You are on page 1of 29

' , , :

..

~
2006

AL
PH

......................................................................

............................................................

13

, 'fJ ...................................................................

15

'fJ ....................................................................... 179


'fJ ......................................................................... 493

...................................................................... 557
'fJ~ .................................................................... 563

' ....................................................... 569

'fJ ................................................................... 583


................................................................ 701

' ........................................... 709


{ { {
{ . '
, ' {
{ {: ' {
{ '
',
' { ' , {
i; {
, { ' ' ,

" ,

' .

{ {
. '
!. { ,
{
{ '
t . ' { {,
{ , {
, {
' ' {
-

{
.
'

'
pOTj/'

"/

G. Gjannantonj, Socraticorum
Reliquiae (1983-1985), -
6 - {
{, '
'
. ' { {
' '
"',4 /,
'
/ ,
"
/
, /
,
,
-

l;

, ,

111

50 ' 30 .

7 '
,
'"

\"


.
'
'

':

,
'
:

"
- ~p - ~
, .

Frag-

'"

,
"

p~o

. Djels, l 6.
, , '
Gjannantonj, :
' ,
, [ 6 , '
' 6 , ,
' .
Gjannantonj (
' )

menta der Vorsokratiker

'

"

pu

'

'"

,
6 '
[ .
,~-"
\" ,

"

"
.

:
,
6, V 141 pf Socraticorum
Reliquiae,
' , '
6 '
.
, Gjannantonj, J?
' (
Socraticorum Reliquiae pfo )
. .
:
- -

6 '6 . ' ,

\,

.. , ..
-.
''

~o

.'

\'

1,

~~-

6, .

'

"

, ,

Ol

11


6. 6 '6 6 :
, ,
' ' -
6 '

"

'

'"

, ' 6 , ,
,
.
...

',

1996

' ': ~ ] u u 6,
] ',
, ] ']Opj j. "
. f
.

~, 21 ' 1998
...

Billerbeck

Dje Kynjker jn der modernen Forschung,


Billerbeck (.), Amsterdam 1991.
(~Fragmente)
Dje }ragmente der Vorsokratjker, .
Diels-W. Kranz (.), Berlin 71951-54.
F Gr Hjst Dje Fragmentev!er (;liechjschen Hjstorjker, F. J acoby (.), Berlin -Leiden
1923 ..
FHG Fragmenta Hjstorjcorum Graecorum, C.
Miller (.), Paris 1841 ..
Goulet-Caze Le Cynjsme ancjen et ses prolongements,
. - O.Goulet - Caze,
(.),
Paris
1993.
LSJ Greek-English Lexicon, H.G. LiddellR. Scott. Oxford 91940, XOOj
pJj H.S. Jones R.
McKenzie.
RE Pau~y's Realencyclop/1dje der classjschen
Altert.ums~vissenschaft, G. vVissowa-W.
ro .. . Stuttgart 1894 .
.

) \)

+
6.
u

SVF
Zeller

Suidae Lexicon, . Adler (.), Leipzig


1928-38.
Stojcorum veterum fragmenta, .
(.), . -, Leipzig 1903-24.
Dje Phjlosophje der Grjechen jn jllrer geschjchtljchen Entwjcklung, Ed. Zeller
Darmsl}Idt ;)1963 [1844-52]. '
\)
6, 11/1.


j (

455-360

..), ;), j

~ ' A~ . /)oj, ~,
, \) pj , , /) \) Oj
j, (/), pt
'jpO, popt /)), t '.

. ~~
\) pj, pOj t Xj
, ao
j ( c), /)pj
\) \). '

1)

OC

/)jop \) j /) . ~ K~ .
/) OC ~ \) \)

1)

\) j,

/)/) \)
j : /) p~,
~ ~ j,

1)

1)

, j'., /)

p~ , ~ j, /)/).

' \) OC

1)

pj

. /) j p~j

, ~/)j OC ~ Sj , ApXj, ~
(oj

15

13),

/) Oj
J, Oj '

1)

j
2538-2545 . Natorp.

op~ ) \) \)

~.

RE

2(1894), .

1. , 6 80
1. . , ' j" ,
96 . 95, 1. , 2,9.

