You are on page 1of 35

# Determinarea parametrilor principali

P
H
A

m
v

15000000
12
150
0.9
0.975
0.98

randamentul hidraulic
h

0.94191523

debitul turbinei
Q
141.578888
inaltimea barometrica
Hb
9.92333333

Pcp

pv/g

0.24

1
1

inaltimea de aspiratie
Hs

-2.07667

rapiditatea turbinei
nscr
746.899407
ns

687.147455

n'

107.451236

20400
numar de perechi de poli
p'

27.9196416 p

n
ns

107.142857
685.17538

28

Dimensionare turbinei

## metoda dorin pavel

a0'
a1
a2
b'
db
Db'

0.885679796
0.764059693
0.741492554
0.391758549
0.42363511
2.299989151

ns
ku1
ku2
ku3
kub
ko
b=B0/D1
Qc/Q

metode/marimi
D.P
T
marimi finale

600
1.6
1.63
1.66
0.73
0.322
0.382
0.95

D0'
D1
D2
B0
Db

metoda thomann
700
1.77
1.8
1.82
0.75
0.334
0.41
0.97

D0'
5.662140927
4.7

5.662140927
4.884624981
4.740353519
2.218192114
2.069298643

ns
ku1
ku2
ku3
kub
k0
b=B0/D1
Qc/Q

685.1753803
1.744798147
1.774798147
1.796280609
0.747035076
0.332221046
0.405849106
0.967035076

D0
D1
D2
D3
4.884624981 4.740353519
4.801699525 4.772467218 4.854524857 4.913285
4.2
4.1
4.05
4.1

Db/D1

0.43902439

D1
D2
D3
Db
Bo
Do

4.772467
4.854525
4.913285
2.043331
1.936902
4.8017

Db
Db'
B0
2.069299 2.299989 2.218192
2.043331
1.936902
1.8
2
1.8

D
D

3.505234181
2.78627589

m
m

Diametre
m

A
4.1

B
3.802617091

C
3.145755036

E
2.293137945

Raza
m

A
2.05

B
1.901308545

C
1.572877518

E
1.146568972

u.m
m
m/s
m/s
m/s
m/s
m/s
m/s

m/s

A
2.05
23.00094621
13.28399695
4.820769527
0
22.51629186
26.56140248
36.16
30.00820933
6.15
24.50379146
32.82807761
1.287719795
0.022478735
0.645149817
0.949431294
3.22013247
2.168245151
0.709203881
0.756201399
1.066267993
4
57.17192239
1.410031765
1.67
0.58
1.821370016
0.585420855
4404
0.053
1.252673473
0.031027305
2.797722052
27.52807761

B
1.901308545
21.33263199
13.28399695
5.197776844
0
20.89971592
25.13057426
39.46
31.9108451
7.55
22.96557692
35.34024875
1.140237824
0.019903532
0.709094629
0.940883026
2.986568479
2.01097709
0.715647258
0.863887759
1.207141856
6
54.65975125
1.397336451
1.62
0.48
1.737984546
0.694564206
4406
0.046
1.208156752
0.031949953
-5.621698392
30.74024875

C
1.572877518
17.64764448
13.28399695
6.283119581
0
17.48190496
22.0885475
49.45
36.97005095
12.48
19.66954672
42.48200144
0.741983025
0.012950771
0.915753439
0.912072129
2.470670227
1.663601976
0.738253409
1.202040806
1.628222492
8
47.51799856
1.354548435
1.53
0.43
1.670520894
0.974679513
4408
0.018
0.800817441
0.017544231
-7.346794972
40.68200144

a doua iteratie
Marime
R
u
Cm
C1
C2
W1
W2
1
2
1-2
W

tg
tg
cos
t
desimea
(l/t)x
Cp*l/t
Cp
d/l
lambda
t/l
k
K
Kr
Cp0
profil
tg(citit)
(calculat)
Cr
(eroarea)
o

