cancellation of the meeting% The telephone records needed to be e:amined, but it #as never done% 9h$ do $ou think Vaiko tried to stop KarunanidhiA 2fter Rajiv’s assassination, man$ !"K #orkers #ere attacked, their offices burnt% If Karunanidhi had gone there, he #ould have been in trouble and there #ould have been an onslaught% 0ence, the$ #ere tr$ing to protect him% !oes this mean even Karunanidhi #as part of the plotA ;o, that is not #hat I meant% Karunanidhi is not a killer% 0e #anted a democratic solution to the problem and this #as never liked b$ slain ,TT- O Images P chief 1rabhakaran% Iou accuse Vaiko of having a hand in this entire issue% Vaiko #as the one #ho spoke vehementl$ against the Indo4.affna accord% Vaiko said at that time he #as first an ,TT-, then a Tamilian and then an Indian% 2t the time of the accord, 1rabhakaran #as brought do#n to ;e# !elhi O Images P and #as put up at the 0otel 2shoka% Vaiko sought to meet him, but he #as not allo#ed to do so% 0e conversed #ith 1rabhakaran on the intercom, during #hich the latter told him, /2nna, this Rajiv has betra$ed me% I feel like committing suicide as he is sealing m$ fate% (ut I cannot kill m$self as I need to fight for m$ people%5 Vaiko #rote a book later in #hich he mentions that 1rabakaran had thought of committing suicide% Tell us more, sirR 9hen Vaiko had gone to Sri ,anka O Images P, #e had secured a videotape titled Inside a Tiger’s &ave #hich has him on tape% There he spoke ever$thing that #as anti4Rajiv% It appeared that he #as more against Rajiv than 1rabakaran himself% This #as also a point noted during our investigation%

Then there is also a meeting in #hich Vaiko sa$s that Rajiv #on’t go back alive from Tamil ;adu% 0e, ho#ever, retracted that statement% !uring the investigation, #e 3uestioned one &hinna #ho is on death ro#% 0e said that in one of the hideouts, Sivarasan >the prime accused in the assassination? held talks #ith one Srinivas 2$$a and said that after the successful completion of the mission, the$ should ensure that Vaiko becomes the chief minister of Tamil ;adu% 9h$ #as the evidence not used thenA This is a 3uestion that I have been asking% 9e had so much evidence, but surprisingl$ Vaiko #as roped in as prosecution #itness number 6)* in the Terrorist and !isruptive 2ctivities court% !uring the trial, he denied speaking all of #hich #as on video #ith 1rabhakaran% The video #as pla$ed out% 0e claimed that it #as him in the video but the voice #as not his% It #as sent for e:amination and the voice too #as confirmed, but till date there is no perjur$ case against him% Iou have alleged that even the Intelligence (ureau and the Research and 2nal$sis 9ing tried to cover up ,TT-’s roleA 2fter the assassination, &handrashekhar, the then prime minister, convened a meeting in #hich even .anata 1art$ president Subramanian S#am$ >then minister of commerce and industr$? #as present% The then I( chief, "K ;ara$anan, and R29 boss, S (ajpai, #ere also present% S#am$ said that it #as obvious that the ,TT- #as responsible% (ajpai retorted that it #as not the ,TT-% The meeting #as adjourned% "ean#hile, the &(I director had gone to &olombo for the investigation% The$ #ere called back and rushed to !elhi for the meeting% !uring the meeting, it #as again asked #h$ a trip #as made to &olombo and did that mean it #as preconceived that it #as the ,TT- #hich #as behind the assassination% (ajpai once again opposed this% 0e even 3uoted one Kittu to be his source% Kittu, incidentall$, #as 1rabhakaran’s right hand man% 2n ,TT- man could never have been a R29 mole and even !r S#am$ had termed this as absurd% 9hat are $our allegations against ;ara$ananA 2 video taken at the meeting on that ill4fated da$ in #hich there #ere images of !hanu #as never made available to the &(I% The assassination team #as #aiting for nearl$ t#o hours in a sterile area% The original video reached ;ara$anan% The government had decided to conduct an investigation in this regard and this case #as registered #ith the Special Investigating Team and the &(I% 0o#ever, it #as buried% "$ 3uestion is, #h$ no action has been taken for suppressing evidence% It #as being said that !hanu had barged into the meeting, but this video clearl$ sho#s that the$ #ere #aiting for a long time% 9e probed this case risking our o#n lives and it does upset me that people sitting at the helm of affairs are protecting the accused% !o $ou think the loopholes #ill be rectified no#A ,et us see% &overing up ,ate 1" Rajiv andhi 2ssassination conspirac$ J (C@CRS S&2"

The &(I J CI is more interested in favoring accused persons , Suattrochi J closing (C@CRS &ase than punishing the guilt$% The CI J investigating authorities have failed to punish the real master minds behind the ,ate 1rime minister Shri % Rajiv andhi assassination case % 9hen a responsible Indian citi+en volunteered to appear before the supreme court of india as

an amicus curie , to give certain information before the court relating to this assassination , he #as not at all permitted% Instead he #as threatened , attempts made to murder him , his ne#s paper #as closed , his jobs #ere illegall$ snatched a#a$ , police J investigating agencies repeatedl$ grilled him , T0- 1BR1CS- IS TC SI,-;&- T02T 1-RSC; % The 1olice failed to act upon his complaints% The Supreme &ourt of India @ailed to admit his 1I, 1etitions% 2,, TC &CV-R B1 T0- 1C9-RS T02T (- % #ho are covering4up late p%m% rajiv gandhi assassination caseA #ho are those conspiratorsA #ho are tr$ing to silence meA "$ sufferings began hand in hand #ith m$ crusade% I have raised various issues of social concern from time to time at the appropriate levels, one of those is ,2T- 1%"% R2.IV 2;!0I 2S2SSI;2TIC; &2S-% #here4in onl$ the tools of the conspirator’s #ere punished #here as the conspirators are roaming free% i have raised this topic of ine3uit$ , travest$ of justice and sought a fair, proper en3uir$J trial , at various forums% but to no avail% the conspirators #ere disturbed b$ this and tried to silence me b$ threatening me, ph$sicall$ assaulting me and even made attempts to murder me% the$ prevented me from appearing before the .2I; &C""ISSIC; C@ -;SBIRI% the$ even manipulated the recruitment s$stems to den$ me the appointments in R%(%I%&BRR-;&I ;CT- 1R-SS "ISCR-, 1%-%S% &C,,- - C@ -; I;--RI; "2;!I2, ;%I%- "ISCR- , !istrict &ourt "$sore J Illegall$ snatched a#a$ m$ job in R1 &ables ,td , "$sore % the$ even tried to silence me b$ forcibl$ closing do#n m$ ne#spaper publications T0- T-STB!C J VCI&- C@ &RBS2!-R% m$ appeals for justice resulted onl$ in police en3uiries% the central intelligence bureau>I%(%? state intelligence J state police personnel en3uired me e:haustivel$ number of times, but the$ never did en3uire the po#ers that be% an$ #a$ these people don’t have practical po#ers to en3uire such people% the highest constitutional functionaries #ho can order a proper en3uir$, trial are keeping mum inspite of repeated appeals% probabl$ the$ are acting under the directions of conspirators% thereb$ the$ are not onl$ covering up the crime, the$ are activel$ sponsoring terrorism , but are also violating m$ fundamentalLhuman rights J obstructing me from performing m$ fundamental duties as a citi+en of india%

&ontinue reading at ;o#1ublic%com= Rajiv 2ssasination 4 Bnans#ered 3uestions K ;o#1ublic ;e#s &overage http=LL###%no#public%comL#orldLrajiv4assasination4unans#ered4 3uestionsMi:++62$g8VIF<

1eople at the helm are protecting Rajiv murder accusedT

@ormer &entral (ureau of InvestigationTs former chief investigating officer K Ragothaman has claimed in a recentl$ published book 44 Conspiracy to kill Rajiv: From CBI files ' that a lot of facts pertaining to the former prime ministerTs assassination #ere either suppressed, or #ere studiousl$ ignored% Ragothamam #rites that there #ere attempts made to protect the ,iberation Tigers of Tamil -elam from being called the conspirators behind RajivTs killing% In this intervie# #ith rediff.com's Vick$ ;anjappa, Ragothaman speaks about the conspirac$ and the hurdles that #ere faced in a probe in #hich man$ aspects #ere hushed up% 0o# has $our book been receivedA That is too earl$ to tell% It is just out, but is under debate% ,et us #ait and #atch% Iou #rite that !ravida "unetra Ka+hagam chief " KarunanidhiTs O Images P scheduled public meeting in Sriperumbudur on "a$ 67, 7887, the da$ Rajiv #as killed, #as abruptl$ cancelled% Karunanidhi #as to address a meeting at ETC clock that evening, t#o hours before RajivTs meeting% The police had made all arrangements% Then there #as a telegram from the 2nna 2rival$am postal office jurisdiction that the meeting #as cancelled% I probed the sender of that telegram% I #as told to ask Karunanidhi about the same% 0o#ever, I could not investigate him directl$% ,ater, I #as told b$ m$ superiors that the matter #as being looked into, and I should remain 3uiet% I #as also told that it #as a director general of police, Rangas#am$, #ho had advised that the meeting be cancelled% 0o#ever, #hen I looked at the Rangas#am$ affidavit, it read that he had ordered as much police force as possible in vie# of this meeting% I also attended the .ain commission in3uir$ in #hich Karunanidhi #as e:amined% 0e had said then that it #as the then governor, (hishma ;ara$an Singh, #ho had told him to cancel the meeting% ,ook at the contradictions% 9ho according to $ou #as the one #ho advised cancellation of the Karunanidhi meetingA 1robabl$ it #as "arumalarchi !ravida "unetra Ka+hagam leader Vaiko #ho telephoned and sought cancellation of the meeting% The telephone records needed to be e:amined, but it #as never done% 9h$ do $ou think Vaiko tried to stop KarunanidhiA 2fter RajivTs assassination, man$ !"K #orkers #ere attacked, their offices burnt% If Karunanidhi had gone there, he #ould have been in trouble and there #ould have been an onslaught% 0ence, the$ #ere tr$ing to protect him% !oes this mean even Karunanidhi #as part of the plotA ;o, that is not #hat I meant% Karunanidhi is not a killer% 0e #anted a democratic solution to the problem and this #as never liked b$ slain ,TT- O Images P chief 1rabhakaran%

Iou accuse Vaiko of having a hand in this entire issue% Vaiko #as the one #ho spoke vehementl$ against the Indo4.affna accord% Vaiko said at that time he #as first an ,TT-, then a Tamilian and then an Indian% 2t the time of the accord, 1rabhakaran #as brought do#n to ;e# !elhi O Images P and #as put up at the 0otel 2shoka% Vaiko sought to meet him, but he #as not allo#ed to do so% 0e conversed #ith 1rabhakaran on the intercom, during #hich the latter told him, UAnna, this Rajiv has betra$ed me% I feel like committing suicide as he is sealing m$ fate% (ut I cannot kill m$self as I need to fight for m$ people%U Vaiko #rote a book later in #hich he mentions that 1rabakaran had thought of committing suicide% Tell us more, sirR 9hen Vaiko had gone to Sri ,anka O Images P, #e had secured a videotape titledInside a Tiger's Cave #hich has him on tape% There he spoke ever$thing that #as anti4Rajiv% It appeared that he #as more against Rajiv than 1rabakaran himself% This #as also a point noted during our investigation% Then there is also a meeting in #hich Vaiko sa$s that Rajiv #onTt go back alive from Tamil ;adu% 0e, ho#ever, retracted that statement% !uring the investigation, #e 3uestioned one &hinna #ho is on death ro#% 0e said that in one of the hideouts, Sivarasan >the prime accused in the assassination? held talks #ith one Srinivas 2$$a and said that after the successful completion of the mission, the$ should ensure that Vaiko becomes the chief minister of Tamil ;adu% 9h$ #as the evidence not used thenA This is a 3uestion that I have been asking% 9e had so much evidence, but surprisingl$ Vaiko #as roped in as prosecution #itness number 6)* in the Terrorist and !isruptive 2ctivities court% !uring the trial, he denied speaking all of #hich #as on video #ith 1rabhakaran% The video #as pla$ed out% 0e claimed that it #as him in the video but the voice #as not his% It #as sent for e:amination and the voice too #as confirmed, but till date there is no perjur$ case against him% Iou have alleged that even the Intelligence (ureau and the Research and 2nal$sis 9ing tried to cover up ,TT-Ts roleA 2fter the assassination, &handrashekhar, the then prime minister, convened a meeting in #hich even .anata 1art$ president Subramanian S#am$ >then minister of commerce and industr$? #as present% The then I( chief, "K ;ara$anan, and R29 boss, S (ajpai, #ere also present% S#am$ said that it #as obvious that the ,TT- #as responsible% (ajpai retorted that it #as not the ,TT-% The meeting #as adjourned% "ean#hile, the &(I director had gone to &olombo for the investigation%

The$ #ere called back and rushed to !elhi for the meeting% !uring the meeting, it #as again asked #h$ a trip #as made to &olombo and did that mean it #as preconceived that it #as the ,TT- #hich #as behind the assassination% (ajpai once again opposed this% 0e even 3uoted one Kittu to be his source% Kittu, incidentall$, #as 1rabhakaranTs right hand man% 2n ,TT- man could never have been a R29 mole and even !r S#am$ had termed this as absurd% 9hat are $our allegations against ;ara$ananA 2 video taken at the meeting on that ill4fated da$ in #hich there #ere images of !hanu #as never made available to the &(I% The assassination team #as #aiting for nearl$ t#o hours in a sterile area% The original video reached ;ara$anan% The government had decided to conduct an investigation in this regard and this case #as registered #ith the Special Investigating Team and the &(I% 0o#ever, it #as buried% "$ 3uestion is, #h$ no action has been taken for suppressing evidence% It #as being said that !hanu had barged into the meeting, but this video clearl$ sho#s that the$ #ere #aiting for a long time% 9e probed this case risking our o#n lives and it does upset me that people sitting at the helm of affairs are protecting the accused% !o $ou think the loopholes #ill be rectified no#A ,et us see%

&overing up ,ate 1" Rajiv

andhi 2ssassination conspirac$

The GOI & investigating authorities have failed to punish the real master minds behind the Late Prime minister Shri . Rajiv Gandhi assassination case . hen a responsible Indian citi!en volunteered to appear before the supreme court of india as an amicus curie " to give certain information before the court relating to this assassination " he #as not at all permitted. Instead he #as threatened " attempts made to murder him " his ne#s paper #as closed " his jobs #ere illegall$ snatched a#a$ " police & investigating agencies repeatedl$ grilled him " T%& P'RPOS& IS TO SIL&()& T%*T P&RSO( . The Police failed to act upon his complaints. The Supreme )ourt of India +ailed to admit his PIL Petitions. *LL TO )O,&R 'P T%& PO &RS T%*T -& .

#ho are covering.up late p.m. rajiv gandhi assassination case/ #ho are those conspirators/ #ho are tr$ing to silence me/ 0$ sufferings began hand in hand #ith m$ crusade. I have raised various issues of social concern from time to time at the appropriate levels" one of those is L*T& P.0. R*1I, G*(2%I *S*SSI(*TIO(

)*S&. #here.in onl$ the tools of the conspirator3s #ere punished #here as the conspirators are roaming free. i have raised this topic of ine4uit$ " travest$ of justice and sought a fair" proper en4uir$& trial " at various forums. but to no avail. the conspirators #ere disturbed b$ this and tried to silence me b$ threatening me" ph$sicall$ assaulting me and even made attempts to murder me. the$ prevented me from appearing before the 1*I( )O00ISSIO( O+ &(5'IR6. the$ even manipulated the recruitment s$stems to den$ me the appointments in R.-.I.)'RR&()6 (OT& PR&SS 06SOR&" P.&.S. )OLL&G& O+ &(GI(&&RI(G 0*(26*" (.I.& 06SOR& " 2istrict )ourt 0$sore & Illegall$ snatched a#a$ m$ job in RPG )ables Ltd " 0$sore . the$ even tried to silence me b$ forcibl$ closing do#n m$ ne#spaper publications T%& T&ST'2O & ,OI)& O+ )R'S*2&R. m$ appeals for justice resulted onl$ in police en4uiries. the central intelligence bureau7I.-.8 state intelligence & state police personnel en4uired me e9haustivel$ number of times" but the$ never did en4uire the po#ers that be. an$ #a$ these people don3t have practical po#ers to en4uire such people. the highest constitutional functionaries #ho can order a proper en4uir$" trial are :eeping mum inspite of repeated appeals. probabl$ the$ are acting under the directions of conspirators. thereb$ the$ are not onl$ covering up the crime" the$ are activel$ sponsoring terrorism " but are also violating m$ fundamental;human rights & obstructing me from performing m$ fundamental duties as a citi!en of india. hereb$ " i do re4uest $ou to protect m$ fundamental & human rights and to facilitate me to perform m$ +'(2*0&(T*L 2'TI&S as a citi!en of india.also" i do re4uest $ou to give me information about follo#ing cases "it3s final reports& it3s action ta:en report. <.the roost resort scandal involving :arnata:a high court judges. =. The )ase of > $ouths murdered in Puttaparthi sat$a sai baba ashram in puttaparthi. =.the scam of gem cutting & polishing units in m$sore set.up under ,IS% * self.emplo$ment scheme. ?.the murder of under.trial"T*2* detenue mr.arjunan7forest brigand veerappan3s brother8. >.the murder of journalist mr.sat$anara$an near m$sore. @.the murder of e9.minister mr.nagappa near m$sore. A.the amount of ransom paid b$ state governments of :arnata:a"tamilnadu & the union govrnment and the general public to forest brigand veerappan during all :idnap episodes 7including movie star raj:umar3s8.the role pla$ed b$ facilitators.the contents of all cassettes sent b$ veerappan to governments & vice versa. B.the final report of justice a.j. sadashivas3s committee #hich en4uired into atrocities & human rights violations committed b$ police"special tas: force7S.T.+.8 on the innocent tribal people of 0.0.%ILLS. C.the report of past district magistrate of m$sore mr.T.0.vija$abhas:ar about the land scam in & around m$sore. D.even in developed countrise li:e '.S.*. & '.E. mal.handling of radio.active materials ta:es place no# & then" #hich in itself constitute nuclear disasters on small scale.refer the 2&))*( %&R*L2 7<=;<F;F? to<C;<F;F?8.in india ho# man$ cases of mal.handling of radio.active materials have ta:en place/ no public :no#ledge.in the bac: drop of corrupt"negligent"hush.hush"buc: passing #or: culture in most of the government service in india" i do #ant to :no# ho# safe are #e the m$soreans from the processing & storage of radio.active materials at 0;S R*R& &*RT% 0*T&RI*LS PL*(T"$el#al"m$sore/ in the past there #ere media reports about damages caused to the human beings "the environment b$ the same organisation 0;S R.&.0.P. & it3s sister concern 0;S 'R*(I'0 )ORPOR*TIO( O+ I(2I* LI0IT&27'.).I.L.8 at :erala state & at jadaguda "orissa state respectivel$.even some of the insurance companies li:e 0;S.metlife india insurance co."don3t cover the ris: of health damages "death due to nuclear ha!ards.in such an event #ho #ill bear the cost of compensation/ho# the 4uantum of compensation is calculated/give me information about the

safet$ measures ta:en b$ 0;S. R"&"0.P.m$sore & the compensation pa$ sructure and the safet$ measures being follo#ed b$ all agencies dealing #ith radio.active materials.

** TT!"#onia link $ httpG;;indiavie#.#ordpress.com;=FFC;F>;?F;ltte.sonia.lin:; " httpG;;###.scribd.com;doc;<CF@?<B@;Sonias.Ottavio.5uattrochchi.Paid.for.Rajiv.Gandhi " httpG;;###.$outube.nocoo:ie.com;#atch/vHg>uinmue'4g " httpG;;###.legalsutra.org;<>AA;criminal.conspirac$; " httpG;;###.spur.asn.au;e9tra;rajiv.htm "

2n ,TT-4Sonia famil$ linkA S% urumurth$,;e#indpress 2pril 68 6**G

The LTT& suicide s4uad did plan and eliminate Rajiv Gandhi. -ut" #h$ did the LTT& do it/ there a larger conspirac$ that e9tended be$ond the LTT& as the stri:e force/

as

as the LTT& the author of the crime or the mercenar$ for some one else or for some purpose that $ielded some benefit to it/ These 4uestions persisted even after the actual assassins #ere brought to boo:. The (arasimha Rao government appointed the 1ain )ommission to go into the conspirac$ angle to the murder.In its interim report the commission did e9ceedingl$ good #or: to bring on record evidence about the political forces involved in promoting the LTT& in Tamil (adu that made the crime possible. 6et it made a moc:er$ of its main #or:" the conspirac$ angle. It floated dubious and #ild theories" involving 0ossadI )I*I -esides adding confusion" it ended up trivialising a ver$ serious e9ercise. This also robbed the commission of its credibilit$. *s the commissionJs final report proved a flop" the ,ajpa$ee government appointed a 0ulti. 2isciplinar$ 0onitoring *genc$ 7020*8 in <DDC to unearth the conspirac$ angle. -ut the person #ho first demanded" but" ultimatel$ made" investigation into the conspirac$ to murder Rajiv Gandhi irrelevant #as none other than his #ido# Sonia Gandhi.

%er attitude to the investigation and suspected actors in the murder dramaticall$ changed. %er conduct in <DDB #hen she #as #or:ing to enter active politics #as a star: contrast to her attitude after ta:ing over the congress leadership on the 1ain )ommission issue. In <DDB" she demanded that the 20E #hich" the 1ain commission had said" #as part of the conspirac$" be sac:ed as a partner of the '+ alliance and pulled do#n the government #hen the demand #as not met. %er part$ insisted the entire facts about the conspirac$ be investigated and revealed. *ddressing a meeting at *methi" Sonia hinted that the 20E #as a fan of the LTT& and charged that those #ho doubted the 1ain commission report #ere diverting the attention from the investigation into the conspirac$ to murder Rajiv and demanded that the probe be completed e9peditiousl$ 7Indian &9press =.=.<DDC8.

-ut" once she too: over the part$ leadership" she not onl$ ceased to evince an$ interest in pursuing the Rajiv Gandhi murder conspirac$" but also began all$ing #ith the alleged conspirators themselves. The developments" put together" reveal a shoc:ing picture.The $ear after ta:ing over the )ongress" Sonia Gandhi ma:es a secret move. In the $ear <DDD" she told then President 2r E R (ara$anan privatel$ that Kneither she nor her son and daughter #anted an$ of the four convictsJ sentenced to death for RajivJs assassination Kto be hangedJ" and pleaded that no child should be orphaned b$ an act of the State. (oted the Indian &9press 7(ov =F" <DDD8 that before her plea for merc$ to the Rajiv :illers the )ongress part$ #as the leading opponent of merc$ to them. This silenced the part$ once and for all. hat transpired at her private meeting #ith the President #as revealed not b$ Sonia" but b$ 0ohini Giri 7the former chairperson of the (ational omenJs )ommission8 and on that basis (aliniJs death sentence #as commuted to life. 7+rontline (ov @.<C" =FF@8. Then" in +ebruar$ =FF>" there #ere reports" editoriall$ commented b$ the Island ne#spaper in )olombo on +eb =F" =FF>" that &duardo +aleiro" her emissar$" had a secret meeting #ith the LTT& chief Prabha:aran at Eillinochi. Island had also referred to reports that SoniaJs mother 0s Paula 0aino had met *nton -alasingham" LTT&Js point man in London" in connection #ith the electoral alliance bet#een the 20E and the )ongress. hile &duardo +aleiro at least made a feeble attempt to den$ the meeting" Paulo 0aino #ould not even den$ that.Third" the Paulo 0aino meeting preceded" and the +aleiro meeting succeeded" the unbelievable '.turn of Sonia Gandhi to forge alliance #ith the 20E #hich #as accused b$ her o#n part$ in <DDB of being part of the conspirac$ to murder her husband. The 20E.)ongress alliance seems to have been agreed upon sometime in 2ecember =FF?. In 1anuar$ =FF>" Sonia met the 20E chief and concretised the alliance. The coming together of one of the alleged conspirators and the victim of the conspirac$ made a moc:er$ of an$ further investigation into Rajiv Gandhi murder. +or the last four $ears there is not a single #ord spo:en b$ Sonia on pursuing the Rajiv Gandhi murderers and on unearthing the conspirac$ or for the e9tradition of Prabha:aran or Pottu *mman.

This is despite the fact that" #hen" on *pril <F" =FF=" Prabha:aran met the press at Eillinochi" he did not even den$ that LTT& #as involved in Rajiv assassination. +ourth" the LTT& too responded favourabl$ to signals from Sonia that she #as not against LTT&. On 1anuar$ =B" =FFA" *nton -alasingham" told an Indian T, ne#s channel that the Rajiv :illing #as Kmonumental traged$J and as:ed the people of India to be Kmagnanimous to put the past behindJ and deal #ith the LTT&. +ifth" Sonia did not object to the inclusion of the 20E #oman 0P in #hose house Sivarasan the main :iller of Rajiv Gandhi had sta$ed for #hich she #as detained under the T*2*" as a minister in the 'P* government. Si9th" the 020* #hich #as appointed b$ the (2* government after Sonia rejected the *ction Ta:en Report on the 1ain )ommission" has virtuall$ become defunct under the 'P* regime. Since =FF>" she has not uttered a single #ord as:ing #hat the 020* is doing. *nd finall$ no# in 0arch =FFC" Pri$an:a ,adra" SoniaJs daughter ma:es a secret visit to ,ellore jail and meets the first accused in the murder of Rajiv" for over an hour. 0edia reports sa$ that the$ sat b$ each otherJs side" cried and professed good#ill to#ards each otherI (o one :no#s #hat transpired bet#een them. The meeting clearl$ illegal" loo:s almost a conspirac$" #ould have remained a secret had the media not e9posed it. Pri$an:a said that neither Sonia nor Rahul or Pri$an:a believe in hate or anger" and that the visit #as her #a$ of coming to terms #ith the Rajiv Gandhi murder. 0oral high ground seems to be a cover for undisclosed political strategies. -ut #here #as this high moral ground #hen Sonia angril$ pulled do#n the '+ government on the ground that 20E" a suspected co.conspirator #ith LTT&" #as part of the alliance/ Is Rajiv GandhiJs assassination a personal affair bet#een the Sonia Gandhi famil$ and the LTT& for the former to punish or pardon the latter/ LTT& has neither confessed nor regretted its action for the Gandhis to pardon. The LTT& is even toda$ unrepenting. The prosecution case is that the LTT& supremo decided to avenge Rajiv Gandhi for sending IPE+ to Sri Lan:a and betra$ing the LTT&. -ut that #as no personal decision of Rajiv Gandhi. The assassination #as an act against the state of India. This is ho# it should be seen and pursued. (either Sonia nor Pri$an:a nor the )ongress has the right to pardon the criminals #ho have challenged the sovereignt$ of India. 5&2G Sonia Gandhi famil$ and the LTT& connection is m$sterious. Is the maveric: 2r Subramanian S#am$ right after all in his theor$ that LTT& and the 0aino famil$ have had lin:s before/ httpG;;###.ne#indpress.com;(e#sItems.asp/I2HI&0=FFCF>=C=?<?>C&TitleH0ainL*rticle&rLin:HF R&L*T&2 STORI&SG

2o $ou :no# Sonia G Subramanian S#am$ M httpG;;###.saveindi aforum.com; d$namic; Sonia )ongJs blit!:rieg evangelisation thru R-IG ,. Sundaram M httpG;;###.ne#stoda$net.com;=FFBsud;ma$FB;=?F@FB.htm She became lo$al bit lateG b$ Gurumurth$M httpG;;indiavie#.#ordpress.com;=FFB;FA;<>;she. became.lo$al.to.india.a.trifle.late; 2emo.narch$ of India M httpG;;indiavie#.#ordpress.com;=FFB;FC;F<;deNe=NCFNDDmo.narch$.of. democratic.india; Sonia.LTT& lin: G b$ Gurumurth$ M httpG;;###.ne#indpress.com;(e#sItems.asp/ I2HI&0=FFCF>=C=?<?>C&TitleH0ainL*rticle&rLin:HF

httpG;;###.desivideonet#or:.com;vie#;9C@a:B9>i;rajiv.gandhi.assasination.conspirac$.@.of.B; " httpG;;###.$outube.com;#atch/vH<P6.$E#b%Fc "

R2.IV 2SS2SSI;2T-!

The +rench Intelligence *gencies as per a regular routine Intelligence 2rill" :eep under heavil$ Intelligence Surveillance all the activities of all the +oreigners in all the +ive Star %otels.politicspart$.com has learnt from highl$ placed sources that" OIn the course of the routine surveillance the Intelligence *gencies of +rance have in their possession On )amera +ootage of a no# %ighl$ )lassified Recording of a Secret 0eeting at a Paris +ive Star %otel in <DD<.PThe L.T.T.& #as fighting through the use of Terrorism for the separation of the Tamil portion of the countr$ from Sri Lan:a. Rajiv Gandhi as Prime 0inister had sent the Indian *rm$ to Sri Lan:a to assist the Government forces there to fight and destro$ the L.T.T.&. The Indian *rm$ #as finall$ #ithdra#n from Sri Lan:a #ithout achieving success. Rajiv thus became an enem$ of the L.T.T.&.Rajiv lost po#er in <DCD Lo: Sabha &lections.In <DD<" Rajiv Gandhi #as the )ongress President" )handrashe:ar #as the Prime 0inister.The Lo: Sabha &lections #ere announced after Rajiv #ithdre# the )ongress support to the )handrashe:ar Government.The L.T.T.&. )hief had sent t#o L.T.T.& delegations to (e# 2elhi in <DD<" to meet and discuss #ith Rajiv Gandhi" to understand his attitude to#ards the L.T.T.&. *fter these meetings the L.T.T.&. )hief #as not convinced that Rajiv #ould be soft on the L.T.T.&. In fact Prabha:aran e9pected Rajiv to be hostile to the L.T.T.&.In the <DD< &lections Rajiv #as not e9pected to come bac: to po#er. %o#ever the L.T.T.&. did not #ant the ris: of allo#ing Rajiv to come to po#er.Rajiv Gandhi and his )ongress #on a massive victor$ in <DC> because of the nation#ide s$mpath$ generated b$ Prime 0inister Indira GandhiJs *ssassination b$ her Si:h -od$guards. RajivJs )ongress #on ><> Lo: Sabha 0Ps. Rajiv loo:ed li:e being Prime 0inister forever.%o#ever" Rajiv got in to a serious )redibilit$ Problem #hen the %2 Submarine 2eal -ro:e. Rajiv thre# out the then 2efence 0inister ,.P.Singh from the Part$. RajivJs )oterie made a lo$al ,.P.Singh an enem$ of Rajiv.Thereafter the -ofors Gun 2eal Scam tumbled out of the S#edish )loset. Rajiv handled the -ofors Scam horribl$. RajivJs former aides

manipulated to destro$ Rajiv and RajivJs Politics. Rajiv lost complete credibilit$. RajivJs )ongress #on <D@ 0Ps but lost the Lo: Sabha &lections and the )entral Government in <DCD. The ,.P.Singh Government came to po#er and demonstrated 4uic:ness in getting the -ofors Pa$ Offs in +oreign -an: *ccounts Sealed.The -ofors 0one$ Trail led directl$ to the Italian heeler.2ealer Ottavio 5uattrocchi.5uattrocchi reali!ed that IndiaJs Opposition Politicians and *nti.)ongress Governments in their passion to e9pose Rajiv #ould chase the -ofors Scam and all its beneficiaries. %o#ever" in that process the involvement of 5uattrocchi #ould be completel$ e9posed. 5uatrocchi believed that Rajiv and his )ongress #ere not #inning the <DD< &lections. The Third +ront Government of ,.P.Singh #as e9pected to #in. The ,.P. Singh Government #ould accelerate investigation in to the -ofors Scam. 5uattrocchiJs role in the -ofors Scam #ould be completel$ e9posed thus leading to the jailing of 5uattrocchi.5uattrocchi panic:ed. There #as onl$ one #a$ for 5uattrocchi to survive. The -ofors scam must be buried. The -ofors &n4uir$ cannot be stopped if Rajiv #as *live. If Rajiv #as not there then the Political S$stem #ould lose interest in the -ofors Scam. So to bur$ the -ofors Scam -ur$ing Rajiv #as a necessit$ for 5uattrocchi. Onl$ then could 5uattrocchi happil$ survive and enjo$ the millions looted from IndiaJs Public &9che4uer.*nton -alasingham #as the Principal *dviser" 0ost Trusted Lieutenant" Globe Trotting *pe9 (egotiator" ,ital 2eal 0a:er" Super Strategist" Spo:esman and Personal +riend of the )hief of the L.T.T.&. ,elupillai Prabha:aran.Sources sa$ that" O5uattrocchi got in touch #ith the L.T.T.&. The meeting #ith the L.T.T.&. #as fi9ed in a +ive Star %otel in Paris.Ottavio 5uattrocchi and *nton -alasingham met. 5uattrocchi convinced -alasingham that RajivJs death #as vital to both. If Rajiv #ere dead then the -ofors Scam #ould die. If Rajiv #as dead then the L.T.T.&. could be confident that the Indian *rm$ #ill not go to Sri Lan:a to destro$ the L.T.T.&. 5uattrocchi handed over -ags of 2ollars to -alasingham as pa$ment for RajivJs *ssassination.The entire meeting and conversation bet#een Ottavio 5uattrocchi and *nton -alasingham #as Recorded b$ the +rench Intelligence *gencies.POn the da$ of his *ssassination Rajiv Gandhi #as in ,isha:apatnam. Rajiv #as campaigning for his fond candidate 'ma Gajapati Raju. Rajiv #as enjo$ing the campaigning. Rajiv #as in no mood to leave ,isha:apatnam" on that evening.* Trio of )ongress -us$bodies including P.,.(arasimha Rao made frantic Phone )alls from (e# 2elhi urging Rajiv to leave ,isha:apatnam and fl$ to )hennai. Rajiv :een on spending the night at ,isha:apatnam" tried avoiding to go to )hennai. Rajiv made an e9cuse that his aircraft #as not in perfect order. The )ongress -us$bodies of 2elhi got the *ircraft speedil$ chec:ed" repaired and told Rajiv that it #as read$. The )ongress -us$bodies forced a reluctant.to.leave.,isha:apatnam Rajiv" to fl$ from ,isha:apatnam to )hennai enroute to Sriperumbudur in Tamilnadu.Rajiv fle# to )hennai and #ent b$ road to Sriperumbudur. *s soon as the cavalcade of cars of Rajiv and the Tamilnadu State leaders accompan$ing Rajiv reached Sriperumbudur" Rajiv got out of the car and #al:ed through the cro#d to the 2ias. hen an$ national leader visits an$ part of the countr$ then the moment the leader gets do#n from the *ircraft" the entire State Leadership of his Part$ surrounds him. The State Leaders stic: to him through out the ,isit until he gets bac: in to the *irport. If a Photograph is ta:en at an$ given minute of the visit" the Photo #ill contain the (ational Leader and the Top State Leaders. hether it is ,ajpa$ee" *dvani" Rajnath Singh" Sonia or an$ national leader the scenario is the same. &ver$ Photo +rame #ill consist of the (ational leader being surrounded b$ State Leaders. hen Rajiv alighted at Sriperumbudur all the state Leaders #ere there. %o#ever" each of the Tamilnadu State Leaders suddenl$ decided to :eep a#a$ from Rajiv. +rom the car" Rajiv #al:ed through the cro#d unaccompanied b$ an$ State Leader.So" #hen the %uman -omb &9ploded" Rajiv #as -lo#n to pieces" but not a single Tamilnadu State Leader 2ied #ith him. G.E.0oopanar" P.)hidambaram" 0aragatham )handrashe:ar and several Other Tamilnadu state Leaders did not #al: #ith Rajiv. Strange and Impossible. -ut the Tamilnadu State leaders allo#ed Rajiv to #al: the 2eath. al: *lone.In the +inal Photo +rame of Rajiv Gandhi" no Tamilnadu State leader #as present #ith Rajiv. ere all these State Leaders a#are that Rajiv #ould be :illed and hence :ept a#a$ from Rajiv to save their lives/The Investigation in to the Rajiv *ssassination has not interrogated or put on the Lie 2etector Test and the (arco.*nal$sis Test the )ongress -ig#igs #ho insisted that Rajiv must

leave ,isha:apatnam and go to Tamilnadu" that *ssassination night. h$/Similarl$ the Investgation did not interrogate and subject to a Lie 2etector and a (arco *nal$sis Test the Tamilnadu )ongress State Leaders #ho deserted Rajiv immediatel$ after he got out of the car at Sriperumbudur. h$/ Intelligence *gencies Sources sa$ that the International *rms 2ealer *dnan Eashogi provided the -omb -elt #orn b$ the L.T.T.&.Js suicide %uman -omb to assassinate Rajiv Gandhi. IndiaJs Investigation never pursued this lead. h$/Later P.,.(arasimha RaoJs son Prabha:ar Rao and *dnan EashogiJs Son #ere involved in a 'R&* S)*0. The Government of India in 2ollars issued <=@ crores even before the 'rea arrived in India. Till toda$ the 'rea has not arrived. The <=@ )rores has not been recovered from (arasimha RaoJs Son. (o# the 0anmohan Singh Government has allo#ed the )rores of Rupees in the S#iss -an:s to be defree!ed. (arasimha Rao deserved to be in jail for corruption but 0anmohan calls him a Saint.IndiaJs Investigation in to the Rajiv *ssassination has not investigated P.,.(arasimha Rao and *dnan EashoggiJs +amil$ to ascertain the facts and complicit$" if an$" in the *ssassination of Rajiv Gandhi. h$/Ottavio 5uattrocchi #as the 0astermind in the )onspirac$ to *ssassinate Rajiv Gandhi. -ut 5uattrocchi #as never investigated. h$/The Intelligence *gencies of +rance" Israel and the 'nited States of *merica have %ighl$ )lassified Secret 2ata pertaining to all the details of the Rajiv Gandhi *ssassination.Israel" +rance and 'S are all 2emocracies. *ll three nations are closel$ involved #ith India in the International #ar against terrorism. It is their responsibilit$ to provide India #ith ever$ bit of evidence and information that the$ and their Intelligence agencies possess about the *ssassination of R ajiv Gandhi.So far these (ations have not given India an$ information because the government of India has not re4uested them. The moment India re4uests these countries then the$ #ill give to India" all the information the$ have.Politicspart$.com Re4uests the Parliament of India to ensure that the Government of India obtains all the information pertaining to the *ssassination of Rajiv Gandhi available #ith the Intelligence *gencies of +rance" Israel and the 'S and discloses all the information to IndiaJs Parliament.politicspart$.com Re4uests the Parliament of India to ensure that an investigation is ordered in to the Role of Ottavio 5uattrocchi in the *ssassination of Rajiv Gandhi.5uattrocchi must be arrested" brought to India put on a Lie 2etector Test and a (arco.*nal$sis Test and 5uestioned about his Role in the )onspirac$ to *ssassinate Rajiv Gandhi.politicspart$.com e9pects IndiaJs Parliament to do justice to one of its *ssassinated 0ember of Parliament Rajiv Gandhi.President of India Ealam is no# in +rance. The Government of India must re4uest President Ealam to re4uest the +rench President to ma:e available to India the Tapes of the Secret 0eeting in the Paris %otel and all other information involving the *ssassination of Rajiv Gandhi.The People of India must :no# the truth about the *ssassination of Rajiv and the )onspirators must be arrested" prosecuted and given the 2eath Sentence. Sorse of the stor$ hear -$ G. httpG;;blogs.ibibo.com;,ie#)omments.asp9/blogidH?cC>Dc>?.BBD?. >>@@.C?<c.?Bf<eCfC>efA&midHC<<ff<D<.=Aba.><@B.Ddea.D@<>AFeBe?fc పర త గ చదవండ

!"K helped ,TT- assassinate Rajiv andhi%

0unnetra Ea!hagam" 20E Leader

IndiaJs 2ravida 0unnetra Ea!hagam part$ 720E8 and its leader Earunanidhi #ho is the chief minister of Tamil (adu came in for strong criticism in the interim report of a

retired judge #ho probed the circumstances leading to the :illing in <DD< b$ an LTT& female suicide bomber. Indian officials blamed the :illing on Sri Lan:an Tamil Tiger terrorists" #ho the judge said had received support in the past from the 20E. In <DBA" Gandhi3s federal government dismissed Earunanidhi3s government" #hich #as accused of corruption. * $ear later" 0GR #on local elections and sent Earunanidhi into political #ilderness until 0GR3s death in <DCB. *fter a $ear of direct rule b$ the federal government" the 20E part$ regained po#er in Tamil (adu in <DCD. T#o $ears later the federal government dismissed Earunanidhi for a second time" accusing him of not doing enough to crac: do#n on the Tamil Tigers in his state. +urther" the )ommission said" the LTT& #as getting its supplies" including arms" ammunition" e9plosives" fuel and other essential items from Tamil (adu to continue its fight against the IPE+ that too #ith the support of the 20E Government" State *dministration and connivance of the la# enforcement agencies. The report said that soon after the 20E Government too: over the reins of po#er in Tamil (adu" Qthe LTT& slo#l$ began to consolidate itself in the State and their clandestine activities" heretofore dormant" became more and more pronounced. *ll the activities of the LTT& at this stage to#ards resource mobilisation" propaganda and treatment of their #ounded cadres" had ta:en an anti. national dimension.33 The )ommission noted the visit of the then 20E 0P" 0r. ,. Gopalas#am$" 0P 720E8 to (orthern Sri Lan:a and his reported meeting #ith Prabha:aran bet#een +ebruar$ C" <DCD" and 0arch ?" <DCD. QThis visit b$ 0r. ,. Gopalas#am$" and the manner in #hich this entire episode #as dealt #ith b$ the 20E part$ sent clear signals to the pro.LTT& anti.IPE+ elements in the State as #ell as LTT& itself that the ne#l$.elected Government #ould not resort to an$ drastic action against such elementsR on the other hand" the impression that the entire episode created #as that pro.LTT& gestures" even if the$ #ere illegal" #ould be tolerated b$ the Government.33 The )ommission3s report said the then Prime 0inister" Rajiv Gandhi" #as :een that Qsome satisfactor$ solution be arrived at #ith the LTT& so that the Indo.Sri Lan:an *ccord could be implemented in letter and spirit. %e discussed this concern #ith 0r. Earunanidhi and sought his assistance.33 *fter 0r. ,. P. Singh became the Prime 0inister on 2ecember =" <DCD" it #as spelt out that if no solution came" India #ould no longer give an$ militar$ or monetar$ help to an$ of the groups" nor allo# its mainland to be used for militant activities. QThe LTT& remained adamant during their parle$s #ith 0r. Earunanidhi" and continued to demand the formation of &elam"33 the report noted. The interim report said that credible reports e9isted of Qactive connivance of some 20E leaders #ith the LTT&. The LTT& #as in continuous interaction #ith 0r. Earunanidhi" primaril$ to ensure that their activities continue unhindered even after the Padmanabha :illing.33 The *TR Qnoted33 the observation of the )ommission that there #as a ne9us bet#een the LTT& and the 'L+* and their combined endeavours in Tamil (adu had also been confirmed. The )ommission3s report ponders over 4uestions of aid to the LTT& in the :illing of Rajiv Gandhi. Q ere there other forces behind the LTT& involved in the conspirac$ for the assassination of Rajiv

Gandhi/ These are 4uestions re4uiring a deep and an9ious probe"33 the report said referring to conspiratorial aspects #hich #ere $et to be dealt #ith b$ the one.man probe panel. Soon after the 20E Government too: over the reins of po#er in Tamil (adu" the LTT& slo#l$ began to consolidate itself in the State. 2uring <DDF" a gro#ing ne9us bet#een the LTT& and 20E and its repercussions on the local la# enforcement machiner$ #ere discernible. The assassination of &PRL+ leader E. Padmanabha and others at 0adras on <Dth 1une <DDF #as a shoc:ing reminder of the impunit$ #ith #hich the LTT& could operate in India. The case assumes significance due to the fact that stri:ing similarities #ere found in the Padmanabha assassination and the case relating to the assassination of Shri Rajiv Gandhi. It can" therefore" be safel$ concluded that the gro#ing connivance of the 20E Government #ith the LTT& having been brought to the :no#ledge of the (ational +ront Government" effective steps #ere not ta:en b$ the )entral government to chec: it" #hatever ma$ be the reasons. +rom the evaluation of the material" the conclusion is irresistible that there #as tacit support to the LTT& b$ Shri 0. Earunanidhi and his Government and la# enforcement agencies. The charges" put together as long 4uotations from the report" includeG that the 20E provided a safe sanctuar$ for the LTT& cadres and activists" it gave advice" active assistance" finance and securit$ cover to LTT& operations" and that the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi #ould not have been possible the #a$ it happened #ithout the ne9us bet#een the LTT& and the 20E" a ne9us #hich started a chain of events #hich led to the survival and gro#th of the LTT& in Tamil (adu long after the Government of India3s attitude had changed to#ards the LTT& and hostilities had bro:en out bet#een the Indian Peace Eeeping +orce and the LTT& in Sri Lan:a" and finall$ that the 20E leader and Tamil (adu )hief 0inister" 0r. 0. Earunanidhi" had Qhimself been instrumental in ensuring that things #ent smoothl$ for LTT&33 and that the cadres of the LTT& had little fear of the securit$ agencies in India Qthan:s to the patronage of the 20E Government33.

.B! -S , S-V J &RI"- &CV-R4Bps

(o# da$s #e are seeing fre4uent reports of 1udges involvement in crimes " se9ual assaults " misuse of office " etc in the media. The$ are hushing up " covering up those crimes b$ misusing their po#er " enormous clout. Legal Immunit$ applies onl$ to their official actions but not to their actions as individuals " their criminal actions. These guilt$ public servants cunningl$ intert#ine their official & personal actions to escape legal prosecution " in this bac:drop to bring out the #rong " illegal #or: practices of public servants " judges " police I have raised basic 4uestions about their #or: practices in public interest. Till date the guilt$ public servants have not given their full replies at all " as the$ have much to hide than to reveal.

Once again I am raising those 4uestions to %onourable )hief 1ustice of India to ans#er at the earliest in public interest G

@B;!2"-;T2, RI 0TS C@ &ITIH-;S Vs 1RIVI,- -S C@ &C;STITBTIC;2, @B;&TIC;2RI-S I; I;!I2

Let the Legislators of states" members of parliament" %igh courts & Supreme )ourt 1udges & other constitutional functionaries ans#er the follo#ing 4uestions #hich are vital in a democrac$. <8 =8 hat are the fundamental rights of a citi!en guaranteed under the constitution 7*rticle =<8 / hat are the privileges conferred on legislators & parliamentarians b$ the constitution of India/

a8 Inside the %ouse b8 Outside the %ouse ?8 hat are privileges conferred on constitutional functionaries" li:e

a8 President of India b8 Prime 0inister of India c8 )hief 1ustice of India d8 )hairman of (%R) e8 )entral ,igilance )ommissioners. >8 *re the privileges legal immunit$ conferred on above mentioned constitutional functionaries / a8 )over all their official actions irrespective of merit. b8 )over both their official & personal actions. @8 *re the privileges defined & codified / A8 *re these privileges above freedom of the press / B8 *re the libert$ & fundamental rights of the citi!ens guaranteed b$ the constitution" above the privileges of the constitutional functionaries or e4ual or belo# / C8 )an the Indian legislatures & parliament be e4uated to the %ouse of commons in &ngland #hich is considered to be a superior court and court of records / D8 )an the division of po#ers" namel$ the legislature" the e9ecutive and the 1udiciar$" be e4uated to the functioning of the %ouse of commons and %ouse of Lords in &ngland / <F8 )an a citi!en be said to have committed breach of privilege of the %ouse or court and causing contempt of the house or court b$ raising the issues of accountabilit$ of constitutional functionaries / <<8 )an a Legislature or Parliament enact a ne# la#" to circumvent or to nullif$ the 1udicial orders #ith respect to #rongdoings b$ peoples representatives & e9ecutive / does not it amount to infringement of 1udicial po#ers & contempt of the court b$ the %ouse. <=8 *re the +'(2*0&(T*L 2'TI&S of a citi!en more important than constitutional duties of a constitutional functionar$ or e4ual in importance to it /

<?8 )an a constitutional functionar$ commit crimes" anti.national activities in the name of constitutional duties" behind the legal veil of official3s secret act & go unaccountable for his actions and go unpunished b$ his legal immunit$ privileges / <>8 *re the Legislators members of parliament" %igh court & Supreme court 1udges and other constitutional functionaries not #illing to codif$ their privileges for the reason that if codified their privileges #ould be curtailed and their action #ould be subjected to legal scrutin$. / <@8 -$ votes of citi!ens Legislators and parliamentarians get seats in the legislature and Parliament out of ta9 pa$er3s mone$" the$ get their pa$" per:s & lead @.Star lu9urious lifest$les. %ence #hether a vote of a citi!en is above 70ore valid8 or a seat of legislator or parliamentarian is above or more valid in a democrac$ / <A8 1udges & )onstitutional functionaries are indirectl$ appointed b$ voters ; ta9 pa$ers. Out of ta9 pa$ers mone$" the$ get their pa$" per:s & lead @.star lu9urious lifest$les. %ence" #hether the vote of a citi!en" fundamental duties of a ta9 pa$er is above 7more valid8 or a seat of judge ; constitutional functionar$ is above 7more valid8 in a democrac$ / <B8 If there is a vacuum in the Legislature or parliament" #ho is to fill up that vacuum till such time that the legislature or parliament acts provide a solution b$ performing its role b$ enacting proper legislation to cover the field 7vacuum8 / <C8 hile it is an unhealth$ practice for a 1udge to claim to be a 1udge in his o#n cause" is it not #orse for the members of the legislature and parliament to be judges in their o#n cause / <D8 *re the Technicalities of the case more important to a judge or 1ustice to a citi!en" protection of fundamental rights of citi!en./ =F8 h$ not the constitutional functionaries initiate suo moto action #ith respect to numerous cases of injustices reported in 0edia / =<8 h$ not the 1udges admit various cases of Injustices affecting public" as the Public Interest LitigationQ / In some cases" the Public or the person representing them is unable to afford the high cost of the case. h$ not free legal aid is given /. ==8 hat is the criteria for admitting a P.I.L. & giving free legal aid / h$ the constitutional

=?8 )ommunication . free flo# of information is the lifeline of a democrac$. functionaries are not honouring the Right to Information of )iti!ens /

@IRST 211-2, B;!-R S-& 78 >7? C@ RTI 2&T 6**) C@ CV-R;"-;T C@ I;!I2 J CV-R;"-;T C@ K2R;2T2K2 211,I&2TIC; @CR I;@CR"2TIC; 2S 1-R RTI 2&T 6**) > S-- RB,- 66 C@ RTI 2&T 6**) ?

&1IC , ! J I 1 , (2; 2,CR7D%*8%6*76 &1IC , &"C , (2; 2,CR-

Reference ;o = 7*)DLRTILS1>1RC?L6*76LR12! dated Reference ;o = &"LE66LRTIL6*76 dated *F%*8%6*76 Reference ;o = S 7E) RTI 6*76 dated *D%*8%6*76

&1IC , R2.(0292; , (2; 2,CR-

&1IC , B;IC; 0C"- "I;ISTRI , CI , ;-9 !-,0I Reference ;o = !$%;o%767G*)L!SL&SL6*764 &SR%III dated 76%*8%6*76

&1IC , R2.I2S2(02 , ;-9 !-,0I

Reference ;o%RSL6><)G?L6*764RTI dated 7F%*8%6*76

&1IC , ,CKS2(02 , ;-9 !-,0I Reference ;o = 7 >8F8? L I&L76 dated 6<%*G%6*76 and ;o%7 >7*D*? L I& L 76 dated *D%*8%6*76 &1IC , R2S0TR212T0I (0292; , ;-9 !-,0I Reference ;o= 8))LRTIL*GL7647D dated 68%*G%6*76 &1IC , SB1R-"- &CBRT C@ I;!I2 , ;-9 !-,0I , ;C R-1,I

@B,, ;2"- C@ T0- 211,I&2;T = ;2 2R2.2%"%R%

2!!R-SS C@ T0- 211,I&2;T = ;2 2R2.2%"%R%, -!ITCR , SCS -4VCI&- .BSTI&- J SCS -4&,2RIC; C@ !2,IT , M ,I 46 L FE7, C11 92T-R 9CRKS C@@I&-, 0B!&C @IRST ST2 -, ,2V"IK2;T2;2 2R, 0-((2,, "ISCR- , K2R;2T2K2 1I; ' )F**7F%

RTI @irst 2ppeal "ade to @irst 2ppellate 2uthorities

RTI 211-,,2T- 2BT0CRITI , CLC ! J I of 1olice , overnment of Karnataka ,1olice 0S , (angalore%

!-T2I,S C@ !C&B"-;TS L 9RITT-; ST2T-"-;TS L I;@CR"2TIC; R-SBIR-! =

The concerned &1IC has failed to provide information to me , thereb$ he is shielding the criminals , anti nationals% In turn &1IC himself has committed crimes% It goes to prove the e:istence of &riminal ;e:us bet#een &RI"I;2,S 4 &CRRB1T 1B(,I& S-RV2;TS ' &CRRB1T 1C,ITI&I2;S%

0-R-(I , I !C 0B"(,I R-SB-ST ICB TC IV- "- 9RITT-; ST2T-"-;TS L 2;S9-RS TC T0@C,,C9I; SB-STIC;S ' 90I&0 I; ITS-,@ > ie ans#ers ? 2R- T0- I;@CR"2TIC; SCB 0T (I "-% 0-R- 9IT0 I 2" S--KI; ;CT T0- C1I;IC;S 2(CBT SC"- 0I1CT0-TI&2, ISSB-S , (BT ICBR C@@I&I2, ST2;! , ,- 2, ST2;! C; ISSB-S 90I&0 2R- C@ @R-SB-;T C&&BRR-;&90I&0 2R- VIC,2TI; 1-C1,-’S @B;!2"-;T2, RI 0TS J 0B"2; RI 0TS% 9- !C 02V0I 0-ST R-S1-&TS @CR .B!I&I2RI J 2,, 1B(,I& I;STITBTIC;S , T0IS IS 2; 211-2, @CR TRBT0 , I;@CR"2TIC; SC T02T TC 211R-0-;! &CRRB1T @-9 I; 1B(,I& S-RVI&-, 90C 2R- 2I!I; J 2(-TTI; T-RRCRIS" , B;!-R9CR,! J &RI"I;2,S% I 02V- S0C9; I; !-T2I, 9IT0 ,IV- , 2&TB2, &2S-S , -V2"1,-S , 0C9 I;!I2; ,- 2, SIST-" IS "2;I1B,2T-! (I &RI"I;2,S 9IT0I; .B!I&I2RI , 1C,I&- , 1RCS-&BTIC; , -T&% R-2! !-T2I,S 2T = https=LLsites%google%comLsiteLeclarionofdalitL#heeling4dealing4judges4police

0ereb$ , #e do re3uest 1IC CLC 0onourable &hief .ustice of India , 1IC , CLC 0%-%0onorable 1resident of India , 1IC CLC 0onorable Speaker of ,ok Sabha , 1IC CLC !$ &hairman of Raj$a Sabha , 1ICs of Karnataka Raj (ha#an , Karnataka &"C , Bnion 0ome "inistr$ CI and ! J I of 1olice of overnment of Karnataka to ans#er the follo#ing 3uestions in public interest , for safeguarding national securit$ , ;ational unit$ J integrit$ J to legall$ apprehend anti4 nationals , criminals #ithin the judiciar$ J police%

"ain 2 = Iou have not taken appropriate action to m$ previous RTI re3uests , ;umerous appeals for justice J police complaints% Iou have not replied to sho#4cause notice also% Iour inaction has helped the criminals in manipulating J destro$ing evidences%

Iour inaction L dela$ in performing $our duties not onl$ amounts to denial of information , but amounts to violation of our fundamental J human rights , cover4up of crimes , aiding J abetting criminals % The criminal ne:us tried to silence me in man$ #a$s% Is not these acts of $our’s a crime in itself A

If $our acts of crime cover4ups , information L evidence cover4ups , aiding J abetting criminals , silencing a crusader is just J legal% The same t$pe of acts of crimes performed b$ other citi+ens #ill also be legal A

"ain ( = 2t the outset , #e e:press our #hole hearted respects to all constitutional institutions J to the honest fe# in public service% &ontempt of constitutional institutions , citi+ens of India is being made b$ the corrupt persons in constitutional positions themselves% This is an appeal to the honest fe# in public service , constitutional positions , to bring their corrupt colleagues to book%

7% does the action of "1s , ",2s taking mone$ L receiving favors from vested interests , to formulate polic$ decisions , to raise 3uestions in parliament L legislative bodies or to abstain from voting legal A 6% #h$ transparent , fair investigation is not done in such cases A

D% just remember , the vulgar acts of "r%(ora (abu Singh in state legislature J ho# some ",2s vulgarl$ behaved #ith "s%.a$alalita in state legislature , $ears ago% 2re these t$pe of vulgar actions b$ "1s J ",2s legal A does not these constitute contempt of the house b$ "1s J ",2s themselves A <% all the people’s representatives from pancha$ath member to president of India must read 2(&! Cf !emocrac$ provide along #ith%since independence of India till date , "1s J ",2s are forcing projects on people against the #ishes of people , formulating policies against the #ishes of people% 2re not such projects , government policies J ,a#s , undemocratic J illegal A )% is the election commission of India verif$ing the authenticit$ of affidavits submitted b$ electoral candidates A E% ho# man$ candidates have been caught so far for giving false affidavits A are all the violators prosecutedA F% are the "1s , ",2s submitting their #ealth details on affidavits $earl$ to vigilance authorities A defaulters , violators ho# man$ A G% 8% #hat legal action taken against violators , defaulters , for giving false affidavits A #ho is checking the authenticit$ of those affidavits submitted b$ "1s , ",2s A

7*% the agricultural incomes of some "1s , ",2s , their kih J kin raises even during the time of severe drought , floods , fall in prices of agricultural products , their companies register increase in turnover L profits even during recession , the trusts L ; Cs set up b$ them receive huge donations% 2re all these income legal A

"ain & = 7% #e do once again offer our conditional services to the government of india , all state governments J supreme court of india , in apprehending ta: evaders , land grabbers , corrupt police , corrupt judges , corrupt public servants , labor la# violators , etc% #hom the the government officials , vigilance authorities have failed to apprehend% 9h$ the authorities , courts , supreme court of India , are not read$ to utili+e our service A are the$ afraid of being caught A 6% the public servants , courts theselves are dela$ing giving information L records to us in man$ cases% So in the issues L cases raised b$ us , the clause of time bar doe not appl$% 2re these dela$ing tactics of public servants , courts legal A D% #h$ no proper , timel$ action #as not taken based on numerous police complaints made b$ us A <% #h$ ! J I 1 , overnment of Karnataka , has not made an$ efforts to seek legal sanction for prosecution of VVI1s > mentioned in our complaint ? , from union J state home ministries A )% the criminal ne:us is tr$ing to silence me in man$ #a$s , but the supreme court of India J national human rights commission has failed to undo the injustices , #h$ A is it because it is not a high profile case A is it because it is not hi4fi , does not get image ratings , TR1s A E% the public servants are aiding under#orld , na:alites J terrorists , b$ their dela$ing tactics J denial of information , records% 9hat action has been taken against such anti4national elements in public service A F% ho# man$ complaints are made b$ ;agaraj %"%R% , 0uman Rights 2ctivist , "$sore >editor of SCS e4clarion of dalit J SCS e4voice for justice? to Karnataka police , to national human rights commission to supreme court of India till date A #hat action taken #ith respect to each complaint A G% the dela$ in taking action b$ public servants #ith respect to follo#ing cases has resulted in more crimes , destruction L manipulation of evidences , records and more injustices to commonman% 9h$ the authorities did not take timel$ action against criminals in follo#ing cases A

#%# Appeal to #&'R!(! C%&RT of I)*IA +ttp:,,e"clarionofdalit.-logspot.com,./0/,/1,s"o"s"appeal"to"s2preme"3 *!A # I) C%&RT# 4 '% IC! #TATI%)# R!A* : +ttp:,,sites.google.com,site,eclarionofdalit,satyameva"jayate 5 +ttp:,,e"clarionofdalit.-logspot.com,./00,/0,satyameva"jayate.+tml 5 ACC&#!* C+ief 62stice of India +ttp:,,sites.google.com,site,eclarionofdalit,acc2sed"c+ief"j2stice"of3

5 +ttp:,,e"clarionofdalit.-logspot.com,./00,/.,acc2sed"c+ief"j2stice"of3 CR%## !7A( %F 8%)%&RAB ! C8I!F 6&#TIC! %F I)*IA 5 #&'R!(! C%&RT %F I)*IA " +ttp:,,crosscji.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosse9amofc+iefj2stice.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crimesofs2premeco2rt.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosscji.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosse9amofc+iefj2stice.:ordpress.com, 5 CR%## !7A( %F &)I%) 8%(! #!CR!TAR; 5 <%I 5 )!= *! 8I > +ttp:,,crosscji.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosse9amofc+iefj2stice.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crimesofs2premeco2rt.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosscji.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosse9amofc+iefj2stice.:ordpress.com, 5 CR%## !7A( %F *<4I< %F '% IC! 5 <%? 5 BA)<A %R! > +ttp:,,crosscji.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosse9amofc+iefj2stice.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crimesofs2premeco2rt.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosscji.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,crosse9amofc+iefj2stice.:ordpress.com, 5 CR%## !7A( %F <%@!R)%R 5 R!#!R@! BA)? %F I)*IA +ttp:,,t+eftinr-i.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,t+eftinr-i.rediff-logs.com, 5 +ttp:,,t+eftinr-i.:ordpress.com, CR%## !7A( %F (&*A C%((I##I%)!R 5 (&*A 5 (;#%R! > +ttp:,,crimesofm2da.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,manivannanm2da.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crimesatm2damysore.:ordpress.com, 5 CR%## !7A( %F B*A C%((I##I%)!R 5 B*A 5 BA)<A %R! > +ttp:,,crimesof-da.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,-dacrimes.:ordpress.com, 5 C%R'%RAT! CRI(!# R'< CAB !# I(IT!* +ttp:,,crimesatrpg.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crimesatrpg.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,.01 (!<A FRA&* B; <%@!R)(!)T %F I)*IA +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,0AB are yo2 ready to catc+ ta9 t+ieves $ +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,0AB (%BI ! '8%)!# 5 C&RR!)C; #CA)*A # +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,0AB reliance ind2stry :+ere is acco2nta-ility $ +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,megafra2d-ygoi.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,0AB crimes at infosys camp2s

+ttp:,,crimeatinfy.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,crimeatinfy.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,.0C crimes -y B.*.A against a poor :oman +ttp:,,crimesof-da.-logpot.com, 5 +ttp:,,-dacrimes.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,.0. crimes of land mafia in India +ttp:,,landscamsinindia.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,landscam.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,.0. c2rrency t+efts in RBI 'ress +ttp:,,t+eftinr-i.-logspot.com, 5 +ttp:,,t+eftinr-i.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,1/ killer colas 4 killer medicines of India +ttp:,,deat+cola.-logpot.com, 5 +ttp:,,deat+cola.:ordpress.com, 5 +ttp:,,gro2ps.ya+oo.com,gro2p,nag+r:,message,./0 8%)%R %F I)*IA) 'A IA(!)T F%R #A ! http=LLsites%google%comLsiteLeclarionofdalitLhonor4of4indian4parliament4for4sale 1ersecuted IRC" S02R"I,2 of 1uttaparthi 21 ' pushpa kolasani on hunger strike in anantapur district jail 2ndhra 1radesh http=LLsites%google%comLsiteLeclarionofdalitLpersecuted4irom4sharmila4of4puttaparthi4ap

8% ho# man$ judges are caught b$ authorities for doing improper , immoral J illegal acts , since independence till date A #hat action taken in each case A 7*% #hat action taken against cop$ cat judges caught red handed #hile cop$ing in public e:amination in 2ndhra 1radesh A 77% have $ou revie#ed all the previous judicial decisions taken b$ such judges of doubtful integrit$ J honest$ A 76% is it not the dut$ of government J supreme court of India , to protect the fundamental rights J human rights of all Indian citi+ens A 7D% #h$ the government J supreme court of India has failed to protect the fundamental rights J human rights of me J those mentioned in m$ complaint A 7<% #ealth A ho# man$ former &.Is , supreme court J high court judges have disproportionate

7)% Iour denial of information to m$ previous RTI re3uests amounts to suppression of evidence , hiding crimes , #hat action against erring public servants A 7E% #h$ m$ previous RTI re3uests or part there of #as not transferred to appropriate authorities and information given to me in a consolidated form A

"ain ! = S7% 9h$ not death sentence to corrupt police #ho murder people in in lock4up L fake encounters A S6% 9h$ not death sentence to corrupt police #ho appl$ D rd degree torture on prisoners A SD% 9h$ not death sentence to corrupt police , #ho connive #ith criminals J backstabs our motherland , it’s national securit$ A S<% !on’t the police have suo4motto po#ers to take action in the interest of public #elfare , la# J order A S)% !ail$ #e see numerous reports of misdeeds b$ police , public servants , industrialists , etc in the media % Then #h$ not police taking an$ action #ith respect to them A SE% no#ada$s #e see numerous reports of scams , scandals b$ constitutional functionaries , public servants in the media% Instead of #asting mone$ , killing time b$ prolonging formation of parliamentar$ committees , judicial commissions , #h$ not subject those accussed public servants to narco anal$sis , lie deector test , etc to ascertain truth J provide timel$ justice A SF% If a commonman files a complaint , police L courts #ants evidences , #itnesses to take action against the rich J might$ crooks% 9here as if a rich person just gives a complaint against a poor chap , he is arrested , tortured eventhough there are no evidences , #itnesses% 9h$ this double standard A SG% If a poor chap tries to collect evidences as per his fundamental rights or as per RTI 2&T , the public servants don’t give full , truthfull information% Still , police L courts don’t take action against those public servants hiding crimes% 9h$ A S8%#h$ I #as not permitted to appear as an /amicus curie5 before jain commission of en3uir$ or supreme court of india probing late prime minister rajiv andhi assassination case A S7*% The criminal ne:us tried to silence me , b$ closing m$ ne#s paper , b$ snatching a#a$ m$ job oppurtunities in government service, b$ ph$sicall$ assaulting me , b$ threatening me of false fi:4ups in cases J b$ attempts to murder me% (ut no action against culprits , #h$ A S77% 9hereas , I #as en3uired number of times b$ police J intelligence personnel about this case , but the culprits #ere not en3uired even once , #h$ A S76%#ho compensates the losses I have suffered due to these injustices A are not police responsible for it A S7D% Is it not the dut$ of police to protect the lives , livelihood of #itnesses J all parties involved , both during case J after#ards A S7<% 0o# do $ou monitor J check corrupt police personnel J increase in their famil$’s #ealth $ear after $ear A S7)% 9hile getting appointed into government service from the rank of peon to I2S officer , police verification is mandator$% 9hile appointing to sensitive defense establishments ,

research institutes in addition to police verification , central intelligence agencies cross4check candidate’s background% 0o#ever is there no background checks of constitutional functionaries , "1s , ",2s , , #ho are priv$ to national secrets A #h$ A S7E% Recentl$ , the opposition parties have made allegations during presidential allegations that close relative of one of the front running candidates have s#indled public mone$ b$ their bank , misused public mone$ through one of their ; C% Is it true A S7F%has CI funded an$ terrorist outfits in india or abroad A S7G%india preaches non4violence , panchasheel principles to the #orld% In india , more than half the population are poor , people are starving to death% Inspite these background , CI funded J aided terrorist outfits in former east 1akistan ensuring the creation of (angladesh , CI has funded J aided terrorist outfits like ,TT- , TB,@ , -T& in srilanka , "S" in 1akistan% In turn these terrorist outfits have murdered thousands of innocents in those countries% 2re these acts of CI just J legal A Is not CI responsible for all those murders of innocents A has CI paid an$ compensation to those victims or their famil$ mebers A #h$ not A S78%#ithin india , to reduce the influence of certain terrorist groups , CI has funded J aided couter terrorist groups , is it right J legal A S6*% In .harkhand , chattisgarh , etc , the government has armed , trained J funded /sal#a judum5 to counter na:alites% Sal#a judum cadres are terrori+ing innocents just like na:alites% Is this action of government just J legal A S67%in india, T2!2 , 1CT2 is being rampantl$ misused b$ police% -ven #here there are no problems of terrorism , T2!2 L 1CT2 is being slapped against innocents , even children% In "%"%0ills of Karnataka state , ST@ personnel charged tribal people #ith T2!2 on frivolous charges of taking lunch to veerappan , stiching dress for the forest brigand, etc% #here as the prominent political, film , sports personalities #ho have links #ith under#orld , anti national elements J attended parties hosted b$ da#ood Ibrahim , other dons in gulf countries , else #here% (ut these hi4fi people are not charged #ith T2!2 L 1CT2 A #h$ A S66% @ilm actor sanja$ dutt had contacts #ith under#orld J full$ kno#ing #ell the criminal objectives of criminals , hid the dangerous arms J ammunition in his home , #hich #ere intended for terrori+ing public% 0o#ever mr%dutt is not charged #ith T2!2 L 1CT2 instead he is charged #ith illegal possession of arms act > #hich is normall$ applied to farmers #ho use illegal home made guns to scare a#a$ animals , birds in their farms ?% 9h$ this favourable treatment of mr%dutt b$ police A prosecution A is this because dutt is politicall$ might$ J rich A S6D% ,a# is one J same for all , the public servants, police interpretes , enforces it differentiall$ bet#een rich J poor A #h$ this differentiation A S6<%recentl$ in (angalore police nabbed criminals belonging to international criminal s$ndicate selling duplicate nokia mobiles% -ver$ nokia mobile comes #ith 7) digit I"-I number , this number is also used b$ police for tracking criminals% In consumer dispute at consumer disputes redressal forum "$sore &! <8L*) , nokia compan$ stated that all it’s products come #ith I"-I number onl$ J stated that the product in dispute sold b$ tata indicom dealer "LS I;TCTC &C""B;I&2TIC;S , "$sore are not their’s as it doesn’t have I"-I numbers% @urther nokia stated the$ don’t have an$ business relationship #ith either tata indicom or it’s dealer% 0o#ever the tata indicom dealer stated that indeed his products are genuine , first hand products , but doesn’t have I"-I numbers % this proves the dealer in collusion #ith tata compan$ is selling illegal nokia mobile hand sets J cheating the public% These mobiles are evading ta:es , as #ell as these are #ithout I"-I numbers best bu$ for criminal elements #ho #ant to evade police tracking% 9hat police are doing S6)% 9ho , of #hich rank among police personnel takes the decision to close a case ie to file /(5 report , #hen after certain time limit no leads are found in investigation A S6E% 0o# do $ou monitor corrupt police personnel , #ho purposefull$ fail to investigate case properl$ , so that either the case can be closed #ith /(5 report or the prosecution fails to prove the case in court A

S6F% 9ho among police takes the decision to appeal against the verdict of a lo#er court , #hen the prosecution fails A S6G% 9ho took the decision , not to appeal against the argentina court order ac3uitting mr%3uatrochi accussed in bofors scandal A S68% !o $ou treat all the prison convicts same in the prison or does the notorious big time rich criminals get spacious barracks #ith tv, ne#s paper , ade3uate food , medical care , etc #hile small time criminals , poor are crammed into pig st$ like rooms #ith E*4F* inmates #ithout an$ basic re3uirements A SD*% 9hat is the status of m$ complaint made to the ! J I of police , government of Karnataka on 7*L76L6**< A the copies of complaint #as released at press meet at patrakartara bhavan "$sore on same da$, even copies #ere given to police J intelligence personnel A SD7% 9h$ no action , repl$ regarding the complaint till date A SD6% Cur constitutional frame #orkers gave legal immunit$ privileges to certain constitutional functionaries , so that the$ are not burdened #ith frivolous court cases J can concentrate on their constitutional duties% (ut these privileges doesn’t cover the individual actions of those public servants like rape , murder , do#r$ harassment , ta: evasion , misuse of office , etc% but still la# enforcement L police department is bound to send re3uest to home ministr$ seeking permission J home ministr$ sits over files for months% This gives the accussed ample time to destro$ evidences% Is it right J legal A SDD% !oes legal immunit$ privileges cover their official actions alone A if not #hat does it cover A SD<% 9hat is the time limit for home ministr$ to give sanction for the prosecution of tainted constitutional functionaries A SD)% 0o# man$ present "1s , ",2s , "B;I&I212, &CR1CR2TCRS , other people’s representatives are facing criminal charges A SDE% In the past , ho# man$ "1s , ",2s , corporators #ere facing criminal charges , $ear#ise since 78GF A ho# man$ of them #ere eventuall$ convicted A SDF% 0o# man$ "1s , ",2s , prominent film , sports personalities have have contacts #ith under#orld , foreign intelligence agencies A SDG% 0o# man$ of them have attended fre3uent parties hosted b$ under#orld dons in gulf countries , else #here A SD8% 0o# man$ "1 , ",2 , other people’s representatives are #anted b$ police in various cases % but sho#n in the police records as absconding but in realit$ are attending the proceedings of the house as usual A S<*% 9hen did smt% Sonia andhi became a citi+en of india A did she occup$ an$ public office before naturali+ation A S<7% In india , ho# man$ "1s , ",2s , ",&s are of foreign origin or have a spouse of foreign origin A S<6% !oes smt% Sonia andhi have citi+enship of an$ other countr$ A S<D% !id she occup$ an$ public office #hile enjo$ing dual citi+enship A S<<% 0o# do $ou monitor public servants #ho have spouses of foreign origin J #hile the$ are on foreign tour , from national securit$ perspective A S<)% Is mr% "%S SB((2 member of parliament a citi+en of india A S<E% 9hat is the status of complaint made b$ former union minister mr%subraman$a s#am$ alleging that late 1%" rajiv gandhi’s famil$ received mone$ from foreign intelligence agencies A S<F% In man$ cases like mass riots involving certain political parties , #hen that culprit part$ comes to po#er all the cases involving it’s part$men are #ithdra#n b$ the government orelse prosecution fails to prove it’s case J prefers not to appeal% .ust remember (omba$ riot case involving shiv sainiks J others , #hen shiv sena ' (.1 came to po#er in "aharashtra , all the cases against it’s part$men #ere #ithdra#n% 2re these t$pe of decisions b$ government just J legal A

S<G%#hat damages has been done to india’s national securit$ due to mole in the 1"C, as alleged b$ former union minister mr%nat#ar singh A S<8% 9hat action b$ the government A S)*% 0o# man$ Indians are in the custod$ of police L militar$ in various foreign countries A S)7% 0o# man$ foreigners are there in Indian prisons A S)6% 0o# CI is protecting the human rights of these prisoners A S)D% Is the government pa$ing an$ compensation to victims of police failures , fi:4ups , , #ho suffer in jail for $ears J ac3uitted b$ courts upon finding them as not guilt$ A S)<% !o $ou register murder charges L attempt to murder charges against guilt$ police officers #ho are responsible for lock4up deaths , fake encounters J D rd degree torture A S))% 0o# man$ cases has been filed since 78GF till date A S)E% 9hat action has been taken against guilt$ police officers , ST@ personnel #ho #ere responsible for gross human rights violations , Drddegree torture , lock4up deaths of innocents in forest brigand veerappan’s territor$ , based on justice 2%.%Sadashiva commission findings A if not #h$ A S)F% I , as a citi+en of india as m$ /fundamental dut$5 hereb$ do offer m$ conditional services to CI J CK to apprehend corrupt public servants% 2re $ou read$ to utili+e m$ services A S)G% 1olice personnel are al#a$s in the forefront of containing crimes , mass fur$ , riots , etc% the$ suffer more J even their famil$ members suffer threats from the criminal elements% !o the government provide insurance coverage to police J their famil$ members on the lines of defense forces A S)8% 9hat is the amount of coverage to a police constable J his famil$ A SE*% 9ho makes the premium contributions A SE7% !o the government provide overtime allo#ance , food allo#ance to police #ho dail$ #ork be$ond G hours of dut$ A SE6% Is the government giving an$ training to police personnel in public interaction , human rights A SED% Is it right to post professionall$ trained police to sentr$ , orderl$ duties of ministers A SE<% 9hat is the ratio of police personnel to total population in india since 78GF A SE)% IS T0- CV-R;"-;T IVI; 2!-SB2T- @CC!, "-!I&2, &2R- , &,CT0I; , ,IVI; S12&TC 1RISC; I;"2T-S , 2S R-SBIR-! (I 2 ;CR"2, 0B"2; -I; 2&&CR!I; TC 9%0%C ;CR"S A SEE% Is the forensic science department #hich conducts narcfo4anal$sis , lie4detector test , etc under the control of police department A SEF% Is it not right to put it under impartial control of ;0R& or like bodies A SEG% Is the action of some police officers arranging compromise meetings J subtl$ insisting the poor to to# the line of rich or else face the conse3uences , is it right J legal A this happens mostl$ in real estate matters% SE8% !id government make an$ ransom pa$ments to forest brigand veerappan during his various kidnappings A SF*% 9hat action has been taken based on revealations b$ karim telgi during narco anal$sis about public servants involvement A SF7% 0o# man$ cases of allegations against judges #ere made in the media about misuse of office , criminal acts b$ judges from munsiff court to supreme court of India A since 78<F till date SF6% are the en3uir$ report findings, action taken reports of such cases accessible to public A if not #h$ A SFD% #hat action has been taken against guilt$ judges A SF<% are the guilt$ judges legall$ prosecuted in all such cases A or has it just ended #ith their resignation from services or his superior judge not allotting him an$ judicial #ork A SF)% #h$ some high ranking judges are not legall$ prosecuted for their #rong doings A SFE% are judges above la# A are not ever$bod$ e3ual before la# A

