You are on page 1of 18

-

John Stuart Mill



JOHN STUART MILL I:
Mill


1.
(Bentham)

.
.
, (Ricardo)
. J.S. Mill
( ).
.
( 2006), ,
. ,
,
, .
,
.

2. :

(Meikle 2001: 141)


, ,
.1 (Adam Smith)
.
, ,
.
(Rubin 1994: 220-1),
. ,
.

.

2 :
(Screpanti & Zamagni 2002: 91).
, ,
1 / 18

John Stuart Mill



,
.
, ,
, . , ,

.3 :
, () (,
) :


, ,
,
(Mill 1992: 156-7).

- (
)
.4
,
( ) ,
(
- ).

. ,
:
.

3.
( )


.5 ,
,
.

)
, , )
.
(Keynes)
2 / 18

John Stuart Mill



.

( ) ( -).
.
1 : ,
. 2:
,
(
). ,
.
1 ,
1 2 .
, ,

. ,
, ,

,
-.
(Jevons), (Edgeworth)
(Marshall). , ,

(Marshall 1956: 32).
[]:
(Marshall 1966: 162). , , .

.
,
(Heilbroner 2001:
237). , ,
, .6
(Jevons 1971: 27)
,
.
.

()
.7
.

.

3 / 18

John Stuart Mill



4.

4.1

4.1.1

,8
. 9
,

(Bentham 1988: 1).
(principle of utility),
,
,
(Bentham 1988: 2).

.
, .

. , ,

,
(Shaftesbury) (Hume), (Helvetius)
(Hutcheson).10

:11 1. .
,
. 12 2.
,
, .
. 3.
, .13

4.1.2

4 / 18

John Stuart Mill




.14
19 ,
. ,
1832 (),
( 1985: 239).
.
, ,
. , ,
(Bentham 1988:
313) .
, (probity)
(beneficence) :
(..). ,
, ,
.
, ,
(Bentham 1988: 70) Viner (1991: 159):

(.
Bentham 1988: 323).
, ,
;
(moral arithmetic felicific calculus) .
,

(Bentham 1988: 29). :15 1.

. 2.
. 3.
. 4.
-
.

, .
,
, . , ,
. , , Mitchell 1918: 172:

.
, ,
,
. ,
5 / 18

John Stuart Mill



.
.

,
. , .
,
. , ,
, . , ,
.

4.1.3

,
16 ( Henry 1990: 92, ):

1. Caeteris paribus .
,
2. ,
.
3.
[].
. ,
4. , []
[]
...

, ,
. U
, w (a particle of wealth)
: U/w<0.
.17

6 / 18

John Stuart Mill



, ,
18
. ,
. 1782,
,
.19 ,
.20

,
,
.21 (Henry 1990: 94),

/, / ,
. Stigler (1965: 74, ):
.

. .

4.2

4.2.1

. 1826 ,
,
(James Mill). , ,
( (Saint-Simon
Comte) . ,
( 1836
1832).22
1833, ,
Remarks on Benthams Philosophy
Bulwer-Lytton England and the English. , 1838, London and
Westminster Review Essay on Bentham,
. , 1840,
(Coleridge).
(. Viner 1991: 167).
:
, (Viner 1991: 167).
,
7 / 18

John Stuart Mill



.

.
, 1863 Utilitarianism.
(Mill 2002: 80-1). ,
(consequentialism)
(deontology), (Mill
2002: 75, Roncaglia 1999: 108).
.
, ,
.
,
.
, - (maximizing
utilitarianism) ,
. o (minimizing
utilitarianism):
, , ,
, , . ,
(. Edwards 1986: 125-6).
, ,
. , ,
:

[]
.
, (Mill 2002: 127).

, , :

[] , .
, ,
, . ,
; (Mill 2002: 160-1, )

, ,
8 / 18

John Stuart Mill



.
.

. ,
, (
), . ,

(Mill 2002: 160, ).

, , , .
, , ,
(Mill ..).
.

4.2.2

, ,

.

(4.2.2.) ,
, , .
,
, -
-, . ,
, .