m
-

NACA
%

i
l

naca 4404
x[%]
y0/l
yu/l

x
y0
yu

5.3
2.283730444

4.6
2.137329544

1.8
1.823980718

0
0.0222
0.0222

1.25
0.0296
0.017

2.5
0.0331
0.0157

5
0.0382
0.0145

0
0.050698816
0.050698816

0.028546631
0.067598421
0.038823418

0.057093261
0.075591478
0.035854568

0.114186522
0.087238503
0.033114091

0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-0.05

0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8

naca 4406
x[%]
y0/l
yu/l

0
0.0222
0.0222

1.25
0.0328
0.0138

2.5
0.0374
0.0113

5
0.0442
0.0086

naca4406
x
y0
yu

0
0.047448716
0.047448716

0.026716619
0.070104409
0.029495148

0.053433239
0.079936125
0.024151824

0.106866477
0.094469966
0.018381034

0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-0.05 0

naca 4408

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

x[%]
y0/l
yu/l
x
y0
yu

0
0.0222
0.0222

1.25
0.0359
0.0107

2.5
0.0418
0.0069

5
0.0501
0.0027

0
0.040492372
0.040492372

0.022799759
0.065480908
0.019516594

0.045599518
0.076242394
0.012585467

0.091199036
0.091381434
0.004924748

0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-0.05

naca 4410
x[%]
y0/l
yu/l
x
y0
yu

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

0
0.0222
0.0222

1.25
0.0391
0.0075

2.5
0.0462
0.0026

5
0.056
-0.0032

0
0.032547422
0.032547422

0.018326251
0.057324513
0.010995751

0.036652502
0.067733824
0.00381186

0.073305004
0.082101605
-0.00469152

0.2

0.3

0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.25

0.35

-0.05

naca4412
x[%]
y0/l
yu/l

0
0.0222
0.0222

1.25
0.0423
0.0044

2.5
0.0505
-0.0018

5
0.0619
-0.0092

x
y0
yu

0
0.031384511
0.031384511

0.017671459
0.059800216
0.006220353

0.035342917
0.071392693
-0.00254469

0.070685835
0.087509063
-0.013006194

0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
-0.05

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

idiu profa

dmbucur

F
1.8

F
0.9

E
1.146568972
12.86447379
13.28399695
8.619261264
0
13.94583824
18.49214051
72.28
45.91916826
26.36
15.80031381
57.21861988
0.640193823
0.011173955
1.552804266
0.827162981
1.80102633
1.212703714
0.814035896
2.038418351
2.504089022
10
32.78138012
1.228447056
1.37
0.38
1.537780696
1.628378499
4410
0.012
0.602320859
0.019540542
6.287838683
56.01861988

F
0.9
10.09797639
13.28399695
10.9806417
0
13.31328934
16.68633279
-86.20
52.75931927
-138.96
14.06040769
70.87050732
0.741983025
0.012950771
2.883027354
0.706853263
1.413716694
0.951912505
1
2.910298918
2.910298918
12
19.12949268
1
1.08
0.348
1.348
2.158975458
4412
0.015
0.709947103
0.032384632
4.51243792
69.27050732

Conditii
C1
1-2

<
<

u
22'-23'

