Case: 09-56073

11/20/2009

Page: 1 of 6

DktEntry: 7138870

R 9 t 1 ùV E D ' â ï Mi %

è, % l F l % u)&%7 i. Lt ,) '
Nv 2222 0 28
..

1

RI HARD 1FNE,nP oPe C .I I r r

coMe ' Ce la Ji / ns n l al 3 4 Ba c e Sre 41 u h t tet s g ls CA 0 1 4 Lo An ee, 9 0 2 5 UM TED S TATESCOURTOFAPP EALS
6

PinrD#1237 roeI 846 s

L E ' D I QT

jyu xj

FOR THE M NTH CG CUI T
8 9 1 0 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 5

RI I 1F NE, CIARD . I Ap eln a dPeio e, p l t n tin r a t
VS .

CaeNo 0 -6 7 s . 95 0 3

D.. . :9c-11 JW ( C No20-v094 F CW) R LE TF RJDII I EQ TS O U C A ,

S I RIFOFLOSANGEL FE F ES COUNT e a, Y, t 1 Ap ele a dRep n e t p l s n so d ns e

NOTI OFE ' M P LL E CE NIRE E AT I DIT CT' S LF RECUS SI S RI S E M N T t TURGEON'AP EALS HE & S ' P

Ap eln rsetul rqet ta teC utaejdca nt eo te pl t ep cfl eusshth ortk uiil oi fh a y c
atc e lte d td No e e 9 2 0 ,n n t ig te sl- c slo a1 t h d etr ae v mb r , 0 9 n omcn h ef e u a f 1 a r

jscso teScn ApeleDi it Cafri C uto Apelwi ute f h eod plt s c, lona or f pa, t i a k i h
rsett tecretap a u dr yi tematro Sugo v Co nvo ep c o h urn p el n ewa n h te f tren . u t . f L sAn ee, A Comt S p r rCo r CaeNo 8C3 1 8 . o g ls L t y u ei u t s . 5 7 6 o
T e Co r i as rq etd t tk n t e o te S c n Ap elt h u t s lo eu se o a e oi f h eo d p lae c
Dilc' pirta se o te cs o i frta p a,a e ie c d b te s its ro rn fr f h ae n t t p el s vd n e y h s s

atc e cp o i lt rdtdMa 1 , 0 7 t h d o y ft et ae y 0 2 0 . a s e

I

Case: 09-56073

11/20/2009

Page: 2 of 6

DktEntry: 7138870

1
2 3 5 6 8 9

T erlv n eo teed cme t i ta ic nrdcstefleifrn e h ee a c fh s ou ns s h tt o ta it h as nee c
o Ap ele L S p ro Co r adJ d eDa i P. fesa s r gb ifh t f p l s A u eir ut n u g vd Yaf' nwei re ta e n

4 Jd eYaf wa n t biae t rc s hmsli teisa t %e u g fe s o o l td o eue i efn h ntn c . g

T eedomet cntuefcsntraoal sbetodsue ' e hs o l ns ostt at o esnby ujc t i t. F i p h
LEGALS TANDARD

7 ddn t o t Ap eln' atninu t afw dy ao i o cme o p l ts t t ni e a s g . a e o l 1 c A c ut ypo el tk n tc o ' atr o p bi rc r'plsa to o rma rp r a e oie f' t s f u l eod' t u n t y m e c r

1 FdrlR l o E ec scin2 1t teetn te aentsbett 1 eea ue f Wdne et 0 o h xethy r o ujc o o 1 2 1 raoal dsue f ev C o L sAnee, 5 F3 6 8 69(t C 3 esnbe i t. e . # f o gl 2 0 .d 6 , 8 9h k. p s 1 20) S c rcrs yZcueamii aieeod,eotadpoeue. 4 01. uh eod ma ld d ns t rcrsrpr n rcdrs lv s 1 5 Se e .ItrttNaua G sC .. otenC lonaGa C .2 9F2 e, .,nes e trl a o v Suhr airi s o, 0 .d g a f 1 6 1 30 3 5(t Ci 15)C isa.n.. iB n A tmae Sx,n.98 7 8, 8 9h r 93. ontrIcv Con ak uo td j Ic, 9 . , 1 F.Sp . 19 11 ( D. l19) 8 u p 10, 14N. Ca.98. 1 9
2 0

