You are on page 1of 10

Joseph E.

Stiglitz [Ideological Profiles of the Economics Laureates]


Daniel B. Klein, Ryan Daza, and Hannah Mead
Econ Journal Watch 10(3), September 2013: 650-658
Abstract
Joseph E. Stiglitz is among the 71 individuals who were awarded the Sveriges
Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel between 1969 and 2012.
This ideological profile is part of the project called The Ideological Migration of the
Economics Laureates, which fills the September 2013 issue of Econ Journal Watch.
Keywords
Classical liberalism, economists, Nobel Prize in economics, ideology, ideological
migration, intellectual biography.
JELclassification
A11, A13, B2, B3
Link to this document
http://econjwatch.org/file_download/778/StiglitzIPEL.pdf
Joseph E. Stiglitz
;R :GB>E B. 'E>BG, .R:G :S:, :G= $:GG:A )>:=
.:BL>= ;R I:K>GML MA:M A> A:L =>L<KB;>= :L : *>P >:E >FH<K:M :G= :
&>??>KLHGB:G =>FH<K:M, &HL>IA /MB@EBMS (1943d) @K>P NI BG #:KR, %G=B:G:, PBMA
LHF>PA:M FBQ>= OB>PL H? @HO>KGF>GM. !:KER HG, A> P:L HIIHL>= MH L>@K>@:MBHG
:G= =BLMNK;>= ;R <BOBE KB@AML OBHE:MBHGL. %G ABL RHNMA, A> A:L L:B=, A> :<JNBK>= :G
>G=NKBG@ f=BLMKNLM H? :NMAHKBMRg (/MB@EBMS 2002:). $> >:KG>= ABL *H;>E ,KBS> ?HK
ABL PHKD HG :LRFF>MKB< BG?HKF:MBHG. /MB@EBMS L>>L F:KD>M ?:BENK>L <:NL>= ;R LN<A
:LRFF>MKB>L, :G= H?M>G :=OH<:M>L @HO>KGF>GM BGM>KO>GMBHG BG MAHL> :K>:L. /MB@EBMS
A:L :<DGHPE>=@>= MA> IKH;E>F H? BG<>GMBO>L BG MA> IHEBMB<:E LIA>K>, :L P>EE (/MB@EBMS
2002;, 523).
A?M>K >:KGBG@ ABL ;:<A>EHKiL ?KHF AFA>KLM CHEE>@>, /MB@EBMS P>GM MH )%0 ?HK
ABL ,A.. BG ><HGHFB<L. $> M:N@AM :M )%0, 5:E>, +Q?HK=, ,KBG<>MHG, :G= /M:G?HK=
;>?HK> L>MMEBG@ :M CHENF;B:. $BL PHKD A:L ;>>G :IIEB<:;E> MH :G :KK:R H? ><HGHFB<
BLLN>L, ?KHF <K>=BM K:MBHGBG@ MH >??B<B>G<R P:@>L. ':KE: $H?? PKBM>L:
$BL PHKD >EN<B=:M>= : ;KH:= L>M H? IA>GHF>G: MA:M A:= E:K@>ER ;>>G
B@GHK>= ;>?HK> 1970 ;><:NL> MA>R P>K> HNMLB=> MA> EBFBML H? MA>
LM:G=:K= I:K:=B@F: BG<>GMBO> <HGMK:<ML, ;:GDKNIM<R, JN:GMBMR K:MBHG-
BG@, ?BG:G<B:E LMKN<MNK>, >JNBEB;KBNF IKB<> =BLMKB;NMBHGL, BGGHO:MBHG,
:G= =RL?NG<MBHG:E BGLMBMNMBHGL. 0ABL PHKD <HGMKB;NM>= MH : I:K:=B@F
LAB?M BG ><HGHFB<L. %G MA> G>P I:K:=B@F, MA> IKB<> LRLM>F HGER
BFI>K?><MER LHEO>L MA> BG?HKF:MBHG IKH;E>F H? L<:K<BMR ;><:NL> H? MA>
F:GR HMA>K BG?HKF:MBHG IKH;E>FL MA:M :KBL> BG MA> ><HGHFR. ($H??
2008)
/MB@EBMS PKBM>L BG ABL :NMH;BH@K:IAB<:E >LL:R: f0A> IHEBMB<L H? )%0 :ELH LNBM>=
F> P>EE. )R M>:<A>KL P>K> FHLMER >LM:;EBLAF>GM EB;>K:EL, ;NM MA>K> P>K> : ?>P MA:M
P>K> FHK> JN>LMBHGBG@. % PHG=>K MHH AHP % PHNE= A:O> ?:K>= A:= % @HG> MH HG> H?
MA> L<AHHEL, EBD> CAB<:@H, PA>K> MA>K> BL : FHK> <HGL>KO:MBO> ;>GM. 3HNE= % A:O>
<A:G@>=? +K PHNE= % A:O> CNLM ;>>G NGA:IIR?g (/MB@EBMS 2002:).
%G 1980 /MB@EBMS :G= AGMAHGR AMDBGLHG PKHM>:
0A> LM:M>cA:L : FN<A FHK> ;:LB< KHE> MH IE:R BG MA:M BML ?BKLM ?NG<MBHG
BL MH >LM:;EBLA :G= >G?HK<> MA> fKNE>L H? MA> ><HGHFB< @:F>.g c 0A>
LM:G=:K= CNLMB?B<:MBHG H? LM:M> BGM>KO>GMBHG M:D>L :L BML LM:KMBG@ IHBGM MA>
;>A:OBHNK H? MA> ><HGHFR BG MA> :;L>G<> H? MA> @HO>KGF>GM, MA:M BL,
ECON JOURNAL WATCH
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 650
BG MA> ARIHMA>MB<:E LBMN:MBHG H? : ?K>> F:KD>M ><HGHFR. (AMDBGLHG :G=
/MB@EBMS 1980, 4-6).