1.057681

1.2
1.466100083

1.6
1.413716694

7.5
0.0423
0.0143

0.171279783
0.096601798
0.032657345

10
0.0456
0.0144

7.50
0.0493
0.0073

0.65

0.7

0.75

20
0.0547
0.0164

## 0.228373044 0.34256 0.456746

0.104138108 0.116242 0.12492
0.032885718 0.034713 0.037453

0.160299716
0.105370347
0.015602506

15
0.0509
0.0152

30
0.0589
0.0189

35
0.0596
0.0199

40
0.0593
0.0207

## 0.570932611 0.685119 0.799306 0.913492

0.130857754 0.134512 0.13611 0.135425
0.040422029 0.043163 0.045446 0.047273

1.05 1.1 1.15 1.2 1.25 1.3 1.35 1.4 1.45 1.5 1.55 1.6 1.65 1.7 1.75 1.8 1.85

10
0.0534
0.0066

15
0.0598
0.0063

20
0.0642
0.0069

## 0.213732954 0.320599 0.427466

0.114133398 0.127812 0.137217
0.014106375 0.013465 0.014748

0.8

25
0.0573
0.0177

0.85

0.9

0.95

1.05

1.1

25
0.0672
0.0078

30
0.0689
0.0089

35
0.0695
0.01

40
0.069
0.011

## 0.534332386 0.641199 0.748065 0.854932

0.143628545 0.147262 0.148544 0.147476
0.01667117 0.019022 0.021373 0.023511

1.15

1.2

1.25

1.3

1.35

1.4

1.45

1.5

1.55

7.5
0.0563
0.0003

10
0.0612
-0.0012

15
0.0687
-0.0026

20
0.0738
-0.0027

## 0.136798554 0.182398072 0.273597 0.364796

0.102690114
0.11162762 0.125307 0.13461
0.000547194 -0.002188777 -0.00474 -0.00492

0.5

0.55

0.6

7.5
0.0633
-0.0067

0.65

0.7

10
0.069
-0.009

0.75

0.8

0.85

15
0.0776
-0.0115

0.9

0.4

0.45

7.5
0.0703
-0.0137

0.5

10
0.0768
-0.0168

0.55

0.6

15
0.0865
-0.0204

0.65

20
0.0929
-0.0218

30
0.0789
-0.0011

35
0.0794
0.0001

40
0.0787
0.0013

## 0.45599518 0.547194 0.638393 0.729592

0.140628913 0.143912 0.144824 0.143547
-0.00383036 -0.00201 0.000182 0.002371

0.95

20
0.0834
-0.0123

## 0.109957506 0.146610008 0.219915 0.29322

0.092804135 0.101160906 0.113769 0.122273
-0.00982287 -0.013194901 -0.01686 -0.01803

0.35

25
0.0771
-0.0021

1.05

25
0.087
-0.012

1.1

30
0.0889
-0.0111

1.15

1.2

35
0.0893
-0.0098

1.25

1.3

40
0.0884
-0.0084

## 0.366525021 0.43983 0.513135 0.58644

0.127550707 0.130336 0.130923 0.129603
-0.017593201 -0.01627 -0.01437 -0.01232

0.7

0.75

25
0.0969
-0.0219

0.8

30
0.0989
-0.0211

0.85

35
0.0992
-0.0198

0.9

40
0.098
-0.018

0.95

0.106028752
0.099384284
-0.01936792

0.35

0.4

## 0.141371669 0.212058 0.282743

0.108573442 0.122286 0.131334
-0.02375044 -0.02884 -0.03082

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

## 0.353429174 0.424115 0.494801 0.565487

0.136989148 0.139817 0.140241 0.138544
-0.030960396 -0.02983 -0.02799 -0.02545

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

0.85

0.9

prima iteratie

z=

Marime
u.m
R
m
u
m/s
Cm
m/s
C1
m/s
C2
m/s
W1
m/s
W2
m/s
1

1-2

W
m/s

tg
tg
cos
t
m
desimea
(l/t)x
Cp*l/t
Cp
d/l
lambda

t/l
k
K
Kr
Cp0
profil
NACA
tg(citit)
(calculat)
Cr
(eroarea)
%
o
i

A
2.05
42.9351
8.599431
4.787292
0
39.10506
43.78782
12.7035
11.32586
1.377647
41.44345
11.97577
1
0.017455
0.212115
0.949431
3.220132
2.168245
0.709204
0.251907
0.355198
4
78.02423
1.410032
1.67
0.58
1.82137
0.195017
4404
0.06
1.28772
0.011701
-22.3434
5.975765
6

B
1.901309
39.82091
8.599431
5.161681
0
35.71012
40.73887
13.93448
12.18604
1.74844
38.22006
13.00275
2
0.034921
0.230919
0.940883
2.986568
2.010977
0.715647
0.318434
0.44496
6
76.99725
1.397336
1.62
0.476
1.737985
0.25602
4406
0.038
1.140238
0.009729
75.402
9.20275
3.8