,
.
.23 , ,
, ,
, ,
(Mill 2002: 86).

:

9 / 18

John Stuart Mill



, ,
, , , ,
..., .
. ,
, .
. ,
,
(Mill 2002:
82).

, , . (Mill
2002: 85),
.
. ,
, .

. , , , .. ,
, (Mill 2002:
83). ,
. ,
,
: .

,
, ,
, (..). . ,


.

(4.2.2.B)
.
,
. , , ,
,
. []
(Mill 2002: 128-9,
). , ,
,
. ,
, (.. 219)24 .

10 / 18

John Stuart Mill



4.2.3 : ( : )

,
. (Stigler 1965: 75):
.
,
,
.25 ,
.
(Viner) . 26
, .
,
, . ,
.
, .. ,
..

.


.
.
, , ,
. ,
:
(Mill 2002: 83, ).

,
(Mill 2002: 82).
, , ,
. , ,
27
, . , ,

homo economicus ,
2.
, ) , )
-,
(. 2006).
, ,
.

5. -

11 / 18

John Stuart Mill



, .
(. 2). ,
(. 2006) , .
, , , ,
, . , , .
,

( ) .

. , ,
, , .
- . (
) .

19 . , ,
(Say) (Lauderdale ),
, , .
28 (
).
. , ,

. .

Althusser L. (1990), Philosophy and the Spontaneous Philosophy of the Scientists & Other Essays, London and New York: Verso.
Bentham J. (1988), The Principles of Morals and Legislation, New York: Prometheus Books.
Black R.D.C. (1972), Jevons, Bentham and De Morgan, Economica, New Series, 39, 154: 119-134.
Eatwell J., Milgate M. (1999), Some Deficiencies of Walrasian Intertemporal General Equilibrium, G. Mongiovi, F. Petri (eds), Value, Distribution and Capital, Essays in
Honour of Pierangelo Garegnani, London: Routledge.
Edwards R.B. (1986), The Principle of Utility and Mills Minimizing Utilitarianism, The Journal of Value Inquity 20: 125-136.
Garegnani P. (1978), Notes on Consumption, Investment and Effective Demand: I, Cambridge Journal of Economics 2 (1978): 335-353.
Garegnani P. (1979), Notes on Consumption, Investment and Effective Demand: II, Cambridge Journal of Economics 3 (1979): 63-82.

12 / 18

John Stuart Mill



Jevons W.S. (1871), The Theory of Political Economy, London & New York: Macmillan and Co., :
http://cepa.newschool.edu/het/texts/jevons/jevons18711.pdf .
Kurz H. (1985), Sraffas Contribution to the Debate in Capital Theory, Contributions to Political Economy 4: 3-24.
Levine D. (1998), Subjectivity in Political Economy, London and New York: Routledge.
Marshall A. (1956), Principle of Economics, 8th Edition, London: Macmillan & Co Ltd.
Marshall A. (1966), The Present Position of Economics, A.C. Pigou (ed.), Memorials of Alfred Marshall, New York: August M. Kelley Publishers.
Meikle S. (2000), , : .
. (1997), , : .
Mill J.S. (1902), Principles of Political Economy, 6th edition, Longmans, Green, And Co.
Mill J.S. (1992), , -
(.), , .
Mill J.S. (2002), , : .
Mitchell W. (1918), Benthams Felicific Calculus, Political Science Quarterly 33, 2: 161-183.
. (2002), , : .
Harrison R. (1987), Bentham, Jeremy, J. Eatwell, M. Milgate, P. Newman (eds), The New Palgrave, A Dictionary of Economics, vol. I, London: Macmillan: 226-9.
Harrod R. (1936), Utilitarianism Revisited, Mind 45, 178: 137-156.
Heilbroner R. (2001), , : .
Henry J.F. (1990), The Making of Neoclassical Economics, Boston: Unwin Hyman.
Hutchison T.W. (1956), Bentham as an Economist, The Economic Journal 66, 262: 288-306.
Pasinetti L. (1991), , : .
. (1985), , , : .
Robinson J. (1970), Capital Theory Up to Date, Canadian Journal of Economics 3: 309-17.
Robinson J. (1972), Economic Heresies: Some Old-Fashioned Questions in Economic Theory, London: Macmillan.
Roncaglia A. (1999), From Utilitarianism to Marginal Utility, G. Mongiovi, F. Petri (eds), Value, Distribution and Capital, Essays in Honour of Pierangelo Garegnani,
London: Routledge.
Rubin I.I. (1994), , : .
Schumpeter J. (1994), History of Economic Analysis, New York: Oxford University Press.

