www.istame.

gr

2010

ISSN 1792-5185

&

John Rawls
toy

L eif W enar

1.
2.
2.1
2.2
2.3 -
2.4
2.5
3. :

3.1 :
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5 :
3.6
4. :
4.1
4.2

4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7 :
4.8 :
4.9 :
4.10
5. :
5.1
5.2 :
5.3
5.4
5.5 :

5.6
6.
7.

John Rawls (1921- 2002) , .

, .
,
, .
,
.

1.
Rawls ,
.
. Rawls
, Wittgenstein, Norman Malcolm
, H. L. A. Hart,

Isaiah Berlin Stuart Hampshire. MIT. 1962

Rawls

.
, Rawls :
.
. ,
Rawls
&

www.istame.gr

2010

4
.

. ,
60, Rawls
. Rawls




.
Rawls
,
.
Rawls
1971
, . Rawls

,
(1993),
(1999) (2001). 1971
Freeman
(2007). Rawls
, .

2.
2.1

Rawls
.
:

. Rawls
Leviathan Hobbes

Federalist Papers

.

&

.



.
.

. ,

: . , ,
.
:
,
[...]

. (JF, 3)

, ,
,

.
Rawls
,
.





.
, Rawls
, ,
.

www.istame.gr

2010

2.2
,
Rawls
.
( ), , ,
.
Rawls :
, ,
. (TJ, 29) Rawls


-
.
Rawls - .
-
.
, Rawls
-:
.
Rawls ( )

-,
.
, -
.

2.3
-
-
Rawls : .
.
,
( ) . ,
()
( ). ,
,

. ,

,

.
,
Rawls, -
( )
. -,
-, . ,


,
-
. ,
,
,
.

2.4

. Rawls

.
,
,
. ,
(..
,
) (..
)

(..
). ,
,
. ,

&

www.istame.gr

2010

4
.

,
.

:

(.. , ).


,
.
, ,

.
,
.


:
. ,

,

.
,
,
.
,
(foundationalism) .

.
:

&

,

.

2.5

.
,


. , ,
Rawls

. , , Rawls
.

(
) . (CP, 286-302)
Rawls

, , ,
.

3. :



. .
.

. ,
. .
.

. -

www.istame.gr

2010

4

.
Rawls

.
:
. ,
.
,
;


.


; ,

.
Rawls
.
Rawls ( ).
,
.

3.1 :


,
; Rawls

:

,
,
. (PL, 137)
,

.
:

.

,

.

: .
Rawls
.

3.2



.
,



.
, ,
.
,
, .
Rawls
. , ,

.
,

,

.

, Rawls,
.
&

www.istame.gr

2010

4
. ,


( , ,
.).



.

3.3
Rawls
.
,
Hobbes
(1651, 58).

.

, .
Rawls ,


. ,
,
, , .
,

.
:
;

,
,
.

&

.


.



.
,
;
,

.
,


(PL, 100-01).



, .
, Rawls,


( ),
(PL, 13-14). Rawls , ,
,
.

.

3.4
Rawls

.

www.istame.gr

2010

4

.

, .
:
.





.

.

Rawls

.

. , , . ,

,
:
1.
,
, .
2.
, (..
) (..
).
3.

.

Rawls,

.
:
.
( )

.

.

.

.
Rawls, (
Nozick , )
.


, .
, Rawls
( )
.



-
.

3.5 :


. :
;
.
Rawls

.
Rawls .
.
Rawls, -

&

www.istame.gr

2010

4

.
:

.

.

() (
) :

.

. (1965, 2)

.


,
.

, . ,
.

. ,



. . , -
, , ,
. .
-
, - ,
.

Rawls,


.
( Nozick ,
Rawls

)

.
.





.
( modus

vivendi)
.
,


.

&

www.istame.gr

2010

4

. Rawls

:
( ) ( ).
,
, ,
.
Rawls
.
,


. Rawls
,
,

.
,
.

3.6
Rawls
,

:
.


.
, Rawls

. ,


.
:






.



.
.
Rawls :



.

:


:


. ,
, ,



.
(..
) (..
&

www.istame.gr

2010

4
)
.
,

.


. ,
. ,
,
.
:
,
,
. Rawls .

, ,


.

,

. ,
,



.
Rawls
.

. , ,

10

&

,
,
,
,
.
, , :
.


.



.
Rawls


,

. , , ,
,


. ,
, Rawls

.

4. H : .
Rawls .

. ,
.

.

www.istame.gr

2010

4
:
.
Rawls


.
,
.
Rawls

,

.

Rawls

: .

.
:

.
Rawls




.
,

.

4.1 .


: ,
, , ,
. .
, ,
, ,
,
, .

, ,
, ,
.
-

.


.

,
,

.
, Rawls
, ,
:
. Rawls
,
. ,
.
&

11

www.istame.gr

2010

4.2.
.
, , , . ,

. Rawls


. Rawls

.