45
0.0583
0.0211

50
0.0565
0.0212

55
0.054
0.021

60
0.0508
0.0203

65
0.0468
0.0193

70
0.0422
0.0178

75
0.0369
0.0159

80
0.031
0.0135

85
0.0243
0.0107

## 1.027679 1.141865 1.256052 1.370238 1.484425 1.598611 1.712798 1.826984 1.941171

0.133141 0.129031 0.123321 0.116014 0.106879 0.096373 0.08427 0.070796 0.055495
0.048187 0.048415 0.047958 0.04636 0.044076 0.04065 0.036311 0.03083 0.024436

Series2
Series3
1.85 1.9 1.95

45
0.0676
0.0118

50
0.0654
0.0124

55
0.0623
0.0127

60
0.0584
0.0127

65
0.0537
0.0124

70
0.0483
0.0117

75
0.0422
0.0106

80
0.0353
0.0091

85
0.0278
0.0072

## 0.961798 1.068665 1.175531 1.282398 1.389264 1.496131 1.602997 1.709864 1.81673

0.144483 0.139781 0.133156 0.12482 0.114775 0.103233 0.090195 0.075448 0.059418
0.02522 0.026503 0.027144 0.027144 0.026503 0.025007 0.022656 0.01945 0.015389

Series1
1.55

1.6

1.65

1.7

1.75

1.8

1.85

1.9

1.95

2.05

2.1

2.15

2.2

2.25 Series2

45
0.0769
0.0025

50
0.0742
0.0036

55
0.0705
0.0045

60
0.066
0.0051

65
0.0606
0.0055

70
0.0544
0.0056

75
0.0475
0.0053

80
0.0397
0.0047

85
0.0312
0.0038

## 0.820791 0.91199 1.003189 1.094388 1.185587 1.276787 1.367986 1.459185 1.550384

0.140264 0.135339 0.128591 0.120383 0.110533 0.099225 0.086639 0.072412 0.056908
0.00456 0.006566 0.008208 0.009302 0.010032 0.010214 0.009667 0.008573 0.006931

Series1
Series2
1.3

1.35

1.4

45
0.0862
-0.0068

1.45

50
0.083
-0.0052

1.5

1.55

55
0.0788
-0.0038

1.6

60
0.0736
-0.0025

1.65

1.7

65
0.0675
-0.0014

1.75

1.8

70
0.0605
-0.0005

1.85

75
0.0527
0.0001

1.9

1.95

80
0.0441
0.0004

85
0.0346
0.0004

## 0.659745 0.73305 0.806355 0.87966 0.952965 1.02627 1.099575 1.17288 1.246185

0.126378 0.121686 0.115529 0.107905 0.098962 0.088699 0.077263 0.064655 0.050727
-0.00997 -0.00762 -0.00557 -0.00367 -0.00205 -0.00073 0.000147 0.000586 0.000586

0.95

45
0.0955
-0.0161

1.05

50
0.0918
-0.0141

1.1

55
0.087
-0.012

1.15

60
0.0812
-0.0101

1.2

1.25

65
0.0744
-0.0083

1.3

70
0.0666
-0.0066

1.35

75
0.058
-0.0052

1.4

80
0.0485
-0.004

1.45

85
0.038
-0.003

1.5

## 0.636173 0.706858 0.777544 0.84823 0.918916 0.989602 1.060288 1.130973 1.201659

0.13501 0.129779 0.122993 0.114794 0.105181 0.094154 0.081996 0.068565 0.053721
-0.02276 -0.01993 -0.01696 -0.01428 -0.01173 -0.00933 -0.00735 -0.00565 -0.00424

0.95

1.05

1.1

1.15

1.2

1.25

1.3

1.35

1.4

1.45

1.5

C
1.572878
32.94227
8.599431
6.239487
0
28.05332
34.04619
17.85076
14.63031
3.220454
31.03761
16.0851
3
0.052408
0.288354
0.912072
2.47067
1.663602
0.738253
0.491684
0.66601
8
73.9149
1.354548
1.53
0.428
1.670521
0.398684
4408
0.016
0.741983
0.006379
304.3219
14.4851
1.6

