You are on page 1of 6

Case: 09-56073 11/20/2009 Page: 1 of 6 DktEntry: 7138870

RM9i
'
ât% 1 ùV EïD
u.)
Lè&t,F
%%7,
%i)l-
l'
N0v 222228
1 RICHARD 1.FINE,InProPer
PrisonerID#1824367 L'
IQTED .. jxyju
c/oMen'sCenlalJail
3 441BauchetStreet
4 LosAngeles,CA 90012
5 UM TED STATESCOURTOFAPPEALS
6
FOR THE M NTH CG CUIT
8
9 RICIIARD 1.FINE, CaseNo.09-56073
10
AppellantandPetitioner,
D.C.No.2:09-cv-01914JFW (CW)
VS.
12 REQLTESTFORJUDICIAI,
NOTICE OFENI'IREM PELLATE
13 SFIERIFFOFLOSANGELES DISTRICT'SSELF-RECUSM SIN
14 COUNTY,eta1, THE t&STURGEON''APPEALS
AppelleesandRespondents
15
16
17 AppellantrespectfullyrequeststhattheCourttakejudicialnoticeofthe
18 attached letter dated November9,2009,nnnotmcing the self-recusalof a11
19
20 justicesoftheSecondAppellateDiskict,CaliforniaCourtofAppeal,with
21 respecttothecurrentappealunderwayinthematterofSturgeonv.Countvo.f
22
LosAngeles,LA CotmtySuperiorCourtCaseNo.8C351786.
23
The Courtis also requested to take notice ofthe Second Appellate
25
Dislict'spriortransferofthe case on itsftrstappeal,asevidenced by the
attachedcopyofitsletterdatedMay10,2007.
I Case: 09-56073 11/20/2009 Page: 2 of 6 DktEntry: 7138870

1 Therelevanceofthesedocumentsisthatitcontradictsthefalseinference
2
ofAppelleesLA SuperiorCourtandJudgeDavidP.Yaffe'sansweringbriefthat
3
4 JudgeYaffewasnotobligatedtorecusehimselfintheinstantc%e.
5
6 Thesedoolmentsconstitutefactsnotreasonablysubjecttodispute.'
Fhe
7 didnotcometoAppellant'sattentionuntilafew daysago.
8
LEGALSTANDARD
9
1c A courtmayproperlytakenoticeof''
mattersofpublicrecord''ptlrsuantto
11 FederalRuleofEWdencesection201totheextenttheyarenotsubjectto
12
13 reasonabledispute.feev.C# ofLosAngeles,250F.3d668,689(9thCk.
14 2001).SuchrecordsmayZcludeadminislativerecords,reportsandprocedures.
15
16
See,e.g.,InterstateNaturalGasCo.v.SouthernCali forniaGasCo.,209F.2d
17 380,385(9thCir.1953). ,Coinstar.Inc.v.CoinBankAutomatedSjx,Inc.,998
18 F.Supp.1109,1114(N. D.Cal.1998).
19
20
21 CONCLUSION
22
23
Theallegationsin theinstantappealandtmderlyingPetition forWritof
24 Habe% Copusareinexr
tricablyintertwinedwiththeissuesraisedintheattached
25
26
documents.Accordingly,thisCourtisentitledtotakejudicialnoticeofthese
27 documents,andAppellanttherefore specifically requeststhatthisCourttake
28 judidalnoticeofthedocllmentsidentifiedabove.