SFF% do the judiciar$ subject , all the cases handled b$ accussed L tainted , guilt$ judges to revie# , to undo past unjust judgements A SFG% ho# A if not #h$ A SF8% ho# do the judiciar$ monitor the net #ealth gro#th of some judges including the #ealth in the name of judge’s famil$ members A SG*% do all the judges file their annual income , #ealth statements on s#orn affidavits to the higher judiciar$ A defaulters ho# man$ A SG7% ho# does the judiciar$ verifies those statements A SG6% is such statements made public , on #eb A SGD% #hen the judgement of a lo#er court is turned do#n b$ the higher court , #hat action is initiated against lo#er court judge for making unjust judgement J meating out injustice A SG<% #hen allegations of corruption , misuse of office , etc against judges are made , #h$ the accussed ' judges are not subjected to tests like /pol$ graph , lie detector , brain mapping , etc5 , in the interest of justice J truth A SG)% judges are not emplo$ees of government , so the$ are ineligible to be the members of /Karnataka state government judicial department house building co4operative societ$5% Then ho# come , man$ judges including supreme court judges are admitted as members of this societ$ J allotted prime residential site #orth crores of rupees for a fe# thousands b$ the said societ$ at said societ$’s ' judicial la$out , $elahanka , (angalore A #hile the ordinar$ members like peons , clerks in judicial department are #aiting for a site since $ears , is not the #hole thing grossl$ illegal A SGE% in more than F*W of cases before all courts in India , central government or state government or government agenc$ is one of the parties% 0o# man$ judges or their famil$ members , have received out of turn , favourable allotments of sites , gas agenc$ , petrol pumps , etc b$ the government A is not such allotments illegal A #hat action A SGF% #hen a person under police custod$ or judicial custod$ suffer D rd degree torture b$ police , is not the judge of the respective court #hich is handling that tortured person’s case responsible for it A SGG% has the higher judiciar$ legall$ prosecuted respective judges J the police officers for committing Drd degree torture , on charges of attempt to murder J murder A if not #h$ A SG8% registrar , "$sore district J sessions court , has called for the candidatures to various vacancies in that court from the public vide notification no = 2!";L2L7*G6)L6**D dated 78L77L6**D% 1lease furnish me the merit ranking list of selected candidates along #ith m$ merit ranking for the post of peon% S8*% registrar , (angalore cit$ civil court , has called for the candidatures to various vacancies in that court from the public vide notification no = 2!"4I>2?<66L*D dated 78L*)L6**D% 1lease furnish me merit ranking list of selected candidates for the post of peon% S87% #hen a person doesn’t get ade3uate food , medical care #hile under police custod$ or judicial custod$ , is not the respective judge dealing that person’s case responsible for it A #hat action A S86% ho# judiciar$ is monitoring food J medical care to prisoners A S8D% numerous accussed persons are suffering in jail under judicial custod$ , for periods far e:ceeding the legall$ stipulated sentence periods% @or e:ample = a pick4pocketer is in jail for one $ear , the judge finds him guilt$ of offence J gives him D months sentence% 9hat about the e:cess punishment of 8 months% Is not the judge responsible for the illegal , e:cess punishment of the convict A #hat action against the judge in such cases A S8<% numerous innocents suffer in jail for $ears J finall$ the judge finds them as innocents J ac3uits them of the charges% 9hat about the prison sentence , the innocent has alread$ served A is not the judge responsible for this illegal , unjust punishment to an innocent A remed$ A #hat action against the judge A S8)% does the privileges of judges cover both their official actions J the actions arising out of

misuse of office A S8E% does the privileges of judges cover both their official actions as judges J their personal actions as individuals A S8F% are the fundamental rights of citi+ens supreme or the privileges of judges , constitutional functionaries supreme A S8G% #hat is the criteria adopted for promotion of judges A S88% #hat is the criteria adopted for appointment of advocates from bar , as the judges A S7**% #hat is the criteria adopted for appointment of retired judges , as governors of states , members or as chairman of commissions , etc A S7*7% ho# man$ judges belonging to oppressed classes ' scheduled caste , scheduled tribe , other back#ard classes , minorities J #omen are their in supreme court , state high courts J subordinate courts A kindl$ provide specific figures % S7*6% #hat are the legal measures enforced b$ judiciar$ , to enforce the accountabilit$ of judges J to check corruption in judiciar$ A S7*D% are not these measures a failure , looking at present state of affairs of judiciar$ A S7*<% does the judges arrange for distribution of alchoholic drinks at the official meetings , parties , at the ta: pa$er’s e:pense A S7*)% does an$ judges have included their consumption of alchoholic drinks , in their hotel bill J claimed traveling allo#ance A S7*E% #hat action has been taken against ' selectors ie Karnataka high court judges J ne#l$ selected #omen judges involved in roost resort scandal in "$sore , Karnataka A S7*F% #hen common people L ta: pa$ers J even government emplo$ees are not getting proper health care from government at government hospitals% Is it right J just to provide premium health care to judges , constitutional functionaries at )4star private hospitals in India , abroad , all at ta: pa$er’s e:pense A S7*G% are the judges subjected to periodical health check4ups to ascertain their health , mental faculties J mental balance in the midst of all #ork pressures , emotional tensions A S7*8% #hat is the criteria adopted b$ judiciar$ for accepting applications seeking public interest litigations A S77*% #h$ numerous appeals for 1I, b$ me , #ere not considered A S777% #hat is the criteria adopted b$ judiciar$ , for appointing /amicus curie5 in a case A S776% #h$ m$ appeal to honourable supreme court , to make me as an /amicus curie5 in late 1%" Rajiv andhi’s assassination case , #as not considered b$ the court A S77D% #hat is the criteria adopted b$ judiciar$ , for initiating suo4motto action A S77<% numerous cases of injustices are reported in the media dail$ , #ith supporting evidences % #h$ not the judiciar$ take suo4motto action in all such cases A S77)% legal aid boards pre4judge the cases in the name of taking legal opinion , before providing legal aid to the need$ A is it not need$ person’s rights violation A S77E% is not the safet$ of #itnesses , parties in cases responsibilit$ of the court , both during hearing of the case J after#ards A S77F% is the use of Drd degree torture b$ police on prisoners , during the police custod$ L judicial custod$ L prison sentence right A #hat action A S77G% #hen the corrupt police officer J government prosecution advocate together cover4up evidences , conducts improper investigation intentionall$ to fail the case ' to cover4up rich crooks , high J might$ people , #hat action judge takes in such cases A S778% ho# does the judiciar$ monitor the #ealth gro#th of police , government advoctes , ta: officials , officials of licensing authorities , to ensure proper J fair prosecution of cases against rich J might$ A S76*% #hat are the status of appeals made b$ human rights activist ;2 2R2.%"%R% to the honourable supreme court of India A S767% corruption is rampant for selection of officers to 3uasi4judicial positions like district L

taluk magistrates , ta: officers , revenue officers , land ac3uisition officers , etc% ho# the judiciar$ monitors over their 3uasi4judicial actions A S766% subject to conditions , I , ;2 2R2.%"%R% , editor , e4voice of human rights #atch , do offer m$ free services to honourable supreme court of India , to apprehend corrupt judges , are $ou ' the honourable court read$ to utili+e it A S76D% #hat are the status of m$ appeals , sent to the honourable supreme court of India , through government of india’s on4line grievance s$stem > !1 J !2R1 ? = !1 L"L6**ELG***G , !2R1 L-L6**EL***)F, !2R1 L-L6**EL**66) , !1 L"L6**ELG**67 , !2R1 L-L6**EL**6)D , !1 L"L6**ELG**D6 , !2R1 L-L6**EL*77<8 , !1 L"L6**ELG**<F , !2R1 L-L6**EL*77E< , !1 L"L6**ELG**<D , !1 L"L6**ELG**G) , !2R1 L-L6**EL*EF*< , !2R1 L-L6**EL*F*7F , !2R1 L-L6**EL*F*7G , !1 L"L6**ELG*7)8 , !1 L"L6**ELG*7E6 , !2R1 L-L6**EL*FGE< , !1 L"L6**ELG*7E) , !2R1 L-L6**EL*FGFF , !1 L"L6**ELG*7EF , !2R1 L-L6**EL*G*6G , !2R1 L-L6**EL*G*68 , !2R1 L-L6**EL*G*D6 , !2R1 L-L6**EL*G*<D , !2R1 L-L6**EL*G*<< , !1 L"L6**ELG*7F< , !1 L"L6**ELG*78D , !2R1 L-L6**FL***<< , !1 L"L6**FLG***D , !1 L"L6**FLG**7* , !2R1 L-L6**FL**7E< , !2R1 L-L6**FL**7E) , !1 L"L6**FLG**7< , !1 L"L6**FLG**6) , !1 L"L6**FLG**<8 , !1 L"L6**FLG**)) , !1 L"L6**FLG**)E , !1 L"L6**FLG**FG , !1 L"L6**FLG**G6 , !2R1 L-L6**FL*6E7G S76<% the appeals made to the honourable supreme court of India , copies of #hich are available at follo#ing #eb pages http=LLgroups%$ahoo%comLgroupLnaghr#LmessageL7G6 , http=LLgroups%$ahoo%comLgroupLnaghr#LmessageL6*E , http=LLgroups%$ahoo%comLgroupLnaghr#LmessageL6*G , http=LLgroups%$ahoo%comLgroupLnaghr#LmessageL676 , http=LLgroups%$ahoo%comLgroupLnaghr#LmessageL6*8 , http=LLgroups%$ahoo%comLgroupLnaghr# #hat are the status of those appeals A S76)% in the media , #e have seen reports about judges committing crimes ' rape , attempt to murder , s#indling government mone$ , untouchabilit$ practice , the disrespect to national flag , sale of judicial orders , bail , receipt of monetar$ gains b$ #a$ of ro$alt$ for books , prime real estate purchase at discounted rate , taking round about long foreign tours along #ith famil$ in the name of official #ork , etc% b$ this #a$ , judges themselves are making contempt of court , constitution of India J citi+ens of India% 0o# $ou are protecting the honour of the judiciar$ , constitution of India J citi+ens of India A please ans#er% S76E% Is the government giving an$ facilities L affirmative actions to policemen’s famil$ as being given to defense personnel , e:4servicemen J their families , like preferential site allotment , lpg agenc$ , ration depot , reservation in college admission , soft bank loans , etc A S76E% if not , #h$ A after all , the contribution of police to national securit$ is on par #ith defense forces% S76F% is not some high police officials addressing their subordinates in singular term , abusing them #ith vulgar #ords #rong A S76G% is not some police personnel calling public #ith singular term, abusing public #ith vulgar #ords #rong A S768% is it not the dut$ of prison authorities to protect the health, lives of prison in4mates A S7D*%#hat action is taken against police personnel #ho #rongl$ charged an innocent person of criminal acts , resulting in his confinement in jail , finall$ ac3uitted b$ court as found to be innocent A S7D7% is it not right to #ith hold salar$ , gratuit$ , pension to such guilt$ police personnel J pa$ it as compensation to victims of police failures J atrocities A S7D6% does our Indian constitution legall$ permit a citi+en of foreign origin naturali+ed b$ marriage to an Indian or naturali+ed b$ option , to occup$ an$ constitutional office A S7DD% during british rule in india J various other british colonies , criminal cases #ere foisted

against our freedom fighters in India J other british colonies% 2fter india’s independence #hat happened to those cases A did our Indian government close all such cases or did it continue #ith the prosecution A S7D<% in ho# man$ cases CI J other state government continued #ith the prosecution 2 2I;ST CBR @R--!C" @I 0T-RS A #h$ A S7D)% #hat about the status of cases against shri%netaji subash &handra bose A S7DE% has CI deported an$ freedom fighters to (ritain or it’s colonies , to face prosecution after India gained independence A 02S CI R-&-IV-! 2;I R-SB-ST @RC" (RIT2I; TC T02T -@@-&T A if $es , #h$ , #hom A S%7DF% the honourable supreme court of India failed provide information to me as per m$ RTI re3uest appeal no = 87 L 6**F in response to $our letter no = @7 L RTI L 2%87 L 6**F dt 7D%76%*F , #h$ A S7DG % the honourable union home secretar$ failed to give me information as per m$ rti re3uest , he transferred m$ application to others , in turn the$ transferred the application to some others% @inall$ , complete truthful information #as not given , #h$ A as the union home secretar$ has got copies of all those replies in response to transferred RTI application , #ill he send me a consolidated repl$ to m$ present RTI re3uest A S7D8% in a high profile case before the honourable delhi high court , #e have seen ho# defense advocate mr% R%S%2;2;! J prosecution advocate mr% I%B%K02; made a secret pact to #in the case in favour of rich criminal , totall$ manipulating prosecution #itnesses , evidences J prosecution stand , totall$ making mocker$ of justice s$stem % ho# $ou are ensuring the deliver$ of justice , there being numerous such advocates in practice A S7<*% Smt% Sonia andhi is person of foreign origin , she #ields enormous clout more than the 1rime "inister himself over the government of India being the chair person of B12% Is she legall$ permitted to summon confidential official records , minutes of the cabinet , to hold the cabinet meeting of union ministers A S7<7% 2s per la# , is she permitted to hold constitutional offices like prime minister of India or president of India , etc A S%7<6% 9hat are the fundamental rights of a citi+en guaranteed under the constitution >2rticle 67? A S7<D% 9hat are the privileges conferred on legislators J parliamentarians b$ the constitution of IndiaA a? Inside the 0ouse b? Cutside the 0ouse S7<<% 9hat are privileges conferred on constitutional functionaries, like a? 1resident of India b? 1rime "inister of India c? &hief .ustice of India d? &hairman of ;0R& e? &entral Vigilance &ommissioners% S7<)% 2re the privileges legal immunit$ conferred on above mentioned constitutional functionaries A a? &over all their official actions irrespective of merit% b? &over both their official J personal actions%

S7<E% 2re the privileges defined J codified A S7<F% 2re these privileges above freedom of the press A S7<G% 2re the libert$ J fundamental rights of the citi+ens guaranteed b$ the constitution, above the privileges of the constitutional functionaries or e3ual or belo# A S7<8% &an the Indian legislatures J parliament be e3uated to the 0ouse of commons in -ngland #hich is considered to be a superior court and court of records A S7)*% &an the division of po#ers, namel$ the legislature, the e:ecutive and the .udiciar$, be e3uated to the functioning of the 0ouse of commons and 0ouse of ,ords in -ngland A S7)7% &an a citi+en be said to have committed breach of privilege of the 0ouse or court and causing contempt of the house or court b$ raising the issues of accountabilit$ of constitutional functionaries A S7)6% &an a ,egislature or 1arliament enact a ne# la#, to circumvent or to nullif$ the .udicial orders #ith respect to #rongdoings b$ peoples representatives J e:ecutive A does not it amount to infringement of .udicial po#ers J contempt of the court b$ the 0ouse% S7)D% 2re the @B;!2"-;T2, !BTI-S of a citi+en more important than constitutional duties of a constitutional functionar$ or e3ual in importance to it A S7)<% &an a constitutional functionar$ commit crimes, anti4national activities in the name of constitutional duties, behind the legal veil of official’s secret act J go unaccountable for his actions and go unpunished b$ his legal immunit$ privileges S7))% 2re the ,egislators members of parliament, 0igh court J Supreme court .udges and other constitutional functionaries not #illing to codif$ their privileges for the reason that if codified their privileges #ould be curtailed and their action #ould be subjected to legal scrutin$% A S7)E% ($ votes of citi+ens ,egislators and parliamentarians get seats in the legislature and 1arliament out of ta: pa$er’s mone$, the$ get their pa$, perks J lead )4Star lu:urious lifest$les% 0ence #hether a vote of a citi+en is above >"ore valid? or a seat of legislator or parliamentarian is above or more valid in a democrac$ A S7)F% .udges J &onstitutional functionaries are indirectl$ appointed b$ voters L ta: pa$ers% Cut of ta: pa$ers mone$, the$ get their pa$, perks J lead )4star lu:urious lifest$les% 0ence, #hether the vote of a citi+en, fundamental duties of a ta: pa$er is above >more valid? or a seat of judge L constitutional functionar$ is above >more valid? in a democrac$ A S7)G% If there is a vacuum in the ,egislature or parliament, #ho is to fill up that vacuum till such time that the legislature or parliament acts provide a solution b$ performing its role b$ enacting proper legislation to cover the field >vacuum? A S7)8% 9hile it is an unhealth$ practice for a .udge to claim to be a .udge in his o#n cause, is it not #orse for the members of the legislature and parliament to be judges in their o#n cause A

S7E*% 2re the Technicalities of the case more important to a judge or .ustice to a citi+en, protection of fundamental rights of citi+en%A S7E7% 9h$ not the constitutional functionaries initiate suo moto action #ith respect to numerous cases of injustices reported in "edia A S7E6% 9h$ not the .udges admit various cases of Injustices affecting public, as the 1ublic Interest ,itigation5 A In some cases, the 1ublic or the person representing them is unable to afford the high cost of the case% 9h$ not free legal aid is given A% S7ED% 9hat is the criteria for admitting a 1%I%,% J giving free legal aid A S7E<% &ommunication ' free flo# of information is the lifeline of a democrac$% 9h$ the constitutional functionaries are not honouring the Right to Information of &iti+ens A S7E)% Recentl$ , #hile assuming office as honourable chief justice of Karnataka , justice% 1%!%!I;2K2R , gave a blanket #ithdra#al of all internal departmental en3uiries against appro:imatel$ 6** judges , is it just J legal A give me the names of accused judges J description of charges against them A S7EE% does it not sho# that judges are more e3ual than others A S7EF% #ho are involved in 1@ scam A #hat action against guilt$ judges A S7EG% 9h$ $ou did not give information to me as per RTI 2ct inspite of appeal A refer% @7LRTIL287L6**F% S7E8% 2lmost a $ear ago , in the Karnataka state ne# chief justice of Karnataka high court honble "r%!inakar >no# elevated to supreme court of India? just on assuming offices #ithin hours scrapped disciplinar$ in3uir$ proceedings against 6**X erring judges% In such a short time no human being can stud$ all the cases in detail , then ho# come he arrived at this vital decision in such short timeA 9ho are those 6**X judges facing en3uir$ A S7F* %Recentl$ in the Karnataka state , high court found out that a district judge #ithout conducting hearings properl$ , entering fictious dates of hearings >#hich happens to be government holida$s ? facilitated in e:onerating a top politician % has the court en3uired into the previous judgements of the accussed judge A did it find an$ #rongdoingsA S7F7% 2s per la# , #hile on dut$ a person should not be drunk , under the influence of alchohol , as it limits the functioning of his senses J brain% That is #h$ the acts J sa$ings of drunkards , committed L said #hen the$ are drunk are not taken seriousl$% 0o#ever most of the police officers after evening hours are drunk , in that state onl$ the$ apprehend man$ suspects J produce those suspects at the residences of magistrates before magistrate during #ee hours L night% Some of of the judges are also drunk during that time% !oes the senses of drunken police J judges #ork properl$ to do their respective duties in identif$ing criminals , apprehending them J to issue judicial orders% 2re these actions of police J judges in drunken state legal A S 7F6 % 9hat action has been taken in bhopal gas leak case against the guilt$ police officials #ho changed the charge sheet against union carbide officials A S 7FD % 9hat action has been taken against guilt$ police officials , district magistrate , state ministers J central ministers #ho full$ aided the criminals ' Bnion &arbide official "r% 2nderson to escape la# , to jump bail J flee the countr$ #ithout court’s permission A S 7F< % 9hat action has been taken against the above said guilt$ #ith respect to their contempt of court J for aiding a criminal to escape A

S 7F)% 9hat action has been taken against the chief justice of India , #ho changed the legal clause under #hich the guilt$ should be tried A #hat action has been taken against the &.I #ho became an official of the trust belonging to the criminal A S 7FE % 9hat action has been taken against the Indian 1ublic servant #ho decided to #ithdra# cases from BS &ourts #ith respect to (hopal gas traged$ A S 7FF % 9hat action has been taken against the state labour department J pollution control board officials #ho have failed in their duties , inspite of earlier #arnings b$ journalists A S 7FG % 9hat action has been taken against state cabinet ministers #ho decided the 3uantum of compensation mone$ to favour the criminal although the$ don’t have right to do so A S 7F8 % 9hat action has been taken against 1residing .udge of the trial court , &hief .ustice of India , state police officials , public prosecutors J &entral (ureau of Investigation officials #ho kept 3uite all along and didn’t press for the e:tradition of the criminal "r%2nderson , for producing the criminal accussed no%7 before the trial court A S 7G* % Is it not S02"-@B, for the judiciar$ , police , government officials J people’s representatives #ho became part of Cperation &rime 0ush Bp J aided criminals responsible for ghastl$ murders of thousands J maiming of lakhs of hapless public in (hopal as ,eak Traged$A S 7G7 % 2re these &orrupt 1olice , corrupt judges , corrupt ministers , corrupt labour L pollution control board officials 0B"2; (-I; S A S 7G6 9h$ police are not registering m$ complaint against &.I J other VVI1S ,-ven after $ears A S 7GD don’t the police of vija$anagar police station m$sore have legal jurisdiction to register the case against these VVI1s A or just because the criminals happens to be VVI1s ,the$ are not booked b$ policeA If the said police don’t have legal jurisdiction to book these VVI1s , the$ should have transferred the complaint to those authorities #ho have jurisdiction J authorit$ to book J prosecute these VVI1s , but not done so , #h$ A S 7G< are not all these actions , of VVI1s J police amounting to cover up of crimes J criminals A are not these cover ups itself is a crime A S 7G)% -ven an appeal for justice b$ post card must be treated as 1I, b$ courts of justice % ho#ever m$ appeals for justice concerning public #elfare , national securit$ sent through post , e4mail to supreme court of india are not admitted as 1ublic interest litigation , #h$ A does not these acts of Supreme court amount to aiding criminals , anti nationalsA S 7GE 2re not the honourable chief justice of india together #ith the jurisdictional police J Revenue district magistrate responsible to protect the fundamental J human rights of people A #h$ the &.I , "$sore !& J .urisdictional 1olice have failed to protect the fundamental J human rights of people including mine A @or all the previous injustices I have suffered at the hands of the criminal ne:us 0onourable &.I , "$sore revenue district magistrate J jurisdictional police are together responsible , if an$thing unto#ard happens to me or to m$ famil$ members or to m$ dependents the 3uartet ' 0onourable &hief .ustice of India , 0onourable !istrict "agistrate , "$sore , 0onourable 1olice &ommissioner of "$sore cit$ J &ircle Inspector of police , vija$anagar police station , m$sore #ill be responsible % These corrupt parasites #ill feel , understand the pain onl$ #hen the$ also suffer in the same manner% ,et us pra$ to almight$ ' In #hose &ourt of justice "2T&0 @IVI; is not there J ever$ bod$ is e3ual , let us pra$ to that god to give these corrupt parasites ghastl$ deaths nothing less nothing more%

I-2R TC 90I&0 2(CV- 1-RT2I;S = "2.CRITI C@ !C&B"-;TS 1-RT2I;S TC I-2R 788746*76 % SC"- C@ T0- !C&B"-;TS 2R- !2T-! (2&K TC 78<F%

1B(,I& I;@CR"2TIC; C@@I&-Rs #ho failed to provide information and shielding criminals , anti nationals = 7% 1IC , CLC 0onorable &hief .ustice of India , Supreme &ourt of India , ;e# !elhi% 6% 1IC , CLC 0%-%0onorable 1resident of India , Rashtrapathi (ha#an , ;e# !elhi% D% 1IC CLC 0onorable Speaker of ,ok Sabha , CI , ;e# !elhi% <% 1IC CLC !$ &hairman of Raj$a Sabha , CI , ;e# !elhi% )% 1IC , CLC Bnion 0ome "inister , CI , ;e# !elhi% E% 1IC , CLC 0%-%0onorable overnor of Karnataka , Raj (ha#an , (angalore% F% 1IC , CLC 0onorable &hief "inister of Karnataka , &"C , (angalore% G% 1IC , CLC ! J I of 1olice , overnment of Karnataka ,1olice 0S , (angalore%

@ees 1aid = 7% 6% D% <% )% E% F% G% I1C *G@ <68D*E for rupees ten onl$% I1C *G@ <68D*F for rupees ten onl$% I1C *G@ <68D*G for rupees ten onl$% I1C *G@ <68D*8 for rupees ten onl$% I1C *G@ <68D7* for rupees ten onl$% I1C *G@ <D*F*7 for rupees ten onl$ % I1C *G@ <D*F*6 for rupees ten onl$ % I1C *G@ <D*F*D for rupees ten onl$%

-nclosed =

7% 6% D%

1olice &omplaint dated 6*%*G%6*76 Sho# &ause ;otice !ated 6*%*G%6*76 2(&! ,esson of !emocrac$%

!2T- = *6%7*%6*76 RRRRR%%RRRRRRRRR;2 2R2.2%"%R%

1,2&- = "ISCR- , I;!I2R%% RRRRRRRRR%> 211,I&2;T?

)ditorial : *ang +apist ,udges to Lamp -osts - ,./0)S 1 S)2.3L C+'4)S

3t the outset , we express our whole hearted respects to the honest 5ew public ser(ants in public ser(ice including judiciary 1 -olice *owe(er, the corrupt in public ser(ice don6t deser(e respect as indi(iduals 7 as they are parasites in our legal system Still we respect the chairs they occupy but not the corrupt indi(iduals

3ll the 5ollowing articles / issues , past cases o5 sexual assaults on women by judges 8hushed up 9: , whole articles published in the weblinks mentioned below 5orms part o5 this appeal ;he term <,./0)= mentioned throught includes all public ser(ants discharging judicial 5unctions right 5rom taluk magistrates , quasi-judicial o55icers to Chie5 ,ustice o5 'ndia 'ndian Legal / ,udicial System is manipulated at (arious stages 1 is 5or sale 't is a S*34) ;he persons who raise their (oice seeking justice are silenced in many ways ;he criminal nexus has already attempted to silence me in many ways '5 anything untoward happens to me or to my 5amily members , my dependents , *onourable Chie5 ,ustice o5 'ndia together with jurisdictional police o55icer will be responsible 5or it *ereby, we do once again o55er our conditional ser(ices to the honourable supreme court o5 'ndia 1 other go(ernment authorities, in apprehending criminals including corrupt judges 1 police *erewith , we once again appeal to the honourable supreme court o5 'ndia , to consider this as a -'L 3ppeal in public interest Consider the cases o5 sexual assault by ,./0)S , ->L'C) on women ;he ,./0)S ha(e legal immunity with respect to their o55icial duties, o55icial actions but not their indi(idual actions amounting to C+'4)S ;he public ser(ants 1 the go(ernment must be role models in law abiding acts , 5or others to emulate 1 5ollow i5 a student makes a mistake it is excusable 1 can be corrected by the teacher i5 the teacher himsel5 makes a mistake , all his students will do the same mistake i5 a thie5 steals , he can be caught , legally punished 1 re5ormed i5 a police himsel5 commits crime , many thie(es go scot- 5ree under his patronage e(en i5 a police , public ser(ant commits a crime , he can be legally prosecuted 1 justice can be sought by the aggrie(ed just think , i5 a judge himsel5 that too o5 apex court o5 the land itsel5 commits crime - (iolations o5 +;' 3ct , constitutional rights 1 human rights o5 public and

obstructs the public 5rom per5orming their constitutional 5undamental duties , what happens 9 it gi(es a booster dose to the rich 1 mighty , those in power , criminals in public ser(ice to committ more crimes that is exactly what is happenning in india the educated public must raise to the occassion 1 peace5ully , democratically must oppose this criminalisation o5 judiciary , public ser(ice then alone , we can build a +34 +3,?3 >@ 43*3;43 03A/*'BS /+)34

*ereby , we request the honourable court to reopen all hushed up old cases o5 sexual assault in(ol(ing judges and to punish the guilty judges

*ea+ Is CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA above LAW ??? https://sites.goog e.!o"/site/sosevoi!e#o$%&sti!e/!hie#'%&sti!e'above' a( )

Law student sexually harassed by ex-Supreme Court judge: case is not unique, but speaking out is nearly impossible

http://www legallyindia com/!"#$####%"&&/'nter(iews/sexual-harassment-supreme-court-iscommon ,

I, I,+ia ) !o$$&ptio, ) #avo&$itis" is p$eva e,t i, a $e!$i&t"e,t / se e!tio, p$o!esses. The se e!tio, is "a+e o, b$ibe ) !aste ) $e igio, b&t +e#i,ite - NOT o, the basis o# .e$it / I,teg$it-. The se e!tio, to the posts o# eve, S&p$e"e !o&$t J&+ges ) 0&asi %&+i!ia o##i!e$s i1e +ist$i!t "agist$ates ) ta &1 "agist$ates ) po i!e ) et! is ,ot above boa$+. Fo$ e2a"p e (e have $e!e,t see, the i ega ities i, 34SC i,te$vie(s se e!ti,g ga5ette+ o##i!e$s to gove$,"e,t o# 1a$,ata1a se$vi!e. These tai,te+ ) i,e igib e &,#it (aste bo+- !a,+i+ates (ho get se e!te+ as %&+ges ) po i!e th$o&gh +evio&s "ea,s se thei$ %&+i!ia o$+e$s ) e2e!&tive o$+e$s ) po i!e o$+e$s #o$ a p$i!e. The +e,ot#i!atio,s o# gove$,"e,t a,+s ) et! as i, the !ase o# .-so$e DC 6ast$a+ ) as i, the !ase o# Neg e!t o# Hebba La1e /) 7E.L 8&a$te$s La1e E,!$oa!h"e,t b- DC .a,iva,,a, ) as i, the !ase o# La,+ i$$eg& a$ities b- 7a,ga o$e DC Ai--appa ) !ha,gi,g the pe,a ! a&se o# pe,a !ha$ges to #avo&$ the !$i"i,a as i, the !ase o# &,io, !a$bi+e9s (a$$e, A,+e$so, #$o" "ass "&$+e$ to i"p$ope$ "a,age"e,t o# the #a!i it- ) as i, the !ase o# Sa,%a- +&tt #$o" TADA !ha$ges to i ega possessio, o# a$"s ) et!. The po i!e #o$ a p$i!e #i2 i,,o!e,ts ) #i e 7

$epo$ts #avo&$i,g the !$i"i,a s to ! ose the !ase ) p$e#e$ ,ot to #i e a, appea i, the highe$ !o&$t ) et!. As i, the !ase o# 7o#o$s ) as i, the !ase o# past S4 o# !ha"a$a%a,aga$ 4&ttas(a"ta1i,g b$ibe #$o" a g$a,ite 0&a$$- o(,e$ #o$ #i i,g 7'$epo$t i, a !ase. Disg$a!e#& - ) $e!e,t - a %&+ge tai,te+ i, .:SO*E *OOST *ESO*T SE; SCANDAL (as p$o"ote+ as a s&p$e"e !o&$t %&+ge. What J&sti!e !o""o, #o 1 !a, e2pe!t #$o" these !o$$&pt bo+ies ? The- t&$, i ega ities i,to ega iss&es b- thei$ o$+e$s. These CO**U4T J&+ges ) 4o i!e ) Dist$i!t .agist$ates ) Ta &1 .agist$ates a$e +oi,g "o$e +a"age to I,+ia9s U,it- / I,teg$it- tha, the Na2a ites / Te$$o$ists. These !o$$&pt p&b i! se$va,ts "&st be p&t behi,+ ba$s togethe$ (ith te$$o$ists / ,a2a ites. Let the se,se p$evai / De"o!$a!- p$ospe$. The Ho,est #e( i, J&+i!ia$- ) 4o i!e / E2e!&tive "&st $aise &pto the o!!asio, to SA6E DE.OC*AC: / to 1i!1 o&t thei$ !o$$&pt !o eag&es #$o" o##i!e.

:o&$9s Si,!e$e - ) Naga$a%a...*.

Supreme Court Ceroes in on Dharass6 judgeE support 5or disclosure grows C,' lauded 5or probe order + F3L3,'

Aew /elhi, Ao( #G: +he /upreme 'ourt appears to have identified the former udge who is accused of se3ually assaulting at least two law interns while in office, sometime about two years ago& On the 'hief 2ustice of "ndia(s directions, the court registry has chec*ed the intern:assignment records relating to udges who retired in the past two years, sources told ;he ;elegraph& +hey said that while convention demanded that an intern wor* with a particular udge for only a month, the accused udge seemed to have insisted that the women interns wor* with him for si3 months& According to the sources, the feeling among the higher udiciary is that the udge should be named, if only to end the speculation about the other udges who retired recently& /o far, the accused udge has not been named&

Legal e3perts have complimented the 'hief 2ustice for setting up a three: udge panel to probe the allegations after one intern came out with se3ual assault charges on 0ovember ;& /ince then, a second intern has made similar accusations against the same udge& /uch a panel has no precedent in the /upreme 'ourt(s history, nor has any sitting or former ape3 court udge ever faced charges of se3ual harassment at the wor*place before& Legal e3perts said the 'onstitution had no provision for the ape3 court setting up such a committee but added that the top court could certainly do so under the e3traordinary powers granted to it by Article <=>& What the committee will do is ?uestion the first intern @she has been re?uested to appear before it on $onday, 0ovember <AB and then confront the accused udge& "f the panel prima facie finds truth in the allegations, it can direct the police to register an C"5& A P+" report said police have initiated a preliminary probe into the case& "f the udge is convicted of assaulting or using criminal force with intent to outrage a woman(s modesty @molesting herB, he can be ailed for two years& A rape conviction can put him behind bars for life or at least <D years& +he 2udges Protection Act <EAF grants udges and former udges immunity from prosecution for actions committed in the discharge of their official duties& +he immunity does not apply to cases of molestation or rape as such offences cannot conceivably be a fallout of a udge performing his ob, legal e3perts said& !@.venB if the offence was committed while he was a sitting udge, he is amenable to all the laws of the country that apply to all ordinary citi%ens,# said 2aspal /ingh, a former Pun ab and -aryana -igh 'ourt udge who now practises as a lawyer in the /upreme 'ourt& !+he allegations are very seriousG the law will ta*e its own course,# he added& As*ed if the udges( panel had udicial sanctity, /ingh said4 !@/uchB charges against a udge of the /upreme 'ourt are a very serious matter& +hey involve the institution and therefore they @the courtB want to verify the charges before ta*ing any action&# /enior counsel 8ushyant 8ave said the '2" had done !an e3tremely good thing# by forming the panel to probe a !brother udge#& !+hat this is an in:house committee owes not to any legal re?uirement but more to propriety,# he said& -e added that the police must not act unless and until the panel as*ed them to register an C"5, for neither has the accused been identified yet, nor has any of the interns lodged a formal complaint&

!"f any third party has lodged a complaint without proper material, it ma*es no sense,# 8ave said& -e added4 !"t(s a very serious chargeG the udge concerned has to face the music&#

Aothing but the truth Fy 'ndira ,aising A midst the rising din of the demand for death penalty for rapists comes the news that three udges of the Karnata*a -igh 'ourt have been involved in what has come to be described as a Hse3 scandalH on the outs*irts of $ysore at a place called 5oost 5esorts& Our attention is now directed to those who dispense ustice rather than those who *noc* at the doors of ustice& "n both cases, we are tal*ing about the use and abuse of women I those who are victims of se3ual abuse, and those who are used as se3ual ob ects, willingly or unwillingly& After the reports in local newspapers that three high court udges were found with women at a resort, there was the usual crop of denials& Although the $ysore police were called in to settle a brawl, on being told that the persons in ?uestion were udges they said that they heard no evil and saw no evil& And everyone thought the matter ended there& Attempts to get the names of the udges or of the women in ?uestion drew a blan*& +he bar association also drew a blan* as most people said, J8onHt ?uote meK butKJ On 0ovember LD, the Bangalore edition of +he +imes of "ndia published a front:page story giving the names and photographs of the three udges and confirming that the "ntelligence Bureau had done an investigation and come to the conclusion that the incident had indeed occurred& +here were still no details of the incident, though it was stated that the report has been given to the chief ustice of "ndia& +here were reports on the same day that the Karnata*a -igh 'ourt chief ustice had sought the transfer of the three udges to Patna, 2ammu and Kashmir and 1uwahati& Apparently, the chief ustice has agreed to this re?uest and the transfer orders have been issued& +hen came the news that the chief ustice of "ndia has set up a committee of in?uiry under the Hin: houseH procedure consisting of the chief ustice of the Andhra Pradesh -igh 'ourt, the chief ustice of the $adras -igh 'ourt and the chief ustice of the Patna -igh 'ourt& +here were still no details in the press about the actual incident and the entire episode continued to be referred to as a Hse3 scandalH& What is interesting about these reports is not what they reveal, but what they conceal& "t is a conspiracy of silence& "f the information is now available to the chief ustice of "ndia, why is it not being made public9 8o we, the public, not have the right to information9 "ronically, the morning newspapers brought the news that the Creedom of "nformation Act has been passed& What are the legitimate limits of the right to freedom of information and the re?uirement of *eeping information a secret9 +his episode would ma*e an interesting case study& What e3actly is at sta*e here9 +here is much that should concern the nation about the incident& +his is not a case about the private morality of the udges, be that as it may, but about the abuse of office that they hold& What has not been made *nown is that the three women in ?uestion are women

lawyers practising in their courts& What is at sta*e here is the pollution of the stream of ustice at its very source& +here must be countless cases in which these women appeared before these very udges day in and day out of their routine practice& 'an one honestly say that in such a situation ustice is being done Jwithout fear or favourJ9 2udges swear on oath of allegiance to Jbear true faithJ to the 'onstitution and do ustice Jwithout fear or favourJ& -ow well have these udges honoured this oath9 What is at sta*e here is the cynical use of women as se3ual commodities& +he usual ustifications have already begun ma*ing the rounds& "f the women have not complained, what ob ection can anyone else have, it is as*ed& What is lost sight of is the fact that the udges are in a position of dominance vis:M:vis the women, in a position to do favours that pertain to their office& What is at sta*e here is the cynical use of public office, the seat of ustice, for personal petty gain& "t is irrelevant whether the women consented or not& +he usual blame game will now begin I blaming the victim rather than the perpetratorG the usual loose tal* about the character of the woman in ?uestionG the usual attempt to cover up by diverting attention from the actual incident to the motives of those who brought the incident to light& What is at sta*e here is the perception of women as se3ual commodities by those who are responsible for sitting in udgment over cases brought for and on behalf of women& +he issues at sta*e here concern one half of "ndians& With what faith can "ndian women approach the courts demanding the right to e?uality, the right to be free from se3ual harassment or rape and the right to live with dignity, if the persecution of udges who sit in udgment over them is non: negotiable9 "n the circumstances, the suggested solution is worse than the offence I to transfer them to Patna, 1uwahati and 2ammu and Kashmir& Why these particular cities9 Are they not an integral part of the country, or are they mere islands within the country that are considered Hpunishment postingsH where people are sent a la Hcrossing Kala PaniH of the old days9 +o the credit of the 1uwahati Bar Association, it protested against the proposed transfer& +he only decent thing to do is for the chief ustice of "ndia to disclose full details of the incident so that rumour:mongering comes to an end& +his would be in the best interest of the udiciary itself& As things stand, the rumours are ma*ing the rounds that there were more than three udges involved, that the women were professional call girls, many of which are baseless& We, the people, have the right to *now& +he conspiracy of silence must be bro*en& +he udges in ?uestion must neither be assigned any udicial functions pending an in?uiry nor be transferred to sit in udgment over others& +wo of the udges are stated to be additional udges& +hey must not be confirmed& "f there is prima facie evidence against the one remaining udge, the chief ustice must recommend his impeachment& "t is time for all concerned bar associations, bar councils and other male:dominated bodies of legal professionals to act and ensure that there is no cover:up& +here is little point in showing sympathy to women in udgments and in seminar rooms, or in recommending the death penalty for rape if we cannot deal with the men who dispense ustice& +here are contempt of court petitions pending in the Karnata*a -igh 'ourt against some of the publications for disclosing details of the incident& 'ivil society and womenHs organisations must demand that ustice is now done when it comes to the udges themselves& +he law of contempt can offer no solution to the crisis of credibility in the udiciary that this incident has thrown up& One positive aspect of the incident is that it is only after the chief ustice of the high court issued a public notice inviting information that he received >D representations, which

led to the discovery of the truth& Let the truth now be made public&

,udge accused o5 molesting ! rape sur(i(ors in .-

3 sitting judicial magistrate sexually assaulted them

6P4 +wo rape victims claim that a sitting udicial magistrate se3ually assaulted them& +he girls alleged that when they went to the magistrate(s chamber to give their statement, he allegedly made them strip and molested them& One of the girls is a minor and the police have filed a complaint& +he girls also claimed that the udge threatened them to not spea* of the incident to anyone& Lawyers and the general public in 1onda launched a protest against the udge&

3nother law intern alleges sexual harassment by a 5ormer SC judge

Aew /elhi: Another law intern has leveled allegations of se3ual harassment against a former /upreme 'ourt udge& A /upreme 'ourt committee is already probing allegations made by another student and had as*ed her to appear before it& .arlier, a woman lawyer had written a blog in which she charged a former /upreme 'ourt udge of se3ually harassing her, while she interned with him in >D<>& +he woman lawyer who completed her law degree from 0ational 6niversity of 2urdicial /ciences, Kol*ata wrote is her blog, J"n 8elhi at that time, interning during the winter vacations of my final year in the 6niversity, " dodged police barricades and fatigue to go to the assistance of a highly reputed, recently retired /upreme 'ourt udge whom " was wor*ing under during my penultimate semester& Cor my supposed diligence, "

was rewarded with se3ual assault @not physically in urious, but nevertheless violatingB from a man old enough to be my grandfather&J /he had also claimed that at least three other girls have also faced harassment by the same udge& +he girl said that she had refrained from disclosing the details initially due to the high position that the udge held& +he 'hief 2ustice of "ndia said, JAs the head of the institution, " am also concerned about the allegations and an3ious whether the statement is true or not& +he committee will go into the whole affair and find out the facts& We are ta*ing steps and in cases of se3ual harassment, we cannot ta*e it lightly&J

Another law student who interned with the /upreme 'ourt has accused a now:retired udge of se3ually harassing her, barely a wee* after similar charges were levelled by another intern& +he latest allegations were made on a Caceboo* post on 0ovember << and reported by a law website, Legally "ndia, on +hursday& +he same website had given the lin* to the first intern(s blog, describing her ordeal& +he /upreme 'ourt has appointed a three: udge panel to in?uiry into her allegations and the victim has been as*ed to record her statement on 0ovember <A& But unli*e the first instance, the website this time has not given the lin* to the Caceboo* post or identified the woman& When contacted Kian 1an%, who reported both the incidents, told -+4 !" got to *now about the second intern(s e3perience with the udge through the Caceboo* post& -owever, " wasn(t able to confirm if she wanted to go public&# +he second victim, too, was an intern with the same udge, the website said& -+, however, could not confirm the claims or the allegations independently& +he two women can(t be identified for legal reasons& +he e3cerpts uploaded on Legally "ndia on +hursday ?uote the second intern as saying she was !at the receiving end of unsolicited se3ual advance more than once#& Both the interns *new each other, the report claimed& !K& we *ept attributing all the signs of leeriness to our hypersensitivity&&& We discussed innocuously said off:colour remar*s and dismissed their creepiness because we really respected him Nthe udgeO, and the possibility seemed at odds with everything we *new about him, his ideas about feminism, patriarchy, social ustice&&&,# the website ?uoted from the second intern(s post& +he first intern had alleged that the udge had misbehaved with other women interns as well& +he second intern said as much& !"n this case, we spo*e to other women&&& and found out that there was a history to such behaviour&#

!We also alerted some female senior faculty to the incident so that they would ensure that no female student was assigned wor* with him without being told to be on her guard&# +he website further ?uotes her as saying !he promised, incidentally, that he would never misbehave with another lady& $aybe it(s naivetP to believe him& $aybe it(s ust youthful optimism& Being brave is tougher than it appears on the face of it, no9# +he post then goes on say that the udge !lost his 5A(s Nresearch assistantsO and got a dressing down from a >L:year:old which should have come from his father& !Why deprive girls from the chance to wor* with an illustrious mind because the mind is a little sic*9 A guy who gets the tas* would get a savvy ') and a better ob opp @opportunityB& We didn(t want girls to be left at a disadvantage,# the post, as uploaded on Legally "ndia, read&

Law student sexually harassed by ex-Supreme Court judge: case is not unique, but speaking out is nearly impossible

A law graduate who recently blogged about how a retired /upreme 'ourt udge se3ually assaulted her while she was his intern, says that the problem is real and not uncommon amongst the udiciary and senior bar but that she sees few if any ways of tac*ling it& /tella 2ames, who graduated from 062/ Kol*ata this year and now wor*s at the 01O 0atural 2ustice, Lawyers for 'ommunities and the .nvironment, wrote about an alleged incident of physical, se3ual assault by an unnamed, retired /upreme 'ourt udge in late >D<>& "n a post that was published on the blog of the 062/ 2ournal of "ndian Law and /ociety on ; 0ovember, she wrote about trying to come to terms with her e3perience of >= 8ecember >D<>, 'hristmas .ve, ironically against the bac*drop of the then:ongoing 8elhi gang rape protests4 !"n 8elhi at that time, interning during the winter vacations of my final year in 6niversity, " dodged police barricades and fatigue to go to the assistance of a highly reputed, recently retired /upreme

'ourt udge whom " was wor*ing under during my penultimate semester& Cor my supposed diligence, " was rewarded with se3ual assault @not physically in urious, but nevertheless violatingB from a man old enough to be my grandfather& " won(t go into the gory details, but suffice it to say that long after "(d left the room, the memory remained, in fact, still remains, with me&# !Cran*ly " was really shoc*ed,# 2ames tells Legally India in an interview today& !+here(s this thing4 a person who is a /upreme 'ourt udge : you don(t e3pect a /upreme 'ourt udge to harass somebody&# -owever, she says that her e3perience was neither uncommon, nor merely restricted to the udiciary4 !"(ve heard of three other cases Nof se3ual harassmentO by the same udge and " *now of at least four other girls who(ve faced harassment from other udges : not perhaps as Nbad as mineO4 most of them were in the chambers of the udge and other people around, so it never gets too bad& !A girl " *now faced continuous se3ual harassment throughout and se3ual advances, and actually faced troubles through her wor* because of it&# And she says she(s heard of /upreme 'ourt senior counsel who have made passes at or have continuously harassed interns for longer periods& And though it is barely, if at all, *nown outside legal circles, it is a bit of an open secret or a !big o*e# within the profession, particularly among cler*s and women wor*ing in the /upreme 'ourt, according to 2ames& !People in the /upreme 'ourt *ind of *now,# she says& !" did my internship through the college Nrecruitment processO&# After beginning to share her e3perience with others in college, however, 2ames found that others had also faced similar problems with the same udge& 2ames( reasons for not going public with the name of the udge or not lodging a formal complaint are comple3, both morally and practically& On the one hand, she wrote in the blog post4

!" bore, and still bear, no real ill:will towards the man, and had no desire to put his life(s wor* and reputation in ?uestion& On the other hand, " felt " had a responsibility to ensure that other young girls were not put in a similar situation& But " have been unable to find a solution that allows that& 8espite the heated public debates, despite a vast army of feminist vigilantes, despite new criminal laws and se3ual harassment laws, " have not found closure& +he lac* of such an alternative led to my facing a crippling sense of intellectual and moral helplessness&# !"(d wor*ed for him for si3 months and he treated me really well for si3 months and has been really *ind to me,# 2ames e3plains& !"t was rather strange to me but " haven(t really forgiven him for itK NButO " don(t *now if " want to let myself : my impression of him as a person : be entirely dictated by that actK $y leeway to him isn(t because he(s had a shining career and all that : part of it is that Q NbutO "(m not really sure " want to ruin somebody(s entire life because of that&# !Once it gets out in the open that he(s harassed other girls,# 2ames says, !people will only loo* at him in that light&# -owever, 2ames admits that one other strong reason, which was not really touched upon in her blog post, was concern about whether legal action would even have any effect& 2ames had managed to reach two of the other young women who were harassed by the same udge but neither were willing to come forward in public, mostly out of fear& !+hey don(t really want to eopordise their careers,# 2ames relates& !-e(s a /upreme 'ourt udge& "f it(s going to be his word against our word, he(s got more credibility, so to spea*, of his words&# And she adds that if she by herself had wanted to ta*e legal action, it would probably not have been possible& !+here were no other witnesses, it was ust me& "t was a hotel room, NpeopleO saw me wal*ing in voluntarily, saw me wal*ing out very calmly& " didn(t even wal* out NwithO fear& At that moment " felt " needed to wal* out very calmly& " never mentioned anything the same day to anybody&#

Apart from the evidentiary difficulty in proving the crime, the more serious problem for lawyers is perhaps inherent in the profession itself& 2ames said she had never heard of any official harassment complaints within the legal profession or against any udges& And while Legally India understands that se3ual harassment complaints are at times made in law firms, most are handled very delicately and ?uietly, with the firm encouraging informal resolution& "n courts, it is even worse, speculates 2ames, in that there is usually no one you can realistically complain to, unli*e in a company or college structure where harassed by a boss or lecturer, for e3ample, and where she would have ta*en formal action in a similar incident& !Of course you can file a criminal complaint Nagainst a udge or lawyerO but that(s a whole different level&# And it is also li*ely to impact your career& !" *now a friend of mine who was se3ually harassed at the Karnata*a high court,# says 2ames& +hat friend !wasn(t *eeping it a secret# and telling lawyer friends about why she left the ob with that senior, and for two months afterwards she wasn(t able to find a ob at the same court, being as*ed about the incident in interviews after it dripped through the court(s grapevine @she eventually found a ob after deciding to evade the issue at interviewsB& +he mindset in such cases often is, !she created trouble for him, she(ll create trouble for us#, speculates 2ames& /he says she was also s*eptical about the /upreme 'ourt(s recently started se3ual harassment cell and guidelines improving matters considerably& !"t is often one person(s word against another person(s word, and a lot of people tend not to ta*e the word# of a young lawyer against a senior advocate who(s made his reputation for <D to <F years& !+here is a balance of power thing going on here&# +he only thing that 2ames has been able to do, other than write the blog, is discuss the incident with members of her alma mater, possibly de:listing the udge from the recruitment process so

that others are not e3posed to similar e3periences& While 2ames does feel that colleges have a responsibility to protect their students, she ac*nowledges that it could be difficult& +he udge in ?uestion has been closely associated with her former college for a while by giving lectures and regularly ta*ing on research assistants, so whether faculty can ta*e une?uivocal action is not certain& 0evertheless, 2ames says that potentially recruitment committees of colleges could ma*e a difference& !" thin* at least Q there should be some way, if not publicly then at least privately, *ids who go intern with a udge should *now that this has happened before&# 2ames says that she was able to come forward, albeit without disclosing names, because of her choice to wor* with an 01O with a possible view to entering academia at some point in her career& !" was a little afraid,# she admits& !+he other friends "(ve spo*en about, they are in positions where these udges play an important role Nat the /upreme 'ourt or teaching in a college and theyO are afraid of eopardising their careers& " don(t have such concerns here at 0atural 2ustice : " have a team that(s incredibly supportive, and three colleagues were first to read the blog post Nbefore publicationO& !Cor me, the great thing is that "(m in an organisation where " *now that if " come out in public about it, we are >F people, and "(m pretty sure "(ll have the entire team behind me&# +hat lawyers elsewhere are unli*ely or unable to protect their own from se3ual harassment, is a problem the profession will have to deal with sooner rather than later&

.pdate #! Ao(ember4 +he 'hief 2ustice of "ndia has decided to institute a three:member udicial committee to probe the allegation&

,./0) S)A/'A0 >FSC)A) S4S ;> H>4)A

Lucknow ;aking cognisance o5 the allegation against a ci(il ,udge 8junior di(ision: o5 Fudaun court that he sent obscene S4Ses to a woman lecturer, the +egistrar 0eneral o5 3llahabad *igh Court today sought a report 5rom the district judge into the matter ;he ci(il judge o5 0unnor sub-di(ision court o5 Fudaun I -ramod Jumar 0angwarI was accused o5 sending obscene S4Ses 5rom his cellphone to a woman lecturer o5 Classic College o5 Law, Fareilly 3 lecturer o5 the same college, Ki(ek 0upta, was named in the @'+ lodged by the (ictim while 0angwar6s name sur5aced in the primary in(estigation +egistrar 0eneral /inesh 0upta said, <;he district judge o5 Fudaun has been asked to send a detailed report into the allegations 3ppropriate action would be taken on the basis o5 the report = /istrict ,udge Suresh Jumar Sri(asta(a said, <' ha(e asked the Fareilly district police to send a report about the matter ;he report on the basis o5 the police inquiry would be sent to the 3llahabad *igh Court +egistrar 0eneral = <' am not aware about the matter, as the Fareilly police did not intimate me be5ore initiating the probe against the ci(il judge ;hey should ha(e in5ormed me when they had recei(ed any such complaint,= the judge added 4eanwhile, Fareilly C> '' +aj Jumar, who is in(estigating the case, today recorded the statement o5 the (ictim <' ha(e collected the call details o5 the cellphone used 5or sending the S4Ses, but ' ha(e yet to get the address o5 the person who is subscriber o5 the S'4 card,= he said <;he probe is on to (eri5y i5 the accused in the case were present on the location recorded

in the call details when the S4Ses were sent ;he details o5 the 5indings o5 the in(estigation would be sent to the Fudaun district court to seek the direction,= the C> added 3sked i5 the in(estigation was earlier conducted into the matter, +aj Jumar said, <;he S8Crime: had initiated probe into the matter, but ' am not aware i5 the in(estigation had reached to any conclusion = ;he woman lecturer had lodged an @'+ at the 4ahila police station on ;hursday alleging she had recei(ed obscene S4Ses on her cellphone in(ol(ing her colleague Ki(ek 0upta ;he preliminary inquiry into the case by the police yesterday had 5ound that the mobile phone used in the crime belongs to the ci(il judge

'F con5irms 4ysore +oost +esort sex scandal

+he "ntelligence Bureau has provided the 'entre with a detailed account of the escapade involving three Karnata*a -igh 'ourt udges on 0ovember L in a resort on the outs*irts of $ysore, highly placed sources told +he +imes of "ndia on Criday& According to a senior official, !$ost of the information sought has not only confirmed the veracity of the incident but the government has crosschec*ed it with another police agency& Both the reports match&# +he incident was widely reported in the media& What has surprised the 'entre is the !dogged refusal# of the Karnata*a police to confirm the incident& !$ysore Police 'ommissioner '& 'handrase*har first denied that the incident ever too* place& Only when a public notice was

issued through the high court registrar see*ing information on the $ysore scandal, did the facts come out in the open& Public protest helped a lot,# says the source& What transpired at the resort, says the source, !cannot be e3pected from anyone in civil society, leave alone persons sworn to upholding the law#& According to him, !+he "B report consists of unmentionable facts and also ma*es it amply clear that the $ysore incident is not the first time such things have happened& 'an anyone e3pect upholders of the law to pic* a fight with people who complained to the police when caught in a compromising position9# "n a related development, Karnata*a -igh 'ourt 'hief 2ustice 0&K& 2ain has written to 'hief 2ustice of "ndia 2ustice 1&B& Pattanai* as*ing that three udges be transferred& 2ain has proposed that 2ustice 0&/& )eerabhadraiah be transferred to the Patna -igh 'ourt, 2ustice 'handrase*haraiah to 2ammu & Kashmir and 2ustice )& 1opala 1owda to the 1auhati -igh 'ourt& While 2ain is understood not to have given any reasons, highly placed sources say the proposal for transfers is lin*ed to the $ysore incident& -owever, the source says that now the government is worried about the appropriate !remedial measures#& "n such cases, transferring a udge to a remote high court doesn(t always wor*& -e says, !Bar associations and the people of northeastern states were up in arms when some udges of the Pun ab and -aryana high courts were transferred there& We e3pect similar protests if the '2" accepts 2ustice 2ain(s proposal to transfer the three udges of the Karnata*a -igh 'ourt&# +he Bar 'ouncil of "ndia on Criday, while e3pressing its anguish at the Karnata*a incident, called for !follow:up action#& !6nless prompt and appropriate action is ta*en, it will erode the faith of public in the only institution considered to be the bastion of our fighting faith in democracy,# it said in a statement&

+he B'" has !lamented# inaction in this case by !the higher udiciary and the government#&

5ead more4 "B confirms $ysore se3 scandal Q +he +imes of "ndia http4,,timesofindia&indiatimes&com,city,bangalore,"B:confirms:$ysore: se3scandal,articleshow,>EAD<;;>&cmsRi3%%<BSPtvCd6

Lokayukta: /C demanded sex 5rom widow

In the midst of a national outrage over former Haryana DGP SPS Rathore molesting a teenager, the Karnataka Lokayukta on Saturday made a startling revelation that the state government was shielding a top ureau!rat who had demanded se"ual favours from a young widow# Lo*ayu*ta 2ustice /antosh -egde disclosed that the official concerned, who was the deputy commissioner of one of the districts when he demanded se3 from the widow in return for discharging his duties as public servant, has since been promoted to a senior position& 2ustice -egde, in the course of an interaction with ournalists at the 8eccan -erald office /aturday afternoon, said the unnamed widow had dared the deputy commissioner and approached the Lo*ayu*ta(s office with a complaint against the officer& On e3amination of the complaint, the Lo*ayu*ta had found sufficient grounds to recommend to the state government the suspension and prosecution of the 8' concerned& +he recommendation was subse?uently considered by the concerned department head as well as the chief secretary and both endorsed it& But, according to 2ustice -egde, no action was initiated against the 8' as the same official who had endorsed the recommendation subse?uently found no basis for initiating departmental action

against him& "nstead, the official cleared the 8'(s name for promotion in the super:scale& Presently, the official holds a senior position in the government& +he widow, in her late >Ds, had approached the 8' with a representation to sort out some problems& But she was shoc*ed when the 8' demanded se3& 2ustice -egde did not identify the official in ?uestion or the complainant& 0or did he offer to name the district where the official was serving as deputy commissioner& But the incident has happened sometime in the course of last three years as 2ustice -egde too* over as the Lo*ayu*ta in mid:>DD;&

$-year jail term 5or Ddirty6 judge

$amily !ourt %udge Ramrao Gangaram &hise attempted to get se"ual favours from a housewife in '(() Camily court udge 5amrao 1angaram Bhise(s attempts to e3tract se3ual favours, in addition to a bribe, from a housewife, Al*a 1ai*wad I who had sought an increase in her monthly maintenance allowance from her estranged husband, in <EES I proved costly to him& Pronouncing him guilty on both counts, the special court hearing anti:corruption bureau @A'BB matters sentenced him to three years rigorous imprisonment and a collective fine of 5sFF, DDD, on $onday& According to the C"5 in the case registered against Bhise by the A'B, /urya*ant 1ai*wad had filed for divorce from his wife, Al*a, before the Bandra family court& Al*a, a housewife, in turn, filed a petition see*ing mutual cohabitation with her husband& +he then family court udge, $eera Khada**ar, directed the husband to pay her an interim maintenance allowance of 5sSFD per month&

/ubse?uently, in 2anuary <EES, Al*a filed another application before the same family court @now presided over by BhiseB see*ing to increase the monthly maintenance amount to 5sL,FDD& !On October >S, <EES, Bhise issued an interim order, increasing the maintenance allowance to 5s>,DDD to be paid by /urya*an to his estranged wife till the disposal of the case& "mmediately after issuing the order, Bhise as*ed Al*a to meet him and gave her his residential telephone number, as*ing her to call him when the court hours ended& -e told her that he would as* her husband to pay her a lump sum of 5s> la*h in addition to the monthly maintenance, provided she called him up,# the C"5 states& When she called up the udge at S pm the same day, Bhise told her that she would have to pay him a sum of 5s>,DDD in addition to granting his se3ual favours if she wanted an order in her favour& -e also directed her to meet him at the -a i Ali bus stop with the bribe amount the following evening& !Al*a approached the A'B, which sought permission from the 'hief 2ustice of the Bombay -igh 'ourt before laying a trap on the first class udicial magistrate @BhiseB& +he -' while granting the permission designated a court official to bear witness to the events leading to the trap& Al*a, under video camera surveillance of A'B sleuths, along with the court official and other women witnesses met Bhise at A&LD pm at the -a i Ali bus stop& Bhise too* hold of Al*a(s wrist and when she protested, repeated his demands,# the C"5 states& Al*a was then ta*en to a nearby hotel, /harda, where the udge accepted the bribe amount& But before he could do anything else, A'B sleuths swooped in and arrested him&

+ajasthan judge is indicted 5or seeking sexual 5a(ours

'hief 2ustice of "ndia 1 B Pattanai* retires tonight and he doesn(t have much to write home about on the unprecedented drive he launched to enforce udicial accountability& After the PP/' scam fiasco, reported in +he "ndian .3press today, comes the case of the 5a asthan udge who has been indicted in a se3 scandal and yet has escaped actionIpending another in?uiry& On 8ecember <=, a three: udge committee set up by Pattanai* confirmed the TTinvolvement(( of 2ustice Arun $adan of the 5a asthan -igh 'ourt in a proposition to a woman doctor to have se3 with him in e3change for a udicial favour& +he committee, headed by the 'hief 2ustice of the Pun ab and -aryana -igh 'ourt 2ustice B K 5oy, submitted its report to Pattanai*, indicting $adan on a complaint made from 2odhpur by the woman concerned, /unita $alviya& But Pattanai* has not announced any action against $adan& When contacted by +he "ndian .3press, Pattanai* confirmed that the committee had indicted $adan and his TTbad reputation(( in see*ing se3ual favours in return for udicial ones& -owever, Pattanai* said that no action was being ta*en since the committee had also mentioned allegations of corruption against $adan& And so he had ordered a further in?uiry by the same committee into the corruption charges& When as*ed what he did with the indictment of $adan in the se3 scandal, Pattanai* said, TT+hat is on hold because " could not have ta*en piecemeal action against himK&" am praying to 1od that the final report will give some tangible material to ta*e action&(( -ighly placed sources told +he "ndian .3press that when the committee recorded statements last wee* in 2odhpur of about LD persons over four days, it also came to *now of several allegations of corruption against $adan and another udge of the same high court& +he committee put these on record as well&

Pattanai* said that when he summoned $adan to 0ew 8elhi last wee*, he did not raise the se3 scandal issue and instead limited himself to saying that he was ordering a further in?uiry into corruption allegations& "n effect, Pattanai* has now passed the 5a asthan buc* to his successor 2ustice ) 0 Khare& +he gist of $alviya(s complaint is that $adan made a se3ual proposition to her in October through a deputy registrar of the high court, 1ovind Kalwani, who said that the udge would help her, in turn, get out of a criminal case boo*ed against her& With this, Pattanai*(s much:touted in:house udicial accountability seems to have hit a wall& +he first committee(s report into the PP/' scam e3onerated one udge despite evidence and let two others off with a mere slap on the wrist& +he third committee is now busy probing the involvement of udges in the $ysore se3 scam&

;en reasons why criminals in khaki get away /iddharth )aradara an

Behind every man li*e /&P&/& 5athore who abuses his authority stand the generals and footsoldiers who help and support him& We need to ta*e them all down& /&P&/& 5athore, the criminal former top cop of -aryana, may appear alone today but we must never forget that he was able to get away with the se3ual molestation of a young child and the illegal harassment of her family for <E years because he had hundreds of men who supported him in his effort to evade ustice& +he fact that these men Q fellow police officers, bureaucrats, politicians, lawyers, udges, school administrators Q were willing to bend the system to accommodate a man accused of molesting a

minor spea*s volumes for the moral impoverishment of our establishment and country& 8ecent societies shun those involved in se3ual offences against children& .ven criminals ailed for UordinaryH crimes li*e murder treat those serving time for molesting children as beyond the pale& But in "ndia, men li*e 5athore have their uses for their masters, so the system circles its wagons and protects them& +he 'B"Hs appeal may lead to the enhancement of 5athoreHs sentence and perhaps even the slapping of abetment to suicide charges, since his young victim *illed herself to put an end to the criminal intimidation her family was being sub ected to by 5athore and his men& But the systemic rot which the case has e3posed will not be remedied unless sustained public pressure is put on Prime $inister $anmohan /ingh and 6nion -ome $inister P& 'hidambaram, two men who have it in their power to push for simple remedies in the way the "ndian law enforcement and ustice delivery system wor*s& Cirst, abolish the need for official, i&e& political sanction to prosecute bureaucrats, policemen and security forces personnel when they are accused of committing crimes& +he original intent behind this built:in stay:out:of: ail card was to protect state functionaries from acts done in the course of discharging their duties in good faith& /omewhere along the line, this has come to mean protecting our custodians of law and order when they murder innocent civilians @eg& the infamous Panchalthan case in Kashmir where the trial of army men indicted by the 'B" for murdering five villagers in >DDD still cannot ta*e place because the 'entral government will not grant permissionB, or assault or molest women and children& 0o civilised, democratic society grants such impunity& "t is disgusting to see former officials and bureaucrats from -aryana saying how they had wanted 5athore prosecuted but were prevented from doing so because of pressure& /uch officials should either be made formally to testify in a criminal case against the politicians who so pressured them or they should themselves be hauled up for perverting the course of

ustice& /econd, stop tal*ing about how ma*ing the police and army answerable to the law will somehow demoralise their morale& 8oes anybody care about the morale of ordinary citi%ens any more9 Or the morale of upright police and army officers, who do not thin* it is right for their colleagues to be able to get away with criminal acts9 +hird, bring an end to the cosy relationship between the police and politicians& 5athore was protected by four chief ministers of -aryana& -e served them and they served him by ensuring his unfettered rise& "t is absurd that the "ndian Police is still governed by a colonial:era Act dating bac* to <A;<& A number of commissions have made recommendations for reforming the police over the yearsG but no government or political party wants to give up its ability to use and misuse the police for their own benefit Courth, ensure that police officers who abuse their authority and engage in mala fide prosecutions are dismissed from service and sentenced to ail for a long period of time& $r& 'hidambaram should use the considerable resources at his command to find out who were the policemen involved in filing << bogus cases against the teenaged brother of the young girl 5athore molested& -e should then ma*e sure criminal proceedings are initiated against all of them& +he message must go out to every policeman in the country4 "f you abuse the law at the behest of a superior, you will suffer legal conse?uences& Cifth, ensure that criminal charges against law enforcement personnel are fast:trac*ed as a matter of routine so that a powerful defendant is not able to use his position to delay proceedings the way 5athore did for years on end& +he destruction or disappearance of material evidence in such cases must be treated as a grave offence with strict criminal liability imposed on the individual responsible for brea*ing the chain of custody& /i3th, empower the 0ational -uman 5ights 'ommission with teeth so that police departments

and state governments cannot brush aside their orders as happened in the 5athore case& +his would also re?uire appointing to the 0-5' women and men who have a proven record of defending human rights in their professional life, something that is done today only in the breach& +he attitude of the $anmohan /ingh government to this commission and others li*e the 0ational 'ommission for Women @0'WB and 0ational 'ommission for $inorities is shoc*ing& )acancies are not filled for months on end& /eventh, ensure the early enactment of pending legislation broadening the ambit of se3ual crimes, including se3ual crimes against children& Between rape, defined as forced penetrative se3, and the vague, )ictorian:era crime of Uoutraging the modesty of a womanH, the "ndian Penal 'ode recognises no other form of se3ual violence& As a result, all forms of se3ual molestation and assault short of rape attract fairly lenient punishment, of the *ind 5athore got& "n his case, the udge did not even hand down the ma3imum sentence, citing concerns for the criminalHs age& /adly, he did not ta*e into account the age of the victim and neither does the "P', which fails to distinguish between Uoutraging the modestyH of an adult woman and a young child& A draft law changing these provisions and bringing "ndia into line with the rest of the modern world has been pending with the 0'W and Law $inistry for years& Perhaps the government may now be shamed into pushing it through Parliament at the earliest& .ighth, ta*e steps to introduce a system of protection of witnesses and complainants& +he fate that the family of 5athoreHs young victim had to endure is testament to the fact that people who see* ustice in "ndia do so at their own peril& 0inth, ensure that robust interrogation techni?ues li*e narco:analysis, which are routinely used against other alleged criminals, are also employed against police officers accused of crimes& +enth, the media and the higher udiciary must also turn the light inward and as* themselves whether they were also derelict in their duty& +he 5athore case did not attract the *ind of constant

media attention it deserved, nor do other cases involving serving police officers accused of crimes against women, wor*ers, peasants and minorities& As for the upper courts, their record is too patchy to inspire confidence& "t was, after all, the high court which chose to disregard the 'B"Hs re?uest for including abetment to suicide charges& Keywords4 /iddharth )aradara an, /&P&/& 5athore, criminals, *ha*i, former 81P of -aryana, custodians, se3ual violence, 0-5'

-orbandar judge accused o5 dowry harassment

A complaint has been filed against 8istrict and /essions udge of Porbandar for allegedly harassing his daughter:in:law for dowry, police said here on /unday& 8arshana 8ave, a native of Amreli, has filed a complaint against her husband Kinnar, father:inlaw and district udge Arvind 8ave, mother:in:law Pratibha and brother:in:law Prashant, the police added& 8arshana married Kinnar two years ago& -er complaint says that she was harassed from the beginning, and was even beaten up by the husband and in:laws, who were demanding 5s <D la*h as dowry& /he has also alleged that she was thrown out of the house a few months bac*, and her husband is now see*ing divorce, the police said& Amreli /uperintendent of Police - 5 $uliyana confirmed to have received the complaint against the udge and others& -e said that action will be ta*en after verifying the complaint& +his is the second complaint related to dowry harassment filed against a udge in the state in the recent past&

.arlier, a woman had filed a complaint against additional sessions udge of 2etpur after her daughter and the udgeHs wife committed suicide&

0urgaon judge to also 5ace dowry harassment charge

1urgaonHs 'hief 2udicial $agistrate 5avneet 1arg, boo*ed for the murder of his wife, will also face dowry harassment charge, police here said $onday& Police have issued notices to the '2$Hs father K&K& 1arg and mother 5achna 1arg, who have also been named in the dowry harassment case& +he '2$Hs father reached here $onday morning from -aryanaHs Panch*ula town and contacted police, who wanted to ?uestion him& JWe had called '2$Hs parents&&&K&K& 1arg was ?uestioned by special investigation team @/"+B,J 1urgaon Police 'ommissioner Alo* $ittal said& $ittal said on the basis of written complaint filed by the parents of the '2$Hs wife 1eetan ali, penal sections of dowry harassment and e3tra:marital affair were included in the C"5 lodged against the '2$ /aturday& 1eetan ali, >=, bore three bullet wounds : on her chin, chest and stomach : but no bullets were found in her body that was recovered here +hursday& +he '2$Hs licensed firearm was found near the body, police said& $ittal said two bullets were sei%ed from the scene of crime and would be sent for ballistic e3amination $onday, a day after ballistic e3perts e3amined the crime spot& J+he /"+ /unday ?uestioned two women relatives of 5avneet 1arg for hours at his government allotted house here in the Officers 'olony,J said $ittal&

JWe have as*ed '2$ to produce supporting evidences to prove his statement,J he said& +he '2$ allegedly said that his driver and domestic help may throw some light on his wifeHs death& 2udge 1argHs in:laws alleged that two cars were provided to the accused on his and his familyHs demand& 5s&> la*h were also delivered to him at the time of the admission of his daughters in school in $ay& 1eetan aliHs brother Pradeep Aggarwal /aturday lodged a first information report against 1arg and his parents, accusing them of murder& J5avneet and 1eetan ali got married in 0ovember >DDS& .verything was fine for a few years but the attitude of 5avneet and his parents towards 1eetan ali started changing after she delivered two baby girls @now aged around four and a half and three yearsB,J Aggarwal said in his complaint& -e demanded a probe by the 'entral Bureau of "nvestigation @'B"B into his sisterHs murder&

SP nabbed by Karnataka Lokayukta

Dai%i(o$ + .e+ia Net(o$1 < 3o a$ =S4> Jolar, Ao( !L !""& : Jolar district superintendent o5 police, J - -uttaswamy, was to proceed 5or a %"day special training scheduled to be held in *yderabad, on Saturday Ao(ember !L *e was caught by the Lokayukta police, while accepting a bribe o5 +s #",""" 5rom a subordinate worker a day be5ore Fased on a complaint 5iled by a constable 5rom the town police station here, a Lokayukta team led by superintendent o5 police 8S-:, 4adhukar Shetty and others caught the S- red-handed ;he team which raided the house o5 the S- reco(ered +s # MG lac in cash 3s per the in5ormation pro(ided by the Lokayukta team, - - -rakash, who is an ex-ser(iceman, working as a constable in the town police station here, had become ill and gone on lea(e 35ter rejoining the duties, he 5ailed to pro(ide details and certi5icates 35ter the departmental inquiry was conducted against him 5or this lapse, the constable apologiCed *owe(er, instead o5 showing lenience, the department conducted another inquiry against him 3t that time, -rakash is said to ha(e approached the superintendent o5 police, who reportedly demanded a bribe o5 +s !G,""" to show lenience in the case )(en a5ter he paid it, -rakash was handed the punishment o5 compulsory retirement 5rom ser(ice Hhen -rakash approached the S- in this connection, the latter reportedly demanded an additional +s #",""" 5rom him 5or 5a(ouring him @rustrated, -rakash directly went to the o55ice o5 the Lokayukta in Fangalore and complained about this harassment 3t around #! $" pm on @riday, the constable entered the o55ice o5 the S- with +s #",""" in his hand and placed a packet o5 +s #"" notes on the S-6s table 3t the time the S- touched cash, a burqa-clad lady constable o5 the Lokayukta suddenly entered the room, resisting attempts by the guard to stop her 3s she signalled other Lokayukta o55icials, they rushed into the room and caught the S- o55 guard ;he Lokayukta succeeded in maintaining so much secrecy, that long a5ter the S- was caught, many in the

o55ice were unaware o5 the incident )(en the additional superintendent o5 police, -hanindra Singh, was in5ormed about the incident later 't is said that the S- initially did not cooperate, but later, apologiCed 5or his action Simultaneously, the Lokayukta personnel raided the S-6s house %M year-old -uttaswamy, who was promoted 5rom the JScadre to the '-S grade in #&&N, had taken o(er as the superintendent o5 police o5 the district in the year !""L *e happens to be the second '-S o55icer in the state to ha(e been nabbed by the Lokayukta

S- 3++)S;)/ >A 0+3@; C*3+0) F? Jarnataka lokayukta

$arch <= >DDA

Srikantappa F3A03L>+): ;he Lokayukta police on ;hursday arrested a Superintendent o5 -olice 5or allegedly accepting bribe 5rom a businessman in Chamarajanagar 3dditional /irector-0eneral o5 -olice 8Lokayukta: + J /atta told presspersons here that Lokayukta o55icers arrested Chamarajanagar /istrict Superintendent o5 -olice Srikantappa 5or allegedly accepting +s G",""" 5rom S 4 @arooq 5or closing a case registered against him and allowing him to continue with sand mining Srikantappa6s associate, Subbanna, who allegedly acted as the middleman, has also been arrested 4r /atta said there were se(eral complaints o5 harassment and demands 5or bribe against Srikantappa >ne such complaint was 5iled by 4r @arooq <3s the complaint was against a senior o55icer, we took e(ery precaution,= 4r /atta said 3 team, led by /eputy 'nspector 0eneral o5 -olice 8Lokayukta: J S + Charan +eddy, was sent 5rom Fangalore to Chamarajanagar on Hednesday ;he Lokayukta police went to Srikantappa6s house and sur(eyed the exit points >n ;hursday, 4r @arooq sent the money through his manager 3kbar, who went to Srikantappa6s house with Subbanna, who allegedly struck the deal between the businessman and Srikantappa Subbanna took the money to the Superintendent o5 -olice while 3kbar waited in another room Hhen Subbanna and 3kbar came out o5 the house, the Lokayukta police team entered the house and 5risked Srikantappa <*e had hidden the cash between his shirt and (est *e has been booked 5or demanding and accepting bribe,= Lokayukta A Santosh *egde said ;he cash has been seiCed 4r @arooq got embroiled in the a55air as he was being harassed 5or bribes by a 5orester at a check-post to allow transportation o5 sand 4r @arooq then 5iled a complaint with the Chamarajanagar 8)ast: police ;he 5orester also 5iled a complaint against 4r @arooq accusing him o5 obstructing him while carrying out his o55icial duty ;he in(estigating o55icer did not 5ind any substance in the 5orester6s complaint and wanted to close the case *owe(er, Srikantappa sent a message to the in(estigating o55icer, through a sub-inspector, asking him not to close the case until 5urther orders 5rom him, the Lokayuta said

Srikantappa approached the businessman through Subbanna seeking +s !G,""" to get the case closed and an additional +s !G,""" to let 4r @arooq continue with his business Subsequently, the businessman 5iled a complaint with the Lokayukta, 4r *egde said

More Corrupt the Police are, More unsafe are our People - By K B GANAPATHY It is sickenin ! It is nauseatin ! It is "ul ar! It is #irty! It is a sin an# a$o"e all, it is a cri%e $eyon# any a%elioratin circu%stances! The punish%ent for this cri%e shoul# $e a real #eterrent an# %ust not take %ore than a %onth to a&ar#! I a% talkin a$out the cri%e co%%itte# $y the Kolar 'P, K! P! Puttas&a%y, IP', &ho &as cau ht re# - han#e# &hile takin a $ri$e of (s!)*, *** fro% a ci"il Police Consta$le P!P! Prakash $y the Ban alore +okayukta Police on No"e%$er ,-! .hen the cri%e &as co%%itte# in Kolar, ho& is it that the Ban alore +okayukta took action/ This is not a %illion #ollar 0uestion! This is a %illion #ollar sha%e on the honesty an# inte rity of our Police force itself 1honoura$le e2ceptions are honoura$ly e2e%pte# here3! I un#erstan# the reason is that the +okayukta Police officers in Kolar are too co%passionate an# consi#erate in na$$in cri%inals an# corrupt persons in their o&n turf 1#epart%ent3! 4arlier, three atte%pts &ere %a#e to catch this cornucopia of a corrupt person calle# Puttas&a%y, $ut he &as alerte# in ti%e! Thus the local +okayukta faile# in its %ission!

