You are on page 1of 17

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011


IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
I N D E X
Sr. No. Particulars Page No. C. Fee
1. Noti*e of +otion
2. Ur,ent !))-i*ation ($.2../
3. +emo of Partie$
0. Contem)t Petition %nder
$e*tion 12 of the *ontem)t of
*o%rt$ a*t1 12.1.
/. !))-i*ation for 34em)tion from
fi--in, ori,ina- do*%ment$.
6. !NN35U(3 !61
.. #a7a-tnama
COUN839 FO( :;3 P3:I:ION3(8
N3W <39;I
<!:3<:
NOTICE OF OTION
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
:o
:he Ca=inet 8e*retar>1
Ca=inet 8e*retariat1
(a$htra)ati ?ha@an1
NeA <e-hi.
8ir/+adam
:he en*-o$ed )etition in the afore$aid matter a$ =ein, fi-ed on
=eha-f of the Petitioner i$ -i7e-> to =e -i$ted on BBBB or an>
date thereafter. P-ea$e ta7e noti*e a**ordin,->.
! "
COUN839 FO( :;3 P3:I:ION3(8
N3W <39;I
<!:3<:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
URGENT APPLICATION
:O
:;3 (3CI8:(!(1
<39;I ;IC; COU(:1
N3W <39;I
;onD=-e 8ir
&ind-> treat the a**om)an>in, *ontem)t )etition (*i@i-) a$ an
%r,ent one in a**ordan*e Aith the <e-hi ;i,h Co%rt (%-e$ and
order$. :he ,ro%nd of %r,en*> i$:6
#URGENT ORDERS FOR PUNISHING THE
RESPONDENT FOR WILFULL$ DISO%E$ING
THE &UDGENT'DECREE DATED ().*(.(+*+
PASSED %$ THIS HON,%LE COURT IN THE
PRESENT SUIT- %$ PROSECUTING HI FOR
IPRISONENT ARE PRA$ED FOR.
! "
COUN839 FO( :;3 P3:I:ION3(
N3W <39;I
<!:3<:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
EO OF PARTIES
1. Union of India
2. Pra$ar ?harti
#er$%$
!& 'ain "..(e$)ondent
! "
COUN839 FO( :;3 P3:I:ION3(
N3W <39;I
<!:3<:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
CONTEPT PETITION UNDER SECTIONS
** / *( OF THE CONTEPT OF COURTS
ACT- *01*
+o$t (e$)e*tf%--> 8hoAeth:
I. :hat the )re$ent Contem)t Petition (Ci@i-) i$ =ein,
)referred => the re$)ondent$ a,ain$t the )etitioner for
*ommittin, Ai--f%- di$o=edien*e of the E%d,ment
de*ree dated 20.12.2010 )a$$ed => thi$ ;onD=-e Co%rt
in the a=o@ementioned Arit )etition1 => the )etitioner.
It i$ mo$t h%m=-> $%=mitted that the )etitioner ha@e
*ate,ori*a--> fai-ed to *om)-> Aith the dire*tion$ of the
;onD=-e ;i,h Co%rt in the afore$aid mentioned Arit
)etition to *ond%*t and re*ord *orre*t findin, in the
!C( re)ort of the re$)ondent$ for the >ear$ 12236
1220 and a-$o in the >ear$ FGH and ha@e =een
a=$tainin, from *om)-ian*e of the *o%rt order ti-- date.