E
1.146569
24.01368
8.599431
8.559405
0
17.68573
25.507
29.09346
19.70272
9.390737
21.52627
23.54601
4
0.069927
0.435768
0.827163
1.801026
1.212704
0.814036
0.947872
1.164411
10
66.45399
1.228447
1.37
0.38
1.537781
0.757202
4410
0.013
0.640194
0.009844
524.8108
22.24601
1.3

F
0.9
18.84956
8.599431
10.90439
0
11.70794
20.71849
47.2646
24.52313
22.74147
15.91978
32.69539
5
0.087489
0.641875
0.706853
1.413717
0.951913
1
1.587136
1.587136
12
57.30461
1
1.08
0.348
1.348
1.177401
4412
0.016
0.741983
0.018838
573.8699
31.09539
1.6

90
0.017
0.0074

95
0.0091
0.0037

100
0.0004
-0.0004

## 2.055357 2.169544 2.28373

0.038823 0.020782 0.000913
0.0169 0.00845 -0.00091

90
0.0195
0.005

95
0.0104
0.0024

100
0.0006
-0.0006

## 1.923597 2.030463 2.13733

0.041678 0.022228 0.001282
0.010687 0.00513 -0.00128

90
0.0219
0.0026

95
0.0118
0.001

100
0.0008
-0.0008

## 1.641583 1.732782 1.823981

0.039945 0.021523 0.001459
0.004742 0.001824 -0.00146

Series1
Series2

90
0.0243
0.0002

95
0.0131
-0.0003

100
0.001
-0.001

1.31949 1.392795
1.4661
0.035626 0.019206 0.001466
0.000293 -0.00044 -0.00147

Series1
Series2
1.5

1.55

90
0.0267
-0.002

95
0.0145
-0.0017

100
0.0013
-0.0013

## 1.272345 1.343031 1.413717

0.037746 0.020499 0.001838
-0.00283
-0.0024 -0.00184

Series1
Series2
1.5

Nd

24

D1
D0
B0

t0'

0.615229

D0'

lo
d/lo

0.738274
0.14

0.012403

k=tg=
=

1.364004
53.75353

4.1
4.1
1.8
4.7

n=
Q=
Pcp=

## calculul scheletului palei drectoare

Ro

2.05

m

xo
x
y

0
0
0

-5
-2
-0.08727 -0.03491
1.819948 1.954681

0
2
5
10
0 0.034907 0.087266 0.174533
2.05 2.149967 2.309132 2.601019

0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.073827 0.147655 0.221482 0.29531 0.369137 0.442965
0.006202 0.016537 0.028419 0.040508 0.051679 0.060762

107.1429
141.5789
20400

15
20
25
30
0.261799 0.349066 0.436332 0.523599
2.929803 3.300147 3.717304 4.187193

0.7
0.8
0.9
1
0.516792 0.590619 0.664447 0.738274
0.066311 0.066149 0.055814
0

p=

Q= 141.5789 m/s
A=
150 mdMN
H=
12 m
=
1000 kg/m
g=
9.81 m/s
m=
4 canale
Nd=
24 pale
B0=
1.8 m
Patm= 99702.3 Pa

Pct
um
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15

nj
m
0.05
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.07
0.07
0.08
0.11
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.062

Lpala=

117720 Pa
0.6058 m

masurata pe desen

Fi= 128366.6 N
ai=
m
Mi=
Nm

lj
m
0.10
0.11
0.11
0.11
0.10
0.12
0.01
0.10
0.10
0.10
0.11
0.11
0.11
0.07
0.0389

Xi=
Yi=

cj
m/s
15.76
26.09
23.21
17.66
12.17
11.12
9.78
7.80
14.98
17.10
15.82
12.21
10.20
9.01
13.21488

Pj
Pa
93293.42
-123002
-51935.8
61523.22
143317
155628.6
169626.3
186978.4
105245
71134.37
92333.05
142874.6
165369
176801.2
130105.8

-134398
-86390.5

aj
m
0.161
0.060
0.025
0.124
0.216
0.321
0.392
0.141
0.127
0.036
0.060
0.161
0.252
0.369
0.02