,
, , ,

.
, , ,

. ,
, ,


.

.
.
Rawls
. ,
.
, ,

.


.
.

12

&

.

Rawls .

4.3
.


:
:
,
.
: :
.

,
.
( ). (JF, 42-43)


,
.


.
: ,
, ,
, , .

.
,
.
Rawls .
. , :

www.istame.gr

2010

4

. ,
,
.

,

.

Rawls . ,
,

.
Rawls
. ,

, ,
,
.

,
.
Rawls
. , ,
,
, .


. (JF, . 44) , ,

, ,
( )

25% ,
25%
, .

,

.

.


.
,
,
:
,
,

.


.
- , :
-

10,000

10,000

10,000

12,000

15,000

20,000

20,000

30,000

50,000

17,000

50,000

100,000

, .

( ), ( ).

( ).

:
.

.

. ,

&

13

www.istame.gr

2010

4

.

.


. ,

. , Rawls,

. (TJ, 102).

4.4 .
Rawls
, Rawls
.
Rawls, ,

. Rawls
:
.

.




.


,

.
14

&

Rawls .



.

: , ,
, . , ,

.


. ,

,
.
Rawls , .

.
,
,
. Rawls

. :
. Rawls
.
.
( Hobbes, Locke Mill),
: . Rawls

.

www.istame.gr

2010

4
.
:

:

(selfworth) . (JF, 58-59)




.
,
Rawls, .

4.5 .
Rawls :

, ,
, , , , .
O Rawls ,
. ,


.
,
.



:
. (PL, 68).

4.6
Rawls
.

-

.
:

;

;

Rawls

Locke, Rousseau Kant.
,
. ,
Rawls

.
Rawls




.
:


.

,

,
.
.


,
,
. ,

,
:
&

15

www.istame.gr

2010

4
.

,


. Rawls
, , ,
.
,
. , , Rawls,

:
, , ,
. , (citizens
society),
.


:
:
- , , , ,
, , , ,
.
.
- ,
, .
:
-
, .
- : ,
.
-
, ,
( ) .

.

16

&

,
.
,

.

(,

).
,
.

Rawls
. ,


.

:
(
).

. ,
:


.

4.7 :
.
.

.

. Rawls
,

. Rawls

.

www.istame.gr

2010

4

Rawls
.
:


.
Rawls
,
maximin :

.


. ,

.


,

.

, Rawls
, .
, Rawls, .


,
. ,
,



. ,
,
,
. (considerations)
, Rawls,
.

,
Rawls


,
.
,
.
maximin
,
. (JF, XVII, 43,
95, 96) ,
Rawls,

.
.


,
. ,
,
.

,



. ,

,



.
&

17

www.istame.gr

2010

4

. ,

, ..

.

.


.

.



. ,
.
,
Rawls, (reason)
,
,
. (TJ, 261)

,
. ,
,

.
Rawls .


,
.

.

,

.
.

, Rawls
.

Rawls ,

.

(principle of just
savings) .

. Rawls
.
,
(Millian)

.

, ,
,
.




.



.

4.9 : 4.8 :
.

18

&

www.istame.gr

2010

4


.

.


.
:
,

,
, , .
,



. (PL, 289 371)


.
Rawls :
, ,
,

,
.

, , ,
, , .


,
,

.
Rawls

.
,
,
. ,

.
Rawls
(..


).
, ,
, .
Rawls
. (JF, 137-40)
. ,

.


. Laissez-faire ,
.

,
,
, .
,
Rawls,
.

.
&

19

www.istame.gr

2010

4
,
.
,
,
.
,
, - ,
, -
. (JF, 139)

4.10
.
Rawls
. ,

,
,


.

, ,

,
, -


.
20

&

. ,

,


.

. Rawls

, , , ,
.
. ,

,
.

Rawls, .
Rawls
. ,
Rawls,

.
,

.

,


.

:

-

www.istame.gr

2010

4

.
, , Rawls,
.

5. :

, Rawls
: .
Rawls
.




.
, :

, .
Rawls :

. ,

, ,
,
,
[] , ,

( )
( ) ,
. (LP, 6-7)
Rawls
.
:
, ,
.

5.1
Rawls


.

, ,
Rawls, . (LP,
33, 62, 114, 115, 122, 123) Rawls
,
(..
1990
).
.



.
Rawls :
1.

.
2.
.
3. .
4.
- ( ).
5. ,

.
6.
.
7. .
8.

. (LP, 37)
, , (
&

21

www.istame.gr

2010

4
Rawls 4
6 ). Rawls


,

,
.

5.2 :
Rawls
()
().
,
(common sympathies)
.

.


.
Rawls

.


.
,

,
. ,

.
.
Rawls
:
,
,

,

22

&

.
Rawls .
, Rawls,



.