2 1
2 2 2 3

CONCLUS ON I

T ealg t n i teisa tap a a dt eligP tin frWrto h l ai s n h n tn p e l n mdryn eio o i f e o t

2 Ha e Co saeieria l itr n dwi teise rie i teatc e 4 b % pu r n xrcby net e t h su s asd n h t h d t wi h a
2 5 2 6

dcmet.Acodnl,hsCori etldt t ejdca nteo tee ou ns crigy ti uts nie o a uiil oi fhs t k c

2 d cmet,a dAp eln teeoe se i cl rq et ta ti Co r tk 7 ou ns n p l t h rfr p cf al eu ss h t hs u t a e a i y

2 jddant eotedcmetietidaoe 8 ui l oi fh ol nsdnie bv. c l f
-2

Case: 09-56073

11/20/2009

Page: 3 of 6

DktEntry: 7138870

Dae ti / dyoNoe e,09 Repcfl sb td tdhs f a f vmbr20 set l umie, uy t
2

3 4

BY:

RI HARD 1FNE, C .I l P oPe nr r

8 9 1 0 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8

Case: 09-56073

11/20/2009

Page: 4 of 6

DktEntry: 7138870

P ROOF OF S ERW CE S AT OFCALWOR A, T E M COLNT OFL ANGE ES T Y OS L 1a F e S tl. My a desi 2 0 E. coi Sre,# 1 8 Ra c o m rd ote i d rs s 6 1 Vitra tet 0 , n h Do n u z C 9 2 0 mig e, A 0 2 .

o Noebr p , 09lsre tefrgigdcmetdsr e a n vm e # 20, evd h oeo ou n ecbd s n i
CI CE RE REQUES FOR JUDI AL NOTI OF ENTI M VELLATE T

' n DI TRI S S S CT' ELF RECUS ALS I T G TURGEON' APPEALS o N HE S

itrs dpre nti at nb dpst gat ecp teef whc wa neet atsi hs ci y eoin r oy hrol i s e i o i u h
e coe i asae e v lp ,wi p sa efl pe ad i teUntd Sae n lsd n eld n eo e t otg ul rp i, n h i tts h y e

Mala desda fl ws i d rse s ol : , o
Aao Mi h lF naa rn t el otn c P u B. ah al Bec L AWRENC B HAL E & CHOIP E EAC L N ,C 1OWet o d y Se 10 0 sBrawa ,t.2 0 GlnaeCA 921-29 edl, 1 011 Kei M. comik vn Mc r c BE N, DW AL&BUCI NTO ORR, UNGHAM 3 N. lonaS e 9 Cai ri ket f P. Bo 17 O. x 18 Vetr, 9 02 ntaCA 3 0 l

l etyaddcael epnl opr r t e tea o te id crf n elr,mdr eay f euymdrh lws fh Unt i t j e
Sae o Ameiaa dteSaeo Caio a h ttefrg ig i tu a d tts f rc n h tt f l mi,ta h oe on s r e n f
c re t or c.

