Ipen Irtdibixy, Iutrfkdt Deresy onb tde Irtdibix \elfrtd ic tde Hinservotfve Mivement

 Ovridim Kirbfmer

O tremenbius omiunt ic afteroture dos leen penneb oliut tde Ipen Irtdibix mivement, bepfhtfnk onb betofafnk fts hiuntaess, dofr-rofsfnk bevfotfins crim trobftfinoa Irtdibix prohtfhe onb tdiukdt, ronkfnk crim Ipen Irtdibix rollfs aillyfnk cir some-kenber morrfoke, ti Ipen Irtdibix synokikues distfnk onb primitfnk portnersdfp mfnyonfm (proyer kriups fn wdfhd wimen aeob ports ic tde servfhe), ti o vonkuorb Ipen Irtdibix fnstftutfin irbofnfnk wimen cir tde rollfnote, ti tde ciunbers ic Ipen Irtdibixy obvihotfnk cir tde rfkdt ti nin-doaohdfh hinversfins fn Eretz Vfsriea, ti Ipen Irtdibix fnterbenimfnotfinoa onb fntercoftd fnftfotfves tdot vfiaote wfbeay-ohhepteb onb prehebent doaohdfh ruafnks, ti Ipen Irtdibix rollfs espiusfnk deresy ic tde dfkdest irber.

?

 [dfae tde aost ocirementfineb ftem - tde emlrohe ic deresy ly Ipen Irtdibixy rollfs - wiuab oppeor ti le ine ic tde mony hinsequenhes ic o mivement tdot dos mobe tde recirm ic Irtdibix Gubofsm fts cihus, relronbfnk onb resdopfnk Irtdibixy ti cft o afleroa, ekoaftorfon vfsfin, tde dorb onb trokfh trutd fs tdot iutrfkdt deresy fs ot tde very hire ic tde fnteaaehtuoa enkfne tdot piwers tde Ipen Irtdibix mivement. Fn o Moy <<, <0?2 Coheliij pistfnk, \. Vsishder Jotz, hdofrmon ic tde Beportment ic Roamub ot Vesdfvot Hdivevef Rirod (VHR), tde Ipen Irtdibix rollfnfhoa shdiia ciunbeb ly \. Ovf [efss, beminstroteb dfs leafec tdot Rirod Xde-

l‖oa Ped

, tde Iroa Aow ic tde Roamub, fs nit Mf-Xfnof/Bfvfneay-kfven. Pistfnk in Coheliij oliut Mosehdes Xitod, Jotz wrftes7

F gust cfnfsdeb teohdfnk o yeor aink haoss in mosehdet Xitod, ine ic tde mist bfccfhuat trohtotes fn tde Roamub. Xfmpay reob, tde Lflafhoa prihebure seems hoprfhfius onb potrforhdoa. Rde rollfs brostfhoaay refnterpret tde prihess ti moje ft sensftfve onb ekoaftorfon. Rdey were tde prikressfves ic tdefr tfmes, onb, reaotfve ti tdefr mfafeu, tdey were qufte robfhoa.  Os F wos wroppfnk up tde haoss F reoafzeb diw auhjy hdozoa were tdot tdey were wrftfnk oliut twi tdiusonb yeors oki. Fc tdey wiuab dove leen wrftfnk tiboy, o Hdorefbf essoyfst mfkdt dove bulleb tdem robfhoa cemfnfsts, o MI essoyfst mfkdt dove hoaaeb tdem resdo'ofm, onb o MI laikker mfkdt dove "worneb" peipae nit ti le pditikropdeb wftd tdem. (Onb, wdi jniws, tdey mfkdt dove even kitten o Mfr \isd Vesdfvo upset eniukd ti hoaa cir tdefr murber.) Fn itder wirbs7 iur trobftfin wos oawoys oliut prikressfve hdonke, robfhoa hinservotfsm fs ohtuoaay o bevfotfin ic iur dfstirfhoa nirm.

Jotz osserts dfs leafec fn tde fnsensftfve onb lfkiteb presentotfin ic tde doaohdis ic Xitod os ceotureb fn tde [rftten Rirod, onb dfs vfew tdot Hdozoa colrfhoteb ir resdopeb tde Lflafhoa Xitod prihebure fnti tde versfin presenteb fn tde Roamub, fn irber ti recirm tde Xitod prihebure tiworb on ekoaftorfon vfsfin.

?

 \eobers ore obvfseb ti see dttp7//www.yuhimmentotir.irk/<0?8/?</ipen-irtdibixy-o-respinse-ti-rollf-sdmuay-yonjaiwftz/ onb ti ipen tde afnjs cir extensfve eaolirotfin onb hftotfins.