II. :hat the re$)ondent i$ =ein, $%=Ee*t to hara$$ment
and ha$ =een $%=Ee*t to de)artmenta- e4)-oitation =>
den>in, him hi$ -e,a- ri,ht$. It i$ )ertinent to mention
herein that at fir$t the de)artment had Ai--f%--> and
ne,-i,ent-> re*orded the !C($ of the re$)ondent and
f%rther ha$ fai-ed to remo@e the taint e@en on $)e*ifi*
dire*tion$ of thi$ ;onD=-e Co%rt. It i$ imminent to
mention that in the E%d,ement dt 20.12.2010 the
;onD=-e Co%rt had a))re*iated the fo--oAin, in *onte4t
of the *a--o%$ne$$ of the )etitioner$ in )ara 13 of the
E%d,ement Ahi*h i$ =ein, reiterated a$ fo--oA:6
Iwe need to express our anguish at the manner in
which service records of senior officer of the
government are being maintained and at the
callousness with which ACRs recorded. Indeed, it
shocks the court that so callous is the manner of
recording of ACR that for the year !!"#!!" and
the year !!$#!!%, one self assessment proforma
pertaining to only year has been photocopied and
used as basis to pen the ACR grading for the next
year.&
It i$ -i,ht of $%*h findin,$ the re$)ondent $ee7$ the ind%-,en*e
of the ;onD=-e *o%rt to @o%*h for the ,ra@it> of the $it%ation
and a-$o the fa*t that not on-> the re$)ondent ha$ $%ffered
d%e to admini$trati@e -a4it> or ne,-i,en*e for -a$t man> >ear$1
=%t ha$ noA in t%rn =ein, denied the fr%it of the
E%d,ement/order dt 20.12.2010 d%e to non *om)-ian*e of the
order => the )etitioner. It i$ imminent to mention herein that
$%*h ne,-e*t and Ai--f%- di$o=edien*e => the )etitioner in
term$ of a=$tainin, to re*ord the *orre*t !C($ ha$ -ed to
de)artmenta- hara$$ment of the re$)ondent1 Aho in t%rn i$
=ein, denied )romotion. :he fa*t$ in =rief *%-minatin, into the
)re$ent *ontem)t are =ein, narrated for the referen*e of thi$
;onD=-e Co%rt:66
1. :hat the re$)ondent i$ an offi*er of Indian
!dmini$trati@e 8er@i*e$ (12..) =at*h1 Na,a-and
*adre. :he re$)ondent ha$ maintained an
o%t$tandin, $er@i*e re*ord and ha$ $er@ed the
*o%ntr> Ahi-$t maintainin, the hi,he$t $tandard$
of inte,rit> and $er@i*e )rofi-e. :he re$)ondent
ha$ =een a))ointed at @ario%$ )o$t
*ommen$%rate to hi$ $er@i*e re*ord$ at the
re$)e*ti@e time and )re$ent-> i$ $er@in, a$
mem=er(finan*e) Pra$ar ?harti. It i$ mo$t
h%m=-> $%=mitted that d%e to the a=$tainment
of the )etitioner i$ remo@in, the anoma->/taint
in the !C($ of the re$)ondent1 the re$)ondent
ha$ =een denied hi$ a--e@iation to the )o$ition of
the !dditiona- 8e*retar> to Co@ernment of India1
Ahi*h e@en a$ )er the order of ;onD=-e Prin*i)a-
?en*h of Centra- !dmini$trati@e :ri=%na- dt
06/08/2010 Aa$ to =e done retro$)e*ti@e-> and
notiona--> a,ain$t Ahi*h the )etitioner had
)referred the )re$ent Arit )etition Ahi*h Aa$
di$mi$$ed in -imine. :he ;onD=-e *o%rt Aa$
)-ea$ed to %)ho-d the order of the Centra-
!dmini$trati@e :ri=%na- in fa@o%r of the
re$)ondent. It i$ mo$t h%m=-> $%=mitted that
the )re$ent Ai-f%-- di$o=edien*e of the )etitioner
in *om)->in, Aith the *o%rt order dt 20.12.2010
ha$ *a%$ed h%mi-iation to the re$)ondent a$
mo$t of hi$ =at*h mate$ at )re$ent ha@e =een
a))ointed a$ $e*retar> to ,o@ernment of India1
Ahi-e the re$)ondent for no fa%-t of hi$ i$ $%=Ee*t
to hara$$ment and h%mi-iation d%e to
taint/anoma-> in hi$ !C($ =ein, )re$ent d%e to
)etitioner$ -a4it>.
2. :hat the em)ane-ment of the offi*er$ in the )o$t
of !dditiona- 8e*retar>/ 8e*retar> to
Co@ernment of India i$ done on merit of $er@i*e
)rofi-e of the offi*er *on*erned. It i$ mo$t
h%m=-> $%=mitted that $%*h a))ointment i$ done
=> the *ommittee of the $e*retarie$ and a$ )er
a))-i*a=-e r%-e$1 10 >ear$ !C($ )re*eedin, the
>ear Ahen the *ommittee meet$ are *on$idered.
It i$ th%$ imminent to mention that for $%*h
e-e@ation of the re$)ondent !C($ $)annin, from
>ear 122361220 ti-- the >ear 200/62006 are to
=e *on$idered. ;oAe@er the re$)ondent ha$
=een denied $%*h e-e@ation d%e to infirmit> in
the !C( ,radin, of a))e--ant1 )ertainin, to the
>ear 12236201 122062/1 2002603 2003600.
