You are on page 1of 30

1 .

j~ (

(>~'-k~"/

Jl/-V;.

/;u'~ Y~.-J!-

~04:V!j):

p. !l4yl)t~/')

'--

~TF

. /

DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE


INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL,
E.O.13526, SECTION 5.3(b)(3)

l/ ,-

, [v., ,)./
Il1"j,
7!

ISCAP APPEAL NO. 2012-042, document no. 31


DECLASSIFICA TION DATE: September 29, 2014

_ (/ d~
- CoL.

U,5, /f~l/
~--~/_------~

l)u~cJ... 1'10 u[ 77;1')

------------------------------~-----------------------~
-~-

..

1-11-

!"7 7'{) 15

'\

/'"

---.

.~

I)

,.)

_;;[1~

Jl

. .

~~77J

V-J"

-,.' .'

==>:

~)~

/~

. F~ ~ FrY -~

----- fJ;Z. ~
. ~~

..~.y~

.U\vvz.

,~-

'/'-"~

- d-I;

oL~

~pA/ , ~/~

. {J-:t '\~

-1--+-1

~~,

'

-=----~
.

.----r:r-

~l)/e,4'D.

...

.::V-J<.

..~;7Ci~

?-v~. ~~

r-~~.,~),.(.~."~~,~
-tr: '-r."'-P/7 ~

1/1., -.
<<:::-.--

--

_/VJ~()

/)

!JJ---;--;/
/,-,,~

~/.'

--

!-IcY- ~

/:~-'.---

j}

_/

tY-F-

J'

~~

Ifr;~'

C'".~. ~~

L7r~ ~~;

7b .../~
--~

~-z.--?