. 8' l

16

' 8{ , ' {

{. 8 :! .

j, ~o ~j, joc. ~oc, ~

yocv,

j~ ~~, 8oc o~o woc ~' oc6, oc~

8~ j

XOCL

~ jpOC oc~

OC \)Loc. ~OCL ~\)6oc 8~ ~ oc \) ~oc OC

pj.
) jVoco 8

59b [= ) 30]

OCococ , OC 8 oc ), oc

, 8 .&. VOI )oc. r8)) OC


poc~ ococ~ )oc 8 OCoc OC op~
OC) , , 8 ococ .

Gigon, Sokrates, . 290, oc ~ ococ

~ oc OC ~o ocOC80 8 oc' 8
. oc ) 80c &
, oc ~ oc OC 8 oc ) oc
) OCOC po~oc .

2. SENECA, De

constanta

sapientis 18, 5.

Antistheni mater harhara et 'rhressa ohiciehatur; respondit et deorum


matrem Idaeam esse.
6~~\)oc ~j ~ oc \) ~oc OCj ~
OC pj OC 8

XOCL

~ jpOC

~oc OC ~ ''I~j [ \)Loc].

3.

, ' i]

17

607b.

8 ' {
, ;

LPO ~ OCjj ~j '


' 8 ~ oc \) oc~ OC ~ \)LOC; '~~o

voc~

XOCL ~ joc, OCj ~j.

ot .

Natorp,

"l)

2538

17

jot

RE,

ot

otot /) ot "l) otot !, otot


OC OC/) "l) ot,
"l)

1 [='

OC 6 ! ' i

1],

ot "l)' . ot .

Hense, Rheinisches Museum 45 (1890),

544

4.

, , V

66, 1.

{ 6 ' ' '


6. ' {
, , '

r)

6 , ~, . ..;

!. ~.

OL

.!. !.

'. !.

OL

pp~ ~ !.

~p ~ p~ ,
~ ~ ~ !.

) ~ ,l .;

1.

/) ~"l) , ot, "l) "l),

oc6, ! [!

31e

OC oc OC OCococ

U.

5.

, 6 '

31.

6 U

/, '

[sc. ]
4Jou, ,

;.

' ) ) ~
), : ~

S & ' ) Suo

, );.
2.

18

6.

, ! '

1.

' TIYiypq: 17

[sc.

] !
.

', j ~ Xj ~

,1 o~ j O:r
.' ' j.'
'.

1.

,~ XJ , 426 .., ~

uul>l>j,

11139.

. Gigon,

Sokrates,

. 290,

,~ ,oJ Joo: l>l>u , ,


l>l> XJ ~ ,
, 'Jj l>

. l>~ u~J , po~o,


ul> l> )) ,'
) , . G. Giannantoni,

7.

SR, . 3, . 180 .

, ! ' -

4.

[sc.

] l'

j
J .' :

060 ~ j, ~
j.
( x":jj 'A.~j o~ : J :~+,, '
-rou I>l: ~, I>) ,) :;
J-:- -:- o~(

70U

oJ_ ~ ~

,) ; oof -rou , ':' F. Sa)Te,

Antisthenes tiJo SOTa[jc, . 4, 'j , ; ':') -rou ;

r
~

'.1

19

Tl

Ol ll)
ll.

8.

, !

[sc.

43.

' ] , (jj 8, ' ' -

8 8 ' [
4J 8 '
. 8 {5. '(
' 8 ,

) , . ' !
' ' ' ' ' '
' 8 l80 .

: 6, u1J,

1J ~ l5 - -,
oU 6 p~
. 6 . -
6 '

6' 6 61J ~,

, ,

'

1Jxtlv,

'

'

".
"

'' '1J,

, 1J Z~ 1J

' 1J )

u . 1

1.

Ol !3 OlO !3 OC !30 ~ ll )),

G. Giannantoni, SR,

3,

181.

9. GGU VATICANUM 743 n. 10.


[sc. ' ] 80 '
'(, ' , l, 8' 8' '

, ' 8 ~o '( '4Jov.

' 1J , 6
~ ' ,

Ki!\!IKO

20

~ ~ ~ ~,
~ .