0A>R <HGMBGN>=:
0A>K> BL BG=>>= EBMME> K>:LHG MH ;>EB>O> MA:M MA> F:KD>M <HNE= ?NG<MBHG
BG MA> P:R :LLNF>= BG MA> fGH-@HO>KGF>GM ><HGHFRg: fHG> =>L<KBI-
MBHG H? LN<A : LH<B:E HK=>K, :G= IKH;:;ER : AB@AER K>:EBLMB< HG>, PHNE= ;>
LNFF:KBS>= ;R MA> PHK= h<A:HLig (BN<A:G:G, 1970, I. 3). AL P> A:O>
:K@N>=c, MA> LM:M> BL >LL>GMB:E MH MA> ?NG<MBHGBG@ H? : FH=>KG F:KD>M
><HGHFReMH IK>O>GM LN<A f<A:HLg =>O>EHIBG@e;R E>@BMBFBSBG@
IKHI>KMR KB@AML, ;R <HGMKHEEBG@ FHG>M:KR :G= ?BG:G<B:E HI>K:MBHGL, ;R
K>@NE:MBG@ >GMKR MH ><HGHFB< :<MBOBMB>L, >M<. (AMDBGLHG :G= /MB@EBMS
1980, 8-9)
%G 1989, /MB@EBMS K>F:KD>= HG K>=BLMKB;NMBHG:
%G :==BMBHG MH MAHL> BGLM:G<>L PA>K> MA> F:KD>M ?:BEL MH IKHOB=> :
(,:K>MH) >??B<B>GM :EEH<:MBHG H? K>LHNK<>L, MA> @HO>KGF>GM F:R A:O>
: KHE>, >BMA>K ;><:NL> MA> K>LNEMBG@ =BLMKB;NMBHG H? BG<HF> BL H;-
C><MBHG:;E>, HK ;><:NL> MA>K> :K> LHF> F>KBM @HH=L HK ;:=L GHM
:=>JN:M>ER LNIIEB>= ;R MA> F:KD>M. (/MB@EBMS 1989, 39)
/MB@EBMS, AHP>O>K, L>>FL MH :=OBL> :@:BGLM PB=>LIK>:= @HO>KGF>GM HPG>KLABI BG MA>
IKH=N<MBHG H? @HH=L :G= L>KOB<>L:
0A> B=>: MA:M IKBO:M>, IKH?BM-F:QBFBSBG@ ?BKFL :<M BG : P:R PAB<A BL
GHM <HGLBLM>GM PBMA MA> IN;EB< BGM>K>LM, :G= MA:M MABL =BL<K>I:G<R BL
>LI><B:EER BFIHKM:GM BG <>KM:BG <>GMK:E L><MHKLeA>:OR BG=NLMKB>L,
?BG:G<B:E BGLMBMNMBHGL, MK:GLIHKM:MBHGeA:L ;>>G : <>GMK:E M>G>M BG
LH<B:EBLM B=>HEH@R. A L>>FBG@ (NGIKHO>=) <HKHEE:KR BL MA:M B? MA>
@HO>KGF>GM G:MBHG:EBS>= MA>L> >GM>KIKBL>L, MA>R PHNE= :<M BG MA>
IN;EB< BGM>K>LM. (/MB@EBMS 1989, 31)
0A> IN;EB< L><MHK, L:R /MB@EBMS :G= (RG /JNBK>, fLAHNE= ?H<NL BML >??HKML HG
MAHL> :K>:L PA>K> MA> IKBO:M> L><MHK ?:BELg (/MB@EBMS :G= /JNBK> 1998, 144). f>?>GL>,
K>=BLMKB;NMBHG, MA> E>@:E :G= CN=B<B:E LRLM>F, K>@NE:MBHG H? ?BG:G<B:E F:KD>ML, :G=
IKHM><MBHG H? MA> >GOBKHGF>GM :K> :EE :K>:L BG PAB<A MA> IN;EB< L><MHK A:L MH IE:R
MA> <>GMK:E KHE>g (B;B=., 144-145).