Kolar 'P Puttas&a%y Consta$le Prakash, the "icti% of Puttas&a%y5s ree#, a"arice an# cra"in for %oney kne& this "ery &ell! It &as for this reason, he ha# to approach the Ban alore +okayukta 1Phone6 789:****,,3! Naturally this ti%e, the +okayukta operation &as a co%plete success!

Co%plainant Mr! P! P! Prakash Think of the #epth of #e%an# fro% Puttas&a%y an# you &ill kno& ho& fatho%less it is! I a% re%in#e# of a Ta%il fil% Anniyan! The Consta$le Prakash ha# alrea#y i"en (s!,:, *** as $ri$e

1&hich in fact is also an offence3! But the ree#y 'P, Puttas&a%y, in or#er to %ake a killin out of this Consta$le seekin per%ission for "oluntary retire%ent fro% ser"ice un#er ;(', reco%%en#e# his #is%issal! This %a#e the Consta$le ner"ous as he &oul# lose his pension an# other $enefits! P! P! Prakash, the Consta$le, no& a e# 9-, hailin fro% 'outh Ko#a u, near Ponna%pet 1Pullan a#a fa%ily3 ser"e# in the In#ian Ar%y 'i nals for se"en years an# then <oine# the Police =epart%ent in Kolar an# has ser"e# for ,* years! >f late, he &as not keepin oo# health an# hence took ?%e#ical per%ission@ for )A %onths lea"e B sick lea"e! It appears he &as suppose# to su$%it a =octor5s certificate fro% ti%e to ti%e #urin this perio#! He #i# not #o so as it is not co%pulsory, an# rarely insiste# upon, he says! Ho&e"er, in this case the Kolar 'P K! P! Puttas&a%y or#ere# a =epart%ental 4n0uiry 1=43 a ainst hi%! (ealisin that this en0uiry &oul# take at least : to C %onths to co%plete an# as he &as in a hurry to take ;(' he #eci#e# to apolo ise for the ina#"ertent lapse! 'u$se0uent to the apolo y su$%itte# $y hi% to the =4 >fficer, the =y! 'P, the =4 &as close# an# the report sent to the 'uperinten#ent of Police, K!P! Puttas&a%y! 'ee ho& ree# for %oney tears a&ay the hu%an face of a hu%an $ein ! The 'uperinten#ent of Police, Puttas&a%y, returnin the file to the 4n0uiry >fficer, the =y! 'P, aske# hi% to re -e2a%ine the =epart%ental 4n0uiry! Consta$le Prakash says that nor%ally if one a#%its his fault, in cases such as this, no re e2a%ination of =4 is necessary! Ho&e"er, Consta$le Prakash thou ht there &as no use pursuin the path of la& to et his ;(' fro% an >fficer like K! P! Puttas&a%y an# #eci#e# to talk to hi%! An# he #i#! It &as here he a ree# to pay the #e%an#e# a%ount of (s! ,:,*** to this corrupt 'P for t&o fa"ours6 1)3 To &ith#ra& the =epart%ental 4n0uiry after a &arnin an# par#on! 1,3 To rant per%ission for the ;('! After %akin this pay%ent of (s! ,:,***, the Consta$le Prakash &as happily &aitin at his nati"e place for ;(' per%ission! Ho&e"er, after t&o %onths, to his utter shock he recei"e# a notice a$out his DCo%pulsory (etire%ent5 &hich tanta%ounte# to #is%issal fro% ser"ice! He rushe# to Kolar an# %et the 'uperinten#ent of Police, K!P! Puttas&a%y, on ,9th No"e%$er &hen he &as tol#6 ?>kay, I &ill see! 1Aayitu No#u"a3@ >n further plea#in s fro% the Consta$le, Puttas&a%y &rote on a piece of paper <ust, ?)*,***@ an# spoke &ith his hea# an# eyes pushin the paper to&ar#s the Consta$le to see the fi ure! 'ince the Consta$le foun# the ne& #e%an# too %uch for hi% to $ear, he #eci#e# to retaliate! He kne& there &as no use co%plainin to the Kolar +okayukta &hich coul# not trap this corrupt 'P three ti%es earlier on othersE co%plaints! 'o Consta$le P! P! Prakash strai ht a&ay &ent to Ban alore an# %et (oop Ku%ar =atta, the A=GP, a &on#erful person &ho is kno&n to atten# to co%plaints pro%ptly in confi#ence &ithout any #elay! He kne&, spee# is the secret of success not only in lo"e an# &ar $ut also in +okayukta operations! He i%%e#iately calle# another s%art officer, 'uperinten#ent of Police 1'P3 Ma#hukar 'hetty an# lo an# $ehol# the operation &as successful! Prakash, the Consta$le, says that the Kolar 'P ha# his %oles in his office keepin an eye on the +okayukta co%plainants an# officers &ho %ay $e aroun#! In case of suspicion, infor%ation &as passe# on to hi% an# the 'P &ill not see such "isitors!

Hence, this ti%e the Ban alore +okayukta ot s%art! .aitin at the 'PEs #oor to see hi% &as a $ur0acla# la#y Consta$le an# a Police 'u$ - Inspector #is uise# as a Musli% &ith full %akeup, &earin a $ear# hire# fro% a clothier to #ra%as! >ne %ore person &as also there &ith $an#a es, #hoti an# chappals &ho &oul# see the 'P only after his F=o##a"aruF 1el#er3 ca%e there! Thus there &as a$solutely no roo% for suspicion for the Police%en on #uty at the 'P5s #oor! 'ince Prakash &as alrea#y kno&n, he &as allo&e# in! =urin the course of con"ersation, the 'uperinten#ent of Police K! P! Puttas&a%y, alert an# s%art, tol# his supplicant Prakash ?Naale Banni@ GCo%e to%orro&H three ti%es! Then Prakash a"e the co"er &ith the %oney insi#e, as pre - arran e# $y the +okayukta! Puttas&a%y instincti"ely stretche# his han# to recei"e it $ut 0uickly &ith#re&, lifte# a file, place# it on the ta$le an# aske# Prakash to keep the co"er $elo& the file! The latter o$li e#! Ho&e"er, &hile han#lin the file Puttas&a%y unkno&in ly touche# the co"er to push it properly un#er the file! ?I &ill call the G'A an# et the file an# ask hi% to #o the nee#ful@, sai# the 'P &ho #i# not for et to speak alou# ?Be#a@ 1=on5t &ant3 all the &hile takin care not to touch the co"er or %oney! But to his $a# luck he ha# alrea#y touche# the co"er, thou h unkno&in ly, rather acci#entally! .ell, &hen Prakash ca%e out, the +okayukta &alke# in! (est is ?$reakin an# hea#lines in ne&spapers! ne&s@ in T; channels

An# in#ee# the co%plainant P! P! Prakash #i# teach his corrupt $oss a lesson &hich the people of our 'tate think &ill $e a lesson for the likes of K! P! Puttas&a%y, IP', in office! But no! 4arlier, another 'uperinten#ent of Police, B! 'rikantappa of Cha%ara<ana ar too &as trappe# $y the +okayukta &hile recei"in a $ri$e of (s! :*,*** fro% a san# transporter a ainst &ho% a char e sheet &as file#!The san# transporter &ante# 'rikantappa to help hi% $y filin a ?B@ report to the Court 1?B@ report is one &here Police in"esti ate the case an# then file a report to the court sayin there is no su$stance in the co%plaint or there is no pri%a facie case as such3! The case &ill then $e close#! Interestin ly, the sa%e K! P! Puttas&a%y &as the A##itional 'P in Cha%ara<ana ar at that ti%e, &hen his $oss B! 'rikantappa &as cau ht in the snare set $y the +okayukta! Yet, K! P! Puttas&a%y, no& 'P at Kolar, #i# not learn any lesson fro% the past e2perience of his $oss! Therefore, no %atter ho& %any Police officers the +okayukta catches, it &oul# $e $usiness as usual for these o"ern%ent officers inclu#in those of the IA', II' an# IP' class! It is sai# ha$its #ie har#! These t&o officers are fro% the Karnataka A#%inistrati"e 'er"ice 1KA'3 &ho rose to the rank of IP' after years of ser"ice in the lo&er rank! It is uni"ersally kno&n corruption at the lo&er le"el in the Police force happens on a #aily $asis an# therefore e"en after the ele"ation to the IP', the ha$it %ust ha"e continue#, so%eti%es consciously an# so%eti%es unconsciously, as if it is a natural part of the <o$! Ha$its in#ee# ne"er #ie! At another le"el, it is not as if those &ho enter ser"ice #irectly fro% IP' are not corrupt! If only a honest an# a ressi"e in"esti ation is %a#e into the &ealth a%asse# an# properties ac0uire# $y these officers 1inclu#in the $ena%i an le3, one &ill fin# a can of sinister &or%s cra&lin all o"er the place! .hile a Police Consta$le %ay collect on a #aily $asis a fe& hun#re# rupees an# on occasions a fe& thousan#s, these IP' officers 1e2ceptions apart3 %ake a killin in one #eal an# like the Python &hich after s&allo&in an ani%al lies lan ui#ly for %onths, these officers strut aroun# &ith an aura of honesty, till the ne2t "icti% co%es $y! Be that as it %ay, the point to pon#er is &hether the o"ern%ent5s recruit%ent policy, specially in #epart%ents like Police, 42cise an# (e"enue, nee#s to $e chan e# to ensure the kin#s of B! 'rikantappa an# K! P! Puttas&a%y are not recruite# at all or pro%ote#! In case they are recruite# they %ust $e #is%isse# fro% ser"ice if cau ht re#-han#e# an# foun# uilty, rather

than %erely suspen#in

the%, only to $e reinstate# later or let the% off &ith %inor punish%ent!

Just as in cases of rape or %ur#er, the la& relatin to $ail in cases of corruption too nee#s to $e chan e#! The present la& relatin to $ail for these offences see% to $e "ery li$eral an# la2! .hen a person is sent to Ju#icial Custo#y, he is in <ail only for a fe& hours! 'oon he is shifte# to a hospital un#er le al ri %arole an# %anipulation! .ell, &hy not call it Ehospital custo#yE instea# of ?Ju#icial custo#y@/ Politicians, hi her officials an# the rich shoul# $e #iscoura e# $y the la& courts fro% ettin this Fhospital custo#yF! Consi#er this6 a politician is arreste# for so%e %is#e%eanour or offence! He is foun# in the pink of health at the ti%e of his arrest! But su##enly &hen he is pro#uce# $efore the court, he fei ns illness of se"ere nature like chest - pain, hi h $loo# pressure or e"en un$eara$le $ack ache! Ne2t, &e see hi% $ein taken to a super - specialty hospital &ar# in the na%e of <u#icial custo#y instea# of $ein treate# in the prison! The sa%e has happene# in the case of K! P! Puttas&a%y too! In#ian 42press #ate# )st =ece%$er, ,**7 reporte#6 F.hile in Kolar <ail, he 1K! P! Puttas&a%y3 reporte#ly co%plaine# of chest pain an# &as taken to hospital! Puttas&a%y &as later shifte# to Jalappa Hospital at %i#ni ht an# a#%itte# in the ;IP &ar#!F A %ockery of la& an# <ustice! A sho& of soli#arity $y the <ail authorities an# the #octorsK Consi#erin the all - per"asi"e corruption in the Police =epart%ent, I ha"e a lin erin suspicion that %ost of the %issin cases, %ur#er cases, ro$$ery cases, rape cases etc! are not #etecte# at all, si%ply for the reason of corruption! Iilin false co%plaints or threatenin to file false co%plaint is another ploy e%ploye# $y the Police! As a <ournalist, a nu%$er of people ha"e co%e to %e to et the co%plaint re istere# or if re istere# to et the case in"esti ate#! A couple of years $ack, the $o#y of a s%all ti%e planter in Ko#a u &as foun# han in on a tree in the pre%ises of the (ace Clu$ an# #espite the co%plaint, nothin happene#! The persons na%e# as suspects $y the "icti%5s %other 1a &i#o&3 an# relati"es &ere not e"en taken into custo#y for interro ation! The "icti%5s relati"es tol# %e that the culprits ha# "isite# the <uris#ictional Police 'tation in the city a couple of ti%es! You can %ake your o&n inference! The senior officers in the Police =epart%ent %ust re"ie& perio#ically all the un#etecte# cases an# put pressure on the 'tation House >fficers to sol"e the cases an# for this purpose perio#ically ui#e the%! Ho&e"er, if the top officers the%sel"es are of the Cha%ara<ana ar 'P B! 'rikantappa5s kin# or the Kolar 'P K! P! Puttas&a%yEs kin#, Go# only shoul# help the co%plainant! I a% not a&are if there is a psycholo ical test for the can#i#ates &ho appear for pu$lic ser"ice e2a%inations B like the IP', IA', KA' B to fin# out the propensity of a person for %akin %oney $y %eans fair or foul! I %ay soun# harsh an# it %ay e"en $e ille al, $ut ho& a$out $rain %appin un#er narcoanalysis test to fin# out the ?%in#@ of the can#i#ate/ This #ay %ay not $e far - off, if corruption continues una$ate# at this le"el! In#ira Gan#hi &as in#ee# ri ht &hen she ackno&le# e# corruption as a ?Lni"ersal Pheno%enon@, al%ost <ustifyin it! No &on#er she &as also in a &ay responsi$le for the present run of corrupt officers in all our o"ern%ent #epart%ents an# Constitutional institutions! .e ha# al&ays thou ht at least our Ar%y an# Ju#iciary are &ell insulate# fro% corruption! Ne&spapers rarely carrie# any ite% relatin to corruption in the Ar%y an# Ju#iciary! But to#ay &e ha"e Ar%y sca%s an# Ju#icial corruption al%ost #aily $ein &ritten in ne&spapers an# sho&n on T;! +ack of trust in the lea#ership in all areas of o"ernance is &orryin e"ery citiMen to#ay! The situation in#ee# is ri%! If a citiMen cannot trust a Police >fficer, Ar%y General, Chief Justice of the hi her court, &here shall he o for his security an# <ustice/ Are &e as a country lost in the li%$o of a #e%ocratic anarchy/

Tailpiece: +okayukta 'P arrests Kolar 'P on corruption char es! A &a catch a thief/K@

asks6 Is it a case of ?set a thief to

S > S e - Koice @or ,ustice - e-news weekly Spreading the light o5 humanity 1 5reedom E+ito$: Naga$a%a...*.. 6o .?@..Iss&e.AB........AC/?@/D?CA

Editorial : PIL Appeal To Honorable Supreme court of India For Writ of Mandamus - No AIL for !riminal ud"es # !riminal Police $

We salute our freedom fi"%ters & militar' personnel # mart'rs for all t%e sacrifices made b' t%em( Let us build a stron" & Secular & )emocratic India b' "ettin" rid off fe* corrupt elements & anti nationals & traitors amon" public ser+ants & amon" ,udiciar' # amon" police *%o are "reater t%reat to India-s unit' # inte"rit' t%an Pa.istani terrorists or c%inese militar'(

Information input forms part of process of one-s e/pression( 0ne-s e/pression in an' forms 1 *ritten & oral & etc becomes information input to t%e opposite person & in turn %e e/presses %is repl'( Information # E/pression are inseparable parts # form lifeline of a democrac'( T%at is t%e reason & 2i"%t to E/pression is t%e basic fundamental ri"%t as *ell as %uman ri"%t of e+er' Indian citi3en( W%en a person-s ri"%t to e/pression is +iolated & %is ot%er ri"%ts to e4ualit' & ,ustice & etc also are +iolated( Suppression of Information amounts to curbin" of E/pression(

In a democrac' & people %a+e a ri"%t to .no* %o* t%e public ser+ants are functionin"( Ho*e+er till date public ser+ants are %idin" be%ind t%e +eil of 0fficials Secrets Act 5*%ic% is of britis% +inta"e created b' britis% to suppress nati+e indians6( 7' t%is co+er-up public ser+ants are %idin" t%eir o*n corruption & crimes & mismana"ement & failures & etc( e+en 2TI Act is not bein" follo*ed intoto b' public ser+ants( Ho*e+er t%e recent del%i %i"% court rulin" affirmin" t%at ! I is under 2TI pur+ie* # bound to ans*er 2TI re4uest & is note*ort%'(

0ur pre+ious 2TI re4uest to ! I & union %ome secretar' of 80I& President of India & )8 # I8P of 809 and ot%ers *ere not %onored( T%e information I sou"%t *ere ans*ers to t%e follo*in" 4uestions mentioned in t%e belo* mentioned *ebsites ( t%e 4uestions concerned t%e past & present continuin" in,ustices meted out to millions of Indian citi3ens & due to *ron" : ille"al *or. practices of Indian ,ud"es & police # public ser+ants ( T%e information *e sou"%t *ould e/pose t%e traitors & anti-nationals & criminals in public ser+ice( T%e information *e are see.in" are no defense secrets & no national secrets( T%e trut%ful information e/poses t%e anti-nationals & traitors in t%e public ser+ice # stren"t%ens our national securit' & national unit' # inte"rit'(

Hereb' & i do re4uest t%e %onourable supreme court of india & for a Supreme !ourt monitored !7I En4uir' into t%is *%ole issue as .arnata.a police are %elpless & t%e' don;t %a+e le"al po*ers to prosecute %i"% # mi"%t' & constitutional functionaries( T%e' %a+e not e+en en4uired t%e "uilt' <<IPs e+en once %o*e+er =nder pressure from %i"%er-ups t%e' repeatedl' called me t%e complainant to police station too. statements from me all for closin" t%e files(

Hereb' & I do re4uest t%e %onorable supreme court of India to consider t%is as a PIL for : >*rit of Mandamus? and to issue instructions to t%e concerned public ser+ants in t%e follo*in" cases to perform t%eir duties # to ans*er t%e 4uestions( AI HIN)( <AN)E MATA2AM(

@our-s sincerel' & Na"ara,(M(2(

ud"e accused of molestin" A rape sur+i+ors in =P

A sittin" ,udicial ma"istrate se/uall' assaulted t%em UP: Two rape victims claim that a sitting judicial magistrate sexually assaulted them. The girls alleged that when they went to the magistrate’s chamber to give their statement, he allegedly made them strip and molested them. One o the girls is a minor and the police have iled a complaint. The girls also claimed that the judge threatened them to not spea! o the incident to anyone. "awyers and the general public in #onda launched a protest against the judge.

S=P2EME !0=2T 0F IN)IA Acti+ists !ITIBENS # THEI2 2I8HTS

2esponsible for Murders of 2TI Supreme !ourt-s failure to

P20TE!T

9arnata.a: Anot%er 2TI acti+ist found murderedC *%istleblo*ers demand !7I probe

7an"alore 1 Less t%an t*o mont%s since t%e murder of an 2TI acti+ist from 7an"alore& t%e state Saturda' *itnessed a brutal murder of anot%er *%istleblo*er( T%is time <asude+a Adi"a %ailin" from coastal district of =dupi follo*ed t%e fate of Lin"ara,u& *%o *as alle"edl' murdered b' t%e local corporator for e/posin" corruption last No+ember( T%e bod' of a missin" 2TI acti+ist <asude+a Adi"a %as been found in brutall' murdered state on Saturda'( Adi"a& *%o %ails from <andaru +illa"e in =dupi district& %ad "one missin" since Monda'& D anuar'( T%e bod' %as been found at 9adur of nei"%borin" !%ic.ma"alur district& about AAE .ms from =dupi& *it% multiple in,uries and its face smas%ed be'ond reco"nition( At t%e same time ot%er *%istle-blo*ers from =dupi district %a+e alle"ed t%e in+ol+ement of local influential politicians& businessmen and top le+el "o+ernment ser+ants be%ind t%e murder( T%e' %a+e also demanded !7I en4uir' into t%e murder( Adi"a %ad dra*n t%e *rat% of some local politicians and %i"%-ran. officers of t%e district for bein" +er' instrumental in e/posin" t%e corruption at +arious le+els& said S%reeram )i*an& a ,ournalist cum 2TI acti+ist( 2ecentl' %e %ad obtained some +ital documents re"ardin" alle"ed irre"ularities in muc%-dela'ed <ara%i irri"ation pro,ect& affairs of Mandarti temple and Nirmiti 9endra t%rou"% 2TI& %e said(

W%ile <ara%i irri"ation pro,ect %as been dela'ed since t%ree decades& Mandarti temple comes under Mu3urai department of 8o+ernment of 9arnata.a( T%e Nirmiti 9endra %eaded b' t%e )eput' !ommissioner of t%e district ser+es as a seminal a"enc' to "enerate and propa"ate inno+ati+e ideas on %ousin" and participates in tender of an' "o+ernment or pri+ate or"ani3ation and e/ecutes t%e same in line *it% t%e ob,ecti+es( It can underta.e t%e "o+ernment construction pro,ects t%at cost less t%an F crore rupees( >Adi"a %as been abducted and murdered after %e determined to complain Lo.a'u.ta o+er misappropriation of public funds t%at run in multiple crores(? e/plained )i*an( Accordin" to )i*an& Adi"a %ad pla'ed crucial role in e/posin" %u"e irre"ularities b' t%e stone 4uarries at 8olian"adi recentl'( Follo*in" t%e complaints& t%e minin" department %ad fined t%ose companies upto 2s(G crore( >He e+en 4uestioned t%e district aut%orities o+er "rantin" permission to t%ose blac.listed stone-4uarries& *%ic% %ad not e+en paid t%e fine amount imposed b' t%e department& to operate at ot%er places(? %e added( Sources said t%at Adi"a *as approac%ed b' t%ose officials& couple of da's bac. to %is abduction& for a compromise for *%ic% %e did not bud"e( He *as also t%reatened of dire conse4uences& t%e sources said( Adi"a *ent missin" on t%e ni"%t of D anuar' *%ile %e *as returnin" to %is %ome in A-*%eeler alon"-*it% some important documents obtained t%rou"% 2TI( Famil' members found %is deserted mobile& foot*ear& pen and t*o*%eeler on follo*in" da' about FA.ms a*a' from %is +illa"e& but not t%ose documents %e *as carr'in"(

Attac.s

Murders

of 2TI Acti+ists in India

%ttp:::en(*i.ipedia(or":*i.i:Attac.sHonH2TIHacti+istsHinHIndia

Name

State Lin.

Appro/imate date

Harassed : Assaulted : 9illed

San,ib Tanti Assam I:FF:JD Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:assam-rti-applicant-alle"esassault:FAKFLE:J Firo3 Ibra%im 9%an Ma%aras%ta FF:FD:JD Assaulted %ttp:::***(e/pressindia(com:latest-ne*s:estate-a"ent-assaulted-for-filin"-rtifour-arrested:AGEGLM:

8opalband%u !%%atria 0rrisa A:F:JM Assaulted %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 2ipu )aman 0%ri Pun,ab I:F:JM Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:applicant-complains-of-recei+in"t%reat:IDMIGM:J 2in.u Sin"% 2a%i =ttar Prades% L:AI:JM Assaulted %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-JGAM:luc.no*:LFGDEIEKHFHmu.es%-c%o*d%ar'-%un"er-stri.e-ips )r( San,ib Nandi Pun,ab D:I:JM Assaulted %ttp:::***(tele"rap%india(com:FJMJDJK:,sp:sports:stor'HFFAJKIIF(,sp Muni.ris%na 9arnata.a FJ:AD:JM Assaulted %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:ban"alore:reportHrti-acti+ist-attac.ed-o+er-le"aldisputeHFLJGGIK A,a' 9umar )el%i F:F:FJ Assaulted %ttp:::***(csmonitor(com:World:Asia-Sout%-!entral:AJFJ:JLFJ:In-Indiadeadl'-bac.las%-a"ainst-freedom-of-information-acti+ists Na'ana 9at%palia Ma%aras%tra F:K:FJ Assaulted %ttp:::***(frontline(in:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJAIJJ(%tm 9iran Pande' Pun,ab F:FJ:FJ Assaulted %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp Sumaira Abdulali Ma%aras%tra L:FI:FJ %ttp:::***(frontline(in:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJAEJJ(%tm Assaulted

Ab%a' Patil Ma%aras%tra G:F:FJ Assaulted %ttp:::***(frontlineonnet(com:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJJGJJ(%tm As%o. 9umar S%inde Ma%aras%tra D:FD:FJ Assaulted %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-see.s-details-attca.ed:FAIMJG-L(%tml$ fromN r%s 7ud%ai 9umar =ttar Prades% K:M:FJ Assaulted %ttp:::***("o+ernanceno*(com:"o+-ne/t:rti:rti-applicant-attac.ed S !%annabasappa Patil 9arnata.a M:FI:FJ %ttp:::***(deccan%erald(com:content:FJJEJA: Assaulted

@as%*ant 8a+and Ma%aras%tra F:A:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':mumbai:2TI-acti+ist-assaulted-in7%andup:articles%o*:DAJKLGJ(cms

Arun 7aburao Mane Ma%aras%tra F:A:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(%indu(com:AJFF:JF:JE:stories:AJFFJFJEIGLKFDJJ(%tm Salman 2edd' 0rissa F:FD:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':b%ubanes*ar:8oons-beat-up-2TIapplicant-in-2a'a"ada:articles%o*:DLAGFDL(cms Safdar Ali ammu and 9as%mir F:AJ:FF Assaulted %ttp:::lite(epaper(timesofindia(com:"etpa"e(asp/$ articlesN'es#pa"eidNI#ma/Ntrue#articleidNArJJIJF#sectidNLedidN#edlabel N!AP#m'dateHidNAD-JF-AJFF#pubnameNTimesOofOIndiaO-O)el%iOOTimesO!it'#titleNLandOmafiaOtar"etsO2TIOman#ednameN#publabelNT0I <i.rant 9arni. Ma%aras%tra F:AE:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':mumbai:2TI-acti+ist-attac.edsuspicion-on-builder:articles%o*:DLILDAG(cms Amar Pande' =ttar Prades% F:AD:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(sif'(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-attac.ed-ne*s-national-lbF/Gf,abcf(%tml 8opal Prasad& Anil Mittal& Nanda Sa*ant )el%i A:L:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:L-2TI-acti+ists-rou"%edup:ArticleF-IEKAMG(asp/ Man"ala 2am 2a,ast%an L:L:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:states:ot%er-states:articleFEAJMEE(ece$ %omepa"eNtrue 7%arat 8u""ul& 7%an,i o"en 8u,arat L:E:FF Assaulted %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JLJE:surat:AKIEKMAJHFH+illa"ers-rti-application-%ousin"-scam <is%nu Med%.ar Ma%aras%tra G:A:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':mumbai:Man-t%ras%ed-o+er-2TI-4uer'in-Turb%e:articles%o*:DKIMKMG(cms )ilip ais*al Ma%aras%tra G:E:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':na"pur:No-action-a"ainst-2T0-staffers*%o-beat-up-2TI-acti+ist:articles%o*:DKMJFFG(cms Ar+ind 9aus%al Ma%aras%tra G:K:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:rti-applicant-on-.%aradi-constructionattac.ed:DDGFJE:J Popat 7ar"e Ma%aras%tra G:FD:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(punemirror(in:article:A:AJFFJGFMAJFFJGFMJFJAGLAGGGGDDEIKF:Ha 3arePEAPKJPMMs-anti"raft-crusader-seriousl'-%urt-in-Satara-attac.(%tml

ai 7%a"*an # 9arambir Har'ana E:AF:FF Assaulted %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:rti-applicants-s%ot-at-insonepat:FELFEG-L(%tml Ismail Pat*ari Ma%aras%tra E:AD:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:2TI-acti+ist-attac.ed:ArticleF-DJGLJJ(asp/ !(P( Sin"% Ma%aras%tra I:AA:FF Assaulted %ttp:::man"alorean(com:ne*s(p%p$ne*st'peNlocal#ne*sidNAGIDAA 7a"%u )e*ani 8u,arat I:AG:FF Assaulted %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-attac.ed-in-porbander:FIALEL-L(%tml 8anas%am 9un.ol.ar 8oa D:AA:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':"oa:8oa-2TI-acti+ists-too-facebrunt:articles%o*:FJGJKAFA(cms aisu.% 7amb%ania )aman and )iu K:K:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-attac.edC-politicians-officialson-run:KLIJGL:J San,it )as Me"%ala'a K:FG:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:in-ne-rti-acti+ists-at-t%e-recei+in"end:KLMGFJ:J A,a' Ambalia 8u,arat K:LF:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:anot%er-rti-acti+ist-assaulted-no*-b',etpur-na"arpali.a-c%ief:KGJELG:J Pars%uram 9is%anlal Mali 8u,arat M:D:FF Assaulted %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JM-JK:ra,.ot:LJFAMKKFHFHrtiapplicant-rti-act-indian-rail*a's Manis%a 8os*ami 8u,arat M:AF:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:commentHrti-acti+ists-%a+e-al*a's-beentar"etted-in-"u,aratHFIJKLFE Me%ul 9ataria Ma%aras%tra FJ:D:FF Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:india:2TI-acti+ist-in-Mumbaiattac.ed:articles%o*:FJAKLEJG(cms Santos% M Ti*ari Ma%aras%tra : 8u,arat FJ:FI:FF Assaulted %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:Mumbai-2TI-acti+ist-left-inSurat-after-abduction-and-assault:ArticleF-DEDMIM(asp/ Poonam Solan.i 8u,arat FA:A:FF Assaulted %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-FAJL:a%medabad:LJGDFEJEHFHrti-acti+ist-coma-sarpanc%

)%udaram 2a,ast%an A:A:FA Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':,aipur:2TI-applicant-attac.ed-fore/posin"-"raft-in-M8N2E8A:articles%o*:FFDKGFLD(cms Nabi A%mad 7i%ar G:E:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(ndt+(com:article:cities:ri"%t-to-information-acti+ist-assaulted-inbi%ar-FMGALG H S 2at%i Pun,ab G:LJ:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:2TI-acti+ists--"roup-condemns--attac.-on-collea"ue:MGEMFJ: 2a3i Hasan 7i%ar E:FF:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(deccanc%ronicle(com:c%annels:nation:nort%:rti-acti+ist-s%ot-bi%arIFF )eepa. 2e"e 9arnata.a E:FA:FA Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':%ubli:Sand-mafia-assaults-2TI-acti+istin-)%ar*ad:articles%o*:FLGADFLI(cms 9amles% Parmar 8u,arat E:FM:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:reportHa%medabad-ta/i-dri+er-beaten-up-fore/posin"-corruptionHFIMFDJI Nat%ala Su.%adi'a 8u,arat I:AG:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:cop-names-minister-in-fir-marc%ed-out*it%in-%ours:MIDAKL:J 7abban Mis%ra =ttar Prades% D:AA:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(business-standard(com:"eneralne*s:ne*s:man-assaulted-forsee.in"-info-under-rti-act:LEIDF: Naus%ad 9%an Ma%aras%tra M:FF:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(mumbaimirror(com:article:A:AJFAJMFGAJFAJMFGJLGKALGEIGdFdDb IF:2TI-acti+ist-t%ras%ed-for-complaint-a"ainst-ille"al-factor'-on-7M!land(%tml San,a' )attaram 9ode Ma%aras%tra FJ:FE:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:mumbai:reportHrti-acti+ist-beaten-up-at-mlasofficeHFDEAKEI 7 2ama.ris%nappa 9arnata.a FF:FI:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(deccan%erald(com:content:AMAGKK:rti-acti+istassaulted(%tml N Srini+asa 2ao And%ra Prades% FF:AA:FA Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':%'derabad:W%istleblo*ers-face-deat%t%reats-but-cops-cool:articles%o*:FDLIEMKJ(cms

N Srini+asa 2ao And%ra Prades% FA:LJ:FA Assaulted %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:states:and%ra-prades%:rti-acti+ist-in,ected*it%-poisonous-substance:articleGAEIIGF(ece T%a.ur 2a,.umar Sin"% And%ra Prades% F:F:FL Assaulted %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFL-JFJL:%'derabad:LIFLJAMJHFHrti-acti+ist-lo.a'u.ta-case-encroac%ment-case Nars%ib%ai Malani 8u,arat F:I:FL Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':ra,.ot:Farmer-t%ras%ed-for-usin"-2TIto-fi"%t-pollution-menace:articles%o*:FDMFKLEG(cms A.%iles% Sa/ena =ttar Prades% in AJJK Assaulted %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 2in.u Sin"% 2a%i =ttar Prades% in AJJM Assaulted %ttp:::dail'(b%as.ar(com:article:=P-up-protestin"-*%istleblo*er-officer-loc.edup-in-mental-as'lum-LJAALLL(%tml 9% Pasot Manipur in AJFA Assaulted %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainEL(asp$filenameNWsFAJMFAMANIP=2(asp Parames*ar Sabar 0rissa une AJFF Assaulted %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JIAF:b%ubanes*ar:AMIMJAEAHFHbpl-list-rti-application-rti-act Niren Paree.& !%ristop%er Min3 Assam Ma' AJJD Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:assam-rti-applicantalle"es-assault:FAKFLE:J 2ames% A"ra*al !%%attis"ar% ul' AJFA %ttp:::***(outloo.india(com:article(asp/$AKAAKJ Assaulted

Ma%endra T%a.ur Ma%aras%tra Au" AJFA Assaulted %ttp:::***(mone'life(in:article:ration-card-frauds-can-be-e/posed-t%rou"%rti:ADMGL(%tml Tapal 8anes% 9arnata.a =n.no*n Assaulted %ttp:::***(ndt+(com:article:india:men-*%o-fou"%t-redd'-brot%ers-attac.edFKIIM Purs%ottam !%au%an 8u,arat =n.no*n Assaulted %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:A%medabad:Man-t%ras%ed-for-see.in"-infounder-2TI:articles%o*:GDLKKGI(cms Nara'an Hare.a 0rissa =n.no*n Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:attac.in"-t%e-ri"%t-to-as.:LAAEAD:J

A.%il 8o"oi Assam =n.no*n Assaulted %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:assam-rti-applicant-alle"esassault:FAKFLE:J Sumit 9umar Ma%ato %ar.%and =n.no*n Assaulted %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 7ib%a+ 9umar& 2a,ee+ 9umar =ttar Prades% F:AI:JD Harassed %ttp:::cities(e/pressindia(com:fullstor'(p%p$ne*sidNAFMGIM Tu.aram 7ansode Ma%aras%tra FA:LF:JD Harassed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:acti+ist-see.in"-info-under-rti-,ailed-onne*-'ears-e+e-fined:AEIMEA:J < 8opala.ris%nan Tamil Nadu L:FL:JM Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':c%ennai:Info-panel-orders-probe-intot%reat-to-2TI-applicant:articles%o*:EEMEAJD(cms Sri.ant Prab%u Ma%aras%ta E:F:JM Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 9is%ori 2am 7i%ar D:AF:JM Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 8o+erd%an Sin"% 2a,ast%an L:F:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp Mo%it S%arma )el%i L:FA:FJ Harassed %ttp:::sif'(com:ne*s:mcd-en"ineers-t%reatened-to-.ill-me-alle"es-rtiapplicant-ne*s-national-.dp+ucibcdb(%tml a' 9umar 2a"%u+ans%i Ma%aras%tra L:FL:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(mid-da'(com:ne*s:AJFF:ma':JFJEFF-police-complaint-2TI-acti+istHS!7-7H!-<itt%al*adi(%tm )a+inder 9%urana Pun,ab G:A:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 2ames% A"ra*al !%attis"ar% I:AL:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp 8anes% 7or%ade Ma%aras%tra D:D:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:cit'-acti+ist-for*ards-b%orade-appeal-forprotection-to-state-%ome-dept:IGIAIL:J

Manis% 7%atna"ar Ma%aras%tra D:FK:FJ Harassed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:acti+ist-see.s-info-from-cbi-"ets-t%reatsinstead:FAIMEM-L(%tml Hars%ad Patil Ma%aras%ta K:FL:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(mid-da'(com:ne*s:AJFJ:au":ALJKFJ-peon-%ospitalised-%arassedsc%ool-lo*-salar'(%tm 8opal.ris%nan& Si+a Elan"o& Mad%a+ <is%nub%atta Tamil Nadu M:F:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(indiato"et%er(or":AJFJ:sep:rtitnsic(%tm Fatima M'nson"& Ac4uiline Son"t%ian"& Matilda Sutin" Me"%ala'a M:F:FJ Harassed %ttp:::***(businessstandard(com:india:ne*s:*%istleblo*ers-face-persecution-inme"%ala'a:GJIIDM: Ab%i,it 8%os% Ma%aras%ta M:F:FJ Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:india:Harassed-*%istleblo*er-forced-to"i+e-up-fi"%t-bu'-peace-*it%-ban.:articles%o*:IDAFKFL(cms 2atna Ala 8u,arat M:AM:FJ Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:india:7lind-2TI-crusader-"ets-deat%t%reats:articles%o*:IDJLAKI(cms 7obb' 7asaia*moit Me"%ala'a A:F:FF Harassed %ttp:::ne*s(outloo.india(com:item(asp/$DFJEDL Mar' Anne Po%s%na Me"%ala'a L:M:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:Me"%ala'a-2TI-acti+ist-s-arrestfla'ed:ArticleF-IDAIMM(asp/ San,a' 8ura+ Ma%aras%tra L:AA:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(ndt+(com:article:cities:mumbai-rti-acti+ist-recei+es-deat%-t%reatsMGADA M B Ali 9arnata.a E:FJ:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:ban"alore:reportHban"alore-corporator-t%reatens-rtiacti+ist-o+er-land-disputeHFEGFGIE 9etan S%a% 8u,arat E:FA:FF Harassed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:"eneralne*sfeed:ne*s:sarab%ai-demands-action-a"ainstt%ose-t%reatenin"-rti-acti+ist:IKJDLF(%tml 2a+inder 2at%i Har'ana I:A:FF Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JI-JL:india:AMIFIKAJHFHrtiacti+ist-+ice-c%ief-information Pa'i 8'adi Arunac%al Prades% I:E:FF Harassed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:arunac%al-minister-in+ol+ed-in-"o+t-,obscam:FIMAIL-LD-IG(%tml

7ri,es% 9umar )el%i K:A:FF Harassed %ttp:::indiatoda'(intoda'(in:site:stor':abusi+e-repl'-to-rti-4uer'-b'mcd:F:FGDIJG(%tml As%o. Pas*an 7i%ar K:FM:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(tele"rap%india(com:FFFJKAF:,sp:bi%ar:stor'HFGGJADDG(,sp Ar+ind S%arma Pun,ab M:E:FF Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JMJI:lud%iana:LJFFKJFFHFHacti+ist-"lada-t%reat )erric. )ias 8oa M:FF:FF Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':"oa:8oa-2TI-acti+ists-too-facebrunt:articles%o*:FJGJKAFA(cms Sub%as% A""ar*al )el%i FJ:D:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:cities:)el%i:articleAEAJAKG(ece S%eeba Fe%mi and Ars%ad Ali Fe%mi )el%i FJ:K:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-attac.ed-b'mob-in-,ama-mas,id-area:KEDKEI: San,a' 8ura+ Ma%aras%tra FF:AK:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(mid-da'(com:ne*s:AJFF:dec:JFFAFF-Ha*.ers-t%reaten-2TIacti+ist-o+er-complaint(%tm Anupam Saraf& <aib%a+ 8and%i and )ines% S%a% Ma%aras%tra FA:FL:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(midda'(com:ne*s:AJFF:dec:FGFAFF-pune-<oter-re"istration-officer-tries-to-s%oo2TI-acti+ists-a*a'-*it%-FI2-t%reat(%tm 2( Mari,osep% 9arnata.a FA:LJ:FF Harassed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:toda's-paper:tp-national:articleADIELID(ece Surendra @ada+ =ttara.%and I:FJ:FA Harassed %ttp:::dail'pioneer(com:state-editions:de%radun:DAEID-rti-acti+istt%reatened(%tml Panduran" and Nara'an 8ae.*ad 8u,arat L:FI:FA Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':surat:2TIapplicants-in-)an"-t%reatened:articles%o*:FALJMFJD(cms 2a,u Malt%um.ar And%ra Prades% I:FF:FA Harassed %ttp:::ne*indiane/press(com:cities:%'derabad:articleEGKJEF(ece 0 P 9ataria Har'ana I:FM:FA Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-JIAF:"ur"aon:LALEFIDLHFHfa.e-+oter-rti-acti+ist-arrest-*arrant

=ma S%an.ar @o"i 2a,ast%an FJ:F:FA Harassed %ttp:::dail'(b%as.ar(com:article:2A - P2-acti+ist-"oes-b'-boo.-to-see.-inforuns-into-trouble-LKKIDDF-PH0(%tml Prof S9 7%alla ammu and 9as%mir FF:I:FA Harassed %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:Ne*s-Feed: ammuPAJSec:Minister-s-*ifet%reatened-me-claims-2TI-acti+ist:ArticleF-MEDLDF(asp/ ) 8anapati 2a,u And%ra Prades% FF:AL:FA Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':%'derabad:W%istleblo*ers-face-deat%t%reats-but-cops-cool:articles%o*:FDLIEMKJ(cms )ines% 9alla%alli 9arnata.a FF:AI:FA Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:ban"alore:reportH'et-anot%er-rti-acti+ist-comesunder-t%reat-cloud-in-ban"aloreHFDDJDEE S Lo.ra, 9arnata.a FF:AD:FA Harassed %ttp:::***(ban"aloremirror(com:article:FJ:AJFAFFAKAJFAFFAKJAJLAAKJGLDDb DEeM:9id*ai-emplo'ee-*%o-filed-FJJ-2TI-4ueries-faces-ministerPEAPKJPMMs*rat%(%tml Anis 9%an Ma%aras%tra FA:A:FA Harassed %ttp:::***(ndt+(com:article:cities:m'-*ife-*as-t%reatened-after-i-filed-an-rtiLJELIA 9is%an Lal 8era Har'ana AJJK on*ards Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':del%i:2TI-acti+ist-8era-"ettin"-t%reatcalls:articles%o*:DLIKFDJ(cms 7is%amb%ar )a'al Har'ana AJJK on*ards Harassed %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:India-ne*s:8ur"aon:EJ-'r-old-cop-%arassedfor-fi"%tin"-corruption:ArticleF-KGMAEI(asp/ A,a' 7ose Ma%aras%tra AJJK on*ards Harassed %ttp:::***(li+emint(com:Leisure:)GMi0u/4/EpNsb./Lm=LGH:W%istleblo*ers-A-matter-of-confidentialit'(%tml 2 < Prasanna 9arnata.a AJJM on*ards Harassed %ttp:::***(ban"aloremirror(com:inde/(asp/$ pa"eNarticle#sectidNFJ#contentidNAJFAJFFDAJFAJFFDJGELLILEDbfEbeeDM S%i+ Pra.as% 2ai 7i%ar Ma' AJJK Harassed %ttp:::***(tele"rap%india(com:FFFJKAF:,sp:bi%ar:stor'HFGGJADDG(,sp Ta.%ellambam Ibempis%a.& sa"olsem Memc%a and 9on,en"bam Anita Manipur Apr AJFF on*ards Harassed %ttp:::***(epao(net:8P(asp$srcNFF((FFJGFF(aprFF

Pa*an S%arma =ttar Prades% Apr FFt%& AJFF on*ards Harassed %ttp:::indiatoda'(intoda'(in:site:stor':rti-acti+ist-,ailed-in"%a3iabad:F:FGIKKM(%tml Emmanuel And%ra Prades% Feb # Mar AJFF Harassed %ttp:::***(deccanc%ronicle(com:%'derabad:rti-acti+istsee.s-refu"e-copPEAPKJPMMs-false-c%ar"es-DDG a"bir Sin"% )el%i Feb AJFF on*ards Harassed %ttp:::***(mid-da'(com:ne*s:AJFF:mar:AAJLFF-ne*s-del%i-2TI-unaut%orisedencroac%ment-@amuna-ri+er-bed(%tm 7iren Lu*an" Manipur April AJFF on*ards Harassed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:"eneralne*sfeed:ne*s:rti-applicant-t%reatenedostracised-b'-local-residents:KJFMIJ(%tml QIn,amba..am- H Se.ar Tamil Nadu Au"ust AJFF on*ards Harassed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:acti+ist-recei+es-t%reat-callssee.s-protection:AFDKED-IJ-FAJ(%tml 9%irasind%u Sa"ria 0rrisa After No+ember AJFF Harassed %ttp:::***(mone'life(in:article:*ell-done-sa"riamdas%t%e-"%ost-farm-pond*%istleblo*er-of-odis%a:AALAK(%tml Mu3ibur 2e%man =n.no*n in AJJD Harassed %ttp:::***(li+emint(com:AJJD:FJ:AAALGLGG:2TI-*%istleblo*er-sa's-%e-is(%tml Saleem 7ai" =ttar Prades% in AJJD Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp Asit% San"ma Me"%ala'a in AJJK Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp As%o. <erma Pun,ab in AJJM Harassed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:applicant-complains-of-recei+in"t%reat:IDMIGM:J 9%eemaram 2a,ast%an in AJFJ Harassed %ttp:::***(opent%ema"a3ine(com:article:nation:t%e-man-*%o-dares-to-bare 2a,ee+ 9umar West 7en"al Ma' AJFF Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-FJLJ:mumbai:LGKFIADAHFHrti-acti+ists-rti-4ueries-rti-user S%i+a,i 2aut Ma%aras%tra une AJFF Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:mumbai:reportHprobe-into-t%reats-to-ma%aras%trarti-acti+istHFEEAKID

A,a' 8a.%ar )el%i ul' AJFF Harassed %ttp:::ne*s(outloo.india(com:item(asp/$DADELD All 8u,arat 2TI users 8u,arat ul' AJFF Harassed %ttp:::***(a%medabadmirror(com:article:L:AJFFJDAAAJFFJDAAJAGGEJGLKAcIG KAFM:8u,arat-"o+t-to-put-2TI-acti+ists-under-scanner-(%tml An.ur Patil Ma%aras%tra Sep AJFF Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:mumbai:reportHrti-acti+ist-"ets-t%reat-from-mulundinspectorHFEKLLEK 8un,an Me%ta 8u,arat )ec AJFF Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-FAAL:a%medabad:LJEEJIFGHFHcit'-police-rti-application-anandna"ar H 2 7an"ia Hara'ana Ma' AJFA Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-JEFL:"ur"aon:LFIKMJDDHFHrti-acti+ist-rti-4ueries-information-acti+ist )eepa. 8ade.ar 8oa Sep AJFA Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':"oa:2TI-acti+ist-boo.ed-'eta"ain:articles%o*:FILIEEAA(cms )ur"a )el%i in AJFF Harassed %ttp:::***(deccan%erald(com:content:FDDDDD:cic-issues-stern-*arnin"a"ainst(%tml ! 9arira And%ra Prades% in AJFF Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':%'derabad:!I!-issues-s%o*-causenotice-to-2P0-official:articles%o*:MLDDFAF(cms Nelapati Papiredd' Pac%alla Sur'anara'ana 2edd' and 9o+uru Sat'anara'ana 2edd' And%ra Prades% in AJFF Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':%'derabad:L-'out%s-ostracised-for-2TIe/pose:articles%o*:MEEMJEM(cms Mo%inder 9umar Pun,ab =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:Anot%er-2TI-acti+ist-alle"est%reat:IKLILJ: An*ar S%ai.% Ma%aras%tra =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-"ets-t%reats-o+er-mumbai-landscam:FLFEAM-L(%tml @( E.'imo 9i.on Na"aland =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(tele"rap%india(com:FJMJIFL:,sp:nort%east:stor'HFFFJFLGD(,sp As%o. 2at%od 8u,arat =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:reportHsc%ool-bullies-fat%er-after-rtipleaHFADEAMF

7%arat H 8a,,ar& Milan os%i 8u,arat =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(e/pressindia(com:latest-ne*s:info-on-sc%ools-under-rti-in+itest%reat-calls:AKGIJA: 2oll' S%i+%are Mad%'a Prades% =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(te%el.a(com:stor'HmainGD(asp$filenameNNeJMFJFJ)eadH2i"%t(asp ai Pra.as% Ar'a )el%i =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(deccanc%ronicle(com:national:FF-arrested-'ear-%arassin"-rtiacti+ists-GDM )r( 8ian Sin"% )el%i =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(deccanc%ronicle(com:national:FF-arrested-'ear-%arassin"-rtiacti+ists-GDM 2am Sa"ar )el%i =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:en4uire-deat%-t%reats-to-*%istleblo*ercic-to-police-c%ief:DGIELM:J Suman.ant 2aic%aud%ari 7i%ar =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***("oo"le(com:%ostedne*s:afp:article:ALe4ME%9-!WB<%Wu8Fi8@Ll+*M.JKEDM"$docIdN!N8(dKAeeMdMfAIaAGDGIGcdFJKdddaJbDJJ(LF Pi'us%a Ti*ari 2a,ast%an =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JL-JG:,aipur:AKIEMJLJHFHrtiapplication-state-information-commission-n"o 2a'ab%ai Bapadi'a 8u,arat =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFF-JL-JE:ra,.ot:AKIEMAMLHFHrtiapplicants-public-information-officer-rti-act 2a3uddin Hara'ana =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':del%i:M'ster'-clouds-deat%-of,ournalist:articles%o*:FJAGJJEK(cms 2u.%minib%ai And%ra Prades% =n.no*n %ttp:::***(timesno*(t+:Teac%er-fired-after-son-filed2TI:articles%o*:GLMGFDD(cms Harassed

2os%an Lobo 9arnata.a =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:cities:Man"alore:articleAIJJEDM(ece 7%adres% Wam,a 8u,arat =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:commentHrti-acti+ists-%a+e-al*a's-beentar"etted-in-"u,aratHFIJKLFE 7%an,ib%ai o"el and 7%aratb%ai 8%u"%al 8u,arat =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:commentHrti-acti+ists-%a+eal*a's-been-tar"etted-in-"u,aratHFIJKLFE

5=n.no*n6 Ma%aras%tra =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(mid-da'(com:ne*s:AJFA:mar:LJJLFA-W%istleblo*er-fears-forsafet'-approac%es-cops(%tm Lal,i Ma.*ana 8u,arat =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:reportHdalits-demur-complain-a"ainst-"u,aratpoliceHFIKKMDE <en.ata 2ao And%ra Prades% =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(asiana"e(com:%'derabad:fa.e-cases-a"ainst-rti-acti+ists-fi"%tin""raft-JEL 5=n.no*n6 Ma%aras%tra =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':mumbai:!i+ic-bod'-re+eals-identit'-of2TI-applicant-to-institutes:articles%o*:FELEDGJM(cms Na"endra ais*al 7i%ar =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:India-ne*s:Patna:W%istleblo*er-faces-t%reatto-life-runs-for-co+er:ArticleF-MLKADA(asp/ eetendra 8%ad"e Ma%aras%tra =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-FJLJ:mumbai:LGKFIADAHFHrti-acti+ists-rti-4ueries-rti-user Manoran,an 2o' Ma%aras%tra =n.no*n %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-FJLJ:mumbai:LGKFIADAHFHrti-acti+ists-rti-4ueries-rti-user Harassed

Sunil Sin"%& 8ulab Sin"%& 2am Milan Sin"% and S%i+ Sin"% =ttar Prades% =n.no*n Harassed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-FF-JK:.anpur:LGMMLDGMHFHrtiapplication-rti-acti+ist-rti-4ueries Lalit Me%ta %ar.%and E:FE:JK 9illed %ttp:::***(e/pressindia(com:latest-ne*s:In-"rief-o+er-a-murdered-N2E8acti+ist-%is-coura"e-is-%ealer:LFLKML: 9ames%*ar @ada+ %ar.%and I:D:JK 9illed %ttp:::***(tele"rap%india(com:FJKJIJM:,sp:frontpa"e:stor'HMLKEFEM(,sp <en.ates% 9arnata.a G:I:JM 9illed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:7an"alore:2TI-acti+ist-*as-murderedAutops':articles%o*:GLKIKIL(cms Satis% S%ett' Ma%aras%tra F:FL:FJ %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:articleKJAAA(ece 9illed

Arun Sa*ant Ma%aras%tra A:F:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(frontlineonnet(com:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJJGJJ(%tm

<is%ram La/man )odi'a 8u,arat A:FF:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:national:articleELAJEF(ece S%as%id%ar Mis%ra 7i%ar A:FG:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(frontlineonnet(com:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJJGJJ(%tm Sola 2an"a 2ao And%ra Prades% G:FF:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:national:articleELAJEF(ece <itt%al 8ite Ma%aras%tra G:AF:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(frontlineonnet(com:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJJGJJ(%tm )attatra'a Patil Ma%aras%tra E:AA:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(frontlineonnet(com:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJJGJJ(%tm Amit et%*a 8u,arat D:AJ:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(frontlineonnet(com:stories:AJFJJMFJADFKJJGJJ(%tm <i,a' Pratap alias 7abbu Sin"% =ttar Prades% D:AE:FJ 9illed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':luc.no*:Home-"uard.illed-for-see.in"-info-under-2TI:articles%o*:IAAEDIK(cms 2amdas 8%ade"aon.ar Ma%aras%tra K:AD:FJ 9illed %ttp:::***(%industantimes(com:Not-enou"%-steps-ta.en-to-curbattac.s:ArticleF-EMGJAM(asp/ Sonu Har'ana A:FJ:FF 9illed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:states:ot%er-states:articleFGGDGDK(ece Ni'amat Ansari %ar.%and L:A:FF 9illed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:states:ot%er-states:articleFEJEKKK(ece Amit 9apasia 8u,arat FA:AM:FF 9illed %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:Slain-Surat-builder-%ad-filed-LJ-2TI4ueries:KMGFID: S%e%la Masood Mad%'a Prades% K:FI:FF 9illed %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:india:Anna-supporter-and-2TI-acti+ist-s%otdead-in-7%opal:articles%o*:MIAAFLM(cms S 7%u+anes*aran Tamil Nadu F:FJ:FA 9illed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-JF-FF:india:LJIFEEGGHFHrtiapplications-rti-acti+ist-land-encroac%ment Prem.ant %a Ma%aras%tra A:AI:FA 9illed %ttp:::ibnli+e(in(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-s%ot-dead-in-ma%aras%tra:ALLMAJ-L(%tml

Perumalla Sur'anara'ana And%ra Prades% I:AA:FA 9illed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:toda's-paper:tp-national:tpand%raprades%:articleLEIFIIF(ece 9apurc%and 8upta Ma%aras%tra FF:AJ:FA 9illed %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-FFAA:mumbai:LELJFMLFHFHmultiple-stab-*ounds-%a*.ers-nas%i. Lin"ara,u 9arnata.a FF:AJ:FA 9illed %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:cities:ban"alore:rti-acti+istmurdered:articleGFFIEJD(ece Nadeem Sai'ed 8u,arat FF:E:FF 9illed 5Possibl' for reason unrelated to 2TI filed6 %ttp:::***(dnaindia(com:india:reportHslain-rtiman-nadeem-sai'ed-*as-t%reatened-b'-"oonHFIJKIJD 2am+ilas Sin"% 7i%ar FA:K:FF 9illed 5Possibl' for reason unrelated to 2TI filed6 %ttp:::***(indiane/press(com:ne*s:rti-acti+ist-s%otdead-in-bi%ar:KKEIMK:J < 7alasubramanian Tamil Nadu K:FM:FJ 9illed 5$6 %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':c%ennai:2TI-acti+ist-found-dead-onroad:articles%o*:ILGIKIE(cms a'es% 7arot # @o"es% S%e.%ar 8u,arat FF:FL:FF 9illed 5$6 %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':+adodara:7 P-e/-sarpanc%-accused-of.illin"-t*o-in-Halol:articles%o*:FALAJAID(cms 2a+inder 7al*ani )el%i G:AL:FA 9illed 5$6 %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:cit':del%i:2TI-acti+ist-dies-m'steriousl'famil'-sa's-%e-*as-murdered:articles%o*:FLJEIDAA(cms abbardan 8ad%+i 8u,arat A:AA:FF 9illed self %ttp:::timesofindia(indiatimes(com:india:)enied-info-2TI-acti+ist-immolatesself-in-8u,arat:articles%o*:DEGLGED(cms

Last updated on Dt% an AJFL

0t%er articles of rele+ance: 2TI information sou"%t b' *%istle-blo*ers& since .illed& to be made public %ttp:::***(t%e%indu(com:ne*s:national:articleAEFADMI(ece 2TI Anon'mous comes to t%e rescue of t%ose afraid of bein" tar"eted for filin" 2TI applications

%ttp:::***(mone'life(in:article:rti-anon'mous-comes-to-t%e-rescue-of-t%oseafraid-of-bein"-tar"eted-for-filin"-rti-applications:AGGJA(%tml Pun,ab "o+ernment mo+es to protect ;*%istleblo*ers; %ttp:::***(dail'mail(co(u.:india%ome:indiane*s:article-AAFKFIJ:Pun,ab"o+ernment-mo+es-protect-*%istle-blo*ers(%tml$itoNfeeds-ne*s/ml Har'ana notifies polic' for securit' of *%istle blo*ers %ttp:::***(businessstandard(com:"eneralne*s:ne*s:%ar'ana-notifies-polic'-for-securit'*%istleblo*ers:IIAII: Police protection to 2TI acti+ist remains on paper %ttp:::articles(timesofindia(indiatimes(com:AJFA-FAAL:t%ane:LEMKAAMLHFHrti-acti+ist-social-acti+ists-+i.rant-.arni.

3rd DEGREE torture by POLICE World over due to Judicial irresponsibility

Matc% Fi/in" ud"es of India https:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$match% ixing%judges%police

! I P Sat%asi+am led 7enc% refuses to e/tend 0rderC ai Pra.as% Associates Limited to pa' AE crores

The &upreme 'ourt yesterday re used to extend order passed by the predecessor bench, which granted interim protection to (ai Pra!ash )ssociates "imited rom paying *+ 'rores. This civil appeal in the &upreme 'ourt arises rom a writ petition that was iled by ,imprivesh -nvironment Protection &ociety be ore the ,igh 'ourt o ,imachal Pradesh against setting up o cement plant and thermal plant by (ai Pra!ash )ssociates "imited .()"/. The ,igh 'ourt gave a judgment against ()" on 0th 1ay, *23* and imposed huge damages on the company. 4n the judgment, the ,igh 'ourt observed that the entire project o ()" was based on a 5tissue o lies6 and at every stage ()" has either given wrong in ormation or has tried to mislead the authority. 4t was ound that ()" was guilty o ma!ing alse statements or obtaining environmental clearances or all its projects. ,igh 'ourt 7uashed the environment clearance in respect o thermal plant. The ,igh 'ourt observed that even environment clearance with regard to cement plant is liable to be 7uashed but !eeping in view livelihood o thousands o villagers, the same was allowed. The 'ourt urther said, 5) ter having discussed the matter in detail above and inding ()" guilty o deceit, we must ma!e sure that neither ()" nor any other 'ompany in the uture behaves in such a manner. 8e have, there ore, decided to impose damages on ()".6 9amages worth :s. 322 crores was imposed on ()" and that was supposed to be paid in our instalment o :s. *+ crores each; the irst to be paid by <3st )ugust *23*; second by <3st 1arch, *23<, third by <3st 1arch *230 and the last instalment by <3st 1arch *23+. ()" approached the &upreme 'ourt against this order through a special leave petition. ) =ench o (ustices ) > Patnai! and , " #o!hale on *?th @ovember *23*, granted leave to appeal but a stay on the ,igh 'ourt order was re used. On *2th 1arch, *23< a =ench comprising o then 'hie (ustice o 4ndia, (ustice )ltamas >abir gave extension o time or payment o *+ crores .which was supposed to be paid on <3st 1arch, *23</ till *2th )pril, *23<. On 3Ath )pril, *23< a =ench presided by (ustice >abir allowed the Binterim order’ dated *2th 1arch, *23< to continue operation and the matter was listed or Cth 1ay, *23<. On Cth 1ay, *23< the 'ourt in its Order mentioned, 5The stay granted shall continue till then6. ,owever there was no Bstay’ actually granted by the 'ourt in any o the proceedings till then, though the Cth 1ay order mentioned about a Bstay’. On 32th (uly, *23< a =ench presided by (ustice >abir said, 5,aving heard learned counsel or the parties and since it has not been possible or this =ench to ta!e up the matter, let it stand over till *<rd (uly, *23<, and be placed be ore the =ench presided over by ,on’ble the 'hie (ustice. Till then, the payment o the installment shall continue to be de erred.6 Desterday, senior counsels )bhishe! 1anu &inghvi and E > #upta sought or de erring payment o the installment. (ustices P &athasivam and :anjan #ogoi a ter going through the order dated *?th @ovember, *23* passed by (ustices (ustices ) > Patnai! and , " #o!hale re using a stay, came down heavily and re used to de er payment.

Porbandar ,ud"e accused of do*r' %arassment Press Trust o 4ndia : :aj!ot, 1on (an *0 *233, 2+:*C hrs

) complaint has been iled against 9istrict and &essions judge o Porbandar or allegedly harassing his daughter%in%law or dowry, police said here on &unday. 9arshana 9ave, a native o )mreli, has iled a complaint against her husband >innar, ather%in%law and district judge )rvind 9ave, mother%in%law Pratibha and brother%in%law Prashant, the police added. 9arshana married >innar two years ago. ,er complaint says that she was harassed rom the beginning, and was even beaten up by the husband and in%laws, who were demanding :s 32 la!h as dowry. &he has also alleged that she was thrown out o the house a ew months bac!, and her husband is now see!ing divorce, the police said. )mreli &uperintendent o Police , : 1uliyana con irmed to have received the complaint against the judge and others. ,e said that action will be ta!en a ter veri ying the complaint. This is the second complaint related to dowry harassment iled against a judge in the state in the recent past. -arlier, a woman had iled a complaint against additional sessions judge o (etpur a ter her daughter and the judgeFs wi e committed suicide.

8ur"aon ,ud"e to also face do*r' %arassment c%ar"e

#urgaonFs 'hie (udicial 1agistrate :avneet #arg, boo!ed or the murder o his wi e, will also ace dowry harassment charge, police here said 1onday. Police have issued notices to the '(1Fs ather >.>. #arg and mother :achna #arg, who have also been named in the dowry harassment case. The '(1Fs ather reached here 1onday morning rom ,aryanaFs Panch!ula town and contacted police, who wanted to 7uestion him. G8e had called '(1Fs parents...>.>. #arg was 7uestioned by special investigation team .&4T/,G #urgaon Police 'ommissioner )lo! 1ittal said.

1ittal said on the basis o written complaint iled by the parents o the '(1Fs wi e #eetanjali, penal sections o dowry harassment and extra%marital a air were included in the H4: lodged against the '(1 &aturday. #eetanjali, *0, bore three bullet wounds % on her chin, chest and stomach % but no bullets were ound in her body that was recovered here Thursday. The '(1Fs licensed irearm was ound near the body, police said. 1ittal said two bullets were seiIed rom the scene o crime and would be sent or ballistic examination 1onday, a day a ter ballistic experts examined the crime spot. GThe &4T &unday 7uestioned two women relatives o :avneet #arg or hours at his government allotted house here in the O icers 'olony,G said 1ittal. G8e have as!ed '(1 to produce supporting evidences to prove his statement,G he said. The '(1 allegedly said that his driver and domestic help may throw some light on his wi eFs death. (udge #argFs in%laws alleged that two cars were provided to the accused on his and his amilyFs demand. :s.* la!h were also delivered to him at the time o the admission o his daughters in school in 1ay. #eetanjaliFs brother Pradeep )ggarwal &aturday lodged a irst in ormation report against #arg and his parents, accusing them o murder. G:avneet and #eetanjali got married in @ovember *22A. -verything was ine or a ew years but the attitude o :avneet and his parents towards #eetanjali started changing a ter she delivered two baby girls .now aged around our and a hal and three years/,G )ggarwal said in his complaint. ,e demanded a probe by the 'entral =ureau o 4nvestigation .'=4/ into his sisterFs murder.

:s 322 crore o ered or #ali (anardhan :eddy’s bail: )rrested judge

1ore s!eletons are tumbling out in the mur!y cash% or%bail scam involving mining baron and ormer >arnata!a minister #ali (anardhan :eddy as a lower court judge, arrested in the case, disclosed to the )'= that #aliFs men were ready to o er as much as a staggering :s 322 crore to secure bail or him. -arlier, the deal amount was put at :s 3+ crore. T "a!shminarasimha :ao, the arrested judge, disclosed that 9asaradharami :eddy, a relative o #ali, had made the :s 322 crore o er, according to the con ession statement recorded by the )'=. >rishna Prasad, an auditor, who is !nown to him and another relative 1 Een!ateswara :ao approached "a!shminarasimha :ao in the second wee! o

)pril with a re7uest to loo! or a JchannelF to in luence the '=4 judge or #aliFs release on bail. GThey were in touch with 9asaradharami :eddy who was willing to pay even :s 322 crore or securing the bail,G the con ession statement o :ao said. Though the deal initially came as a shoc! to the arrested judge, who at the time was registrar .en7uiries/, high court, he was later attracted towards the deal, it said.

"a!shminarasimha :ao called the '=4 court judge = @agamaruti &arma to his residence on )pril 3C and tried to convince him on granting o bail to #ali. &arma did not agree or the deal and went away rejecting the o er. ,e had, in act, dismissed the bail plea. Then another person :aavi &urya Pra!ash =abu, a real estate dealer, who was ta!en to =ellary 1") &riramulu by his associate >olli "a!shmaiah 'howdary or stri!ing the deal, approached :ao again. &urya Pra!ash had already met &riramuluFs nephew and >ampli 1") T , &uresh =abu who, too, was trying to secure bail or #ali and advised him to wait as @agamaruti &arma was not o Ftheir typeF. =ut he re7uested "a!shminarasimha :ao to !eep the JchannelF open as the deal was Gtoo lucrative to be ignoredG. "ater, in a strange se7uence o events, @agamaruti &arma was shi ted out o '=4 court and a resh bail plea was iled which came be ore another special judge T Pattabhirama :ao. "a!shminarasimha :ao roped in PattabhiFs batchmate 9 Prabha!ar :ao, another district judge, who was with the state election commission as its secretary .legal/. ,e also tried to push the deal but ailed as Pattabhi told him that he would decide the matter on only JmeritF. 4t turned out later that Pattabhi chose a FrouteF planned by his riend 'halapati though the deal was only or :s + crore. This was mainly because his riend did not put any precondition that he should meet #ali &omase!hara :eddy, brother o #ali (anardhana :eddy, be ore giving bail as was done by Prabha!ar :ao, who was also arrested in the case. Prabha!ar in his con ession spo!e o only :s 3+ core implying that he too was unaware o the whopping :s 322%crore deal. 8hile the )'= arrested "a!shminarasimha :ao on (uly 3*, Pattabhi was arrested last month. 4nterestingly, the )'= sleuths seiIed some che7ues bearing the names o "a!shminarasimha :aoFs amily members with some complaint letters written by advocates against some )P high court judges. The letters were addressed to the President o 4ndia. B'orrupt judges must ace the music’

'orruption exists in the 4ndian judiciary. ) ew judges are inappropriately in luenced in their decision ma!ing. &aying this is ) P &hah, ormer chie justice o the high courts o 1adras and 9elhi. &hah lived up to his reputation or calling a spade a spade on &aturday, when he delivered a speech on judicial appointments and accountability at a unction organiIed by the @ani Pal!hivala Houndation and the #ovindh &waminadhan Trust at the 1usic )cademy .

5'orruption has spread its tentacles and does not seem to be limited to conventional orms o bribery,6 he said. &tating that judges guilty o misconduct should ace prosecution, he said judicial independence should not protect a judge rom investigation and censure or a valid charge. The country remembers (ustice &hah or his orders in the 9elhi high court decriminaliIing Bunnatural sexual o ences’ under &ection <AA o 4P' and ruling that the o ice o the 'hie (ustice o 4ndia too was amenable to the :T4 )ct. =ut, 'hennai remembers the no% nonsense jurist or being instrumental in the removal o giant hoardings in the city. &itting with (ustice > 'handru, he 7uashed the political exemption granted to unauthorised buildings in the city, and it was because o his orders that many public buildings today o er a barrier% ree environment to disabled people. On Thursday, (ustice &hah spo!e on judicial accountability, servility, corruption, judicial independence and the need to usher in a transparent process to select judges. "amenting the Bdemocratic de icit’ in the way judges are chosen on the basis o undisclosed criteria and circumstances, (ustice &hah said: 5The present system o judicial appointments in the constitutional courts exempli ies the misalignment between the core values o judicial independence and accountability.6 ,e discussed the U& and the U> model o appointing judges, but said a hybrid model where a judicial appointment commission short%listing the names, which could be rejected only on speci ic reasons, was most suitable or 4ndia. &lamming the (udicial &tandards and )ccountability =ill *232, he said involving 1Ps in the procedure would undermine the judicial independence. 54 implemented in the present orm, the =ill would mar! the beginning o the end o the judiciary,6 he said.

8ho 8ill (udge the (U9#-& K

1r.)rvind >ejriwal L 1r.8inston 'hurchill are )lmost :4#,T M 'riminals have entered 4ndian Parliament % "egislate "O>P)" =ill

8ith whole hearted respects to the parliament L all constitutional bodies , hereby we are appealing to the honest ew in public service , honest ew in parliament , honest ew in judiciary L honest ew in police , to legally prosecute their corrupt colleagues , to legislate 5 "O>P)" =4""6 with ull powers to en orce accountability o all public servants , 1Ps , 1")s , Police , etc to the citiIens o india. 'ontempt o Parliament L other constitutional bodies is being made by some o the 'orrupt 1Ps themselves. Therby these 1Ps are ma!ing contempt o 4ndian Parliament , 32+ crore 4ndian citiIens ,

'onstitution o 4ndia and Obstructing the 4ndian 'itiIens rom per orming their HU@9)1-@T)" 9UT4-& to uphold constituion o india , it’s dignity. These 'orrupt Public &ervants are doing more damges to 4ndia’s @ational Unity L 4ntegrity than naxals L terrorists . These 'orrupt Public &ervants are more deadlier L greater threat to india than Pa!istan L 'hina. The honest ew in parliament L other constitutional bodies are either !eeping mum or not ta!ing appropriate steps to intiate criminal legal prosecution against their corrupt colleagues , this is aiding those criminals to do more crimes , to go unpunished , to manipulate legal system , to manipulate evidences $ records , to get ac7uitted by courts or lac! o evidences , to in luence police to withdraw cases against them or to ile = reports , etc. 4n these ways the corrupt public servants will never be convicted , they will be either stay as accussed or ac7uitted or lac! o evidences or government withdraws cases against them or police ile = report.

'itiIens o india are supreme in democratic republic o india. parliament , 1Ps , 1")s are creations o citiIens and are subservient , subordinate to the citiIens o india. 'reations cann’t be supreme than the creator.

Eohra committee has o icially ac!nowledged the criminaliIation o politics , parliament , legislatures. The politicians crave or power because , while in power investigating $ prosecuting agencies will be under their control $ in luence and they can manipulate the legal process , 8,4T- 8)&,4@# all their crimes. (ust see , recently union home minister 1r.'hidambaram in luencing the delhi police or closing a cheating case against a builder by orcing the police to ile 5=6 report. :ecent example read vijaya !arnata!a !annada daily dated 30.20.*23* lo!ayu!ta police avoring ex%'1 Dediyurappa L 1inister &omanna tried to close a case be ore lo!ayu!ta court by iling = :eport although enough evidences are there to prosecute -x '1 L 1inister . Politicians stoop low to such levels , to ma!e money -x : irregularities in purchase o co ins meant or !argil martyrs , allotment o lats meant or war widows , war veterans at 1umbai. 4 proper accountability o public servants is legally enacted, independence , autonomy o judiciary L police is legally enacted , then those in power cann’t 8,4T- 8)&, their own crimes. That is the reason many political parties are opposing 5"O>P)" =4""6 since decades under many pretexts. &ubject to conditions , 4 do o er my services to the government o india L supreme court o india , to legally apprehend ':414@)"& , 'O::UPT PU="4' &-:E)@T& , ):- DOU :-)9D to utiliIe our services K

HU@9)1-@T)" :4#,T& OH '4T4N-@& Es P:4E4"-#-& OH 'O@&T4TUT4O@)" HU@'T4O@):4-& 4@ 4@94)

"et the "egislators o states, members o parliament, ,igh courts L &upreme 'ourt (udges L other constitutional unctionaries answer the ollowing 7uestions which are vital in a democracy. 3/ 8hat are the undamental rights o a citiIen guaranteed under the constitution .)rticle *3/ K */ 8hat are the privileges con erred on legislators L parliamentarians by the constitution o 4ndiaK a/ 4nside the ,ouse b/ Outside the ,ouse </ 8hat are privileges con erred on constitutional unctionaries, li!e a/ President o 4ndia b/ Prime 1inister o 4ndia c/ 'hie (ustice o 4ndia d/ 'hairman o @,:' e/ 'entral Eigilance 'ommissioners. 0/ )re the privileges legal immunity con erred on above mentioned constitutional unctionaries K a/ 'over all their o icial actions irrespective o merit. b/ 'over both their o icial L personal actions. +/ )re the privileges de ined L codi ied K ?/ )re these privileges above reedom o the press K A/ )re the liberty L undamental rights o the citiIens guaranteed by the constitution, above the privileges o the constitutional unctionaries or e7ual or below K C/ 'an the 4ndian legislatures L parliament be e7uated to the ,ouse o commons in -ngland which is considered to be a superior court and court o records K O/ 'an the division o powers, namely the legislature, the executive and the (udiciary, be e7uated to the unctioning o the ,ouse o commons and ,ouse o "ords in -ngland K 32/ 'an a citiIen be said to have committed breach o privilege o the ,ouse or court and causing contempt o the house or court by raising the issues o accountability o constitutional unctionaries K 33/ 'an a "egislature or Parliament enact a new law, to circumvent or to nulli y the (udicial orders with respect to wrongdoings by peoples representatives L executive K does not it amount to in ringement o (udicial powers L contempt o the court by the ,ouse. 3*/ )re the HU@9)1-@T)" 9UT4-& o a citiIen more important than constitutional duties o a constitutional unctionary or e7ual in importance to it K

3</ 'an a constitutional unctionary commit crimes, anti%national activities in the name o constitutional duties, behind the legal veil o o icial’s secret act L go unaccountable or his actions and go unpunished by his legal immunity privileges K 30/ )re the "egislators members o parliament, ,igh court L &upreme court (udges and other constitutional unctionaries not willing to codi y their privileges or the reason that i codi ied their privileges would be curtailed and their action would be subjected to legal scrutiny. K 3+/ =y votes o citiIens "egislators and parliamentarians get seats in the legislature and Parliament out o tax payer’s money, they get their pay, per!s L lead +%&tar luxurious li estyles. ,ence whether a vote o a citiIen is above .1ore valid/ or a seat o legislator or parliamentarian is above or more valid in a democracy K 3?/ (udges L 'onstitutional unctionaries are indirectly appointed by voters $ tax payers. Out o tax payers money, they get their pay, per!s L lead +%star luxurious li estyles. ,ence, whether the vote o a citiIen, undamental duties o a tax payer is above .more valid/ or a seat o judge $ constitutional unctionary is above .more valid/ in a democracy K 3A/ 4 there is a vacuum in the "egislature or parliament, who is to ill up that vacuum till such time that the legislature or parliament acts provide a solution by per orming its role by enacting proper legislation to cover the ield .vacuum/ K 3C/ 8hile it is an unhealthy practice or a (udge to claim to be a (udge in his own cause, is it not worse or the members o the legislature and parliament to be judges in their own cause K 3O/ )re the Technicalities o the case more important to a judge or (ustice to a citiIen, protection o undamental rights o citiIen.K *2/ 8hy not the constitutional unctionaries initiate suo moto action with respect to numerous cases o injustices reported in 1edia K *3/ 8hy not the (udges admit various cases o 4njustices a ecting public, as the Public 4nterest "itigation6 K 4n some cases, the Public or the person representing them is unable to a ord the high cost o the case. 8hy not ree legal aid is given K. **/ 8hat is the criteria or admitting a P.4.". L giving ree legal aid K *</ 'ommunication M ree low o in ormation is the li eline o a democracy. 8hy the constitutional unctionaries are not honouring the :ight to 4n ormation o 'itiIens K

&tage set or arrest o suspended )ndhra '=4 judge

The stage was &aturday set or the arrest o suspended 'entral =ureau o 4nvestigation .'=4/ judge in a cash% or%bail scam which has sent shoc! waves among the judiciary across the state.