, ' 17

10.

211,

637,36-39.
' &
, ' ~ & &
6, ' cx ,
' [.

' "fj '

"fj [ ~ ~ ~
~ , ~"fj
~~ ~ ,
~ ~
.
oc88 ) , )

46

oc) B~ u)' . ,

11.

29, 13,

) , jo ' '.

104, 15-105, 6.

8 &, ... 8 &


, 6 , V 6 6
8 80
&8 .

, ["fj, ~
[ ... xp~p ~ ,
~ "fj, ~
+, ~ ~ "fj -
6 6 .
&~p.

"'

21

59 [ = 350] &il[i
Gellius, Noctes Attjcae 21, 33. . Pack-

. .
10hr,

De Djogenjs Sjnopensjs apophthegmatjs quaestjones selectae,

88,

il~ i
ilo~ . ' - '

i p~o o~ &
&JVo' ~ il~ &JVo'o &[
; ; ;

;'~I,7O. ' . , , .
8 [ ; pjV[o

F. Ollier, La mjrage Spartiate, . , . 8

.., '

ii il[i , ~
, ~ , ~ [ [ po~
, & .

12.

, 6 [ '

[sc.

1.
' ] ' '

TifJ

[ [

'

'
/
",

" /'

" jO

oc ~ 6xo~ 3

~ ~ . .
[, H.D. Rankin,

Sophjsts ., . 219, ~

[ iI[ - &; ' &il, &


ii :i, [ ~o.

13.

, 6 [ '

2.

Tn

' ' ' poto [sc. ' ]



[ ' ', [,

. [ 6 [ 6 .

22

' '
"1

'
\
'f) )

'

'f),

(' ''f)

"

rf

'

")

\ ?;;
",

\
\
-

- () a Elae:

oc oc ocii oc

xocL oc: oc .

~ OC1Joc 1J .
1J1J; ~oc . .

kratiker,

Patzer, Antisthenes der 50252-5. oc' . OC1J 1J . ~ [oc

ocu,

ococ,

6oc

ococ

430-420 .. - ~oc . . oc ' ~ ~


voc xocL ~ ' , oc. Patzer, - [oc oc~ -
ococ 1J ~ ~ ' -
1J xocL . 1J . 1J
oc ~ ococ , OC ~

oc u1J . . oc
~oc oc~L, ococe:oc, OC

01JxocL

oc oc o~ xocL 1Jococ ocu


G.E. Lessing (1729-1781). . Apelt, Diogenes Laertius. Lehen und Meinungen herahmten PhiJosophen, . 324, ococ 1J ococ
Philologischer Nachtrag , . 295 ., (Hempel):
oc oc . " ~) ) -oc OC oc xocL
1Joc . oc1J, oc1J xocL ococ1J,

. - OC1Joc , 1J 1J OC 0 - oc 1J, . p~ 1J .
! oc . '' ococ
. . "oc, , .

xocL . ~ . )oc oc 1J oc1J xocL, ,


xocL ococ1J" .
oc 060 1Joc1J -ijcrocv oc oc , ~

OC oc oc1J

oc, o~, oc oc ~
oc )oc , , ococ oc

xocL ococ. - oc oc ococ ,


oc1J oc1J, "
) oc . )oc, .
ococ

xocL oc ococ ococ 1J. T~

o~ 1J oc~ 1Joc xocL oc~ 1J [ ~


YJ.

1. fr. 38 FHG . 45.

2. ococ

oc p~op, xOCL 1Joc 1J


oc 01Jococ . 1J 1J. . , '

363c

.,

[= D

86

8J.

14.

, ,

23

30, 7 . 58a-59a.

' 6J
, t 6JV
6 6Jv V6JV.

~oo ~j j
[ - {) ~ j -

~o

j [, : ~ o~po [ ~p ~

o~ ~ j j[
~ L.

"Av 8 80 - . Gigon, Sokrates, . 290, -)


[ ' J' . OC,
'AJ

11-

, : . 'AJ

() ocJ 371 .. ' ,


8 ~ Jpoop[o 8 76, So 'AJ
8ocjo 8

366 ..,

OC S ~[o 86 .