/MB@EBMS A:L :MM>FIM>= MH LMKBD> : ;:E:G<> ;>MP>>G MA> LM:M> :G= MA> F:KD>M:
IDEOLOGICAL PROFILES OF THE ECONOMICS LAUREATES
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 651
0A> G>P =>O>EHIF>GM :@>G=: BL BG?HKF>= ;R ABLMHKB<:E >QI>KB>G<>L
:G= A:L =BL<:K=>= MA> GHMBHGL H? fHGER-#HO>KGF>GMg HK fHGER-
F:KD>Mg ;:L>= =>O>EHIF>GM. 0ABL ?K:F>PHKD L>>L @HO>KGF>GM :G=
F:KD>ML :L <HFIE>F>GML K:MA>K MA:G LN;LMBMNM>L. %M M:D>L :L =H@F:
G>BMA>K MA:M F:KD>ML ;R MA>FL>EO>L PBEE >GLNK> =>LBK:;E> HNM<HF>L GHK
MA:M MA> :;L>G<> H? : F:KD>M, HK LHF> K>E:M>= F:KD>M ?:BENK>, PBEE
K>JNBK> MA:M @HO>KGF>GML :LLNF> K>LIHGLB;BEBMR ?HK MA> :<MBOBMR. %M
H?M>G =H>L GHM >O>G :LD PA>MA>K : I:KMB<NE:K :<MBOBMR LAHNE= ;> BG MA>
IN;EB< HK IKBO:M> L><MHK. .:MA>K, BG LHF> <BK<NFLM:G<>L, MA> G>P
:@>G=: L>>L @HO>KGF>GM A>EIBG@ MH <K>:M> F:KD>MLe:L F:GR H? MA>
!:LM ALB:G ><HGHFB>L =B= BG D>R :LI><ML H? MA> ?BG:G<B:E F:KD>M. %G
HMA>K <BK<NFLM:G<>L (LN<A :L >=N<:MBHG), BM L>>L MA> MPH PHKDBG@
MH@>MA>K :L I:KMG>KL, >:<A PBMA BML HPG K>LIHGLB;BEBMB>L. %G LMBEE HMA>KL
(LN<A :L ;:GDBG@), BM L>>L @HO>KGF>GM IKHOB=BG@ MA> >LL>GMB:E
K>@NE:MHKR L>KOB<>L PBMAHNM PAB<A F:KD>ML <:GGHM ?NG<MBHG ;><:NL>
BGO>LMHKL PBEE E:<D G><>LL:KR <HG?B=>G<>. 0A> G>P:@>G=: L>>L MA> /M:M>
LMK>M<ABG@ ;>RHG= BFIE>F>GMBG@ ,B@HNOB:G M:Q:MBHG MA:M <HKK><ML
>QM>KG:EBMB>L, MHP:K= : <HFIE>F>GM:KR KHE> MA:M A>EIL IKHOB=> MA>
BG?HKF:MBHG :G= BGLMBMNMBHG:E, ANF:G :G= IARLB<:E BG?K:LMKN<MNK>
K>JNBK>= ?HK F:KD>ML MH >QBLM :G= ?NG<MBHG P>EE. (/MB@EBMS 1999, 3)
AEMAHN@A /MB@EBMS H?M>G F:D>L @>G>K:E K>F:KDL :;HNM MA> G>>= ?HK F:KD>ML,
P> A:O> GHM ?HNG= :GR <:EEL ;R ABF?HK EB;>K:EBS:MBHG H? LI><B?B< K>LMKB<MBHGL. /MB@EBMS
A:L LB@G>= I>MBMBHGL ?HK K:BLBG@ MA> FBGBFNF P:@>, LNIIHKMBG@ MA> 2008 ">=>K:E
.><HO>KR A<M, LNIIHKMBG@ :N@F>GM:MBHG H? NGBHG IKBOBE>@>L (f!FIEHR>> "K>>
CAHB<> A<Mg), HIIHLBG@ MA> #>HK@> 3. BNLA M:Q <NML, :G= >G=HKLBG@ &HAG '>KKR
?HK IK>LB=>GM BG 2004 ($>=>G@K>G >M :E. 2010).
:OB= $>G=>KLHG (2008) =>L<KB;>L /MB@EBMSiL ?:BMA BG @HO>KGF>GM :<MHKL :L
fM>FI>K>=,g IHLLB;ER ;R ABL >QI>KB>G<> PHKDBG@ PBMA MA>L> :@>G<B>L. $> =>L<KB;>L
/MB@EBMSiL BGOHEO>F>GM BG IHEB<RF:DBG@:
"KHF 1993 MH 2000, /MB@EBMS >GM>K>= MA> IHEBMB<:E :K>G:, ?BKLM :L :
F>F;>K :G= MA>G :L <A:BKF:G H? ,K>LB=>GM BBEE CEBGMHGiL CHNG<BE H?
!<HGHFB< A=OBL>KL, :G= MA>G :L MA> <AB>? ><HGHFBLM H? MA> 3HKE=
B:GD. %G MABL E:MM>K KHE> A> A:= F:CHK <HG?EB<ML PBMA ><HGHFBLML :M
MA> %GM>KG:MBHG:E )HG>M:KR "NG= (%)") :G= :M MA> 1./. 0K>:LNKR HO>K
MA>BK OB>PL H? @HO>KGF>GM ><HGHFB< IHEB<R BG %G=HG>LB: :G= HMA>K
IHHK <HNGMKB>L. /MB@EBMS H;C><M>= MH MA>BK :=OH<:<R H? M:Q BG<K>:L>L :G=
MB@AM FHG>M:KR IHEB<R =NKBG@ MBF>L H? K><>LLBHG, : IHEB<R MA:M A> <:EE>=
fF:KD>M ?NG=:F>GM:EBLF.g ($>G=>KLHG 2008)
ECON JOURNAL WATCH
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 652
/MB@EBMS >QIE:BGL ABL <HG<>KGL PBMA @HO>KGF>GM :<MBHG: f0A> IKH;E>F BL MH
IKHOB=> BG<>GMBO>L ?HK MAHL> LH >GMKNLM>= MH :<M HG ;>A:E? H? MAHL> PAH MA>R :K>
LNIIHL>= MH ;> L>KOBG@g (/MB@EBMS 2002;, 523). 5>M, A> L>>L : I:KMB:E LHENMBHG:
f>FH<K:<Re<HGM>LM:;BEBMR BG IHEBMB<:E IKH<>LL>LeIKHOB=>L : <A><D HG :;NL>L
H? MA> IHP>KL MA:M <HF> ?KHF =>E>@:MBHG CNLM :L BM =H>L BG ><HGHFB< IKH<>LL>L;
;NMcMA> >E><MHK:E IKH<>LL IKHOB=>L :G BFI>K?><M <A><Dg (B;B=.). /MB@EBMS :ELH A:L
AB@A AHI>L ?HK MA> >??><MBO>G>LL H? @HO>KGF>GM MK:GLI:K>G<R (B;B=., 524).