) ter receiving a nod rom )ndhra Pradesh ,igh 'ourt to register a case, the '=4 may arrest any time Hirst )dditional '=4 (udge T. Pattabhirama :ao on charges o ta!ing bribe to grant bail to ormer >arnata!a minister #ali (anardhana :eddy in an illegal mining case, sources here said. '=4 sources said the investigative agency would register a irst in ormation report be ore carrying out the arrests. )n )ndhra Pradesh cabinet minister, two >arnata!a legislators, a retired judge, a rowdy sheeter and the suspended judge’s son are also believed to have played a role in stri!ing the deal. The exact deal amount remained a mystery but it is believed to be anywhere between :s.+ crore and :s.3+ crore. The judge allegedly demanded :s.3+ crore but the deal was inally struc! or :s.32 crore. ,e allegedly received :s.< crore as advance be ore granting bail to :eddy 1ay 33 in the Obulapuram 1ining 'ompany .O1'/ case. The '=4 Hriday recovered part o the amount rom ban! loc!ers belonging to the judge’s son. The '=4, which grew suspicious o the judge’s action, started investigations a ter a go% ahead rom high court 'hie (ustice 1adan =. "o!ur. The investigators tapped the judge’s phone and 7uestioned him, his son and others. The chie justice was in ormed o the preliminary investigations and, based on this, he suspended the judge late Thursday. (anardhana :eddy’s amily allegedly approached the judge through Dadagiri, a rowdy sheeter o @acharam area in ,yderabad, who then got in touch with a retired judge. ) state minister is also suspected to have helped in the deal. (anardhana :eddy’s brother and >arnata!a legislator #. &omase!hara :eddy allegedly met the middlemen in a hotel in ,yderabad to inally stri!e the deal. The accused’s brother allegedly handed over the money, brought rom =ellary town in >arnata!a. 9espite Pattabhirama granting the bail, the mining baron remained in =angalore jail, where he is lodged in another illegal mining case. On a petition by the '=4, the high court later stayed the bail. The mining baron was arrested by the '=4 rom =ellary &ep + last year in a case o illegal mining in )nantapur district o )ndhra Pradesh.

(udge suspension: '=4 claims :s.3.C2 crore recovererd rom loc!er

The '=4 claims to have recovered nearly :s. 3.C2 crore here rom a ban! loc!er, the !eys o which were allegedly in possession o the son o &pecial '=4 court judge T. Pattabhiramaa :ao, who has been suspended on charges o bribery and corruption by the )ndhra Pradesh ,igh 'ourt. The agency had carried the search based on a source based input that a deal was allegedly struc! between :ao and ormer >arnata!a 1inister #. (anardhana :eddy or granting bail to the latter in the illegal mining case, '=4 sources said today. =e ore proceeding with the search, the '=4 o icials too! 'hie (ustice o )ndhra Pradesh ,igh 'ourt in con idence and apprised him about the input received by them, they said. ) ter getting a green signal rom the 'hie (ustice, a '=4 team got the loc!er opened and recovered nearly :s. 3.C2 crore rom it which the agency suspects belonged to :eddy and was allegedly given as illegal grati ication, they said. :elated )rticles P P P P P 'ourt awards jail term to =(P 1") in >arnata!a &ome ministers may scrape thru disputed #Os 'ourt tells '=4 to deposit #ali’s :s. 0.*cr Opposition demands action against #ali, tainted judge Pattabhi ixed bail deal or :s.3+ crore

:elated 4mages altQ6http:$$www.asianage.com$sites$de ault$ i altQ6http:$$www.asianage.com$sites$de ault les$images$prot.jpg.cropRdisplay.relatedRima $ iles$images$patt.jpg.cropRdisplay.relatedRi ges.jpg6 u*:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*+″ mages.jpg6 u*:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*?″ v:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*+″S borderQ2 v:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*?″S altQ6http:$$www.asianage.com$sites$de ault$ i altQ6http:$$www.asianage.com$sites$de ault les$images$jagancR3.jpg.cropRdisplay.relatedR $ iles$images$justiceR<.jpg.cropRdisplay%.jpg .cropRdisplay.relatedRimages.jpg6 images.jpg6 u*:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*A″ u*:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*C″ borderQ2 v:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*A″S v:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32*C″S The sources claimed that the o icials ound the !eys o the loc!ers to be in possession o (udge’s son.

The matter was again put be ore the 'hie (ustice who ordered suspension o :ao, they said. &enior o icials o the agency said there are three options M the case is probed by local police, '=4 iles a new H4: or adding the charges in the ongoing trial against :eddy. They however added that any urther action could ta!e place only a ter getting permission rom the ,igh 'ourt. 5Hirst )dditional &pecial (udge or '=4 cases Pattabhirama :ao has been placed under suspension a ter the ,igh 'ourt considered the in ormation it received against the judge in Bpublic interest’, the ,igh 'ourt :egistrar said in a release. 4ncidentally, the judge had granted bail to ormer >arnata!a 1inister #ali (anardhan :eddy in the O1' illegal mining case last month while he had rejected bail to 4)& o icer D. &rila!shmi, another accused in the O1' scam.

The need or a (udges )ccountability =ill =y Eic!y @anjappa

O late there is a lot o tal! regarding the necessity to have a (udges )ccountability =ill. -ven when the "o!pal =ill was being debated the inclusion o judges into this bill was strongly opposed by the government despite members o the civil society urging the government to ma!e such an inclusion. O late there have been reports galore regarding judges being o ered sites or houses under the discretionary 7uota o the 'hie 1inister. :ecently there was an expose at the Orissa ,igh 'ourt. Prior to this there were reports rom >arnata!a and also another report which spo!e about how the @arendra 1odi government had o ered prime lands to judges o the ,igh 'ourt. The big 7uestion is whether judges deserve such treatment rom the state government considering the act that the government is the biggest litigant be ore any court in the countryK 4s this an illegality or is it corruptionK (ustice &anthosh ,egde, ormer judge o the &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia says it is illegal to accept sites under the discretionary 7uota. (udges ought to !now that while accepting such sites they are succumbing to temptation. They have to examine any such o er and ind out properly whether it is in accordance with law or not. 4t is very dangerous to accept such avours since in the days to come it would hold against themselves. &pea!ing o a judges accountability bill, well there is one but it has not come out as yet. This has been loitering around or some years now and it is time that something is done about it. 4n act while we were discussing the "o!pal bill this was one o the primary contentions during the debate. -ither the government had to include it into the "o!pal =ill or ma!e unctional the judges accountability bill. ,owever there was a lot o misunderstanding regarding this. )ll 4 said was it was not right to leave out the judges when we are ighting corruption. They should include this portion into the "o!pal bill.

,owever once the (udges )ccountability =ill is made unctional then it could be deleted out o the "o!pal bill. There was no need to !eep this in abeyance until that happened. 8hen this issue is being argued and ought or the past 00 years then it is impertive or the government to include it. &enior )dvocate in the >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt, @av!esh =atra is o the view that ta!ing sites under the discretionary 7uota is nothing but corruption. Hirst and oremost (udges are not entitled or a site under this 7uota. This 7uota is meant or poor people, outstanding people including judges. 4t cannot be given as a bul allotment as it amounts to nothing but a sop. 8hen the government is the biggest litigant be ore any court in 4ndia then such a sop does not instill con idence in the public and it would be better i both the government and the judiciary abstains rom such an act. ,ere 4 would li!e to 7uote the incident involving the great (ustice : ) (agirdhar o the =ombay ,igh 'ourt. 4n act he was the only judge who re used to apply or a site despite a re7uest by the then 'hie 1inister o 1aharashtra. ,e even went one step urther and at a public unction when the '1 sought to sha!e his hand he publicly rebu!ed him by saying, 6 1r '1 your cases are pending be ore the high court. )s a high court judge 4 re use to sha!e your hand.6 http:$$vic!ynanjapa.wordpress.com$*233$33$2C$the%need% or%a%judges%accountability%bill$

")@9 &')1 4@ T)14"@)9U One or my o icer, one or my boyT

Land and property are coveted assets. So why are chief ministers allowed to give these away as favours? JEEMON JA O! trac"s how #amil Nadu hief Minister M $arunanidhi has %een using his &uotas 4@ @OE-1=-:, 'hie 1inister o >arnata!a =& Deddyurappa almost lost his job, due to the uproar over pre erential allotment o land and property to his sons and close associates. ,e has since cancelled the allotments, as!ed his children to move out o his o icial residence, and retained his seat through some de t political manoeuvring and muscle% lexing. )t the height o the campaign against him, as political opponents paraded on apparent moral high ground, 4""U&T:)T4O@: )@)@9 T-,-">) published details o plots similarly allotted by previous >arnata!a chie ministers, both o the 'ongress and @)O:-1 the (9.&/, to relatives, servants, drivers, maids and partymen .")@9 &')1 *.2, 0 9ecember/. The purpose was not to ma!e Deddyurappa’s wrongdoings loo! less shoc!ing, but to show that the problem was endemic and needed rooting out. The right given to chie ministers to hand out public land to a avoured ew U relatives, bureaucrats, judges, police o icers and others U smac!s o nepotism and arbitrary eudal power structures that should have no place in a modern democracy. .Though there is no immediate proo o this, some o these allotments could also be %enamitransactions, in which the ultimate ownership remains with the distributor o the largesse, camou laged by a stac! o a!e documents./ This power U euphemistically called 5discretionary 7uota6 U has even been used to avour allegedly corrupt army o icers li!e #eneral 9eepa! >apoor .)T -)&- 84T,

#:-)&-, T-,-">), *2 @ovember/, who was given a large +22 s7 yd plot in ,aryana by the ,ooda government, which then aced the embarrassment o re using him permission to sell it o be ore ive years had elapsed, as per rules. The plot was given to him by the government as pre erential allotment in recognition or his Boutstanding achievement’. This wee!, continuing its campaign against out%o %turn allotments o land and property, T-,-">) has an exposV on Tamil @adu 'hie 1inister 1 >arunanidhi. The Tamil @adu ,ousing =oard .T@,=/ which commands a large land ban!, has a government discretionary 7uota .#9W/ under which 3+ percent o all allotments can be recommended by the '1. -ligibility or allotment under #9W is as ollows: single$deserted women; widows; social wor!ers; physically handicapped persons; de ence personnel; ex%servicemen; eminent persons in the ield o science, arts, literature, economics, public administration and sports; reedom ighters; government servants with unblemished service records; employees o P&Us, central government underta!ings and nationalised ban!s; PH institutions; journalists; university sta ; and employees o local bodies and municipalities. 8hile some o these categories sound !osher, most o them raise a undamental 7uestion: why should the government have the power to give coveted land to select employees and journalists over othersK The only rationale could be proximity U which is an untenable reason or being the bene iciary o political avours, o ten worth several crores. &etting this aside, even within the legal ambit o the #9W, T-,-">)’s investigation shows that many o the allotments in >arunanidhi’s tenure have violated the rule boo!. 1any bureaucrats and their relatives have been given plots or lats under the category o 5social wor!er6. &ome o these last did social wor! when they were in college; many o them claim to be volunteers in such routine activity as helping in blood donation or eye camps. 1any have issued certi icates to themselves; some have ac7uired letters rom the "ions and :otary 'lubs with vague endorsements. 4n other violations, the rules say that no one who has any other land or property in Tamil @adu or any other capital city, in either their own or spouse or minor children’s name, can apply or #9W allotments. T-,-">) ound this is routinely violated. The other braIen violation lies in the claim o 5unblemished6 service records as a 1any o the allottees issued certi icates to themselves, while some got letters rom "ions and :otary 'lubs 7uali ication or allotment. 8hen :T4 activist E #opala!rishnan sought a list o such bureaucrats, )dditional &ecretary & &olomon :aj said, 5)s no unblemished government servant certi icates are issued, the 7uestion o urnishing a list o names does not arise.6 The additional secretary also clari ied that the home department didn’t have such a list. This is the phantom category under which many public servants li!e (a ar &ait, 3OC? batch 4P& o icer, now 4nspector #eneral o PoliceM4ntelligence, got large allotments o land in prime locations. 8hy them more than hundreds o othersK That’s a democratic 7uestion the chie minister will have to answer. jeeTXgmail.com

"egal "argesse : =hanumathi &erving (udge, 1adras ,igh 'ourt H")T @O&: 14# *0O%*+2, &,O"4@#)@)""U: P,)&- 444, ',-@@)4 9)T-: <2 1):', *22C &4N-: 3*2 &W 1 L 3<O &W 1 P:4'-: :s. *A.++ ")>, L :s. <2.2+ ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: @) E4O")T4O@& The judge was allotted two adjoining plots on the same day .<2 1arch *22C/. )ccording to her 9isclosure o )ssets statement o *22O, the judge already had a house in her name, and another plot in her husband, advocate > #anesan’s name. The house, in the Uthangarai area o >rishnagiri district, was constructed in 3OC+ on a plot purchased in 3OC*. The plot o land is located in &aidapet and was purchased in 3OO<. &he however admits in her declaration that she owns two plots, which she purchased rom the T@ ,ousing =oard in *22C. =ut this allocation was made under the #eneral 'ategory. &ince judges do not come under any o the 7uota categories, the government’s way o allotting land to them di ers rom the rest. (udges are in ormed about the availability o land. )nd when they apply or the same, the government acilitates the allotment. > :aviraja Pandian :etired (ustice, 1adras ,igh 'ourt P"OT @O: =*$+, T,4:UE)@14DU: -YT-@&4O@ 9)T-: 33 @OE-1=-: *22O &4N-: <,33A &W HT P:4'-: :s. ?C.+0 ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. <.* ':O:E4O")T4O@& 'lose relative o 91> supremo >arunanidhi and the 'hairman o the &chool Hee 9etermination 'ommittee. "ittle wonder then he was also the recipient o special avours while he was still a serving judge. )t the time o the allotment, the judge owned a +2 percent share in an ancestral house at ThiruveeIhimiIhalai village. The judge had also sold a property he owned at PaIhavatthan!attali village near >umba!onam. The land was purchased in 3OO3, a house was constructed on it in 3OO* and sold in *22O. ,e had also sold the landed property o his wi e in *22O. E )mbi!a )dvocate P"OT @O: )C, >)9)P-:D, 1)9,U:)@T,)#)1 9)T-: 3? H-=:U):D *22C &4N-: *,*C+ &W HT

P:4'-: :s. 0.+0 ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. 3+ ")>, E4O")T4O@& The advocate owned landed property in more than one location when she was allotted the plot U one vacant house site in >aranai Puducheri village and another in >atrampa!!am village, in >ancheepuram district. ,er husband, (ustice 1 &atyanarayanan o the 1adras ,igh 'ourt, in his 9isclosure o )ssets, stated that he owns a repurchased 14# lat constructed in 3O?O at 4ndra @agar in 'hennai. )mbi!a was allotted land under the #9W. =ureaucratic =onanIa (a ar &ait 4#P%4ntelligence H")T @O&: +02, T,4:UE)@14DU:, >)1):)( @)#): 9)T-: *< )P:4" *22C &4N-: 0,A+? &W HT P:4'-: :s. 3.*? ':O:'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. ? ':O:E4O")T4O@& )llotted under Bunblemished’ government servant category. On ? (une *22C, the government trans erred the ownership o the plot to his daughter (enni er (a ar, then a student. (enni er made two payments o :s. 0?.2< la!h and :s.3.A< la!h towards cost o the plot. 4n Hebruary *22O, she paid another :s.?2 la!h. ) ter having paid :s.3.2A crore, the ownership o plot was trans erred to her mother Parvin (a ar. 4nterestingly, Parvin also made the payment all over again. 4n October *22O, she paid :s. +2.?0 la!h and then again in @ovember *22O, another :s. *+ la!h was deposited. ) urther payment o :s. +3.+ la!h in the same month was made. 4ncome tax o icials eel the &ait amily made the double payment to avoid an 4T investigation on (enni er, who would not have been able to show any source o income. The Tamil @adu ,ousing =oard then returned the original amount paid by (enni er. @ow, Parvin in collaboration with 9urga &an!ar, son o an 4)& o icer, has commissioned a builder to construct a multi%storey complex in which 3* lats have already been built. -ach lat is expected to etch an estimated 3 crore. &o, by paying :s. 3.*? crore in *22O, the 4#P’s amily made a pro it o more than :s. +.A crore. # Pra!ash (oint &ecretary, 4ndustries P"OT @O: &?, T,4:UE)@14DU: -YT-@&4O@ 9)T-: ? 1)D *22C &4N-: <,C*O &W HT P:4'-: :s. A?.+C ")>,

'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. 0 ':O:E4O")T4O@& The ormer district collector o Tirunelveli issued himsel a certi icate or unblemished government service. '> #ariyali :etired 4)&, &ecretary to #overnor at the time o allotment H")T @O&: &0, T,4:UE)@14DU: -YT-@&4O@ 9)T-: A 1)D *22C &4N-: ?,2*< &W HT P:4'-: :s. 3.*2 ':O:-. P)D1-@T 8)& 1)9- 4@ << 4@&T)"1-@T& H:O1 3C (U"D *22C TO ? 1):', *22O 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. ?.C ':O:- .)PP:OY/ E4O")T4O@& ,er husband 9r & :aja!umar has a house in 'hennai. &umathi :avichandran Hormer :egional Passport O icer, 'hennai, and close relative o 91> minister > )nbaIhagan P"OT @O: 32+2 ,4#, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: *C 1):', *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. +O.3+ ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. 3 ':O:E4O")T4O@& ,er husband 9r & :avichandran owns a plot. Hollowing an :T4 probe, the T@,= issued a show%cause notice and placed the allotment under suspension. Political Per!s " #aneshan Hormer 1P, who le t Eai!o to join 91> H")T @O&: 32+* ,4#, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: *A 1):', *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. AO.C? ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: @) E4O")T4O@& #aneshan is a trade union leader with the 91> and is close to >arunanidhi. ,e owns property in his as well as his wi e’s name. =rinda @eduncheIhiyan 8i e o late 'heIhiyan and daughter%in%law o )griculture 1inister Eeerapandi )rumugam

P"OT @O: ,4# = <$30, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: 3< 1):', *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. O.C* ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. 0+%+2 ")>, E4O")T4O@& )llotted lat under &ocial wor!er category. The tehsildar o &alem issued her a certi icate though he is not empowered to. The certi icate says she 5is a well%!nown social wor!er involved in social wel are activities such as president o Poolavari village panchayat, head o parent%teachers association, participating in educational programmes o many schools6. & :ajala!shmi 8i e o : &a!!arapani, 1") and 91> chie whip P"OT @O: 320A, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: O 1):', *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. AO.C? ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. <.+ ':O:E4O")T4O@& &he was allotted the lat under the &ocial 8or!er category. The supporting document was a letter rom a :otary 'lub. The letter rom P@> Een!atachalapathy, president o the :otary 'lub o Oddachatram, dated <3 1arch *22C, states that 5she is !nown to me as a social wor!er who is participating in social service activities o our :otary 'lub at blood donation camps, ree health chec!up camps and other wel are activities. &he has also been helping in providing several other basic amenities or the people surrounding the slum area or the past several years. 4 wish her every success to do more services to needy people in and around the area6. 9 Dasodha 'ongress 1"), >ancheepuram 'ongress 1"), >ancheepuram H")T @O&: )+, ,4#, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: 3O 9-'-1=-: *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. +O.+? ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. < ':O:E4O")T4O@& ) certi icate rom the 'hennai 1unicipal 'ouncillor stating she has been an active social wor!er or the past 02 years actively involved in helping the poor in the area. Poochi 1urugan 1ember o a 91> trade union

P"OT @O: ) 33, T,4:UE)@14DU: -YT-@&4O@ 9)T-: ? (U@- *22C &4N-: *,0** &W HT P:4'-: :s. +C.?3 ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. *.A+ ':O:E4O")T4O@& Though a member o a 91> trade union, he was allotted land under the &ocial 8or!er category. ,as three plots in his name and one in his spouse’s name. ,e has not produced any supporting document about the social wor! he has done. =harati Thennarasu 8idow o &ivagangai politician Thennarasu H")T @O&: &A, T,4:UE)@14DU: -YT@ 9)T-: *? )U#U&T *22C &4N-: <,CAO &W HT P:4'-: :s. AO.3< ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. <.A+ ':O:E4O")T4O@& &he was allotted the plot under the &ocial 8or!er category. )n :T4 application revealed that she had not been engaged in any !ind o social wor! that would ma!e her eligible or this category. P 1oorthy 1adurai 1") H")T @O&: -*$?, 14#, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: + 9-'-1=-: *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. A*.+ ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. 0 ':O:E4O")T4O@& )llotted under the &ocial 8or!er category on a certi icate issued by the "ions 'lub. Owns several plots in his and his wi e’s name. @ &oorya 9aughter o =rinda 'heIhiyan and grand%daughter o )griculture 1inister Eeerapandi )rumugam H")T @O&: =<$3<, ,4#, 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: < (U@- *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. C.OO ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. 0+%+2 ")>, E4O")T4O@& "i!e her mother, the *2%year%old was given a certi icate o social wor! and domicile by the tehsildar o &alem, stating that she 5is a

well!nown social wor!er who is involved in many social wel are activities, such as national social service, participating in eye camp, blood donation and giving education to poor students6. The certi icate was issued on *A Hebruary *22C, the same day her mother got one. =oth got adjoining lats. >ith and >in 9eepa 9aughter o 9evaraj 1, Private &ecretary to the 'hie 1inister H")T @O&: +0<, T,4:UE)@14DU:, >)1):)( @)#): .P"OT )9(O4@4@# &)4T’& )@9 &,)@>):’&/ 9)T-: *< 1)D *22C &4N-: 0,0?? &W HT P:4'-: :s. 3.2C ':O:'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: @) E4O")T4O@& )llotted plot under the &ocial 8or!er category but there’s no evidence to bac! it. 'onstructing a three%storey building involving a cost beyond the amily’s !nown sources o income. ,er husband owns another property in his name. ,er plot is adjacent to the plots o 4#P% 4ntelligence (a ar &ait and 9urga &han!ar, son o the '1’s secretary. @aveen!umar &on o P 1uthuveeran, 4)&, who was 9istrict 'ollector, Theni, and close to the 'hie 1inister H")T @O&: +03, ,4#, T,4:UE)@14DU:, >)1):)( @)#): 9)T-: *A (U"D *22C &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. 3.2? ':O:'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: @) E4O")T4O@& )llotted lat under the &ocial 8or!er category. ,e wor!s in a so tware company in 'hennai and submitted a salary slip o :s. *2,222 per month at the time o allotment. @ow, he is constructing a ourstorey structure on the plot. ( @aveen 4brahim &on o &4 (a ar )li, 4P& .retd/ H")T @O&: )4 ,4# 1O#)PP)4: 9)T-: <3 1):', *22O &4N-: @) P:4'-: :s. ?0.O+ ")>, 'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: :s. <.*+ ':O:E4O")T4O@& )llotted lat under the &ocial 8or!er category. 'erti icate issued

relates to 3OC<, when he was a student. The college principal says he actively participated in 5many social activities conducted by us. ,e continues to evince interest in social service activities6. 'uriously, the -14 o :s. A0,222 is almost double his monthly salary. 9urga &an!ar &on o :ajamani!!am, 4)&, &ecretary to 'hie 1inister H")T @O&: +<C, T,4:UE)@14DU:, >)1):)( @)#): .P"OT )9(O4@4@# &)4T’& )@9 &,)@>):’&/ 9)T-: *C 1):', *22C &4N-: *,0+2 &W HT P:4'-: :s. 3.3* ':O:'U::-@T 1):>-T P:4'-: @) E4O")T4O@& ,e is a businessman, but allotted the plot under the &ocial 8or!er category. ,e also submitted an a idavit that the plot would be used or residential purposes. =ut he violated the conditions and developed the property or commercial purposes. The Others 1 4lamu!il 4T 1anager, 91> ,W, 'hennai E4O")T4O@& )llotted lat under the &ocial 8or!er category on a certi icate issued by the "ions 'lub. The certi icate states that he 5is participating in social service activities o "ions 'lub at blood donation camp, ree health camps or the past several years6. 4lanthendral 4lamu!il’s sister E4O")T4O@& )llotted ,4# lat under the &ocial 8or!er category on the basis o a certi icate issued by a panchayat, which is not valid. @ >annabiran (unior attendant at the &upreme 'ourt E4O")T4O@& )llotted lat under the &ocial 8or!er category. >annabiran, a 9elhi resident, was issued a salary certi icate by the &' registrar or purchasing land in Tamil @adu. ,e was allotted on the recommendation o his superior, who has close lin!s with the 91>. ' #aneshan and ' Einothan P&Os, '1’s &ecurity E4O")T4O@& )llotted lats under the Bunblemished’ government servants category.

9ocuments reveal the &uperintendent o Police, &ecurity =ranch, 'hennai, issued vague conduct certi icates a ter the duo were allotted the lats provisionally. P 1eena 8$O P Pandian, P&O, '1’s &ecurity E4O")T4O@& )llotted lat under the &ocial 8or!er category. &he produced a letter rom 1& Eelu o the "ions 'lub, who liberally issued certi icates or sons and daughters o bureaucrats to help them avail o prime plots allotted by the T@ ,ousing =oard out o the government discretionary 7uota. P,OTO&: T,- ,4@9U, (--1O@ ()'O= :eactions to "and &cam <.2 9 Dashoda, 'ongress 1"), >ancheepuram 54 have done a lot o wor! or 9alits throughout Tamil @adu, especially in &riperumbudur and 'hennai. 4 have helped them in getting pattas or their land, recommending their names or loans rom ban!s, distributing cycles to 9alits on the birthdays o (awaharlal @ehru and 4ndira #andhi.6 (a ar &ait, 4P&, 4#%4ntelligence 5#overnment agencies have already probed the matter. 4 am being governed by the conduct rules, so 4 should not tal! to you about the issue. 4t is advisable that you see! a response rom the Tamil @adu government. 4 would li!e to add that i any de amation or liability arises out o your article, necessary legal action would be ta!en.6 P 1oorthy, 1adurai 1") 54 don’t !now much about the certi icate, 4 thin! 4 got the plot because 4’m an 1"). 4 have done a lot o wor! in upli ting the people in villages o my constituency. That amounts to social wor!. 4 don’t need a social wor! certi icate rom the "ions 'lub but my riends, partners and 4 too! the certi icate anyway. 5

B#9W is a way o ma!ing you part o the syndicate’ =D (--1O@ ()'O=

)3OO2 batch 4)& o icer, ' Umashan!er shot to ame during the )4)91> regime when he exposed a scam in the construction o sheds in a cremation ground under the (awahar :oIgar Dojana when he was additional collector in 1adurai. ,is brush with )4)91> supremo ( (ayalalithaa’s partymen resulted in his trans er out o the district.

' Umashan!er P,OTO: (--1O@ ()'O=

"ater, when the 91> came to power, he was appointed managing director o the state% run -lectronic 'orporation o Tamil @adu and put in charge o procuring colour television sets or ree distribution to the poor in the state, in !eeping with an election promise o the 91>. ,e was trans erred with immediate e ect a ter he exposed corporate raud committed by the joint venture promoter -"@-T Technologies "td. "ater, he was posted as managing director o the state%run )rasu 'able TE 'orporation. 4n this capacity, he opposed the monopoly o &umangali 'orporation run by >alanidhi 1aran. ,e also too! steps to nationalise &umangali 'able Eision. =y that time, 1aran had a patch%up with the >arunanidhi amily and Umashan!er was trans erred with immediate e ect. "ater, the anti%corruption and vigilance department registered a case against him or Plots are allotted even without any ormal applications. There is no transparency at all disproportionate assets. The government suspended him or claiming a!e caste certi icate as a 9alit when he is a practising 'hristian. ,e lodged a complaint with the @ational =ac!ward 'ommission against his suspension and got a avourable order rom the ,igh 'ourt. )t present, he is managing director o Tamil @adu &mall 4ndustries 'orporation. Umashan!er was allotted a plot .under government order *9 <*+/ on < )pril *22C at Thiruvanmiyur -xtension when he was in charge o the ree colour television or the poor programme. Hor this, he would have had to pay ++.3* la!h. ,e wrote to the chie minister that he could not a ord to pay such a huge amount. "ater, his allotment was cancelled without stating any reason. Umashan!er revealed he had an 14# lat in his name when the plot was allotted and he was not aware about the rule o Tamil @adu ,ousing =oard .T@,=/ that he can’t claim a plot when he has another lat in his name. 4t certainly seems commendable that Umashan!er turned down a chance to own a plot in Thiruvanmiyur -xtension, one o the poshest areas o the city. The plot is just <22 metres rom the beach. Though the entire colony has been parcelled out to those close to the ruling establishment, it is the nouveau riche and the industrialists who dream o owning a

house in Thiruvanmiyur, where they can rub shoulders with ormer judges, bureaucrats and political power bro!ers. 4 and when the allottees decide to sell their plots, they can demand extremely high prices. 4n a ran! chat, Umashan!er tal!s about how the government discretionary 7uota has been misused. -xcerpts: 8hy are bureaucrats, judges, ormer judges and politicians given housing plots in posh localities under government discretionary 7uotaK 8ho can re use a good piece o land in 'hennai cityK 4t’s a way o rewarding people or good wor! done. @o in7uiry has been conducted in this matter so ar. 9iscretionary 7uota is the prerogative o the government. ) ter :T4 came into existence, several activists are ta!ing up the matter in court. =asically, there is no control mechanism or chec!s and balances. There is little transparency while awarding the #9W U the plots are allotted without ormal applications. Dou were also allotted a plot in *22C under the Bunblemished government servant’ category. 8hat happened to the allotmentK Des, 4 was allotted a plot in Thiruvanmiyur -xtension. 4nitial payment or the plot was :s. *+ la!h. 4 never had that much money. &o 4 re7uested the government to reduce the price. =ut there was no response. 4 did not want a house to compromise my integrity. &o 4 never too! possession. "ater, in *22O, the government ordered a vigilance in7uiry against me and cancelled the allotment. Hran!ly, 4 was not aware about the T@,= rules that bars a person having a plot, a lat or a house rom claiming another plot. 9o you thin! the #9W 7uota is a way o silencing people, buying them outK Des, it is a way o ma!ing you a part o the syndicate. Plots or lats are given to those civil servants, judges or relatives o the bureaucrats or politicians or complying with certain re7uirements. There is no procedure or 4)& or 4P& o icers to get a land or plot or lat in a transparent manner. &o everybody uses short cuts.

1inister’s 9W proves judges are more corrupt than civil servant

@-8 9-",4$=,U=)@-&8):: )n investigation by 'obra post and 4=@ @etwor! has revealed how ormer and sitting judges o Orissa, police o icers and bureaucrats have received lats rom the 9iscretionaryWuota .9W/ o ministers. )s a matter o act, successive Urban 9evelopment 1inisters in the @aveen Patnai! government have misused the discretionary housing 7uota. )ccording to the revelation, the judges have got the Bminister 7uota’ lats out o turn and at cheaper rates. The 4=@ @etwor! accessed letters o judges written to the government as!ing or prime property in 'uttac! and =hubaneswar.

Prime properties were ac7uired in 'uttac! at concession rates, bypassing the 'uttac! 9evelopment )uthority. 4n act, &ectors 32, 33 and 3< o 'uttac!’s )bhinav =idanasi project has practically become a judges’ residential colony. Hormer 'hie (ustice # =. Patnai! is a resident o lat 3=$** in &ector 33 while ormer Orissa ,igh 'ourt(udge :adha!rishna Patra has lat 3=$*< in the same sector, given out on lease. &upreme 'ourt judge 9eba Priya 1ohapatra, Orissa ,igh 'ourt judges &anju Panda, 1adan 1ohan 9as, @ityanand Prastuti also own lats in &ector 32 and 33.Papers or the lats were prepared 7uic!ly and some judges even got pre erred plots. 1ost o the allotments too! place between *222 and *22A, under the =(P cadre Urban and ,ousing 9evelopment 1inister &ameer 9e who was &tate 9evelopment 1inister rom *222%*220 and then >ana! Eardhan &ingh 9eo who called the shots rom *220 to *22A. )ll that the judges had to do was written to the 1inister. The '@@%4=@ has a letter written by (ustice 1adan 1ohan 9as to the '9) 'hairman and to 1inister >ana! Eardhan &inghdeo, as!ing or a =%'ategory Hlat in &ector 32, saying he would ensure a third party trans er o a '%'ategory Hlat already owned by his wi e.(ustice 9as was allotted the lat in just six days.

8hen as!ed why the discretionary 7uota was used to ma!e the allotments, &ameer 9ey, ormer Orissa urban development minister, said, 5The Orissa act does not have any such rule. There is + per cent and 32 per cent allocation in discretionary 7uota. )part rom that we don’t have any rule.6 >ana! Eardhan &ingh 9eo, ormer Orissa urban development minister, said, 5The rule is that only those who apply or the project can be allotted land via 9iscretionary Wuota. &o i any such person does not apply what can we doK6 '@@%4=@ has also ound that many o the judges who were allotted land through the discretionary 7uota already own ancestral property in 'uttac!. Det the ministers were allotted the land they as!ed or.

(udicial "ayout &ite )llotment at Dehan!a =angalore M =:4=- TO (U9#-& K

http:$$www.vijay!arnata!aepaper.com$svwwRIoomart.phpK )rtnameQ*2332O3Oa=223323220Lile tQ3AALitopQ3*+*LIoom:atioQ3<0L)@Q*2332O 3Oa=223323220 , http:$$www.vijay!arnata!aepaper.com$svwwRIoomart.phpK )rtnameQ*2332O3OaR22032322*Lile tQ*<<LitopQO*LIoom:atioQ3<2L)@Q*2332O3Oa R22032322* ,

http:$$www.vijay!arnata!aepaper.com$svwwRIoomart.phpK )rtnameQ*2332O3OaR22032322<Lile tQAC2LitopQO*LIoom:atioQ3+AL)@Q*2332O3Oa R22032322< (U94'4)" 'O::UPT4O@ 1D "O:9&, T,-:-’& ) ')&- )#)4@&T DOU

'ormer (nion law ministers are spearheading a campaign against sitting )udges they accuse of %eing corrupt. *hat is the higher )udiciary doing to clear itself of these grave charges? )vinash 9uttNew +elhi

Under observation: T he &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia ,hoto %y $. Satheesh

&enior lawyers have complained to the '(4 and the President that (ustice =halla illegally amassed properties The campaign by some senior lawyers and ormer law ministers who have 7uestioned the integrity o sitting high court judges is set to ratchet up the growing con rontation between the legislative and the judicial arms o the government. Hormer Union law ministers &hanti =hushan and :am (ethmalani are leading the battle against what they claim are corrupt practices in the highest echelons o the judiciary. =hushan has categorically condemned the rot he eels has set in the judicial system. 5The judiciary o this country is not merely unaccountable, but corrupt and braIenly so,6 he wrote in a letter to President )P( )bdul >alam on 9ecember 3A. =hushan has demanded that the President initiate impeachment proceedings against (ustice (agdish =halla o the "uc!now =ench o the )llahbad ,igh 'ourt. On 9ecember 30, a &upreme 'ourt .&'/ collegium recommended that (ustice =halla be appointed the 'hie (ustice o the >erela ,'.

=hushan and (ethmalani, along with noted lawyers and ormer justices, including :ajendra &achar, 4ndira (aisingh and ,ardev &ingh, have ormed the 'ommittee on (udicial )ccountability .'O()/ and presented documents to the 'hie (ustice o 4ndia .'(4/, D> &abharwal, to support their complaint against the sitting judges. 'O() complained to the '(4 on (uly 33 that (ustice (agdish =halla had amassed several illegal properties in the name o his wi e and other close relatives. (ustice Eijender (ain, the ormer senior (udge in the 9elhi ,igh 'ourt, who was recently appointed the '( o Punjab and ,aryana ,', is also in 'O()’s line o ire. =y 7uestioning the integrity o (ustices =halla and (ain, =hushan has thrown open the much larger 7uestion o judicial accountability. .&ee interview/ 5"eave aside ta!ing any action against corrupt judges li!e (ustice (agdish =halla and (ustice Eijender (ain, the '(4 has been actually avoiding even properly investigating charges against them,6 says =hushan. )ccording to documents produced by 'O() on *3 (uly *22<, :enu =halla bought a A,*22 s7. metre plot near the @oida%#reater @oida expressway. On *C 1arch *22+, Uday &han!ar, dsp, #autam =uddha @agar .@oida’s o icial name/ submitted a report to the area dm in which he states that the sellers o the plot belong to the 5land ma ia6. 4n an en7uiry submitted to the dm on *? (une *22+, :> &ingh, the area sdm, also described the sellers as belonging to the 5land ma ia6. )ccording to the two reports, the plots constituted a portion o the gram samaj .joint village property/ land, illegally grabbed by the 5land ma ia6. .)ll the documents relating to the transaction are in possession o Tehel!a/ The &91’s report says that at the time o the transaction, the plot was worth :s A.*2 crore in the open mar!et, whereas :enu =halla paid :s + la!h or it. The two reports also state that the sellers o the plot have been charged in several criminal cases, and had sold plots to several in luential people to curry avour with them. :enu =halla is the wi e o (ustice (agdish =halla. =hushan has also drawn attention to the (uly *22+ draw o lots or allotment o plots in &ector 00 in #reater @oida. 8hen the computerised draw threw up several in luential names, a ew people approached the )llahabad ,' alleging oulplay. 4n October *22+, the ,' decided that the case warranted a resh draw o lots and ordered a cbi in7uiry into the scam. )mong those who had been allotted plots in the scrapped list were )arohi =halla and &heeba &abharwal. )arohi =halla, who is the son o (ustice =halla, was allotted plot number %+*, while &heeba &abharwal, daughter%in%law o the '(4 D> &abharwal was allotted plot number %AC. 4n @ovember *22+, the &upreme 'ourt stayed the )llahabad ,' judgement, putting the cbi en7uiry and the ,'’s order to hold a resh draw o lots on hold. )dmissible in courtK 9ocuments urnished by 'O() against the justices 1embers o 'O() have o ered to discuss the matter in person with the '(4 but they say that they are still waiting to hear rom him. Hive months a ter their initial re7uest, they sent another application to the '(4 in @ovember. This time they sought his permission to register an H4: against (ustice =halla, claiming that their initial evidence was enough to register an o ence against him under the Prevention o 'orruption )ct.

5The '(4 did not even call us to hear our point,6 says =hushan. 54 don’t !now why (ustice &abharwal is shielding (ustice =hallaZ6 =hushan is e7ually critical o (ustice Eijender (ain. (ustice (ain, who too! oath as the new '( o Punjab and ,aryana ,' in @ovember, had to Third time luc!y: 'hie (ustice Eijender (ain 8hen a collegium headed by the '(4 recommend ed (ustice (ain’s name, the President returned the ile endure many delays be ore he could be appointed to the post. The '(4 had to ma!e three e orts to promote (ustice (ain. ) collegium headed by the 'hie (ustice o 4ndia irst recommended (ustice (ain’s name or the post in (uly. ,owever, President )P( )bdul >alam returned the ile, causing a minor embarrassment to the '(4 and the Union government. 8hen the collegium reiterated its recommendation through the government in @ovember, the President had to sign the ile. -arlier in 1ay, a proposal by the '(4 to ma!e (ustice (ain '( o the 1aharsahtra ,' was stonewalled by a judge in the three%member collegium who 7uestioned (ustice (ain’s integrity. The member on the panel cited a complaint made to ormer '(4 :' "ahoti against (ustice (ain in (anuary *22+. The '(4 revived the proposal a month later, but again a judge on the collegium opposed his appointment. Hinally, a ortnight later, in (uly *22?, the '(4 made his third attempt to promote (ain, this time to the Punjab and ,aryana ,'. This time around, to address dissenting voices, the '(4 also consulted other &' judges who happened to be ormer chie justices o the 9elhi ,igh 'ourt. )ccording to reliable sources, (ustice (ain’s ormer seniors also 7uestioned his integrity. ,owever, on the basis o a majority, the proposal to promote him was orwarded to the Union government or the President’s assent. ) major hurdle in promoting (ustice (ain continued on page C continued rom page ? was a complaint by one &ubhash )grawal who approached then '(4 :' "ahoti in (anuary *22+ with the complaint that (ustice (ain had violated the code o conduct or judges. )grawal claimed that (ustice (ain gave a judgement in avour o someone with whom he had 5 amily relations6. ,e produced a copy o the invitation card o the litigant’s granddaughter’s wedding, held in )pril *223. )ccording to the card, the venue o the wedding was the o icial residence o (ustice (ain. .Tehel!a has obtained a copy o the

wedding card rom the 'entral 4n ormation 'ommission/. 4n @ovember *220, (ustice (ain, hearing an appeal, decided a civil suit in avour o the person who had held his granddaughter’s wedding at his o icial residence. 8hen there was no response to his complaint in October *22+, )grawal approached the &' to ind out the status o his complaint under the rti )ct. ,e was told that his complaint was in the relevant ,' ile. @ot satis ied, )grawal approached the 'entral 4n ormation 'ommission. On the commission’s insistence, the &' inally told )grawal that his complaint had not actually been orwarded to the ,', as the &' has 5no administrative jurisdiction6 over high court judges. There ore, the complaint was pending be ore the '(4, D> &abharwal. The commission as!ed the '(4 to act on the application. The '(4 inally settled the complaint, saying he ound no merit in it. 8hen )grawal as!ed or reasons behind the decision, he drew a blan!. 4t’s not just =hushan who eels the need to bring about accountability and transparency in the judiciary. (anata 9al .U/ president &harad Dadav says the issue will be discussed when the (udicial )ccountability =ill is tabled in Parliament. 58hen the government tables the bill, all its aspects will be discussed,6 Dadav told Tehel!a. '(4 D> &abharwal could not be reached or his comments. 9espite conciliatory notes rom him there are all indications that the clamour surrounding judicial misdemeanour and the demand or greater accountability will only increase in the days to come. +ec -. / 0..1

T,- &TO:D OH ) WU4-T =U:4)"K &pecial '=4 judge :ama (ain uncovers :s A crore Provident Hund scam during vigilance in7uiry )ccused )shutosh )sthana revealed that he was paying o <? judges including a sitting &upreme 'ourt judge and 33 ,igh 'ourt judges &upreme 'ourt directs '=4 to investigate, permits interrogation o all involved judges &everal status reports given by the '=4 to the apex court :eports !ept secret. )ction ta!en on basis o reports un!nown =urn ) ter :eading =:4(-&, P)@9-D and &)@()D 9U=-D trac" the Supreme investigating charges of )udicial corruption ourt2s lac" of urgency in

8,-@ &P-'4)" '=4 judge :ama (ain received an anonymous letter in (anuary *22C, telling her that the provident unds o 'lass < and 'lass 0 employees o the #haIiabad court were being siphoned o , she had no idea that she had stumbled onto the biggest judicial scam in the history o independent 4ndia. )s she was the designated vigilance o icer at the #haIiabad court, she irst conducted an in7uiry on her own, which uncovered the involvement o at least three judges and the 'entral @aIir in the embeIIlement o unds. &he reported the matter to the )llahabad ,igh 'ourt, which, in turn, ordered a vigilance in7uiry. ,olding that the report, prima facie/ had merit, the court directed her to ile an H4:. 'entral @aIir )shutosh )sthana was arrested on the basis o the H4: on )pril 32, *22C. ,is interrogation revealed that )sthana was not a solo player. ,e claimed that he was

irst introduced to the scam by a district judge himsel . 8hat ollowed was so shoc!ing that even the #haIiabad police was on the bac! oot. )sthana con essed that rom the :s A crore embeIIled, he had given cash and gi ts such as airconditioners, re rigerators, expensive clothes, jewellery and urniture to as many as <? judges, including about 32 ,igh 'ourt judges and one &upreme 'ourt judge. 4n a sworn statement be ore a magistrate, )sthana revealed that this raud had run rom *223 to *22A with the active connivance o district judges. -very month, )sthana even paid bribes to various judges, rom :s *+,222 to a whopping :s 3.+ la!h. 8hen these excerpts rom )sthana’s con ession became public, the public image o the judiciary touched a new low. 4n perhaps the biggest moment o crisis or the 4ndian judiciary, )sthana, the main accused, has in turn named judges rom the #haIiabad 9istrict 'ourt to the )llahabad ,igh 'ourt, right up to the &upreme 'ourt. This was not all. These revelations stunned the #haIiabad police. 'learly out o their depth and .justi iably/ wary o ta!ing on the power ul judiciary, they re7uested the #haIiabad court to hand over the probe to the '=4. 4n &eptember *22C, the &upreme 'ourt trans erred the case to the '=4, but with a rider: 4nvestigate, but give us a sealed report. The PH scam, as it had come to be !nown, gave the judiciary a wonder ul opportunity to redeem itsel in the eyes o the people but the case remained shrouded in secrecy. 'ynics then said that the whole matter would be given a 7uiet burial. -ighteen months a ter the scam became public and our '=4 status reports later, the cynics appear to have had the last laugh.

This delay and secrecy in such a highpro ile scam raises various uncom ortable 7uestions or the 4ndian (udiciary. "egal luminaries believe that this is symptomatic o a larger malaise which ails the judiciary. &ays jurist :am (ethmalani, 5The reputation o a judge is more important than the actual act o his honesty. 4n act, i a judge has a bad reputation, even i it is undeserved, he should not be appointed because then nobody will have con idence in his judgements,6 adding, 58hen the judiciary expedites cases concerning the executive branch or even most prominent cases, why is such urgency not displayed here, when the matter is extremely serious. 8hy this delayK6 ) E)"49 WU-&T4O@. )sthana named <? judges .a list o which is with T-,-">)/. Other than the act that a ew have retired, virtually nothing is !nown about the ate o the judges o the )llahabad ,igh 'ourt and the &upreme 'ourt judge. 8hether or not the apex court is planning to initiate or has initiated, criminal charges against any o the judges U sitting or retired the &upreme 'ourt can answer. Hor six years, unds worth :s A crore were embeIIled and judges were allegedly bribed U are 7uestions that only

)nd the apex court should answer, argues ormer Union law minister and senior advocate &hanti =hushan. 54 don’t appreciate this sealed%cover business except in very rare cases when ma!ing something public might be detrimental to the public interest U mainly i there is an army secret. 8hether it is the judiciary or the executive, all o icers are appointed on the behal o the people. 4t is on the people’s behal that the judiciary exercises its powers. ,ow can you !eep investigations in the PH scam secretK The people

have every right to !now what is going on.6 E@ >hare, ormer 'hie (ustice o 4ndia, concurs. 5These !ind o things should not be allowed to linger. This sha!es the con idence o the people in the judiciary. 4 there is an allegation or misconduct, it must be in7uired into immediately and strict action should be 8hen the judiciary expedites cases concerning the executive branch or even most prominent cases, why is such urgency not being displayed in this matterK :)1 (-T,1)")@4, Jurist ta!en against the erring judges. 8hy should the reputation o most judges su er or no ault o theirsK6 The biggest 7uestion which arises rom this scam is the lac! o will on the part o the judiciary to rein in errant judges. "et alone the judges named by )sthana, what about the ate o the three #haIiabad 9istrict (udges named by vigilance o icer o the district court &pecial '=4 (udge :ama (ain hersel K "egal luminaries say this hesitancy on the part o judges to act against ellow judges involved in wrongdoing clearly illustrates the prevailing mindset o the judiciary. 54 !now o a retired 'hie (ustice o 4ndia who is one o the most honest judges 4 have ever seen. 4t’s di icult to imagine a more honest person. ,owever, when a responsible minister made complaints to him against a corrupt ,igh 'ourt (udge, he did not grant permission or an investigation because he elt that as the head o the judicial amily, it was his job to protect judges, be they corrupt or not,6 says &hanti =hushan. :am (ethmalani chips in sarcastically, 5This is the reason why judges call each other Bbrother judge.’6 4T 4& not only cases li!e the PH scam which taints the image o the judiciary, but also the extreme reluctance on the part o the judiciary to be open and transparent. :eams and reams o paper have gone towards pious exhortations by the judiciary as!ing the government to re rain rom corruption and wor! in an e icient manner. =ut sadly, no judge has held orth at length on the need or the judiciary to re rain rom corruption. -ven attempts to exercise the :ight to 4n ormation with respect to the o ice o the '(4 came a cropper as the '(4’s o ice was always declared out o bounds. 4t too! a historic verdict by the 9elhi ,igh 'ourt to declare that the o ice o the '(4 was not immune rom accountability and outside the purview o the :T4 )ct. &enior lawyers and retired chie justices eel that i the judiciary is not transparent or accountable, it only means that they are trying to hide something. (ustice >hare eels, 5(udges are more accountable than other persons because they hold a very high post. The very existence o the judiciary is based on the aith o the common man in it. 4 that aith is not there, how can the judiciary unctionK6 8hat incenses them is the behaviour o the government with regard to the (udges’ )ssets 9eclaration =ill which the government tried to introduce in *22O. The opposition

erupted in protest and orced the government to de er the bill. (ethmalani terms the government’s approach to this bill as a 5conspiracy o corruption6. 5The government is scared to ta!e on the judiciary. 4t’s clear that the executive wants to cosy up to the judiciary.6 )grees retired '(4 E @ >hare, 58hy should there be any hesitancy to declare assets at all on the part o judiciaryK The whole episode is beyond me.6 4n a recent development, the &upreme 'ourt has reiterated be ore the 9elhi ,igh 'ourt that the '(4’s o ice is outside the purview o the :T4 )ct.

)nother assault on the public image o the judiciary is the 9ina!aran episode. 'urrently, judges are appointed to the &upreme 'ourt by the &upreme 'ourt 'ollegium, a group o judges chaired by the 'hie (ustice o 4ndia. 8hen 'hie (ustice 9ina!aran o the >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt was elevated to the &,)@T4 &upreme 'ourt, the state =ar and legal luminaries rose up in =,U&,)@, 'ormer law protest because the 'ollegium appeared to have dismissed, minister or, at least, not have considered the serious allegations o corruption against him. )ccording to &enior )dvocate &oli &orabjee, 5The 9ina!aran episode shows that the 'ollegium is not wor!ing satis actorily. Dou must have a national commission or judges which should be made up o judges, eminent jurists and senior government o icials. This council should have the power to get independent in ormation and evaluate it.6 &hanti =hushan eels that as judges are extremely busy with hearing cases, there should be a ull%time commission whose sole unction is to pic! judges or the ,igh 'ourt and the &upreme 'ourt and eels that the commission should also have its own bureau o investigation. They should not be dependent on either the local police, who might be a raid to investigate judges, or on an overburdened '=4. =ut all this is very hard to achieve. (urists eel that the judges o the higher courts have converted themselves into a union o sorts and are trying to protect each other. 5Their approach is to sweep every allegation under the carpet. 9on’t allow the public to !now about it. "et the public believe that our judiciary is very honest. =ut this has been counterproductive. 4t has given a shield o total immunity to the judges and they thin! they can get away with anything. This has led to an increase in corruption in the judiciary,6 states &hanti =hushan. Time and again, opportunities have arisen or the judiciary to reinvent itsel in a new avatar. )nd time a ter time, it has ailed. 'aesar’s wi e, they say, should be above suspicion. 8hatever the cost it might ta!e to ensure it.

@o judge holds orth at length on the need or the judiciary to re rain 'orruption charges are rom corruption swept under the carpet by the judiciary. =ut this has given a shield o total immunity to the judges, who thin! they can get away with anything

8:4T-:&’ -1)4" brijeshXtehel!a.com sanjayXtehel!a.com 'rom #ehel"a Maga3ine/ 4ol 1/ 5ssue 67/ +ated Octo%er 78/ 0..9

B,al o last 3? chie justices have been corrupt’ =y churumuri B altQ6http:$$churumuri. iles.wordpress.com$*232$2O$prashant%and%shantibhushan.pngK wQ*22LhQ<22″ borderQ2 v:shapesQ6Rx2222Ri32<?″S

(udicial corruption is a bull ew in 4ndia are willing to attach their names to. There are whispers o this or that sitting judge ma!ing piles or cash; o sons, daughters and other near and dear ones acting as 5bro!ers6 or cases, deals, etc, but none o those allegations see the light o day. @ot because the media is a willing accomplice but because o the sword o 5contempt o court6 hanging over us. Hor long, truth was not, repeat not, a de ence in the case o contempt. )lthough that is now no longer the case, judicial corruption still isn’t headline news li!e corruption in other spheres o 4ndian li e. The case o (ustice P.9. 9ina!aran is one o the rare exceptions and that too only in sections o the media. 4n &eptember *22O, the &upreme 'ourt lawyer Prashant =hushan, in an interview to &homa 'haudhury o #ehel"amagaIine, said 5hal o the last 3? chie justices were corrupt6. The comment invited the apex court’s contempt. @ow, =hushan’s ather, the noted jurist &hanti =hushan has joined issue. 4n his application be ore the &upreme 'ourt praying or his impleadment as respondent @o.< in the case o the )micus 'uriae vs Prashant =hushan, =hushan senior repeats his son’s charge that eight out o the last 3? '(s were corrupt, even going so ar as to deliver the names o the corrupt in a sealed cover. 54n the applicant’s opinion, eight [o the last 3? chie justices\ were de initely corrupt, six were de initely honest and about the remaining two, a de inite opinion cannot be expressed whether they were honest or corrupt.6 =elow is the ull text o &hanti =hushan’s application, published in the public interest. ]]] To The ,on’ble 'hie (ustice o 4ndia L ,is companion justices o the &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia The humble application o the Petitioners above named. 1ost respect ully showeth:

3. That the applicant is iling the present application or his impleadment as :espondent @o. < in the a orementioned contempt petition as the applicant is ma!ing a categorical statement in the present application that eight o the last sixteen 'hie (ustices o 4ndia were de initely corrupt and also providing the names o those eight de initely corrupt 'hie (ustices in a sealed cover as an annexure along with the present application. *. The applicant is a practicing advocate who was enrolled on C (uly 3O0C. ,e has appeared in each and every ,igh 'ourt in the country. ,e is well ac7uainted with the manner in which the 4ndian judiciary has been unctioning and how its character has been changing over the years. <. That the applicant has been a part o the campaign or judicial accountability since its inception in the year 3OO2. 0. That there was a time when it was almost impossible even to thin! that a judge o a ,igh court or the &upreme 'ourt could be corrupt. Things have changed drastically during the last * or < decades during which corruption has been growing in the 4ndian judiciary. &o much so that even a sitting 'hie (ustice o 4ndia had to openly admit that *2^ o the judges could be corrupt. Eery recently in 1arch *232 a sitting 'hie (ustice o a high court openly made a statement. The statement o the sitting chie justice was published by the #imes of 5ndia in its issue o ?th march *232 with the headlines/ :5n our )udiciary/ any%ody can %e %ought/ says ;u)arat chief )ustice<. ) copy o the news paper report is being annexed hereto as )nnexure ). +. That the applicant believes that the reported statement may not be correctly re lecting the perception o the #ujarat 'hie (ustice, since he should be !nowing as the applicant does that there are and have always been plenty o totally honest judges, but they are also becoming the victim o this public perception since no institution o governance in the country is ta!ing any e ective steps about dealing with corruption in the judiciary. ?. That 4ndia became a republic in 3O+2, when the people became sovereign. They got the right to constitute their institutions, the executive, the legislature and the judiciary, to serve them, who would be accountable to them. A. That be ore 3O+2, corruption was almost non existent in the ,igh 'ourts. The ederal court had in 3O0O got (ustice &hiv Prasad &inha removed rom the )llahabad ,igh 'ourt, merely on the inding that he had passed * judicial orders on extra judicial considerations. C. That it however appears that therea ter the judiciary has adopted the policy o sweeping all allegations o judicial corruption under the carpet in the belie that such allegations might tarnish the image o the judiciary. 4t does not realiIe that this policy has played a big role in increasing judicial corruption. O. That the 'onstitution prescribed removal by impeachment as the only way o removing judges who commit misconduct since it was believed at the time o the raming o the 'onstitution that misconduct by judges o the higher judiciary would be very rare. ,owever those expectations have been belied as is apparent rom the sur acing o a series o judicial scandals in the recent past. The case o (ustice E.

:amaswami and subse7uent attempts to impeach other judges have shown that this is an impractical and di icult process to deal with corrupt judges. The practical e ect o this has been to instill a eeling o impunity among judges who eel that they cannot be touched even i they misconduct. 32. That corruption by judges is a cogniIable o ence. The 'ode o 'riminal Procedure re7uires that whenever an H4: is iled with respect to a cogniIable o ence, it is the statutory duty o the police to investigate the o ence. The police has to collect evidence against the accused and charge%sheet him in a competent court. ,e would then be tried and punished by being sent to jail. The &upreme 'ourt has however by violating this statutory provision in the 'rP' given a direction in its 'onstitution bench judgement in theEeeraswamy case o 3OO3 that no H4: would be registered against any judge without the permission o the 'hie (ustice o 4ndia. 4n not a single case has any such permission ever been granted or the registration o an H4: against any judge a ter that judgement. 33. That the result o this direction has been that a total immunity has been given to corrupt judges against their prosecution. @o wonder that judicial corruption has increased by leaps and bounds. 3*. That an honest judiciary enjoying public con idence is an imperative or the unctioning o a democracy, and it is the duty o every right thin!ing person to strive to achieve this end. 3<. That unless the level o corruption in the judiciary is exposed and brought in the public domain, the institutions o governance cannot be activated to ta!e e ective measures to eliminate this evil. 30. That it is the common perception that whenever such e orts are made by anyone, the judiciary tries to target him by the use o the power o contempt. 4t is the reputation o the judge which is his shield against any malicious and alse allegations against him. ,e doesn’t need the power o contempt to protect his reputation and credibility. 3+. That the applicant strongly believes that a responsible citiIen should be prepared to undergo any amount o su ering in the pursuit o the noble cause o ighting or a clean judiciary. 3?. That there are two statements o :espondent no. 3 .Prashant =hushan/ published in #ehel"a by :espondent no. * which are alleged to constitute contempt o court. 4n the 3st statement, :espondent no. 3 has expressed that in his view, out o the last 3? or 3A chie justices o 4ndia, hal have been corrupt. 3A. The applicant states that in his view too this statement is absolutely correct. )t the time o the publication o this report in #ehel"a, the last 3? 'hie (ustices o 4ndia were the ollowing: 3. (ustice :anganath 1ishra, *. (ustice >.@. &ingh, <. (ustice 1.,. >ania, 0. (ustice ".1. &harma, +. (ustice 1.@. Een!atchalliah, ?. (ustice ).1. )hmadi, A. (ustice (.&. Eerma, C. (ustice 1.1. Punchhi,

O. (ustice ).&. )nand, 32. (ustice &.P. =harucha, 33. (ustice =.@. >ripal, 3*. (ustice #.=. Patnai!, 3<. (ustice :ajendra =abu, 30. (ustice :. '. "ahoti, 3+. (ustice E.@. >hare, 3?. (ustice D.> &abharwalOut o these, in the applicant’s opinion, eight were de initely corrupt, six were de initely honest and about the remaining two, a de inite opinion cannot be expressed whether they were honest or corrupt. The signed lists identi ying these eight, six and two 'hie (ustices o 4ndia are being enclosed in a sealed cover which is being annexed here to as )nnexure =. 3C. That in act two ormer chie justices o 4ndia had personally told the applicant while they were in o ice that their immediate predecessor and immediate successor were corrupt judges. The names o these our 'hie (ustices o 4ndia are included in the list o the C corrupt 'hie (ustices o 4ndia. 3O. That since the applicant is publicly stating that out o the last sixteen 'hie (ustices o 4ndia, eight o them were de initely corrupt, the applicant also needs to be added as a respondent to this contempt petition so that he is also suitably punished or this contempt. The applicant would consider it a great honour to spend time in jail or ma!ing an e ort to get or the people o 4ndia an honest and clean judiciary. *2. That the applicant also submits that since the 7uestions arising in this case a ects the judiciary as a whole, the petition needs to be decided by the entire court and not merely by three judges handpic!ed by a 'hie (ustice. P:)D-:& 4n view o the above, it is most respect ully prayed that this ,on’ble 'ourt may be pleased to: 3. allow the present application and implead the )pplicant as a contemnor in the a orementioned contempt petition as :espondent no. <; and *. pass any other or urther order$s as this ,on’ble 'ourt may deem it and proper in the acts and circumstances o the case. .&hanti =hushan/ applicant%in%person @ew 9elhi ]]] Photograph: courtesy &hailendra Pandey$ #ehel"a ]]] Hull coverage: The strange case o (ustice P.9. 9ina!aran

',U:U1U:4 PO"": 4s 9alit 9ina!aran above the lawK 4 he is un it or &upreme 'ourt, how is he it or >arnata!a ,'K 4 he is un it or &upreme 'ourt, how is he it or >arnata!a ,'U44K B4ntegrity _ competence _ judicial temperament’ =ella not O>, but &upreme 'ourt silent yaa"eK The braIen conduct o (ustice 9ina!aran The strange case o (ustice 9ina!aran .continued/ Audi alteram partemK ,ear the other side outK ',U:U1U:4 PO"": 8ill (ustice 9ina!aran be impeachedK 4s '(4 >.#. =ala!rishnan right about P.9. 9ina!aranK ',U:U1U:4 PO"": 4s 9ina!aran it or &i!!im ,'K ',U:U1U:4 PO"": P.9. 9ina!aran vs 9.E. &hylendra >umar 4s &i!!im ,'’s dignity less than that o >arnata!a’sK #he father/ the sons>in>law and the unholy properties

JEEMON JA O! ? 4$ S@AS@5$(MAA scoop documents to esta%lish property amassed %y former hief Justice of 5ndia $; !ala"rishnan2s son>in>law/ ,4 Sreeni)an/ a practising

P,OTO: &,)4"-@9: ) P)@9-D lawyer who recently resigned from the $erala ongress

*@EN $; !ala"rishnan was appointed hief Justice of 5ndia in 0..8/ it was a great moment for a man of hum%le origins. !ut 4A $rishna 5yer/ former )udge of the Supreme ourt and national icon/ now says/ :5 used to say that an era had %egun when $; !ala"rishnan %ecame the first +alit hief Justice. Now/ 5 don2t feel that way.< ,ost retirement/ !ala"rishnan %ecame head of the National @uman Aights ommission BN@A C in June last year. Ever since/ a rising crescendo of allegations of corruption have %een heard/ fuelled %y the fact that his younger %rother $; !has"aran and his two daughters and sons>in>law all ac&uired vast properties during his tenure as hief Justice.

#E@EL$A has accessed documents that show that %etween 0..8 and 0.7./ son>in>law ,uliyanaveettil 4asu Sreeni)an purchased property worth As. 7.DE crore. #he current real estate value of these properties is in eFcess of As. 0E crore. #his is a truly ama3ing story of wealth creation %y a man who/ while contesting elections from $erala2s reserved N)arac""al Assem%ly constituency as a ongress candidate in 0..1/ had declared a %an" %alance of As. 0E/... apart from 06 g of gold. Sreeni)an is married 3to !ala"rishnan2s elder daughter $! Sony/ whom he met in college. @e traces his %ac"ground to a hum%le and hard>wor"ing familyG his father was a factory wor"er in ,remier #yres/ $alamassery/ and a ongress party wor"er. @is classmates remem%er him as an introvert who had a muted/ almost latent/ am%ition to %ecome a powerful politician. 'rom campus politics he moved to the =outh ongress and too" active part in its programmes and activities. Sreeni)an %ecame a practising lawyer in the $erala @igh ourt. *hen !ala"rishnan started his three>year tenure as hief Justice/ Sreeni)an started ma"ing huge investments in real estate and tourism. #his sudden ac&uisition of wealth is currently %eing pro%ed %y the vigilance department after a pro%e was ordered %y hief Minister 4S Achuthanandan. #E@EL$A repeatedly tried to esta%lish contact with Sreeni)an for his version via SMS and phone/ %ut all calls went unanswered. After his marriage with Sony/ Sreeni)an2s political career also leapfrogged. @e was appointed state vice>president of the =outh ongress. #hough ongress leaders li"e MA $uttappan Balso a former ministerC challenged Sreeni)an2s rise/ such protests were short> lived. @e lost the 0..1 elections %ut his wife purchased a flat and car par"ing space in #ravancore Aesidency #owers for As. 1 la"h in 0..8. *5#@5N A month/ Sony again purchased another flat in Mather S&uare. #he cost of the flat mentioned in the title deed is only As. 7.69 la"h/ %ut the mar"et price of flats in the vicinity was a%out As. 11 la"h at that time. #oday/ $erala =outh ongress leaders who were angry a%out Sreeni)an2s political rise are gunning for him. :*e demand a !5 in&uiry to find out how Sreeni)an ac&uired so much property and assets within the last three years/< said M Li)u/ former =outh ongress state president. On E January/ Sreeni)an tendered his resignation as =outh ongress

"egal richesK &reenijan’s wealth has multiplied since *22A vice>president. 5n Novem%er 0..D/ Sreeni)an purchased a river>front property of 088.E0 cents in $adu"utti village in #hrissur district where he is now reportedly constructing a resort. According to the title deed/ he purchased the land from Mohammed 5&%al Mather for As.

76 la"h. 4illagers who prefer to remain anonymous say the mar"et price was As. 7 la"h per cent. 5f that is the case he has allegedly shelled out As. 0.88 crore. And %uilding the resort could put him %ac" %y more than As. 7. crore. 5n 0..9/ Sreeni)an purchased another property on +esha%himani Aoad in Erna"ulam for As. -. la"h. Later/ a property of -.E cents of land was purchased in his mother2s name BSreemathy 4asuC ad)acent to his plot. !ut it is not only Sreeni)an who %ecame rich during !ala"rishnan2s tenure as J5. #he second son>in>law/ advocate MJ !enny/ too/ %ecame wealthier after his marriage to Aani/ !ala"rishnan2s younger daughter. !orn to a wor"ing>class hristian couple in Nettur/ Erna"ulam/ !enny married Aani in 0..1. !enny and Aani/ %oth lawyers/ fell in love in the court. !enny2s assets piled up in a manner similar to Sreeni)an2s. !etween 79 March 0..D and 01 March 0.7./ he purchased 9D.E cents of land through five title deeds for As.D7.E la"h. #his is prime land along the National @ighway in Marad/ Erna"ulam district. A cursory comparison of land rates during this period shows that the property was undervalued. *hen !enny purchased the property it was around As. 6 la"h per cent and at current rates would %e As. 7. la"h per cent. =et !enny showed his yearly income as As. E la"h and As. E.E la"h during the assessment years 0..D>.9 and 0..9>7.. Just five land deals made !enny a millionaire in two years. Aani also em%ar"ed on an investment spree/ purchasing 7..E acres in Athirampu3ha with her relatives/ including A%hilash # handran in 0..8. handran is the son of #hangappan/ one of !ala"rishnan2s siF %rothers. #hen there2s $; !has"aran/ younger %rother of the former J5/ who is in the spotlight for possessing property %eyond his "nown sources of income. A senior government pleader practising in the $erala @igh ourt/ !has"aran reportedly purchased E. acres of land in +indigul/ #amil Nadu. 5n the light of allegations of having illegally amassed property he was as"ed to go on leave from 6 January %y $erala2s Advocate ;eneral , Sudha"ara ,rasad. !has"aran/ a former mem%er of the ,M/ contested Assem%ly elections as a party candidate from 4ai"om in 7988. !has"aran was a regular visitor to the Supreme ourt during his elder %rother2s tenure as the J5. @e is also reportedly close to Justice ,aul +aniel +ina"aran Bcurrently hief Justice of Si""im @igh ourt and former hief Justice of $arnata"a @igh ourtC against whom serious allegations have %een levelled of land gra% in #amil Nadu. No wonder/ the $erala 4igilance +epartment is now pro%ing all the assets ac&uired %y !ala"rishnan2s family. Especially as the patriarch has not faded into the sunset and is now heading a %ody tas"ed with %ringing )ustice to those whose human rights have %een violated.

Public prosecutor caught on the wrong side o law 4n a decision termed 5rarest o rare6 by a city court, a trial court judge ound a public prosector on the wrong side o the law. 4ndicting the prosecutor or deliberately botching up examination o witnesses in a case o abduction or ransom, )dditional &essions (udge Pratap & 1ali! has passed strictures against the state’s counsel and sent the copy o his order to the prosecution branch or necessary action. The judge held that there was a deliberate attempt by the prosecutor to create situations avourable or the three accused, ound guilty o abducting one &anjay >han or ransom in *220. >han had later committed suicide to escape urther assault and the court, inding ample evidence on record, had awarded li e imprisonment to the trio on &aturday. The prosecutor had re rained rom putting important 7uestions to police o icials and other witnesses that could help the prosecution nail the accused in a more convincing manner, the court observed.

Prosecutor caught in )'= trap

Thane, )pr A .PT4/ )n assistant Public Prosecutor attached to the >alyan court was trapped by Thane unit o )nti 'orruption =ureau while allegedly accepting bribe in the court premises this evening. )'= o icials said that one Tuna =harati, a resident o 1alad, had iled case o dowry harassment against husband and in%laws o his late sister, =havana. )ssistant Public Prosecutor, 'hayya =had!am!ar allegedly demanded :s *2,222 and accepted the irst instalment o :s <,+22, or arguing the case e ectively, )'= said. &he was trapped today while ta!ing the balance amount, it said.

(U9#-& 4@ P:OE49-@T HU@9 &')1 K

@-8 9-",4: Haced with accusations having the potential to unhinge the traditional public perception o the judiciary’s clean image, the &' on 1onday decided to examine the possible mode o probe into the :s *< crore illegal PH withdrawal scam allegedly involving *< judges, including some rom the ,'s and one rom the apex court. The di icult 7uestion on the mode o probe was posed by a petitioner, who is the chairman o )dvocates 8el are Trust and =ar )ssociation o #haIiabad U the place where the scam too! place U even as '(4 > # =ala!rishnan had shown aith in the integrity o the judges by as!ing the UP police, which is probing the scam, to send 7uestionnaires to the judges, whose names allegedly igured in the scam. Unwilling to have the judges interrogated by the police at irst go, &' had written to the UP police that i the response o those judges

to the 7uestionnaire did not satis y the probe team, then it could send re7uest or personal interrogation. The re7uest or interrogation in person would be considered on merit, the &' had told the police in a communication. )ppearing or the =ar, senior advocate Hali & @ariman lan!ed by senior advocates )nil 9ivan and 1 @ >rishnamani expressed concern over the scandal and also pointed out the possible dent in the image o the judiciay i an &,O was seen interrogating a judge. =ench comprising '(4 =ala!rishnan and (ustices P &athasivam and ( 1 Panchal appeared undecided about the constitution o a committee as suggested by @ariman, it decided to see! the assistance o solicitor general # - Eahanvati to chart out a possible course to deal with the situation.

To !eep the proceedings o the media glare, the bench decided to ta!e up the matter in chamber on (uly 30, when Eahanvati and other senior advocates would ma!e good their assistance to loo! or a way out o the problematic situation. The petition said one )shutosh )sthana, the 'entral @aIir in the judgeship o #haIiabad, had allegedly con essed be ore a magistrate about his role in the PH scam and had allegedly mentioned the names o *< judges who were bene iciaries o the ill%gotten money.

SOS Appeal to S(,AEME O(A# of 5N+5A httpGHHe>clarionofdalit.%logspot.comH0.7.H.DHs>o>s>appeal>to>supreme>I +EALS 5N O(A#S ? ,OL5 E S#A#5ONS AEA+ G httpGHHsites.google.comHsiteHeclarionofdalitHsatyameva>)ayate / httpGHHe>clarionofdalit.%logspot.comH0.77H.7Hsatyameva>)ayate.html / A (SE+ hief Justice of 5ndia httpGHHsites.google.comHsiteHeclarionofdalitHaccused>chief>)ustice>ofI / httpGHHe>clarionofdalit.%logspot.comH0.77H.0Haccused>chief>)ustice>ofI

P:OT-'T4O@ OH 84T@-&&-& 4@ ':414@)" ')&-& P (-&&4') ")" 1U:9-: ')&- L #U():)T, :4OT&

4n the A year old jessica lal murder case , all the accussed M children o rich L mighty have gone scot ree , or lac! o both prosecution L witnesses. The culprits have orced the witnesses to remain silent through the use o muscle L money power. The investigating police o icial, rom the beginning has done roughshod

wor! L also have played a role in silencing witnesses. 4.O 1O:- :4',-: @O8K P:O1OT4O@&K The presiding judge o the court has overloo!ed many omissions L commissions by the prosecution and in a hurry closed the case , ac7uitting all the accussed. :eward or judge M promotion as high court judge. 4n this way, the police%prosecutor%judge were together ganged up against the victim rom the beginning. )lso, the witnesses were a raid o brute muscle power o rowdies L rowdies in !ha!i uni orm. @ow, ta!e the gujarath riots case. 4n the irst place riot too! place under the active patronage o gujarath state government machinery. @aturally the police , prosecutors L judges in gujarath were against the riot victims L closed one case a ter another, ac7uitting the guilty. ,owever the apex court got trans erred riot cases out o gujarath , under public pressure. ,owever, even the apex court ailed to instill con idence , in the prime witness o best ba!ery case , the apex court ailed to positively reassure the witness o her sa ety L livlihood. )s a result , out o changing her statements. 4n this manner, numerous low pro ile cases involving commonman are buried , witnesses silenced by the corrupt nexus o police%prosecutor% judge. They don’t even draw media attention as they are low pro ile. 9rastic re orms o criminal justice system in india is needed. Punishing the hostile witness is not the solution. )ccountability o investigating o icers , police , prosecutors L judges is needed.how come some police o icials , public prosecutors L judges are leading luxurious li estyles, beyond the scope o their legal incomeK ear she became hostile% went on

:ecently in the media there was mention o a '.9 o alleged conversation between samajvadi party 1.P mr.amar singh L U.P chie minister , about in luencing a high court judge L ixing a case. This is the way our judiciary unctions in india. :ewards or corrupt judges M out o turn promotions, post retirement postings , postings to !ith L !in , land allotments , etc. )ccountability o judiciary L investigating agencies is the need o the day. "et us start with polygraph tests or 4.O , PO"4'- , PU="4' P:O&-'UTO: L (U9#- o jessica lal murder case.

:eproduced rom The Times O 4ndia )ugust 3?, *22A page32 8e do rame people, says @'= o icial &ub%4nspector Tell ,' ,ow They Plant 9rugs On 4nnocents )bhinav #arg $ T@@

@ew 9elhi:4t’s been suspected by many, but con irmation o the police alsely implicating people by planting drugs on them has now come rom the policeman himsel who has been accused o planting drugs on two innocent people. &ub%4nspector :anbir &ingh o the @arcotics 'ontrol =ureau .@'=/ admitted at the 9elhi ,igh 'ourt that testing !its or chec!ing banned drugs wereo ten de ective. 8hat’s more o icers o ten replaced the recovered substance with lethal drugs in order to implicate them. ) shoc!ed court has summoned the @'= director to explain the charge. :anbir is himsel tainted o this grave abuse o authority. There is an H4: against him or alsely implicating rwo persons under the harsh @arcotics 9rugs and Psychotropic &ubstances act. ,e claimed to have recovered 322gm heroin rom them which later turned out to be harmless paracetomal powder. The o icer is now see!ing to get the H4: 7uashed and in his de ence has claimed that he was not the only one who ramed people, several other o icers did the same. The (udge has also summoned the >amala 1ar!et @arcotics 'ell in%charge rom whose area &ingh allegedly pic!ed up the two persons.