15.

, ~o ''.

: pT6p6JV 6 6J
6.

j: ~j jVL, p~o ~oo


p~op.

16.

, 66JV 6JV 6J
6J

l5

1.

[sc. ] '

J 6 '

fj q. ' .

~j p~ ~ )~ p~op ['
, , ) '
(
,
'
\..' '
o~ ~ pjOpO pjp O~ ,

24

' ~ 6

oc f pJ -oc 427 .., popJJ


~oc, oc- ococ , -
3 - -oc oc oc. -

Joc ;:; 3- JP J oc J3 J
-. ' '; oc 330oc 3 ococ
oJ ococ ;:; J oc, ~ ococ Jpoooc ;:;
oJ oc ( [) . oc oc 330

, oc 3 J
'IoJ [ 82

[= D 82 4] oc
18], oc oc oU JX 33ococ,

oc J, oc ococ oc, ~. oc

ocJ ;:; J foc oc-. Joooc ;:; oJ


ococ-oc 3oc ;:; J oc oc, oc

oc J ococ J ocJoc ;:; '


J oc, ~ oc, oc 3 oc oc oc ococpJ

J-, oc oc oc oc ococJ-.
, ocpocJ

F. Kindstrand, The Cynics and Heraclitus, .


150, ocJ oc ~ J oc 3 oc ocJ-, 3

~ oc ococ oc
'; oc ' AJ.

360

,; ocococ ocp~ 3 ,
oc

- oc oc -

3oc ococ-oc ,; oc33 '

oc oJ oc ( 6). oc

R. Hirzel, Der Dia1, 3 foc ';


. Hirzel, .., oc

/og, 1963 [1895],

. 119, J.

;:; ococ, oc oc oc

ococ oc J oc oc-J ;:;


, . Gigon, Sokrates, . 296,
J, oc oc ;:; oc3J, 3oc

oc ,; oc033 ' oc po~J, 1024b 26 ..


[ = J 182]. - oc J oc oJ oc
ocococ 3 3J ' !
' [ d , , [, ! 6 ' ' ;:; ococ (. ococ, J 49). -)
-J 3 oc oc oc 360
J, ~oc oc oc ocococ 3ocoJ oc oc3oc oc . oJ, oc6 oc
.

17.

, 6 '

2.

[sc. ] , '

, !; xtJT4J
.

' , '

'

015 '

'
.

' 'Lj jO Xj, . L

'

""

'

'

'
j

XL . Oj Xj.
nELpOLcX, jL L 6oj
rLX CtXOGcrEL Xj. '

- ~ L6 . ~jX Xj ~ L~

O~j ,l L, 'Lj, L~
L- L.

' ~ op~ pocJ OC . u


u ) f . ~ OC

J .

1.

KJ

IJEV

~ . '

J ~o : ) tJJ .

IJEV

OC , ~ J/ OC

18. GNOMOLOGIUM VATICANUM 743

ll.

4.

[sc. ] 6
6 6
, , {' ' , .

LL Lj OjO jL~, L,

"

' j

'

11"
, 11'11'
,
"
1:
XOj L j LL , c" -

XL

''
Oj

j , OjOtl

26

Kl'N!KO!

, , ~ j ' ,

, .
.

Patzer, Antisthenes dcr Sokratiker,

251-2,

[ ~ , [

:, ') & f u
f ~
.

19. HIERONYMUS, Adversus Jovinianum

14.

Hic certe est Antisthenes qui cum glorjose docujsset rhetorjcam, audjssetque Socratem, dixjsse fertur ad discjpulos suos ahite et magistrum
quaerjte; ego enjm iam reperj; statjmque venditjs quae hahehat, et
puhljce dist1hutis, njhjl sihj amplius quam palljolum reservavit paupertatjsque ejjus et lahoris et Xenophon testis est in Symposio, et jnnumerahiles lihri ejus: quorum aljos phjlosophjco, aljos rhetorjco genere conscrjpsjt.
, , j,
jO OC j,
o~ j : j

' ~jl
Oj , j

, \

\ ,' j

'

'

OC o~ OC
.!'

1.

) )

2.

