Pugh Concept Selection

Name
Concept Criteria/Concept Data integrity Ease of use Suport India requirements - CoP tracking Scalability Data back up Access control
Datum Concept 1 Concept 2 Concept 3 Concept 4

S S S S S S S S S S S S S 0 0 13 0 1

Total S + Total S Total S S Total Rank

0 0 0 0 1

0 0 0 0 1

0 0 0 0 1

0 0 0 0 1

Note: Ranking is color coded 1--- Green 2--- Yellow 3---- Red

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 1

Pugh Concept Selection

+ S

+ S

+ S

+ S

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 2

Pugh Concept Selection

0 0 0 0 1

0 0 0 0 1

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 3

Pugh Concept Selection

+ S

+ S

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 4

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 5

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 6

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 7

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 8

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 9

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 10

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 11

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 12

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 13

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 14

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 15

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 16

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 17

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 18

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 19

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 20

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 21

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 22

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 23

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 24

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 25

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 26

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 27

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 28

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 29

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 30

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 31

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 32

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 33

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 34

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 35

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 36

Pugh Concept Selection

Cummins Inc. Confidential

1/21/2014

Page 37