Xe= 44300.34
Ye= 26927.14

Fint= 159769.3 N
Fext= 51841.98 N
i= 32.73267
e= 31.29255
FHx=
FHy=

Fj
N
17397.4
-24420.8
-10376.8
12126.2
26209.8
32243.1
1893.0
34632.1
19777.6
12817.0
18581.1
28057.7
32147.7
23709.0
9110.0

-63159
-91304.5

FH= 111020.6

masurata pe desen

Mj
Nm
2794.016
-1475.01
-254.231
1503.652
5658.698
10337.15
741.3104
4865.814
2509.783
458.8483
1116.724
4520.096
8091.584
8751.007
182.2002

79
57
40
35
29
30
40
176
206
204
202
227
226
225
304

Xj
N
3319.572
-13300.5
-7949.08
9933.223
22923.62
27923.36
1450.145
-34547.8
-17776
-11708.9
-17228.1
-19135.3
-22331.7
-16764.8
5094.253

Yj
N
17077.72
-20481
-6670.07
6955.318
12706.77
16121.56
1216.816
2415.815
-8669.95
-5213.14
-6960.6
-20520.1
-23125.1
-16764.8
-7552.54

Ns=Nd=
Ro=
Ro'=
Ro"=

R1=
R2=
R3=

24

pale

2.925
3.3181
3.5826

m
m
m

0.6576
0.13152
0.4384

Rse= 3.71412
Rsi= 4.15252
k=tgo= 1.364004

Rse'=

3.71412

m

-5
-0.08727
3.29732

si= 0.081799

-2
-0.03491
3.541425
~

ls= 0.543445

x/ls
/d
x

0
0
3.71412

2
5
7.025
4.686714
0.034907 0.087266 0.122606 0.081799
3.895237 4.183606 4.390211 4.15252

4.686714
d= 0.081517

BA

0.1
0.2
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.808
0.945
0.995
1
0.995
0.925
0.83
0.692
0.054344 0.108689 0.163033 0.190206 0.217378 0.271722 0.326067 0.380411
0.065866 0.077033 0.081109 0.081517 0.081109 0.075403 0.067659 0.05641
0.032933 0.038517 0.040555 0.040758 0.040555 0.037701 0.033829 0.028205
ra= 0.020379
rf= 0.010597

BF
0.8
0.9
0.555
0.4
0.434756 0.4891
0.045242 0.032607
0.022621 0.016303

148.6578 m/s

Q=
ki

Bo=

2.44

Rsi=

4.15252

0.24

ci=

4.510212

max=

210

Interpolare pentru H
H(m)
ki

10
0.24

Qmax= 86.71705
Smax= 19.22682

n=m
B
R
a
B/2

0
0
2.44
4.153
0.000
1.22

Bmax=

7.93

nmax=

2.745

30
60
90
120
150
180
0.392143 0.784286 1.176429 1.568571 1.960714 2.352857
3.224286 4.008571 4.792857 5.577143 6.361429 7.145714
5.049
5.594
5.961
6.225
6.424
6.579
0.896
1.442
1.809
2.072
2.271
2.426
1.612143 2.004286 2.396429 2.788571 3.180714 3.572857

210
2.745
7.93
6.703
2.551
3.965

20
0.24

H
ki

Rmax= 6.922929

6.22878

18
0.24

D1=

5.85

h=
h1=
h2=
h3=
h4=
h5=
h6=

13.455
1.053
2.34
3.2175
6.8445
7.02
3.4164

m
m
m
m
m
m
m

D3=
D4=

5.967 m
7.02 m

B5=
b5=

13.923 m
1.9071 m

L1=
L=

8.775 m
26.325 m

r=
R=
a1=
a2=
a4=

R'=
r3

4.3173
5.265
7.69275
1.35135
2.20545
10
4.095
2.9835

m
m
m
m
m

k=

0.2

Mt=

1604282 Nm

60 Mpa

D= 0.418064 m
d=

0.082 m

Verificare
=

n
P

63.61036 Mpa

0.41

200
18

Q22=
n22=

1.023858
188.0261

D1=

5.85

Efect de scara
n=
m

H=
Q22
0.978
0.1076
0.1592
0.169
m
77.00%
78.00%
79.00%
80.00%
81.00%
81.00%
80.00%
79.00%
78.00%
77.00%

77.00%
Q
133.88
121.35
113.25
107.4
95.2
29.69
28.19
26.74

0.03
.