.
[ =

6}

87

u ' )

, ,
~ .

3.

'.

paupertas

4.

Jabor

U,//.'r,

, ~ io ') 'J,
, ) ,) 6j pj.

Tl

20.

[sc.

27

61-64.

] ,

[sc.

],

l 15. ' , '!;;, ,

, , ; ' ', . '


. ;

, . ' '

(62)

, (]j , ; OlSx , ,
' , 6
, - {
/ , '

015

15 ' - '

015

' ,
.

(63)

' '

' ,
. ' '
l. '

(64)

l. l

, 15 ' '
, l
' [ .

, . " , .
,
.. ' .

~, pj,
j. j, ' ,
j, 8 ~ j ; ,

j" . p~ ~ ~'
jpT j. . ~; j

. , . ' .6 8j

pj:

(62)

\;;: /

",,

,/

,/

pj, -

; , , u 8
'

\"

\"

,~
l
'
\ "
,

6 . ~ l:..Q j . . -

28

?(J)

KYl\'IKOI

&.~ ' ( (H~

~oc oc jO~O ococ' oc~

ococ ~x~ ~ ~o p~pj - ~oc ,


oc 'a aEV x~ ~ .
' ~,

"

OCl'l ~ ~oc

"

1;'1
"

(63) oc 6ococ
"
,
oc
j

' oc
' ~oc, 2

' ~oc ~ ~oc ~' oc6, oc


j. oc , ' ~OC, Xpj ~' oc6, ~oc
ococ ococ~ oU ~o . ' oc

oc~~ ' ~
~ooc,3 oc ~ oc, aEV ~p - oc
-

o~oc OCOCj,

o~, oc ~oc o~ ~poc;

(64)

o~o ~ o~oc ococ, ~x


j loc~ oc o~oc. ~oc loc~ oc

a~oc~ o~o , oc

oc~

,\"
oc

oc

oc~

'
'"
'
ocooc~ oco~ oc~oc ~ ~oc,

'>"

o~"

fl

oc ~ Mocj ~ a ~oc
oc ~ oc~oco ~ loc~

oUo 6joc ~ 6~, ,

. 6, lj)oc ~oc p~~ oc


oc o~oc, p~j . oc,
pj, oc aEV ~ . ~oc ~ Mocj

oc o~oc ococ, ' 'oc~ ~


j o~ . K~ l :- oc~ ~ jj.

oc - oc Yj
. , 6 oc

ococ 336oc ~ 6oc OC'JU 36 oc)


oc ). oc. oc oc6oc
. ococ ), 3 ,
oc , oc 3oc, , oc oc+, oc6.
3ococ 6 'oc .

422 .. oc

,,; ococ 3 3oc. oc

, 6, 6oc, oc oc6oc
oc ) oc ,

III'ie.

History

. oc ..

Greek Philosophy,

\V.K.C. Gu-

. 3, . 341. . 6ococ oc

F'fitz, Antisthenes und Sokrates Xenophons Symposion, .

29

25 j . Patzer, Antisthenes der Sokratiker, . 60 .., a G. Giannantoni, SR, . 3, j. 39. 1. OC a aopoc pOCj ocpxl OC ocaa ~ 3pajp6)a j poao oc'
oa oca j 6a, a, a &,

oc
a.

2.

opa

. Korte,

63 a

Aufbau und Zie] von Xenophons Symposion,

. 38,

j. 2, a pjO OC Zj,
a Aa6, ,

j.

3.

17, 6a OC

. Kijrte, .., a - oc aa

- OC . Hultsch, -a RE, jpa


1 (1903), . 40.
4. a R. Hoistad, Cynic Hero
and Cynic King, . 106, j apaja oc-a ~a oc

LO a 3 ~ ~a OC + 6a a

21.

360.

632d-e.

' l
' '
' { '
.

"Evoc

Loc ococ~ EIvoc~ oc

oc~ OCL oc --

xoct - oc ~oc -
~ xoc~ ~ gvocv oc oc
"ococ" xoct "6~ococ".
1.

22.

. apaoc, j

20.

, 6 4-6.