 

Jotz okofn expresseb dfs leafec tdot Rirod Xde-

l‖oa Ped

 wos hinhihteb ly Hdozoa onb fs nit Xonoftfh, fn dfs hrftfque ic RdeRirod.him, o welsfte run ly seac-becfnfnk Irtdibix Gews tdot regehts tde bfvfnfty ic tde ([rftten) Rirod. Jotz wrftes7

Unafje tde welsfte wdfhd hdise ti bfshorb trobftfinoa nitfins ic bfvfne outdirsdfp, tde \ollfs reoafzeb tdot tdese textuoa bfccfhuatfes ore on fnvftotfin ti emlorj in on okkressfve ottempt ti reevoauote nitfins ic textuoaay, trutd, coht onb dermeneutfhs wftdiut nehessorfay bfshorbfnk tde text's stotus onb stoture. Rdey were olae ti iccer fnnivotfve dermeneutfhs wdfhd oaaiweb tdem ti mofntofn iptfmoa cfbeafty ti tde nitfin ic tde text's bfvfnfty. Rdey bfb nit toje tde eosy riute ic regehtfnk tde trobftfin, nekotfnk fts outdirfty onb tden aettfnk tde "hdfps coaa wdere tdey moy" (os sime laikkers dove sukkesteb). Rdey fnsteob reoafzeb tdot reafkfius texts, onb tdeiaikfhoa tenets dove o lufat-fn omirpdiusness tdot oaaiws cir onb perdops even bemonbs  perpetuoa refnterpretotfin.

<

 

Rdfs benfoa ic tde ilgehtfve Mf-Xfnof outdirsdfp onb hdorohter ic Rirod Xde-

l‖oa Ped, pirtroyfnk tde Iroa

Aow os simetdfnk hinhihteb ir monfpuaoteb ly Hdozoa ti serve o sihfoa okenbo, fs dfkday prilaemotfh, ti put ft afkdtay. Xee \omlom Dfa. Resduvo 874, Jesec Mfsdned flfb., por. ? ic fntribuhtfin ti Mfsdned Rirod, onb por. 2 ic \omlom's fntribuhtfin ti Pefrusd Do-Mfsdnoyis. Xdirtay octer fssufnk dfs remorjs oliut tde outdirsdfp onb okenbo ledfnb tde doaohdis ic Xitod, Jotz spent Xdollis os tde shdiaor-fn-resfbenhe ot tde Hinservotfve Xynokikue ic Cfctd Ovenue, wdere de

beafvereb tde b‖vor Rirod

ot mirnfnk servfhes onb spije severoa tfmes oliut tde Xitod fssue, fnhaubfnk

on obbress entftaeb, ‑Ore \ollfs Priti

-

Cemfnfsts9 O Hrftfhoa \eobfnk ic Rrohtote Xitod”.

8

 Oatdiukd tde nitfin ic o dfkd-

ronjeb Roamub aehturer fn o yesdfvo‖s semfhdo

 prikrom spenbfnk Xdollis ot o nin-Irtdibix hinkrekotfin fs loccafnk, ft fs o testoment ti tde tdeiaikfhoa pisture ic Ipen

Irtdibix aeobersdfp. (Nit ti mentfin Jotz‖ tde

sfs onb tdeme ic bfshussfin, wdfhd hertofnay cft letter wftd o Hinservotfve irfentotfin tdon wftd on Irtdibix ine.) Mony ic us ore comfafor wftd tde wirbs ic \. Biv Afnzer, risd yesdfvo onb beon ic VHR, fn on ortfhae

2

 oliut perhefveb fnequftfes fn tde Roamub tiworb kentfaes. Afnzer write tdot oatdiukd sime Roamubfh ipfnfins hon le reob ti kront kentfaes mire covirolae

stonbfnk fn tde afmfteb oreo ic tde ortfhae‖s

bfshussfin,

tde doaojdo ciaaiws tde fnterpretotfin tdot tde Kemoro kfves ti tde stotements ic tde Rono‖fm onb

 Omi

ro‖fm. Nevertdeaess, mony himmftteb Gews ore icten aect ceeafnk tdot even wden doaojdfh siautfins

ore lefnk ciunb, tdey run hiunter ti tde etdis ic tde system, onb ore ti sime bekree bfsfnkenuius onb aohjfnk fn fntekrfty. "Xdiuab we le lenbfnk tde doaojdo ti hincirm ti iur mibern nitfins ic

<

 dttps7//www.coheliij.him/pditi.pdp9clfb=?0?5<<44;5;258386&set=o.?0?5??;0860<04386.25??02.5065<4384&type=? 

8

 dttp7//www.hsconyh.irk/event/wimon-suspehteb-lflafhoa-sitod-rollfs-sdollot-aeornfnk-rollf-ysishder-jotz/ Jotz fs servfnk os shdiaor-fn-resfbenhe okofn ot tdfs Hinservotfve hinkrekotfin7 dttp7//www.hsconyh.irk/event/sdollot-aeornfnk-rollf-ysishder-jotz/. 

2

 Mfafn Dovfvfn giurnoa, via. ?, p. 83

 

ekoaftorfonfsm9" fs o reosinolae questfin ti osj onb o dorb ine ti onswer. On dinest onswer requfres  cfnbfnk wftdfn tde Roamub tdise vifhes tdot ortfhuaote tdise some voaues tdot ore brfvfnk us.

Afnzer‖s

stotement tdot "'Xdiuab we le lenbfnk tde doaojdo ti hincirm ti iur mibern nitfins ic ekoaftorfonfsm9' fs o reosinolae questfin ti osj onb o dorb ine ti onswer" fs sdihjfnk onb speojs cir ftseac. Afnzer dos tojen tde tdeme ic hdoaaenkfnk Rirod outdirfty severoa steps curtder. Fn o sfmfaor vefn ti tde Jotz oppriohd, Afnzer wrftes (empdosfs mfne) rekorbfnk tde mftzvod ic Mehdfyos Omoaej/Ilafterotfnk Omoaej7

Rdree mftzvit7 Ine, rememler. Rwi, bi nit cirket. Onb tdree, sonbwfhdeb fn letween

‘ 

 yiu sdoaa lait iut tdefr memiry. Jfaa tdem, wfpe tdem iut. [dot pissflae messoke hon we aeorn crim tdfs mftzvod9 Kib fs o venkecua Kib. Sfiaenhe must le met wftd vfiaenhe. Even fnnihents

‘ 

 tde fnconts onb tde cuture beshenbonts ic tde irfkfnoa notfin - hon le saoukdtereb ly tde donb ic Fsroea wden Fsroea fs ciaaiwfnk

Kib‖s himmonb onb fs tde okent ic Kib‖s gustfhe.

 Fs tdfs tde messoke ic Omoaej9 Fs tdfs tde stiry tdot we teaa9 [e jniw tdot ft fs nit. Ft fs nit tde stiry tdot we os o peipae dove tiab. Dovfnk os o peipae leen  persehuteb onb saoukdtereb fn tde nome ic reafkfin, onb os wftness tiboy ti tde evfas tdot hon le  perpetroteb ly o murberius, cunbomentoafst reafkfius leafec

‘ 

 

tdfs oasi fs nit tde stiry tdot we hon ever teaa.

Rde mftzvod ti lait iut tde memiry ic Omoaej fs surriunbeb ly twi itder mftzvit, twi mftzvit ic memiry. Wojdir, rememler, onb ai tfsdjohd, bi nit cirket. Rde aotter, ohhirbfnk ti tde \ollfs, fs o himmonb ti rememler fn iur deorts, wdereos tde cirmer fs o himmonb ti verloafze tdot memiry, o mftzvod ti teaa o stiry. Diw bi we afve up ti tdese ilafkotfins9 [dot fs tde stiry we hdiise ti teaa onb wdot fs tde stiry we hdiise ti rememler9... Ft hon le deorb fn tde wirbs ic \ov Vojiv Hdoyfm Xicer ic Lokbob (?4;0-?686) wdi wrftes fn dfs doaojdfh moknum ipus tde Hoc DoHdoyfm tdot we mobe ni lrojdo wden we bi tde mftzvod ic rememlerfnk

 Omoaej, lehouse diw hiuab we moje o laessfnk iver tde stiry ic tde bestruhtfin ic Kib‖s

hreotures9 Onb tdfs de soys oliut o mftzvod tdot Kib dos himmonbeb! Ft fs o stiry ic o kroppafnk, yes, lut nit ine tdot aeobs ti resfknotfin ir regehtfin, lut ti tronscirmotfin. Ft fs o stiry oliut diw Omoaej stips lefnk o peipae wdim we must pdysfhoaay bestriy, onb fnsteob lehimes o symlia, on fbeo, tdot we must cfkdt okofnst, peohecuaay onb wftdiut vfiaenhe. Rdfs stiry hon le deorb fn tde wirbs ic \ov Xdfmsdin \opdoea Dfrshd, wdi stotes tdot we must bestriy nit Omoaej, lut zejder Omoaej, tde kairfcyfnk ic oaa tdey stiib cir.

5

 Rdfs fs o mftzvod oliut ippisfnk tde swirb, nit wfeabfnk ft. Omoaej represents o huature tdot voairfzes vfiaenhe onb tde swirb. Xuhd o huature

5

 \ov Dfrshd mist hertofnay bies

nit

wrfte tdot we must nit pdysfhoaay bestriy Omoaej. \otder, de wrftes tdot tde tdrust ic iur ippisftfin ti Omoaej fs tde erobfhotfin ic tde pdfaisipdy representeb ly Omoaej: \ov Dfrshd fn ni

monner ir sense pisfts tdot Omoaej nit le pdysfhoaay bestriyeb. Paeose see \ov Dfrshd‖s himments in Bevorfm

<57?;, fn wdfhd de expaofns rekorbfnk tde mfaftory iperotfins okofnst Omoaej wdfhd we ore himmonbeb ti percirm

tdot L‖nef Vfsriea ossu

me tde riae ic siabfers ic Dosdem rotder tdon os siabfers cfkdtfnk tdefr iwn wor.