H
Q22
n22

m
77.00%
78.00%
79.00%
80.00%
81.00%
81.00%
80.00%
79.00%
78.00%
77.00%

n
H
Q=

16
Q
133.88
14.73
21.79
23.13
H
Q
P
Q
P
Q
P
Q
P
Q
P

P
0.66
5.36
5
4.75
4.21
1.31
1.25
1.18

16
17
18
19
20
1.085965 1.053541 1.023858 0.99655 0.971317
199.4318 193.4772 188.0261 183.0111 178.3772

m
P
5.92
0.66
0.98
1.02
16
133.88
0.66
14.73
0.66

78.00%
Q
14.73
128.12
119.06
113.37
104.07
28.77
27.15
25.96

H=
Q22
0.86
0.908
0.101
0.158
0.1716
0.1788

17
Q
121.35
128.12
14.25
22.29
24.21
25.23

17
121.35
5.74
14.25
0.65
128.12
5.36

18
113.25
5.33
129.51
8.2
178.59
5.87
119.06
5

P
0.66
5.74
5.33
5.07
4.66
1.29
1.22
1.16

79.00%
Q
14.25
129.51
122.32
110.19
27.67
26.11
24.54

m
P
5.36
5.74
0.65
1.01
1.08
1.11
19
107.4
5.07
122.32
6.12
145.44
6.76
133.21
5.55
113.37
4.75

P
0.65
5.87
5.55
5
1.25
1.18
1.11

H=
Q22
0.780
0.820
0.892
1.230
0.129
0.169
0.179
0.184

18
Q
113.25
119.06
129.51
178.59
18.66
24.54
25.96
26.74

20
95.2
4.66
110.19
5.48
129.78
6.03
119.38
5
104.07
4.21

20
29.69
1.29
27.67
1.21
24.76
1.15
26.45
1.25
28.77
1.31

80.00%
Q
178.59
133.21
119.38
26.45
24.61
18.66

P
8.2
6.12
5.48
1.21
1.13
0.86

25.23
23.13

1.11
1.02

24.21
21.79

1.08
0.98

22.29
-

1.01
-

modelmax=

136.3636
18
149

m
P
5.00
5.33
5.87
8.20
0.86
1.11
1.16
1.18

H=
Q22
0.720
0.760
0.820
0.893
0.975
0.154
0.165
0.175
0.182
0.189

19
Q
107.40
113.37
122.32
133.21
145.44
22.94
24.61
26.11
27.15
28.19

19
28.19
1.22
26.11
1.13
22.94
1.07
24.61
1.18
27.15
1.25

18
26.74
1.16
24.54
0.86
18.66
1.11
25.96
1.18

17
25.23
1.08
22.29
1.01
24.21
1.11

H=
Q22
0.622
0.680
0.720
0.780
0.848
0.162
0.173
0.181
0.188
0.194

P
4.75
5.07
5.55
6.12
6.76
1.07
1.13
1.18
1.22
1.25
16
23.13
0.98
21.79
1.02

20
Q
95.20
104.07
110.19
119.38
129.78
24.76
26.45
27.67
28.77
29.69

m
P
4.21
4.66
5.00
5.48
6.03
1.15
1.21
1.25
1.29
1.31

`
81.00%
Q
145.44
129.78
24.76
22.94
-

P
6.76
6.03
1.15
1.07
-

H
16
17
18
19
20
20
19
18

17
16

#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

0.91

77.00%
P
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

Q
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

78.00%
P
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

Q
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

79.00%
P
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

Q
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

80.00%
P
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

Q
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

81.00%
P
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!

Q
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!
#REF!