3. :hat it i$ mo$t h%m=-> $%=mitted a$ far a$ the
infirmit> in the !C($ of the re$)ondent
)ertainin, to the >ear 122361220 i$ *on*erned it
i$ $%=mitted that the ;onD=-e Prin*i)a- ?en*h of
the Centra- !dmini$trati@e :ri=%na- fo%nd that
$%*h !C($ Aere =ein, *ond%*ted on the =a$i$ of
the $ame $e-f a$$e$$ment )roforma =ein, %$ed
for =oth the >ear$J one =ein, ori,ina- and the
$e*ond one =ein, )hoto*o)>. It i$ f%rther $tated
that $%*h !C($ Aere re*orded on-> in the >ear
1222 i.e. after 6 >ear$ of the >ear 122361220
and / >ear$ a$ far a$ !C( of 12206122/ i$
*on*erned. F%rthermore the )etitioner had
a--oAed one of it$ offi*er to a*t a$ re)ortin,
offi*er1 Aho had not e@en $%)er@i$ed the
Aor7in, of the re$)ondent for the >ear$ 12236
1220 and 12206122/.
0. It i$ f%rther $%=mitted that a$ far a$ !C($ of the
>ear 200262003 2003620001 the )etitioner had
ne,-i,ent-> a--oAed the re@ieAin, offi*er to
red%*e the ,radin, of the re$)ondent from
Ko%t$tandin,D to K,oodD and K@er> ,oodLD Aitho%t
$tatin, *o,ent rea$on$ for $%*h red%*tion Ahi*h
o%,ht to ha@e =een $tated and a$ $%*h the a*t$
of the )etitioner i$ doin, $o Aa$ not Aarranted
and the ;onD=-e Co%rt had ordered the )etitioner
to remo@e infirmit> in $%*h !C($ => Aa> of
*ond%*tin, and re re*ordin, $%*h !C($ and had
f%rther dire*ted the )etitioner to re*on$ider the
*andidat%re of the )etitioner.
/. :hat1 hoAe@er the )etitioner ha@e ti-- date not
)aid an> heed to the E%d,ement/order of ;onD=-e
;i,h Co%rt and ha$ f%rther on =ein, informed
=> the re$)ondent @ide hi$ -etter dated 12
th
'an%ar>1 20111 11
th
'%->1 2011 f%rther @ide
-etter dt 23
rd
8e)tem=er1 2011 ha@e fai-ed to
e@en intimate the )ro*e$$ and ha@e =een a$
$%*h => *ond%*t ha@e Ai-f%--> di$o=e>ed the
order of the ;onD=-e Co%rt.
III. It i$ mo$t h%m=-> $%=mitted that the )etitioner ha@e
not e@en initiated the de)artmenta- )ro*e$$ to *om)->
Aith the order$ of the ;onD=-e *o%rt and ha@e =>
@irt%e of $%*h *ond%*t tran$,re$$ed o@er the ri,ht$ of
the re$)ondent$ to =e a))ointed a$ the additiona-
$e*retar> retro$)e*ti@e-> $in*e 200. and a$ $%*h
$ho%-d ha@e =een a))ointed 8e*retar> to Co@ernment
of India had the )etitioner not *a%$ed the taint to
ari$e in the !C($ of the re$)ondent$. It i$ herein
$%=mitted that $%*h a*t of the )etitioner ha$ *a%$ed
hara$$ment a$ Ae-- a$ h%mi-iation to the re$)ondent
Aho for no fa%-t of hi$ i$ =ein, for*ed to =e $er@in,
the )etitioner at a E%nior )o$t and i$ $%=Ee*t to re)ort
to hi$ fe--oA offi*er$ E%nior to him in term$ of )o$tin,
in$)ite of ha@in, merit to =e a))ointed a$ additiona-
$e*retar> a$ )er the E%d,ment/order dt 20.12.2010 of
thi$ ;onD=-e ;i,h Co%rt.
I#. P R A $ E R
In @ieA of the a=o@e mentioned fa*t$ and *ir*%m$tan*e$ it i$
mo$t h%m=-> and re$)e*tf%--> )ra>ed in the intere$t of E%$ti*e
that :
a) the re$)ondent =e )%ni$hed for Ai-f%--> di$o=e>in, the
E%d,ment/de*ree dated 20.12.2010 )a$$ed => thi$
;onD=-e Co%rt in the )re$ent $%it1 => )ro$e*%tin, him for
im)ri$onment.
=) Pa$$ $%*h other or f%rther order a$ thi$ ;onD=-e Co%rt
ma> deem$ fit and )ro)er in the fa*t$ and *ir*%m$tan*e$
of the *a$e and in the intere$t of E%$ti*e.