.
,
. :


.

,

.
, .


.
, Rawls,

.
,
.
Rawls -

.
. , .
,

(decent consultation hierarchy).

www.istame.gr

2010

4


.
. .
Rawls
. ,
. ,
.

. ,
Rawls, -
.

5.3

.
, Rawls,
.


.

. .
, (reason)
,
.

.
,
Rawls,


. ,
,
,
,

( , , ).


. ,

.
.
Rawls

.



.

5.4

.
; (
) ;
,
:
.

&

23

www.istame.gr

2010

4
. , ,
,

. ,
.
Rawls

. ,

(
,

).
,

.

,

. ,


,
. (
modus vivendi),


.
Rawls

.
.
Rawls
,
, .
,

,
.
, Rawls

. ,
.

,

.

,




,

.


(
5.5 :
modus vivendi),




:
.
24

&

www.istame.gr

2010

4

.
4 8 .
:
.


.
,
,

. , Rawls,


.

.
, .
( )
(
). Rawls

.

. Rawls
.


.

5.6

Rawls ,

,
.
.

.

Rawls:
.

.
Rawls :
,
, ,
.


Rawls.
, Rawls
.
Rawls


, .

, .

,

. (LP, 128)
&

25

www.istame.gr

2010

6.
Rawls , Rawls
Hume, Leibniz, Kant Hegel (LHMP)
Hobbes, Locke, Hume, Mill,
Marx, Sidgwick Butler (LHPP)
Rawls
. Reath, Herman
Korsgaard (1997) Rawls
.
Freeman (2007)
Rawls,

. Pogge (2007) , Rawls

(
Pogge 1989). .
Freeman (2003) Rawls.

Rawls. Daniels
(1975). Griffin Solum
(1994), Lloyd (1994), Davion Wolf (1999).
Martin and Reidy (2006)
. Fleming (2004)
Rawls
.
(
) Kukathas (2003, 4 )
Richardson Weithman (1999, 5 )

() Rawls, (.. maximin , )
(.. , ).

26

&

7.
1971 A Theory of Justice [TJ], Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
1993 Political Liberalism [PL], New York:
Columbia University Press.
1999 The Law of Peoples [LP], Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
1999 Collected Papers [CP], S. Freeman (ed.),
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
1999 Lectures on the History of Moral
Philosophy [LHMP], B. Herman (ed.), Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press.
2001 Justice as Fairness: A Restatement [JF],
E. Kelly (ed.), Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
Press.
2007 Lectures on the History of Political
Philosophy [LHPP], S. Freeman (ed.), Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press.

Daniels, N., (ed.), 1975, Reading Rawls: Critical
Studies on John Rawls A Theory of Justice, New
York: Basic Books.
Davion, V. and Wolf, C. (eds.) 1999, The Idea of
a Political Liberalism: Essays on Rawls, Lanham,
MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Fleming, J., (ed.), 2004, Rawls and the Law,
Fordham Law Review 72 (special issue).
Freeman, S., (ed.), 2003, The Cambridge
Companion to Rawls, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
, 2007, Rawls, London, Routledge.
Griffin, S., and Solum, L. (eds.) 1994,
Symposium of John Rawlss Political Liberalism,
Chicago Kent Law Review 69: 549-842.
Hobbes, T., 1651, Leviathan, 1994 edition, E.
Curley (trans.), London: Hackett.
Kukathas, C., (ed.), 2003, John Rawls: Critical
Assessments of Leading Political Philosophers, 4
vol., London, Routledge.
Lloyd, S., (ed.), 1994, John Rawlss Political
Liberalism, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 75.
Martin, R. and Reidy, D. (eds.), 2006, Rawlss
Law of Peoples: A Realistic Utopia?, Oxford:
Blackwell.
Nozick, R., 1974, Anarchy, State, and Utopia,
New York: Basic Books.

www.istame.gr

2010

4
Pogge, T., 1989, Realizing Rawls, Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press.
, 2007, John Rawls: His Life and Theory of
Justice, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Reath, A., Herman, B., and Korsgaard, C.,
(eds.), 1997, Reclaiming the History of Ethics:
Essays for John Rawls, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Richardson, H., and Weithman, P. (eds.), 1999,
The Philosophy of Rawls: A Collection of Essays, 5
vol., New York: Garland.
Vatican Council II, 1965, Dignitas Humanae
(Declaration on Religious Freedom), in Documents
of Vatican II, W. Abbott (ed.), New York: Herder
and Herder, 1966.

H. Richardson, John Rawls, Internet
Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
M. Nussbaum, The Enduring Significance of
John Rawls, Chronicle of Higher Education July
20, 2001.

K
.

Leif Wenar
O Leif Wenar Kings College .
Stanford,
Harvard
Robert Nozick T. M. Scanlon.

Princeton, Murphy Carnegie .
&

27