/MB@EBMS L:RL ABL BGLB@AML <:LM =HN;M HG MA> <HG<ENLBHGL H? <HFI>MBMBHG-;:L>=
><HGHFB< FH=>EL: f/HF> H? MA> FHLM BFIHKM:GM <HG<ENLBHGL H? ><HGHFB< MA>HKR
:K> GHM KH;NLM MH <HGLB=>K:MBHGL H? BFI>K?><M BG?HKF:MBHGg (.HMAL<ABE= :G= /MB@EBMS
1976, 629).
%G ABL *H;>E E><MNK>, A> L:B=:
3> A:O> L>>G AHP MA> <HFI>MBMBO> I:K:=B@F MA:M =HFBG:M>=
><HGHFB< MABGDBG@ ?HK MPH <>GMNKB>L, GHM HGER P:L GHM KH;NLM, GHM HGER
=B= GHM >QIE:BG D>R ><HGHFB< IA>GHF>G:, ;NM :ELH E>= MH FBL@NB=>=
IHEB<R IK>L<KBIMBHGL. (/MB@EBMS 2002;, 519)
/MB@EBMS F>:GL F:KD>M-;:L>= IHEB<B>L, PAB<A, A> <HGM>G=>=, :K> fI:KMB<NE:KER BG:I-
IKHIKB:M> ?HK =>O>EHIBG@ <HNGMKB>Lg (B;B=.).
/HF> H? /MB@EBMSiL PHKD HG =>O>EHIF>GM ><HGHFB<L BL =>L<KB;>= ;R $H?? :L
?HEEHPL:
$BL FH=>EL P>K> BFIHKM:GM BG >LM:;EBLABG@ (:) MA:M IHLBMBO> ?>>=;:<D
F><A:GBLFL <:G @BO> KBL> MH FNEMBIE> >JNBEB;KB: :G= NG=>K=>O>EHIF>GM
MK:IL; (;) MA:M, ;><:NL> MA> <:NL>L H? F:KD>M ?:BENK>L :G= <HGLMK:BGML HG
@KHPMA O:KR @K>:MER ?KHFL>MMBG@ MH L>MMBG@, :G:ERLBL A:L MH ;> =HG> <:L>
;R <:L>; :G= (<) MA:M GHG-F:KD>M BGLMBMNMBHGL G>>= A:O> GH >??B<B>G<R
IKHI>KMB>L. ($H?? 2008)
3BMA (RG /JNBK>, /MB@EBMS HNMEBG>= MAK>> BG@K>=B>GML ?HK @KHPMA: f: LM:;E> :G=
<K>=B;E> IHEB<R >GOBKHGF>GM, :G HI>G :G= <HFI>MBMBO> ><HGHFR, :G= : ?H<NL>=
IN;EB< L><MHKg (/MB@EBMS :G= /JNBK> 1998, 142). $> A:L <KBMB<BS>= MA> MK>G= H? <:IBM:E
F:KD>M EB;>K:EBS:MBHG, L:RBG@ BM ANKML =>O>EHIBG@ <HNGMKB>L (/MB@EBMS 2002<, 244).
A?M>K MA> ?:EE H? <HFFNGBLF, /MB@EBMS PKHM>, G:MBHGL FHO>= MHP:K= F:KD>ML,
:G= F:GR :LLNF>= MABL PHNE= ;KBG@ :;HNM AB@A>K BG<HF>L. f%GLM>:=, BG<HF>L
IENFF>M>=, : =><EBG> <HG?BKF>= GHM HGER ;R #,LM:MBLMB<L :G= AHNL>AHE= LNKO>RL,
;NM :ELH ;R LH<B:E BG=B<:MHKLg (/MB@EBMS 2002;, 519). /MB@EBMS ;E:F>L K:IB= IKBO:MB-
S:MBHG MA:M =B= GHM >GLNK> @HH= <HKIHK:M> @HO>KG:G<>: fK:MA>K MA:G IKHOB=BG@ :
;:LBL ?HK P>:EMA <K>:MBHG, BM E>= MH :LL>M LMKBIIBG@ :G= P>:EMA =>LMKN<MBHGg (B;B=.).
3BMA /JNBK>, /MB@EBMS PKHM>:
IDEOLOGICAL PROFILES OF THE ECONOMICS LAUREATES
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 653
0A> ?:BENK> H? LM:M> >GM>KIKBL>L :G= MA> LN<<>LL H? F:KD>M ><HGHFB>L
A:O> E>= MH LMKHG@ >??HKML MH IKBO:MBS> :G= EB;>K:EBS> F:KD>ML. BNM
LHF>MBF>L MA>L> >??HKML :K> FHMBO:M>= FHK> ;R B=>HEH@R MA:G ><H-
GHFB< :G:ERLBL :G= F:R IKH<>>= MHH ?:K, MHH ?:LM. 3A>G MA:M A:II>GL,
MA> ><HGHFR F:R LN??>K. ,KBO:MBSBG@ : G:MNK:E FHGHIHER ;>?HK> :G
>??><MBO> K>@NE:MHKR ?K:F>PHKD BL BG IE:<> F:R E>:= MH AB@A>K, GHM
EHP>K, IKB<>L :G= F:R >LM:;EBLA : O>LM>= BGM>K>LM K>LBLM:GM MH K>@NE:MBHGL
MA:M >G<HNK:@> <HFI>MBMBHG. /MKBDBG@ MA> KB@AM ;:E:G<> ;>MP>>G
NG?>MM>K>= F:KD>ML :G= LM:M> K>@NE:MBHG BL =B??B<NEM :G= K>JNBK>L :
MAHKHN@A NG=>KLM:G=BG@ H? AHP F:KD>ML PHKD. (/MB@EBMS :G= /JNBK>
1998, 145)
):AFHH= ):F=:GB (2012) :LDL PA>MA>K /MB@EBMS <A:G@>= ABL FBG= HG
=>K>@NE:MBHG: fA<:=>FB< K>OB>P>KL H? /MB@EBMS A:O> H?M>G PHG=>K>= PA>G A> L:P
MA> EB@AM: =B= ,KH?>LLHK /MB@EBMS HIIHL> =>K>@NE:MBHG :M MA> MBF> HK <A:G@> ABL FBG=
PA>G BML <HGL>JN>G<>L ;><:F> <E>:K? /AHNE= P> NG=>KLM:G= ABL <KBMBJN> H?
=>K>@NE:MBHG :L ?HK>LB@AM HK ABG=LB@AM, ?HK>LB@AM BG 1996 HK ABG=LB@AM :?M>K ABL MBF>
:L CEBGMHGiL L>GBHK IHEB<R :=OBLHK?g
BR LMN=RBG@ :G= >QIHLBG@ MA> <HLML H? P:K, /MB@EBMS A:L MH LHF> >QM>GM
IHLBMBHG>= ABFL>E? HG ?HK>B@G IHEB<R. %G 2008, /MB@EBMS :G= (BG=: &. BBEF>L IN;EBLA>=
: ;HHD HG MA> AB@A <HLM H? MA> P:K BG %K:J (/MB@EBMS :G= BBEF>L 2008), :G= A> =B=
O:KBHNL F>=B: >O>GML MH IN;EB<BS> ABL ?BG=BG@L, LN<A :L :G BGM>KOB>P:M MA> P>;LBM> H?
Foreign Policy F:@:SBG> (/MB@EBMS 2008). BNM, MH HNK DGHPE>=@>, /MB@EBMS =H>L GHM H?M>G
LI>:D HNM BG : FHK> @>G>K:E P:R HG ?HK>B@G IHEB<R BLLN>L.
3KBMBG@ HG : ?BL<:E LMBFNENL BG 2010, /MB@EBMS LM:M>=:
0A> 1GBM>= /M:M>L G>>=L : LMBFNENL, ;NM BM G>>=L MH ;> P>EE =>LB@G>=
:G= JNB<D-:<MBG@ (:G= B? <NKK>GM MK>G=L <HGMBGN>, MA> L:F> PBEE ;> MKN>
?HK !NKHI>). AGR LMBFNENL PBEE :== MH MA> =>?B<BM, :G= PBMA MA> =>?B<BM
LH:KBG@ LBG<> 2002, BM BL >LI><B:EER BFIHKM:GM MH A:O> :L ;B@ :L : ;:G@
?HK MA> ;N<D :L IHLLB;E>. 0A> LMBFNENL LAHNE= :==K>LL EHG@-M>KF
IKH;E>FLe:G= :M MA> O>KR E>:LM, BM LAHNE= GHM F:D> MA>F PHKL>.
(/MB@EBMS 2010;, 79)
/MB@EBMS :ELH :=OH<:M>= : @EH;:E LMBFNENL:
0A> <KBLBL BL @EH;:E BG G:MNK> :G= <HNGMKB>L LAHNE= INM BG IE:<> :
K>LIHGL> MA:M BL :L <HHK=BG:M>= :L IHLLB;E> MH :OHB= F:LL NG>F-
IEHRF>GM :G= MA> KBLD H? BG<K>:LBG@ LH<B:E M>GLBHGL. /A>>K IKN=>G<>
K>JNBK>L FHK> LMBFNENL. 0A> PHKE= ><HGHFR G>>=L : FHK> @EH;:E
LMBFNENL :G= LAHNE= GHM MHE>K:M> ?K>> KB=BG@ ;R LHF> <HNGMKB>L. 0ABL
ECON JOURNAL WATCH
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 654
BFIEB>L : ?:BK LA:KBG@ H? MA> ;NK=>G H? MA> LMBFNENL :FHG@ <HNGMKB>L,
:G= : I:KMB<NE:K >??HKM MH A>EI MAHL> <HNGMKB>L MA:M =HGiM A:O> MA>
K>LHNK<>L MH E>:= : <HNGM>K-<R<EB<:E ?BL<:E IHEB<R. ("BMHNLLB :G= /MB@EBMS
2009, 3-4)
+G M:Q <NML:
0A> BNLA A=FBGBLMK:MBHG A:= EHG@ M:D>G MA> OB>P MA:M M:Q <NML (>L-
I><B:EER I>KF:G>GM M:Q <NML ?HK MA> KB<A) :K> MA> LHENMBHG MH >O>KR
IKH;E>F. 0ABL BL PKHG@. 0A> IKH;E>F PBMA M:Q <NML BG @>G>K:E BL MA:M
MA>R I>KI>MN:M> MA> >Q<>LLBO> <HGLNFIMBHG MA:M A:L F:KD>= MA> 1/
><HGHFR. c A M:Q K>;:M> M:K@>M>= HGER :M EHP>K :G= FB==E> BG<HF>
AHNL>AHE=L F:D>L L>GL>, >LI><B:EER LBG<> BM PHNE= ;> ?:LM>K :<MBG@.
(/MB@EBMS 2010;, 79)
%G K><>GM R>:KL, /MB@EBMS A:L <:EE>= ?HK @K>:M>K f>JN:EBMR H? HIIHKMNGBMR.g
fAF>KB<:GL :K> <HFBG@ MH K>:EBS> MA:M MA>BK <A>KBLA>= G:KK:MBO> H? LH<B:E :G=
><HGHFB< FH;BEBMR BL : FRMA,g A> PKHM> (/MB@EBMS 2013:). $> >QIE:BG>=:
A?M>K 1980, MA> IHHK @K>P IHHK>K, MA> FB==E> LM:@G:M>=, :G= MA> MHI
=B= ;>MM>K :G= ;>MM>K. BLI:KBMB>L PB=>G>= ;>MP>>G MAHL> EBOBG@ BG IHHK
EH<:EBMB>L :G= MAHL> EBOBG@ BG KB<A LN;NK;LeHK KB<A >GHN@A MH L>G= MA>BK
DB=L MH IKBO:M> L<AHHEL. A K>LNEM P:L : PB=>GBG@ @:I BG >=N<:MBHG:E
I>K?HKF:G<>eMA> :<AB>O>F>GM @:I ;>MP>>G KB<A :G= IHHK DB=L ;HKG
BG 2001 P:L 30 MH 40 I>K<>GM E:K@>K MA:G BM P:L ?HK MAHL> ;HKG 25
R>:KL >:KEB>K, MA> /M:G?HK= LH<BHEH@BLM />:G ". .>:K=HG ?HNG=. (/MB@EBMS
2013:)
%G 1973, /MB@EBMS PKHM> MA:M MA> 1GBM>= /M:M>Li =BO>KL> L<AHHE LRLM>F P:L
L>KOBG@ LMN=>GML P>EE (/MB@EBMS 1973, 145), :G= :==>=:
/HF> H? MA> <HFIE:BGML :@:BGLM MA> >=N<:MBHG:E LRLM>F :K> K>:EER :=-
=K>LL>= MH :LI><ML H? HNK ><HGHFB< LRLM>F, I:KMB<NE:KER MH MA> =>@K>>
H? BG>JN:EBMR PAB<A BM >G@>G=>KL. AEMAHN@A BM A:L ;>>G :K@N>= MA:M MA>
>=N<:MBHG:E LRLM>F BL GHM MA> <:NL> H? BG>JN:EBMR, MA> =B??B<NEM JN>LMBHG
K>F:BGL: BL BM IHLLB;E>, :G=/HK =>LBK:;E>, MH NL> MA> >=N<:MBHG:E LRLM>F
MH IKHFHM> @K>:M>K >JN:EBMR? (/MB@EBMS 1973, 145)
%G 2013, AHP>O>K, /MB@EBMS <BM>= : PB=>GBG@ >=N<:MBHG:E :<AB>O>F>GM @:I, L:RBG@
BG>JN:EBMR FNLM ;> :==K>LL>=: f738> A:O> MH K>O>KL> MA> =:F:@BG@ <NM;:<DL MH
IK>L<AHHE >=N<:MBHGc. 3> A:O> MH F:D> LNK> MA:M :EE <ABE=K>G A:O> :=>JN:M>
IDEOLOGICAL PROFILES OF THE ECONOMICS LAUREATES
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 655
GNMKBMBHG :G= A>:EMA <:K>eGHM HGER =H P> A:O> MH IKHOB=> MA> K>LHNK<>L, ;NM B?
G><>LL:KR, P> A:O> MH BG<>GMBOBS> I:K>GML, ;R <H:<ABG@ HK MK:BGBG@ MA>F HK >O>G
K>P:K=BG@ MA>F ?HK ;>BG@ @HH= <:K>@BO>KL. c #BOBG@ FHK> FHG>R MH IHHK L<AHHEL
PHNE= A>EI. c "BG:EER, BM BL NG<HGL<BHG:;E> MA:M : KB<A <HNGMKR EBD> MA> 1GBM>=
/M:M>L A:L F:=> :<<>LL MH AB@A>K >=N<:MBHG LH =B??B<NEM ?HK MAHL> :M MA> ;HMMHF :G=
FB==E>g (/MB@EBMS 2013:). !<HGHFB< :G= >=N<:MBHG:E BG>JN:EBMR K>BG?HK<> >:<A HMA>K,
/MB@EBMS L:B=. $> <:EE>= ?HK fLN;LM:GMB:E IHEB<R <A:G@>L,g <HG<EN=BG@: f3> A:O> :G
><HGHFB<, :G= GHM HGER FHK:E, BGM>K>LM BG L:OBG@ MA> AF>KB<:G =K>:Fg (B;B=.).
%G : ;HHD /MB@EBMS IN;EBLA>= BG 2010, A> PKHM> H? ABL >:KER AHI>L MA:M MA>
G>P +;:F: A=FBGBLMK:MBHG fPHNE= KB@AM MA> ?E:P>= IHEB<B>L H? MA> BNLA :=FBG-
BLMK:MBHG, :G= P> PHNE= F:D> IKH@K>LL GHM HGER BG MA> BFF>=B:M> K><HO>KR ;NM :ELH
BG :==K>LLBG@ EHG@>K-KNG <A:EE>G@>L. 0A> <HNGMKRiL ?BL<:E =>?B<BM PHNE= M>FIHK:KBER
;> AB@A>K, ;NM MA> FHG>R PHNE= ;> P>EE LI>GM: HG A>EIBG@ ?:FBEB>L D>>I MA>BK
AHF>L, HG BGO>LMF>GML MA:M PHNE= BG<K>:L> MA> <HNGMKRiL EHG@-KNG IKH=N<MBOBMR :G=
IK>L>KO> MA> >GOBKHGF>GM, :G=, BG K>MNKG ?HK :GR FHG>R MA:M P:L @BO>G MH MA> ;:GDL,
MA>K> PHNE= ;> : <E:BF HG ?NMNK> K>MNKGL MA:M PHNE= <HFI>GL:M> MA> IN;EB< ?HK MA>
KBLD BM ;HK>g (/MB@EBMS 2010:, QQBBB).
.>@:K=BG@ MA> ?BG:G<B:E <KBLBL, /MB@EBMS L:B= MA:M F:GR BG MA> ?BG:G<B:E L><MHK
fLHE= 7AHF> ;NR>KL8 <HLMER FHKM@:@>L :G= P>K> AB=BG@ =>M:BEL H? MA> ?>>L BG ?BG>
IKBGMc. 0A> ?BG:G<B:E >EBM> LNIIHKM MA> IHEBMB<:E <:FI:B@GL PBMA AN@> <HGMKB;N-
MBHGL. 0A>R ;NR MA> KNE>L MA:M :EEHP MA>F MH F:D> MA> FHG>R. )N<A H? MA>
BG>JN:EBMR MA:M >QBLML MH=:R BL : K>LNEM H? @HO>KGF>GM IHEB<B>Lg (/MB@EBMS 2012:).
%G 2013, /MB@EBMS :==K>LL>= :G A"(-C%+ <HGO>GMBHG, L:RBG@ BG I:KM:
3> A:O> ;><HF> : AHNL> =BOB=>= :@:BGLM BML>E?e=BOB=>= ;>MP>>G MA>
99% :G= MA> 1%, ;>MP>>G MA> PHKD>KL, :G= MAHL> PAH PHNE= >QIEHBM
MA>F. 3> A:O> MH K>NGBM> MA> AHNL>, ;NM BM PHGiM A:II>G HG BML HPG.
%M PBEE HGER A:II>G B? PHKD>KL <HF> MH@>MA>K. %? MA>R HK@:GBS>.
%? MA>R NGBM> MH ?B@AM ?HK PA:M MA>R DGHP BL KB@AM, BG >:<A :G= >O>KR
PHKDIE:<>, BG >:<A :G= >O>KR <HFFNGBMR, :G= BG >:<A :G= >O>KR LM:M>
<:IBM:E :G= BG 3:LABG@MHG.
3> A:O> MH K>LMHK> GHM HGER =>FH<K:<R MH 3:LABG@MHG, ;NM MH
MA> PHKDIE:<>. (/MB@EBMS 2013;)
$> <HG<EN=>= MA> LI>><A ;R L:RBG@:
5HN FNLM @>M HMA>KL MH CHBG RHN, MH PHKD PBMA RHN, MH HK@:GBS> PBMA
RHN, MH ?B@AM PBMA RHN. %M BL HGER RHN PAH <:G K:BL> MA> OHB<> H? HK=BG:KR
AF>KB<:GL, :G= =>F:G= PA:M RHN A:O> PHKD>= LH A:K= ?HK. 0H@>MA>K,
P> <:G @KHP HNK ><HGHFR, LMK>G@MA>G HNK <HFFNGBMB>L, K>LMHK> MA>
ECON JOURNAL WATCH
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 656
AF>KB<:G =K>:F, :G= K>->LM:;EBLA HNK =>FH<K:<Re: @HO>KGF>GM GHM
H? MA> 1%, ?HK MA> 1%, :G= ;R MA> 1%, ;NM : @HO>KGF>GM H? :EE
AF>KB<:GL, ?HK :EE AF>KB<:GL, :G= ;R :EE AF>KB<:GL. (/MB@EBMS 2013;)
References
Atkinson, Anthony B., and Joseph E. Stiglitz. 1980. Lectures on Public Economics.
*>P 5HKD: )<#K:P-$BEE.
Buchanan, James M. 1970. The Public Finances: An Introductory Textbook, 3K= >=.
$HF>PHH=, %EE.: %KPBG.
Fitoussi, Jean-Paul, and Joseph E. Stiglitz. 2009. 0A> /A:=HP #N*: 0A> 3:RL
+NM H? MA> CKBLBL :G= MA> BNBE=BG@ H? : )HK> CHA>LBO> 3HKE=. 3HKDBG@ I:I>K
2009-17. +;L>KO:MHBK> "K:GZ:BL =>L CHGCHG<MNK>L T<HGHFBJN>L (,:KBL).
Link
Hedengren, David, Daniel B. Klein, and Carrie Milton. 2010. !<HGHFBLM
,>MBMBHGL: %=>HEH@R .>O>:E>=. Econ Journal Watch 7(3): 288-319. Link
Henderson, David R. 2008. &HL>IA !. /MB@EBMS. %G The Concise Encyclopedia of
Economics, >=. $>G=>KLHG. (B;>KMR "NG= (%G=B:G:IHEBL). Link
Hoff, Karla. 2008. &HL>IA !. /MB@EBMS. Policy Research Working Paper 4478. 3HKE=
B:GD >O>EHIF>GM .>L>:K<A #KHNI (3:LABG@MHG, .C.). Link
Mamdani, Mahmood. 2012. A.>LIHGL> MH ,KH? &HL>IA /MB@EBMS. Pambazuka News
(":F:AN (M=.), &NER 25. Link
Rothschild, Michael, and Joseph E. Stiglitz. 1976. !JNBEB;KBNF BG CHFI>MBMBO>
%GLNK:G<> ):KD>ML: AG !LL:R HG MA> !<HGHFB<L H? %FI>K?><M %G?HKF:MBHG.