P3:I:ION3(
:;(OUC;
( )
!<#OC!:3
N3W <39;I
<!:3<:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
AFFIDA2IT
I1 !& 'ain 8/o 8h. 1 !,ed a=o%t >ear$1 (/o BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
1. :hat I am a re$)ondent and f%--> a%thori$ed and
em)oAered in the a=o@e noted *a$e. ?ein, $o I am Ae--
*on@er$ant Aith the fa*t$ of the *a$e and *an de)o$e Aith
re$)e*t thereto.
2. :hat I ha@e read and %nder$tood the *ontent$ of the
a**om)an>in, a))-i*ation and the fa*t$ $tated are tr%e and
*orre*t to =e$t of m> 7noA-ed,e. :he $ame =e read a$ )art
of thi$ affida@it and the $ame are not =ein, re)eated for the
$a7e of =re@it>.
<3PON3N:
#3(IFIC!:ION:6
#erified at <e-hi on thi$ da> of '%->1 2011 that the
*ontent$ of the a=o@e affida@it are tr%e and *orre*t to m>
7noA-ed,e and nothin, ha$ =een *on*ea-ed there from or
$tated fa-$e therein.
<3PON3N:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
APPLICATION UNDER SECTION *3* OF CODE
OF CI2IL PROCEDURE FOR EXEPTION FRO
FILING THE ORIGINAL- T$PED COPIES OF
THE ANNEXURES
(e$)e*tf%--> 8hoAeth :
1. :hat the Petitioner$ ha@e )referred the a**om)an>in,
*ontem)t )etition (*i@i-) a,ain$t the e4e*%tion
)etition1 *ontent$ of the $ame =e read a$ )art and
)ar*e- of thi$ a))-i*ation a$ the $ame are not =ein,
re)eated herein for the $a7e of =re@it>.
2. :hat a-on,Aith the a))-i*ation/o=Ee*tion1 the
Petitioner ha$ fi-ed tr%e *o)> of !nne4%re !6 to !61 for
read> referen*e and *on@enien*e of thi$ ;onD=-e
Co%rt.
3. :hat d%e to ,ra@e %r,en*> in the matter1 the
Petitioner$ $ee7$ e4em)tion from fi-in, the ori,ina-/
t>)ed *o)ie$ of the dim anne4%re$. :he Petitioner1
hoAe@er %nderta7e$ to )-a*e the t>)ed *o)ie$ of the
$aid anne4%re$ Aith in a $hort )eriod of time.
P R A Y E R
It i$1 therefore1 mo$t h%m=-> )ra>ed that the Petitioner$
ma> 7ind-> =e e4em)ted from fi-in, the ori,ina-/ t>)ed
*o)ie$ of the dim anne4%re$1 in the intere$t of E%$ti*e.
!n> other or f%rther re-ief ($) Ahi*h thi$ ;onD=-e Co%rt
deem$ fit and )ro)er in the fa*t$ and *ir*%m$tan*e$ of the
*a$e and in the intere$t of E%$ti*e =e a-$o )a$$ed in fa@o%r
of the Petitioner$ and a,ain$t the re$)ondent.
P3:I:ION3(8
:;(OUC;
( )
!<#OC!:3
N3W <39;I
<!:3<:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
AFFIDA2IT
I1 !& 'ain 8/o 8h. 1 !,ed a=o%t >ear$1 (/o BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
1. :hat I am a re$)ondent and f%--> a%thori$ed and
em)oAered in the a=o@e noted *a$e. ?ein, $o I am Ae--
*on@er$ant Aith the fa*t$ of the *a$e and *an de)o$e Aith
re$)e*t thereto.
2. :hat I ha@e read and %nder$tood the *ontent$ of the
a**om)an>in, a))-i*ation and the fa*t$ $tated are tr%e and
*orre*t to =e$t of m> 7noA-ed,e. :he $ame =e read a$ )art
of thi$ affida@it and the $ame are not =ein, re)eated for the
$a7e of =re@it>.
<3PON3N:
#3(IFIC!:ION:6
#erified at <e-hi on thi$ da> of '%->1 2011 that the
*ontent$ of the a=o@e affida@it are tr%e and *orre*t to m>
7noA-ed,e and nothin, ha$ =een *on*ea-ed there from or
$tated fa-$e therein.
<3PON3N:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
C.C.P(O) NO. OF 2011
IN
WP (C) NO 3361/2008
In the matter of:
Union of India !nr .".Petitioner
#er$%$
!.& 'ain ""(e$)ondent
COPLETE COURT FEE
( )
!<#OC!:3
N3W <39;I
<!:3<: