You are on page 1of 21

OE 6200 - DESIGN OF OFFSHORE STRUCTURES - Tutorial 1

Design of Fatigue Damage of tubular Joint (Y-Joint) to API RP 2A


Given Data
Chord Dimensions D 762 mm := T
c
32mm :=
Brace Dimensions d 508 mm := t 20mm :=
Brace inclination 30deg :=
Length of Chord L
c
15m :=
Chord end fixity parameter C
c
0.7 :=
Fatigue design life DL 25yr :=
Period for Cycle Data TL 1 yr :=
Yield strength of material F
y
345 MPa :=
Y - Joint
Plan view of Y - Joint
Tutorial 1 1 of 21
Wave Data and Cycle information
Expense
time period
In-Plane
Bending stress
Out-of-Plane
Bending stress
Time period Axial Stress
T
1
6 sec := p
1
0.4 :=
ax1
5 MPa :=
ip1
8 MPa :=
op1
16MPa :=
T
2
6 sec := p
2
0.1 :=
ax2
5.5MPa :=
ip2
8 MPa :=
op2
12MPa :=
T
3
6 sec := p
3
0.1 :=
ax3
6 MPa :=
ip3
7 MPa :=
op3
16MPa :=
T
4
7 sec := p
4
0.05 :=
ax4
6.5MPa :=
ip4
9 MPa :=
op4
14MPa :=
T
5
8 sec := p
5
0.08 :=
ax5
8 MPa :=
ip5
6 MPa :=
op5
15MPa :=
T
6
8 sec := p
6
0.06 :=
ax6
9 MPa :=
ip6
9.5MPa :=
op6
12MPa :=
T
7
8 sec := p
7
0.06 :=
ax7
12MPa :=
ip7
10MPa :=
op7
13MPa :=
T
8
9.5sec := p
8
0.08 :=
ax8
15MPa :=
ip8
14MPa :=
op8
14MPa :=
T
9
9.5sec := p
9
0.05 :=
ax9
15.5 MPa :=
ip9
16MPa :=
op9
15MPa :=
T
10
9.5sec := p
10
0.02 :=
ax10
16MPa :=
ip10
15MPa :=
op10
16MPa :=
Basic Parameters Calculation
Geometry Definitions
forEfthymiou SCFs

D
2 T
c

:= 11.906 =

d
D
:= 0.667 =

t
T
c
:=
0.625 =

L
c
2 D
:= 9.843 =
"Correction factor not reqrd. " 12 > if
"apply Correction factor " 12 < if
:=
"apply Correction factor " =
Short Chord
Correction factors
F
1
1 0.83 0.56
2
0.02
( )

0.23
exp 0.21
1.16

2.5

( )
:= F
1
0.986 =
F
2
1 1.43 0.97
2
0.03
( )

0.04
exp 0.71
1.38

2.5

( )
:= F
2
1 =
F
3
1 0.55
1.8

0.16
exp 0.49
0.89

1.8

( )
:= F
3
0.986 =
Tutorial 1 2 of 21
a) Chord side crown & saddle and quarter points (SCF Calculation)
Take General Fixity Conditions
(i) Axial Load
Chord Saddle T
11

1.1
1.11 3 0.52 ( )
2

sin ( ) ( )
1.6

F
1
:= T
11
2.415 =
C
1
2 C
c
0.5
( )
:= C
1
0.4 =
C
2
C
c
2
:= C
2
0.35 =
C
3
C
c
5
:= C
3
0.14 =
SCF
Sa_C
T
11
C
1
0.8 6 ( )
2
1
2

( )
0.5
sin 2 ( ) ( )
2
+

(
(

F
2
:= SCF
Sa_C
2.53 =
Chord Crown SCF
Cr_C

0.2
2.65 5 0.65 ( )
2
+

C
2
3
( )
sin ( ) +

:= SCF
Cr_C
2.812 =
(ii) In-Plane Bending
Chord Crown SCF
Cip_C
1.45
0.85

1 0.68 ( )
sin ( ) ( )
0.7

:= SCF
Cip_C
1.546 =
(iii) Out-of-Plane Bending
Chord Saddle SCF
Sop_C
1.7 1.05
3

( )
sin ( ) ( )
1.6

F
3
:= SCF
Sop_C
2.24 =
(iv) Axial Load for Intermediate points
SCF
In_C
SCF
Sa_C
SCF
Cr_C
+
2
|

\
|
|
.
:= SCF
In_C
2.671 =
(v) In-Plane Bending for Intermediate points
SCF
Inip_C
SCF
Cip_C
0 +
2
|

\
|
|
.
:= SCF
Inip_C
0.773 =
(vi) Out-of-Plane Bending for Intermediate points
SCF
Inop_C
SCF
Sop_C
0 +
2
|

\
|
|
.
:= SCF
Inop_C
1.12 =
Tutorial 1 3 of 21
b) Brace side crown & saddle and quarter points (SCF Calculation)
(i) Axial Load
Brace Saddle SCF
Sa_B
1.3
0.52

0.1
0.187 1.25
1.1
0.96 ( )

sin ( ) ( )
2.7 0.01 ( )
+

F
1
:=
SCF
Sa_B
2.086 =
Brace Crown
SCF
Cr_B
3
1.2
0.12 exp 4 ( ) 0.011
2
+ 0.045
( )
+ C
3
1.2
( )
+

:=
SCF
Cr_B
2.453 =
(ii) In-Plane Bending
Brace Crown SCF
Cip_B
1 0.65
0.4

1.09 0.77 ( )
sin ( ) ( )
0.06 1.16 ( )
+

:= SCF
Cip_B
3.04 =
(iii) Out-of-Plane Bending
Brace Saddle SCF
Sop_B

0.54

0.05
0.99 0.47 0.08
4
+
( )
SCF
Sop_C

F
3
:= SCF
Sop_B
1.741 =
(iv) Axial Load for Intermediate points
SCF
In_B
SCF
Sa_B
SCF
Cr_B
+
2
|

\
|
|
.
:= SCF
In_B
2.269 =
(v) In-Plane Bending for Intermediate points
SCF
Inip_B
SCF
Cip_B
0 +
2
|

\
|
|
.
:= SCF
Inip_B
1.52 =
(vi) Out-of-Plane Bending for Intermediate points
SCF
Inop_B
SCF
Sop_B
0 +
2
|

\
|
|
.
:= SCF
Inop_B
0.871 =
Tutorial 1 4 of 21
c) Maximum Hot Spot Stress range (HSSR) among Chord side locations
For Load Case :1
HSSR
c1

ax1
SCF
Cr_C

ip1
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c1
1.7 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c2

ax1
SCF
In_C

ip1
SCF
Inip_C

op1
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c2
1.07 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c3

ax1
SCF
Sa_C

op1
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c3
2.32 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c4

ax1
SCF
In_C

ip1
SCF
Inip_C
+
op1
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c4
1.62 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c5

ax1
SCF
Cr_C

ip1
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c5
2.64 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c6

ax1
SCF
In_C

ip1
SCF
Inip_C
+
op1
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c6
3.75 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c7

ax1
SCF
Sa_C

op1
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c7
4.85 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c8

ax1
SCF
In_C

ip1
SCF
Inip_C

op1
SCF
Inop_C
+ :=
HSSR
c8
2.51 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C1 max HSSR
c1
HSSR
c2
, HSSR
c3
, HSSR
c4
, HSSR
c5
, HSSR
c6
, HSSR
c7
, HSSR
c8
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C1 4.85 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :2
HSSR
c11

ax2
SCF
Cr_C

ip2
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c11
3.1 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c12

ax2
SCF
In_C

ip2
SCF
Inip_C

op2
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c12
4.93 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c13

ax2
SCF
Sa_C

op2
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c13
1.3 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c14

ax2
SCF
In_C

ip2
SCF
Inip_C
+
op2
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c14
7.43 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c15

ax2
SCF
Cr_C

ip2
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c15
2.78 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c16

ax2
SCF
In_C

ip2
SCF
Inip_C
+
op2
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c16
3.43 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c17

ax2
SCF
Sa_C

op2
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c17
4.08 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c18

ax2
SCF
In_C

ip2
SCF
Inip_C

op2
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c18
2.2 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C2 max HSSR
c11
HSSR
c12
, HSSR
c13
, HSSR
c14
, HSSR
c15
, HSSR
c16
, HSSR
c17
, HSSR
c18
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C2 4.08 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 5 of 21
For Load Case :3
HSSR
c21

ax3
SCF
Cr_C

ip3
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c21
6.05 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c22

ax3
SCF
In_C

ip3
SCF
Inip_C

op3
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c22
7.3 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c23

ax3
SCF
Sa_C

op3
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c23
2.07 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c24

ax3
SCF
In_C

ip3
SCF
Inip_C
+
op3
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c24
3.52 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c25

ax3
SCF
Cr_C

ip3
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c25
2.77 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c26

ax3
SCF
In_C

ip3
SCF
Inip_C
+
op3
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c26
3.94 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c27

ax3
SCF
Sa_C

op3
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c27
5.1 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c28

ax3
SCF
In_C

ip3
SCF
Inip_C

op3
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c28
2.85 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C3 max HSSR
c21
HSSR
c22
, HSSR
c23
, HSSR
c24
, HSSR
c25
, HSSR
c26
, HSSR
c27
, HSSR
c28
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C3 5.1 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :4
HSSR
c31

ax4
SCF
Cr_C

ip4
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c31
4.37 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c32

ax4
SCF
In_C

ip4
SCF
Inip_C

op4
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c32
5.27 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c33

ax4
SCF
Sa_C

op4
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c33
1.49 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c34

ax4
SCF
In_C

ip4
SCF
Inip_C
+
op4
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c34
8.64 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c35

ax4
SCF
Cr_C

ip4
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c35
3.22 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c36

ax4
SCF
In_C

ip4
SCF
Inip_C
+
op4
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c36
4 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c37

ax4
SCF
Sa_C

op4
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c37
4.78 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c38

ax4
SCF
In_C

ip4
SCF
Inip_C

op4
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c38
2.61 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C4 max HSSR
c31
HSSR
c32
, HSSR
c33
, HSSR
c34
, HSSR
c35
, HSSR
c36
, HSSR
c37
, HSSR
c38
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C4 4.78 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 6 of 21
For Load Case :5
HSSR
c41

ax5
SCF
Cr_C

ip5
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c41
1.32 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c42

ax5
SCF
In_C

ip5
SCF
Inip_C

op5
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c42
6.93 10
4
Pa =
HSSR
c43

ax5
SCF
Sa_C

op5
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c43
1.34 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c44

ax5
SCF
In_C

ip5
SCF
Inip_C
+
op5
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c44
9.21 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c45

ax5
SCF
Cr_C

ip5
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c45
3.18 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c46

ax5
SCF
In_C

ip5
SCF
Inip_C
+
op5
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c46
4.28 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c47

ax5
SCF
Sa_C

op5
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c47
5.38 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c48

ax5
SCF
In_C

ip5
SCF
Inip_C

op5
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c48
3.35 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C5 max HSSR
c41
HSSR
c42
, HSSR
c43
, HSSR
c44
, HSSR
c45
, HSSR
c46
, HSSR
c47
, HSSR
c48
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C5 5.38 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :6
HSSR
c51

ax6
SCF
Cr_C

ip6
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c51
1.06 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c52

ax6
SCF
In_C

ip6
SCF
Inip_C

op6
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c52
3.26 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c53

ax6
SCF
Sa_C

op6
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c53
4.11 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c54

ax6
SCF
In_C

ip6
SCF
Inip_C
+
op6
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c54
1.79 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c55

ax6
SCF
Cr_C

ip6
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c55
4 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c56

ax6
SCF
In_C

ip6
SCF
Inip_C
+
op6
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c56
4.48 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c57

ax6
SCF
Sa_C

op6
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c57
4.97 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c58

ax6
SCF
In_C

ip6
SCF
Inip_C

op6
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c58
3.01 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C6 max HSSR
c51
HSSR
c52
, HSSR
c53
, HSSR
c54
, HSSR
c55
, HSSR
c56
, HSSR
c57
, HSSR
c58
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C6 4.97 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 7 of 21
For Load Case :7
HSSR
c61

ax7
SCF
Cr_C

ip7
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c61
1.83 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c62

ax7
SCF
In_C

ip7
SCF
Inip_C

op7
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c62
9.76 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c63

ax7
SCF
Sa_C

op7
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c63
1.24 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c64

ax7
SCF
In_C

ip7
SCF
Inip_C
+
op7
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c64
2.52 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c65

ax7
SCF
Cr_C

ip7
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c65
4.92 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c66

ax7
SCF
In_C

ip7
SCF
Inip_C
+
op7
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c66
5.43 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c67

ax7
SCF
Sa_C

op7
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c67
5.95 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c68

ax7
SCF
In_C

ip7
SCF
Inip_C

op7
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c68
3.89 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C7 max HSSR
c61
HSSR
c62
, HSSR
c63
, HSSR
c64
, HSSR
c65
, HSSR
c66
, HSSR
c67
, HSSR
c68
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C7 5.95 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :8
HSSR
c71

ax8
SCF
Cr_C

ip8
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c71
2.05 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c72

ax8
SCF
In_C

ip8
SCF
Inip_C

op8
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c72
1.36 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c73

ax8
SCF
Sa_C

op8
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c73
6.59 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c74

ax8
SCF
In_C

ip8
SCF
Inip_C
+
op8
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c74
3.52 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c75

ax8
SCF
Cr_C

ip8
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c75
6.38 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c76

ax8
SCF
In_C

ip8
SCF
Inip_C
+
op8
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c76
6.66 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c77

ax8
SCF
Sa_C

op8
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c77
6.93 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c78

ax8
SCF
In_C

ip8
SCF
Inip_C

op8
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c78
4.49 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C8 max HSSR
c71
HSSR
c72
, HSSR
c73
, HSSR
c74
, HSSR
c75
, HSSR
c76
, HSSR
c77
, HSSR
c78
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C8 6.93 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 8 of 21
For Load Case : 9
HSSR
c81

ax9
SCF
Cr_C

ip9
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c81
1.89 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c82

ax9
SCF
In_C

ip9
SCF
Inip_C

op9
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c82
1.22 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c83

ax9
SCF
Sa_C

op9
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c83
5.62 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c84

ax9
SCF
In_C

ip9
SCF
Inip_C
+
op9
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c84
3.7 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c85

ax9
SCF
Cr_C

ip9
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c85
6.83 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c86

ax9
SCF
In_C

ip9
SCF
Inip_C
+
op9
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c86
7.06 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c87

ax9
SCF
Sa_C

op9
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c87
7.28 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c88

ax9
SCF
In_C

ip9
SCF
Inip_C

op9
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c88
4.58 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C9 max HSSR
c81
HSSR
c82
, HSSR
c83
, HSSR
c84
, HSSR
c85
, HSSR
c86
, HSSR
c87
, HSSR
c88
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C9 7.28 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case : 10
HSSR
c91

ax10
SCF
Cr_C

ip10
SCF
Cip_C
:= HSSR
c91
2.18 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c92

ax10
SCF
In_C

ip10
SCF
Inip_C

op10
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c92
1.32 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c93

ax10
SCF
Sa_C

op10
SCF
Sop_C
:= HSSR
c93
4.64 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
c94

ax10
SCF
In_C

ip10
SCF
Inip_C
+
op10
SCF
Inop_C
:= HSSR
c94
3.64 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c95

ax10
SCF
Cr_C

ip10
SCF
Cip_C
+ := HSSR
c95
6.82 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c96

ax10
SCF
In_C

ip10
SCF
Inip_C
+
op10
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c96
7.23 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c97

ax10
SCF
Sa_C

op10
SCF
Sop_C
+ := HSSR
c97
7.63 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
c98

ax10
SCF
In_C

ip10
SCF
Inip_C

op10
SCF
Inop_C
+ := HSSR
c98
4.91 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_C10 max HSSR
c91
HSSR
c92
, HSSR
c93
, HSSR
c94
, HSSR
c95
, HSSR
c96
, HSSR
c97
, HSSR
c98
,
( )
:=
HSSR_C10 7.63 10
7
Pa =
Maximum Hot Spot Stress range for Chord
HSSR
C
max HSSR_C1 HSSR_C2 , HSSR_C3 , HSSR_C4 , HSSR_C5 , HSSR_C6 , HSSR_C7 , HSSR_C8 , HSSR_C9 , HSSR_C10 , ( ) :=
HSSR
C
7.63 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 9 of 21
d) Maximum Hot Spot Stress range (HSSR) among Brace side locations
For Load Case :1
HSSR
b1

ax1
SCF
Cr_B

ip1
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b1
1.21 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b2

ax1
SCF
In_B

ip1
SCF
Inip_B

op1
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b2
1.47 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b3

ax1
SCF
Sa_B

op1
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b3
1.74 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b4

ax1
SCF
In_B

ip1
SCF
Inip_B
+
op1
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b4
9.58 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b5

ax1
SCF
Cr_B

ip1
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b5
3.66 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b6

ax1
SCF
In_B

ip1
SCF
Inip_B
+
op1
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b6
3.74 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b7

ax1
SCF
Sa_B

op1
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b7
3.83 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b8

ax1
SCF
In_B

ip1
SCF
Inip_B

op1
SCF
Inop_B
+ :=
HSSR
b8
1.31 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B1 max HSSR
b1
HSSR
b2
, HSSR
b3
, HSSR
b4
, HSSR
b5
, HSSR
b6
, HSSR
b7
, HSSR
b8
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B1 3.83 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :2
HSSR
b11

ax2
SCF
Cr_B

ip2
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b11
1.08 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b12

ax2
SCF
In_B

ip2
SCF
Inip_B

op2
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b12
1.01 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b13

ax2
SCF
Sa_B

op2
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b13
9.43 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b14

ax2
SCF
In_B

ip2
SCF
Inip_B
+
op2
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b14
1.42 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b15

ax2
SCF
Cr_B

ip2
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b15
3.78 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b16

ax2
SCF
In_B

ip2
SCF
Inip_B
+
op2
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b16
3.51 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b17

ax2
SCF
Sa_B

op2
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b17
3.24 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b18

ax2
SCF
In_B

ip2
SCF
Inip_B

op2
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b18
1.08 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B2 max HSSR
b11
HSSR
b12
, HSSR
b13
, HSSR
b14
, HSSR
b15
, HSSR
b16
, HSSR
b17
, HSSR
b18
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B2 3.78 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 10 of 21
For Load Case :3
HSSR
b21

ax3
SCF
Cr_B

ip3
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b21
6.56 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b22

ax3
SCF
In_B

ip3
SCF
Inip_B

op3
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b22
1.1 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b23

ax3
SCF
Sa_B

op3
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b23
1.53 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b24

ax3
SCF
In_B

ip3
SCF
Inip_B
+
op3
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b24
1.03 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b25

ax3
SCF
Cr_B

ip3
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b25
3.6 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b26

ax3
SCF
In_B

ip3
SCF
Inip_B
+
op3
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b26
3.82 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b27

ax3
SCF
Sa_B

op3
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b27
4.04 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b28

ax3
SCF
In_B

ip3
SCF
Inip_B

op3
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b28
1.69 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B3 max HSSR
b21
HSSR
b22
, HSSR
b23
, HSSR
b24
, HSSR
b25
, HSSR
b26
, HSSR
b27
, HSSR
b28
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B3 4.04 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :4
HSSR
b31

ax4
SCF
Cr_B

ip4
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b31
1.14 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b32

ax4
SCF
In_B

ip4
SCF
Inip_B

op4
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b32
1.11 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b33

ax4
SCF
Sa_B

op4
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b33
1.08 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b34

ax4
SCF
In_B

ip4
SCF
Inip_B
+
op4
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b34
1.62 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b35

ax4
SCF
Cr_B

ip4
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b35
4.33 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b36

ax4
SCF
In_B

ip4
SCF
Inip_B
+
op4
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b36
4.06 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b37

ax4
SCF
Sa_B

op4
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b37
3.79 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b38

ax4
SCF
In_B

ip4
SCF
Inip_B

op4
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b38
1.33 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B4 max HSSR
b31
HSSR
b32
, HSSR
b33
, HSSR
b34
, HSSR
b35
, HSSR
b36
, HSSR
b37
, HSSR
b38
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B4 4.33 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 11 of 21
For Load Case :5
HSSR
b41

ax5
SCF
Cr_B

ip5
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b41
1.38 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b42

ax5
SCF
In_B

ip5
SCF
Inip_B

op5
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b42
4.03 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b43

ax5
SCF
Sa_B

op5
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b43
9.44 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b44

ax5
SCF
In_B

ip5
SCF
Inip_B
+
op5
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b44
1.42 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b45

ax5
SCF
Cr_B

ip5
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b45
3.79 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b46

ax5
SCF
In_B

ip5
SCF
Inip_B
+
op5
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b46
4.03 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b47

ax5
SCF
Sa_B

op5
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b47
4.28 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b48

ax5
SCF
In_B

ip5
SCF
Inip_B

op5
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b48
2.21 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B5 max HSSR
b41
HSSR
b42
, HSSR
b43
, HSSR
b44
, HSSR
b45
, HSSR
b46
, HSSR
b47
, HSSR
b48
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B5 4.28 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :6
HSSR
b51

ax6
SCF
Cr_B

ip6
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b51
6.8 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b52

ax6
SCF
In_B

ip6
SCF
Inip_B

op6
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b52
4.46 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b53

ax6
SCF
Sa_B

op6
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b53
2.13 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b54

ax6
SCF
In_B

ip6
SCF
Inip_B
+
op6
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b54
2.44 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b55

ax6
SCF
Cr_B

ip6
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b55
5.1 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b56

ax6
SCF
In_B

ip6
SCF
Inip_B
+
op6
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b56
4.53 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b57

ax6
SCF
Sa_B

op6
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b57
3.97 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b58

ax6
SCF
In_B

ip6
SCF
Inip_B

op6
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b58
1.64 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B6 max HSSR
b51
HSSR
b52
, HSSR
b53
, HSSR
b54
, HSSR
b55
, HSSR
b56
, HSSR
b57
, HSSR
b58
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B6 5.1 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 12 of 21
For Load Case :7
HSSR
b61

ax7
SCF
Cr_B

ip7
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b61
9.63 10
5
Pa =
HSSR
b62

ax7
SCF
In_B

ip7
SCF
Inip_B

op7
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b62
7.13 10
5
Pa =
HSSR
b63

ax7
SCF
Sa_B

op7
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b63
2.39 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b64

ax7
SCF
In_B

ip7
SCF
Inip_B
+
op7
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b64
3.11 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b65

ax7
SCF
Cr_B

ip7
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b65
5.98 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b66

ax7
SCF
In_B

ip7
SCF
Inip_B
+
op7
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b66
5.38 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b67

ax7
SCF
Sa_B

op7
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b67
4.77 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b68

ax7
SCF
In_B

ip7
SCF
Inip_B

op7
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b68
2.34 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B7 max HSSR
b61
HSSR
b62
, HSSR
b63
, HSSR
b64
, HSSR
b65
, HSSR
b66
, HSSR
b67
, HSSR
b68
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B7 5.98 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case :8
HSSR
b71

ax8
SCF
Cr_B

ip8
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b71
5.76 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b72

ax8
SCF
In_B

ip8
SCF
Inip_B

op8
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b72
5.7 10
5
Pa =
HSSR
b73

ax8
SCF
Sa_B

op8
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b73
6.9 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b74

ax8
SCF
In_B

ip8
SCF
Inip_B
+
op8
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b74
4.31 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b75

ax8
SCF
Cr_B

ip8
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b75
7.94 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b76

ax8
SCF
In_B

ip8
SCF
Inip_B
+
op8
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b76
6.75 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b77

ax8
SCF
Sa_B

op8
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b77
5.57 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b78

ax8
SCF
In_B

ip8
SCF
Inip_B

op8
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b78
2.49 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B8 max HSSR
b71
HSSR
b72
, HSSR
b73
, HSSR
b74
, HSSR
b75
, HSSR
b76
, HSSR
b77
, HSSR
b78
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B8 7.94 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 13 of 21
For Load Case : 9
HSSR
b81

ax9
SCF
Cr_B

ip9
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b81
1.06 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b82

ax9
SCF
In_B

ip9
SCF
Inip_B

op9
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b82
2.21 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b83

ax9
SCF
Sa_B

op9
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b83
6.21 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b84

ax9
SCF
In_B

ip9
SCF
Inip_B
+
op9
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b84
4.64 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b85

ax9
SCF
Cr_B

ip9
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b85
8.67 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b86

ax9
SCF
In_B

ip9
SCF
Inip_B
+
op9
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b86
7.26 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b87

ax9
SCF
Sa_B

op9
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b87
5.84 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b88

ax9
SCF
In_B

ip9
SCF
Inip_B

op9
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b88
2.39 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B9 max HSSR
b81
HSSR
b82
, HSSR
b83
, HSSR
b84
, HSSR
b85
, HSSR
b86
, HSSR
b87
, HSSR
b88
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B9 8.67 10
7
Pa =
For Load Case : 10
HSSR
b91

ax10
SCF
Cr_B

ip10
SCF
Cip_B
:= HSSR
b91
6.35 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b92

ax10
SCF
In_B

ip10
SCF
Inip_B

op10
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b92
4.22 10
5
Pa =
HSSR
b93

ax10
SCF
Sa_B

op10
SCF
Sop_B
:= HSSR
b93
5.51 10
6
Pa =
HSSR
b94

ax10
SCF
In_B

ip10
SCF
Inip_B
+
op10
SCF
Inop_B
:= HSSR
b94
4.52 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b95

ax10
SCF
Cr_B

ip10
SCF
Cip_B
+ := HSSR
b95
8.49 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b96

ax10
SCF
In_B

ip10
SCF
Inip_B
+
op10
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b96
7.3 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b97

ax10
SCF
Sa_B

op10
SCF
Sop_B
+ := HSSR
b97
6.12 10
7
Pa =
HSSR
b98

ax10
SCF
In_B

ip10
SCF
Inip_B

op10
SCF
Inop_B
+ := HSSR
b98
2.74 10
7
Pa =
HSSR_B10 max HSSR
b91
HSSR
b92
, HSSR
b93
, HSSR
b94
, HSSR
b95
, HSSR
b96
, HSSR
b97
, HSSR
b98
,
( )
:=
HSSR_B10 8.49 10
7
Pa =
Maximum Hot Spot Stress range for Brace
HSSR
B
max HSSR_B1 HSSR_B2 , HSSR_B3 , HSSR_B4 , HSSR_B5 , HSSR_B6 , HSSR_B7 , HSSR_B8 , HSSR_B9 , HSSR_B10 , ( ) :=
HSSR
B
8.67 10
7
Pa =
Tutorial 1 14 of 21
e) Cycles of HSSR applied to the joint
No of Cycles for Load Case 1 n
1
TL p
1

T
1
:= n
1
2.104 10
6
=
n
2
TL p
2

T
2
:= n
2
5.259 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 2
n
3
TL p
3

T
3
:= n
3
5.259 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 3
n
4
TL p
4

T
4
:=
No of Cycles for Load Case 4 n
4
2.254 10
5
=
n
5
TL p
5

T
5
:= n
5
3.156 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 5
n
6
TL p
6

T
6
:= n
6
2.367 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 6
n
7
TL p
7

T
7
:= n
7
2.367 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 7
n
8
TL p
8

T
8
:= n
8
2.657 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 8
n
9
TL p
9

T
9
:= n
9
1.661 10
5
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 9
n
10
TL p
10

T
10
:= n
10
6.644 10
4
=
No of Cycles for Load Case 10
f ) Cycles of failure from S-N curve (API-WJ curve)
Calculation of Allowable cycles from WJ Curve for Chord side
Refer API RP 2A Page No: 58 Table 5.5.1- Basic Design S-N Curves, For welded joints(WJ).
Max HSSR for Chord HSSR
C
76.33 MPa =
From figure 5.5-1 (N value) for Max HSSR for Chord
For WJ Curve
m
1
3 := m
2
5 := k
11
12.48 := k
12
16.13 :=
Tutorial 1 15 of 21
N
C1
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C1
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C1
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 1
N
C1
5.028 10
7
=
N
C2
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C2
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C2
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 2
N
C2
1.193 10
8
=
N
C3
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C3
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C3
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 3
N
C3
3.899 10
7
=
N
C4
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C4
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C4
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 4
N
C4
5.399 10
7
=
Tutorial 1 16 of 21
Allowable cycles for Load case 5 N
C5
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C5
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C5
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
C5
2.98 10
7
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 6 N
C6
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C6
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C6
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
C6
4.468 10
7
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 7 N
C7
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C7
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C7
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
C7
1.811 10
7
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 8 N
C8
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C8
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C8
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
C8
9.066 10
6
=
Tutorial 1 17 of 21
Allowable cycles for Load case 9 N
C9
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C9
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C9
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
C9
7.819 10
6
=
N
C10
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_C10
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_C10
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 10
N
C10
6.79 10
6
=
Calculation of Allowable cycles from WJ Curve for Brace side
Refer API RP 2A Page No: 58 Table 5.5.1- Basic Design S-N Curves, For welded joints(WJ).
Max HSSR for Brace HSSR
B
86.67 MPa =
From figure 5.5-1 (N value) for Max HSSR for Brace
For WJ Curve
m
1
3 = m
2
5 = k
11
12.48 = k
12
16.13 =
N
B1
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B1
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B1
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 1
N
B1
1.639 10
8
=
Tutorial 1 18 of 21
Allowable cycles for Load case 2 N
B2
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B2
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B2
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B2
1.745 10
8
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 3 N
B3
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B3
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B3
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B3
1.257 10
8
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 4 N
B4
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B4
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B4
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B4
8.854 10
7
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 5 N
B5
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B5
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B5
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B5
9.388 10
7
=
Tutorial 1 19 of 21
Allowable cycles for Load case 6 N
B6
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B6
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B6
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B6
3.924 10
7
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 7 N
B7
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B7
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B7
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B7
1.758 10
7
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 8 N
B8
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B8
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B8
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B8
6.042 10
6
=
Allowable cycles for Load case 9 N
B9
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B9
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B9
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
N
B9
4.639 10
6
=
Tutorial 1 20 of 21
N
B10
N
2
10
k
12
m
2
log
HSSR_B10
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
10
k
11
m
1
log
HSSR_B10
MPa
|

\
|
|
.

N
1
N
1
10
7
< if
N
2
otherwise
:=
Allowable cycles for Load case 10
N
B10
4.942 10
6
=
g) Fatigue damage for brace & Chord side
i ) Chord side
Fatigue Damage of
Chord side
FD
C
n
1
N
C1
n
2
N
C2
+
n
3
N
C3
+
n
4
N
C4
+
n
5
N
C5
+
n
6
N
C6
+
n
7
N
C7
+
n
8
N
C8
+
n
9
N
C9
+
n
10
N
C10
+
|

\
|
|
.
:=
FD
C
0.153 =
Fatigue Life of Chord side FL
C
DL
FD
C
:= FL
C
163.177 yr =
ii ) Brace side
Fatigue Damage of
Chord side
FD
B
n
1
N
B1
n
2
N
B2
+
n
3
N
B3
+
n
4
N
B4
+
n
5
N
B5
+
n
6
N
B6
+
n
7
N
B7
+
n
8
N
B8
+
n
9
N
B9
+
n
10
N
B10
+
|

\
|
|
.
:=
FD
B
0.139 =
Fatigue Life of Chord side FL
B
DL
FD
B
:= FL
B
180.287 yr =
Tutorial 1 21 of 21