13 / 18

John Stuart Mill



Screpanti E., Zamagni S. (2002), , , : .
Smith A. (2000), . & , : .
Stark W. (1946), Jeremy Bentham as an Economist, The Economic Journal 56, 224: 583-608.
Stigler G. (1965), The Development of Utility Theory, Essays in the History of Economics, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
. (2005), John Stuart Mill: , :
.
. (2006), John Stuart Mill . : Smith Ricardo
, 95: 147-166.
Viner J. (1991), Bentham and J. S. Mill: The Utilitarian Background, Douglas A. Irwin (ed.), Essays on the Intellectual History of Economics / Jacob Viner, Princeton:
Princeton University Press.

1. . 1841, (Auguste Comte)


( Stark 1946: 583).

2 The Theory of Moral Sentiments , IV : ,


, , ,
. , , , . ,
. , , , ,
. . ,
, ( Rubin 1994: 222, ).

3. .
, (Mill 1992: 153).

4 . Althusser 1990: 101-144, 2002: 44-52.

14 / 18

John Stuart Mill



5. : Robinson 1970, Garegnani 1978, 1979, Pasinetti 1991, Kurz 1985, Eatwell & Milgate 1999.

6. Stark 1946: 601-8, , , , (Menger).

7., , Stigler 1965, Stark 1946, Mitchell 1918, Black 1972, Hutchison 1956, Roncaglia 1999, Henry 1990. . 1997 2005.

8. (Mitchell 1918: 162) ,


.

9... Schumpeter 1994: 302-3, 1054, Stigler 1965: 70-75, Screpanti & Zamagni 2002: 105-6, Stark 1946: 600-1, Viner 1991: 162, Mitchell 1918, Hutchison 1956: 289-290, Henry 1990: 90-95.

10.. Schumpeter 1994: 130-2, Screpanti & Zamagni 2002: 105. Mitchell 1918: 162, , (Hume, Hartley
Priestley, ), (Helvetius, ) (Beccaria, ).

11. Rubin 1994: 299-305 Henry 1990: 92-5.

12 , .

13 Bentham 1988: 3 : (fictitious body), . , ;

15 / 18

John Stuart Mill



. .

14. . Viner 1991: 155. , , ,


[] (..).

15 . Viner 1991: 160-1, Roncaglia 1999: 108-9, Harrison 1987: 226.

16. . 1801 The True Alarm (. Hutchison 1956: 290-1)



. , , (Smith 2000: I.iv.13). ,
(. Schumpeter 1994: 300-311). , , (..).

( 1801), -, . , :
(value with a view to exchange) (value with a view to use).
, . , . ,
, , ( Hutchison 1956: 291).

17 : ( Henry 1990: 92). , . Henry 1990:


92, Stigler 1965: 74, Stark 1946: 606-607. Marshall 1956: 32.

18, , , .
(Benjamin Franklin) (Viner 1991: 161).

19 . Stigler 1965: 74.

16 / 18

John Stuart Mill



20., , Hutchison 1956: 290, , , ,
.

21 Hutchison (1956), , .
(forced saving) . , ,
Hutchison 1956: 306: , ,
.

22 . Viner 1991: 166.

23., , (Mill 2002: 82).

24. : , .
. , (volition) ,
, . [] , , . ,
, , ,
. , , , (Mill 2002: 128-9).

25 Hutchison 1956: 289, , , ,


, .

26. Viner 1991: 171-2, Black 1972: 126. Jevons 1871: 30-2 Marshall 1956: 79, 107. .

17 / 18

John Stuart Mill



27. 2005: 127-131.

28 Meikle 2000: 38.

18 / 18