Dear Congressman Chabot We are extremely troubled that you have chosen to cosponsor HR 3899, the Voting Rights Amendment Act. On behalf of our organizations, and of the millions we collectively represent, we respectfully request an opportunity to meet with you to discuss this bill and your participation with it. All of us share in the desire to protect every Americans right to vote and to prevent any repeat of the shameful episodes in American history, when those rights were legally, often violently, denied to many of our nations citizens. However, HR 3899, the Voting Rights Amendment Act, is a step backward, not forward, in securing American voters rights. The truth is, this bill will fundamentally and intentionally change American elections into race-reliant battleelds where, for the rst time in our history, the United States, as a legal matter, would EXCLUDE a majority of Americans as a class from the full protection of federal law based solely on the color of their skin. It is our hope that you will take a stand in support of equal protection for the rights of all American voters by withdrawing your sponsorship of this racially discriminatory bill. HR 3899 was written in response to the U.S. Supreme Courts 2013 ruling to strike down an obsolete part of the 1965 Voting Rights Act that singled out certain states and local jurisdictions for federal oversight based on 50-year old data. Having long outlived its intended utility, this portion of the Act had in recent years become an easy mark for exploitation by partisan interests. It had also served as a transparent excuse for politically partisan federal ofcials to block common-sense election safeguards enacted by the states, such as photo voter ID. HR 3899 would grant even greater authority to Attorney General Eric Holder than was provided under the original Act itself. It is important to note that the Supreme Court left the rest of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, and its protections against intentional voter discrimination, intact and in so doing reafrmed that a citizens vote is a civil right guaranteed toALLAmericans. People interested in fair and honest elections the indispensable requirement for a free people were relieved when the Courts sensible ruling was announced. That is, until HR 3899 was introduced. This bill would not only send the nation backward, it would give Attorney General Eric Holder and this Administration a clear pathway to impose unprecedented federal oversight for any and all election law changes nationwide, not just in certain states as provided under the single section of the 1965 Voting Rights Act that the Supreme Court struck down.
Here are just a few of HR 3899s regressive requirements:
Forces racial gerrymandering, making race the predominant factor in election boundaries and advancing the partisan interests of one political party.
Offers only a vague denition of "voting rights violations that are needed to retrigger federal control of elections in a jurisdiction, and even allows objections made by the Attorney General himself to count as a violation and triggering event. Thus, Eric Holder can, in effect, use his own ndings of disparate impact vs. actual instances of discrimination, as he did with South Carolinas voter ID law until it was reversed, in order to justify placing a state under DOJspre- clearancecontrol.
RequiresthatStates be placed under DOJspre-clearancerequirements whenever DOJitself determines that ve voting rights violations occurred during a 15-year periodeven if a state is itself only cited for a single violation. This will impact a far greater number of states than the nine previously covered under the 1965 Act. Clearly, those nine states will immediately be put back under DOJs pre-clearance regime upon bill signing, but many more states, as well as state and local jurisdictions, will assuredly follow after myriad groups launch deliberate litigation campaigns to establish the minimal number of voting rights violations needed to trigger DOJ oversight.
Expands dramaticallythe Attorney Generals power to challenge any act prohibited by the 14th or 15th amendment of the U.S. constitution. Eric Holder -- the most partisan and ethically challenged Attorney General in U.S. history cannot be trusted with this kind of power. It would have allowed Attorney General Janet Reno to intervene in (or bring) the Bush v. Gore case. It extends the reach of the Attorney General in this area of law well beyond the authority granted him or her under the original Voting Rights Act in 1965, and the amendments to it since then. The possibilities for partisan mischief are limitless.
Actually codies racial discrimination INTO the law, protecting only certain categories of citizens, not all Americans, because it specically and explicitly excludes non-minorities from the full protection of the Voting Rights Act under some parts of the bill despite convictions and other documented Voting Rights Act violations by minorities, as well as non-minorities, across the country.
Congressman Chabot, given the wide range of issues you deal with on a daily basis, we understand you may not have been able to fully appreciate the ramications of HR 3899, as written. We will be glad to share our organizations analyses, discuss our concerns, and most importantly, work together to protect the hard won civil rights of all Americans by preventing this socially destructive, discriminatory piece of legislation from advancing before it is xed. Wewill contact your staff this week in an effort to coordinate a convenient meeting time in your Washington, D.C. ofce.
Sincerely,
Gregg Phillips Hon. Ken Blackwell Gen. Ed Meese VotersTrust SOSforSOS Super PAC American Civil Rights Union
Catherine Engelbrecht Christian Adams Anita MonCrief True the Vote Election Law Center Black Conservatives Fund
CC: Rep. Jim Sensenbrenner
Georgia Republican Delegation Rep. Jack Kingston Rep. Lynn Westmoreland Rep. Tom Price Rep. Rob Woodall Rep. Austin Scott Rep. Doug Collins Rep. Paul Broun Rep. Phil Gingrey Rep. Tom Graves Mississippi Republican Delegation Rep. Alan Nunnelee Rep. Gregg Harper Rep. Steven M. Palazzo North Carolina Republican Delegation Rep. Renee Ellmers Rep. Walter Jones Rep. Virginia Foxx Rep. Howard Coble Rep. Richard Hudson Rep. Robert Pittenger Rep. Patrick McHenry Rep. Mark Meadows Rep. George Holding Louisiana Republican Delegation Rep. Steve Scalise Rep. Charles Boustany Rep. John Fleming Rep. Vance McAlister Rep. Bill Cassidy Texas Republican Assembly Delegation Rep. Louie Gohmert Rep. Ted Poe Rep. Sam Johnson Rep. Ralph Hall Rep. Jeb Hensarling Rep. Joe Barton Rep. John Culberson Rep. Kevin Brady Rep. Michael McCaul Rep. Michael Conaway Rep. Kay Granger Rep. Mac Thornberry Rep. Randy Weber Rep. Bill Flores Rep. Randy Neugebauer Rep. Lamar Smith Rep. Pete Olson Rep. Kenny Marchant Rep. Roger Williams Rep. Michael Burgess Rep. Blake Farenthold Rep. John Carter Rep. Pete Sessions Rep. Steve Stockman