Quarterly Journal of Economics 90: 630-649.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 1973. !=N<:MBHG :G= %G>JN:EBMR. Annals of the American Academy
of Political and Social Science 409: 135-145.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 1989. +G MA> !<HGHFB< .HE> H? MA> /M:M>. %G The Economic Role
of the State, >=. AKGHE= $>>KMC>. +Q?HK=, 1': B:LBE BE:<DP>EE.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 1999. State Versus Market: Have Asian Currency Crises Affected the
Reform Debate? A:D:: 1GBO>KLBMR ,K>LL.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2002:. ANMH;BH@K:IAR. %G Les Prix Nobel: The Nobel Prizes 2001,
>=. 0HK> "KXG@LFRK. /MH<DAHEF: *H;>E "HNG=:MBHG. Link
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2002;. %G?HKF:MBHG :G= MA> CA:G@> BG MA> ,:K:=B@F BG
!<HGHFB<L. %G Les Prix Nobel: The Nobel Prizes 2001, >=. 0HK> "KXG@LFRK,
472-540. /MH<DAHEF: *H;>E "HNG=:MBHG. Link
IDEOLOGICAL PROFILES OF THE ECONOMICS LAUREATES
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 657
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2002<. C:IBM:E ):KD>M (B;>K:EBS:MBHG :G= !Q<A:G@> .:M>
.>@BF>L: .BLD 3BMAHNM .>P:K=. Annals of the American Academy of Political and
Social Science 579: 219-248.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2008. />O>G -N>LMBHGL: &H> /MB@EBMS HG $HP MA> %K:J 3:K %L
3K><DBG@ MA> !<HGHFR 7BGM>KOB>P;R &HAG 0ARL8. Foreign Policy, AIKBE 9. Link
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2010:. Freefall: America, Free Markets, and the Sinking of the World
Economy. *>P 5HKD: 3. 3. *HKMHG.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2010;. .>LIHG=BG@ MH MA> CKBLBL. %G Time for a Visible Hand:
Lessons from the 2008 World Financial Crisis, >=L. /M>IA:GR #KB??BMA-&HG>L, &HL[
AGMHGBH +<:FIH, :G= &HL>IA !. /MB@EBMS. +Q?HK=: +Q?HK= 1GBO>KLBMR ,K>LL.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2012:. %GM>KOB>P PBMA !<HGHFBLM &HL>IA /MB@EBMS: f0A>
AF>KB<:G K>:F $:L B><HF> : )RMA.g Spiegel Online, +<MH;>K 2. Link
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2012;. The Price of Inequality. *>P 5HKD: 3. 3. *HKMHG.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2013:. !JN:E +IIHKMNGBMR, +NK *:MBHG:E )RMA. New York
Times, ">;KN:KR 16. Link
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 2013;. 0A> ,>HIE> 3AH BK>:D MA> .NE>L $:O> .:D>= $N@>
,KH?BML :G= 3>:EMA :G= %MiL /B<D>GBG@ +NK ,HEBMB<L. AlterNet, />IM>F;>K 11.
Link
Stiglitz, Joseph E., and Linda J. Bilmes. 2008. The Three Trillion Dollar War: The
True Cost of the Iraq Conflict. *>P 5HKD: 3. 3. *HKMHG.
Stiglitz, Joseph E., and Lyn Squire. 1998. %GM>KG:MBHG:E >O>EHIF>GM: %L %M
,HLLB;E>? Foreign Policy 110: 138-151.
Richard Stone
;R :GB>E B. 'E>BG :G= .R:G :S:
(HG=HG-;HKG &HAG .B<A:K= *B<AHE:L /MHG> (1913d1991) ?HEEHP>= ABL
FHMA>KiL ?HHMLM>IL BG :MM>G=BG@ C:F;KB=@>, :G= BGBMB:EER IE:GG>= MH ?HEEHP ABL
?:MA>KiL ?HHMLM>IL :G= @H BGMH E:P. $:E?P:R MAKHN@A ABL NG=>K@K:=N:M> LMN=B>L,
AHP>O>K, /MHG> P:L BGLIBK>= ;R MA> #K>:M >IK>LLBHG MH L>>D LHENMBHGL BG MA>
LMN=R H? ><HGHFB<L (/MHG> 1985). /MHG> >O>GMN:EER =>O>EHI>= : M><AGH<K:MB< OB>P
H? ><HGHFB< IHEB<R (&HA:GL>G 1985, 5; 3HE?> 1968, 428).
AM C:F;KB=@>, /MHG> E>:KG>= LM:MBLMB<L, FH=>EBG@, :G= F>:LNK>F>GM ?KHF
CHEBG CE:KD (>:MHG 2008). NKBG@ 3HKE= 3:K %%, /MHG> PHKD>= :M MA> C>GMK:E
!<HGHFB< %G?HKF:MBHG />KOB<> H? MA> +??B<>L H? MA> 3:K C:;BG>M HG G:MBHG:E
:<<HNGMBG@ PBMA &:F>L )>:=>. &HAG ):RG:K= '>RG>L, MA>G PHKDBG@ :M MA>
0K>:LNKR, K><HFF>G=>= MA>BK PHKD, PAB<A P:L MA>G IN;EBLA>= BG 1941 :L :
ECON JOURNAL WATCH
jump to navigation table jump to navigation table
2+(1)! 10, *1)B!. 3, /!,0!)B!. 2013 658

You might also like