-2-
Case: 09-56073 11/20/2009 Page: 3 of 6 DktEntry: 7138870

Datedthis /f dayofNovember,2009 Respectfullysubmitted,


2
3 BY:
4 RICHARD 1.FINE,
lnProPer

8
9
10

12
13
14
15
16

18
19
20
21
22

24
25
26
27
28
Case: 09-56073 11/20/2009 Page: 4 of 6 DktEntry: 7138870

PROOF OF SERW CE

STATE OFCALWORM A,
COLTNTY OFLOSANGELES

1am FredSottile. My addressis2601E.VictoriaStreet,# 108,Rancho


Dominguez,CA 90220.
onNovember p#,2009,lservedtheforegoingdocumentdescribedas
REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE OF ENTIRE M VELLATE
DISTRICT'S SELF-RECUSALS IN THE GSTURGEON'' APPEALS on
interestedpartiesinthisactionbydepositingat
ruecopythereoflwhichwas
enclosed in asealed envelope,with postagefullyprepaid,in theUnited States
Mail,addressedasfollows:
AaronMitchellFontana KevinM.Mccormick
PaulB.Beach BENTON,ORR,DW AL&BUCIUNGHAM
LAWRENCEBEACHALLEN& CHOI,PC 39N.CaliforniaSkeet
10OWestBroadway,Ste.1200 P.O.Box1178
Glendale,CA 91210-1219 Venttlra,CA 93002
lcertifyanddeclare,lmderpenaltyofperjurytmderthelawsoftheUnited
StatesofAmericaandtheStateofCalifomia,thattheforegoing istrueand
correct.
Executedonthis /U dayofNovember,2009,atRanchoDominguez,
(zalifornia.
AL-
ze,:o N szr/ua
FRED SOTTILE
e5/11/20@7 11:33 6262372:03 JUDICIALUATCH 1HC PAGE el/el
Case: 09-56073 11/20/2009 Page: 5 of 6 DktEntry: 7138870

Coud ofAppeal
FOURTHMPBLLATEDISTRICT
DivlsionOne
750BSh'eatSuhb300
SanDiego,CA 921:1
m .couïnfo.ogegok/eoe coo ofappoal
(619)645-2760
'May10r2007

RB: AM OLDP.STURGBON,
PlainoffandAppellax:
M.
cou#rYoFLosANecEs,
Dôfendnntandkev ndenl.
oogeoz
(oldcnseNo.8196715)
Los'MgelegCountyNo.Bci5128d
DH Counsel:
Theabove-enutledma* hasbe=kansferzedtotbleourtandasse edtheabovô
number.Pleasedlraot=yfutuzecoaespondenceorinqlllm-estotheCourtofAppea
'lpFoal'
t'fb
AppellueDiskiotDivl
l. '
-smnOne,
'750:S.tred,
'Suite30Q,S= Dfôz
'<o.
.
Cslifornia*92101.

S'IYPNRN .KIN,
LY,CLBRK
%
? .
BY: - . .
D C1 ''
:
<c'. A11.Pame
;s
œ.2.tœ,t2'*.u1WU WAWm*l=<W* kzulumhzzarnk- YYO 1+1I A.I'%2 lrNwfG Wœ'WA
Case: 09-56073 11/20/2009 Page: 6 of 6 DktEntry: 7138870

JOSEPH A,LANE
GWRKOF'TKCX URT/AQMt
NIFCaAXM
aooKUTHSPRI NGsmFr
'SECONDFLOOR,NORTHDWCR
Cmzrtaflppeat :.25MGFNFR:GALIFORNI
90013
A
DANIEL F. FQTTER STATE OF CALIFORNIA fEIa)830.7000
MSISTANTCLERR/ADMI
NI
STMKR SKQNDAFFZLLATQDIWRI
GN-
November9,2009
FrederickK.Ohlrich,Clerk/Administrator
SupremeCourtofCalifornia
350MtAlliste:Skeet1stFloor
SanFrancisco,CA 94102

DearMr.Ohlrich:
'AttlzediredionoftheAdminislativiPresidingJusticeoftllisDistrictjIam
requestingtlletransferofthefollowingmattertethePourthApptllateDistriot,Division
One.
8219365,HakoldSturgeonv.Count yofLosAntelea,eta1.
TheJusticesoftbisDistridhaverecusedGemselvesfromtllismatter.
Additionally,tàeFourthAppelhteDistrict,Div.0neconsideredandruleontheprior
relatedmatterofHaroldSmrgeonv.CountyofLosAngeles.eta1..casen'lmber
D050232.IntheinterestofjudicialeconomyanduniformltyofdecisiontheFourth
Diskict,Div.Oneshouldoonsidertheabovenmnedappeal.
Thankyouforyom'assistanceiueffedingth1requestedkansfer.
Shncerely,
/ .
D-P.'Potter.
ChiefDeputyClerk

cc: KevinLane,AssistantClerk/Adminiskator
FourthAppellateDisect,Div.One
AlICoupsel
File