6, J '!, oJo /; ' , l


, ' 6 . '
6 l T<;J 6 /,
. (5) ' ' .
6

6 (J7l , ' . (6) ' -

1'

30

; l' , d. , 6 6f. '

8' &' 6;

' 't .

, l, l , 8 ' l
' .

'
' 'J ) '
""
"' 'J,
( pOJ ,
a ' p~o o~o;1 , ,
.', XOL 6: ' ~o. 6,

"

"
,,\"
'
, J -

.' , u '' ~ J a6. (5)

~J , 6 6 , c1)

'

""
'''

'
,~

Jo

,~,

'

'

"

6 6 6.

(6) 6:
' u u, ~J, 6 ~ a 2
, "'
;::.
\"
' -
"
J
J
''"

. 6, ~, 6 p~

6, 1. a ~ oc
.

'ij

213c-d

{ , ) ~o
3j. ' ) 3 j j-p

jO
-

- 3~

&, 8 &i. ' t

&' ), 6, ~ ..

und Sokrates

Xenophons Symposion,

29,

Fritz, Antisthenes

j'ij

3 j &, ~o
)}. & & &~

\) & j,
\) &oc &.

1.

j ~o,
) { , ) j 3

146. 2. ~
31, 3 & Ojj
6 { 213d 3,

( ), .. j

..

Fritz,

).., .

& o~ ~o j &
j 6r \)\).

'
31

23.

(,

11, 17.

], 66 6

[sc.

' ;

. 6 , , 6, ,
a '6a ')

aEV

;
' 6 OC6 OC ~
OC) ~ ococ 06) OC ~ OC
ococ ') ~oc

oc~ OC). OC 63 OC oc'~O,


oc oc OCoc~ OC), oc oc ~
3) oc OCoc (' 34a, 38b 59a-b).

24.

, 6

[sc.

36.

, ,
.

' ) 6
. , ),

EtaE,

, , 6 ~
a .
' ) F.D. Caizzi,

Antjsthenjs Fragmenta, . 124 oc G. Giannantoni, SR, . 3, . 187, OC30 OC ~


ococ oOCL~ )' oc OC) j oj
':" , ~ oc ) OC6 OCoc ()

[=' ) 37])

oc ~ OC6 oc

) () oc 25-26 [ = ) 77]).

25.

, oxt '

35.


6,
-!;;

, , 6

32

Lj OC

OC aLL L jO LO , OC
L, , OC jL;

26.

11 11.

6 6

, ' 6 ".
f5T 6 '

fj /f , '
' ' ; a
6 ' " '
'

, :> "
6 6.

pj, 6 ,; ~ OC OL

L, L '; LL OL L '; 6

"
xtXL\ OL

a.

'

'
,

-,

Lj, ,; j :

M~ LL ,; a L xxt

~
LL

'
j,

xtXL\

\ "

'
-

~ aL, '; xxt ';

xtXL\

\ ''
\ "LL ; 'L\ ' tXLtX \

xtXL\
,
'
\
'
\,
\
Lj L L L, LL LL
~p, OC OC aL ~ OC

L aL pLO L~ a ~p 6

'
jpO

"

t:'

r"

"

c,L LL -

L a ~ ~ .
A~ ~ )

ka,

F. Dumrler, Akademi-

. 3, p~ 8) ~ xpxo~ '1j xp~ crK"fJv~

86 , . 80.

6) Dtimmler
-

Tou Lovou, a: { '


6 , oJ'
, 24, 15 . 22, 27.

27.

, V

[sc.

25, 1.

] ,

' 17 { , '
4> .

]~Po '
~ ] ' ],
] ...

28.

, 6

10.

' , 3, , d ,
' {,

xpn

' , [

' ' r;;

] : , , ], -
- ], a a ~ ], .
~ ] ' . ] ~,
' jp .
;

, ' op~ . Tou ,,:u


. - - pJ opoJP~
) a ~ a~ . 6
yV l, . u . . a
a. . ) ),
, a,,: . pJ ~
) - a- aoc, a aoc . '

6, oc . . xocTL
.U . ' ..

krates

Xenophons Symposion,

22,

Fritz, Antisthenes und So-

":0

U OC . . ' ;

aEV , u ) ' 'J 3.