E eue o ti / dyo Noe e, 09aRacoDo nuz xctd n hs U a f vmbr20,t nh mige,
(aiona zl r i. f

A-, N sz u Leo z: r/a
F S TL RED OT I E

e/1 2@ 1 :3 51/07 13

Case: 09-56073

6632 0 2 27:3

11/20/2009

Page: 5 of 6

J DCA UTH 1C U IIL AC H

DktEntry: 7138870

PG e/l AE l e

Co o App ud f eal
F UR HMP L A EDIT C O T B L T S RIT DilinOn vs e o 70BS'tSh 30 5 ha ub 0 e SnDig,C 9 11 a eo A 2: m . u f. eo/o co oapa c ïnoogkee o fpol o g

(1)4-70 696526
' y1r07 Ma 020

RB: A OLDP S RGBON, M . TU Pliofn Apelx an fad pl : a
M.

c u Yo L s Ne s o #r F o A cE ,
Dôednadke n el fnntn v dn. ooe g oz ( dcne .8 975) ol sNo 161

L s eg ony oB i18 o' l C utN . c52d Mg e
D C u sl H one: T eaoeeul ma hs e knfrettleutn as e tebv h bv- td * ab= ase dob orad se dh aoô ne z nmbr Pes dro=yftz caepnec oiql-soteCoro Ap elF a' u e. lae lat uue o sodne rnlm t h utf papolf le ' ' t b
Apel Dil.tDilmnOn,5 :Srd,ut3QS Dfz. lona*911 pl s o' vs e70 . e 'Si 0, = ôoCsi ri 2 0 . ue ki t e f ' ' . < SI NRN . N,Y,CL RK ' YP KI L B % ? . BY: - . . D C1 ' '
:' A1P me <. 1 a ;s c .

œ2 œt' .1 U . t , *uW . 2

Case: 09-56073

W *l * AWm =<W

11/20/2009

Page: 6 of 6

ku hz n Y 1 1 A ' zl za k Y + I . % um r- O I2

DktEntry: 7138870

l Nf W ' rwG œ WA

G KO'K X UT Q tFaX WR F C R/ MN CA M T A I MSSATCER D IS MKR I N LR/ MN T T A I

JOSEPH A,L ANE
DANIL F. FQ E TTER

Cmzt flpet r a pa
S ATE OF CALF A T IORNI
S N A FLAQDWRN KQ D F ZLT I IG

a oKUHS RN s r o T P IG mF 'SC N FO , OT DWC EO D LOR N RH R :5MGNF :ALFR I . F R G IO NA 2 9 3 001 fI) 3 7 0 Ea 8 0.00

Noe e 9 2 0 vmbr , 09 Fe eikK. lc, ekAd nsrtr rdrc Ohr h Clr/ miitao i S pe Coro C lona urme utf ai ri f 3 0Mt lt:S e 1t lo 5 Alie ket sFor s SnFacso CA 9 0 a rnic, 412
DerMrOhrc a . lih: 'Atl drdino teAd ns tv PeiigJsieo tiDititIa te ie o fh mii ii rsdn ut fls srcj m z la c l rq et gternfr fh fl wigmatreteP utAp tltDir tDiio eusi l t se o te ol n t t h orh p l e s i , vs n n la o e a to i On . e

8296, klSugo vC uto o A tlaea. 135Haod tren . ony fL s n ee,t1 TeuteotiDir hv rcsd msle fmtimae. hJscsfb si aeeue Ge e sr ls tr i s td v o l t Adioal,à FutApehtDirtDi. ecniee adrlo tepir dtnl te or pl e si, v0n os rd n ue nh ro i y h tc d rl e matr f rl S go v C u t o L s g lsea.cs nl e ea d t o Haod mren . o ny f o An ee.t 1 ae ' r t e . mb D003.Iteitrsojdcaeoo adui r t o dcs nteF ut 5 22 nh neetfuiilcnmy n nf ml f eii h or o y o h
Di itDi. e h udonie teao en n dap a. s c, v On so l o sdrh b v m e p el k T aky ufr o ass nei efdigt1rq etdkase. hn o o y m'siac u fe n h eu s nfr t e Sneey, hcrl / . D- ' te. P.otr P Che DeuyClr if p t ek

c : Kei LaeAsitn Clr / miikao c vn n, ssat ek Ad ns tr Fo rhAp elt Diec, v On ut p lae s tDi. e AlCopsl I ue Fl ie