The 9irector and the 'ell in%charge will have to explain be ore the court as to how these two innocents were boo!ed and thrown into jail when two orensic reports clearly stated that the substance in 7uestion was paracetomol. The case in which &ingh is involved too! place in 1arch last year. #yanender and &antosh were arrested by him or alleged possesion o heroin. The substance was sent or testing to two 'H'" labs%one in :ohini and the other in 'handigarh% and both labs reported bac! that the powder was’nt heroin but just parecetomal. ) ter this came to light, the additional sessions judge hearing the case ac7uited the two men and recommended that an H4: be lodged against &ingh as the two undertrials had to languish in jail because o the wanton abuse o authority. The high court, while hearing a petition iled by &ingh see!ing 7uashing o H4: against him ound it intriguing that even when the investigating team is e7uipped with 5 ield testing !it6 to test the contraband, they had mista!en paracetomal powder or heroin. Upon which &ingh revealed that !its were o ten de ective and that o icers also changed the actual recovered substance with banned contraband.

=,OP)" #)& E-:94'T H4Y-9 % &hame &hame to &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia L &upreme 'ourt o U&)

@ow it is a !nown act that =hopal #as "ea! 'ase Eerdict was H4Y-9 years be ore , 1)T', H4Y-9 by then 1P #overnment 'hie 1inister , 4ndian Prime 1inister and most shame ully 'hie (ustice o 4ndia. @ow The Hinal Eerdict is out in =hopal #as Tragedy . This !ind o 4njustice can only happen in banana republics , where rich croo!s are protected by authorities L courts. &,)1- &,)1- to supreme court o 4ndia , supreme court o U&) L #overnment o U&) , or practicing double standards in en orcement o law L justice.

9ouble standards o supreme court o 4ndia http:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$is%the%supreme%court%o %india%dea %dumb% blind

P4" )ppeal L &how 'ause @otice to &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia http:$$sites.google.com$site$eclariono dalit$pil%appeal%show%cause%notice%to%supreme% court%o %india

4n 4ndia, Havorable treatment is given by police L courts o law or rich croo!s where as poor innocents are harassed , tortured by the very same police L judges . 4n india &ome 1P , 1")s even ta!e money or as!ing 7uestions in parliament $ legislature , Havourable laws are enacted to legaliIe crimes o rich croo!s or example : 4llegal land encroachments by rich croo!s. The same 1Ps , 1")s are not aware about problems o poor public , they don’t even open their mouth or as!ing 7uestions on wel are o poor , let alone enact laws or wel are o poor. @o government law , no decisions o judges , no orders o public servants are sacrosanct . ,ereby , e%voice urges the supreme court o india , 3. To legally prosecute the jurisdictional police who changed the charge sheet , who let out 1ain criminal)nderson illegally without orders rom the court. *. To legally prosecute the &&P , 9' o the district , Then 'hie 1inister o 1adhya Pradesh L Then Prime 1inister o #O4 , who ully aided the main accussed , criminal )nderson to escape , to jump law. <. To legally prosecute 4ndian Public &ervants , who were responsible or withdrawing the case rom U& 'ourts o (ustice. 0. To legally prosecute Then 'hie (ustice o 4ndia (ustice )hmadi L ,is bench colleagues , who diluted the case by changing the clause under which )nderson L others were charged.

The Public servants M 1ps , 1")s , (udges , 4)& $ 4P& o icers , Police ta!e thousands o rupees monthly salary , cars , bungalows , +%star hotel stay together with +%star meal complete with alchoholic drin!s , +%star health care at premium hospitals , business class air travel , oreign tours , etc all at tax payer’s expense. ) ter enjoying to the hilt at taxpayer’s expense , these same public servants don’t serve the public , they serve the rich croo!s , anti nationals in their greed or more money.

)ll the while the same poor tax payer su ers without justice . 4n 4ndia more than +2 'rore people are barely surviving on a single piece meal ."et the corrupt public servants eat their +%star meals by the side o the graves o =hopal #as Eictims. )tleast this will open the eyes o honest ew in public service M police , judiciary L parliament , it is a ond hope. This is an appeal to those honest ew in judiciary , police L parliament to catch hold o their corrupt colleagues.

'ormer S

)udge wants eF> J5 pro%ed for corruption

4n the wa!e o allegations that ormer 'hie (ustice o 4ndia > # =ala!rishnan’s relatives have amassed property worth crores, a long%retired &upreme 'ourt judge on 1onday demanded that the 'entre initiate a probe against him. 8ith reports appearing in the local media, ormer &upreme 'ourt judge .retd/ (ustice E : >rishna 4yer on 1onday led calls or a thorough in7uiry into the allegations a day a ter a local TE news channel made the stunning expose. 54 mysel eel sad that 4 was a judge. 4 used to say that an era had begun when > # =ala!rishnan became the irst 9alit chie justice. @ow, 4 don’t eel that way,’’ said the ormer &upreme 'ourt judge. ,e pointed out that there were allegations against =ala!rishnan’s daughter, son%in%law and even mother%in%law. 5) commission comprising chie justices should probe the assets and ban! balances o all o =ala!rishnan’s relatives,’’ he said in >ochi. ) leading jurist and ormer &upreme 'ourt judge, (ustice 4yer urged Parliament and the Prime 1inister to appoint a high%powered commission to in7uire into the issue. 5The President must re7uire politely =ala!rishnan to resign,6 (ustice 4yer said o (ustice =ala!rishnan who is the @ational ,uman :ights 'ommission 'hairman. )s reported, (ustice =ala!rishnan’s son%in%law P E &reenijin, who is a member o the >erala Pradesh 'ongress 'ommittee, had contested the *22? )ssembly election rom the @ara!!al reserved constituency in -rna!ulam district. )t that time, while iling his nomination papers, &reenijin had declared he possessed no landed property and that his wi e had only gold worth :s 0.<C la!h and a little over :s 3 la!h in cash. Three years later, &reenijin and his wi e > = &ony, both lawyers, declared :s <+ la!h while iling their income tax returns. ,owever, according to reports now, the couple, who have not declared any sources o income other than their legal pro ession, own property worth crores and are constructing a river% ront resort in Thrissur. &everal o these properties are worth many times more than the amounts or which they have been registered. The 'P1’s youth wing, the 9DH4, has claimed that whatever in ormation had come out was only the tip o the ice%berg. 58e have more evidence to prove that the ormer '(4’s relatives have property in 9ubai, =angalore and Tamil @adu. The needle o suspicion naturally points to (ustice =ala!rishnan himsel ,’’ said 9DH4 state president and 1P 1 = :ajesh. &reenijin has re used to answer 7uestions rom mediapersons saying he will react later. (ustice =ala!rishnan was also recently embroiled in a controversy over a letter written by a 1adras ,igh 'ourt judge to him complaining against ormer Telecom minister ) :aja having tried to in luence him over phone. Hor the record, 9elhi%based journalist 1 Hur7uan in (une this year petitioned Eice% President ,amid )nsari or a '=4 investigation against =ala!rishnan and his amily 5 or inding out how much inancial assets they have .allegedly/ accumulated since he too! over as the '(4’’.

)nsari had passed on the complaint to the Union ,ome 1inistry which in turn handed it over to the '=4. The complaint is reported to be with the '=4 >ochi unit now.

DOU TOO, DOU: ,O@OU:K #he retired )udge pic"ed to pro%e the $arnata"a land scams has a Jtsunami of scandals2 in his past/ reports 5MAAN $@AN

&O1- T,4@#& just seem to get worse. Under pressure to 7uit or alleged corruption in land allotment, >arnata!a 'hie 1inister =& Deddyurappa inally constituted a one%man commission to probe alleged land scams since 3OO+. Deddyurappa chose retired >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt judge, (ustice = Padmaraj. The opposition, which was gunning or the chie minister, appeared satis ied and stopped its campaign. =ut, (ustice Padmaraj, it appears, has something in his past that ought to have dis7uali ied him rom heading the probe. 4n *22A, a (oint "egislature 'ommittee .("'/ indicted (ustice Padmaraj and C0 other ,' and &upreme 'ourt judges or owning plots in the >arnata!a &tate (udicial 9epartment -mployees ,ouse =uilding 'o%operative &ociety. )ccording to the ("', the society had created Ban all 4ndia record or being the mother o all illegalities’ and was ormed by Bunleashing a tsunami o scandals’. 'onstituted in (une *22?, the ("' was headed by )T :amaswamy and had 30 1")s and six 1"'s. 4t was entrusted with the objective o investigating land encroachments in =engaluru. The )T :amaswamy report ound that the society had violated the >arnata!a "and :e orms )ct by ac7uiring <? acres o private agricultural land in =engaluru @orth Talu! without prior permission o the government. ) (oint "egislature 'ommittee indicted The "and :e orms )ct stipulates that any such ac7uired land (ustice Padmaraj and C0 shall be or eited a ter a summary in7uiry by the assistant other judges in a *22A commissioner concerned. The ("' also ound that the land scam residential layout did not see! approval rom the =angalore 9evelopment )uthority .=9)/ U the planning authority under the >arnata!a Town and 'ountry Planning )ct. Hurther, the report notes that 5the ,ouse =uilding 'o%operative &ociety then submitted its layout to the 'ity 1unicipal 'ouncil, Delahan!a, which is not the planning authority or the society land. The ("' also ound that the layout violated norms or the allocation o civic amenities and par!s. Town planning norms mandate *+ percent or civic amenities, while the original layout plan envisage only + percent. The ("' also 7uestioned the appropriateness o both sitting and retired judges being allotted sites. 4t wrote: 5The society has allotted sites to persons who are ineligible or allotment o sites as judicial employees. 1ost noteworthy o such ineligible persons are the ,' judges, many o whom have been allotted sites.6 &hoc!ed at the extent o corruption perpetuated by the judiciary, the ("' noted: 5The society, which should have been a model to others, has become the leading lawbrea!er

without ear or care o law, property or public interest.6 This is a strong indictment. &o how did Deddy pic! PadmarajK

-x%'(4’s wealth under scanner

>O',4: There is no respite or (ustice > # =ala!rishnan, ormer '(4 and present @,:' 'hairman, rom controversies. 'lose on the heels o the ) :aja episode, he has landed in trouble with allegations erupting over his assets. ) '=4 in7uiry into the amassment o wealth by him is now on the cards. The '=4 is awaiting a ormal nod rom the :egistrar%#eneral o the &upreme 'ourt, which is a legal re7uirement, to launch a probe into his mysterious assets. '=4 sources have con irmed the receipt o a complaint against =ala!rishnan by a 9elhi% based journalist. The journalist, in his complaint iled be ore the Eice%President’s o ice, alleged that the ormer '(4 had amassed wealth disproportionate to his !nown sources o income. The Eice% President’s o ice orwarded the complaint to the Union ,ome 1inistry which in turn orwarded it to the '=4. 58e have received the complaint but no investigation has been launched. 4t will be launched only a ter getting an o icial nod. The &upreme 'ourt :egistrar%#eneral is the competent authority to give sanction or the probe,6 said sources in the >erala unit o the '=4. =ut, it is reliably learnt that a 7uic! veri ication o assets o (ustice =ala!rishnan’s daughter > = &ony and her husband P E &reenijin indicated that everything was not hun!y%dory. &reenijin, a >P'' member, has allegedly amassed wealth to the tune o several crores in the past our years. &reenijin, who had declared only assets worth :s *+,222 in the a idavit iled in the *22? )ssembly polls .he was the 'ongress candidate rom @jarac!al,/ now owns several prime properties, including a riverside plot o *.+ acres at )nnamanada in Thrissur. ,e and his wi e &ony have also ac7uired a lat in the city, a plum o ice space near the ,igh 'ourt and *+ cents o land at -lama!!ara .in the suburbs o >ochi/ where the construction o a bungalow is in progress. =oth &reenijin and &ony are practising advocates and don’t have any other !nown sources o income.

The state unit o the 9DH4 has also called or a detailed in7uiry into the allegations and demanded the resignation o (ustice =ala!rishnan as @,:' chie . The resh controversy will land (ustice =ala!rishnan in a precarious position as he has already been under a cloud ollowing &upreme 'ourt (udge , " #o!hale’s revelation regarding ormer Telecom 1inister ) :aja’s bid to in luence a 'hennai ,igh 'ourt judge.

Hive%star jails o 4ndia

4n a raid on 1eerut (ail led by the 94# o )gra (ail to recover and seiIe cell phones and other unauthorised and prohibited items, there was a ight between the jail police and inmates o the high%security prison. 4t le t six police o icials and our inmates injured. The raiding 94# said, 54t could not have happened without the connivance o jail o icials. 8e had special instructions rom the home department as 1eerut (ail is !nown or its lawlessness. =ut we were shoc!ed when a thou%sand%strong mob attac!ed us with stic!s and stones. 8e were trapped and could only escape a ter we charged towards the gate.6 The prisoners snatched away all the mobile phones and contra%band recovered during the chec! that was ordered at the instance o the &tate #overnment. The 94# has accused the superintendent o 1eerut (ail o 5inciting the jail inmates to attac! us so that we could not ind prohibited articles in the jail6. On the other hand, the jail superintendent has accused the 94# o demanding illegal grati ication. &ome sta has been suspended. The other orm o corruption reported rom the 1eerut (ail included unauthorised sale o items at exorbitant prices. 'igarettes were being sold or :s *2 per stic!. 4t cost :s +22 or a meal o choice. ) local call could be made or :s *2, an &T9 call cost :s 322. The 1eerut (ail, built to house A22 inmates, now has 3,C+2 prisoners. ) ormer Uttar Pradesh 1inister, serving his sentence in "uc!now (ail or the murder o his mistress 1adhumita &hu!la, reely hosted a wedding anniversary bash or a co% accused in the murder case inside the jail premises. ) sitting 1inister when as!ed replied, 5@o one is born a criminal and the &amajwadi Party believes in trans ormation o criminals. Dou can’t stop anyone rom celebrating an occasion concerning him, his amily or near and dear ones M within the premises o the jail. )s per my !nowledge, there was no violation o the jail manual.6 4n *220, three accused involved in the assassination o Punjab 'hie 1inister =eant &ingh escaped scandalously rom the =urail (ail in 'handigarh. 4nspection o the jail showed that the high pro ile prisoners were not only leading a luxurious li e, but they had also enclosed their cells in a way that their activities inside could not be !ept under vigil. Once the cell was turned into a virtual ortress, the prisoners dug a tunnel to escape.

The escape o terrorists involved in one o the most high%pro ile assassinations could not have materialised simply through a nexus between corrupt jail sta ers and the prisoners. East sums o money as well as a pattern o internal and external intimidation was necessary to create the conditions or the eventual brea!out and a signi icant networ! o support was essential to ma!e sure that the ugitives could evade the police system once they were out. The escape o Phoolan 9evi’s !illers rom high security Tihar (ail and other similar escapes o prisoners highlight the ineptitude and complicity o jail sta . Tihar (ail is actually a complex o seven prisons, having a capacity o 0,222 prisoners. =ut actually there are more than 3*,222 prisoners lodged there. :egrettably, there is no ixed rule as to how many prisoners can be lodged in a particular jail. The ollowing is the existing jail system. There are two categories o jails M district jails normally built or 022 prisoners each and central jails or A+2 each. The jail sta members are not rom the police and have their own distinct hierarchy. There are di erent categories o under%trial prisoners depending upon their education and social status. 'ourts have directed jails to do away with the colonial, vintage classi ication o under%trial prisoners into 'lass 4, 44 and 444, based on their socio%economic status, but #overnment continues to stic! to the old practice. &elected prisoners are used or the internal management o jails M to ma!e up or manpower shortage M as well as administrative wor!. The convict% supervisors become a lin! between the prisoners and jail o icials. They are given an incentive or their wor!. )ny wrong placement or selection can lead to the escape o prisoners or other crimes going unchec!ed inside the jails. The 4ndira #andhi #overnment had set up a high%powered panel in 3OC2 to propose prison re orms. The apparent cause was 1rs #andhi’s irst%hand experience o the conditions in Tihar where she was lodged in 3OAC. 1rs #andhi appointed the (ustice )@ 1ulla 'ommittee to review the national jail system even though jail is a &tate #overnment subject. The 1ulla 'ommittee, 3OC<, recommended that the 'onstitution be amended to shi t the subject o prisons rom the &tate "ist to the 'oncurrent "ist. That never happened. The 'entre at present has no say in the matter o jails except when they are in Union Territories where, again, jails are ar rom being models. The result is that jails continue to be governed by an outdated law enacted by the =ritish in 3CO0. The position is that the jail conditions vary greatly rom one &tate to another or even rom prison to prison. There is no national policy on prisons. ) sensible recommendation o the 1ulla 'ommittee was to classi y prisons into special security, maximum, medium and minimum security prisons. &uch a classi ication can serve as a sa eguard against jailbrea!s and jail riots. 1uch be ore sting operations became a norm with the media, a hard%hitting report had shown that in the Tihar (ail, o icials mixed with notorious inmates li!e 'harles &obraj who ran an extensive drug and li7uor rac!et with impunity. This led to a secret visit o the then ,ome 1inister #iani Nail &ingh to Tihar (ail. ,e was stunned to see a drun!en prisoner o ering him a bottle o li7uor. ) morti ied #overnment inally suspended two jail o icials.

'riminalisation o politics has produced a strange phenomenon. 'riminals have contested elections rom behind the bars and some o them have won. #iven such topsy% turvy world o politics, prison o icials are o ten either unmind ul o the crimes being committed regularly inside the prisons, or sometimes they are the ones to provide prisoners with mobile phones, drugs and ood. These jail sta ers also organise !avi sammelans and mushairas and help prisoners run extortion rac!ets and criminal gangs rom inside the jails. ) prison or some prisoners has become a home away rom home. The next issue is that o under%trials. )ccording to the statistics compiled by the 'ustodial (ustice 'ell o the @ational ,uman :ights 'ommission, **+,C3A o <20,CO< or A0.2? per cent o the total prison population in the country comprises those awaiting trial. The total jail capacity in 4ndia is *<*,03* prisoners, which ma!es the total prison population <3 per cent higher than capacity, clearly emphasising the urgent need or a speedier justice mechanism. Only when politicians go to jail do they tal! about re orming the jail system. They orget the issue the moment they are out. 8e must be clear as to what !ind o con inement or jail system we want. The time to ma!e a beginning is now be ore things get worse. There must be a 'entral law to be ollowed as a model by all &tates.

No restrictions at Arthur Aoad )ail/ gangsters ta"e leave at will

Pune: ) highly con idential in7uiry report by the 1aharashtra prison department has revealed that several !ey undertrials, including 1ohammad 9ossa, underworld don% turned%politician )run #awli and 9> :ao .the right%hand man o ugitive gangster 'hhota :ajan/, among others, reely availed o 5leave6 out o the )rthur :oad jail in 1umbai over the last three years.

The jail authorities neither reported the leave granted to these high%pro ile undertrials to senior prison authorities, nor did they raise objections to the leave applications in court. ) senior prison o icer told 9@) that the in7uiry report has been sent to the state home department or action as it has exposed corrupt practices at the jail. 4ronically, o icials o the state prison department have none other than *?$33 accused 1ohammed )jmal )mir a!a >asab to than! or the revelation o this nexus between the prison authorities and the undertrials. &ources told 9@) that when the undertrials, including :ao and #awli, were shi ted to Taloja in @avi 1umbai, they started demanding similar treatment at the new jail premises. They were shi ted to Taloja so that maximum protection could be provided to >asab, who was to be lodged at the )rthur :oad jail.

5The undertrials continued to demand leave at Taloja as they had at )rthur :oad,6 said an o icial, adding that the authorities at Taloja then reported the matter to senior prison authorities in Pune and 1umbai. Hormer superintendent o )rthur :oad jail &wati &athe, who is currently posted in @ashi!, said she was unaware o any in7uiry. 4t was during &athe’s tenure that the 5in luential undertrials6 availed o leave. The in7uiry revealed that leave extended rom a ew hours to even a couple o days. 4t also ound that this practice had been going on at the jail or nearly three years. The authorities did not deny leave to around 0+ gangsters, most o whom are boo!ed under the stringent 1aharashtra 'ontrol o Organised 'rime )ct, 3OOO. One undertrial gangster was ound to have 5gone on leave6 on <+ occasions, the report said. The 1aharashtra Prisons 1anual has no provision to grant leave to undertrials, as is allowed in the case o convicts lodged in jails. 4t is customary or an undertrial to obtain permission rom a court in order to avail leave. The in7uiry revealed that none o the 0+ undertrials sent their applications via the jail o icials. They were directly sent to court. &igni icantly, the authorities at )rthur :oad jail ailed to appeal against this. The jail authorities also ailed to report the leave ta!en by the under%trials to the state government, which generally alerts the police machinery to !eep a close watch on the activities o the suspects. &tate prisons chie , inspector%general o police Uddhav >amble con irmed to 9@) the commissioning o the in7uiry, but re used to elaborate. ) senior o icial o the prison department con irmed the developments as well. )nother senior jail o icial explained that leave is only granted to an under%trial by the court or emergency situations, li!e the demise or serious health condition o the next%o % !in, besides attending the marriage o his$her children. "eave can also be availed or emergency medical treatment at the private hospitals, but only under the supervision o the jail authorities. ,owever the under%trials went on leave to attend marriages and death o distant relatives, other minor health issues o amily members and even their companions. >amble sought a detailed record rom the deputy inspector general o police .prisons/, 1umbai, o all the leave awarded by the courts. The 94#, 1umbai conducted an in7uiry and ound the involvement o )rthur :oad (ail o icials. )nother in7uiry was commissioned to veri y the indings o the 94#’s report. 4n Pune, ** inmates have been missing rom the Derawada 'entral Prison a ter they were granted parole or urlough in the past <2 years. 1umbai%based gangster Eijay Thopte who was accused in the murder o union leader 9atta &amant and )run #awli gang member -!nath )rjun 1ohite o =hosari are among

those missing rom the Derawada jail. 8hile Thopte has been missing a ter he was granted parole a year ago, 1ohite, who has several cases registered against him with the Pune city and rural police units, has been missing or more than a year now.

1ight @ot ,ave :ecommended Parole Hor 1anu: Pilot

9isapproving the grant o parole to (essica "all murder convict 1anu &harma, who also happens to be the son o an in luential ,aryana 'ongress leader, 'ongress leader &achin Pilot has said that he might not have recommended parole to the li er had he been the chie minister o 9elhi. 54 personally believe that perhaps more diligence should have been made be ore issuing these orders. The act that he has already gone bac! .to jail/ does not ma!e a di erence now,6 Pilot said while participating in a TE programme. )s!ed whether it was a mista!e or the 9elhi government to have recommended parole or &harma, Pilot said, 58ell 4 am not 9elhi chie minister. Hrom whatever 4 !now o the case, i 4 was the chie minister 4 would probably not have given the parole6. &harma was granted parole a ter chie minister &heila 9i!shit recommended it. &harma, who had applied or the parole on the ground o per orming religious rites or his grandmother .who died in *22C/, attending to his ailing U later modi ied to Bageing’ U mother, and business matters, in 'handigarh. &igni icantly, the 9elhi Police has gone on record to say that it had opposed the grant o parole. 4t has been reported that the 9elhi government has so ar received 3<* parole applications this year out o which as many as CC are still pending, << were rejected and 33 applicants were granted parole. 9i!shit had so ar been under ire or justi ying her decision, saying that it was within the 5legal purview6 only rom the opposition =(P and legal luminaries, who had so ar been protesting that it was a blatant case o partisanship. @ot only was 1anu &harma granted parole on limsy grounds, and his parole extended by another month on the recommendation by 9i!shit, he clearly violated the parole conditions as well. Opposition =(P points out that 1anu &harma’s ather Eenod &harma, who is an in luential 'ongress leader in ,aryana, played a major role in ensuring that the 'ongress government in ,aryana could be sworn. ,e is believed to have been instrumental in getting the support o not only the seven independents but also the de ectors rom ,aryana (anhit 'ongress which now only has >uldeep =ishnoi le t because as many as ive o his 1")s joined 'ongress on 1onday. &achin Pilot is the irst 'ongress leader who has gone on record to even mildly express disagreement over the issue.

@obody would have !nown

8hat is even more signi icant is that the news o (essica "al murder convict U who is serving a li e sentence or having shot dead the 9elhi model on )pril *O, 3OOO at the Tamarind 'ourt =ar U being out on parole came to public notice only because he was yet again involved in a brawl in a nightclub. Observers point out that the brawl on the night o @ovember ? at H bar in @ew 9elhi’s )sho!a hotel that 1anu &harma and &ahil 9hingra got involved with Pranay 9adwal and his emale riend may even have gone unreported or been hushed up had 9elhi police commissioner’s own son not been involved in the case. The argument turned ugly and Pranay 9adwal in ormed his ather, who happens to be none other than 9elhi Police 'ommissioner D.&. 9adwal. 4t was because o this that a jeepload o cops landed up at the bar. =y then 1anu &harma and his riends had le t H bar and moved to the exclusive ")P bar in the adjacent &amrat hotel, which is owned by 1umbai ilm actor and model )rjun :ampal. =y the time the police reached ")P, 1anu had escaped. The police pic!ed up 9hingra, and it was only on going through the ''TE video coverage that it could be con irmed that the person accompanying 9hingra was none other than the high pro ile 1anu &harma who, most people assumed, should have been in jail. 4t was only then that it came to light that he had not only been granted parole, it had even been extended, while he had been out there partying at various nightclubs and bars, not only in 'handigarh, where he was supposed to be or the period o his parole, but also in 9elhi. Observers also point out how thee is nothing new in the subversion o justice in 1anu &harma’s case, as the powers that be had almost ensured his ac7uittal in the (essica "al murder case, which got re%opened because o an unprecedented media and public campaign.

')@ (U9#-1-@T =- 1)@4PU")T-9 4@ 4@94)@ 'OU:T& OH (U&T4'- K M 8,D @OT P:4&O@ &-@T-@'- HO: #U4"TD &UP:-1- 'OU:T )9EO')T-& K

@ew 9elhi, )ugust *3 The 9elhi ,igh 'ourt imposed a our%month ban on senior advocate : > )nand and colleague 4 U >han on Thursday or inter ering with judicial proceedings in the high%pro ile =18 hit%and% run case. ) ine o :s *,222 was levied as well.

On 1ay <2, *22A, television channel @9TE caught both lawyers in a 5sting6 operation, conniving with !ey prosecution witness &uniel >ul!arni to get main accused &anjeev @anda o the hoo!. ) ,igh 'ourt =ench comprising (ustices 1adan = "o!ur and 1anmohan &arin ound the two guilty o criminal contempt. 5The entire material leaves a bitter taste in the mouth about the goings%on in the =18 case. There is no manner o doubt whatsoever that there was complicity between 1r >han and 1r )nandT There can be absolutely no doubt that 1r >han and 1r )nand were, somehow or the other, more than mixed up in the =18 case,6 observed the court, which had ta!en suo motu cogniIance o the expose the day a ter it was aired. 51r )nand and 1r >han are prohibited rom appearing in this court .9elhi ,igh 'ourt/ or courts subordinate to it or our months rom today. ,owever, they are ree to discharge their pro essional duties in terms o consultation, advice, con erences, opinions, etc,6 said the =ench. The court desisted rom commenting on the conduct o >ul!arni, saying it would not be 5proper6 to do so. Though the verdict comes solely on basis o the '9s and transcripts o the sting operation, the =ench said, 5the unsha!eable truth is that 1r )nand is guilty o criminal contempt o court6. 'ontemplating a it punishment, the =ench wondered how many in the legal raternity had had been ta!en by surprise to ind )nand indulging in such 5sharp practices6. 51r )nand has held many prestigious elective positions in the legal raternity, including the =ar 'ouncil o 9elhi. ,e has also been a 1ember o the :ajya &abha,6 noted the =ench. The court said it !new >han or his legal acumen and orensic s!ills U 5perhaps the reason why he was appointed &pecial Public Prosecutor in the =18 case6. ,igh expectations over >han ell apart when his conduct 5betrayed the trust that prosecution reposed in himT what he did was perhaps beyond the realm o contemplation o the prosecuting agency6. 'hastising the two or their misconduct, the =ench said: 58e are not dealing with a young lawyer who, driven by ambition and desireT transgresses the limits or unwittingly or un!nowingly commits criminal contempt. 8e are dealing with senior advocates, who are expected to conduct themselves as gentlemen and role models or younger members o the =ar.6 The court orwarded a recommendation that the two be 5stripped o their designations as senior advocates6. The ,igh 'ourt :egistrar #eneral will put up the court’s recommendation be ore 'hie (ustice )P &hah within a month. 4n response to the verdict, the 9elhi =ar )ssociation president, advocate :ajiv >hosla, said about *2,222 lawyers rom district courts were going on stri!e on )ugust ** in protest.

: > )nand

=egan legal career in 9elhi’s Tis ,aIari 'ourt as a civil lawyer in 3O?A. )ppointed government counsel in 3OA?. 4n *222, (11 nominated him to :ajya &abha rom (har!hand. )ppointed )4'' observer or )ssembly polls in ,imachal Pradesh in Hebruary *22<. ,igh%pro ile cases: ] 4n 3OC2, represented the late 4ndira #andhi in a property litigation iled by 1ane!a #andhi a ter &anjay #andhi’s death ] @arasimha :ao in the (11 bribery and the &t >itts case ] 'handraswami in the H-:) violation case ] , > " =hagat in the 3OC0 anti%&i!h riots case ] Hormer external a airs minister @atwar &ingh’s son (agat &ingh in the murder$suicide o his wi e @atasha &ingh 4 U >han One o the top ive criminal lawyers in 'apital. ,e was charging a ee o only :e 3 in the =18 case. =egan his career in late 3O?2s, and came into spotlight in 3OC2s. ] 9e ended &ushil &harma in the tandoor murder case, &ubash #upta in the Personal Point triple murder, ormer Douth 'ongress President :omesh &harma in several cases and Tony #ill in (essica "all murdercase 8hen prosecution L de ence lawyer together team up along with corrupt police $ public servants and manipulate evidences $ records , the court is helpless and will ac7uit the accussed or lac! o evidences eventhough the presiding judge is o impeccable integrity , honesty , he is help less. )dd to this , i the presiding judge happens to be corrupt L teams up with the criminal nexus , the result is devastating , the rich criminal will get away L the innocent will su er punishment in some cases even death sentence. 8ho will bell these ew corrupt among the judiciary , bar , police L public service K why not prison sentence or two leading advocates on criminal charges o contempt o court , destruction o evidences K are they above law K why avouritism by court to the guilty in awarding punishment to guilty two advocates as they happen to be political in luential K will the court let a common man so leniently or the same charges K 4n the past cases dealt by these corrupt duo advocates , there are possibilities that the same tactics o manipulation o evidences , prosecution is done to win the cases , to ree the rich criminals , why not review o the cases dealt by these corrupt advocates K The honest ew among judiciary , bar , police L public service must uphold our constitution , rule o law L bring to boo! their corrupt colleagues.

')&, HO: (U9#-1-@T

'handigarh, )ugust **: Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt (udge @irmal Dadav who has gone on leave a ter her name is said to have igured in the statements o the main accused in the case involving the delivery o cash at another ,igh 'ourt (udge’s house, said today that she was a 5victim o a vili ication campaign.6 &pea!ing to The 4ndian -xpress at her &ector *0 residence here today, (ustice Dadav said that 5some in luential persons were trying to shi t the ocus on her to save the real accused.6 (ustice Dadav denied that ormer ,aryana )dditional )dvocate #eneral &anjeev =ansal had tal!ed to her on phone on )ugust 3< when =ansal’s cler! 5mista!enly6 delivered a bag containing :s 3+ la!h to the residence o (ustice @irmaljit >aur, another sitting (udge o the ,igh 'ourt. 5"et any agency prove that 4 tal!ed to &anjeev =ansal on phone either on that day or any day in the past one month,6 (ustice Dadav said. 54 am ready to ace all conse7uences i this allegation is ound true. 4 have had no dealings with =ansal. 4 have not received any money rom =ansal or any o his associates. 4 am sure 4 will get justice.6 (ustice Dadav said she had explained her position to ,igh 'ourt 'hie (ustice T & Tha!ur and had 5proceeded on leave.6 &he said she would not hear any case until her name is cleared. &ources close to her said that during her meeting with (ustice Tha!ur yesterday evening, in which some other senior judges were also present, (ustice Dadav o ered to proceed on leave to 5maintain the highest traditions o 4ndian judiciary.6 (ustice Tha!ur told The 4ndian -xpress that he had not as!ed (ustice Dadav to proceed on leave and that it was her own decision. 4t is learnt that in her meeting with (ustice Tha!ur, Dadav vehemently denied any role in the entire role. 8hile ac!nowledging that she and some other members o her amily had bought a plot o 33.3 bighas o land .see accompanying story/ at village :ihun Pargana near >umharhatti in &olan district o ,imachal Pradesh on )ugust 30, Dadav is learnt to have denied that the money or purchasing the land came rom =ansal or :avinder &ingh, the 9elhi businessman, who is also named in the case. 5'an’t a judge buy legal propertyK "et the police or any other investigating agency prove that the money or the deal was provided by =ansal or &ingh,6 she is learnt to have told the 'hie (ustice. =ut she is learnt to have ac!nowledged, in her meeting with the 'hie (ustcie, that she !new :avinder &ingh. &he is learnt to have said that she came to !now him through some other judges. 1eanwhile, highly placed sources in the ,igh 'ourt con irmed that 'hie (ustice Tha!ur is awaiting the return o 'hie (ustice o 4ndia ># =ala!rishnan rom =raIil to apprise him o the developments in the case. The 'hie (ustice is learnt to have as!ed the administrative committee, comprising senior judges, to monitor the case on a daily basis. The :s 3+%la!h delivery: &tory &o Har `)ugust 3<: Par!ash :am, an assistant to ,aryana’s )dditional )dvocate #eneral &anjeev =ansal, delivers a parcel containing :s 3+ la!h at the residence o (ustice @irmaljit >aur o the Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt. (ustice >aur calls the police. `:ajeev #upta, =ansal’s riend and a property dealer, tells the police that the money reached there by mista!e and it was meant or @irmal &ingh, another property dealer. 'handigarh Police decline to hand over the cash. =ansal is 7uestioned

`)ugust 3?: ) case is registered against =ansal, Par!ash :am and 9elhi% based hotelier :avinder &ingh who allegedly organised the money `=ansal resigns as )ddl )# and surrenders on )ugust 3O `)ugust *3: :ajeev #upta, the property dealer who claimed the money was meant or @irmal &ingh, is arrested. The 4nspector #eneral o Police sends a report to the 'hie (ustice o Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt. The report says that the money was meant or another judge. `)ugust **: (ustice @irmal Dadav proceeds on leave

'aught in controversy is &olan plot that judge, 3? others purchased

',)@94#):,, &O")@, )ugust **: On )ugust 30, according to revenue records, a plot measuring 33.3 bighas in &olan was purchased by (ustice @irmal Dadav and others or :s +, +*, +22. 9etails o the transaction, obtained by The 4ndian -xpress, show that the land was purchased by her and 3? others rom six persons, all residents o village :ihun Pargana, near >umharhatti in the &olan district o ,imachal Pradesh. This purchase is said to have igured in the meeting between (ustice Dadav and the ,igh 'ourt 'hie (ustice yesterday. (ustice Dadav is said to have told the 'hie (ustice: 5'an’t a judge buy legal propertyK "et the police or any other investigating agency prove that the money or the deal was provided by .&anjeev/ =ansal or :avinder &ingh.6 The purchasers and sellers obtained permission rom the ,imachal Pradesh #overnment under &ection 33C o the ,imachal Pradesh Tenancy )ct. &olan @aib Tehsildar @ & 'hauhan has con irmed on record that that the deal had been registered as per the details we have. The land was sold by residents o village including =aldev; @arinder >umar; &urinder >umar; :ajinder >umar; =imla 9evi and )mar &ingh. The sellers have given a #eneral Power o )ttorney to &urinder >umar .one o the partners among the sellers/, who executed a sale agreement in avour o the buyers. Those named as purchasers .partners/ in the land deal include &uruchi, a resident o ,ouse no. <, &ector 30, #urgaon; Trisha 'haudhary; :am @iwas; :ajender Dadav; 'hiranjeev; "ati!a; 9eepa!; &unita; Eive!; 'apt. @T Puri; 9evinder &ingh; &ha!untla; >uldip &ingh Dadav; )jay Dadav; &ushan! Puri; 1ohit .all residents o house no. 3333, &ector 33, Panch!ula/ and Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt (ustice @irmal Dadav.

Three boo!ed in judge bribery case

,aryana )ddl )dvocate #eneral among boo!ed 'handigarh, )ugust 3?: Three persons, including )dditional )dvocate #eneral o ,aryana &anjeev =ansal, were on &aturday boo!ed or an attempt to bribe a Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt (udge. The other two

are =ansal’s munshi Par!ash, who had carried :s 3+ la!h to the residence o ,igh 'ourt judge @irmaljit >aur on 8ednesday night, and :avinder &ingh, a 9elhi%based businessman who has a hotel in >arol =agh. The munshi was ta!en into custody while a police party has been despatched to 9elhi to nab &ingh. )ssistant &uperintendent o Police 1adhur Eerma said the amount was supposed to be handed over to some other public servant but was mista!enly delivered at >aur’s house. )n H4: was lodged a ter >aur complained to the police. &he also reported the matter to the 'hie (ustice. Police said &ingh had allegedly paid =ansal a huge amount to get settled a criminal case pending in the ,igh 'ourt. The case is due to come up or hearing on 8ednesday. -arlier, &ingh had claimed the amount was pertaining to a property deal he had struc! with a resident o Panch!ula. The money was supposed to be delivered to one @irmal &ingh and was mista!enly delivered at the judge’s house. Eerma, however, said the preliminary investigation had ruled out the possibility o the amount being related to any property deal. 5=ansal ailed to give a detailed account o the cash. ,e produced some papers pertaining to some property in Panch!ula but that did not carry any weight. Our investigations caught him on the wrong oot and, there ore, we boo!ed him along with two others under the Prevention o 'orruption )ct and criminal conspiracy,6 he added. =ansal has been handling several high%pro ile cases. ,e is one o the doIen%odd )dditional )dvocate #enerals appointed by the ,aryana #overnment about two years ago.

'orrupt judge in )llahabad ,igh 'ourt by :ajeev

4 the (udges go corrupt, then it is #O9 who will give one justice when one go to heaven or hell. 4t is a 4rony that 4 iled a complaint against a 9istrict and &ession (udge who later promoted to ,igh 'ourt o )llahabad. 4 wish the #od will serve ,4& justice to ,on’ble (ustice Umeshware Pandey, now enjoying at ,igh 'ourt and selling .1is/(ustice at :s 322222 per pageZZ ,ere 4 am elaborating what had happened. 4n 3OO0, two people name Parashram )garwal and 1ohan "al )garwal wanted to grab my ather’s property and in 1arch 3OO0 they beat him and pulled his legs. just imagine the pain/ ma!ing him handicapped or li e. Then in court those guys were merely sentenced or ? months in (ail, but they did not went or the jail or single day or hour and appealed to &essions 'ourt and then the corrupt (udge Umeshwar Pandey too! the bribe o :s *22222 in 'riminal :evision number 3<$*222 rom Parashram )garwal and 1ohan "al. 4t is a shame on Umeshwar Pandey that he cannot see a ,andicapped man su ering or last O years and even then not given the justice. Umeshwar Pandey has ta!en this bribe via his &teno name some #. 9. #upta. 4t is the habit o Parashram and 1ohan"al to record the conversation while giving bribes on hidden audio recorder and the same cassette can be recovered i the authority try. 4t is been C months since 4 have in ormed various authorities by registered letters and phone calls rom U&) or no action till date.

4 have spo!en to 1r (agmohan Paliwal who was posted as Eigilance O icer or no action till date and the recording attached is rom &ept *22*. &imilarly 4 have spo!en with 1r.

>. &. :a!hra who was posted as :egistrar #eneral but no action till date, and the recoding shown is rom &ept *22* too. -ven '=4 has orwarded my letter to :egistrar #eneral, but no action is ta!en on that one too.

4 have emaild my plea to ew ,igh court (udges too or no response. 4 just hope #O9 is there who will give some justice. =ut the corrupt (udges should stop imitating as #O9 they are devil actually. The only solution can be people ma!e a limit. ,ow much money a person needs. 4 o ten thin! about a story that a saint re used to ta!e the ood as he already got the ood or today and he do not want to collect or tomorrow. =ut 4 don’t !now why people want to generate money or A generations. 4 a care ul analysis and investigation is done Umeshwar Pamdey has =lac! money worth < generations. 4 guess instead o "a!hs and 'arore now corruption should be measured in generations.

-ducation is important. People need to understand the meaning o reedom truly. 4H 4 say boldly 4ndia is still not ree. People have mentality that they need to pay to #overnment o icials or wor!. This mentality has to be removed.

Than!s :ajeev

,' suspends judge over corruption complaints

),1-9)=)9: The #ujarat ,igh 'ourt has suspended a ast trac! court judge in :ajpipla a ter receiving several complaints o corruption and avouritism against her. :ajpipla ast trac! court (udge 9" 9esai was suspended on Thursday evening a ter a primary in7uiry held by the court’s vigilance department said that the complaints against her had substance. Hurther in7uiry against her will be conducted by the department. =esides the complaint o avouritism in :ajpipla, where she was presently posted, the 9esai was also accused o similar charges and issuing certi icates without proper veri ication in =haruch, where the she was discharging her duty as a principal district judge, the ,igh 'ourt authorities said.

The ,' administration seems to be seriously ta!ing the issue o corruption prevailing in #ujarat’s judiciary, as 9esai’s is the ourth suspension in last three months. -arlier in 1ay, a judge in &urat’s court, )@ Einjhola was suspended a ter similar complaints against him. The court administration also ound him in possession o property out o proportion considering his !nown sources o income. "ast month, two judges were suspended on charges o corruption. The )hmedabad city civil (udge @1 Tha!or and >E >a!!ad were also suspended by the ,' a ter holding preliminary in7uiry into complaints against them. )ll the our suspended judges are now acing departmental in7uiry.

HO:-4#@ TOU:& OH 4@94)@ (U9#-& )T T)YP)D-:’& -YP-@&-

@ew 9elhi: '@@%4=@’s exclusive report on some judges using o icial trips to holiday, has spar!ed o the debate M should judges be above the purview o the :ight to 4n ormation .:T4/ )ctK :T4 activists say there is every reason why the :T4 )ct should apply to the higher judiciary as well. Wuestions are now being as!ed in &outh =loc!, too, ollowing the expose on &upreme 'ourt judges. :ecords obtained under the :T4 shows judges have been converting wor! trips to holidays, ta!ing long detours and are accompanied by their wives while traveling abroad. )t present there are no travel guidelines or the judiciary and the =ar 'ouncil o 4ndia is suggesting a course correction. 54 thin! the judges must pay or should pay the amount to the government,6 =ar 'ouncil o 4ndia 'hairman &@P &inha said in Patna on 8ednesday. Under the :T4, '@@%4=@ ound that or 'hie (ustice ># =ala!rishnan’s 33%day trip to Pretoria, &outh ) rica in )ugust *22A the route was M 9elhi, 9ubai, (ohannesburg, @elspruit, 'apetown, (ohannesburg, Eictoria Halls, where the judge inally didn’t go and bac! to 9elhi via 9ubai. Hormer chie justice D> &abharwal attended three con erences in *22+ to -dinburgh, 8ashington and Paris. 8hile the con erences lasted 33 days, &abharwal was out or <C days with *3 days converted into a private visit. The travel plan included a detour rom 8ashington to =altimore, Orlando and )tlanta, be ore rejoining the con erence route in Paris. The Hirst 'lass air are or &abharwal’s entire trip was paid by the government. )ctivists are now renewing the debate on the :T4 act applying to judges as well :T4 activist )rvind >ejriwal said: 54t only underscores why the :T4 needs to be applied to judges and judiciary.6 (ust li!e 'aesar’s wi e should be above suspicion, :T4 activists are demanding that &' judges too should be seen to be accountable.

4= con irms 1ysore sex scandal

The 4ntelligence =ureau has provided the 'entre with a detailed account o the escapade involving three >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt judges on @ovember < in a resort on the outs!irts o 1ysore, highly placed sources told The Times o 4ndia on Hriday. )ccording to a senior o icial, 51ost o the in ormation sought has not only con irmed the veracity o the incident but the government has crosschec!ed it with another police agency. =oth the reports match.6 The incident was widely reported in the media. 8hat has surprised the 'entre is the 5dogged re usal6 o the >arnata!a police to con irm the incident. 51ysore Police 'ommissioner '. 'handrase!har irst denied that the incident ever too! place. Only when a public notice was issued through the high court registrar see!ing in ormation on the 1ysore scandal, did the acts come out in the open. Public protest helped a lot,6 says the source. 8hat transpired at the resort, says the source, 5cannot be expected rom anyone in civil society, leave alone persons sworn to upholding the law6. )ccording to him, 5The 4= report consists o unmentionable acts and also ma!es it amply clear that the 1ysore incident is not the irst time such things have happened. 'an anyone expect upholders o the law to pic! a ight with people who complained to the police when caught in a compromising positionK6 4n a related development, >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt 'hie (ustice @.>. (ain has written to 'hie (ustice o 4ndia (ustice #.=. Pattanai! as!ing that three judges be trans erred. (ain has proposed that (ustice @.&. Eeerabhadraiah be trans erred to the Patna ,igh 'ourt, (ustice 'handrase!haraiah to (ammu L >ashmir and (ustice E. #opala #owda to the #auhati ,igh 'ourt. 8hile (ain is understood not to have given any reasons, highly placed sources say the proposal or trans ers is lin!ed to the 1ysore incident. ,owever, the source says that now the government is worried about the appropriate 5remedial measures6. 4n such cases, trans erring a judge to a remote high court doesn’t always wor!. ,e says, 5=ar associations and the people o northeastern states were up in arms when some judges o the Punjab and ,aryana high courts were trans erred there. 8e expect similar protests i the '(4 accepts (ustice (ain’s proposal to trans er the three judges o the >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt.6 The =ar 'ouncil o 4ndia on Hriday, while expressing its anguish at the >arnata!a incident, called or 5 ollow%up action6. 5Unless prompt and appropriate action is ta!en, it will erode the aith o public in the only institution considered to be the bastion o our ighting aith in democracy,6 it said in a statement. The ='4 has 5lamented6 inaction in this case by 5the higher judiciary and the government6. :ead more: 4= con irms 1ysore sex scandal M The Times o 4ndia http:$$timeso india.indiatimes.com$city$bangalore$4=%con irms%1ysore%sex% scandal$articleshow$*OC23??*.cmsaixII3=APtvHdU

'( suspends copycat judges, wants report

8atch : http:$$www.youtube.com$watchKvQs8bR#U=RTN-

,yderabad$8arangal, )ug. *+: The )ndhra Pradesh ,igh 'ourt 'hie (ustice, 1r @isar )hmad >a!ru, on 8ednesday suspended ive subordinate judges or allegedly indulging in copying during the ""1 exams held at >a!atiya University in 8arangal district on Tuesday. 1r )jitsimha :ao, senior civil judge, 1r Eijayender :eddy, second additional district judge o :anga :eddy district, 1r 1. >istappa, senior civil judge o )nantapur, 1r &rinivasa 'hary, senior civil judge o =aptla and 1r ,anumantha :ao, additional junior civil judge o 8arangal were caught red%handed while copying in the irst year exams. The 'hie (ustice reviewed the situation a ter obtaining the preliminary report rom the university authorities and issued orders suspending them rom the service. ,e also as!ed the university to send a detailed report on the exam malpractice by the judges. 1eanwhile, the 8arangal 9istrict =ar )ssociation .89=)/ has demanded registration o cases under the )P Public -xamination .Prevention o 1alpractices L Un air 1eans/ )ct, 3OOA, against the errant judges. 54t was unbecoming o the judges to indulge in mass copying,6 said 1r 'h &ambasiva :aju, vice%president, 89=). The 89=) o ice bearers also demanded suspension o 1r :aIa! UIama, 44 &ub%(udge, 8arangal and his wi e 1s Prema :ajeshwara, secretary, district legal services authority, 8arangal, both o who appeared in the ""1 exam. :eportedly, it was 1r :aIa! who encouraged the mass copying. ,owever, he and his wi e were spared. 1eanwhile, 9r Talapalli 1anohar, additional controller o examination, &9"'-, clari ied that the lying s7uad had actually debarred only three judges U 1r 1. >istappa, 1r Eijayender :eddy and 1r )jitsimha :ao. &ources said the other two judges, 1r ,anumantha :ao and 1r &rinivasa 'hary were caught based on visual evidence.

1agistrate issues arrest warrant against 4ndian president a ter cash bribe.

)n 4ndian magistrate who allegedly accepted a bribe to issue arrest warrants against 4ndia’s president and senior legal igures has been trapped in a sting operation by a journalist, a report said. The journalist videotaped magistrate 1eghani @agar, who practices in )hmedabad, commercial capital o #ujarat state, accepting a bribe o 02,222 rupees .C+3 dollars/ to issue the arrest warrants, the Times o 4ndia newspaper said Thursday. )mong those cited in the warrants or criminal breach o trust and or cheating and dishonesty are 4ndian President )bdul >alam and 'hie (ustice E.@. >hare, a senior judge and a well%!nown T

4ndian president arrest warrant probe

4ndia’s &upreme 'ourt has ordered an investigation into how an arrest warrant was issued against the country’s president and its top judges. ) shoc!ed 'hie (ustice E@ >hare as!ed 4ndia’s top police body, the 'entral =ureau o 4nvestigation, to report its indings in a wee!. President )bdul >alam, two &upreme 'ourt judges M including 'hie (ustice >hare himsel M and the president o 4ndia’s bar association were issued with the warrants a ter a case o raud was iled against them. )n 4ndian television journalist has told the court he secretly ilmed a magistrate accepting 02,222 rupees .bCC</ to issue the warrants. The magistrate apparently had not realised who they were, newspaper reports said on Thursday. ,e has now been suspended rom his duties. 'ourt re7uest (ournalist Eijay &he!har has handed over to the court videotapes o the incident, which too! place in the state o #ujarat. The court has issued notices to the magistrate and the lawyers who iled the case, as!ing them or their version o the events, the Press Trust o 4ndia reports. 58hat is happening in #ujaratK =y giving 02,222 rupees you can get a judicial order,6 'hie (ustice >hare is reported as saying. 54 this is the state o a airs only #od !nows what will happen to the country,6 he added. 1r &he!har said he carried out the sting operation to expose corruption in 4ndia’s judiciary. 4n *223 4ndia was hit by an arms scandal a ter a website secretly ilmed senior military and de ence o icials apparently accepting cash rom journalists posing as arms dealers.

"o!ayu!ta: 9' demanded sex rom widow

5n the midst of a national outrage over former @aryana +;, S,S Aathore molesting a teenager/ the $arnata"a Lo"ayu"ta on Saturday made a startling revelation that the state government was shielding a top %ureaucrat who had demanded seFual favours from a young widow.

"o!ayu!ta (ustice &antosh ,egde disclosed that the o icial concerned, who was the deputy commissioner o one o the districts when he demanded sex rom the widow in return or discharging his duties as public servant, has since been promoted to a senior position. (ustice ,egde, in the course o an interaction with journalists at the 9eccan ,erald o ice &aturday a ternoon, said the unnamed widow had dared the deputy commissioner and approached the "o!ayu!ta’s o ice with a complaint against the o icer. On examination o the complaint, the "o!ayu!ta had ound su icient grounds to recommend to the state government the suspension and prosecution o the 9' concerned. The recommendation was subse7uently considered by the concerned department head as well as the chie secretary and both endorsed it. =ut, according to (ustice ,egde, no action was initiated against the 9' as the same o icial who had endorsed the recommendation subse7uently ound no basis or initiating departmental action against him. 4nstead, the o icial cleared the 9'’s name or promotion in the super%scale. Presently, the o icial holds a senior position in the government. The widow, in her late *2s, had approached the 9' with a representation to sort out some problems. =ut she was shoc!ed when the 9' demanded sex. (ustice ,egde did not identi y the o icial in 7uestion or the complainant. @or did he o er to name the district where the o icial was serving as deputy commissioner. =ut the incident has happened sometime in the course o last three years as (ustice ,egde too! over as the "o!ayu!ta in mid%*22?.

<%year jail term or Bdirty’ judge

'amily court )udge Aamrao ;angaram !hise attempted to get seFual favours from a housewife in 7998 Hamily court judge :amrao #angaram =hise’s attempts to extract sexual avours, in addition to a bribe, rom a housewi e, )l!a #ai!wad U who had sought an increase in her monthly maintenance allowance rom her estranged husband, in 3OOA U proved costly to him. Pronouncing him guilty on both counts, the special court hearing anti%corruption bureau .)'=/ matters sentenced him to three years rigorous imprisonment and a collective ine o :s++, 222, on 1onday. )ccording to the H4: in the case registered against =hise by the )'=, &urya!ant #ai!wad had iled or divorce rom his wi e, )l!a, be ore the =andra amily court. )l!a, a housewi e, in turn, iled a petition see!ing mutual cohabitation with her husband. The then amily court judge, 1eera >hada!!ar, directed the husband to pay her an interim maintenance allowance o :sA+2 per month.

&ubse7uently, in (anuary 3OOA, )l!a iled another application be ore the same amily court .now presided over by =hise/ see!ing to increase the monthly maintenance amount to :s<,+22. 5On October *A, 3OOA, =hise issued an interim order, increasing the maintenance allowance to :s*,222 to be paid by &urya!an to his estranged wi e till the disposal o the case. 4mmediately a ter issuing the order, =hise as!ed )l!a to meet him and gave her his residential telephone number, as!ing her to call him when the court hours ended. ,e told her that he would as! her husband to pay her a lump sum o :s* la!h in addition to the monthly maintenance, provided she called him up,6 the H4: states. 8hen she called up the judge at A pm the same day, =hise told her that she would have to pay him a sum o :s*,222 in addition to granting his sexual avours i she wanted an order in her avour. ,e also directed her to meet him at the ,aji )li bus stop with the bribe amount the ollowing evening. 5)l!a approached the )'=, which sought permission rom the 'hie (ustice o the =ombay ,igh 'ourt be ore laying a trap on the irst class judicial magistrate .=hise/. The ,' while granting the permission designated a court o icial to bear witness to the events leading to the trap. )l!a, under video camera surveillance o )'= sleuths, along with the court o icial and other women witnesses met =hise at C.<2 pm at the ,aji )li bus stop. =hise too! hold o )l!a’s wrist and when she protested, repeated his demands,6 the H4: states. )l!a was then ta!en to a nearby hotel, &harda, where the judge accepted the bribe amount. =ut be ore he could do anything else, )'= sleuths swooped in and arrested him.

:ajasthan judge is indicted or see!ing sexual avours

'hie (ustice o 4ndia # = Pattanai! retires tonight and he doesn’t have much to write home about on the unprecedented drive he launched to en orce judicial accountability. ) ter the PP&' scam iasco, reported in The 4ndian -xpress today, comes the case o the :ajasthan judge who has been indicted in a sex scandal and yet has escaped actionU pending another in7uiry. On 9ecember 30, a three%judge committee set up by Pattanai! con irmed the BBinvolvement’’ o (ustice )run 1adan o the :ajasthan ,igh 'ourt in a proposition to a woman doctor to have sex with him in exchange or a judicial avour. The committee, headed by the 'hie (ustice o the Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt (ustice = > :oy, submitted its report to Pattanai!, indicting 1adan on a complaint made rom (odhpur by the woman concerned, &unita 1alviya.

=ut Pattanai! has not announced any action against 1adan. 8hen contacted by The 4ndian -xpress, Pattanai! con irmed that the committee had indicted 1adan and his BBbad reputation’’ in see!ing sexual avours in return or judicial ones. ,owever, Pattanai! said that no action was being ta!en since the committee had also mentioned allegations o corruption against 1adan. )nd so he had ordered a urther in7uiry by the same committee into the corruption charges. 8hen as!ed what he did with the indictment o 1adan in the sex scandal, Pattanai! said, BBThat is on hold because 4 could not have ta!en piecemeal action against himT.4 am praying to #od that the inal report will give some tangible material to ta!e action.’’ ,ighly placed sources told The 4ndian -xpress that when the committee recorded statements last wee! in (odhpur o about <2 persons over our days, it also came to !now o several allegations o corruption against 1adan and another judge o the same high court. The committee put these on record as well. Pattanai! said that when he summoned 1adan to @ew 9elhi last wee!, he did not raise the sex scandal issue and instead limited himsel to saying that he was ordering a urther in7uiry into corruption allegations. 4n e ect, Pattanai! has now passed the :ajasthan buc! to his successor (ustice E @ >hare. The gist o 1alviya’s complaint is that 1adan made a sexual proposition to her in October through a deputy registrar o the high court, #ovind >alwani, who said that the judge would help her, in turn, get out o a criminal case boo!ed against her. 8ith this, Pattanai!’s much%touted in%house judicial accountability seems to have hit a wall. The irst committee’s report into the PP&' scam exonerated one judge despite evidence and let two others o with a mere slap on the wrist. The third committee is now busy probing the involvement o judges in the 1ysore sex scam.

7an"alore ,ail *arden supplies dru"s to inmates& %eld

7an"alore: 7an"alore !entral ail !%ief Warden 7 'ot%i'amma %as been cau"%t suppl'in" mari,uana& SIM cards and li4uor to inmates( 'ot%i'amma %as "uarded prisoners for o+er FE 'ears but it turns out t%at %er priorities la' in suppl'in" t%em *it% t%e lu/uries of outside *orld& some of t%em ille"al( An embarrassed state police is no* promisin" action a"ainst 'ot%i'amma(

RWe %a+e re"istered a case under AJ 576 N0PS Act( =nder t%is section t%e accused if found "uilt' can be punis%ed unto FJ 'ears imprisonment and fined up to 2s F la.%&R sa's )!P Sout% East 7NS 2edd'(

'ot%i'amma;s lucrati+e business came to li"%t after anot%er *arden )ilip 9umar cau"%t %er suppl'in" a .ilo of mari,uana and SIM cards to a prisoner( Police are no* in+esti"atin" %o* lon" s%e %as been runnin" t%e dru" suppl' business( RWe %a+e to find out from *%ere s%e collected t%e dru"s and to *%om s%e *as "i+in" it to( We %a+e also informed t%e ,ail aut%orities about t%e usa"e of mobile p%ones and it *ould be better if in t%e prison t%e inmates could be fris.ed&R sa's 2edd'( Last 'ear t%e cit' police %ad busted a c%ain snatc%in" "an" operatin" inside t%e ,ail& *%ic% *as coordinatin" its operations t%rou"% cell p%ones(

'ot%i'amma;s arrest s%o*s t%at t%e effort to crac.do*n on contraband in ,ail seems to %a+e %ad little effect(

=)8E SEN)IN8 07S!ENE SMS T0 W0MEN

Luc.no* Ta.in" co"nisance of t%e alle"ation a"ainst a ci+il ud"e 5,unior di+ision6 of 7udaun court t%at %e sent obscene SMSes to a *oman lecturer& t%e 2e"istrar 8eneral of Alla%abad Hi"% !ourt toda' sou"%t a report from t%e district ,ud"e into t%e matter(

T%e ci+il ,ud"e of 8unnor sub-di+ision court of 7udaun S Pramod 9umar 8an"*arS *as accused of sendin" obscene SMSes from %is cellp%one to a *oman lecturer of !lassic !olle"e of La*& 7areill'( A lecturer of t%e same colle"e& <i+e. 8upta& *as named in t%e FI2 lod"ed b' t%e +ictim *%ile 8an"*ar-s name surfaced in t%e primar' in+esti"ation( 2e"istrar 8eneral )ines% 8upta said& >T%e district ,ud"e of 7udaun %as been

as.ed to send a detailed report into t%e alle"ations( Appropriate action *ould be ta.en on t%e basis of t%e report(? )istrict ud"e Sures% 9umar Sri+asta+a said& >I %a+e as.ed t%e 7areill' district police to send a report about t%e matter( T%e report on t%e basis of t%e police in4uir' *ould be sent to t%e Alla%abad Hi"% !ourt 2e"istrar 8eneral(? >I am not a*are about t%e matter& as t%e 7areill' police did not intimate me before initiatin" t%e probe a"ainst t%e ci+il ,ud"e( T%e' s%ould %a+e informed me *%en t%e' %ad recei+ed an' suc% complaint&? t%e ,ud"e added( Mean*%ile& 7areill' !0 II 2a, 9umar& *%o is in+esti"atin" t%e case& toda' recorded t%e statement of t%e +ictim( >I %a+e collected t%e call details of t%e cellp%one used for sendin" t%e SMSes& but I %a+e 'et to "et t%e address of t%e person *%o is subscriber of t%e SIM card&? %e said( >T%e probe is on to +erif' if t%e accused in t%e case *ere present on t%e location recorded in t%e call details *%en t%e SMSes *ere sent( T%e details of t%e findin"s of t%e in+esti"ation *ould be sent to t%e 7udaun district court to see. t%e direction&? t%e !0 added( As.ed if t%e in+esti"ation *as earlier conducted into t%e matter& 2a, 9umar said& >T%e SP 5!rime6 %ad initiated probe into t%e matter& but I am not a*are if t%e in+esti"ation %ad reac%ed to an' conclusion(? T%e *oman lecturer %ad lod"ed an FI2 at t%e Ma%ila police station on T%ursda' alle"in" s%e %ad recei+ed obscene SMSes on %er cellp%one in+ol+in" %er collea"ue <i+e. 8upta( T%e preliminar' in4uir' into t%e case b' t%e police 'esterda' %ad found t%at t%e mobile p%one used in t%e crime belon"s to t%e ci+il ,ud"e( Mumbai police c%ief recommends suspension of )!P& A!P

Mumbai Fi+e police personnel& includin" an IPS officer& *%o alle"edl' attended a !%ristmas-e+e part' t%ro*n b' t%e !%ota 2a,an "an"& face suspension(

T%e suspension of )!P < N Sal+e& an IPS officer& and A!P Pra.as% Wani& and t%ree ot%er police personnel& %as been recommended b' Mumbai Police !ommissioner ) Si+anandan on Saturda'( T%e Ma%aras%tra "o+ernment %ad on Frida' ordered an in4uir' into alle"ations t%at besides Sal+e and Wani& senior police inspector Tulsidas 9%a..ad& a police inspector of anti-e/tortion cell and a constable from !%embur police station %ad attended t%e part'( RI %a+e recommended to t%e state "o+ernment to initiate disciplinar' action a"ainst t%e fi+e policemen and suspend t%em pendin" in4uir'&R Si+anandan said( He said t%ere *ere R!!T< foota"es and p%oto"rap%s *%ic% ma' pro+eR t%at t%e officials *ere present at t%e part' %eld at a pri+ate "'m.%ana in suburban !%embur( T%e part' *as reportedl' or"anised to celebrate t%e release of some topran.in" members of t%e "an"( Amon" t%em *ere dreaded ) 9 2ao& *%o *as released from ,ail after FL 'ears of imprisonment& Farid Tanas%a and Sunil Poddar( Ma%aras%tra Home Minister 2 2 Patil %ad on Frida' ordered t%e in4uir' after p%oto"rap%s and "rain' +ideo foota"e purportedl' s%o*in" t%em *ere aired on T< c%annels( Mean*%ile& Wani +e%ementl' denied t%e accusation& claimin" t%e +ideo clippin"s and p%oto"rap%s *ere doctored( RT%is is a conspirac' a"ainst me( I am a member of t%e "'m.%ana and %ad "one t%ere *it% m' *ife for dinner and not to part' *it% an' "an" members&R %e said( T%e part' *as reportedl' t%ro*n b' Paulson osep%& a close aide of !%ota 2a,an& *%o is said to be loo.in" after t%e under*orld don;s business interests in Mumbai;s suburbs( Sources at t%e "'m.%ana said osep% *as a member of t%e upmar.et club& *%ic% c%ar"es a members%ip fee of 2s fi+e la.%& and used to "o t%ere re"ularl' to pla' cards and part'( Spea.in" strictl' on condition of anon'mit'& t%e' said t%at a member could brin" alon" an' number of "uests after pa'in" 2s LJ for eac% of t%em( RSo man' people +isit t%e club on t%e !%ristmas-e+e and it is not possible to ascertain t%e identit' of eac% one of t%em&R t%e' said& *%en as.ed if t%e' %ad spotted an' police officer at osep%;s bas%(

2a,ast%an launc%es searc% for former )I8 c%ar"ed *it% rape

AIP=2: T%e 2a,ast%an "o+ernment %as as.ed t%e Special 0perations 8roup 5S086 to find former deput' inspector "eneral 5)I86 Mad%u.ar Tandon *%o %as been abscondin" for t%e last FL 'ears after %e *as c%ar"es%eeted for rapin" a tribal *oman( RWe %a+e %anded o+er t%e case to t%e S08 of t%e 2a,ast%an Police( It;s a serious matter t%at Tandon not been arrested since FMMD( We *ant to arrest %im and find out *%' %e;s not been arrested so far&R state Home Minister S%anti )%ari*al told reporters %ere( A 2a,ast%an Police part' arri+ed in Noida in =ttar Prades% Wednesda' to in+esti"ate t%e matter and +isited t%e propert' t%at earlier belon"ed to Tandon( )%ari*al %as also sou"%t all t%e files relatin" to t%e case( RI %a+e as.ed t%e police to brin" all t%e files relatin" to Tandon to me((( I *ant to .no* t%e details&R %e said( Malli )e+i& a resident of 7andi.ui in )ausa district %as alle"ed t%at on an AF& FMMD s%e *as abducted and ta.en to Noida *%ere s%e *as alle"edl' raped b' former )I8 Tandon& t%en posted in t%e police %ead4uarters and *%o is no* reported to be abscondin"( 9%a'ali 2am& t%e %usband of t%e +ictim *%o *as a constable attac%ed to t%e )I8 said: RIt %as been FL 'ears t%at %e ruined me and m' famil'(R RTandon %ad summoned m' *ife to aipur from t%e +illa"e on t%e prete/t t%at an accident %as %appened in m' famil'( W%en s%e arri+ed in aipur s%e *as forcefull' ta.en to Noida& to t%e )I8;s residence& *%ere s%e *as +ictimised&R said 2am( RI *as forced out of t%e ser+ice *%en I refused to *it%dra* t%e case a"ainst Tandon in AJJJ&R %e added( Tandon *as suspended in AJJA& fi+e 'ears after first FI2 *as lod"ed a"ainst %im and a ma"isterial court in )ausa %ad ordered all %is propert' includin" %is %ouse in Noida to be attac%ed(

,istory o 'orruption in 4ndian (udiciary since 4ndependence: 3O0A % *22< 3O0O: 1r. (ustice &inha only (udge impeached; courtesy #ood (udges L 'onstitution Hramers: Our Hore%Hathers represented by 'onstituent )ssembly o 4ndia ramers o 'onstitution o 4ndia then in 3O0O .year be ore 'onsitution came into existence/ impeached 1r. (ustice &inha;

inding him Gguilty o improper exercise o (udicial unctions, the cumulative e ect o which was to lower the dignity o his o ice and undermine the con idence o the public in the administration o justicecdeG [22C.2A\. &uch$ similar acts$ behaviours by whom%so%ever including (udges is since 3OA3 is covered as an act o 'riminal 'ontempt o 'ourt [203.2+ \. @ot a single (udge is either 4mpeached or hauled%up or 'ontempt till 3OO3. PeoplesF 4nner ,ope 'ourts to maintain their 1ajesty L 9ignity will prosecute 3222 (udges in context, who have tarnished L undermined the Hair image o (udiciary. "et (udges relish (ail or months i not years ; to asses personally the convinences%@%com orts provided even to innocent citiIens or persons who were not having :s. 322 to give as =ail. Then they will be in better position to Trans orm (ails into :e ormation 'entres. (ailing corrupt (udges by (udges , we hope will instill con idence o people in 'ourts L law. 8ho%is%who o 4ndia then only will scare to get into any scam nor 'riminals will thin! o becoming "egislators. 3OAO : 'hie (ustice 1r. >. Eeeraswami ; 'hie (ustice o 4ndia permitted 'entral =ureau o 4ndia to ile case o 9is%proportionate o 4ncome $ wealth against 'hie (ustice 1adras ,igh 'ourt 1r. >. Eeeraswami . ather%in%law o 1r. (ustice E. :amaswami /. <2 years elaped. &heltered by 'ourtsF easy%go%tactic. [20O.20\ [2+O.2+ \ 3OO3%O<: 1r. (ustice E. :amaswami . son%in%law o 'hie (ustice 1r. >. Eeeraswami [20O.20 \ / : &)8)@T 'O114TT-- :-PO:T had held he is guilty o several charges. &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia also upheld guilty o <%0 charges ; L recommended to Parliament or urther action. Parliamentarians ailed in their 9uty to 4mpeach the &itting (udge o &upreme 'ourt 1r. (ustice E. :amaswami ; not rising to the ,eights o -minent 'onstitution ma!ers ; but chose to have unholy alliance with 'orruption in (udiciary vis%a%vis "egislature L #overnment.[22C.22 \. &upreme 'ourt which upheld 'harges o 1is%=ehaviour also , we opine , ailed to prosecute him under 'ontempt o 'ourt )ct L relevant "aws . 4t also ailed G To 9o 'omplete (usticeG by invo!ing )rticle30* . 'riminal (udge was allowed to go scot% ree; both by Parliament L &upreme 'ourt Z #ood precedent or other (udges K 4 so 8hat !ind o message to we% innocent%'itiIens K Hor almost complete proceedings in &' L Parliament: [22C.22 \

3OO+ ).1. =,)TT)',):(--: The chie justice o the =ombay ,igh 'ourt was orced to resign in 3OO+ a ter it was ound that he had received :s.A2 la!h as boo! advance rom a publishing irm !nown to have lin!s with the underworld. 3OO? )(4T &-@#UPT): The 'alcutta ,igh 'ourt judge made it a routine to issue ex parte, ad interim stay orders on anticipatory bail pleas rom smugglers having lin!s with the 1umbai underworld. ,e was arrested in 3OO? or H-:) violations a ter retirement 3OO0 to 3OOA: ).1. ),1)94: 8hen he was 'hie (ustice o 4ndia .October 3OO0%1arch 3OOA/, his daughter, a lawyer in the 9elhi ,igh 'ourt, caused eyebrows to be raised or getting GspecialG treatment rom certain judges. 8hen some members o the bar sought a resolution banning lawyer relatives o judges rom staying in the same house, the '(4 got members to de eat the motion. *222 ).&. )@)@9: )s 'hie (ustice o 4ndia. .a/ ,e was accused o using his position to get the subordinate judiciary to rule in avour o his wi e and mother%in%law in a suit that had been barred by limitation or two decades.Hor more: [20O.2+\ [20O.2+)\ [20O.2+=\ [20O.2+'\ [20O.2+9\ [20O.2+- \ called as T)@#"-9 P"OT. )lso read :am (ethmalaniFs G =4# -#O&, small men G. .b/ &upreme 'ourt , while he was '(4,directed a '=4 probe a ter a dispute arose over his age in *222. The investigation report was not made public.This arose due to scan copy published in :am (ethmalaniFs G =4# -#O&, small men G. *22*: &-Y HO: )'WU4TT)" 4n @ovember *22*, &unita 1alviya, a (odhpur%based doctor, alleged that a deputy registrar o the :ajasthan ,igh 'ourt had sought sexual avours or himsel and or (ustice )run 1adan to G ixG a case in her avour. (ustice 1r.f` )run 1adan . 'ase o "ady &unita 1alviya.&T)TU&: ) committee set up by ormer '(4 #.=. Pattanai! ound prima acie evidence against 1adan, who does not attend court anymore. (udge :esigned ')&,%HO:%(O= :Three judges o the Punjab and ,aryana ,igh 'ourt sought the help o disgraced PP&' chie :.P. &idhu to ensure that their daughters and other !in topped examinations conducted by the commission . (udges are 1.". &ingh , 1ehtab &ing #ill L )marbir &ingh &T)TU&: Two in7uiry panels indicted the judges. #ill and )marbir &ingh have resigned 1.". &ingh continues, though no wor! is allotted to him.

*22*%2<: < (udges 1ysore &ex &candal . alleged / : On &unday, @ovember <, *22*, three judges o the >arnata!a ,igh 'ourt, along with two women advocates, allegedly got involved in a brawl with a woman guest at a resort. The police arrived but reportedly didnFt ta!e action. (udges are @.&. Eeerabhadraiah , E. #opalagowda Lf` 'handrashe!araiah .&T)TU&: The three%judge in7uiry committee appointed by the '(4 iled its report. #ave clean chit. 1arch *22< % 9elhi ,igh 'ourt (udge resigns: &uspected o collusion with Property 9evelopers. :aids by '=4 on corrupt higher o icials in 9elhi 9evelopment )uthority .99)/, ound 9ra t (udgement%@%'ourt :ecords RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR -.4/n7uiry%in%camera or 4n%,ouse 4n7uiry was L is contrary to "aw . 4s ultra vires )rticle 30 o 'onstitution o 4ndia: G The &tate shall not deny to any person e7uality be ore the law or the e7ual protection o the laws within the territory o 4ndiaG Hollowing Wuestions $ 4ssues, inter alia , arise . a / -n7uiry in%camera was held contrary to the observations made by, 'onstituent )ssembly o 4ndia in 3O0O. 4n itsF 4mpeachment Order had held thus:G8hile we are alive to the desirability, in the interests o the public, o investigating charges against a (udge in open court, we held the -n7uiry in%camera in view o the allegation made in the a idavits and the circumstances o the case. This mode o proceeding should not, however, be regarded as a precedent.G [22C.2A \. . b/ 4n the case o similar 4n%,ouse 4n7uiry held under the Orders o 'hie (ustice o 4ndia in (usice E. :amaswamiFs case , (ustice :amaswami had held that G 4n7uiring 'ommitteeG as well as G 4n7uiryG have no basis L orce o law. 4t is re lected in the :eport , which was read%out by '(4 to )dvocates L publicised , submitted by < (udges 'ommittee thusG 4ndeed (ustice :amaswami had made it clear to the 'hie (ustice that he did not recognise any such (urisdiction in any body or authority.G .c/ 4t will not be out%o place to mention here that Two o GThree (udges 'ommittee G appointed by '(4 in :e. E. :amaswamiFs case are alleged to be involved in (udges Plot 0 Plot.[230.22\. 4t is li!e 'riminal investigating another criminal . . d / 4 so how sure can we be that G < (udges 'ommittee G appointed to invetigate G < (udges 1ysore &ex &candal G were un%biased or were above =oard L have presented an accurate :eport K Wueries to &upreme 'ourt , Parliament o 4ndia L 'entral #overnment 4n :e. (udgesF 1ysore &ex &candal . a/G 8ill the &upreme 'ourt Publicise :eport o G < (udges 'ommittee G . all L sundry material/; more ully to !now whether any evidence adduced by many in support o &cam is in ormed to '(4 L &upreme 'ourt K

.b/ 8hat is the #uarantee that despite prima acie evidence (udges o &upreme 'ourt which consists o Hew corrupt (udges seved in >arnata!a are not inclined to ta!e stern action K .c/ 4nvestigation o a 'rime comitted by 1inister or anyone lies within -xecutive 9omain li!e the case (ustice >.Eeeraswami, in this case '=4 . 4s it not a case o hushing%up L messing%up o G < Pillars o 'onstitution G K. .d/ ,ow long will you try !eeping suppressed 'rimes o (udges o &upreme 'ourt L ,igh 'ourts when Union "aw 1inister 1r. P. &hiva &han!ar , on *Cth @ov.3OCA said G &upreme 'ourt is illed with H-:) violators L =ride =urnerscdeG . )4: 3OCC &' 3*2C /. 8hen 'hie (ustice O 4ndia (ustice -.&. Een!ataramaiaha admits that Gin every ,igh 'ourt there are <%0 (udges who are out every evening to Party in Horeign -mbassiies or at )dvocatesF placescdedrin!cdedinecdeG .3OO2 'r "( *3AO / [203.2O\. .e/ *2^ o (udges are corrupt , indirectly said 'hie (ustice o 4ndia 1r. (ustice &.P. =harucha , in other words admitted that C2^ o (udges o 4ndia are not corrupt L are above board to be bribed or in lunced K Then why cases are not iled against *2^ o (udges K

“T ere is a i! er court t an t e court o" #ustice and t at is t e court o" conscience It super cedes all ot er courts$ % &a at'a Gand i

PA@ )ama"es ustice Sat%asi+am Honourable !%ief ustice of India - )AMA8ES PA@MENT $ FINAL SH0W!A=SE N0TI!E T0 !HIEF =STI!E 0F IN)IA ,onourable sir , The public servants L the government must be role models in law abiding acts , or others to emulate L ollow. i a student ma!es a mista!e it is excusable L can be corrected by the teacher. i the teacher himsel ma!es a mista!e , all his students will do the same mista!e. i a thie steals , he can be caught , legally punished L re ormed . i a police himsel commits crime , many thieves go scot% ree under his patronage. even

i a police , public servant commits a crime , he can be legally prosecuted L justice can be sought by the aggrieved.

just thin! , i a judge himsel that too apex court o the land itsel commits crime % violations o :T4 )ct , constitutional rights L human rights o public and obstructs the public rom per orming their constitutional undamental duties , what happens K

it gives a booster dose to the rich L mighty , those in power , criminals in public service to commit more crimes. that is exactly what is happening in india. the educated public must raise to the occasion L peace ully , democratically must oppose this criminaliIation o judiciary , public service. then alone , we can build a :)1 :)(D) OH 1),)T1) #)@9,4F& 9:-)1.

I don-t .no* *%et%er secretariat staff of ! I office # )A2P8 : )P8 officials are for*ardin" m' appeals for ,ustice & emails to 'ou or not( T%e' *ill be %eld accountable for t%eir lapses if an'( T%is notice is a"ainst t%e repeated failure of constitutional duties # indirect collusion *it% criminals b' pre+ious !HIEF =STI!Es 0F IN)IA( Notice is ser+ed a"ainst t%em & to t%e office of ! I & N0T personall' a"ainst 'ou( At t%e indi+idual le+el I do *%ole %eartedl' respect %onourable ,ustice Sat%asi+am ! I( Please refer m' appeal for ,ustice t%rou"% )A2P8 C )L8LA:E:AJFL:JJAMA )EP0 :E:AJFL:JJIDM

In india democrac' is a farce & freedom a mira"e( t%e most basic freedom 2I8HT T0 INF02MATI0N # ETP2ESSI0N & is not %onoured b' t%e "o+ernment&as t%e information opens up t%e crimes of <(<(I(Ps # leads to t%eir ill-"otten *ealt%( T%e public ser+ants are least bot%ered about t%e li+es of people or ,ustice to t%em( t%ese t'pe of fat cats & parasites are a drain on t%e public e/c%e4uer ( t%ese people *ant &*is% me to see dead & *is% to see H=MAN 2I8HTS WAT!H closed ( so t%at& a +oice a"ainst in,ustices is silenced fore+er & t%e crimes of <(<(I(Ps closed & buried fore+er( To m' numerous appeals & H2W-s appeals to 'ou &'ou %a+e not 'et replied( It clearl' s%o*s t%at 'ou are least bot%ered about t%e li+es of people or ,ustice to t%em (it pro+es t%at 'ou are %ell bent to protect t%e criminals at an' cost( 'ou are ,ust pressurisin" t%e police to en4uire me &to ta.e m' statement& to repeatedl' call me to police station all *it% a +ie* to silence me(all of 'ou

en,o' >le"al immunit' pri+ile"es? &*%' don-t 'ou %a+e "i+en po*ers to t%e police : in+esti"atin" officer to summon all of 'ou for en4uir' $or else *%' don-t all of 'ou are not appearin" before t%e police +oluntaril' for en4uir' $at t%e least *%' don-t all of 'ou are not sendin" 'our statement about t%e case to t%e police eit%er t%rou"% le"al counsel or t%rou"% post$ 'ou are aidin" criminals &b' den'in" me ,ob oppurtunities in 2(7(I !=22EN!@ N0TE P2ESS m'sore & cit' ci+il court &ban"alore & distict court & m'sore &etc # b' ille"all' closin" m' ne*spaper( t%ere is a "ross& total mismatc% bet*een 'our actions and 'our oat% of office( t%is amounts to public c%eatin" # moral turpitude on 'our part( F('ou are ma.in" contempt of t%e +er' au"ust office 'ou %old( A('ou are ma.in" contempt of t%e constitution of india( L('ou are ma.in" contempt of citi3ens of india( G('ou are sponsorin" # aidin" terorrism # or"ani3ed crime( E('ou are +iolatin" t%e fundamental # %uman ri"%ts of t%e citi3ens of india and of nei"%bourin" countries( I('ou are +iolatin" # ma.in" contempt of t%e =(N H=MAN 2I8HTS !HA2TE2 to *%ic% india is a si"nator'( D('ou are obstructin" me from performin" m' fundamental duties as a citi3en of india( K( As a result of 'our "ross ne"li"ence of constitutional duties 'ou %a+e caused me dama"es : losses to t%e tune of 2=PEES TW0 !202E 0NL@( 'ou are %ereb' called upon to Pa' dama"es to me and SH0W-!A=SE *it%in LJ da's & *%' 'ou cann-t be le"all' prosecuted for t%e abo+e mentioned crimes (

If i am repeatedl' called to police station or else *%ere for t%e sa.e of in+esti"ations & t%e losses i do incurr as a result li.e loss of *a"es & transportation & ,ob & etc must be borne b' t%e "o+ernment( pre+oiusl' t%e police : I7 personnel repeatedl' called me t%e complainant 5sufferer of in,ustices6 to police station for 4uestionin" & but ne+er called t%e "uilt' culprits e+en once to police station for 4uestionin" & as t%e culprits are %i"% # mi"%t' ( t%is t'pe of one sided 4uestionin" must not be done b' police or in+esti"atin" a"encies ( if an't%in" unto*ard %appens to me or to m' famil' members li.e loss of ,ob & meetin" *it% %it # run accidents & loss of li+es & etc & t%e ,urisdictional police to"et%er *it% abo+e mentioned accussed public ser+ants *ill be responsible for it( E+en if criminal ne/us le+els fa.e c%ar"es & police file fa.e cases a"ainst me or m' dependents to silence me & t%is complaint is # *ill be effecti+e( if an't%in" unto*ard %appens to me or m' dependents & t%e "o+ernment of india is liable to pa' 2s( TW0 crore as compensation to sur+i+ors of m' famil'( if m' *%ole famil' is eliminated b' t%e criminal ne/us &t%en t%at

compensation mone' must be donated to Indian Arm' Welfare Fund( after*ards & t%e mone' must be reco+ered b' 80I as land arrears from t%e salar' & pension & propert' & etc of "uilt' ,ud"es & police officials & public ser+ants # !onstitutional fuctionaries( T%an.in" 'ou( ai Hind & <ande Mataram(

)ate : FL(JK(AJFLUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU(('our-s sincerel'& Place : M'sore & IndiaUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU(Na"ara,a M 2

(n (ppeal to )onourable *nited +ations )u'an Ri! ts )i! Co''issioner , )onourable International Court o" Justice

Dear &ada' - .ir / .*0JECT 1 )*&(+ RIG)T. 2IOL(TIO+. 03 GO2ER+&E+T O4 I+DI( / .*PRE&E CO*RT O4 I+DI( , CE+TR(L I+4OR&(TIO+ CO&&I..IO+

I ave individually su""ered nu'erous u'an ri! ts violations / in#ustices by public servants 5or6in! "or !overn'ent o" India 5 en I raised 'y voice see6in! #ustice "or 'y "ello5 country'en $ "or t e society$ T ese public servants are involved in cri'es li6e aidin! , abettin! terroris' / under5orld / 'anslau! ter / etc$ 5 en I appealed to t e supre'e court o" India see6in! #ustice / t ey ave turned t eir blind eye$ (s a result 'ore in#ustices are bein! co''itted till date$ Even t e police are not re!isterin! t e co'plaint a!ainst t ese !uilty public servants$ Police , .upre'e Court Jud!es in lea!ue 5it CRI&I+(L. / (+TI +(TIO+(L. / TERORRI.T. 7 In India / so'e Parlia'entarians ta6e 'oney "or even raisin! 8uestions in parlia'ent / "avorable la5s - !overn'ent rules are enacted to "avor ric cri'inals 9re"er :G , +ira Radia sca';$ Police "or a price 'anipulate evidence / pre'aturely close case / "i< innocent , 'ete out 3rd de!ree torture / 'urder in t e na'e o" encounter $ Public prosecutor can c an!e t e 5ay o" ar!u'ent / etc "or a price$ Even #ud!es in India !ive "avorable #udicial orders "or 'oney / .E= / post retire'ent bene"its / etc$ please re"er details at "ollo5in! 5eb pa!es 1 ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-court>#ud!e'ents>"i<ed /

ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-3rd>de!ree>torture>by>indian>police / ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-court>#ud!e'ents>"or>a>price I ave not !ot #ustice till date / instead I ave su""ered p ysical assaults / 'urder atte'pts on 'e / 'y ne5spaper 5as ille!ally cla'ped do5n / 'y #ob opportunities 5ere ille!ally snatc ed a5ay 9cuttin! o"" t e source o" liveli ood;$ I ave been t reatened by police t at I , 'y "a'ily 'e'bers 5ill be "i<ed up in cri'inal cases 9"alse i'plication; , 5ill be be ind t e bars "or rest o" our li"e$ I ave been re"used proper 'edical care in !overn'ent ospitals / so t at I 5ill die sooner $ (ll t ese In#ustices are 'eted out at t e ands o" cri'inal ne<us o" CRI&I+(L ? POLICE? J*DGE > 0*RE(*CR(T ? &P &L( $ De'ocracy is t e best "or' o" !overnance$ &y 'ot erland India is one o" t e !reatest country$ )o5ever Cri'inals ave entered into alls o" parlia'ent / cri'inals ave beco'e #ud!es / cri'inals ave beco'e police / al'ost total cri'inali@ation o" public service as ta6en place$ T ese cri'inals are "ra'in! la5s "or t e 'asses 'uc a!ainst t e de'ocratic aspirations o" t e 'asses$ Cri'inal #ud!es are relyin! on t ese la5s 'ade by cri'inals , sendin! innocents to !allo5s $ Cri'inal Police are 'a6in! deals 5it cri'inals , arrestin! / torturin! innocents$ .till very "e5 )O+E.T people are le"t in public service > Parlia'ent / Judiciary , Police / )o5ever t ey are 6eepin! 'u'$ &y stru!!le is not a!ainst t e !overn'ent o" India or itAs constitutional bodies rat er it is a!ainst t e corrupt people 5 o are in t ose bodies $ I do ave 5 ole earted respects "or t e !overn'ent o" India , itAs constitutional bodies / 0ut I despise t e corrupt people over t ere in t ose institutions$ Our syste' is !ood / 'any o" t e people 5or6in! t ere are not !ood$ It is stru!!le a!ainst t ose corrupt people / to save our de'ocracy / to save our "reedo'$ )ereby / I do reBuest your onourableselves )onourable *nited +ations )u'an Ri! ts )i! Co''issioner and )onourable International Court O" Justice / to order t e )onourable .upre'e Court o" India / Govern'ent o" India , CIC to do itAs constitutional duties properly / to sa"e!uard t e u'an ri! ts o" all and to provide #ustice in t e 'atter$ T an6in! 3ou$ Date 1 CD$EC$:CE:FFFFFFFFFFFFF$$3ourAs .incerely / Place 1 &ysore / IndiaFFFFFFFFFFFF+a!ara#a $ & $ R $

-ditorial : (U9#-& or 'riminals % &)TD)1-E) ()D)T- K

T%e public ser+ants # t%e "o+ernment must be role models in la* abidin" acts & for ot%ers to emulate # follo*( if a student ma.es a mista.e it is e/cusable # can be corrected b' t%e teac%er( if t%e teac%er %imself ma.es a mista.e & all %is students *ill do t%e same mista.e( if a t%ief steals & %e can be cau"%t & le"all' punis%ed # reformed ( if a police %imself commits crime & man' t%ie+es "o scot- free under %is patrona"e( e+en if a police & public ser+ant commits a crime & %e can be le"all' prosecuted # ,ustice can be sou"%t b' t%e a""rie+ed( ,ust t%in. & if a ,ud"e %imself t%at too of ape/ court of t%e land itself commits crime - +iolations of 2TI Act & constitutional ri"%ts # %uman ri"%ts of public and obstructs t%e public from performin" t%eir constitutional fundamental duties & *%at %appens $ it "i+es a booster dose to t%e ric% # mi"%t' & t%ose in po*er & criminals in public ser+ice to committ more crimes( t%at is e/actl' *%at is %appennin" in india( t%e educated public must raise to t%e occassion # peacefull' & democraticall' must oppose t%is criminalisation of ,udiciar' & public ser+ice( t%en alone & *e can build a 2AM 2A @A 0F MAHATMA 8AN)HI;S )2EAM(

4n 4ndia legislations , Parliamentary )cts , policy decisions are ixed .example : telecom policy ixing by neera radia L others/ , the court judgement are ixed , arrest warrant by courts are ixed .example : '(4. )hmadi changing the charge against =hopal gas co L a judge issuing arrest warrants against then president o 4ndia !alam L then '(4/ , Police ixing cases , torturing innocents , closing cases by = reports , changing trac! o investigations , governments servants giving alse reports L records , etc. 4n this bac! drop , commonman won’t get justice in 4ndia . 4nstead i he raises his voice or justice , he is persecuted by the nexus o ':414@)"& M PO"4'- M (U9#-& M PU="4' &-:E)@T&. -ven the supreme court o 4ndia , is not accepting our o er o service to legally boo! the criminals nor is it registering our P4" nor the >arnata!a police are registering our complaint against public servants.

Our &upreme 'ourt (udges , police L Public &ervants , preach virtues in courts o law L other orums , but they don’t practice it themselves. &)TD)1-E) ()D)T- K :ead L )nswer : http:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$chie %justice%o %india%answer , http:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$cover%up%rajiv%gandhi%assassination , http:$$sites.google.com$site$eclariono dalit$wa!e%up%indian%judiciary

()4 ,4@9. E)@9- 1)T):)1.

Dour’s sincerely , @agaraj.1.:.

UUUUUUUU(()E!LA2ATI0NUUUUUUUUU

Name : (((((((((((((((((((((((((((NA8A2A A(M(2( Address : (((((((((((((((((((LI8-A : DIF & H=)!0 FI2ST STA8E & 0PP WATE2 W029S 0FFI!E & LA9SHMI9ANTANA8A2 & HE77AL & M@S02E - EDJJFD IN)IA Professional : Trade Title : S(0(S - e 1 <oice For ustice Periodicit' : WEE9L@ !irculation : F02 F2EE )IST2I7=TI0N 0N WE7 )onations : N0T A!!EPTE)( Self financin" ( Ne+er accepted an' donations & subscriptions eit%er for oursel+es or on be%alf of ot%er or"ani3ations :

indi+iduals ( Monetar' "ains : nil & ne+er made an' monetar' "ain b' *a' of ad+ertisements on m' *ebsites or *eb ne*s paper or ot%er*ise( 0*ner:editor:printer:publis%er : NA8A2A A(M(2( Nationalit' : IN)IAN 7od' )onation : P%'sical 7od' of Na"ara,a M 2 & Editor & S(0(S- e 1 clarion of )alit # S(0(S-e-<oice for ustice is donated to SS Medical !olle"e & M'sore 5 )onation No( FID dated AA : FJ : AJJL 6 & In case of eit%er =nnatural deat% or Natural )eat% at t%e %ands of criminal ne/us & m' bod' must be %anded o+er to SS Medical !olle"e & M'sore for t%e stud' purposes of medical students( E'e )onation : 7ot% E@ES of Na"ara,a M 2 & Editor & S(0(S- e 1 clarion of )alit # S(0(S-e-<oice for ustice are donated to M'sore E'e 7an. & M'sore & In case of eit%er =nnatural deat% or Natural )eat% at t%e %ands of criminal ne/us & m' e'es must be %anded o+er to M'sore E'e 7an. & M'sore WITHIN I Hours for immediate e'e transplantation to t%e need'( Home pa"e : %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r* & %ttp:::"roups("oo"le(co(in:"roup:%r*epaper: & %ttp:::sites("oo"le(com:site:sose+oicefor,ustice: & %ttp:::e+oiceof%umanri"%ts*atc%(*ordpress(com: & %ttp:::indiapolicela*(blo"spot(com: & %ttp:::na"%r*(tripod(com:e+oice: & %ttp:::e+oiceof%umanri"%ts*atc%(blo"spot(com &

!ontact : na"%r*V'a%oo(com & na"ara,%r*V%otmail(com

&

=I) Aad%aar No : EDJL ELLM LGDM !ell : MF MLGFKAJLFL I &NA8A2A A(M(2( %ereb' do declare t%at information "i+en abo+e are true to t%e best of m' .no*led"e # belief( If i am repeatedl' called to police station or else *%ere for t%e sa.e of in+esti"ations & t%e losses i do incurr as a result li.e loss of *a"es & transportation & ,ob & etc must be borne b' t%e "o+ernment( pre+oiusl' t%e police : I7 personnel repeatedl' called me t%e complainant 5sufferer of in,ustices6 to police station for 4uestionin" & but ne+er called t%e

"uilt' culprits e+en once to police station for 4uestionin" & as t%e culprits are %i"% # mi"%t' ( t%is t'pe of one sided 4uestionin" must not be done b' police or in+esti"atin" a"encies ( if an't%in" unto*ard %appens to me or to m' famil' members li.e loss of ,ob & meetin" *it% %it # run accidents & loss of li+es & deat% due to improper medical care & etc & t%e ,urisdictional police to"et%er *it% abo+e mentioned accussed public ser+ants *ill be responsible for it( E+en if criminal ne/us le+els fa.e c%ar"es & police file fa.e cases a"ainst me or m' dependents to silence me & t%is complaint is # *ill be effecti+e( If I or m' famil' members or m' dependents are denied our fundamental ri"%ts & %uman ri"%ts & denied proper medical care for oursel+es & If an't%in" unto*ard li.e %it # run cases & murder attempts & unnatural deat%s & etc %appens to me or to m' dependents or to m' famil' members - In suc% case !%ief ustice of India to"et%er *it% t%e ,urisdictional re+enue # police officials *ill be responsible for it & in suc% case t%e "o+ernment of india is liable to pa' 2s( TW0 crore as compensation to sur+i+ors of m' famil'( if m' *%ole famil' is eliminated b' t%e criminal ne/us &t%en t%at compensation mone' must be donated to Indian Arm' Welfare Fund( After*ards & t%e mone' must be reco+ered b' 80I as land arrears from t%e salar' & pension & propert' & etc of "uilt' police officials & "uilt' ud"es & "uilt' public ser+ants # "uilt' !onstitutional fuctionaries(

date :

FL(JK(AJFL((UUUUUUUUU((@our;s sincerel'&

place : IndiaUUUUUUUUUU((((((((((((Na"ara,a(M(2(

Sa+e Hebbal La.e Sa+e 7EML Wuarters La.e in M'sore 1 An Appeal to Honourable Supreme !ourt of India

In t%e past & M'sore Ma%ara,a # ot%er p%ilant%ropists %a+e donated t%eir personal lands & properties & built man' la.es # ponds in m'sore & ban"alore and ot%er places *it% public concern & public *ellbein" in t%eir mind ( T%e' built t%ese la.es # ponds in addition to preser+in" t%e natural la.es # ponds( T%e' .ne* about t%e importance of ecolo"ical balance # en+ironment( T%e present rulers & IAS # 9AS babus %a+e e+en failed to preser+e t%e la.es # ponds built decades a"o & let alone build one( T%ese Public ser+ants %a+e e/tended t%eir tacit support to buildin" mafia & to .ill t%ese la.es # ponds & to fill t%ose la.es *it% industrial effluents & se*a"e # buildin" mud *astes( After .illin" t%ose la.es # ponds & t%e buildin" mafia

encroac%es on it # usurps t%at public propert' in turn sellin" it for crores of rupees(

In t%is *a' & Hoota"alli la.e *as .illed # encroac%ed b' 9a'nes Hotel 5 no* silent s%ores %otel6 & Hebbal La.e is bein" .illed # encroac%ed from all sides b' industries and t%e la.e infront of 7EML Wuarters is bein" .illed # land demarcation for sellin" t%ose land %as alread' be"un(

T%e public ser+ants *ere totall' indifferent to*ards public outcr' a"ainst t%is ( T%e IAS # 9AS babus *%o are also ma"istrates *it% ,udicial aut%orit' %a+e failed in preser+in" t%ese la.es # ponds inspite of appeals to t%em( T%ese deat% of la.es resultin" in t%eir encroac%ments could %a+e been pre+ented earlier b' )! & Ta%sildar & M=)A !ommissioner # 9IA)7 0fficers( E+en I %a+e appealed to t%em t%rou"% m' *eb ne*s paper & t%e' didn-t ta.e action at all( I %a+e made 2TI re4uest to t%ose aut%orities to "i+e me information re"ardin" status of t%ose la.es 'ears a"o & fearin" trut% *ill come out t%e' didn-t an*er m' 4uestions in full & t%e' onl' "a+e %alf trut%s( W%en I persisited *it% m' 2TI re4uest t%e M'sore )istrict Ma"istrate at t%at time Mr( P(Mani+annan repeatedl' called me o+er p%one & abused me # t%reatened me ( E+en t%reats *ere made b' some policemen in mufti ( Finall' t%at la.e land *as allotted to an industriall' supposed to be close to Industries minister at t%at time( T%e courts are dispassionate # in%uman & *%ile passin" e+iction orders a"ainst poor people & t%e police are full of "uts # s%o* t%eir full bra+er' & +alour a"ainst t%ese poor land encroac%ers( Fine & let us appreciate t%eir dut' consciousness ( Ho*e+er ric% # *ell connected criminals %a+e ille"all' encroac%ed upon public lands & t%e same courts and police are not ta.in" appropriate action inspite of repeated appeals & *%' $ E+en t%e Supreme !ourt of India # Police are Wea. # Mea. before Land Mafia( )on-t t%e same ud"es # Police %a+e 8uts & 7ra+er' & )ut' !onciousness # Inte"rit' to ta.e action a"ainst suc% ric% land "rabbers $ T%e ans*er lies in t%e follo*in" articles( 0nce a"ain *e offer our conditional ser+ices to Supreme !ourt of India & to le"all' appre%end criminals *%ile t%e respecti+e public ser+ants %a+e failed to do t%e same(

Hereb' & *e re4uest t%e %onourable Supreme !ourt of India & F( To initiate criminal prosecution a"ainst M'sore district ma"istrate & M'sore talu. ma"istrate & M=)A !ommissioner & urisdictional Police 0fficers # 9IA)7 0fficer & for ma.in" contempt of Supreme !ourt of India 0rder appl'in" t%rou"%t india to preser+e la.es # ponds( A( To e+ict all encroac%ers fort% *it% (

L( To immediatel' stop all flo* of industrial effluents # se*a"e to t%ese la.es # ponds(

G( To initiate criminal prosecution a"ainst encroac%ers of t%ese la.es # pollters & .illers of t%ese la.es( E( To preser+e t%e said la.es # ponds & b' reco+erin" cost from encroac%ers & pollutin" industries and t%e co-conspirators M'sore )! & M'sore Ta%sildar & M=)A !ommissioner & 9IA)7 0fficer # urisdictional Police 0fficers( I( To protect me & m' famil' members # dependents from land mafia # coconspirators of t%e crime( D( To order & to issue Writ of Mandamus to M'sore )istrict Ma"istrate & M=)A !ommissioner # 9IA)7 0fficer to disclose all t%e information sou"%t b' me in m' 2TI re4uest publicl'( T%e cop' of m' 2TI re4uest is reproduced belo*(

)ate : FD(FF(AJFA Place : M'sore

@our-s Sincerel'& Na"ara,a(M(2(

Si"n to Sa+e Hebbal La.e #

7EML Wuarters La.e in M'sore

%ttp:::***(c%an"e(or":petitions:%onourable-supreme-court-of-india-sa+e%ebbal-la.e-sa+e-beml-4uarters-la.e-in-m'soreX

Cri'inals in .upre'e Court o" India 7 > (n (ppeal to .upre'e Court o" India

To /

Justice .at asiva' / )onourable C ie" Justice o" India / C-o Re!istrar>General / .upre'e Court o" India / +e5 Del i$

Honourable sir & Hereb' & *e e/press our *%ole %earted respects for t%e %onest fe* public ser+ants in ,udiciar' & politics & police ser+ice # ot%er public ser+ices(

ud"es must become Human 7ein"s first # 2espect Human 2i"%ts & Human )i"nit' of ot%ers(

Man' of t%e *or. practices of ,ud"es & police # ot%er public ser+ants are ille"al leadin" to crimes( T%e inaction of supreme court of india inspite of repeated appeals b' us & tantamounts to crime co+er-ups & a crime in itself( In our appeals & t%ere are cases of ,ud"es & police # ot%er public ser+ants committin" fraud & c%eatin" & se/capades & murder & etc( still & if t%e learned ,ud"es of t%e supreme court of india feels t%at & no action le"al prosecution is called for inferrin" t%ere is no crime at all & t%en t%ere is no crime at all on indian soil( So & if a commonman committs t%e same crime of t%eft & fraud & se/capades & etc & %e must also be let out as t%e "uilt' ,ud"es & police & public ser+ants are let out ( T%ese "uilt' public ser+ants are so cunnin" # cruel t%at misusin" t%eir offices & po*ers sees to t%at no one dares to le+el c%ar"es a"ainst t%em & e+en if one does name sa.e in+esti"ation is conducted e+idences are manipulated & etc( finall' as per tec%nicalit' & le"alit' t%e criminal are not declared as criminals # punis%ed as per t%e la*( A ,ud"e & a policeman committin" a crime t%emsel+es are not morall' # le"all' fit to in+esti"ate & prosecute # sit in ,ud"ement o+er t%e crimes of ot%er criminals( A criminal cann-t prosecute # ,ud"e anot%er criminal( 0ur publication %as raised man' issues of public interest # repeatedl' appealed to supreme court of india to consider t%ose as PILs # to pro+ide ,ustice( T%e learned ,ud"es of t%e ape/ court didn-t care about t%e public *elfare & interest t%e' didn-t admit m' PILs ( Probabl' t%e' %ad pri+ate interests to protect ( T%ereb' ,ud"es are s%ieldin" criminals & t%eir crime and "i+in" t%e free run to criminals to continue *it% t%eir crimes

furt%er( All t%ese acts of ,ud"es itself are crimes # t%e concerned ,ud"es are criminals fit to be le"all' prosecuted( )t the outset , we express our whole hearted respects to the honest ew public servants in public service including judiciary. ,owever, the corrupt in public service don’t deserve respect as individuals M as they are parasites in our legal system. &till we respect the chairs they occupy but not the corrupt individuals.

)ll the ollowing articles $ issues , whole articles published in the weblin!s mentioned below orms part o this appeal. The term 5(U9#-6 mentioned throught includes all public servants discharging judicial unctions right rom talu! magistrates , 7uasi%judicial o icers to 'hie (ustice o 4ndia.

The public servants L the government must be role models in law abiding acts , or others to emulate L ollow. i a student ma!es a mista!e it is excusable L can be corrected by the teacher. i the teacher himsel ma!es a mista!e , all his students will do the same mista!e. i a thie steals , he can be caught , legally punished L re ormed . i a police himsel commits crime , many thieves go scot% ree under his patronage. even i a police , public servant commits a crime , he can be legally prosecuted L justice can be sought by the aggrieved. just thin! , i a judge himsel that too o apex court o the land itsel commits crime % violations o :T4 )ct , constitutional rights L human rights o public and obstructs the public rom per orming their constitutional undamental duties , what happens K it gives a booster dose to the rich L mighty , those in power , criminals in public service to committ more crimes. that is exactly what is happenning in india. the educated public must raise to the occassion L peace ully , democratically must oppose this criminalisation o judiciary , public service. then alone , we can build a :)1 :)(D) OH 1),)T1) #)@9,4F& 9:-)1.

)ue to m' stru""le for ,ustice for public # for m'self & ris.in" m' life # libert' F(I *as not permitted to appear as Amicus !urie before ain !ommission of En4uir' # Supreme !ourt of India IN 2a,i+ "And%i Assasination !ase( A( I %a+e suffered p%'sical assaults # murder attempts( L(M' ne*spaper publication *as ille"all' closed do*n( G( M' ,ob opputunities *ere ille"all' snatc%ed a*a' & etc(

T%e police don-t %a+e t%e le"al po*er to boo. & in+esti"ate cases a"ainst constitutional persons en,o'in" le"al pri+ile"es( T%e police %a+e repetedl' called me to police station & but t%e' %a+e ne+er called t%e "uilt' <<IPs e+en once to police station ( T%e' %a+e repeatedl' tried to close t%e case ( If t%e aut%orities are sincere "i+e le"al aut%orit' sanction to prosecute <<IP criminals( Hereb' & I do once a"ain offer m' conditional ser+ices to supreme court of india & to le"all' prosecute criminals( Neit%er t%e "o+ernment nor t%e courts %a+e accepted m' offer( Inspite of all t%ese attempts b' criminal ne/us to silence me & t%e supreme court of india didn-t bot%er to admit m' PILs # to pro+ide ,ustice to t%e public ( T%e' %ad pri+ate & ille"al interests to protect( T%ese are t%e times *%en ud"es accused in SET scandals "et ele+ated to %i"%est ,udicial institutions( W%en e+er'bod' else does t%e mista.e & *ron" doin" & indul"es in corruption & ,udiciar' alone must be pure li.e +ir"in to punis% # "uide t%e *ron" doers( No* & t%e ape/ court of t%e land # t%e %i"%est ,udicial officer of t%e land & t%e conscience .eeper & protector of ri"%ts & !onstitutional "uardian of t%e land 1 T%e Honourable !%ief ustice of India %imself Has been found "uilt' ( SHAME SHAME(

No*ada's & *e are seein" criminali3ation of politics & ,udiciar' # police( T%e ro*d' elements %a+e become MLAs # MPs # fre4uestl' indul"e in fisticuffs & +ul"ar abuses in t%e precincts of t%e %ouse itself ( T%ese ro*d' elements ta.e mone' for as.in" 4uestions in t%e parliament & to +ote for bills # for a price pass le"islations fa+ourin" lobbies of ric% croo.s( T%e police frame & torture innocents # let out ric% croo.s for a price ( For a price police destro' e+idences & records and create fa.e records & e+idences( Finall' t%ere are ,ud"es *%o issue arrest *arrants & "i+e bail & "i+e ac4uittal # pass fa+ourable ,ud"ements ALL F02 A P2I!E ( SHAME SHAME ( T%ese corrupt ,ud"es & police & MPs & MLAs eac% ta.e salar' # per.s far e/ceedin" la.%s per annum & but ser+e ric% croo.s instead of Indian Public( T%ese corrupt are parasites # deadlier & state enemies t%an na/alites & terrorists( )emocrac' in our countr' & our %ard *on national independence is endan"ered b' t%ese parasites & corrupt ,ud"es & police # people-s representati+es onl'( T%ese parasites t%emsel+es are responsible for ori"in # "ro*t% of na/alism : terrorism in india ( 2ead full details at & Matc% Fi/in" ud"es # Police :

%ttps:::sites("oo"le(com:site:sose+oicefor,ustice:matc%-fi/in"-,ud"es-police &a"ia , .upre'e Court o" India https:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$ma ia%supreme%court%o %india , https:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$crimes%o %mysore%dc%muda ,

https:$$sites.google.com$site$sosevoice orjustice$wheeling%dealing%judges%police%o %india

Hereb' & *e )EMAN) t%e Honourable !%ief ustice of India to ans*er t%e follo*in" 4uestions in public interest & for national securit' & for National unit' # inte"rit'( Hereb' & *e also re4uest t%e ape/ court to order t%e concerned public ser+ants & public aut%orities to ans*er follo*in" 2TI W=ESTI0NS(

2ead full details at follo*in" *eb pa"e : https:$$sites.google.com$site$eclariono dalit$judges%deal%with%ma ia

ai Hind( <ande Mataram(

)ate : FL(JK(AJFL Place : M'sore

@our-s Sincerel' & Na"ara,a(M(2(

.election o" *+4IT W(.TE 0OD3 CRI&I+(L. as Jud!es , Police % GOL&((L in J*DGE / Police selection - Recruit'ent

In India / corruption / "avouritis' is prevalent in all recriut'ent - selection processes$ T e selection is 'ade on bribe / caste / reli!ion but de"initely +OT on t e basis o" &erit , Inte!rity$ T e selection to t e posts o" even .upre'e court Jud!es / Buasi #udicial o""icers li6e district 'a!istrates / talu6 'a!istrates / police / etc is not above board$ T ese tainted / ineli!ible un"it 5aste body candidates 5 o !et selected as #ud!es / police t rou! devious 'eans sell t eir #udicial orders / e<ecutive orders / police orders "or a price$ T e denot"ications o" !overn'ent lands / etc as in t e case o" &ysore DC 2astrad / as in t e case o" +e!lect o" )ebbal La6e ,/ 0E&L 8uarters La6e Encroac 'ent by DC &anivannan / as in t e case o" Land irre!ularities by 0an!alore DC (iyyappa / c an!in! t e penal clause o" penal c ar!es to

"avour t e cri'inal as in t e case o" union carbideAs 5arren (nderson "ro' 'ass 'urder to i'proper 'ana!e'ent o" t e "acility / as in t e case o" .an#ay dutt "ro' T(D( c ar!es to ille!al possession o" ar's / etc$ T e police "or a price "i< innocents / "ile 0 reports "avourin! t e cri'inals to close t e case / pre"er not to "ile an appeal in t e i! er court / etc$ (s in t e case o" 0o"ors / as in t e case o" past .P o" c a'ara#ana!ar Puttas5a'y ta6in! bribe "ro' a !ranite Buarry o5ner "or "ilin! 0>report in a case$ Dis!race"ully / recently a #ud!e tainted in &3.ORE ROO.T RE.ORT .E= .C(+D(L 5as pro'oted as a supre'e court #ud!e$ W at Justice co''on "ol6 can e<pect "ro' t ese corrupt bodies 7 T ey turn ille!alities into le!al issues by t eir orders$ T ese CORR*PT Jud!es / Police / District &a!istrates / Talu6 &a!istrates are doin! 'ore da'a!e to IndiaAs *nity , Inte!rity t an t e +a<alites , Terrorists$ T ese corrupt public servants 'ust be put be ind bars to!et er 5it terrorists , na<alites$ Let t e sense prevail , De'ocracy prosper$ T e )onest "e5 in Judiciary / Police , E<ecutive 'ust raise upto t e occasion to .(2E DE&OCR(C3 , to 6ic6 out t eir corrupt collea!ues "ro' o""ice$

udicial La'out Site Allotment 1 72I7E T0 =)8ES $

Is t%e allotment of residential plots to ud"es V 'ela%an.a udicial La'out & a mode of pa'in" bribe to ,ud"es b' t%e bi""est liti"ant "o+ernment itself # t%e corrupt public ser+ants in t%e "o+ernment( So t%at t%e "o+ernment can pass ille"al la*s li.e >2e"ulari3ation of Ille"al 7uildin"s? & > Ille"al Appointments to Medical colle"es in Hassan & M'sore? &etc # ministers & IAS officers can indul"e in ille"al unconstitutional acts & but t%e courts *ill not ta.e an' appropriate action suo motto or based on an' petition( IT IS M=T=AL HELP & NET=S 0F TW0 !2IMINALS 1 =)I!IA2@ # 80<E2NMENT( 0fcourse & t%ere are %onest fe* e/ceptions in ,udiciar' # "o+ernment( We 2espect t%ose %onest fe*( Information input forms part of process of one-s e/pression( 0ne-s e/pression in an' forms 1 *ritten & oral & etc becomes information input to t%e opposite person & in turn %e e/presses %is repl'( Information # E/pression are inseparable parts # form lifeline of a democrac'( T%at is t%e reason & 2i"%t to E/pression is t%e basic fundamental ri"%t as *ell as %uman ri"%t of e+er' Indian citi3en( W%en a person-s ri"%t to e/pression is +iolated & %is ot%er ri"%ts to e4ualit' & ,ustice & etc also are +iolated( Suppression of Information amounts to curbin" of E/pression( In a democrac' & people %a+e a ri"%t to .no* %o* t%e public ser+ants are functionin"( Ho*e+er till date public ser+ants are %idin" be%ind t%e +eil of 0fficials Secrets Act 5*%ic% is of britis% +inta"e created b' britis% to suppress nati+e indians6( 7' t%is co+er-up public ser+ants are %idin" t%eir o*n corruption & crimes & mismana"ement & failures & etc( e+en 2TI Act is not bein"

follo*ed intoto b' public ser+ants( Ho*e+er t%e recent del%i %i"% court rulin" affirmin" t%at ! I is under 2TI pur+ie* # bound to ans*er 2TI re4uest & is note*ort%'( 0ur pre+ious 2TI re4uest to ! I & union %ome secretar' of 80I& President of India & )8 # I8P of 809 and ot%ers *ere not %onored( T%e information I sou"%t *ere ans*ers to t%e follo*in" 4uestions mentioned in t%e belo* mentioned *ebsites ( t%e 4uestions concerned t%e past & present continuin" in,ustices meted out to millions of Indian citi3ens & due to *ron" : ille"al *or. practices of Indian ,ud"es & police # public ser+ants ( T%e information *e sou"%t *ould e/pose t%e traitors & anti-nationals & criminals in public ser+ice( T%e information *e are see.in" are no defense secrets & no national secrets( T%e trut%ful information e/poses t%e anti-nationals & traitors in t%e public ser+ice # stren"t%ens our national securit' & national unit' # inte"rit'( Hereb' & I do re4uest t%e %onorable supreme court of India to consider t%is as a PIL for : >*rit of Mandamus? and to issue instructions to t%e concerned public ser+ants in t%e follo*in" cases to perform t%eir duties # to ans*er t%e 4uestions at follo*in" *eb pa"e : %ttp:::sites("oo"le(com:site:eclarionofdalit:deals-in-courts

9PS! is a den of corruption: Nanaia%

The recently unearthed recruitment scandal in >arnata!a )dministrative &ervice .>)&/ examinations involving senior 4)& o icer >.). 1onappa is only the Gtip o the icebergG and more such scandals are waiting to be unearthed in the >arnata!a Public &ervice 'ommission .>P&'/, ormer "aw 1inister 1.'. @anaiah has said. )ddressing presspersons here on 8ednesday, he termed >P&' a Gden o corruptionG and its recruitment methods Gnothing but raudG. )ccusing >P&' 'hairman ,.@. >rishna o Gharping on the single issueG o 'o9 in7uiry into the 3OOC recruitment to Gcover up all other lapsesG, 1r. @anaiah challenged him and other members to Gvoluntarily submit themselves to an in7uiryG i they were indeed men o integrity. ,e sought to !now why the #overnment was !eeping 7uiet despite being aware o the malpractices in the commission. ,e said the #overnment should evolve an alternative system o recruitment since ormation o >P&' board was Ginherently lawedG and Gbeyond any clean upG. ,e avoured ormation o departmental committees or recruitment, though >P&' could not be wound up as its ormation was mandated by the 'onstitution. Though ,ome 1inister 1.P. Pra!ash had spo!en o recruiting tahsildars directly, nothing had been done in that direction, he said. G)ll public service commission members enjoy immunity guaranteed by the 'onstitution. These rules were ramed assuming that men o integrity would be appointed to the commission. =ut caste actor and political compulsions have always guided appointments,G 1r. @aniah said. &tate governments, which made these appointments, had no power to sac! any o these

members. E4-8 : www.youtube.com$watchKvQW#0&(0Ib(sC / http:$$www.google.co.in$urlKsaQtLrctQjL7Q!psc^*2^*2recruitment ^*2^*2scandalLsourceQwebLcdQ3LcadQrjaLvedQ2''sWtw4w))LurlQhttp^<)^*H ^*Hwww.youtube.com^*Hwatch^<Hv ^<9W#0&(0Ib(sCLeiQ2,apUd9g40<Or) 8o09W=)LusgQ)HWj'@#tjUg1+:UwHPCWcnD,y dHdc)v3pg

9PS! inter+ie*s come under a cloud

>arnata!a Public &ervice 'ommission .>P&'/ interviews or recruitment o <?* #aIetted probationers starting rom )pril 3, has come under a cloud with a large number o candidates and social activists preparing to approach the high court 7uestioning selection list o candidates called or interview by the >P&'. 9& Parameshwarappa, an ex%serviceman and resident o >asturinagar alleged huge irregularities in the entire process involving big money as bribes. G>P&' chairman #onal =himappaFs term is ending in a month. The hurry with which the interview process is being done gives rise to many suspicions,G he said. Parameshwarappa urther alleged that >P&' had announced the list o candidates selected or interviews even be ore the re%totalling process, or candidates who had applied or the same or the written exam. G4 have speci ic in ormation on >P&' not giving answer scripts sought through :T4 )ct,G he said. ) group o social activists @ Easudev, ,arish )radhya and Parameshwarappa had re7uested the election commission to postpone the interviews scheduled by the >P&'. ,owever, the commission said it wonFt inter ere with the wor!ing o >P&', as it is an autonomous body. 4n turn, Parameshwarappa has decided to ta!e the matter to the ,', with a P4". ,e urther stated he would ma!e the -lection 'ommission also a party to it, or ailing to act. ,owever the >P&' de ended its actions, saying it was an autonomous institution, and the rule provides >P&' with the authority go ahead with regular appointments and promotions. =ut this is an irregular appointment, he asserted. 4t may be recalled that selection o candidates or interview by >P&' in 3OOC, 3OOO and *220 too had raised a storm causing damage to its image.

)ccording to Easudev, the autonomous body does not have the authority to increase the number o posts i there are changes in re%totaling o any candidates. G1oreover, i there is a change, the entire list will have to be changed. 8e will bring up all these acts be ore the court,G he explained. &ources said there was lot o con usion in the cut o %mar!s or candidates selected or oral interview. 1any candidates who scored aggregate o over O22 mar!s out o total 3C22 were not called or interview, while some with much lesser mar!s were summoned, sources added. ,owever, #onal =himappa, 'hairman o >P&' outrightly re uted all the charges. 8hen as!ed about conducting interviews be ore the completion o retotaling, he said it would not ma!e any di erence as there would be no major changes in the re%totaling. :esponding to allegations o being in a hurry as he is set to retire in a month, =himappa clari ied that along with him, another senior member @ :ama!rishna would also be retiring, and decisions were not being ta!en by violating the rules. ,e added the >P&' would go ahead with the schedule o conducting interviews.

!omplaint 2e"istration )etails of complaint made to follo*in" public ser+ants

,onourable 'hie (ustice o 4ndia ,.-.,onourable President o 4ndia

9-PO($-$*23*$22?O? ):@P#$-$*23*$22<2?

,onourable Prime 1inister o 4ndia 9)TO1$-$*23*$22*<? ,onourable #overnor , :eserve =an! o 4ndia :=4=>$-$*23*$22A?2

,onourable Union home secretary 14@,)$-$*23*$23?CC ,onourable 'entral Eigilance 'ommissioner 9OP)T$-$*23*$22OA3

,onourable 'hairman @ational ,uman :ights 'ommission 9"#")$-$*23*$22*CA ,onourable 9irector 'entral =ureau o 4nvestigations ,.-. ,onourable #overnor o >arnata!a 1O9-H$-$*23*$23C+C

#OE>@$-$*23*$22C*2

FI2ST APPEAL =N)E2 SE! FM 5F6 0F 2TI A!T AJJE 0F 80<E2NMENT 0F IN)IA # 80<E2NMENT 0F 9A2NATA9A APPLI!ATI0N F02 INF02MATI0N AS PE2 2TI A!T AJJE 5 SEE 2=LE AA 0F 2TI A!T AJJE 6

!PI0 & )8# I8P & 7AN8AL02E dated FL(JM(AJFA !PI0 & !M0 & 7AN8AL02E JD(JM(AJFA

2eference No : FJEL:2TI:SP5P206:AJFA:2PA) 2eference No : !M:IAA:2TI:AJFA dated 2eference No : 8S FIE 2TI AJFA dated

!PI0 & 2A 7HAWAN & 7AN8AL02E JL(JM(AJFA

!PI0 & =NI0N H0ME MINIST2@ & 80I & NEW )ELHI 2eference No : )'(No(FAFKJE:)S:!S:AJFA-!S2(III dated FA(JM(AJFA

!PI0 & 2A @ASA7HA & NEW )ELHI FD(JM(AJFA

2eference No(2S:A5GEK6:AJFA-2TI dated

!PI0 & L09SA7HA & NEW )ELHI 2eference No : F 5MDM6 : I!:FA dated AG(JK(AJFA and No(F 5FJLJ6 : I! : FA dated JL(JM(AJFA !PI0 & 2ASHT2APATHI 7HAWAN & NEW )ELHI 2eference No: MEE:2TI:JK:FA-FL dated AM(JK(AJFA !PI0 & S=P2EME !0=2T 0F IN)IA & NEW )ELHI & N0 2EPL@

F=LL NAME 0F THE APPLI!ANT : NA8A2A A(M(2(

A))2ESS 0F THE APPLI!ANT : NA8A2A A(M(2(& E)IT02 & S0S E-<0I!E =STI!E # S0S E-!LA2I0N 0F )ALIT & X LI8-A : DIF& 0PP WATE2 W029S 0FFI!E& H=)!0 FI2ST STA8E& LATMI9ANTANA8A2&

HE77AL& M@S02E & 9A2NATA9A PIN 1 EDJJFD(

2TI First Appeal Made to First Appellate Aut%orities

2TI APPELLATE A=TH02IT@ & 0:0 )8 # I8 of Police & 8o+ernment of 9arnata.a &Police HW & 7an"alore(

)ETAILS 0F )0!=MENTS : W2ITTEN STATEMENTS : INF02MATI0N 2EW=I2E) :

T%e concerned !PI0 %as failed to pro+ide information to me & t%ereb' %e is s%ieldin" t%e criminals & anti nationals( In turn !PI0 %imself %as committed crimes( It "oes to pro+e t%e e/istence of !riminal Ne/us bet*een !2IMINALS !022=PT P=7LI! SE2<ANTS 1 !022=PT P0LITI!IANS(

HE2E7@ & I )0 H=M7L@ 2EW=EST @0= T0 8I<E ME W2ITTEN STATEMENTS : ANSWE2S T0 THE F0LL0WIN8 W=ESTI0NS 1 WHI!H IN ITSELF 5 ie ans*ers 6 A2E THE INF02MATI0N S0=8HT 7@ ME( HE2E WITH I AM SEE9IN8 N0T THE 0PINI0NS A70=T S0ME H@P0THETI!AL ISS=ES & 7=T @0=2 0FFI!IAL STAN) & LE8AL STAN) 0N ISS=ES WHI!H A2E 0F F2EW=ENT 0!!=22EN!E WHI!H A2E <I0LATIN8 PE0PLE-S F=N)AMENTAL 2I8HTS # H=MAN 2I8HTS( WE )0 HA<E HI8HEST 2ESPE!TS F02 =)I!IA2@ # ALL P=7LI! INSTIT=TI0NS & THIS IS AN APPEAL F02 T2=TH & INF02MATI0N S0 THAT T0 APP2EHEN) !022=PT FEW IN P=7LI! SE2<I!E& WH0 A2E AI)IN8 # A7ETTIN8 TE2202ISM & =N)E2W02L) # !2IMINALS( I HA<E SH0WN IN )ETAIL WITH LI<E & A!T=AL !ASES & ETAMPLES & H0W IN)IAN LE8AL S@STEM IS MANIP=LATE) 7@ !2IMINALS WITHIN =)I!IA2@ & P0LI!E & P20SE!=TI0N & ET!( 2EA) )ETAILS AT : %ttps:::sites("oo"le(com:site:eclarionofdalit:*%eelin"-dealin"-,ud"es-police

Hereb' & *e do re4uest PI0 0:0 Honourable !%ief ustice of India & PI0 & 0:0 H(E(Honorable President of India & PI0 0:0 Honorable Spea.er of Lo. Sab%a & PI0 0:0 )' !%airman of 2a,'a Sab%a & PI0s of 9arnata.a 2a, 7%a*an & 9arnata.a !M0 & =nion Home Ministr' 80I and )8 # I8 of Police of 8o+ernment of 9arnata.a to ans*er t%e follo*in" 4uestions in public interest & for safe"uardin" national securit' & National unit' # inte"rit' # to le"all' appre%end anti-nationals & criminals *it%in t%e ,udiciar' # police(

Main A : @ou %a+e not ta.en appropriate action to m' pre+ious 2TI re4uests & Numerous appeals for ,ustice # police complaints( @ou %a+e not replied to s%o*-cause notice also( @our inaction %as %elped t%e criminals in manipulatin" # destro'in" e+idences(

@our inaction : dela' in performin" 'our duties not onl' amounts to denial of information & but amounts to +iolation of our fundamental # %uman ri"%ts & co+er-up of crimes & aidin" # abettin" criminals ( T%e criminal ne/us tried to silence me in man' *a's( Is not t%ese acts of 'our-s a crime in itself $

If 'our acts of crime co+er-ups & information : e+idence co+er-ups & aidin" # abettin" criminals & silencin" a crusader is ,ust # le"al( T%e same t'pe of acts of crimes performed b' ot%er citi3ens *ill also be le"al $

Main 7 : At t%e outset & *e e/press our *%ole %earted respects to all constitutional institutions # to t%e %onest fe* in public ser+ice( !ontempt of constitutional institutions & citi3ens of India is bein" made b' t%e corrupt persons in constitutional positions t%emsel+es( T%is is an appeal to t%e %onest fe* in public ser+ice & constitutional positions & to brin" t%eir corrupt collea"ues to boo.(

F( does t%e action of MPs & MLAs ta.in" mone' : recei+in" fa+ors from +ested interests & to formulate polic' decisions & to raise 4uestions in parliament : le"islati+e bodies or to abstain from +otin" le"al $ A( *%' transparent & fair in+esti"ation is not done in suc% cases $

L( ,ust remember & t%e +ul"ar acts of Mr(7ora 7abu Sin"% in state le"islature # %o* some MLAs +ul"arl' be%a+ed *it% Ms( a'alalita in state le"islature & 'ears a"o( Are t%ese t'pe of +ul"ar actions b' MPs # MLAs le"al $ does not t%ese constitute contempt of t%e %ouse b' MPs # MLAs t%emsel+es $ G( all t%e people-s representati+es from panc%a'at% member to president of India must read A7!) 0f )emocrac' pro+ide alon" *it%(since independence of India till date & MPs # MLAs are forcin" pro,ects on people a"ainst t%e *is%es of people & formulatin" policies a"ainst t%e *is%es of people( Are not suc% pro,ects & "o+ernment policies # La*s & undemocratic # ille"al $

E( is t%e election commission of India +erif'in" t%e aut%enticit' of affida+its submitted b' electoral candidates $ I( %o* man' candidates %a+e been cau"%t so far for "i+in" false affida+its $ are all t%e +iolators prosecuted$ D( are t%e MPs & MLAs submittin" t%eir *ealt% details on affida+its 'earl' to +i"ilance aut%orities $ defaulters & +iolators %o* man' $ K( *%at le"al action ta.en a"ainst +iolators & defaulters & for "i+in" false affida+its $ M( *%o is c%ec.in" t%e aut%enticit' of t%ose affida+its submitted b' MPs & MLAs $ FJ( t%e a"ricultural incomes of some MPs & MLAs & t%eir .i% # .in raises e+en durin" t%e time of se+ere drou"%t & floods & fall in prices of a"ricultural products & t%eir companies re"ister increase in turno+er : profits e+en durin" recession & t%e trusts : N80s set up b' t%em recei+e %u"e donations( Are all t%ese income le"al $

Main ! : F( *e do once a"ain offer our conditional ser+ices to t%e "o+ernment of india & all state "o+ernments # supreme court of india & in appre%endin" ta/ e+aders & land "rabbers & corrupt police & corrupt ,ud"es & corrupt public ser+ants & labor la* +iolators & etc( *%om t%e t%e "o+ernment officials & +i"ilance aut%orities %a+e failed to appre%end( W%' t%e aut%orities & courts & supreme court of India & are not read' to utili3e our ser+ice $ are t%e' afraid of bein" cau"%t $ A( t%e public ser+ants & courts t%esel+es are dela'in" "i+in" information : records to us in man' cases( So in t%e issues : cases raised b' us & t%e clause of time bar doe not appl'( Are t%ese dela'in" tactics of public ser+ants & courts le"al $ L( *%' no proper & timel' action *as not ta.en based on numerous police complaints made b' us $ G( *%' )8 # I8P & 8o+ernment of 9arnata.a & %as not made an' efforts to see. le"al sanction for prosecution of <<IPs 5 mentioned in our complaint 6 & from union # state %ome ministries $ E( t%e criminal ne/us is tr'in" to silence me in man' *a's & but t%e supreme court of India # national %uman ri"%ts commission %as failed to undo t%e in,ustices & *%' $ is it because it is not a %i"% profile case $ is it because it is not %i-fi & does not "et ima"e ratin"s & T2Ps $

I( t%e public ser+ants are aidin" under*orld & na/alites # terrorists & b' t%eir dela'in" tactics # denial of information & records( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst suc% anti-national elements in public ser+ice $ D( %o* man' complaints are made b' Na"ara, (M(2( & Human 2i"%ts Acti+ist & M'sore 5editor of S0S e-clarion of dalit # S0S e-+oice for ,ustice6 to 9arnata.a police & to national %uman ri"%ts commission to supreme court of India till date $ *%at action ta.en *it% respect to eac% complaint $ K( t%e dela' in ta.in" action b' public ser+ants *it% respect to follo*in" cases %as resulted in more crimes & destruction : manipulation of e+idences & records and more in,ustices to commonman( W%' t%e aut%orities did not ta.e timel' action a"ainst criminals in follo*in" cases $

.O. (ppeal to .*PRE&E CO*RT o" I+DI( ttp1--e>clariono"dalit$blo!spot$co'-:CEC-CG-s>o>s>appeal>to>supre'e>F DE(L. I+ CO*RT. , POLICE .T(TIO+. RE(D 1 ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-satya'eva>#ayate / ttp1--e>clariono"dalit$blo!spot$co'-:CEE-CE-satya'eva>#ayate$ t'l / (CC*.ED C ie" Justice o" India ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-accused>c ie">#ustice>o"F / ttp1--e>clariono"dalit$blo!spot$co'-:CEE-C:-accused>c ie">#ustice>o"F CRO.. E=(& O4 )O+O*R(0LE C)IE4 J*.TICE O4 I+DI( / .*PRE&E CO*RT O4 I+DI( > ttp1--crossc#i$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eso"supre'ecourt$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crossc#i$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$5ordpress$co'- / CRO.. E=(& O4 *+IO+ )O&E .ECRET(R3 / GOI / +EW DEL)I ? ttp1--crossc#i$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eso"supre'ecourt$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crossc#i$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$5ordpress$co'- / CRO.. E=(& O4 DG,IG O4 POLICE / GOH / 0(+G(LORE ? ttp1--crossc#i$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eso"supre'ecourt$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crossc#i$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$5ordpress$co'- / CRO.. E=(& O4 GO2ER+OR / RE.ER2E 0(+H O4 I+DI( ttp1--t e"tinrbi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--t e"tinrbi$redi""blo!s$co'/ ttp1--t e"tinrbi$5ordpress$co'CRO.. E=(& O4 &*D( CO&&I..IO+ER / &*D( / &3.ORE ? ttp1--cri'eso"'uda$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'anivannan'uda$blo!spot$co'-

/ ttp1--cri'esat'uda'ysore$5ordpress$co'- / CRO.. E=(& O4 0D( CO&&I..IO+ER / 0D( / 0(+G(LORE ? ttp1--cri'eso"bda$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--bdacri'es$5ordpress$co'- / CORPOR(TE CRI&E. RPG C(0LE. LI&ITED ttp1--cri'esatrp!$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'esatrp!$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:EG &EG( 4R(*D 03 GO2ER+&E+T O4 I+DI( ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ are you ready to catc ta< t ieves 7 ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ &O0ILE P)O+E. / C*RRE+C3 .C(+D(L. ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ reliance industry 5 ere is accountability 7 ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ cri'es at in"osys ca'pus ttp1--cri'eatin"y$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eatin"y$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:EK cri'es by 0$D$( a!ainst a poor 5o'an ttp1--cri'eso"bda$blo!pot$co'- / ttp1--bdacri'es$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:E: cri'es o" land 'a"ia in India ttp1--landsca'sinindia$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--landsca'$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:E: currency t e"ts in R0I Press ttp1--t e"tinrbi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--t e"tinrbi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-GC 6iller colas , 6iller 'edicines o" India ttp1--deat cola$blo!pot$co'- / ttp1--deat cola$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:CE )O+OR O4 I+DI(+ P(LI(&E+T 4OR .(LE %ttp:::sites("oo"le(com:site:eclarionofdalit:%onor-of-indian-parliament-for-sale Persecuted I20M SHA2MILA of Puttapart%i AP 1 pus%pa .olasani on %un"er stri.e in anantapur district ,ail And%ra Prades%

%ttp:::sites("oo"le(com:site:eclarionofdalit:persecuted-irom-s%armila-ofputtapart%i-ap

M( %o* man' ,ud"es are cau"%t b' aut%orities for doin" improper & immoral # ille"al acts & since independence till date $ *%at action ta.en in eac% case $ FJ( *%at action ta.en a"ainst cop' cat ,ud"es cau"%t red %anded *%ile cop'in" in public e/amination in And%ra Prades% $ FF( %a+e 'ou re+ie*ed all t%e pre+ious ,udicial decisions ta.en b' suc% ,ud"es of doubtful inte"rit' # %onest' $ FA( is it not t%e dut' of "o+ernment # supreme court of India & to protect t%e fundamental ri"%ts # %uman ri"%ts of all Indian citi3ens $ FL( *%' t%e "o+ernment # supreme court of India %as failed to protect t%e fundamental ri"%ts # %uman ri"%ts of me # t%ose mentioned in m' complaint $ FG( %o* man' former ! Is & supreme court # %i"% court ,ud"es %a+e disproportionate *ealt% $ FE( @our denial of information to m' pre+ious 2TI re4uests amounts to suppression of e+idence & %idin" crimes & *%at action a"ainst errin" public ser+ants $ FI( *%' m' pre+ious 2TI re4uests or part t%ere of *as not transferred to appropriate aut%orities and information "i+en to me in a consolidated form $

Main

) :

WF( W%' not deat% sentence to corrupt police *%o murder people in in loc.up : fa.e encounters $ WA( W%' not deat% sentence to corrupt police *%o appl' Lrd de"ree torture on prisoners $ WL( W%' not deat% sentence to corrupt police & *%o conni+e *it% criminals # bac.stabs our mot%erland & it-s national securit' $ WG( )on-t t%e police %a+e suo-motto po*ers to ta.e action in t%e interest of public *elfare & la* # order $

WE( )ail' *e see numerous reports of misdeeds b' police & public ser+ants & industrialists & etc in t%e media ( T%en *%' not police ta.in" an' action *it% respect to t%em $ WI( no*ada's *e see numerous reports of scams & scandals b' constitutional functionaries & public ser+ants in t%e media( Instead of *astin" mone' & .illin" time b' prolon"in" formation of parliamentar' committees & ,udicial commissions & *%' not sub,ect t%ose accussed public ser+ants to narco anal'sis & lie deector test & etc to ascertain trut% # pro+ide timel' ,ustice $ WD( If a commonman files a complaint & police : courts *ants e+idences & *itnesses to ta.e action a"ainst t%e ric% # mi"%t' croo.s( W%ere as if a ric% person ,ust "i+es a complaint a"ainst a poor c%ap & %e is arrested & tortured e+ent%ou"% t%ere are no e+idences & *itnesses( W%' t%is double standard $ WK( If a poor c%ap tries to collect e+idences as per %is fundamental ri"%ts or as per 2TI A!T & t%e public ser+ants don-t "i+e full & trut%full information( Still & police : courts don-t ta.e action a"ainst t%ose public ser+ants %idin" crimes( W%' $ WM(*%' I *as not permitted to appear as an >amicus curie? before ,ain commission of en4uir' or supreme court of india probin" late prime minister ra,i+ 8and%i assassination case $ WFJ( T%e criminal ne/us tried to silence me & b' closin" m' ne*s paper & b' snatc%in" a*a' m' ,ob oppurtunities in "o+ernment ser+ice& b' p%'sicall' assaultin" me & b' t%reatenin" me of false fi/-ups in cases # b' attempts to murder me( 7ut no action a"ainst culprits & *%' $ WFF( W%ereas & I *as en4uired number of times b' police # intelli"ence personnel about t%is case & but t%e culprits *ere not en4uired e+en once & *%' $ WFA(*%o compensates t%e losses I %a+e suffered due to t%ese in,ustices $ are not police responsible for it $ WFL( Is it not t%e dut' of police to protect t%e li+es & li+eli%ood of *itnesses # all parties in+ol+ed & bot% durin" case # after*ards $ WFG( Ho* do 'ou monitor # c%ec. corrupt police personnel # increase in t%eir famil'-s *ealt% 'ear after 'ear $ WFE( W%ile "ettin" appointed into "o+ernment ser+ice from t%e ran. of peon to IAS officer & police +erification is mandator'( W%ile appointin" to sensiti+e defense establis%ments & researc% institutes in addition to police +erification & central intelli"ence a"encies cross-c%ec. candidate-s bac."round( Ho*e+er is t%ere no bac."round c%ec.s of constitutional functionaries & MPs & MLAs & & *%o are pri+' to national secrets $ *%' $ WFI( 2ecentl' & t%e opposition parties %a+e made alle"ations durin" presidential alle"ations t%at close relati+e of one of t%e front runnin" candidates %a+e s*indled public mone' b' t%eir ban. & misused public mone' t%rou"% one of t%eir N80( Is it true $ WFD(%as 80I funded an' terrorist outfits in india or abroad $ WFK(india preac%es non-+iolence & panc%as%eel principles to t%e *orld( In india & more t%an %alf t%e population are poor & people are star+in" to deat%( Inspite t%ese bac."round & 80I funded # aided terrorist outfits in former east Pa.istan ensurin" t%e creation of 7an"lades% & 80I %as funded # aided terrorist outfits li.e LTTE & T=LF & ET! in srilan.a & MWM in Pa.istan( In turn t%ese terrorist outfits %a+e murdered t%ousands of innocents in t%ose countries( Are t%ese acts of 80I ,ust # le"al $ Is not 80I responsible for all

t%ose murders of innocents $ %as 80I paid an' compensation to t%ose +ictims or t%eir famil' mebers $ *%' not $ WFM(*it%in india & to reduce t%e influence of certain terrorist "roups & 80I %as funded # aided couter terrorist "roups & is it ri"%t # le"al $ WAJ( In %ar.%and & c%attis"ar% & etc & t%e "o+ernment %as armed & trained # funded >sal*a ,udum? to counter na/alites( Sal*a ,udum cadres are terrori3in" innocents ,ust li.e na/alites( Is t%is action of "o+ernment ,ust # le"al $ WAF(in india& TA)A & P0TA is bein" rampantl' misused b' police( E+en *%ere t%ere are no problems of terrorism & TA)A : P0TA is bein" slapped a"ainst innocents & e+en c%ildren( In M(M(Hills of 9arnata.a state & STF personnel c%ar"ed tribal people *it% TA)A on fri+olous c%ar"es of ta.in" lunc% to +eerappan & stic%in" dress for t%e forest bri"and& etc( *%ere as t%e prominent political& film & sports personalities *%o %a+e lin.s *it% under*orld & anti national elements # attended parties %osted b' da*ood Ibra%im & ot%er dons in "ulf countries & else *%ere( 7ut t%ese %i-fi people are not c%ar"ed *it% TA)A : P0TA $ *%' $ WAA( Film actor san,a' dutt %ad contacts *it% under*orld # full' .no*in" *ell t%e criminal ob,ecti+es of criminals & %id t%e dan"erous arms # ammunition in %is %ome & *%ic% *ere intended for terrori3in" public( Ho*e+er mr(dutt is not c%ar"ed *it% TA)A : P0TA instead %e is c%ar"ed *it% ille"al possession of arms act 5 *%ic% is normall' applied to farmers *%o use ille"al %ome made "uns to scare a*a' animals & birds in t%eir farms 6( W%' t%is fa+ourable treatment of mr(dutt b' police $ prosecution $ is t%is because dutt is politicall' mi"%t' # ric% $ WAL( La* is one # same for all & t%e public ser+ants& police interpretes & enforces it differentiall' bet*een ric% # poor $ *%' t%is differentiation $ WAG(recentl' in 7an"alore police nabbed criminals belon"in" to international criminal s'ndicate sellin" duplicate no.ia mobiles( E+er' no.ia mobile comes *it% FE di"it IMEI number & t%is number is also used b' police for trac.in" criminals( In consumer dispute at consumer disputes redressal forum M'sore !) GM:JE & no.ia compan' stated t%at all it-s products come *it% IMEI number onl' # stated t%at t%e product in dispute sold b' tata indicom dealer M:S INT0T0 !0MM=NI!ATI0NS & M'sore are not t%eir-s as it doesn-t %a+e IMEI numbers( Furt%er no.ia stated t%e' don-t %a+e an' business relations%ip *it% eit%er tata indicom or it-s dealer( Ho*e+er t%e tata indicom dealer stated t%at indeed %is products are "enuine & first %and products & but doesn-t %a+e IMEI numbers ( t%is pro+es t%e dealer in collusion *it% tata compan' is sellin" ille"al no.ia mobile %and sets # c%eatin" t%e public( T%ese mobiles are e+adin" ta/es & as *ell as t%ese are *it%out IMEI numbers best bu' for criminal elements *%o *ant to e+ade police trac.in"( W%at police are doin" WAE( W%o & of *%ic% ran. amon" police personnel ta.es t%e decision to close a case ie to file >7? report & *%en after certain time limit no leads are found in in+esti"ation $ WAI( Ho* do 'ou monitor corrupt police personnel & *%o purposefull' fail to in+esti"ate case properl' & so t%at eit%er t%e case can be closed *it% >7? report or t%e prosecution fails to pro+e t%e case in court $ WAD( W%o amon" police ta.es t%e decision to appeal a"ainst t%e +erdict of a lo*er court & *%en t%e prosecution fails $ WAK( W%o too. t%e decision & not to appeal a"ainst t%e ar"entina court order ac4uittin" mr(4uatroc%i accussed in bofors scandal $

WAM( )o 'ou treat all t%e prison con+icts same in t%e prison or does t%e notorious bi" time ric% criminals "et spacious barrac.s *it% t+& ne*s paper & ade4uate food & medical care & etc *%ile small time criminals & poor are crammed into pi" st' li.e rooms *it% IJ-DJ inmates *it%out an' basic re4uirements $ WLJ( W%at is t%e status of m' complaint made to t%e )8 # I8 of police & "o+ernment of 9arnata.a on FJ:FA:AJJG $ t%e copies of complaint *as released at press meet at patra.artara b%a+an M'sore on same da'& e+en copies *ere "i+en to police # intelli"ence personnel $ WLF( W%' no action & repl' re"ardin" t%e complaint till date $ WLA( 0ur constitutional frame *or.ers "a+e le"al immunit' pri+ile"es to certain constitutional functionaries & so t%at t%e' are not burdened *it% fri+olous court cases # can concentrate on t%eir constitutional duties( 7ut t%ese pri+ile"es doesn-t co+er t%e indi+idual actions of t%ose public ser+ants li.e rape & murder & do*r' %arassment & ta/ e+asion & misuse of office & etc( but still la* enforcement : police department is bound to send re4uest to %ome ministr' see.in" permission # %ome ministr' sits o+er files for mont%s( T%is "i+es t%e accussed ample time to destro' e+idences( Is it ri"%t # le"al $ WLL( )oes le"al immunit' pri+ile"es co+er t%eir official actions alone $ if not *%at does it co+er $ WLG( W%at is t%e time limit for %ome ministr' to "i+e sanction for t%e prosecution of tainted constitutional functionaries $ WLE( Ho* man' present MPs & MLAs & M=NI!IAPAL !02P02AT02S & ot%er people-s representati+es are facin" criminal c%ar"es $ WLI( In t%e past & %o* man' MPs & MLAs & corporators *ere facin" criminal c%ar"es & 'ear*ise since FMKD $ %o* man' of t%em *ere e+entuall' con+icted $ WLD( Ho* man' MPs & MLAs & prominent film & sports personalities %a+e %a+e contacts *it% under*orld & forei"n intelli"ence a"encies $ WLK( Ho* man' of t%em %a+e attended fre4uent parties %osted b' under*orld dons in "ulf countries & else *%ere $ WLM( Ho* man' MP & MLA & ot%er people-s representati+es are *anted b' police in +arious cases ( but s%o*n in t%e police records as abscondin" but in realit' are attendin" t%e proceedin"s of t%e %ouse as usual $ WGJ( W%en did smt( Sonia 8and%i became a citi3en of india $ did s%e occup' an' public office before naturali3ation $ WGF( In india & %o* man' MPs & MLAs & ML!s are of forei"n ori"in or %a+e a spouse of forei"n ori"in $ WGA( )oes smt( Sonia 8and%i %a+e citi3ens%ip of an' ot%er countr' $ WGL( )id s%e occup' an' public office *%ile en,o'in" dual citi3ens%ip $ WGG( Ho* do 'ou monitor public ser+ants *%o %a+e spouses of forei"n ori"in # *%ile t%e' are on forei"n tour & from national securit' perspecti+e $ WGE( Is mr( M(S S=77A member of parliament a citi3en of india $ WGI( W%at is t%e status of complaint made b' former union minister mr(subraman'a s*am' alle"in" t%at late P(M ra,i+ "and%i-s famil' recei+ed mone' from forei"n intelli"ence a"encies $ WGD( In man' cases li.e mass riots in+ol+in" certain political parties & *%en t%at culprit part' comes to po*er all t%e cases in+ol+in" it-s part'men are *it%dra*n b' t%e "o+ernment orelse prosecution fails to pro+e it-s case # prefers not to appeal( ust remember 7omba' riot case in+ol+in" s%i+ saini.s # ot%ers & *%en s%i+ sena 1 7 P came to po*er in Ma%aras%tra & all t%e cases a"ainst it-s part'men *ere *it%dra*n( Are t%ese t'pe of decisions b'

"o+ernment ,ust # le"al $ WGK(*%at dama"es %as been done to india-s national securit' due to mole in t%e PM0& as alle"ed b' former union minister mr(nat*ar sin"% $ WGM( W%at action b' t%e "o+ernment $ WEJ( Ho* man' Indians are in t%e custod' of police : militar' in +arious forei"n countries $ WEF( Ho* man' forei"ners are t%ere in Indian prisons $ WEA( Ho* 80I is protectin" t%e %uman ri"%ts of t%ese prisoners $ WEL( Is t%e "o+ernment pa'in" an' compensation to +ictims of police failures & fi/-ups & & *%o suffer in ,ail for 'ears # ac4uitted b' courts upon findin" t%em as not "uilt' $ WEG( )o 'ou re"ister murder c%ar"es : attempt to murder c%ar"es a"ainst "uilt' police officers *%o are responsible for loc.-up deat%s & fa.e encounters # Lrd de"ree torture $ WEE( Ho* man' cases %as been filed since FMKD till date $ WEI( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst "uilt' police officers & STF personnel *%o *ere responsible for "ross %uman ri"%ts +iolations & Lrdde"ree torture & loc.-up deat%s of innocents in forest bri"and +eerappan-s territor' & based on ,ustice A( (Sadas%i+a commission findin"s $ if not *%' $ WED( I & as a citi3en of india as m' >fundamental dut'? %ereb' do offer m' conditional ser+ices to 80I # 809 to appre%end corrupt public ser+ants( Are 'ou read' to utili3e m' ser+ices $ WEK( Police personnel are al*a's in t%e forefront of containin" crimes & mass fur' & riots & etc( t%e' suffer more # e+en t%eir famil' members suffer t%reats from t%e criminal elements( )o t%e "o+ernment pro+ide insurance co+era"e to police # t%eir famil' members on t%e lines of defense forces $ WEM( W%at is t%e amount of co+era"e to a police constable # %is famil' $ WIJ( W%o ma.es t%e premium contributions $ WIF( )o t%e "o+ernment pro+ide o+ertime allo*ance & food allo*ance to police *%o dail' *or. be'ond K %ours of dut' $ WIA( Is t%e "o+ernment "i+in" an' trainin" to police personnel in public interaction & %uman ri"%ts $ WIL( Is it ri"%t to post professionall' trained police to sentr' & orderl' duties of ministers $ WIG( W%at is t%e ratio of police personnel to total population in india since FMKD $ WIE( IS THE 80<E2NMENT 8I<IN8 A)EW=ATE F00)& ME)I!AL !A2E & !L0THIN8 & LI<IN8 SPA!E T0 P2IS0N INMATES & AS 2EW=I2E) 7@ A N02MAL H=MAN EIN8 A!!02)IN8 T0 W(H(0 N02MS $ WII( Is t%e forensic science department *%ic% conducts narcfo-anal'sis & liedetector test & etc under t%e control of police department $ WID( Is it not ri"%t to put it under impartial control of NH2! or li.e bodies $ WIK( Is t%e action of some police officers arran"in" compromise meetin"s # subtl' insistin" t%e poor to to* t%e line of ric% or else face t%e conse4uences & is it ri"%t # le"al $ t%is %appens mostl' in real estate matters( WIM( )id "o+ernment ma.e an' ransom pa'ments to forest bri"and +eerappan durin" %is +arious .idnappin"s $ WDJ( W%at action %as been ta.en based on re+ealations b' .arim tel"i durin" narco anal'sis about public ser+ants in+ol+ement $ WDF( Ho* man' cases of alle"ations a"ainst ,ud"es *ere made in t%e media about misuse of office & criminal acts b' ,ud"es from munsiff court to supreme

court of India $ since FMGD till date WDA( are t%e en4uir' report findin"s& action ta.en reports of suc% cases accessible to public $ if not *%' $ WDL( *%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst "uilt' ,ud"es $ WDG( are t%e "uilt' ,ud"es le"all' prosecuted in all suc% cases $ or %as it ,ust ended *it% t%eir resi"nation from ser+ices or %is superior ,ud"e not allottin" %im an' ,udicial *or. $ WDE( *%' some %i"% ran.in" ,ud"es are not le"all' prosecuted for t%eir *ron" doin"s $ WDI( are ,ud"es abo+e la* $ are not e+er'bod' e4ual before la* $ WDD( do t%e ,udiciar' sub,ect & all t%e cases %andled b' accussed : tainted & "uilt' ,ud"es to re+ie* & to undo past un,ust ,ud"ements $ WDK( %o* $ if not *%' $ WDM( %o* do t%e ,udiciar' monitor t%e net *ealt% "ro*t% of some ,ud"es includin" t%e *ealt% in t%e name of ,ud"e-s famil' members $ WKJ( do all t%e ,ud"es file t%eir annual income & *ealt% statements on s*orn affida+its to t%e %i"%er ,udiciar' $ defaulters %o* man' $ WKF( %o* does t%e ,udiciar' +erifies t%ose statements $ WKA( is suc% statements made public & on *eb $ WKL( *%en t%e ,ud"ement of a lo*er court is turned do*n b' t%e %i"%er court & *%at action is initiated a"ainst lo*er court ,ud"e for ma.in" un,ust ,ud"ement # meatin" out in,ustice $ WKG( *%en alle"ations of corruption & misuse of office & etc a"ainst ,ud"es are made & *%' t%e accussed 1 ,ud"es are not sub,ected to tests li.e >pol' "rap% & lie detector & brain mappin" & etc? & in t%e interest of ,ustice # trut% $ WKE( ,ud"es are not emplo'ees of "o+ernment & so t%e' are ineli"ible to be t%e members of >9arnata.a state "o+ernment ,udicial department %ouse buildin" co-operati+e societ'?( T%en %o* come & man' ,ud"es includin" supreme court ,ud"es are admitted as members of t%is societ' # allotted prime residential site *ort% crores of rupees for a fe* t%ousands b' t%e said societ' at said societ'-s 1 ,udicial la'out & 'ela%an.a & 7an"alore $ *%ile t%e ordinar' members li.e peons & cler.s in ,udicial department are *aitin" for a site since 'ears & is not t%e *%ole t%in" "rossl' ille"al $ WKI( in more t%an DJP of cases before all courts in India & central "o+ernment or state "o+ernment or "o+ernment a"enc' is one of t%e parties( Ho* man' ,ud"es or t%eir famil' members & %a+e recei+ed out of turn & fa+ourable allotments of sites & "as a"enc' & petrol pumps & etc b' t%e "o+ernment $ is not suc% allotments ille"al $ *%at action $ WKD( *%en a person under police custod' or ,udicial custod' suffer Lrd de"ree torture b' police & is not t%e ,ud"e of t%e respecti+e court *%ic% is %andlin" t%at tortured person-s case responsible for it $ WKK( %as t%e %i"%er ,udiciar' le"all' prosecuted respecti+e ,ud"es # t%e police officers for committin" Lrd de"ree torture & on c%ar"es of attempt to murder # murder $ if not *%' $ WKM( re"istrar & M'sore district # sessions court & %as called for t%e candidatures to +arious +acancies in t%at court from t%e public +ide notification no : A)MN:A:FJKAE:AJJL dated FM:FF:AJJL( Please furnis% me t%e merit ran.in" list of selected candidates alon" *it% m' merit ran.in" for t%e post of peon( WMJ( re"istrar & 7an"alore cit' ci+il court & %as called for t%e candidatures to +arious +acancies in t%at court from t%e public +ide notification no : A)M-

I5A6GAA:JL dated FM:JE:AJJL( Please furnis% me merit ran.in" list of selected candidates for t%e post of peon( WMF( *%en a person doesn-t "et ade4uate food & medical care *%ile under police custod' or ,udicial custod' & is not t%e respecti+e ,ud"e dealin" t%at person-s case responsible for it $ *%at action $ WMA( %o* ,udiciar' is monitorin" food # medical care to prisoners $ WML( numerous accussed persons are sufferin" in ,ail under ,udicial custod' & for periods far e/ceedin" t%e le"all' stipulated sentence periods( For e/ample : a pic.-poc.eter is in ,ail for one 'ear & t%e ,ud"e finds %im "uilt' of offence # "i+es %im L mont%s sentence( W%at about t%e e/cess punis%ment of M mont%s( Is not t%e ,ud"e responsible for t%e ille"al & e/cess punis%ment of t%e con+ict $ *%at action a"ainst t%e ,ud"e in suc% cases $ WMG( numerous innocents suffer in ,ail for 'ears # finall' t%e ,ud"e finds t%em as innocents # ac4uits t%em of t%e c%ar"es( W%at about t%e prison sentence & t%e innocent %as alread' ser+ed $ is not t%e ,ud"e responsible for t%is ille"al & un,ust punis%ment to an innocent $ remed' $ *%at action a"ainst t%e ,ud"e $ WME( does t%e pri+ile"es of ,ud"es co+er bot% t%eir official actions # t%e actions arisin" out of misuse of office $ WMI( does t%e pri+ile"es of ,ud"es co+er bot% t%eir official actions as ,ud"es # t%eir personal actions as indi+iduals $ WMD( are t%e fundamental ri"%ts of citi3ens supreme or t%e pri+ile"es of ,ud"es & constitutional functionaries supreme $ WMK( *%at is t%e criteria adopted for promotion of ,ud"es $ WMM( *%at is t%e criteria adopted for appointment of ad+ocates from bar & as t%e ,ud"es $ WFJJ( *%at is t%e criteria adopted for appointment of retired ,ud"es & as "o+ernors of states & members or as c%airman of commissions & etc $ WFJF( %o* man' ,ud"es belon"in" to oppressed classes 1 sc%eduled caste & sc%eduled tribe & ot%er bac.*ard classes & minorities # *omen are t%eir in supreme court & state %i"% courts # subordinate courts $ .indl' pro+ide specific fi"ures ( WFJA( *%at are t%e le"al measures enforced b' ,udiciar' & to enforce t%e accountabilit' of ,ud"es # to c%ec. corruption in ,udiciar' $ WFJL( are not t%ese measures a failure & loo.in" at present state of affairs of ,udiciar' $ WFJG( does t%e ,ud"es arran"e for distribution of alc%o%olic drin.s at t%e official meetin"s & parties & at t%e ta/ pa'er-s e/pense $ WFJE( does an' ,ud"es %a+e included t%eir consumption of alc%o%olic drin.s & in t%eir %otel bill # claimed tra+elin" allo*ance $ WFJI( *%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst 1 selectors ie 9arnata.a %i"% court ,ud"es # ne*l' selected *omen ,ud"es in+ol+ed in roost resort scandal in M'sore & 9arnata.a $ WFJD( *%en common people : ta/ pa'ers # e+en "o+ernment emplo'ees are not "ettin" proper %ealt% care from "o+ernment at "o+ernment %ospitals( Is it ri"%t # ,ust to pro+ide premium %ealt% care to ,ud"es & constitutional functionaries at E-star pri+ate %ospitals in India & abroad & all at ta/ pa'er-s e/pense $ WFJK( are t%e ,ud"es sub,ected to periodical %ealt% c%ec.-ups to ascertain t%eir %ealt% & mental faculties # mental balance in t%e midst of all *or. pressures & emotional tensions $ WFJM( *%at is t%e criteria adopted b' ,udiciar' for acceptin" applications

see.in" public interest liti"ations $ WFFJ( *%' numerous appeals for PIL b' me & *ere not considered $ WFFF( *%at is t%e criteria adopted b' ,udiciar' & for appointin" >amicus curie? in a case $ WFFA( *%' m' appeal to %onourable supreme court & to ma.e me as an >amicus curie? in late P(M 2a,i+ 8and%i-s assassination case & *as not considered b' t%e court $ WFFL( *%at is t%e criteria adopted b' ,udiciar' & for initiatin" suo-motto action $ WFFG( numerous cases of in,ustices are reported in t%e media dail' & *it% supportin" e+idences ( *%' not t%e ,udiciar' ta.e suo-motto action in all suc% cases $ WFFE( le"al aid boards pre-,ud"e t%e cases in t%e name of ta.in" le"al opinion & before pro+idin" le"al aid to t%e need' $ is it not need' person-s ri"%ts +iolation $ WFFI( is not t%e safet' of *itnesses & parties in cases responsibilit' of t%e court & bot% durin" %earin" of t%e case # after*ards $ WFFD( is t%e use of Lrd de"ree torture b' police on prisoners & durin" t%e police custod' : ,udicial custod' : prison sentence ri"%t $ *%at action $ WFFK( *%en t%e corrupt police officer # "o+ernment prosecution ad+ocate to"et%er co+er-up e+idences & conducts improper in+esti"ation intentionall' to fail t%e case 1 to co+er-up ric% croo.s & %i"% # mi"%t' people & *%at action ,ud"e ta.es in suc% cases $ WFFM( %o* does t%e ,udiciar' monitor t%e *ealt% "ro*t% of police & "o+ernment ad+octes & ta/ officials & officials of licensin" aut%orities & to ensure proper # fair prosecution of cases a"ainst ric% # mi"%t' $ WFAJ( *%at are t%e status of appeals made b' %uman ri"%ts acti+ist NA8A2A (M(2( to t%e %onourable supreme court of India $ WFAF( corruption is rampant for selection of officers to 4uasi-,udicial positions li.e district : talu. ma"istrates & ta/ officers & re+enue officers & land ac4uisition officers & etc( %o* t%e ,udiciar' monitors o+er t%eir 4uasi-,udicial actions $ WFAA( sub,ect to conditions & I & NA8A2A (M(2( & editor & e-+oice of %uman ri"%ts *atc% & do offer m' free ser+ices to %onourable supreme court of India & to appre%end corrupt ,ud"es & are 'ou 1 t%e %onourable court read' to utili3e it $ WFAL( *%at are t%e status of m' appeals & sent to t%e %onourable supreme court of India & t%rou"% "o+ernment of india-s on-line "rie+ance s'stem 5 )P8 # )A2P8 6 : )P8:M:AJJI:KJJJK & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JJJED& )A2P8:E:AJJI:JJAAE & )P8:M:AJJI:KJJAF & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JJAEL & )P8:M:AJJI:KJJLA & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JFFGM & )P8:M:AJJI:KJJGD & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JFFIG & )P8:M:AJJI:KJJGL & )P8:M:AJJI:KJJKE & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JIDJG & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JDJFD & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JDJFK & )P8:M:AJJI:KJFEM & )P8:M:AJJI:KJFIA & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JDKIG & )P8:M:AJJI:KJFIE & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JDKDD & )P8:M:AJJI:KJFID & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JKJAK & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JKJAM & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JKJLA & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JKJGL & )A2P8:E:AJJI:JKJGG & )P8:M:AJJI:KJFDG & )P8:M:AJJI:KJFML & )A2P8:E:AJJD:JJJGG & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJJL & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJFJ & )A2P8:E:AJJD:JJFIG & )A2P8:E:AJJD:JJFIE & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJFG & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJAE & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJGM & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJEE &

)P8:M:AJJD:KJJEI & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJDK & )P8:M:AJJD:KJJKA & )A2P8:E:AJJD:JAIFK WFAG( t%e appeals made to t%e %onourable supreme court of India & copies of *%ic% are a+ailable at follo*in" *eb pa"es %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r*:messa"e:FKA & %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r*:messa"e:AJI & %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r*:messa"e:AJK & %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r*:messa"e:AFA & %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r*:messa"e:AJM & %ttp:::"roups('a%oo(com:"roup:na"%r* *%at are t%e status of t%ose appeals $ WFAE( in t%e media & *e %a+e seen reports about ,ud"es committin" crimes 1 rape & attempt to murder & s*indlin" "o+ernment mone' & untouc%abilit' practice & t%e disrespect to national fla" & sale of ,udicial orders & bail & receipt of monetar' "ains b' *a' of ro'alt' for boo.s & prime real estate purc%ase at discounted rate & ta.in" round about lon" forei"n tours alon" *it% famil' in t%e name of official *or. & etc( b' t%is *a' & ,ud"es t%emsel+es are ma.in" contempt of court & constitution of India # citi3ens of India( Ho* 'ou are protectin" t%e %onour of t%e ,udiciar' & constitution of India # citi3ens of India $ please ans*er( WFAI( Is t%e "o+ernment "i+in" an' facilities : affirmati+e actions to policemen-s famil' as bein" "i+en to defense personnel & e/-ser+icemen # t%eir families & li.e preferential site allotment & lp" a"enc' & ration depot & reser+ation in colle"e admission & soft ban. loans & etc $ WFAI( if not & *%' $ after all & t%e contribution of police to national securit' is on par *it% defense forces( WFAD( is not some %i"% police officials addressin" t%eir subordinates in sin"ular term & abusin" t%em *it% +ul"ar *ords *ron" $ WFAK( is not some police personnel callin" public *it% sin"ular term& abusin" public *it% +ul"ar *ords *ron" $ WFAM( is it not t%e dut' of prison aut%orities to protect t%e %ealt%& li+es of prison in-mates $ WFLJ(*%at action is ta.en a"ainst police personnel *%o *ron"l' c%ar"ed an innocent person of criminal acts & resultin" in %is confinement in ,ail & finall' ac4uitted b' court as found to be innocent $ WFLF( is it not ri"%t to *it% %old salar' & "ratuit' & pension to suc% "uilt' police personnel # pa' it as compensation to +ictims of police failures # atrocities $ WFLA( does our Indian constitution le"all' permit a citi3en of forei"n ori"in naturali3ed b' marria"e to an Indian or naturali3ed b' option & to occup' an' constitutional office $ WFLL( durin" britis% rule in india # +arious ot%er britis% colonies & criminal cases *ere foisted a"ainst our freedom fi"%ters in India # ot%er britis% colonies( After india-s independence *%at %appened to t%ose cases $ did our Indian "o+ernment close all suc% cases or did it continue *it% t%e prosecution $ WFLG( in %o* man' cases 80I # ot%er state "o+ernment continued *it% t%e prosecution A8AINST 0=2 F2EE)0M FI8HTE2S $ *%' $ WFLE( *%at about t%e status of cases a"ainst s%ri(neta,i subas% !%andra bose $ WFLI( %as 80I deported an' freedom fi"%ters to 7ritain or it-s colonies & to face prosecution after India "ained independence $ HAS 80I 2E!EI<E) AN@

2EW=EST F20M 72ITAIN T0 THAT EFFE!T $ if 'es & *%' & *%om $ W(FLD( t%e %onourable supreme court of India failed pro+ide information to me as per m' 2TI re4uest appeal no : MF : AJJD in response to 'our letter no : FF : 2TI : A(MF : AJJD dt FL(FA(JD & *%' $ WFLK ( t%e %onourable union %ome secretar' failed to "i+e me information as per m' rti re4uest & %e transferred m' application to ot%ers & in turn t%e' transferred t%e application to some ot%ers( Finall' & complete trut%ful information *as not "i+en & *%' $ as t%e union %ome secretar' %as "ot copies of all t%ose replies in response to transferred 2TI application & *ill %e send me a consolidated repl' to m' present 2TI re4uest $ WFLM( in a %i"% profile case before t%e %onourable del%i %i"% court & *e %a+e seen %o* defense ad+ocate mr( 2(S(ANAN) # prosecution ad+ocate mr( I(=(9HAN made a secret pact to *in t%e case in fa+our of ric% criminal & totall' manipulatin" prosecution *itnesses & e+idences # prosecution stand & totall' ma.in" moc.er' of ,ustice s'stem ( %o* 'ou are ensurin" t%e deli+er' of ,ustice & t%ere bein" numerous suc% ad+ocates in practice $ WFGJ( Smt( Sonia 8and%i is person of forei"n ori"in & s%e *ields enormous clout more t%an t%e Prime Minister %imself o+er t%e "o+ernment of India bein" t%e c%air person of =PA( Is s%e le"all' permitted to summon confidential official records & minutes of t%e cabinet & to %old t%e cabinet meetin" of union ministers $ WFGF( As per la* & is s%e permitted to %old constitutional offices li.e prime minister of India or president of India & etc $ W(FGA( W%at are t%e fundamental ri"%ts of a citi3en "uaranteed under t%e constitution 5Article AF6 $ WFGL( W%at are t%e pri+ile"es conferred on le"islators # parliamentarians b' t%e constitution of India$ a6 Inside t%e House b6 0utside t%e House WFGG( W%at are pri+ile"es conferred on constitutional functionaries& li.e a6 President of India b6 Prime Minister of India c6 !%ief ustice of India d6 !%airman of NH2! e6 !entral <i"ilance !ommissioners( WFGE( Are t%e pri+ile"es le"al immunit' conferred on abo+e mentioned constitutional functionaries $ a6 !o+er all t%eir official actions irrespecti+e of merit( b6 !o+er bot% t%eir official # personal actions( WFGI( Are t%e pri+ile"es defined # codified $ WFGD( Are t%ese pri+ile"es abo+e freedom of t%e press $

WFGK( Are t%e libert' # fundamental ri"%ts of t%e citi3ens "uaranteed b' t%e constitution& abo+e t%e pri+ile"es of t%e constitutional functionaries or e4ual or belo* $ WFGM( !an t%e Indian le"islatures # parliament be e4uated to t%e House of commons in En"land *%ic% is considered to be a superior court and court of records $ WFEJ( !an t%e di+ision of po*ers& namel' t%e le"islature& t%e e/ecuti+e and t%e udiciar'& be e4uated to t%e functionin" of t%e House of commons and House of Lords in En"land $ WFEF( !an a citi3en be said to %a+e committed breac% of pri+ile"e of t%e House or court and causin" contempt of t%e %ouse or court b' raisin" t%e issues of accountabilit' of constitutional functionaries $ WFEA( !an a Le"islature or Parliament enact a ne* la*& to circum+ent or to nullif' t%e udicial orders *it% respect to *ron"doin"s b' peoples representati+es # e/ecuti+e $ does not it amount to infrin"ement of udicial po*ers # contempt of t%e court b' t%e House( WFEL( Are t%e F=N)AMENTAL )=TIES of a citi3en more important t%an constitutional duties of a constitutional functionar' or e4ual in importance to it $ WFEG( !an a constitutional functionar' commit crimes& anti-national acti+ities in t%e name of constitutional duties& be%ind t%e le"al +eil of official-s secret act # "o unaccountable for %is actions and "o unpunis%ed b' %is le"al immunit' pri+ile"es WFEE( Are t%e Le"islators members of parliament& Hi"% court # Supreme court ud"es and ot%er constitutional functionaries not *illin" to codif' t%eir pri+ile"es for t%e reason t%at if codified t%eir pri+ile"es *ould be curtailed and t%eir action *ould be sub,ected to le"al scrutin'( $ WFEI( 7' +otes of citi3ens Le"islators and parliamentarians "et seats in t%e le"islature and Parliament out of ta/ pa'er-s mone'& t%e' "et t%eir pa'& per.s # lead E-Star lu/urious lifest'les( Hence *%et%er a +ote of a citi3en is abo+e 5More +alid6 or a seat of le"islator or parliamentarian is abo+e or more +alid in a democrac' $ WFED( ud"es # !onstitutional functionaries are indirectl' appointed b' +oters : ta/ pa'ers( 0ut of ta/ pa'ers mone'& t%e' "et t%eir pa'& per.s # lead E-star lu/urious lifest'les( Hence& *%et%er t%e +ote of a citi3en& fundamental duties of a ta/ pa'er is abo+e 5more +alid6 or a seat of ,ud"e : constitutional functionar' is abo+e 5more +alid6 in a democrac' $ WFEK( If t%ere is a +acuum in t%e Le"islature or parliament& *%o is to fill up t%at +acuum till suc% time t%at t%e le"islature or parliament acts pro+ide a

solution b' performin" its role b' enactin" proper le"islation to co+er t%e field 5+acuum6 $ WFEM( W%ile it is an un%ealt%' practice for a ud"e to claim to be a ud"e in %is o*n cause& is it not *orse for t%e members of t%e le"islature and parliament to be ,ud"es in t%eir o*n cause $ WFIJ( Are t%e Tec%nicalities of t%e case more important to a ,ud"e or ustice to a citi3en& protection of fundamental ri"%ts of citi3en($ WFIF( W%' not t%e constitutional functionaries initiate suo moto action *it% respect to numerous cases of in,ustices reported in Media $ WFIA( W%' not t%e ud"es admit +arious cases of In,ustices affectin" public& as t%e Public Interest Liti"ation? $ In some cases& t%e Public or t%e person representin" t%em is unable to afford t%e %i"% cost of t%e case( W%' not free le"al aid is "i+en $( WFIL( W%at is t%e criteria for admittin" a P(I(L( # "i+in" free le"al aid $ WFIG( !ommunication 1 free flo* of information is t%e lifeline of a democrac'( W%' t%e constitutional functionaries are not %onourin" t%e 2i"%t to Information of !iti3ens $ WFIE( 2ecentl' & *%ile assumin" office as %onourable c%ief ,ustice of 9arnata.a & ,ustice( P()()INA9A2 & "a+e a blan.et *it%dra*al of all internal departmental en4uiries a"ainst appro/imatel' AJJ ,ud"es & is it ,ust # le"al $ "i+e me t%e names of accused ,ud"es # description of c%ar"es a"ainst t%em $ WFII( does it not s%o* t%at ,ud"es are more e4ual t%an ot%ers $ WFID( *%o are in+ol+ed in PF scam $ *%at action a"ainst "uilt' ,ud"es $ WFIK( W%' 'ou did not "i+e information to me as per 2TI Act inspite of appeal $ refer( FF:2TI:AMF:AJJD( WFIM( Almost a 'ear a"o & in t%e 9arnata.a state ne* c%ief ,ustice of 9arnata.a %i"% court %onble Mr()ina.ar 5no* ele+ated to supreme court of India6 ,ust on assumin" offices *it%in %ours scrapped disciplinar' in4uir' proceedin"s a"ainst AJJO errin" ,ud"es( In suc% a s%ort time no %uman bein" can stud' all t%e cases in detail & t%en %o* come %e arri+ed at t%is +ital decision in suc% s%ort time$ W%o are t%ose AJJO ,ud"es facin" en4uir' $ WFDJ (2ecentl' in t%e 9arnata.a state & %i"% court found out t%at a district ,ud"e *it%out conductin" %earin"s properl' & enterin" fictious dates of %earin"s 5*%ic% %appens to be "o+ernment %olida's 6 facilitated in e/oneratin" a top politician ( %as t%e court en4uired into t%e pre+ious ,ud"ements of t%e accussed ,ud"e $ did it find an' *ron"doin"s$ WFDF( As per la* & *%ile on dut' a person s%ould not be drun. & under t%e influence of alc%o%ol & as it limits t%e functionin" of %is senses # brain( T%at is *%' t%e acts # sa'in"s of drun.ards & committed : said *%en t%e' are drun. are not ta.en seriousl'( Ho*e+er most of t%e police officers after e+enin" %ours are drun. & in t%at state onl' t%e' appre%end man' suspects # produce t%ose suspects at t%e residences of ma"istrates before ma"istrate durin" *ee %ours : ni"%t( Some of of t%e ,ud"es are also drun. durin" t%at time( )oes t%e senses of drun.en police # ,ud"es *or. properl' to do t%eir respecti+e duties

in identif'in" criminals & appre%endin" t%em # to issue ,udicial orders( Are t%ese actions of police # ,ud"es in drun.en state le"al $ W FDA ( W%at action %as been ta.en in b%opal "as lea. case a"ainst t%e "uilt' police officials *%o c%an"ed t%e c%ar"e s%eet a"ainst union carbide officials $ W FDL ( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst "uilt' police officials & district ma"istrate & state ministers # central ministers *%o full' aided t%e criminals 1 =nion !arbide official Mr( Anderson to escape la* & to ,ump bail # flee t%e countr' *it%out court-s permission $ W FDG ( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst t%e abo+e said "uilt' *it% respect to t%eir contempt of court # for aidin" a criminal to escape $ W FDE( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst t%e c%ief ,ustice of India & *%o c%an"ed t%e le"al clause under *%ic% t%e "uilt' s%ould be tried $ *%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst t%e ! I *%o became an official of t%e trust belon"in" to t%e criminal $ W FDI ( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst t%e Indian Public ser+ant *%o decided to *it%dra* cases from =S !ourts *it% respect to 7%opal "as tra"ed' $ W FDD ( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst t%e state labour department # pollution control board officials *%o %a+e failed in t%eir duties & inspite of earlier *arnin"s b' ,ournalists $ W FDK ( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst state cabinet ministers *%o decided t%e 4uantum of compensation mone' to fa+our t%e criminal alt%ou"% t%e' don-t %a+e ri"%t to do so $ W FDM ( W%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst Presidin" ud"e of t%e trial court & !%ief ustice of India & state police officials & public prosecutors # !entral 7ureau of In+esti"ation officials *%o .ept 4uite all alon" and didn-t press for t%e e/tradition of t%e criminal Mr(Anderson & for producin" t%e criminal accussed no(F before t%e trial court $ W FKJ ( Is it not SHAMEF=L for t%e ,udiciar' & police & "o+ernment officials # people-s representati+es *%o became part of 0peration !rime Hus% =p # aided criminals responsible for "%astl' murders of t%ousands # maimin" of la.%s of %apless public in 7%opal 8as Lea. Tra"ed'$ W FKF ( Are t%ese !orrupt Police & corrupt ,ud"es & corrupt ministers & corrupt labour : pollution control board officials H=MAN 7EIN8S $ W FKA W%' police are not re"isterin" m' complaint a"ainst ! I # ot%er <<IPS &E+en after 'ears $ W FKL don-t t%e police of +i,a'ana"ar police station m'sore %a+e le"al ,urisdiction to re"ister t%e case a"ainst t%ese <<IPs $ or ,ust because t%e criminals %appens to be <<IPs &t%e' are not boo.ed b' police$ If t%e said police don-t %a+e le"al ,urisdiction to boo. t%ese <<IPs & t%e' s%ould %a+e transferred t%e complaint to t%ose aut%orities *%o %a+e ,urisdiction #

aut%orit' to boo. # prosecute t%ese <<IPs & but not done so & *%' $ W FKG are not all t%ese actions & of <<IPs # police amountin" to co+er up of crimes # criminals $ are not t%ese co+er ups itself is a crime $ W FKE( E+en an appeal for ,ustice b' post card must be treated as PIL b' courts of ,ustice ( %o*e+er m' appeals for ,ustice concernin" public *elfare & national securit' sent t%rou"% post & e-mail to supreme court of india are not admitted as Public interest liti"ation & *%' $ does not t%ese acts of Supreme court amount to aidin" criminals & anti nationals$ W FKI Are not t%e %onourable c%ief ,ustice of india to"et%er *it% t%e ,urisdictional police # 2e+enue district ma"istrate responsible to protect t%e fundamental # %uman ri"%ts of people $ *%' t%e ! I & M'sore )! # urisdictional Police %a+e failed to protect t%e fundamental # %uman ri"%ts of people includin" mine $ For all t%e pre+ious in,ustices I %a+e suffered at t%e %ands of t%e criminal ne/us Honourable ! I & M'sore re+enue district ma"istrate # ,urisdictional police are to"et%er responsible & if an't%in" unto*ard %appens to me or to m' famil' members or to m' dependents t%e 4uartet 1 Honourable !%ief ustice of India & Honourable )istrict Ma"istrate & M'sore & Honourable Police !ommissioner of M'sore cit' # !ircle Inspector of police & +i,a'ana"ar police station & m'sore *ill be responsible ( T%ese corrupt parasites *ill feel & understand t%e pain onl' *%en t%e' also suffer in t%e same manner( Let us pra' to almi"%t' 1 In *%ose !ourt of ,ustice MAT!H FITIN8 is not t%ere # e+er' bod' is e4ual & let us pra' to t%at "od to "i+e t%ese corrupt parasites "%astl' deat%s not%in" less not%in" more(

@EA2 T0 WHI!H A70<E PE2TAINS : MA 02IT@ 0F )0!=MENTS PE2TAINS T0 @EA2 FMMF-AJFA ( S0ME 0F THE )0!=MENTS A2E )ATE) 7A!9 T0 FMGD(

P=7LI! INF02MATI0N 0FFI!E2s *%o failed to pro+ide information and s%ieldin" criminals & anti nationals : F( PI0 & 0:0 Honorable !%ief ustice of India & Supreme !ourt of India & Ne* )el%i( A( PI0 & 0:0 H(E(Honorable President of India & 2as%trapat%i 7%a*an & Ne* )el%i( L( PI0 0:0 Honorable Spea.er of Lo. Sab%a & 80I & Ne* )el%i( G( PI0 0:0 )' !%airman of 2a,'a Sab%a & 80I & Ne* )el%i( E( PI0 & 0:0 =nion Home Minister &80I & Ne* )el%i( I( PI0 & 0:0 H(E(Honorable 8o+ernor of 9arnata.a & 2a, 7%a*an & 7an"alore(

D( PI0 & 0:0 Honorable !%ief Minister of 9arnata.a & !M0 & 7an"alore( K( PI0 & 0:0 )8 # I8 of Police & 8o+ernment of 9arnata.a &Police HW & 7an"alore(

Fees Paid : F( A( L( G( E( I( D( K( IP0 JKF GAMLJI for rupees ten onl'( IP0 JKF GAMLJD for rupees ten onl'( IP0 JKF GAMLJK for rupees ten onl'( IP0 JKF GAMLJM for rupees ten onl'( IP0 JKF GAMLFJ for rupees ten onl'( IP0 JKF GLJDJF for rupees ten onl' (

IP0 JKF GLJDJA for rupees ten onl' ( IP0 JKF GLJDJL for rupees ten onl'(

Enclosed : F( A( L( Police !omplaint dated AJ(JK(AJFA S%o* !ause Notice )ated AJ(JK(AJFA A7!) Lesson of )emocrac'(

)ATE : JA(FJ(AJFA UUUUU((UUUUUUUUUNA8A2A A(M(2(

PLA!E : M@S02E & IN)IAU(( UUUUUUUUU(5 APPLI!ANT6

Sa+e Hebbal La.e Sa+e 7EML Wuarters La.e in M'sore

- !rimes of M'sore )eput' !ommissioner # !ommissioner M'sore =rban )e+elopment Aut%orit' 1 An Appeal to Honourable Supreme !ourt of India

In t%e past & M'sore Ma%ara,a # ot%er p%ilant%ropists %a+e donated t%eir personal lands & properties & built man' la.es # ponds in m'sore & ban"alore and ot%er places *it% public concern & public *ellbein" in t%eir mind ( T%e' built t%ese la.es # ponds in addition to preser+in" t%e natural la.es # ponds( T%e' .ne* about t%e importance of ecolo"ical balance # en+ironment( T%e present rulers & IAS # 9AS babus %a+e e+en failed to preser+e t%e la.es # ponds built decades a"o & let alone build one( T%ese Public ser+ants %a+e e/tended t%eir tacit support to buildin" mafia & to .ill t%ese la.es # ponds & to fill t%ose la.es *it% industrial effluents & se*a"e # buildin" mud *astes( After .illin" t%ose la.es # ponds & t%e buildin" mafia encroac%es on it # usurps t%at public propert' in turn sellin" it for crores of rupees(

In t%is *a' & Hoota"alli la.e *as .illed # encroac%ed b' 9a'nes Hotel 5 no* silent s%ores %otel6 & Hebbal La.e is bein" .illed # encroac%ed from all sides b' industries and t%e la.e infront of 7EML Wuarters is bein" .illed # land demarcation for sellin" t%ose land %as alread' be"un(

T%e public ser+ants *ere totall' indifferent to*ards public outcr' a"ainst t%is ( T%e IAS # 9AS babus *%o are also ma"istrates *it% ,udicial aut%orit' %a+e failed in preser+in" t%ese la.es # ponds inspite of appeals to t%em( T%ese deat% of la.es resultin" in t%eir encroac%ments could %a+e been pre+ented earlier b' )! & Ta%sildar & M=)A !ommissioner # 9IA)7 0fficers( E+en I %a+e appealed to t%em t%rou"% m' *eb ne*s paper & t%e' didn-t ta.e action at all( I %a+e made 2TI re4uest to t%ose aut%orities to "i+e me information re"ardin" status of t%ose la.es 'ears a"o & fearin" trut% *ill come out t%e' didn-t an*er m' 4uestions in full & t%e' onl' "a+e %alf trut%s( W%en I persisited *it% m' 2TI re4uest t%e M'sore )istrict Ma"istrate at t%at time Mr( P(Mani+annan repeatedl' called me o+er p%one & abused me # t%reatened me ( E+en t%reats *ere made b' some policemen in mufti ( Finall' t%at la.e land *as allotted to an industriall' supposed to be close to Industries minister at t%at time( T%e courts are dispassionate # in%uman & *%ile passin" e+iction orders a"ainst poor people & t%e police are full of "uts # s%o* t%eir full bra+er' & +alour a"ainst t%ese poor land encroac%ers( Fine & let us appreciate t%eir dut' consciousness ( Ho*e+er ric% # *ell connected criminals %a+e ille"all' encroac%ed upon public lands & t%e same courts and police are not ta.in" appropriate action inspite of repeated appeals & *%' $ E+en t%e Supreme !ourt of India # Police are Wea. # Mea. before Land Mafia( )on-t t%e same ud"es # Police %a+e 8uts & 7ra+er' & )ut' !onciousness # Inte"rit' to ta.e action a"ainst suc% ric% land "rabbers $ T%e ans*er lies in t%e follo*in" articles( 0nce a"ain *e offer our conditional ser+ices to

Supreme !ourt of India & to le"all' appre%end criminals *%ile t%e respecti+e public ser+ants %a+e failed to do t%e same(

Hereb' & *e re4uest t%e %onourable Supreme !ourt of India & F( To initiate criminal prosecution a"ainst M'sore district ma"istrate & M'sore talu. ma"istrate & M=)A !ommissioner & urisdictional Police 0fficers # 9IA)7 0fficer & for ma.in" contempt of Supreme !ourt of India 0rder appl'in" t%rou"%t india to preser+e la.es # ponds( A( To e+ict all encroac%ers fort% *it% (

L( To immediatel' stop all flo* of industrial effluents # se*a"e to t%ese la.es # ponds( G( To initiate criminal prosecution a"ainst encroac%ers of t%ese la.es # pollters & .illers of t%ese la.es( E( To preser+e t%e said la.es # ponds & b' reco+erin" cost from encroac%ers & pollutin" industries and t%e co-conspirators M'sore )! & M'sore Ta%sildar & M=)A !ommissioner & 9IA)7 0fficer # urisdictional Police 0fficers( I( To protect me & m' famil' members # dependents from land mafia # coconspirators of t%e crime( D( To order & to issue Writ of Mandamus to M'sore )istrict Ma"istrate & M=)A !ommissioner # 9IA)7 0fficer to disclose all t%e information sou"%t b' me in m' 2TI re4uest publicl'( T%e cop' of m' 2TI re4uest is reproduced belo*(

)ate : FD(FF(AJFA Place : M'sore

@our-s Sincerel'& Na"ara,a(M(2(

2TI W=ESTI0NS !0MMISSI0NE2 0F M=)A 5 M@S02E =27AN )E<EL0PMENT A=TH02IT@ 6 # !0MMISSI0NE2 0F M!! 5 M@S02E !IT@ !02P02ATI0N 6 A2E AF2AI) T0 ANSWE2 F( %o* man' times since FMKD & M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT %as re+ised : modified t%e m'sore cit';s compre%ensi+e cit' de+elopment plan $ A( %o* man' cases of !)P +iolations *ere re"istered b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT since FMKD till date $

L( %o* man' cases of !)P +iolations *ere le"ali3ed in t%e !)P re+ision : modification b' t%e aut%orities $ G( *%en an application for alienation of land is made to 'ou & sa' from ci+ic amenit' site to commercial & *%at norms are follo*ed b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT $ E( %o* do 'ou pro+ide alternate ci+ic amenit' site in t%e localit' & if t%e area is alread' full $ do 'ou depri+e people of ci+ic amenities $ I( durin" suc% alenation & is t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT collectin" mar.et rate difference bet*een ci+ic amenit' site # commercial site $ if not *%' $ D( in m'sore cit' & man' buildin" comple/es & buildin"s %a+e been built full' +iolatin" buildin" b'e-la*s 1 no set off & no par.in" space & no emer"enc' fire e/it & no eart%4ua.e tolerant ( *%at action b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT $ K( %o* man' cases of buildin" b'e-la*s +iolations %as been re"istered b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT since FMKD $ *%at is t%e action status report 'ear*ise $ M( %o* muc% of M=)A;s : M!!;s : 80<E2NMENT;s lands & sites & buildin"s # %ouses %a+e been ille"all' occupied b' criminal tresspassers since FMKD $ FJ( %as t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT re"istered criminal cases a"ainst eac% suc% ille"al occupation $ if not *%' $ pro+ide status report 'ear*ise $ FF( in %o* man' cases of suc% ille"al occupation M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT %as le"ali3ed & re"ulari3ed suc% ille"al occupation ,ust t%rou"% M=)A;s : M!!;s resolution instead of of reallottin" t%e same t%rou"% public notification to t%e ne/t senior most in t%e *aitin" list & after "i+in" notice of allotment cancellation to ori"inal allottee $ if not done so *%' $ FA( %as t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT follo*ed all le"al norms in reallotment of lands & sites & %ouses & etc to t%e ille"al occupiers $ *%at is t%e procedure follo*ed $ FL( in m'sore cit' & numerous %ousin" societies # real estate )e+elopers %a+e mus%roomed & Land allotments of %o* man' %ousin" societies & real estate firms amon" t%em are le"all' aut%ori3ed b' M=)A & M!! & 80<E2NMENT # %o* man' not $ since FMKD till date $ FG( %as t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT filed criminal complaints a"ainst suc% ille"al %ousin" societies # ille"al real estate firms $ if not *%' $ FE( *%at action M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT %as initiated a"ainst real estate firms # %ousin" societies *%o %a+e +iolated M=)A norms & la'out plans & etc $ if not *%' $ FI( t%e "o+ernment %as framed buildin" b'e-la*s li.e *idt% of road & space for ci+ic amenities & par.in" space & emer"enc' fire e/it & etc .eepin" %i"% in t%e

mind safet' of people first( M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT is in t%e practice of le+'in" a pittance as penalt' on t%e buildin" b'ela* +iolators & la'out )e+elopment plan +iolators # le"ali3in" t%ose +iolations( Safet' of public # amenities of public are totall' ne"lected b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT ( W%en public people die & suffer in,uries : accidents 1 sa' durin" a fire tra"ed' in a comple/ due to lac. of fire e/it & *%en people par. +e%icles on pa+ement in front of a business comple/ as t%e comple/ doesn;t %a+e a par.in" space of it;s o*n & t%e pedestrians "oin" t%at *a' are forced to come do*n on road resultin" in accidents & in,uries # deat%s ( is not t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT responsible for t%ose accidents & in,uries # deat%s $ FD( *%at is t%e criteria adopted b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT for out of Turn allotment of Lands & sites & %ouses to reno*ned sports persons & ,ud"es & ,ournalists & politicians & artists & etc $ FK( %o* man' ,ud"es & artists & politicians & ,ournalists & sports persons & etc %a+e benefited from t%ese out of turn allotments b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT $ specific fi"ures 'ear*ise since FMKD $ FM( *%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst de+elopers & %ousin" societies & *%o %a+e +iolated M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT norms $ AJ( *%en poor sc%eduled caste & sc%eduled tribe people & minorit' people ille"all' li+e 0n M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT sites buildin" temporar' %uts & M=)A : A=TH02ITIES *it% t%e %elp of police ra3es do*n t%ose %uts # e+icts t%e poor b' brute force( W%ereas & *%en cronies of political bi"*i"s ille"all' occup' M=)A & M!! : 80<E2NMENT lands *ort% crores of rupees # build bi" comple/es earnin" t%ousands of rupees mont%l' rent & M=)A or aut%orities not e+en files police complaint a"ainst t%em instead re"ulari3es t%e ille"al occupation b' le+'in" a pittance as fine( W%' t%is double standard b' M=)A : M!! 80<E2NMENT $ AF( H0W MAN@ !ASES 0F ILLE8AL 0!!=PATI0NS are re"ulari3ed b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT since FMKD till date $ 'ear*ise fi"ures $ AA( %o* muc% of M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT lands & sites & %ouses are under ille"al occupation $ status report 'ear*ise since FMKD $ AL( %o* muc% of t%ose %as been reco+ered $ %as t%e M=)A &A=TH02ITIES reco+ered t%e rents earned b' ille"al occupation $ AG( %a+e 'ou filed police complaints a"ainst t%ose criminals 1 tresspassers $ if not *%' $ AE( is t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT "i+in" *ide publicit' # sufficient time to bidders about it;s auction sc%edules $ AI( is t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT "i+in" mar.et +alue to land loosers $ AD( is t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT e/actl' usin" t%e ac4uired lands & for

t%e same purpose mentioned in t%e pro,ect plan $ AK( is t%e M=)A : A=TH02ITIES ac4uirin" lands at lo*er rates from farmers # sellin" it at a premium & b' *a' ma.in" profits ,ust li.e a real estate a"enc' $ AM( in +illa"es & t%ere are cattle "ra3in" "rounds meant for t%e usa"e of *%ole +illa"ers& forest for t%e usa"e of *%ole +illa"e & lands belon"in" to +illa"e temples( Some +illa"ers %a+e donated t%eir personal lands to +illa"e temples & cattle "ra3in" for t%e benefit of *%ole +illa"ers( All t%e +illa"ers are sta.e %olders & o*ners of suc% lands( W%en M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT ac4uires suc% lands to *%om does it pa' compensation $ *%at about *elfare ob,ecti+es of t%ose lands $ LJ( till date & %o* man' la.es & ponds & %o* man' feeder canals %a+e been closed & filled *it% mud & de+eloped & sold as sites & etc b' M=)A M!! or ot%er land de+elopers $ LF( %as t%e M=)A & M!! ta.en alternate steps to create ne* la.es & ponds $ %o* man' are created till date $ LA( in # around m'sore cit' & %i"% tension electric lines are t%ere in bus' residential areas ( as per Indian electricit' act & no permanent structures s%ould be under t%e HT lines( Ho*e+er t%ere are buildin"s under it( In some places & HT lines runs in t%e middle of t%e road( T%e aut%orities Ha+e de+eloped t%ose areas beneat% HT lines as par.s & rented out ad+ertisement spaces # built permanent fencin" of t%ose areas spendin" la.%s of ta/pa'er;s mone'( T%is fencin" obstructs t%e mo+ement of ser+ice personnel of electricit' board & to ser+ice HT line( Are all t%ese structures under # surroundin" HT lines le"al $ LL( till date %o* man' burial "rounds are ac4uired # sold as sites b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT or ot%er de+elopers $ specific fi"ures 'ear*ise since FMKD caste*ise & reli"ion*ise $ LG( in # around m'sore cit' & in %o* man' areas de+eloped b' M=)A # pri+ate de+elopers & t%e se*a"e *ater "enerated in t%ose areas is directl' let into la.e & ponds $ LE( %o* man' tributaries & la.es & ponds are .illed in t%is fas%ion b' M=)A & M!! # ot%er de+elopers & %ousin" societies $ LI( %o* man' business comple/es & flats & residential la'outs de+eloped b' pri+ate real estate de+elopers & %ousin" societies are dumpin" t%e se*a"e & : *aste "enerated in t%eir buildin"s & into unaut%ori3ed dumpin" "rounds & la.es & etc ( t%us disturbin" t%e en+ironment # creatin" public %ealt% %a3ard $ %o* t%e M=)A : M!! is monitorin" se*a"e : *aste disposal $ status report 'ear*ise since FMKD till date ( LD( %o* man' unaut%ori3ed %ousin" la'outs are t%ere in # around m'sore cit' $ *%at action b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT a"ainst t%em $ action ta.en

report 'ear*ise since FMKD till date ( LK( around m'sore cit' & +ast areas of +illa"e farm lands & a"ricultural lands are ac4uired b' pri+ate real estate de+elopers for non a"ricultural purposes b' a sin"le firm or sin"le o*ner( Are t%ese actions le"al $ some of t%ese real estate a"ents %a+e sold t%ose lands to pri+ate industries & multinational companies for crores of rupees( Has t%e M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT "i+en alienation of land ie con+ersion from a"ricultural to industrial usa"e( Has 9IA)7 "i+en consent to it $ LM( can a sin"le indi+idual : firm can purc%ase suc% +ast tracts of a"ricultural lands & is it le"al $ is it *it%in t%e 9IA)7;s compre%ensi+e industrial area de+elopment plan $ GJ( %as t%e M=)A : M!! & 9IA)7 "i+en *ide publicit' & public notice callin" for ob,ections before alienation of suc% lands $ GF( are all t%ose alienations & strictl' in conformance to M=)A;s : M!!;s !)P # 9IA)7;s industrial area de+elopment plan $ +iolations %o* man' $ GA( is t%e M=)A # 9IA)7 re+isin" : modif'in" !)P # IN)=ST2IAL A2EA )E<EL0PMENT PLAN & to suit t%ose real estate de+elopers # Pri+ate companies $ on *%at le"al "rounds $ GL(*%at action %as been ta.en based on m'sore district ma"istrate mr(T(M(<i,a'a 7%as.ar;s report on land "rabbin"s in m'sore $ GG(in m'sore cit' & %ebbal-%oota"alli industrial area & a la.e %as been destro'ed *%ile buildin" .a'nes %otel & %in.al la.e is s%rin.in" & la.e in front of 7EML Wuarters %as been alloted to M:S TH2ILLE2 !L0THIN8 !0& are all t%ese actions le"al # in conformance to M=)A;s !)P $ if not *%' $ *%at action $ GE( *%ile auctionin" off t%e lands of sic. industrial unit M:S I)EAL AWA LT) & *as t%ere an' pre-4ualification to bidders t%at after purc%ase of lands onl' it must be used for industrial use or onl' industries can participate in t%e biddin" process $ GI(*%' not it %as been clearl' mentioned in t%e tender document t%at & said land is open for alienation $ GD( about t%is issue & our publication %as e+en raised it;s ob,ections & in it;s ne*spaper ( no action & *%' $ as a result & t%e "o+ernment & ban.s & emplo'ees *ere c%eated off t%eir dues # t%e pri+ate firm made %u"e profits( is t%is auction # alienation le"al $ GK(numerous N80;s & trusts promoted b' reli"ious bodies & mutts are allotted prime lands at preferrential rates & for t%e reason t%at t%e' *ill use it for public : social *elfare( %o*e+er man' of t%e trusts are usin" t%e *%ole or part

of t%e land for commercial purposes ot%er t%an t%e stated public : social *elfare purpose( *%at action %as been ta.en b' M=)A & M!! or "o+ernment in suc% cases $ GM(%o* man' trusts %a+e +iolated "o+ernment norms in t%is *a' since FMKD till date$ *%at action ta.en b' M=)A & M!! # "o+ernment action ta.en report 'ear*ise since FMKD till date $ EJ(%o* man' suc% ille"alities : +iolations b' trusts are re"ulari3ed b' M=)A & M!! or aut%orities & on *%at le"al "rounds $ AT2 since FMKD till date $ EF(before re"ulari3in" suc% +iolations %a+e 'ou sou"%t public ob,ections # "i+en media publicit' $ if not *%' $ EA(%o* 'ou are monitorin" t%e net *ealt% "ro*t% of some M=)A : M!! : 2E<EN=E officials # t%eir famil' members & *%o %a+e land ac4uisition : denotif'in" & land usa"e con+ersion aut%orities $ EL(%o* man' trusts & N80s are allotted prime residential : commercial lands b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT on lease basis & in turn t%e said trusts & N80s %a+e sulet it eit%er partl' or *%oll' to ot%ers $ EG(%o* man' suc% lease allotments are sold b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT before t%e e/pir' of lease period & *it%out public auction $ EE( *%at are t%e norms follo*ed b' M=)A : M!! : 80<E2NMENT for t%e sale of leased lands to t%e lessee before t%e e/pir' of lease period $

2TI 1 W=ESTI0NS !0MMISSI0NE2 0F 7AN8AL02E )E<EL0PMENT A=TH02IT@ 5 7)A 6 & !0MMISSI0NE2 & 72IHATH 7AN8AL02E MAHANA8A2A PALI9E 5 77MP 6 # !HAI2MAN & 9A2NATA9A IN)=ST2IAL A2EA )E<EL0PMENT 70A2) 5 9IA)76 A2E AF2AI) T0 ANSWE2

F( %o* man' times since FMKD & 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT %as re+ised : modified t%e 7an"alore cit';s compre%ensi+e cit' de+elopment plan $ A( %o* man' cases of !)P +iolations *ere re"istered b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT since FMKD till date $ L( %o* man' cases of !)P +iolations *ere le"ali3ed in t%e !)P re+ision : modification b' t%e aut%orities $ G( *%en an application for alienation of land is made to 'ou & sa' from ci+ic amenit' site to commercial & *%at norms are follo*ed b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT$

E( %o* do 'ou pro+ide alternate ci+ic amenit' site in t%e localit' & if t%e area is alread' full $ do 'ou depri+e people of ci+ic amenities $ I( durin" suc% alenation & is t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT collectin" mar.et rate difference bet*een ci+ic amenit' site # commercial site $ if not *%' $ D( in ban"alore cit' & man' buildin" comple/es & buildin"s %a+e been built full' +iolatin" buildin" b'e-la*s 1 no set off & no par.in" space & no emer"enc' fire e/it & no eart%4ua.e tolerant ( *%at action b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT$ K( %o* man' cases of buildin" b'e-la*s +iolations %as been re"istered b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT since FMKD $ *%at is t%e action status report 'ear*ise $ M( %o* muc% of 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT lands & sites & buildin"s # %ouses %a+e been ille"all' occupied b' criminal tresspassers since FMKD $ FJ( %as t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT re"istered criminal cases a"ainst eac% suc% ille"al occupation $ if not *%' $ pro+ide status report 'ear*ise $ FF( in %o* man' cases of suc% ille"al occupation 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT %as le"ali3ed & re"ulari3ed suc% ille"al occupation ,ust t%rou"% 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT Y s resolution instead of of re-allottin" t%e same t%rou"% public notification to t%e ne/t senior most in t%e *aitin" list & after "i+in" notice of allotment cancellation to ori"inal allottee $ if not done so *%' $ FA( %as t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT follo*ed all le"al norms in reallotment of lands & sites & %ouses & etc to t%e ille"al occupiers $ *%at is t%e procedure follo*ed $ FL( in ban"alore cit' & numerous %ousin" societies # real estate )e+elopers %a+e mus%roomed & Land allotments of %o* man' %ousin" societies & real estate firms amon" t%em are le"all' aut%ori3ed b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT # %o* man' not $ since FMKD till date $ FG( %as t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT filed criminal complaints a"ainst suc% ille"al %ousin" societies # ille"al real estate firms $ if not *%' $ FE( *%at action 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT %as initiated a"ainst real estate firms # %ousin" societies *%o %a+e +iolated 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT norms & la'out plans & etc $ if not *%' $ FI( t%e "o+ernment %as framed buildin" b'e-la*s li.e *idt% of road & space for ci+ic amenities & par.in" space & emer"enc' fire e/it & etc .eepin" %i"% in t%e mind safet' of people first( 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT is in t%e practice of le+'in" a pittance as penalt' on t%e buildin" b'ela* +iolators &

la'out )e+elopment plan +iolators # le"ali3in" t%ose +iolations( Safet' of public # amenities of public are totall' ne"lected b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT( W%en public people die & suffer in,uries : accidents 1 sa' durin" a fire tra"ed' in a comple/ due to lac. of fire e/it & *%en people par. +e%icles on pa+ement in front of a business comple/ as t%e comple/ doesn;t %a+e a par.in" space of it;s o*n & t%e pedestrians "oin" t%at *a' are forced to come do*n on road resultin" in accidents & in,uries # deat%s ( is not t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT responsible for t%ose accidents & in,uries # deat%s $ FD( *%at is t%e criteria adopted b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT for out of Turn allotment of Lands & sites & %ouses to reno*ned sports persons & ,ud"es & ,ournalists & politicians & artists & etc $ FK( %o* man' ,ud"es & artists & politicians & ,ournalists & sports persons & etc %a+e benefited from t%ese out of turn allotments b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT$ specific fi"ures 'ear*ise since FMKD $ FM( *%at action %as been ta.en a"ainst de+elopers & %ousin" societies & *%o %a+e +iolated 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT norms $ AJ( *%en poor sc%eduled caste & sc%eduled tribe people & minorit' people ille"all' li+e 0n 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT sites buildin" temporar' %uts & 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT *it% t%e %elp of police ra3es do*n t%ose %uts # e+icts t%e poor b' brute force( W%ereas & *%en cronies of political bi"*i"s ille"all' occup' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT lands *ort% crores of rupees # build bi" comple/es earnin" t%ousands of rupees mont%l' rent & 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT or aut%orities not e+en files police complaint a"ainst t%em instead re"ulari3es t%e ille"al occupation b' le+'in" a pittance as fine( W%' t%is double standard b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT$ AF( H0W MAN@ !ASES 0F ILLE8AL 0!!=PATI0NS are re"ulari3ed b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT since FMKD till date $ 'ear*ise fi"ures $ AA( %o* muc% of 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT lands & sites & %ouses are under ille"al occupation $ status report 'ear*ise since FMKD $ AL( %o* muc% of t%ose %as been reco+ered $ %as t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT areco+ered t%e rents earned b' ille"al occupation $ AG( %a+e 'ou filed police complaints a"ainst t%ose criminals 1 tresspassers $ if not *%' $ AE( is t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT "i+in" *ide publicit' # sufficient time to bidders about it;s auction sc%edules $ AI( is t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT "i+in" mar.et +alue to land loosers $

AD( is t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT e/actl' usin" t%e ac4uired lands & for t%e same purpose mentioned in t%e pro,ect plan $ AK( is t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT ac4uirin" lands at lo*er rates from farmers # sellin" it at a premium & b' *a' ma.in" profits ,ust li.e a real estate a"enc' $ AM( in +illa"es & t%ere are cattle "ra3in" "rounds meant for t%e usa"e of *%ole +illa"ers& forest for t%e usa"e of *%ole +illa"e & lands belon"in" to +illa"e temples( Some +illa"ers %a+e donated t%eir personal lands to +illa"e temples & cattle "ra3in" for t%e benefit of *%ole +illa"ers( All t%e +illa"ers are sta.e %olders & o*ners of suc% lands( W%en 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT ac4uires suc% lands to *%om does it pa' compensation $ *%at about *elfare ob,ecti+es of t%ose lands $ LJ( till date & %o* man' la.es & ponds & %o* man' feeder canals %a+e been closed & filled *it% mud & de+eloped & sold as sites & etc b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT or ot%er land de+elopers $ LF( %as t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT ta.en alternate steps to create ne* la.es & ponds $ %o* man' are created till date $ LA( in # around ban"alore cit' & %i"% tension electric lines are t%ere in bus' residential areas ( as per Indian electricit' act & no permanent structures s%ould be under t%e HT lines( Ho*e+er t%ere are buildin"s under it( In some places & HT lines runs in t%e middle of t%e road( T%e aut%orities Ha+e de+eloped t%ose areas beneat% HT lines as par.s & rented out ad+ertisement spaces # built permanent fencin" of t%ose areas spendin" la.%s of ta/pa'er;s mone'( T%is fencin" obstructs t%e mo+ement of ser+ice personnel of electricit' board & to ser+ice HT line( Are all t%ese structures under # surroundin" HT lines le"al $ LL( till date %o* man' burial "rounds are ac4uired # sold as sites b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT or ot%er de+elopers $ specific fi"ures 'ear*ise since FMKD caste*ise & reli"ion*ise $ LG( in # around ban"alore cit' & in %o* man' areas de+eloped b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT # pri+ate de+elopers & t%e se*a"e *ater "enerated in t%ose areas is directl' let into la.e & ponds $ LE( %o* man' tributaries & la.es & ponds are .illed in t%is fas%ion b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT # ot%er de+elopers & %ousin" societies $ LI( %o* man' business comple/es & flats & residential la'outs de+eloped b' pri+ate real estate de+elopers & %ousin" societies are dumpin" t%e se*a"e & : *aste "enerated in t%eir buildin"s & into unaut%ori3ed dumpin" "rounds & la.es & etc ( t%us disturbin" t%e en+ironment # creatin" public %ealt% %a3ard $ %o* t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT is monitorin" se*a"e : *aste disposal $ status report 'ear*ise since FMKD till date (

LD( %o* man' unaut%ori3ed %ousin" la'outs are t%ere in # around ban"alore cit' $ *%at action b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT a"ainst t%em $ action ta.en report 'ear*ise since FMKD till date ( LK( around ban"alore cit' & +ast areas of +illa"e farm lands & a"ricultural lands are ac4uired b' pri+ate real estate de+elopers for non a"ricultural purposes b' a sin"le firm or sin"le o*ner( Are t%ese actions le"al $ some of t%ese real estate a"ents %a+e sold t%ose lands to pri+ate industries & multinational companies for crores of rupees( Has t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT "i+en alienation of land ie con+ersion from a"ricultural to industrial usa"e( Has 9IA)7 "i+en consent to it $ LM( can a sin"le indi+idual : firm can purc%ase suc% +ast tracts of a"ricultural lands & is it le"al $ is it *it%in t%e 9IA)7;s compre%ensi+e industrial area de+elopment plan $ GJ( %as t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT "i+en *ide publicit' & public notice callin" for ob,ections before alienation of suc% lands $ GF( are all t%ose alienations & strictl' in conformance to 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT;s industrial area de+elopment plan $ +iolations %o* man' $ GA( is t%e 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT re+isin" : modif'in" !)P # IN)=ST2IAL A2EA )E<EL0PMENT PLAN & to suit t%ose real estate de+elopers # Pri+ate companies $ on *%at le"al "rounds $ GL(*%at action %as been ta.en based on m'sore district ma"istrate mr(T(M(<i,a'a 7%as.ar;s report on land "rabbin"s in m'sore $ GG(in m'sore cit' & %ebbal-%oota"alli industrial area & a la.e %as been destro'ed *%ile buildin" .a'nes %otel & %in.al la.e is s%rin.in" & la.e in front of 7EML Wuarters %as been alloted to M:S TH2ILLE2 !L0THIN8 !0& are all t%ese actions le"al # in conformance to M=)A;s !)P $ if not *%' $ *%at action $ GE( *%ile auctionin" off t%e lands of sic. industrial unit M:S I)EAL AWA LT) & *as t%ere an' pre-4ualification to bidders t%at after purc%ase of lands onl' it must be used for industrial use or onl' industries can participate in t%e biddin" process $ GI(*%' not it %as been clearl' mentioned in t%e tender document t%at & said land is open for alienation $ GD( about t%is issue & our publication %as e+en raised it;s ob,ections & in it;s ne*spaper ( no action & *%' $ as a result & t%e "o+ernment & ban.s & emplo'ees *ere c%eated off t%eir dues # t%e pri+ate firm made %u"e profits( is t%is auction # alienation le"al $ GK(numerous N80;s & trusts promoted b' reli"ious bodies & mutts are allotted

prime lands at preferrential rates & for t%e reason t%at t%e' *ill use it for public : social *elfare( %o*e+er man' of t%e trusts are usin" t%e *%ole or part of t%e land for commercial purposes ot%er t%an t%e stated public : social *elfare purpose( *%at action %as been ta.en b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT in suc% cases $ GM(%o* man' trusts %a+e +iolated "o+ernment norms in t%is *a' since FMKD till date$ *%at action ta.en b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT action ta.en report 'ear*ise since FMKD till date $ EJ(%o* man' suc% ille"alities : +iolations b' trusts are re"ulari3ed b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT& on *%at le"al "rounds $ AT2 since FMKD till date $ EF(before re"ulari3in" suc% +iolations %a+e 'ou sou"%t public ob,ections # "i+en media publicit' $ if not *%' $ EA(%o* 'ou are monitorin" t%e net *ealt% "ro*t% of some 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT officials # t%eir famil' members & *%o %a+e land ac4uisition : denotif'in" & land usa"e con+ersion aut%orities $ EL(%o* man' trusts & N80s are allotted prime residential : commercial lands b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT on lease basis & in turn t%e said trusts & N80s %a+e sulet it eit%er partl' or *%oll' to ot%ers $ EG(%o* man' suc% lease allotments are sold b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT before t%e e/pir' of lease period & *it%out public auction $ EE( *%at are t%e norms follo*ed b' 7)A : 77MNP : 9IA)7 : 80<E2NMENT for t%e sale of leased lands to t%e lessee before t%e e/pir' of lease period $ EI( *%at is t%e status of %ouse allotted to sri(c%andras%e.aria% +ide 7)A allotment letter no: LFJ:AID:7)A:A)M:9M2SL5H6:DK-DM dt FF:JK:FMDK( ED( *%' 7)A didn;t file police complaint to e+ict encroac%ers$ EK( *%' 7)A didn;t inform t%e descendents of ori"inal allottee about t%e cancellation of t%eir allotment $ EM(*%at %appened to t%e mone' deposited b' ori"inal allottee$ IJ(is t%e action of 7)A allottin" t%e said %ouse to an ille"al encroac%er ,ust b' t%e resolution of 7)A committee le"al $ IF( in case t%e 7)A *is%ed to re-allot t%e said %ouse & first it must %a+e informed t%e ori"inal allottee about cancellation of allotment allo*in" t%em sufficient time to repl' *it% public notice in ne*s papers & t%en t%e' s%ould %a+e allotted t%e said %ouse to t%e senior most in t%e *aitin" list( 7ut 7)A %as ,ust allotted t%e %ouse to an ille"al encroac%er b' t%e resolution of 7)A committee( Is it le"al $

IA( 7)A officials "a+e %alf trut%s to m' 2TI re4uest # stated t%at t%e said file concernin" t%is issue cann;t be found ie lost ( is it le"al $ IL( %as t%e 7)A filed police complaint re"ardin" t%eft of file from t%e record room $ H0N0=2A7LE !0MMISSI0NE2 0F 7)A PLEASE 2EFE2 THE F0LL0WIN8 A2TI!LE(

NI!E !orridor Wuestions to !HIEF MINISTE2 (Mr(@edi'urappa 2ead full 4uestionnaire %ttp:::sites("oo"le(com:site:sose+oicefor,ustice:nice-corridor-4uestions-toc%ieZ f-minister

T%reats to Human 2i"%ts Acti+ist : 2TI Applicant - An Appeal to !I! & 9I! # !%ief ustice of India

s%ame s%ame to <<IPs & Public ser+ants *%o are %idin" trut%s & *%o are co+erin" up crimes & b' den'in" 2TI 2EW=ESTS to us( In India & man' !orrupt public ser+ants don-t %onour 2TI re4uests *it% one prete/t or t%e ot%er( T%e' are a*are t%at t%e information if "i+en *ill become e+idences of t%eir criminals acts( T%e' "o to an' len"t% to %ide trut% & to %ide information( T%e' murder 2TI Applicants & fi/ t%em in cases & etc( No*ada's murders of 2TI Applicants & Human 2i"%ts Acti+ists are fre4uent( I %a+e m'self suffered t%reats & attempts to murder me & closure of m' ne*s paper & loss of ,ob & etc at t%e %ands of criminal ne/us( E/ample : I %a+e re4uested M'sore district & district ma"istrate for information under 2TI re"ardin" ille"alities *ort% crores of rupees & instead of ta.in" action a"ainst t%e culprits & Pre+entin" furt%er irre"ularities & ille"alities & criminals %e repeatedl' abused me # t%reatened me( T%e ille"alities continued & a la.e *as partiall' closed ille"all' allotted to an industrialist alle"ed to be +er' close to t%e state Industries minister( In t%e same *a' I %a+e been t%reatened b' police often & I %a+e e+en recei+ed t%reatenin" p%one calls from a person claimin" %imself to be a =P Hi"% !ourt ud"e( To m' pre+ious appeals to !I! # 9I! & t%e' *ere mum & as it concerns a !ommoner it *on-t "i+e t%em an' ima"e build up & publicit' or T2P ratin"s instead it *ill raise t%e %ec.les of po*ers t%at be marrin" t%e future prospects & lucrati+e postin"s & etc of !I! # 9I! members (

7ureaucrats are of secreti+e nature & a career bureaucrat if appointed to information commission & %e *or.s a"ainst t%e principle of Transparenc' # 2TI ( If furt%er t%e career bureaucrat %appens to be utterl' corrupt # "i+en postin" in Information commission as a fa+or b' %is corrupt collea"ues in t%e "o+ernment & 2TI # 2TI Applicant *ill suffer & die( E/ample : 9arnata.a state information commissioner Mr( H(N 9ris%na( 0fcourse & t%ere are fe* %onest people in public ser+ice includin" in information commissions ( We respect t%ose %onest fe* # re4uest t%eir support in appre%endin" t%eir corrupt collea"ues ( If an't%in" unto*ard %appens to me or to m' dependents & to"et%er *it% t%e criminals all t%e members of !ENT2AL INF02MATI0N !0MMISSI0N # 9A2NATA9A STATEINF02MATI0N !0MMISSI0N *ill be responsible for it( Sub,ect to conditions & %ereb' I do offer m' ser+ices to !I! & 9I! # 80I in appre%endin" & le"all' prosecutin" criminals & corrupt public ser+ants & etc( Hereb' & I do re4uest t%e !I! # 9I! to order t%e concerned officials to "i+e information in follo*in" cases # 2TI 2e4uests mentioned belo*(

2TI 2e4uest made to )' !%airman & 2a,'asab%a & Ne* )el%i SA:=8:FF:FGAMJfFAf 2TI 2e4uest made to =nion Home Minister & 80I & Ne* )el%i SA:=8:FF:FGAMFi*%o 2TI 2e4uest made to !%ief ustice of India & Ne* )el%i SA:=8:FF:FGAKD"in. 2TI 2e4uest made to President of India & Ne* )el%i SA:=8:FF:FGAKKi+II 2TI 2e4uest made to Lo.sab%a Spea.er & Ne* )el%i SA:=8:FF:FGAKMA',M 0ur pre+ious 2TI re4uest to ! I & union %ome secretar' of 80I& President of India & )8 # I8P of 809 and ot%ers *ere not %onored( T%e information I sou"%t *ere ans*ers to t%e follo*in" 4uestions mentioned in t%e belo* mentioned *ebsites ( t%e 4uestions concerned t%e past & present continuin" in,ustices meted out to millions of Indian citi3ens & due to *ron" : ille"al *or. practices of Indian ,ud"es & police # public ser+ants ( T%e information *e sou"%t *ould e/pose t%e traitors & anti-nationals & criminals in public ser+ice( T%e information *e are see.in" are no defense secrets & no national secrets( T%e trut%ful information e/poses t%e anti-nationals & traitors in t%e public ser+ice # stren"t%ens our national securit' & national unit' # inte"rit'( Hereb' & I do re4uest t%e %onorable supreme court of India to consider t%is as a PIL for : R*rit of MandamusR and to issue instructions to t%e concerned

public ser+ants in t%e follo*in" cases to perform t%eir duties # to ans*er t%e 4uestions(

ai Hind( <ande Mataram( @our-s sincerel' & Na"ara,a M 2 (

2TI W=ESTI0NS H0N0=2A7LE 80<E2N02 0F 2ESE<E 7AN9 0F IN)IA IS AF2AI) T0 ANSWE2

S0ILE) N0TE F2A=) !ASE V 27I 7AN8AL02E Trauma of an old man

'omplete case details also available at http:$$members.lycos.co.u!$ganapathihariram$

)s per allegations o :=4 management =angalore in 3OAA%AO , criminal nexus o :=4 employees stole :s. **2222 rom :=4 =angalore. )ll the ban!s , government treasuries in >arnata!a , submit de aced $ soiled currency notes to :=4 =angalore in exchange or good notes. :=4 a ter collecting such de aced currency notes , sorts out airly good notes which can be reissued L burns o the remaining totally de aced

currency notes. )ll these process is done in a systematic manner.

)s per allegations o the management , the crime too! place in the period o 3OAA%AO at :=4 =angalore. ) nexus o employees, too! away the currency bundles meant or destruction L substituted it in the

place o bundles o reissuables.

'harge sheet issued by :=4 =angalore o ice to mr.#.,ariram &ta no.<?OC$3+?$C0%C+ dt 3 april 3OC+ no <AOC$3+?%C0$C+ dt C april 3OC+

)mended charge sheet sta

'=4 has charge sheeted 3A employees in connection with this case , case olde no. cc<0$3OCO new no. sc 0<?$3OO3 . the honourable *3 city additional city civil L sessions court =angalore in itFs order dated *0.23.3OO* discharged 2< charge sheeted employees , as the prosecution

ailed to prove the charges against them. They came out clean , as they were innocents saddled with the crime done by others. One o the charge sheeted employee who turned approver or the prosecution, has given detailed account o the crime. @owhere he has mentioned the involvement o accussed no.3+ mr.#.,ariram in the crime.

-ven a ter coming out clean, mr.#.,ariram was not reinstated into service by :=4. They gave the ruse o domestic en7uiry L showed contempt to the court order. On appeal, the honourable high court o >arnata!a ordered :=4 to review itFs order with respect to mr.#.,ariram , still :=4 ailed to reinstate mr.#.,ariram into service , once gain showing contempt to the court o law.

4n 4ndia as per law , the decisions o court o law are binding on all , orders o court over rides the organisationFs internal rules , service rules , etc. inspite o lac! o evidences, in a whimsical

manner the higher authorities o :=4 , ixed some innocents as the scape goats heaped all charges against them . against whom they had personal grudge , disli!es /. :=4 repeatedly showed contempt to the court orders , dismissed the scape goat % ailing old man mr.#.,ariram rom service. :=4 snatched away his PH money towards the alleged loss to the ban! , didnFt pay his gratuity amount , salary arrears and inally he was even deprived o the pension. )s a result , the old man has even lost his social prestige, dignity , his amily su ered a lot L he is a mental wrec! today.

8hy :=4 authoroties are hell bent upon to send away the innocents $ scape goats away rom service K why '=4 didnFt conduct polygraph tests o all the accussed , speci ically higher o icers o :=4 , managers o :=4 o ice =angalore K probably the scape goats were aware o the crimes master minded by higher ups L didnFt co%operate with the higher ups in their crimes. &o, the criminals were a raid that the scape goats will blurt out truth to the world , ixed non co%operating innocents themselves as criminals.

8ho will give justice to innocents li!e old man mr.#.,ariram L who will bell the corrupt , criminals , at cats o :=4 K

APPEAL =N)E2 SE! FM 5L6 0F 2TI A!T AJJE 0F 80<E2NMENT 0F IN)IA # 80<E2NMENT 0F 9A2NATA9A

)PP"4')T4O@ HO: 4@HO:1)T4O@ )& P-: :T4 )'T *22+ . &-- :U"- ** OH :T4 )'T *22+ /

HU"" @)1- OH T,- )PP"4')@T : @)#):)(.1.:.

)99:-&& OH T,- )PP"4')@T : @)#):)(.1.:., -94TO: , -%EO4'- OH ,U1)@ :4#,T& 8)T',, a "4#%* $ A?3, OPP 8)T-: 8O:>& OHH4'-, ,U9'O H4:&T &T)#-, ")Y14>)@T)@)#):, ,-==)", 1D&O:- , >):@)T)>) P4@ M +A223A.

9-T)4"& OH 9O'U1-@T& $ 8:4TT-@ &T)T-1-@T& $ 4@HO:1)T4O@ :-WU4:-9 :

,-:-=D , 4 9O ,U1="D :-WU-&T DOU TO #4E- 1- 8:4TT-@ &T)T-1-@T& $ )@&8-:& TO T,- HO""O84@# WU-&T4O@& % 8,4', 4@ 4T&-"H . ie answers / ):- T,- 4@HO:1)T4O@ &OU#,T =D 1-. 84T, :-&P-'T TO ')&- @O old ''<0 $ 3OCO L @-8 @O &'0<?$3OO3 )T *3 &T )994T4O@)" '4TD '4E4" L &-&&4O@& 'OU:T =)@#)"O:-

',):#- &,--T-9 OHH4'-: 1:.#.,):4:)1 :=4 =)@#)"O:-

',):#- &,--T @O sta

no.<?OC$3+?$C0%C+ dt 23.23.3OC+

)mended charge sheet sta

no.<AOC$3+?%C0$C+ dt 2C.20.3OC+

3. 8hy didnFt you notice the alleged crimes o 3OAA , AC L AO till the mid o 3OAO K

*. This crime came to light only due to anonymous phone calls o good &amaritans to authorities , but not due to your inspection . is your inspection division wor!ing properly K

<. why there is no security chec! up o o icers during entry L exit out o premises K

0. why there is no individual weighment , individual statement o value o bags o reissuable notes L bags o note meant or destruction , a ter sorting is done, why they are not tallied with total weight , value o notes issued or sorting K

+. 4mmediately a ter noticing the crime, why did not you trans er all the employees o those sections K

?. why did not you ta!e steps to preserve< L protect respective documents relating to such high pro ile crime K

A. why didnFt you immediately issue charge sheet to all the accussed L waited till 3OC< K

C. 8hy :=4 has le t out , so many o icers . who wor!ed in the same sections or more period than accused o icers / rom domestic en7uiry K

O. why '=4 also ailed to put those people in the charge sheet be ore the court K

32. is it because they were in avorable terms with the vested interests K

33. did the '=4 dance to the tune o vested interests in :=4 while preparing charge sheet L during investigation , instead o independent investigation K

3*. those le t out probables rom the charge sheet might have caused the destruction o evidences $ records. 9uring the course o domestic en7uiry $ court proceedings , it has been recorded that some records have been destroyed. )re not '=4 L :=4 responsible or destruction o evidences , aiding true criminals get away K

3<. in normal times , what is the period speci ied in :=4 regulations or preserving old documents $ records K

30. a ter noticing such a high pro ile crime the :=4 must have ta!en

utmost care to preserve such old records or inde inite time , or producing be ore courts o law as L when demanded. =ut it didnFt , why K

3+. does not this point to connivance o higher authorities o :=4 , with the criminals K

3?. :=4 authorities have conducted domestic mass en7uiries , instead o individual en7uiries , is it not detrimental to the rights o de ense K

3A. :=4 authorities have stated that court proceedings L domestic en7uiry are independent o each other L are not binding on one another. ,owever :=4 authorities straight away too! on record o domestic en7uiry the court statements , evidences , but didnFt honour the order o same court o law K why this double standard by :=4 K

3C. The alleged crime was committed in 3OAA%AO, but charge sheet was ramed in mid 3OC+ , why this long delay K

3O. didnFt this acilitate the masterminds o crime to destroy , manipulate evidences K

*2. as stated be ore court , indeed some records , **nd currency note pac!et were missing , who is responsible or it K

*3. has the '=4 conducted en7uiry , polygraph test o :=4 higher o icers % &.@.:)N9)@ , 8.&.&):)H , (.P.)8)&T,4 , (.14T:) L others ,

i not why K

**. is it not due to ine iciency , negligence o duty by such high ran!ing managers , that such a crime occurred in :=4 =angalore K

*<. what disciplinary action :=4 has ta!en against the ine icient , negligent higher o icials K

*0. whatever internal rules an organiIation ma!es must be within the line o law. 4 such internal laws o the organiIation are violative o law , undamental rights o employees , such internal rules become illegal. )re not the way o :=4 disciplinary proceedings illegal K

*+. as per :=4 pension regulations 3OO2 , :=4 has the right to deduct any loss caused to the ban! , rom the pension o :=4 employee i the misconduct o employee is proved in judicial proceedings . even though mr.#.,ariram came out clean rom the court , why :=4 has denied his pension K

*?. judicial courts o law are appellate authorities over L above , domestic en7uiry committees L judicial orders supersedes the domestic en7uiry proceedings. &till :=4 showed contempt o court L didnFt reinstate mr..#.,ariram into service , why K

*A. even i an employeeFs misconduct causing loss to the ban! is proved , be ore denying him pension .towards ma!ing up loss to the

ban!/ , previous sanction o the central board o :=4 must be ta!en. =ut in mr.#.,ariramFs case , pension was denied in ull without ta!ing previous sanction o the central board o :=4 , is it not illegal K

*C. :=4 alleged that mr..#.,ariram caused loss to the tune o :s.30222 to the ban! L recovered it rom his provident und dues. There was nothing le t over to recover , still :=4 completely denied pension to mr.#.,ariram , why K

*O. ideally, domestic en7uiry indings $ disciplinary actions should be completed irst , then the employee can appeal to appropriate court o law. 4n mr.#.,ariramFs case , '=4 L :=4 ailed to prove the charges in court o law , as a result court discharged him rom the charges. To cover%up itFs ailures :=4 management dragged domestic en7uiry much beyond court orders date L gave indings indicting mr..#.,ariram. does the en7uiry o icer o domestic en7uiry thin! that he is over L above the court o law K is it not illegal L contempt o court K

<2. ideally , :=4 authorities should have appealed to higher court against lower court order discharging mr.#.,ariram rom charges. =ut it was not done , why K

<3. did the :=4 pay interim relie to mr.#.,ariram , during suspension period K

<*. the undue delay in iling charge sheet , conse7uent destruction o

!ey evidences , dishonour $ contempt o court orders , undue haste in giving indings , dismissal , denial o o pension without central boardFs sanction , all point towards criminals within :=4 higher management. 8hat disciplinary action has been ta!en against (.P.)8)&T,4, &.@.:)N9)@,(.14T:), 8.&):)H L others K i not why K

<<. why charge sheet was amendedK 4s it legal K

<0. did the charge sheet was amended to alsely implicate mr..#.,ariram , by including cancelled note vault in the charge sheet K

<+. does not this itsel show that it is not statement o actual happenings $ acts , but a cunning ploy to mislead investigation towards ixed innocents rom actual criminals K

<?. is it true that that only +^ o sample inspection is done out o bundled veri ied de ective note pac!ets K

<A. is not the conduct o joint $ mass en7uiries o all charge sheeted o icers illegal K

<C. how come such an important evidence **nd note pac!et went missing K

<O. is it because it may point towards real criminals K

02. as per the statement o management witness $ inspection head $ expert mr.vijendra rao , the notes o earlier dates have been removed rom pac!ets made into new bundles , right K

03. as per his statement , entire certi icates , seals o some asst treasurers are there , who didnFt wor! at all on that day is not it K

0*. does not it show that some body else was misusing the seals , putting some innocents seals over the notes K

0<. does it not show that , crime has ta!en place at veri ication section K

00. does it not show involvement o some asst treasurers K

0+. why asst treasurers have not been charge sheeted K

0?. why inspection o :=4 =angalore o ice was not done between 3OA+ L 3OAO K

0A. is it not true that you ailed to produce all records showing internal inspection $ audits , during domestic en7uiry L court proceedings K

0C. your expert mr.vijendra rao has stated that some seal mar!s are smudged , he has stated some seal mar!s appears to be so L so. ,e has clearly nowhere stated that this seal mar! is exactly this , so he himsel is not 322^ sure K

0O. your expert nowhere said that 322^ sure this seal mar! is this , on that day this seal was issued to mr.#.,ariram , isnFt it K

+2. your expert says during 3OA+ , he didnFt notice< any raud. ,owever approver says raud was there be ore mid 3OAA also. 8hy no action has been ta!en K

+3. why you didnFt produce all records o all persons , who have speci ically wor!ed in alleged sections , the registers o those departments with daily activity report containing seal nos , pac!et nos , bag nos , etc K

+*. are not their chances o some criminals putting the seal mar!s o innocent o icers over the notes , bundles , bags , etc K

+<. your expert is not 322^ sure o seal mar! , your records are not there to prove the presence o charge sheeted o icers in the alleged sections , neither your expert nor your records are 322^ sure on what date , at what stage , by whom crime was committed , isnFt it K

+0. is not the charge sheet amounting to higher ups pic!ing up o icers they disli!e L alsely implicating them K

++. is it not cunning ploy o higher ups to divert attention rom original criminals K

+?. why no action was ta!en against currency o icer o 3OAA%AO mr.(.1itra K why his pension , super annuation bene its were not withheld K

+A. what is your justi ication , supporting evidence , records or pic!ing up only three o icers including mr.#.,ariram or legal prosecution and leaving the majority o probables K

+C. why you have dropped charges against ive asst treasurers K why you didnFt even conduct domestic en7uiry against them , let alone legal prosecution K

+O. 4s it :=4Fs L '=4Fs way o

air play L justice K

?2. as inly +^ sampling o veri ied note bundles are done , there are more possibilities o rebundled pac!ets getting unnoticed in relaxed O+^ lot , isnFt it K

?3. you have le t out so many o icers who wor!ed in those sections, some o whom even became management witnesses , instead o being charge sheeted by the management, is it air play L legal K

?*. who are the ban! employees , rom whom you have recovered the alleged ban! loss o :s.**2222 K

?<. were all o them charge sheeted , en7uired , legally prosecuted , dismissed L their pension , gratuity withheld K

?0. you donFt have any internal statuotary records to prove that mr.#.,ariram wor!ed in those departments , except a currency o icerFs o ice note dated just on the eve o charge sheet years a ter the alleged crime K does it not prove that this note has been concocted just to ix mr.#.,ariram K

?+. where as you have records o other o icials attendance in those departments , but not charge sheeted them why K

??. three o icers o sta grade ) daily wor! in three sections out o 02 o icers , why you have pic!ed up only mr.#.,ariram , out o 32O+ wor!ing days , he has wor!ed or only **< days in those sections , still those o icers who wor!ed or more days in those sections are not charge sheeted why K the approver , the management expert witness , shi t registers , E* registers , 9estruction certi icates , Horm '9 ++ , etc , nobody , no records were able to say on what date , at what stage , by whom crime too! place , also they were unable to say on what date at what stage crime was committed by mr.#.,ariram K is it not utile imagination , cunning ploy o :=4 higher authorities to ix innocent 1r.#.,ariram K

?A. the management expert witnesses said , the most probable place o crime is punching $ 'ancelled @ote Eault , incinerator , where asst treasurers were joint custodians . they were not en7uired L let o why K

?C. the charge sheet alleges extraction $ substitution o de aced note pac!ets. 8here as the management expert witness say substitution o de aced notes only K is not there di erence between loss o one number o note L 322 number o notes K

?O. as per the normal course o duty , sta o icers does not count notes in each bundles , but they just count the number o bundles only. 4s not there chances o inserted note bundles or bundles containing less number o notes going unnoticed K is it not the ailure o statuotary system o wor! practices K A2. does not all these prove higher authorities o :=4 L '=4 were hell bent to ix mr.#.,ariram L to shield the original criminals K Wuestions with respect to other cases : A3. how do you monitor the wor! o ban! o icials nominated as directors o companies which have availed ban! loans K A*. how do you monitor the wor! o companies , in which ban!s have invested K A<. how do you monitor the rapid wealth growth o certain ban! o icials , who wor! in shares investment $ e7uity unds section , etc K A0. inspite o project reports by ban! o icials , over assessment o collateral securites $ value o debtor companies by ban! o icials , the loans become @P)s L ull value cannFt be realiIed in the mar!et by selling o the assets o debtor companies also. 4n such cases , what action is ta!en against erring ban! o icials who collude with criminal industrialists or availing higher amount o loan than permissible K A+. give ban!wise speci ic igures o @P)s. A?. give names o industrial groups $ promoters whose companies have become @P)s , so that public can be aware o them , be ore investing in new companies promoted by them. AA. is not collection o loan rom debtors o ban! through rowdies $ recovery agents , illegal K AC. why not criminal complaints iled against ban! mangers or aiding , abetting rowdism , murdering people K AO. i your method o employing rowdies to collect loans o :s.32222 rom commoners is right , what would you do to a promoter o a debtor company to recover loans o crores o rupees , supari !illing K but debtors o crores o rupees is let o coolly by ban!s , why K C2. what is the exact amount o loss caused to the exche7uer by !arim lala telgi who printed a!e stamp papers K C3. what action has been ta!en against those involved K

C*. have you ta!en action against all those mentioned by telgi during narco analysis test , i not why K is it because they are power ul L bigwigs K C<. how you are controlling the illegal inance activities , money lending by individuals , pawn bro!ers L chit und companies K C0. how you are monitoring the receipt o public donations , oreign donations by many @#Os K C+. how many erring @#Os , chit und companies , pawn bro!ers , individuals you have boo!ed or illegal inance activities K Wuestions relating to :=4 'U::-@'D @OT- P:-&& 1D&O:C?. who were responsible or selling the good printing machine at security press nasi! to scamster !arim lala telgi as scrap K CA. who recruited the candidates below merit ran!ings in :.=.4 or what criminal roles K CC. how many irregularities have ta!en place in :.=.4 till date K CO. who is responsible or installing, operating L supervising the security set%up in :.=.4 K O2. how the raw materials ie number o paper sheets, in!, etc are accounted or in inward stores L while issuing or printing K O3. how wastages, scrap o in! , papers , etc in the printing process are accounted orK O*. ,ow the inished goods ie currency notes are accounted or K O<. 8ho !eeps physical igures L possession o goods, inventory o all the aboveK O0. ,ow the scrap paper is disposed o K

O+. Hrom security angle who !eeps trac! rom start till dispatch K O?. #ive me the merit ran!ing list o all candidates or the post o stores assistant in =:=@1P" in the year 3OO+%O? K OA. give me the merit ran!ing list o all candidates or the post o process assistant at =:=@1P" in the year 3OO? K

OC. give me the merit ran!ing list o all candidates or the post o process assistants L maintenance assistants at =:=@1P" in the year 3OO?%3OOC K OO. is not :=4 L =:=@1P" authorities created by statuotary laws , ully unded by public money ie rom government exche7uer K 322. still why =:=@1P" L :=4 re used to answer my previous in ormation re7uest as per :T4 )ct K are you a raid that s!eletons will come out o cubboard K 323. what action initiated against the &=4 branch =angalore L &=4 Overseas branch or loss o che7ue $ dra t amounting to crores o rupees K i not why K 32*. give me speci ic igures ban! wise with respect to loss caused to the ban! by loss o che7ues or demand dra ts , etc K 32<. how :=4 is containing crimes o loss o che7ues $ 99s causing huge losses to the ban!s to the tune o crores o rupees K D-): TO 8,4', )=OE- P-:T)4@& : 1)(O:4TD OH 9O'U1-@T& P-:T)4@& TO D-): 3OCC onwards . &O1- OH T,- 9O'U1-@T& ):- 9)T-9 =)'> TO 3O0A. H--& P)49 : 4PO @O ?<- <3CO<+ HO: :UP--& T-@ O@"D Havouring 'P4O :=4 ,W 1U1=)4 PU="4' 4@HO:1)T4O@ OHH4'-: H:O1 8,O1 T,- 4@HO:1)T4O@ 4& :-WU4:-9 : E.&.9)& , '-@T:)" PU="4' 4@HO:1)T4O@ OHH4'-: , O$O ,O@OU:)="- #OE-:@O:, :=4 ,W , '-@T:)" OHH4'- , )1): =U4"94@# , P.1.1):# ,1U1=)4%022223. 9ate : 23.33.*22CTTTTTTTT. Dour’s sincerely, Place : 1ysoreTTTTTTTTTTT.. @agaraj.1.:.

Ten reasons *%' criminals in .%a.i "et a*a' &iddharth Earadarajan

=ehind every man li!e &.P.&. :athore who abuses his authority stand the generals and ootsoldiers who help and support him. 8e need to ta!e them all down. &.P.&. :athore, the criminal ormer top cop o ,aryana, may appear alone today but we must never orget that he was able to get away with the sexual molestation o a young child and the illegal harassment o her amily or 3O years because he had hundreds o men who supported him in his e ort to evade justice. The act that these men M ellow police o icers, bureaucrats, politicians, lawyers, judges, school administrators M were willing to bend the system to accommodate a man accused

o molesting a minor spea!s volumes or the moral impoverishment o our establishment and country. 9ecent societies shun those involved in sexual o ences against children. -ven criminals jailed or JordinaryF crimes li!e murder treat those serving time or molesting children as beyond the pale. =ut in 4ndia, men li!e :athore have their uses or their masters, so the system circles its wagons and protects them. The '=4Fs appeal may lead to the enhancement o :athoreFs sentence and perhaps even the slapping o abetment to suicide charges, since his young victim !illed hersel to put an end to the criminal intimidation her amily was being subjected to by :athore and his men. =ut the systemic rot which the case has exposed will not be remedied unless sustained public pressure is put on Prime 1inister 1anmohan &ingh and Union ,ome 1inister P. 'hidambaram, two men who have it in their power to push or simple remedies in the way the 4ndian law en orcement and justice delivery system wor!s. Hirst, abolish the need or o icial, i.e. political sanction to prosecute bureaucrats, policemen and security orces personnel when they are accused o committing crimes. The original intent behind this built%in stay%out%o %jail card was to protect state unctionaries rom acts done in the course o discharging their duties in good aith. &omewhere along the line, this has come to mean protecting our custodians o law and order when they murder innocent civilians .eg. the in amous Panchalthan case in >ashmir where the trial o army men indicted by the '=4 or murdering ive villagers in *222 still cannot ta!e place because the 'entral government will not grant permission/, or assault or molest women and children. @o civilised, democratic society grants such impunity. 4t is disgusting to see ormer o icials and bureaucrats rom ,aryana saying how they had wanted :athore prosecuted but were prevented rom doing so because o pressure. &uch o icials should either be made ormally to testi y in a criminal case against the politicians who so pressured them or they should themselves be hauled up or perverting the course o justice. &econd, stop tal!ing about how ma!ing the police and army answerable to the law will somehow demoralise their morale. 9oes anybody care about the morale o ordinary citiIens any moreK Or the morale o upright police and army o icers, who do not thin! it is right or their colleagues to be able to get away with criminal actsK Third, bring an end to the cosy relationship between the police and politicians. :athore was protected by our chie ministers o ,aryana. ,e served them and they served him by ensuring his un ettered rise. 4t is absurd that the 4ndian Police is still governed by a colonial%era )ct dating bac! to 3C?3. ) number o commissions have made recommendations or re orming the police over the years; but no government or political party wants to give up its ability to use and misuse the police or their own bene it. Hourth, ensure that police o icers who abuse their authority and engage in mala ide prosecutions are dismissed rom service and sentenced to jail or a long period o time. 1r. 'hidambaram should use the considerable resources at his command to ind out who were the policemen involved in iling 33 bogus cases against the teenaged brother o the young girl :athore molested. ,e should then ma!e sure criminal proceedings are initiated against all o them. The message must go out to every policeman in the country: 4 you abuse the law at the behest o a superior, you will su er legal conse7uences.

Hi th, ensure that criminal charges against law en orcement personnel are ast%trac!ed as a matter o routine so that a power ul de endant is not able to use his position to delay proceedings the way :athore did or years on end. The destruction or disappearance o material evidence in such cases must be treated as a grave o ence with strict criminal liability imposed on the individual responsible or brea!ing the chain o custody. &ixth, empower the @ational ,uman :ights 'ommission with teeth so that police departments and state governments cannot brush aside their orders as happened in the :athore case. This would also re7uire appointing to the @,:' women and men who have a proven record o de ending human rights in their pro essional li e, something that is done today only in the breach. The attitude o the 1anmohan &ingh government to this commission and others li!e the @ational 'ommission or 8omen .@'8/ and @ational 'ommission or 1inorities is shoc!ing. Eacancies are not illed or months on end. &eventh, ensure the early enactment o pending legislation broadening the ambit o sexual crimes, including sexual crimes against children. =etween rape, de ined as orced penetrative sex, and the vague, Eictorian%era crime o Joutraging the modesty o a womanF, the 4ndian Penal 'ode recognises no other orm o sexual violence. )s a result, all orms o sexual molestation and assault short o rape attract airly lenient punishment, o the !ind :athore got. 4n his case, the judge did not even hand down the maximum sentence, citing concerns or the criminalFs age. &adly, he did not ta!e into account the age o the victim and neither does the 4P', which ails to distinguish between Joutraging the modestyF o an adult woman and a young child. ) dra t law changing these provisions and bringing 4ndia into line with the rest o the modern world has been pending with the @'8 and "aw 1inistry or years. Perhaps the government may now be shamed into pushing it through Parliament at the earliest. -ighth, ta!e steps to introduce a system o protection o witnesses and complainants. The ate that the amily o :athoreFs young victim had to endure is testament to the act that people who see! justice in 4ndia do so at their own peril. @inth, ensure that robust interrogation techni7ues li!e narco%analysis, which are routinely used against other alleged criminals, are also employed against police o icers accused o crimes. Tenth, the media and the higher judiciary must also turn the light inward and as! themselves whether they were also derelict in their duty. The :athore case did not attract the !ind o constant media attention it deserved, nor do other cases involving serving police o icers accused o crimes against women, wor!ers, peasants and minorities. )s or the upper courts, their record is too patchy to inspire con idence. 4t was, a ter all, the high court which chose to disregard the '=4Fs re7uest or including abetment to suicide charges. >eywords: &iddharth Earadarajan, &.P.&. :athore, criminals, !ha!i, ormer 9#P o ,aryana, custodians, sexual violence, @,:'

W%'

ur'

S'stem

is

superior

t%an

,ud"e

s'stem

!ontents 3. *. <. 0. +. ?. 8hat is judge system and (ury &ystemK ,ow judge system has wea!ened 4ndia : ) speci ic example judge%lawyer nexus in judge system @exuslessness : >-D di erence (ury &ystem creates over judge system >nowledge$in ormation actor &ummary

W%at is ,ud"e s'stem and ur' S'stem$ 4n any nation, there will be disputes over many issues between two or more individuals, and i these disputes are @OT resolved by the state$nation in short time, the individuals will resolve to private retribution thereby causing a chaos. &uch chaos could wrec! the nation. &o or stability, it becomes necessary or the citiIenry to give judgements on these disputes, and use orce to en orce that judgement. ) nation consisting o la!hs and crores o citiIens would have thousands and la!hs o disputes a year. 4t is @OT possible or every citiIen to personally ta!e interest in each o the these individual thousands and la!hs o disputes. ) citiIen can at best ta!e interest in 3%* disputes a month or year. There ore, the citiIenry has not much option, but to appoint some individuals, or each dispute and ta!e their decision has almost inal in most cases, and scrutiniIe .via appeal/ them in some cases. &o one o the procedure that a nation has to execute, implicitly or explicitly, is to choose individuals to give judgement on a perticular dispute. There are two broad systems depening on how individuals are chosen 3. The (ury &ystem : #iven any dispute, +%32%3+ citiIens are chosen at random rom the voter list o all adult citiIens in that district$state, and these citiIens, called as (urors, hear the arguments, examine the evidences, and give a verdict *. the judge system : some senior individuals in the state appoints some chosen individuals in a district and appointed as judges, who will have term or *%0%more years. )nd these ixed small number o appointed individuals will resolve the disputes.

Other systems, which use =OT,, random selection o citiIenry as well as appointed individuals are basically simple combitions o (ury &ystem and judge system. )nd there are many other actors, li!e siIe o (ury, 7uali ications, screening rules etc which ma!e one (ury &ystem di er rom another. =ut undamental di erence between (ury &ystem and judge system is : (ury &ystem depends on a ew randomly chosen citiIens rom -@T4:- population, and 94HH-:-@T (urors are used or di erent cases; 8,4"- judge system uses same appointed individuals or almost all cases that would come. On the sur ace, this issue may loo! unimportant %%% what di erence does it ma!e whether cases are decided by randomly chosen citiIens or a ixed judgesK =ut this trivial loo!ing di erence plays a huge role in the strengthening or wea!ening the nation. Ho* ,ud"e s'stem %as *ea.ened India : A specific e/ample 'osider a speci ic !ind o crime %%% street criminals .commonly called as 9aadaa/ collecting protection money rom small shop%!eepers etc every month, openly and earlessly. There are places in U&$-urope with high crimes, but nowhere can one see criminals opnely extorting money rom shop%!eepers. There are many di erential reasons or this. One o the actor why career crime is rampant in 4ndia, and less seen in 8est is the that 4ndia uses judge system, while the 8est uses (ury &ystem. The judge system ma!es 4ndiaFs courts very nexused, while the (ury &ystem has drastically reduced the nexusproneness in 8estern courts. "ets see how (ury &ystem reduces the nexusproneness in 8estern 'ourts. 'onsider a mid%level career criminal with a gang o +2%322 criminals. ,e may be operating in some +%32 areas. @ow to sustain their operations, he and his gang members would need to pay monthly bribes to many 1")s, 1Ps, police o icers, other o icers, government lawyers, judges etc and would also need money to hire lawyers, mercinaries etc on time to time basis. )ll this, means a monthly H4Y-9 'O&T o la!hs o rupees. @ow such career criminal ')@ @OT always ind +%32 victims that would cover all the costs and give pro its every month. &o almost always, a gang o career criminals has to victimise 322s o victims a month. 4n short, a career criminal and his gang%member has to commit 322s o crime a month. Out o so many crimes, some *2%<2 o victims would end up iling complain in the courts. This would generate some <22%022 court cases per year. @ow this is where judge system and (ury &ystem would create di erence in combating career crimes. !areer criminal in ,ud"e s'stem !areer criminal in ur' S'stem P 4n the judge system, these <22%022 cases P 4n the (ury &ystem, -)', case goes to 3*% will go to just +%32 judges, who have a term 3+ 94HH-:-@T (urors, randomly chosen rom o *%0 years in their areas. the district. P &o in order to delay the case .to rustrate P &o to get ac7uitals in <22%022 cases a the complainers$witnesses/ or get outright year, the gang leader will need to cultivate a7uittals, the gang leader has to cultivate nexuses with <222%+222 (urors a year.

nexuses with O@"D +%32 judges. P ,e cultivates nexuses with +%32 judges, and bingo ... he can manage an ac7uital$delay in OO^ cases.

P "ong delay in (ury Trials are rare as each (ury is given O@"D one case, hearings are rom 33am to 0pm on one and only one case, and mostly next date is next day. P so managing ac7uitals in even 32^%*2^ cases is next to impossible, much much harder than it is in judge system

4O8, since a large number o cases in 4ndian courts are resolved by a small number o individuals .i.e. judges/ the career criminal who have cultuvated nexuses with are having a ield day. 8hile 8est uses a very large number o individuals to resolve court cases, which ma!es establishing nexuses in a larger number o cases di icult. ,ud"e-la*'er ne/us in ,ud"e s'stem That was about judge%criminal nexus. The courts in 4ndia are sprawling with judge% lawyer nexuses. ,ow does judge%lawyer nexus come into existanceK ,ud"e-la*'er ne/us No ur'-la*'er ne/us P &ay <%+ senior lawyers have 32%*2 junior lawyers wor!ing or them. &ay they are togather ta!ing *22%022 cases a year in a district P @o one in 8estern courts has even seen (uror%lawyer nexus. 4t simply cant exist as ...

P the <%+ senior lawyers, who are ta!ing *22%022 cases a year will end up acing P 1ost o these cases would to same 32%*2 *222%+222 (urors a year judges posted in that district. P there is no time to cultivate nexuses with P 8ithin <%? months these lawyers can even +^ o them. cultivate nexuses with these 32%*2 judges.

Puttin" it ot%er *a' 8hen a lawyer ma!es a nexus with a judge during the trial o a case, that nexus with that judge will be '-:T)4@"D use ul to that lawyer in )"" his cases which will come up be ore that judge.

-ven i a lawyer manages to orm nexuses with say A%C out o 3* (urors during the trial o a case, those nexus with those (urors will be o @O U&- at all in )"" other case o that lawyer, as (urors change with each and every trial.

Ne/uslessness : 9E@ difference ur' S'stem creates o+er ,ud"e s'stem 4 will re%explain the di erence (ury &ystem creates.

3. There are 3* 94HH-:-@T (urors or each case, and @O citiIen is allowed to sit in (ury or more than once in say +%32 years. .The judgeFs role is to guide the (urors, not to decide the guilt./ *. &o in the 8est, say there are +222 cases a year in a district, the verdict is given by +2222 to ?2222 (urors. 8here as in judge system, these +222 verdicts will be given by mere *2%+2 judges. <. "ets loo! at it another way. &ay a judge gives say 322 verdicts a year and say a judgeFs career is <2 years long. &o one individual, the judge, decides <222 cases. 8hereas, in The (ury &ystem, -)', case goes to 32%3+ 94HH-:-@T (urors. &o the judgements in these <222 cases will come rom <2222 to 02222 94HH-:-@T (urors. 0. So t%e number of ;decision ma.ers; in ur' S'stem is muc% muc% lar"er. The number o decision ma!ers in courts go up by not just 32%3*%3+ times, but almost *2222 to 02222 times higher. ,ow does this ma!e courts o 8est less nexusproneK 8hile it is indeed possible to ma!e nexuses with A%32 out o 3* (urors and get a avorable verdict, it is @OT possible or a lawyer or a career criminal to ma!e nexuses with 3222 out o *222 (urors. =asically, in a districtFs courts, when number o decision ma!ers are small, such as just *2%+2, it is possible or a lawyer or a career criminal to cultivate nexuses with them. =ut when number o decision ma!ers are large, as large as +2222%?2222, it is next to impossible or a career criminal or a lawyer to cultivate a nexuses with many o them. [Note : The (ury &ystem is the >-D reason why 'ourts in U& are much less nexused than courts in 4ndia. =ut it is @OT the only reason. Hollowing are the OT,-: additional reasons why U& 'ourts are less nexused than 'ourts in 4ndia 3. #rand (ury &ystem : The public prosecutors in U& are accountable to #rand (ury consisting o some *+%<2 citiIens. They are semi%randomly chosen rom citiIenry; term is ? months to 3 year, and repeatations are @OT allowed. This ma!es #rand (ury a airly less nexusprone body. *. The public prosecuors in most states$district are elected. 8hen not elected, they are appointed by P1$'1$1ayor, and appointment needs approval o majority o 1Ps$1")s$Panchayat%1embers. 8here as in 4ndia, PPs in )"" districts are appointed by "aw 1inisters. The procedure is more nexus%prone compared to election procedure. <. The police chie in most districts in U& is elected. This ma!es police chie s more responsible to citiIenry and less nexused than appointed police chie s. 0. The judges in many states$districts in U& are elected. -lection is less nexusprone procedure than appointment. 8hen not elected, judges are appointed by P1$'1 and appointment needs approval o majority o 1")s$1Ps. This procedure is ar less nexusprone than procedure used in 4ndia, where judges appoint judges without any public debate. end o @ote\

9no*led"e:information factor One objection o ten cited by anti%(ury pro%judge individuals is that (urors have less !nowledge$in ormation about the law. This objection is partly incorrect %%% =OT, jurors and judges have &)1- !nowledge$in ormation about basic concepts o justice, airness, right$wrong etc. The O@"D di erence is that judges have more T-',@4')" !nowledge about speci ic details. eg both judges and (urors !now that violence is crime, crime done with speci ic monetary motive is more henious than spotaneous violence etc. =ut (urors may or may not be aware o speci ic details li!e such and such act carries maximum punishment o say + years or A years or ? months and so orth. &uch speci ic details are easy to grasp and apply. The pro%judge anti%(ury people do not mention the other point %%% i.e. judges progressively get more and more nexused. ) newly appointed young 1agistrate is relatively nexusless, and so he is bold, upright, straight orward and air. =ut as days go, he cultivates more and more nexuses with lawyers, criminals, other judges, o icers, 1inisters, 1")s, local riches etc. 8hereas each (ury is 94HH-:-@T and so un%nexused. 41O, decisions rom un%nexused (urors will have more integrity and airness than decisions o nexused judges, no matter how much more !nowledgeable and in ormed they might be. There or, 4 pre er (ury &ystem over judge system. Ho* to brin" ur' S'stem in India $ The 7uestion is or all those, but O@"D those, who believe that decisions o inhererently ununexused (urors will be better than decisions o the ixed permanent judges, who are nexusprone and o ten nexused. To those who believe that judge system is better than (ury &ystem, this is a non%7uestion. @ow ollowing is are the steps 4 suggest using which citiIens in 4ndia can expel the judges and bring (urors onboard. 3. Hirst citiIens should get "1.23%2< passed in Panchayats, )ssembly and Parliament. These procedures would reduce citiIens dependence on 1")s$1Ps etc in getting (ury related laws passed in Panchayats, )ssembly and Parliament. *. @ext, citiIens should pass a law in Parliament using "1.2<, which would give ull powers the &tate "egislatures to dra t the laws related with appointments o judges in all courts which would ta!es cases on issues which are &tate subjects. The 'entral government would O@"D manage the cases that are related with 'entral subjects. <. @ext, citiIens should pass a law in )ssemblies using "1.2*, which would give ull powers the 9istricts to dra t the laws related with appointments o judges in "ower 'ourts, whose power is restricted to maximum punishment o < years and ine o :s 322,222, and would also empower 9istricts to have ull control over administration o such "'s.

0. Using "1.2<, citiIens can expel all appointed judges in &' and ensure that &'s has O@"D 32 judges o which all 32 are 94:-'T"D elected by citiIens o 4ndia. )nd using "1.2<, citiIens can pass a law that would create (ury &ystem in &upreme 'ourt o 4ndia. +. Using "1.2*, citiIens can expel all appointed judges in ,' and ensure that ,'s has O@"D 32 judges o which all 32 are 94:-'T"D elected by citiIens o the &tate. )nd using "1.2*, citiIens can pass a law that would create (ury &ystem in ,igh 'ourts o &tates ?. Using "1.2<, citiIens can expel all appointed judges in "'s and ensure that "'s judges get 94:-'T"D elected by citiIens o the 9istrict. )nd using "1.23, citiIens can pass a law that would create (ury &ystem in "ower 'ourts. =asically, 3st step redeuces the need to convince 1")s who are hostile to (ury &ystem due to a mutual understainding that whereby judges will not hurt 1")s and 1")s will not hurt the judges. The second step will allow each state to decide whether they want judge system or (ury &ystem, and how they want to manage their &tate courts. The third steps ta!es it down to district level %%% or all crimes in which maximum punishment is below < years. @ow citiIens o districts are on their own %%% some district may decide to continue as is with appointed judges, some may opt or elected judges with no (ury, some district may opt or elected judges with (ury &ystem and so orth. This may reduce uni ormity, but 9O-& @OT result into discrimination, as inside a court, all citiIens are treated e7ually. &uch uni ormity does not exist even today, as some laws under state subjects vary rom state to state. )lso, since 'riminal Procedure 'ode is joint subject in 4ndia, 'rP' in di erent states does vary. )lso, since the procedures to appoint judg es in lower courts is le t to ,' chie judges, they vary rom &tate to &tate. &o we do @OT have uni ormity today. &o my proposed setup 9O-& @OT destroy uni ormity, as we dont have uni ormity anyway. To enact (ury based procedures in 4ndia, 4 have proposed ollowing procedures : 3. *. <. 0. 'T.23 % (ury or$against an employee sta 'T.2* % (ury or$against (unior Policemen 'T.2< % (ury or$against &tate #ovt o icers related to taxation 'T.20 % (ury or$against &tate #ovt o icers related taxation o 1unicipality

+. 'T.2+ % (ury in courts under -xecutive such as court o -xecutive 1agistrate, 9istrict 1agistrate, &&:9 etc/ ?. A. C. 'T.2? % (ury in "ower 'ourts 'T.2A % (ury in ,igh 'ourt 'T.2C % (ury in &upreme 'ourt

Summar' The o icers and private citiIens in 4ndia are supervised by judges who have a tenure o 3+%<2 years and a term o *%< years in a given court. &uch a long tenure and term is 7uite a long time or criminals$lawyers and judges to establish nexuses amongst themselves and bene it at the cost o nation. 8e, the commons o 4ndia, 1U&T abandon this system or good. 4nstead, we 1U&T use a rotating group o +%32%3+ citiIens, chosen at random rom citiIenry to decide upon a case. Unless we use this (ury &ystem in departmental in7uiries, 7uasi%courts and courts, the problem o judge%criminal nexus and judge%lawyer nexus will remain in our courts and will contitue to corrode the nation. -arlier we switch to (ury &ystem, better it is or 4ndia.

!2IMES !0MMITTE) 7@ LAW !0=2TS IN IN)IA - An appeal to %onourable supreme court of india

Indian prisons are meant to be reformin" sc%ools for t%e prisoners( 7' t%e corrupt practices of t%e officials & t%e prisons %a+e become factories turnin" out %ardened criminals(

Sa' & a person *as cau"%t b' police on suspicion of pic.-poc.etin"( T%e police produce t%e accussed before t%e ma"istrate & in turn %e remands %im for ,udicial custod'( Let us consider & T%e punis%ment for t%is offence pic.poc.etin" as per la* is I mont%s imprisonment( Ho*e+er t%e case dra"s on for L 'ears & finall' t%e court finds %im "uilt' of offence # orders for I mont%s imprisonment( Totall'& t%e offender ser+es GA mont%s imprisonment sentence in practice( In some cases & t%e courts consider t%e time alread' spent b' t%e accussed be%ind t%e bars *%ile "i+in" ,ud"ement( In t%is e/ample & e+en if t%e offender is let free ta.in" I mont%s imprisonment sentence& t%e offender %as been "i+en e/cess sentence of LI-INLJ mont%s(

Ta.in" t%e same e/ample furt%er& sa' t%e court finds t%e accused as innocent& not "uilt' of crime # lets %im free( Ho*e+er & t%e poor c%ap %as suffered LI mont%s imprisonment for no fault of %is(

As per la*& no bod' not e+en t%e courts of la* are le"all' empo*ered to punis% an'bod' be'ond t%e le"al procedures & rules establis%ed( In t%is *a'& due to dela' in our le"al s'stem & fault' bail procedures & t%ousands of undertrials are sufferin" in +arious prisons t%rou"%t India( Are* not t%e courts *%ic% remanded t%ose accused to ,udicial custod' responsible for t%is ille"al

act of e/cessi+e punis%ment $ *%at punis%ment s%ould be "i+en to t%ose ,ud"es $

T%e bail procedure in India & is also fault' *it%out considerin" 4uantum of offence # financial status of t%e accused( A person accused of stealin" rs(FJJ %as to pro+ide bail suret' bond of rs(EJJJ or personal suret' b' a *ealt%' person : "o+ernment ser+ant( T%e poor person %a+in" personal contacts & friends%ip *it% ric% persons : "o+ernment ser+ants is 4uite remote & so %e can;nt secure bail on personal bond( T%e poor c%aps famil' is not ric% enou"% to spend rs(EJJJ suret' amount( As a result& unable to secure bail t%e poor c%ap suffers in ,ail for 'ears(

Sa'& a ric% industrialist is accused of rs(AJ crores ta/ e+asion& %e is let free on a personal bond of rs(F la.%( Stamp paper scam .in"pin .arim lala tel"i %as s*indled "o+ernment to t%e tune of t%ousands of crores of rupees& onl' fe* cases are re"istered a"ainst %im( T%at too in one out of t%ose cases in+ol+in" rs(GE la.% *ort% stamp sale & ,ud"e %as "i+en %im ri"orous imprisonment plus a fine of rs(EJJJJ(

!onsiderin" t%e abo+e e/amples it is 4uite clear t%e bail amount& fine amount are peanuts for t%e ric% ,ust a fraction of 4uantum of t%eir crime & *%ile for t%e poor it is %u"e man' times more t%an t%e 4uantum of t%eir crime(( it is biased to*ards ric% # mi"%t' criminals( As a result poor al*a's suffers in ,ail& *%ile ric% are out on bail(

E+en *it%in prisons & t%e number of prisoners per s4(ft area & no of doctors & %ospital beds & medicines a+ailable& *ei"%t of food per da' "i+en to prisoners & are all less # muc% belo* t%e statuotar' limits( T%e food & %ealt% care & li+in" conditions of prisoners & under-trials are *orse t%an pi"s( T%e prison aut%orities are utterl' corrupt& *%ic% %as been brou"%t into li"%t a"ain # a"ain b' t%e media( If a poor prisoner 4uestions t%e ille"al acts of t%e officials & %e is sub,ected to Lrd de"ree torture & rou"%ed up b' ro*d' prisoners on t%e insti"ation of t%e officials t%emsel+es( Man' poor prisoners are sufferin" from %ealt% problems & man' are d'in" due to lac. of proper %ealt% care # food in t%e prisons(

W%ereas & t%e ric% # mi"%t' prisoners & b' pa'tin" bribe "et non-+e" & alc%o%olic drin.s from outside restaurants dail'( T%e' e+en secure dru"s ( t%e' "et spacious <IP rooms & tele+ision & mobile p%ones( T%e' easil' "et parole # easil' "ets admitted in outside %ospitals # roam free & *%ile on record t%e' are in-patients in %ospitals(

T%e la* of limitation *%ic% stipulates time limits for filin" +arious cases is also biased to*ards t%e "o+ernment as a part' # ric% & mi"%t'( For t%e purposes of e+idences & filin" of cases one needs +arious "o+ernment records( T%e concerned officials don;t pro+ide t%ose records for 'ears unless bribed # sit o+er t%e files for 'ears( Some times b' ma.in" absurd & illo"ical file notin"s & re,ects it bac.( T%ere is no time limit for t%e performance of duties b' public ser+ants( W%en a commoner don[\]t "et rele+ant records & files & e+idences in time & %o* can %e file cases in time *it%out t%ose records & e+idences $

No*ada's & numerous cases of irre"ularities & c%ar"es of corruption a"ainst ,ud"es are comin" to li"%t( Ho*e+er & in suc% cases ,ud"es are as.ed to resi"n from ser+ice but no criminal prosecution a"ainst t%em is instituted & onl' in cases in+ol+in" lo*er court ,ud"es it is done( W%en a case of irre"ularit' b' a ,ud"e in a specific present case comes & t%ere are e+er' possibilit' t%at in t%e past also %e %as committed t%e same in cases %andled b' %im *%ic% %as not come to li"%t( In suc% instances & all t%e cases %andled b' t%at particular ,ud"e t%rou"%t %is career must be re+ie*ed & but is not done *%' $ does not it amount to co+er-ups $

In man' cases t%e %i"%er courts %a+e turned do*n t%e +erdicts of t%e lo*er courts & let free t%e innocents & absol+ed innocents of c%ar"es # annulled deat% sentences *%en appeals came before t%em( Ho*e+er & in all suc% cases & t%e lo*er court ,ud"es must be punis%ed for "i+in" out *ron" ,ud"ements& meatin" out in,ustice to innocents( Here a fact must be noted & onl' a fraction of cases "oes in appeal to %i"%er courts& as in ma,orit' of cases t%e poor people lac. t%e financial mi"%t to ma.e t%e appeal( T%e so-called free le"al ser+ices aut%orit' pre-,ud"es t%e cases before "i+in" le"al aid( As a result & man' innocents poor people resi"n to t%eir fates suffer in,ustice in courts of la* & under"o imprisonment punis%ment & some times e+en deat% sentence( So & t%e ur"ent need of t%e %our is to incorporate ,ur' s'stem or some outside monitorin" s'stem to re+ie* cases as # *%en decided(

In man' cases in+ol+in" t%e ric% # mi"%t' li.e tel"i & case proceedin"s are conducted in-camera in ,ud"e;s c%ambers or proceedin"s are conducted t%rou"% +ideo conferencin" ( outside from public "a3e( T%e tapes are not made public and t%e public cann;t e+en ascertain t%e +alidit' of tapes & *%et%er it is edited & doctored (

0ne of t%e basic reasons for dela'ed ,ustice # *orse prison conditions in India & is lo* number of ,ud"es & police personnel & %i"%er rate of case ad,ournments and finall' lo* amount of financial "rants made b' t%e

"o+ernment to ,udicial department : police department( T%e "o+ernment states t%at it doesn;t %a+e enou"% mone' to pro+ide for ,udiciar' # police( As a result& fundamental : %uman ri"%ts of innocent commoners are t%*arted( T%e state "o+ernments # 80I & is one of eit%er parties in DEP of cases before +arious courts in India& it is t%e bi""est liti"ant # is influencin" t%e ,udiciar' b' controllin" t%e "rants & recruitment to ,udiciar' # b' enticin" some *it% post-retirement postin"s(

T%e "o+ernment %as "ot mone' to spend on la+is% parties of <<IPs & IAS officers ser+in" non-+e" foods & alc%o%olic drin.s ( t%eir forei"n ,aunts & E-star bun"alo*s & limousines & interior decorations of t%eir bun"alo*s& etc( *%ic% is of %i"%er priorit' & importance & *%et%er t%e lu/ur' of <<IPs or t%e fundamental : %uman ri"%ts of commoners $ t%e courts s%ould ans*er( T%e courts %a+e t%e le"al po*ers to order "o+ernments to pro+ide enou"% financial "rants to it & %o*e+er it is .eepin" mum & turnin" blinds e'e to crimes of <<IP[\]s( t%e "o+ernment re*ards suc% ,ud"es *it% salar' %i.es & promotions & lu/ur' cars & bun"alo*s & per.s and post-retirement postin"s & sites at ,udicial la'-out & 'ela%an.a & 7an"alore & etc(

We at e-+oice %a+e utmost respect for t%e ,udiciar' & but %ereb' %umbl' brin"in" t%e crimes of ,udiciar' before t%e %onest fe* ,ud"es see.in" ,ustice to t%e common fol.(

POLICE +OT REGI.TERI+G CO&PL(I+T I+DI( , OT)ER.

(G(I+.T C)IE4 J*.TICE O4

4ro'/

+(G(R(J($&$R$ LIG>: - DJE/ )*DCO 4IR.T .T(GE/ L(=&IH(+T(+G(R/ )E00(L/ &3.ORE > LDCCED$

T rou! /

)onourable DG , IG o" Police / .tate Police )$8 / 0an!alore$

To/

)onourable Circle Inspector o" Police/ 2i#ayana!ar Police .tation/ &ysore$

)onourable .ir/

.ub#ect 1 2iolation o" 4*+D(&E+T(L RIG)T. , )*&(+ RIG)T. by )onourable C ie" Jusice o" India , )$E$)onourable President o" India , ot er public servants

Harnata6a Police are +OT re!isterin! , actin! on 'y co'plaint to t e' dated CK$CD$:CCI / EC$E:$:CCK /$ ETC$

( person co''ittin! a cri'inal o""ense is a CRI&I+(L$ T e Person 5 o aids a cri'inal in is cri'inal act / in idin! t e cri'inal act / in destroyin! t e evidences o" cri'inal act is also a CRI&I+(L$ T e person 5 ose duty is to prevent cri'inal acts "ro' appenin! / 5 o intentionally "ails in is preventive duties and t ereby "acilitatin! t e cri'inal in co''ittin! cri'e is also a CRI&I+(L$ In"or'ation !iven by !overn'ent aut orities are E2IDE+CE. / denial o" in"or'ation a'ounts to idin! o" evidence / i'proper / al" trut in"or'ation !iven a'ounts to &(+IP*L(TIO+ , DE.TR*CTIO+ O4 E2IDE+CE.$ In t is 5ay 'any o" our public servants includin! #ud!es , police t e'selves are cri'inals / but are not prosecuted by t e aut orities / 5 y 7 Due to delay in !ivin! appropriate in"or'ation / 'any cri'es ave ta6en place 5 ic could ave been prevented$ (s t e delay in ta6in! action / !ivin! in"or'ation - evidence is on t e part o" !overn'ent aut orities / t e issue o" TI&E 0(RRED 4OR (D&I..(0ILIT3 doesnAt arise$ (t t e outset / 5e e<press our 5 ole earted respects to t e onest "e5 public servants in public service includin! #udiciary$ )o5ever/ t e corrupt in public service donAt deserve respect as individuals ? as t ey are parasites in our le!al syste'$ .till 5e respect t e c airs t ey occupy but not t e corrupt individuals$

(ll t e "ollo5in! articles - issues / 5 ole articles publis ed in t e 5eblin6s 'entioned belo5 "or's part o" t is appeal$ T e ter' “J*DGE% 'entioned t rou! t includes all public servants disc ar!in! #udicial "unctions ri! t "ro' talu6 'a!istrates / Buasi>#udicial o""icers to C ie" Justice o" India$ Indian Le!al - Judicial .yste' is 'anipulated at various sta!es , is "or sale$ It is a .)(&E$ T e persons 5 o raise t eir voice see6in! #ustice are silenced in 'any 5ays$ T e cri'inal ne<us as already atte'pted to silence 'e in 'any 5ays $ I" anyt in! unto5ard appens to 'e or to 'y "a'ily 'e'bers / 'y dependents / )onourable C ie" Justice o" India to!et er 5it #urisdictional police o""icer 5ill be responsible "or it$ T e 2i#ayana!ar police in 'ysore stated t at t ey donAt ave le!al #urisdiction to boo6 t e cri'inals I ave 'entioned in t e co'plaint , by ta6in! a state'ent "ro' 'e to t at e""ect closed t e case te'porarily on EE$CI$:CEC a"ter sittin! over t e co'plaint "or years to!et er$ Is it not t e duty o" DG,IGP to see6 t e per'ission "ro' o'e 'inistry to le!ally prosecute t e alle!ed cri'inal 22IPs 7 W y e 5as silent 7 O"course t e lo5er run! police o""icers practically donAt ave po5er to prosecute i! , 'i! ty 7 )ereby / I do reBuest t e DG , IG O4 Police / Govern'ent o" Harnata6a to see6 t e le!al sanction "ro' union o'e 'inistry , Harnata6a state o'e 'inistry / "or t e prosecution o" belo5 'entioned cri'inal 22IPs , to reopen 'y co'plaint ere 5it $ In India / as per constitution o" india all citi@ens are eBual / ave ri! t to eBual oppurtunity , eBuitable #ustice irrespective o" caste / creed / reli!ion / etc$ t e constitution as !uaranteed t ese to every Indian citi@en by 5ay o" CO+.TIT*TIO+(L 4*+D(&E+T(L RIG)T.$ (lso / every u'anbein! on eart as !ot )*&(+ RIG)T./ by virtue o" is - er birt $ )o5ever in india / CO+.TIT*TIO+(L 4*+CTIO+(RIE. - P*0LIC .ER2(+T. ave "or!otten t is , are actin! as lords / autocrats > unBuestionable public 'asters$ CO+.TIT*TIO+(L 4*+CTIO+(RIE. are P*0LIC .ER2(+T. appointed to serve t e public/ public are t e 6in!s o" de'ocracy / t ey are t e ta<payers , pay'asters o" t is very sa'e public servants$ In India / corruption as spread itAs tentacles "ar , 5ide / it as not even spared t e #udiciary$ T e last resort o" co''on'an "or see6in! #ustice is #udiciary / even t ere corruption as spread $In present day India / i" one is ric / e can co''itt any type o" cri'e , !et a5ay clean "ro' courts o" la5$ t ere are corrupt police o""icials 5 o 'odi"y 4IR / suppress evidences /'anipulate evidences / ta6es up di""erent line o" investi!ation / "i< innocents / cou! s>up "alse con"essions "ro' innocents by 3rd de!ree torture / "ile 0 report closin! t e case / decides not to appeal in i! er court o" la5 / etc / (LL 4OR ( PRICE$ Just see t e list o" 'illionnaire police o""icials 5 o are cau! t by 6arnata6a lo6ayu6ta$ +e<t step / t e prosecutor , de"ense advocate stri6es a deal / 'anipulates evidences / 'anipulates 5ay o" presentation o" case , 5ay o" ar!u'ent "avourin! t e ric croo6s "or a price / as observed in i! pro"ile 0&W case involvin! public prosecutor I* H)(+ , de"ense counsel RH (+(+D$ In t is

5ay / i" corrupt police , advocates / to!et er 'anipulate t e due process o" la5 / t e presidin! #ud!e is le"t i! , dry even t ou! t e #ud!e is onest/ e is le"t elpless$ to add to t is / 5 en t e #ud!e i'sel" is corrupt / peopleAs last ope / de'ocracy is dead$ +o5adays 5e are earin! too 'any reports o" irre!ularities in #udiciary$ our publication as "iled 'any appeals as P*0LIC I+TERE.T LITIG(TIO+ be"ore onAble supre'e court o" India but t e vested interests t ere are not acceptin! it as PILs$ W)(T DOE. P*0LIC I+TERE.T LITIG(TIO+ &E(+. 7 I..*E. W)IC) (RE O4 P*0LIC CO+CER+ (44ECTI+G &(+3 +*&0ER O4 P*0LIC.$ T e issues raised by us "or sa'ple 1 E$ sale o" "a6e 'edicines , adulterated "ood products / bevera!es / colas a""ectin! t e ealt o" 'illions o" Indians , public o" i'portin! nations 5 o are i'portin! t e sa'e dan!erous products "ro' india $ :$ de'olition / eviction o" ouses / lands belon!in! to poor dalits / tribals / bac65ard castes by !overn'ent aut orities 5 ereas re!ularisin! ille!al land encroac 'ents / ille!al buildin!s by i! , 'i! ty people in total disre!ard to la5$ in so'e cases !overn'ent as even 'ade conte'pt o" court / by de"yin! court orders , enactin! special la5s all to "avour ric land !rabbers$ 3$ ta6e t e cases corporate "rauds/ violation o" labour la5s / pollution board la5s / ta< la5s / etc by co'panies$ K$ T e reports in 'edia about certain i! ly placed public servants lea6in! indiaAs de"ense secrets to "orei!n countries , so'e politicians / "il' stars attendin! parties osted by anti nationals D(WOOD I0R()I& , under5orld dons in !ul" countries , else5 ere$ t ese type o" appeals are "or public !ood / national security / as public are a""ected by t e'$ still supre'e court o" india is not considerin! our repeated PIL (ppeals$t e courts ave t e aut ority to consider even a post card / e>'ail as a PIL (ppeal / t e courts even ave t e ri! t to initiate suo>'otto action "or public !ood / inspite o" absence o" any appeals - co'plaints$ over , above t is at t e ti'e o" 'y very "irst appeal 'y inco'e 5as very lo5 , i 5as a retrenc ed "actory e'ployee 5 o 5as eli!ible "or "ree le!al aid/ even "ree le!al aid 5as not !iven to 'e$ +o5 / even to 'y repeated RTI (ppeals t e )onourable c ie" #ustice o" India , )$E$)onourable President o" India are not !ivin! t e reBuested in"or'ation $ t ese action o" CJI , PRE.IDE+T O4 I+DI( is aidin! i! , 'i! ty cri'inals / anti nationals / a'ounts to suppression o" in"or'ation / trut / evidences / 5 ic is a co!ni@able o""ence$ .O. (ppeal to .*PRE&E CO*RT o" I+DI( ttp1--e>clariono"dalit$blo!spot$co'-:CEC-CG-s>o>s>appeal>to>supre'e>$$$

DE(L. I+ CO*RT. , POLICE .T(TIO+. RE(D 1 ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-satya'eva>#ayate / ttp1--e>clariono"dalit$blo!spot$co'-:CEE-CE-satya'eva>#ayate$ t'l /

(CC*.ED C ie" Justice o" India ttp1--sites$!oo!le$co'-site-eclariono"dalit-accused>c ie">#ustice>o"$$$ / ttp1--e>clariono"dalit$blo!spot$co'-:CEE-C:-accused>c ie">#ustice>o"$$$

CRO.. E=(& O4 )O+O*R(0LE C)IE4 J*.TICE O4 I+DI( / .*PRE&E CO*RT O4 I+DI( > ttp1--crossc#i$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eso"supre'ecourt$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crossc#i$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$5ordpress$co'- /

CRO.. E=(& O4 *+IO+ )O&E .ECRET(R3 / GOI / +EW DEL)I ? ttp1--crossc#i$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eso"supre'ecourt$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crossc#i$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$5ordpress$co'- /

CRO.. E=(& O4 DG,IG O4 POLICE / GOH / 0(+G(LORE ? ttp1--crossc#i$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eso"supre'ecourt$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crossc#i$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--crosse<a'o"c ie"#ustice$5ordpress$co'- /

CRO.. E=(& O4 GO2ER+OR / RE.ER2E 0(+H O4 I+DI( ttp1--t e"tinrbi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--t e"tinrbi$redi""blo!s$co'/ ttp1--t e"tinrbi$5ordpress$co'-

CRO.. E=(& O4 &*D( CO&&I..IO+ER / &*D( / &3.ORE ? ttp1--cri'eso"'uda$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'anivannan'uda$blo!spot$co'/ ttp1--cri'esat'uda'ysore$5ordpress$co'- /

CRO.. E=(& O4 0D( CO&&I..IO+ER / 0D( / 0(+G(LORE ? ttp1--cri'eso"bda$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--bdacri'es$5ordpress$co'- /

CORPOR(TE CRI&E. RPG C(0LE. LI&ITED ttp1--cri'esatrp!$blo!spot$co'- /

ttp1--cri'esatrp!$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:EG

&EG( 4R(*D 03 GO2ER+&E+T O4 I+DI( ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ

are you ready to catc ta< t ieves 7 ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ

&O0ILE P)O+E. / C*RRE+C3 .C(+D(L. ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ

reliance industry 5 ere is accountability 7 ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--'e!a"raudby!oi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-EIJ

cri'es at in"osys ca'pus ttp1--cri'eatin"y$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--cri'eatin"y$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:EK

cri'es by 0$D$( a!ainst a poor 5o'an ttp1--cri'eso"bda$blo!pot$co'- / ttp1--bdacri'es$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:E:

cri'es o" land 'a"ia in India ttp1--landsca'sinindia$blo!spot$co'- / ttp1--landsca'$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:E:

currency t e"ts in R0I Press ttp1--t e"tinrbi$blo!spot$co'- /

ttp1--t e"tinrbi$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-GC

6iller colas , 6iller 'edicines o" India ttp1--deat cola$blo!pot$co'- / ttp1--deat cola$5ordpress$co'- / ttp1--!roups$ya oo$co'-!roup-na! r5-'essa!e-:CE

We do ave i! est respect "or all constitutional bodies / public servants / but it is an appeal to t e onest "e5 in public service /to brin! to boo6 t eir corrupt collea!ues$T e )onourable C ie" Justice o" India , )$E$)onourable President o" India ave violated t eir oat s o" o""ice / "ailed in t eir constitutional duties / suppressed 'aterial trut s - in"or'ations , t ereby repeatedly violated 'y Constitutionally !uaranteed 4*+D(&E+T(L RIG)T. , 0(.IC )*&(+ RIG)T. , Obstructin! 'e "ro' per"or'in! constitutionally prescribed 4*+D(&E+T(L D*TIE. (. ( CITIME+ O4 I+DI($ )ereby / i do reBuest you to le!ally prosecute t e belo5 'entioned public servants (CC*.ED CRI&I+(L. vi@ E$)$E$)onourable President o" India :$ )onourable C ie" Justice O" India 3$ *nion )o'e .ecretary / GOI K$ Governor / Reserve 0an6 O" India L$ Director>General , Inspector General O" Police / !overn'ent o" 6arnata6a J$ Co''issioner / 0an!alore Develop'ent (ut ority D$ Co''issioner / &ysore *rban Develop'ent (ut ority G$ Co''issioner / &ysore City Corporation I$ Labour Co''issioner / !overn'ent o" 6arnata6a EC$ Central In"or'ation Co''ission &e'bers and EE$ all public servants belon!in! to ta< dept / pollution control board / etc 'entioned in t e above cases 5it 5eb lin6s/ on t e above 'entioned c ar!es$

t e 5 ole issue o" t is ne5s paper , t e related 'aterials at t e 5eblin6s provided/ "or's part o" t is co'plaint$ I" i a' repeatedly called to police station or else 5 ere "or t e sa6e o" investi!ations / t e losses i do incurr as a result li6e loss o" 5a!es / transportation / #ob / etc 'ust be borne by t e !overn'ent$ prevoiusly t e police - I0 personnel repeatedly called 'e t e co'plainant 9su""erer o" in#ustices; to police station "or Buestionin! / but

never called t e !uilty culprits even once to police station "or Buestionin! / as t e culprits are i! , 'i! ty $ t is type o" one sided Buestionin! 'ust not be done by police or investi!atin! a!encies $ i" anyt in! unto5ard appens to 'e or to 'y "a'ily 'e'bers li6e loss o" #ob / 'eetin! 5it it , run accidents / loss o" lives / etc / t e #urisdictional police to!et er 5it above 'entioned accussed public servants 5ill be responsible "or it$ Even i" cri'inal ne<us levels "a6e c ar!es / police "ile "a6e cases a!ainst 'e or 'y dependents to silence 'e / t is co'plaint is , 5ill be e""ective$ i" anyt in! unto5ard appens to 'e or 'y dependents / t e !overn'ent o" india is liable to pay Rs$ one crore as co'pensation to survivors o" 'y "a'ily$ i" 'y 5 ole "a'ily is eli'inated by t e cri'inal ne<us /t en t at co'pensation 'oney 'ust be donated to Indian (r'y Wel"are 4und$ a"ter5ards / t e 'oney 'ust be recovered by GOI as land arrears "ro' t e salary / pension / property / etc o" !uilty police o""icials / public servants , Constitutional "unctionaries$ T an6in! you$ Jai )ind / 2ande &atara'$ Date 1 :C$CG$:CE:FFFFFFFFFF3ourAs sincerely/ Place 1 &ysoreFFFFFFFFFFF$$+a!ara#a$&$R$

T e stran!e case a!ainst Justice P$D$ Dina6aran

2ustice - / /inakaran, the chief ustice of the Karnata*a -igh 'ourt, is in the middle of a bla%ing legal row& +he lead story of *he Hindu reports that 2ustice 8ina*aran, who is one of five udges recommended for elevation to the /upreme 'ourt, was summoned by the chief ustice of "ndia, J 0 Falakrishnan, in connection with allegations made against him by members of the Bar of the $adras -igh 'ourt of !disproportionate assets#&

2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran, who was sworn in in August >DDA, has reportedly denied the charges, according to '00:"B0& Below is the full unabridged te3t of the memorandum sent to the '2" under the auspices of the $adras:based Corum for 2udicial Accountability, which details serious charges of land grabbing, corruption, abuse of office and lac* of probity against 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran& churumuri com has not independently verified the charges nor does it attest to the veracity of the charges or the lac* thereof& +he memorandum is published here in the public interest given the seriousness of the allegations, and because we believe the memorandum is now a public document, having been brought to the notice of the '2" by such legal luminaries as +am ,ethmalani, @ali S Aariman and Shanti Fhushan& Our ob ective is not to cause disrepute to the image of the honourable udge or of the udiciary& +o ?uote from the memorandum4 !We are doing so only in the larger interests of the institution of the udiciary which is sacred and since the increasing reports against the udge have assumed alarming proportions&# 'oming as it does in the middle of a national debate on the disclosure of assets of udges, l+affaire P&8& 8ina*aran assumes importance, not ust in the way the ape3 court deals with it, but the manner in which the udiciary deals with the media which publishes details of the case& At the same time, the timing raises disturbing ?uestions& Why are the charges surfacing now against a $adras -' udge who is reputed to have disposed S>,SEF cases9 "s somebody out to get him9 "f 2ustice 8ina*aran is unsuitable for the /upreme 'ourt, is he suited to continue as the '2 of Karnata*a -igh 'ourt, or even as a 2udge9 VVV &th September, !""& +o -on(ble $r&2ustice J 0 Falakrishnan, +he 'hief 2ustice of "ndia, -on(ble $r&2ustice F A 3garwal, -on(ble $r& 2ustice S * Japadia, -on(ble $r&2ustice ;arun Chatterjee, -on(ble $r& 2ustice 3ltamas Jabir, /upreme 'ourt of "ndia, 0ew 8elhi& Sirs, Sub4 Representation against ,r# -usti!e 4.D.Di,a1a$a,, .hief -usti!e, Karnataka High .ourt, amassing of huge assets, !orruption and serious irregularities# As per newspaper reports @*he Hindu, dated >Ath August >DDEB $r 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran, presently 'hief 2ustice of the Karnata*a -igh 'ourt, has been recommended by the collegium of the /upreme 'ourt to be appointed as a 2udge of the /upreme 'ourt& +he said udge was a udge of the $adras -igh 'ourt between <E&<>&<EE; to D;&DA&>DDA& We, the members of the Bar of the $adras -igh 'ourt are greatly perturbed by the news of his possible elevation to the Ape3 'ourt, in view of disturbing reports that are strong pointers to the abuse of office and lac* of probity by $r 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran&

We bring to your notice several aspects concerning the 2udge including 8#: huge rural land holdings, illegal appropriation o5 0o(ernment and public land amounting to land-grabbing, illegal constructions, ownership o5 urban properties, 8!: certain inappropriate and startling judicial orders and 8$: conduct raising issues o5 gross impropriety and lack o5 probity He 5eel the materials gi(en below call 5or a detailed in(estigation be5ore taking up his case 5or appointment as a ,udge o5 the highest Court VVV +he following are the issues of deep concern4 ' 3massing Health and 3ppropriation o5 -ublic -roperty +.+3L -+>-)+;? "t is common *nowledge in the Bar at $adras that the 2udge has ac?uired vast e3tents of lands, near his hometown of Ara**onam, )ellore district, and in +hiruvallur district, +amil 0adu& +he ac?uisition started before his appointment as a udge of the $adras -igh 'ourt and is reported to have increased manifold during his tenure as a udge& All these land holdings in the villages are beyond the ceiling limit under the +amil 0adu Land 5eforms @Ci3ation of 'eiling on LandB Act, <E;<, as per which a family of five persons can possess not more than <F standard acres of land& -owever, more shoc*ing is the unbecoming conduct of the udge in encroaching upon 1overnment lands and public property meant for the villagers, amounting to land:grabbing and depriving the poor of their resources and livelihood& # L3A/S 'A J3K)+'+3,3-.+34 K'LL30) 8%%" 3cres: @aB "n the villages of Kaverira apuram, +iruttani talu*, +iruvallur districtG Anaipa**am, Ara**onam talu*, )ellore districtG and $ulvoy, Ara**nonam talu*, )ellore district, the e3tent of lands possessed by the udge is appro3imately FDD acres& $ost of the property is in Kaverira apuram, a village whose population predominantly consists of 8alits, "rulas @scheduled tribesB and most bac*ward classes li*e 0aidus, Boyars and others& +he total e3tent of the village is about <,SDD acres& Anne3ed to this petition are4 @iB A map showing the details of land held and owned by the udge and his family membersG and public and 1overnment lands occupied by him, and @iiB .3tracts from village TA( register which provides the classification of land of the relevant survey numbers in the udge(s occupation, from reliable sources& +he current TA( register reflecting transfer of patta is not accessible& @iiiB Photographs showing the naming of the village road leading to his lands which is in +amil and reads as !.mperor of 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran 5oad, Kaverira apuram# @translation in .nglishB and the fencing of the land& @ivB .3tracts of 5evenue /tanding Orders on Assignment of Land& 8b: 'n all, the judge is in possession o5 approximately %%" 3cres in Ja(erirajapuram (illage alone, almost one-5ourth o5 the (illage Out of this ==D acres4 @iB L<D&LL acres are Tpatta( lands owned by the udge and his family @in his name, his wife 8r Kinodini(s name, his two daughters 3mudha -orkodi and 3mirthra -orkodi, one Cannan and another personG the latter two are reported to be his close relativesB&

@iiB About =<&>S acres is public land classified as 1overnment poram oke, eri @la*e, streamB and other water bodies, pathway and tamarind grove& @iiiB About AA&LL acres are classified as 1overnment T/nadhinam( lands @which can be allotted only to landless poor as per board standing orders of the +amil 0adu 1overnmentB& ! S;3+;L'A0 4>/.S >-)+3A/' iB 5eports are that the patta lands originally belonged to bac*ward and most bac*ward classes& +he purchase of lands seems to have started before his appointment as a udge and continued thereafter& iiB Patta lands have been bought in the name of the udge, his wife /r Kinodini, his unmarried daughters 3mudha -orkodi and 3mirtha -orkodi, one Cannan and another person, the latter two are reported to be close relatives& 8aughter Amudha Por*odi got married recently on <F&<>&>DDA& iiiB )ast e3tents of 1overnment Tporom oke( lands, 1overnment anadhinam lands, waterbodies li*e la*es, canals, streams, common village pathways and an ancient mud fortress abutting his patta lands were progressively encroached upon& ivB +he villagers were then prevented access to these common property resources& 0early ;DD families of 8alits and landless poor in the village are reported to have sought distribution of 1overnment poram oke and anandhinam lands to them as per 1&O&@$sB 0o&>=< dated <>&DE&>DD; issued by the /tate 1overnment& +hey are yet to receive the assignment& vB "mmediately thereafter, these common ,government lands were fenced in by the udge& +here is every possibility that after this representation, the fence around the encroached areas may be removed& But as on today, the fence e3ists around the 1overnment lands and village common resources, and we write this after some of us personally inspected the fence and the relevant records and maps& +he fact remains that the common village lands near the udge(s property are out of bounds for the villagers& )nquiry re(eals that the local police is used to pre(ent access to the area ivB +he 1overnment anadhinam lands are meant to be assigned only to landless poor for small holdings and personal cultivation as per standing orders of the board of revenue, +amil 0adu 1overnment& vB +he 1overnment poram oke lands also are meant for common en oyment of the villagers and cannot be occupied by any individual& 6nder a recent scheme of the /tate 1overnment, they can be distributed to the landless poor& viB +he water:bodies too are meant only for common en oyment of the villagers& viiB By erecting a fence the udge has deprived the local villagers access to common property resources of the village, on which many of them depend for their livelihood& viiiB +he villagers are not able to have access to the water bodies and due to e3tensive use of water for the udge(s farm where there are huge fruit orchards and other cultivations, the water source for the village has got depleted& Large bore wells, open wells are said to have been dug inside the farm&

i3B "t is reported that the entire village administration and government machinery has been e3ploited to provide facilities and free labour for the udge(s property& "t is reliably learnt that the udge is attempting to manipulate revenue records to obtain pattas for the public and government lands in his occupation& 3B "t is an open secret in legal circles that the udicial officers and staff of the udiciary are often as*ed to supervise and facilitate the maintenance and up*eep of the farm& 3iB We have specific reports that anyone who see*s any information li*e survey numbers and e3tent regarding even the village common lands and 1overnment lands is intimidated and not provided the information& )illagers are under mortal fear in this regard& 3iiB .ven the village road that leads to the property has been named as T0eethi /rasar P&8& 8ina*aran Saalai((& @!.mperor of 2ustice, P&8& 8ina*aran road# B $ L3A/S 'A ->>K3L3' K'LL30) +he udge is also reported to possess more than FD acres of lands with mango orchards in Poovalai )illage, 1ummidipoondi talu*, )ellore district, +amil 0adu& -e has been seen visiting the orchard periodically& % L3A/ K3L.) +he mar*et value of these properties are in the range of about >D:>F la*hs per acre& "t appears that the land holding is of an e3tent of appro3imately FFD acres& "t needs to be ascertained whether the udge has filed returns before the ta3 authorities in respect of these properties& "t also needs to be verified if these disclosures of these assets has been made, and updated, as per the <EES resolution regarding the declaration of udge(s assets& VVV .+F3A -+>-)+;? iB On the plot bearing 8oor 0o&>A, .ast Par* 5oad@ unction of Pulla Avenue and .ast Par* streetB, Shenoy 0agar, 'hennai Q ;DD DLD allegedly owned by the udge, an office,commercial construction has been put up consisting of stilt plus F floors, ma*ing it a multi:storeyed building under the development control rules& -aving regard to the dimensions of the plot, fire safety re?uirements, etc, under the development control rules, construction of such a multi:storeyed building is illegal& +his is a newly constructed building and he was fre?uently observed at the site to chec* the construction& iiB +he udge has been observed a number of times to be supervising the construction of a building at 2 Q A<, " $ain 5oad, 3nna 0agar .ast, 'hennai Q ;DD <D>& -is involvement in this immovable property and source of funding needs to be ascertained& iiiB "n Ara**onam +own, the residential building T/n agam( @a residential building said to be owned by $r 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aranB was recently renovated& "t reportedly encroaches on the main road by <D feet& VVV '' 'A3--+>-+'3;) ,./'C'3L >+/)+S 'A C)+;3'A C3S)S # ,./04)A; 'A F'AA? L;/

Finny Ltd& was a B"C5 company but subse?uently came out of it& "t had e3tremely valuable immovable properties situated in the heart of the 'ity& +hese were directed to be auctioned by 2ustice 8ina*aran at LFW of the guideline value& Appro3imately <,>;D grounds of land @about SD acresB situated in Perambur was sold to //" Ltd& for ust 5s ;; crore& At that time, the guideline value was almost 5s <AD crore and the actual mar*et value was even higher& +he promoters of //" Ltd who had purchased the land from Binny Ltd were subse?uently involved in e3tensive rigging of their shares& +he assessments of these promoters were reopened under /ec <=A, "ncome +a3 Act, <E;<& "t is reported that the demand was to the tune of more than 5s F> crore& /i3 writ petitions were filed challenging the reopening of the assessment under /ec <=A& +he writ petitions were heard by 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran& +he udgment is reported in >SE "+5 ;SE& 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran falsely stated that a !concession# was made by the counsel for the "ncome +a3 department& +his was ob ected to by the counsel after receiving the copy of the order& 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran promised to e3punge those sentences that referred to the alleged concession but this was not done& Last wee*, the writ appeals filed by the department against this order have been allowed by the division bench presided by 2ustice @ 4 'brahim Jali5ullah& +he standing counsel for the "ncome +a3 8epartment offered to file an affidavit stating that she never conceded and also referred to the oral representation to 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran& +he division bench has allowed the si3 writ appeals by imposing costs of 5s&<D,DDD each& <& On <A:DL:>DDE, the *he *imes of India, Bangalore edition, carried the following report 4 CJ ea+s spee+- +isposa o# bai F3A03L>+)4 In a spe!ial drive to prevent penden!y of !ases, the High .ourt on *uesday disposed of numerous ail appli!ations out of around 122 petitions in a re!ord time# 3a!h ail plea was dealt with in a out 12 se!onds# .hief -usti!e P#D# Dinakaran himself disposed of 45 !ases in 62 minutes y granting ail 7some !onditional8 in all of them# *he rapid fire se9uen!e went something like this: ;hat is the !harge 7se!tion8< ;hat stage is the trial< .ompleted or not< .hargesheet has een filed< $inal report su mitted# &ail granted# *he !ases were marginal and some pertain to !harges of rape, theft, murder and da!oity in!luding 6asa,th Sa ia,, a!!used in .hemmanur -ewellers da!oity !ase# *he .hief -usti!e and five %udges heard these !ases etween 4 and 4#4= p#m#> *he mem ers of the &angalore &ar state that while minor !ases were allo!ated to the other -udges, the ones posted efore .hief -usti!e P#D# Dinakaran in!luded !ases of persons !harged with serious !rimes under the Indian Penal .ode and also those who had serious !ases filed against them y the 3nfor!ement Department# &ail was granted in all these !ases# It is further stated that this was a one?time disposal drive# *his matter needs to e investigated to as!ertain the names of the a!!used and the gravity of the offen!es# <& Another matter of concern raised by the Bangalore Bar pertains to cases of illegal mining filed against several influential persons& +hese were transferred from the 8harwad circuit bench which was hearing these matters to the 'hief 2ustice(s bench& <& 7et another matter related to the mining lobby which wanted to ac?uire F=D acres of forest land& +he /tate 1overnment had granted leases in respect of LAD acres of forest land& +his was set aside by a single udge of the -igh 'ourt who pointed out several illegalities on the part of the /tate 1overnment including that some applicants had filed applications after the date of the opening of the tender& +he writ appeal order passed by 'hief 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran granted licenses to all the applicants and even increased the area allotted over and above what was granted by the 1overnment& +he issues pointed out by the single udge were not dealt with& +his is a matter which has greatly agitated the Bangalore Bar&

''' Aumber -late o5 Chie5 ,ustice - / /inakaran6s Car 7 Contrary to 4otor Kehicles 3ct 'hief 2ustice P&8&8ina*aran, *nown to misuse office to e3hibit pomp and grandeur, had the number plate of his official car @KA:DL:1A:FS;SB done up in red bac*ground with gold embossed letters& +his is permitted under the motor vehicles rules only for the President of "ndia and /tate 1overnors& .ven the Prime $inister and the 'hief 2ustice of "ndia cannot use such a number plate& +here were adverse news reports in leading newspapers on this issue @,id?Day dated >E&D;&>DDEB& VVV >ur 3ppeal We are greatly saddened that we are forced to impugn the conduct of a holder of high udicial officeG we are doing so only in the larger interests of the institution of the udiciary which is sacred and since the increasing reports against the udge have assumed alarming proportions& 'onscious of our responsibility not to lightly bring any udge to disrepute, we have e3ercised due diligence to verify the allegations to the best of the means available to us, including visits to some of the concerned properties& -owever as private citi%ens and members of the Bar we have severe limitations to call for information and to investigate these matters& "n fact there are reports against $r& 2ustice P&8& 8ina*aran of irregular ac?uisition of properties elsewhere, permitting illegal appointments, favouritism and other improprieties in the discharge of udicial and administrative functions as a udge of the -igh 'ourt& +he information we have gathered so far is reliable and does not permit us to let it pass without calling for urgent attention and appropriate action by the /upreme 'ourt and other 'onstitutional functionaries& We also wish to convey the fear e3pressed by the villagers in Kaverira apuram, all of whom are greatly apprehensive of the severe reprisals and conse?uences if they spea* out& "n fact, after spea*ing to them we ourselves are greatly an3ious for their safety& "t also is evident that the entire administrative machinery has been intimidated by the udge, as no official is willing to respond to any ?ueries regarding the village properties, including innocuous ?uestions li*e details about government lands& +he allegations set out above are strongly suggestive of abuse of office and corruption amounting to grave udicial misconduct& As the matter involves the head of the /tate udiciary in Karnata*a, it is one of immense gravity and calls for immediate investigation and action& When a udge(s reputation is clouded in such adverse reports, his elevation to the highest 'ourt of our country portends grave conse?uences for the udiciary itself& +his case also e3poses the shortcomings of the present procedure adopted for choosing udges for appointment to the higher udiciary and underscores the urgent need to put in place a udicial commission which will have a more democratic and transparent functioning to enable the choice of persons of impeccable integrity and calibre to dispense ustice& We, as responsible members of the Bar, duty bound to safeguard the independence of the 2udiciary, feel impelled in these circumstances to re?uest you 8i: not to appoint 4r ,ustice - / /inakaran as judge o5 the Supreme Court o5 'ndiaE and 8ii: initiate a thorough enquiry into all the allegations against 4r ,ustice - / /inakaran, Chie5 ,ustice o5 Jarnataka *igh Court and take appropriate action therea5ter We re?uest you to act on our representation in public interest, as otherwise the confidence of the public in the ma esty of law will be sha*en&

7ours truly + Kaigai, Sriram -anchu, J + ;amiChmani, 3nna 4athew, S S Kasude(an, 0eetha +amaseshan, Sudha +amalingam, A L +ajah, / Aagasaila, S /e(ikarani, ; 4ohan

......................D"C*$R$T5ON((.......(((((((

Na8e # ...........................N$%$R$&$.'.R. $!!ress # ...................*5%-1 / +<0 6 =9DCO F5RST ST$%" 6 O:: W$T"R WOR>S OFF5C" 6 *$>S='5>$NT$N$%$R 6 ="??$* 6 '@SOR" A+..0+ 5ND5$ :rofessional / Tra!e Title # S.O.S - e B Clarion Of Dalit :erio!i4ity # W"">*@ Cir4ulation # FOR FR"" D5STR5?9T5ON ON W"? Donations # NOT $CC":T"D. Self finan4ing . Ne er a44epte! any !onations 6 subs4riptions either for oursel es or on behalf of other organiCations / in!i i!uals . 'onetary %ains # nil 6 ne er 8a!e any 8onetary gain by way of a! ertise8ents on 8y websites or web news paper or otherwise. Owner/"!itor/:rinter/:ublisher # N$%$R$&$.'.R. Nationality # 5ND5$N ?o!y Donation # :hysi4al ?o!y of Nagara3a ' R 6 "!itor 6 S.O.S- e B 4larion of Dalit & S.O.S-e-)oi4e for &usti4e is !onate! to &SS 'e!i4al College 6 'ysore D Donation No. 0<+ !ate! 11 / 0. / 1..2 E 6 5n 4ase of either 9nnatural !eath or Natural Death at the han!s of 4ri8inal neFus 6 8y bo!y 8ust be han!e! o er to &SS 'e!i4al College 6 'ysore for the stu!y purposes of 8e!i4al stu!ents. "ye Donation # ?oth "@"S of Nagara3a ' R 6 "!itor 6 S.O.S- e B 4larion of Dalit & S.O.S-e-)oi4e for &usti4e are !onate! to 'ysore "ye ?ank 6 'ysore 6 5n 4ase of either 9nnatural !eath or Natural Death at the han!s of 4ri8inal neFus 6 8y eyes 8ust be han!e! o er to 'ysore "ye ?ank 6 'ysore W5T=5N < =ours for i88e!iate eye transplantation to the nee!y.=o8e page # http://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/Home ,

http://groups.google.co.in/group/e-clarion-of-dalit , http://e-clarionofdalit.blogspot.com/ , http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/e-clarionofdalit/

Conta4t # naghrwGyahoo.4o8 6 nagara3hrwGhot8ail.4o8

6

95D $a!haar No # A+.2 A22- 2,+Cell # . -2,0H1.202

5 6N$%$R$&$.'.R. hereby !o !e4lare that infor8ation gi en abo e are true to the best of 8y knowle!ge & belief. 5f i a8 repeate!ly 4alle! to poli4e station or else where for the sake of in estigations 6 the losses i !o in4urr as a result like loss of wages 6 transportation 6 3ob 6 et4 8ust be borne by the go ern8ent. pre oiusly the poli4e / 5? personnel repeate!ly 4alle! 8e the 4o8plainant Dsufferer of in3usti4esE to poli4e station for 7uestioning 6 but ne er 4alle! the guilty 4ulprits e en on4e to poli4e station for 7uestioning 6 as the 4ulprits are high & 8ighty . this type of one si!e! 7uestioning 8ust not be !one by poli4e or in estigating agen4ies . if anything untowar! happens to 8e or to 8y fa8ily 8e8bers like loss of 3ob 6 8eeting with hit & run a44i!ents 6 loss of li es 6 !eath !ue to i8proper 8e!i4al 4are 6 et4 6 the 3uris!i4tional poli4e together with abo e 8entione! a44usse! publi4 ser ants will be responsible for it. " en if 4ri8inal neFus le els fake 4harges 6 poli4e file fake 4ases against 8e or 8y !epen!ents to silen4e 8e 6 this 4o8plaint is & will be effe4ti e. 5f 5 or 8y fa8ily 8e8bers or 8y !epen!ents are !enie! our fun!a8ental rights 6 hu8an rights 6 !enie! proper 8e!i4al 4are for oursel es 6 5f anything untowar! happens to 8e or to 8y !epen!ents or to 8y fa8ily 8e8bers - 5n su4h 4ase Chief &usti4e of 5n!ia together with the 3uris!i4tional re enue & poli4e offi4ials will be responsible for it 6 in su4h 4ase the go ern8ent of in!ia is liable to pay Rs. TWO 4rore as 4o8pensation to sur i ors of 8y fa8ily. if 8y whole fa8ily is eli8inate! by the 4ri8inal neFus 6then that 4o8pensation 8oney 8ust be !onate! to 5n!ian $r8y Welfare Fun!. $fterwar!s 6 the 8oney 8ust be re4o ere! by %O5 as lan! arrears fro8 the salary 6 pension 6 property 6 et4 of guilty poli4e offi4ials 6 &u!ges 6 publi4 ser ants & Constitutional fu4tionaries. !ate # 1A.00.1.02((((((((((..@ourIs sin4erely6 pla4e # 5n!ia(((((((((((((...Nagara3a.'.R.

e!ite! 6 printe! 6 publishe! & owne! by N$%$R$&$.'.R. G # *5%-1 / +<0 6 =9DCO F5RST ST$%" 6 O:: W$T"R WOR>S OFF5C" 6 *$>S='5>$NT$N$%$R 6="??$* 6'@SOR" A+..0+ 5ND5$

4ell # -0 -2,0H1.202 ho8e page# http#//sites.google.4o8/site/e4larionof!alit/=o8e 6 http#//groups.google.4o.in/group/e-4larion-of-!alit 6 http#//e-4larionof!alit.blogspot.4o8/ 6 http#//in.groups.yahoo.4o8/group/e-4larionof!alit/ 6

http#//paper.li/f-02<+-2H<+,

6

Conta4t # naghrwGyahoo.4o8 6 nagara3hrwGhot8ail.4o8 6 http#//www.a8nesty.org/en/user/naghrw $ 'e8ber of $8nesty 5nternational