Iou.

~~~.~--/'-oft~

_/~~j'

..

of

7D~o;f/f-.D

p~ {~
./J[j ;f Au . '
/~,/

-1/'
?t'/

10

11

[ E.O. 13526, section 1.4(a) [

M1 ~~

HL.{14fJ~4~

~k?f&~~~~

Ur ~~;.

'.

- ~#/'1dj::~~N2;/
)~\/l/O~dl)

*~.
Hk.~~
"* ~.~
/~)/

.~

7d~

f~

/d-C/1A'~

/~

...--.

!j

(;"

(IJl

/~~-J(

/V

(~

--

,/'-ro'/~

r,

:' --}/,

iJ..

/1

'//-"vrA

1J

.~~

i~

-~

Ale

c/y {~~
.7I~~

---l{.x#V'0 .~~.
~k

.0'.f

7U

C~{I&

..
v

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

\='4~~\ ~ c::,CJO
16. . ~

I' ....."

.-'\ I

C._,

.----+
(C'CvV

. ,
'Le:.....:.
\

NA
i,

-'.

ff~z-'<.~_/

I\.i

00)

',C::

-t~~;

-,-(\

~ 'N~

~"--"-_

\,~'(;-- :;:::'U_<f't~~

r-

(. ..
D'''-

:.

\\'~-':"~--'

~.,'\,.

""'~'"

C_\ ~..c.) \'\\.C.I '\

('\'\." .-s.:~ _,

C) \ r2v!

\:}\~"

',\,....

,.

1.-.~: ,~..

r-c,

\"j

"'\

(.:--'.~,~-L,z.t.):)-\'--~:

~.,:~_~r.:. ~~ \J:~\_\/(~.~.~,/_.--:

'\'i~\ ('~~~
~

__ .

.c;

\~~;~-

r-,

r-,

\:'~'-..w~(\!1\ \:'L"~;
cSz~:,J~\..IA:..r~3~~c~c:j~
\'.)cJ\-:?5,,~
~&'<

~~'-L~3'\\~~~,"
~''i'<.:''-c:~'- .~"Q-\~\x.,:it(:,
~:0-..,

~~'-~

C-.i.., Cf/,l"

~~

~'&S~~

r \~().~~)4~.\-J;)

~~"-\ \y:,-,--tiic',,~,~'-/

~;:, ';~~
'~9\~ \)\S':::/-

~C.o~

\.i-\'

"\\C:

U-f\

(-.:JL.c

\~\

C3\~:)

~\9.

Y:::'C..,-- '.

\\ .

\'\\\~\N~,-~~y,p
~~&j~L~\::"

~YK~\i:'~,;'('V",-_

c-r-

,-:::::,\)

C'--'-<~'------

~\

:40

(:i~~\i_)'

TI~:Z\

0 __

'--c'(s'G---_

'--'

'\

'\""r~u

(~\0 \---J

(2:~

'..

23

r- ...("\

N/'"

'~"
',...
.\';~
~,
C...............

,,~

l.lL,;/

~&>'-C

./ C~.-/I
\

"

:-;-(~~

c~.

i'1\l..C:'
)

.:~:~\
....\ .~\.<:.-.. ' -'~ (:':~"- ..'\...,

C~~j fYL/f1\/f>.,_. __

.... r)

\~J::..:u-:::"'.y,,S:i\,,:'_, (L~",,-;.~,
vi, Y
\

'",

.~: ...../.__

t.J -: .~.C..

C-)

;,~...:,<./;~

;/,t-:(.:i.\'~.J:=:""'-.--.~

"
(

\...1.:..:.:.f.,)..
\

,~.~/,

x,

" ".

.... ,

.'-.('

"

"..,.~,:~_0..''f"",-,\

')-,j\{ucJ_,:"'J

C<\_'.L

\'\~\_'t:G--'-~~::~J:'~j'

,. ...-,

.y cr--

r-

\'~<"-:",~.:)1J~"z.:\ \~>~\>~J'\..

(0
\
L. ~ ',_

" \'\\r, (' ,-

. ---

,'",.'

\~"~""

,~

"-

-:(

:"\

\\YY~-J V'(-":, .:.:

;,

~"'('=':'v~.v\'_'

,(._

r~L:,l~" \.:-'.i'"...,
.. >...:...
r'

}v''- ..:......)
G~

...Y

v-,

'...
>:')

-, .:'"
<. 'i < <, '\ ',.J",

,-:;

.).,:~-s '--_..

.J.
"

...

(~T '~~~~';-~):.i'~.

{('T: 1

1j_ .'

"'I.

(:

"

;
'.~

24

~\L\YL~
/
r-,

"

( -J':':S),y

";

.'"\

lCJ~\~
....
_/

,'\'0/-,\
t .....

'"

(j Q~~l&L'~YL

__

-'\9w-~~C--0t~,\

'1\)( _j \2<\)"~

9~iI~~\",\\,e.,-\'

(\\i:.~'L_
I
:)
,A '
,

l~,
.._.:

',--..,',

r;(:~"",,\'~.W_J)-;"-,:;~;\'(~~:"~
' ~j

=:
J

'

',)..;~~"-'\

'.

'v, ,

:';i-

\~ QI\\"!'O--

<~.J

'\:t'-c:<:- \:'~,,~,j,~.--1.\"-"

"

~--

,(:-,'~,\""
",~"i\
\.,)
, .

("'(/

'\ r-,

t ,'~-;\:J'!:; '):.).;~!.(jJ,-_'

--'.

...

"

~:
'-.~'V ,S'-j c-.J'("\;,',_

.'

CLl'{Y~,.,---

(-"

"'-

..,

25

(~""'-\!l:~k\V~'\ C),~~t\("iS-~:,--,~t,
\

-\:: .-'

\'

~;:'1;."\'>~-~

'-\'~{i __
\~

\.J

"
\w~-:i~-

~~~;.-

Yl\ \---

~~~~\j~--~'-~~

r\,....

,~

<X~-"J\

.~C') .~;'

\.

\,

I.,'~'

r-.

26

\;c!0':;

.1.. _-':.(.

,
'1

f.

ki\.,..~;.jr\~,
.'~'"

.......

"

, .;-..

"~~':v-.-;")

"
\

(~~ J

c:

~,V"-:I

,...

'.

/\ ,\ C:'~
.. "
-

\\

... -\'

r~-'\(-." .
'1 .J' .-A.;'.':;"'-..) .
/_

27

..

C.i!~C
...~. '

A) C--,

./

'lvt:,u--,- ' v' cr "~,


1

-.....

\.

......-"

(~3fY~!~'

,,"_<.... _

"-----"-- '"
C'"-_,,J:

,!._ ... ',.\..

k\.." ,'-,-,
l-S:O'-.J.;.--

,
y \. 1'--;"-.:-";,,_):,

t,

}<. :~~ ..:"(y\~.:,


..',.(.;.,.j("

-,

GJLt~~'L.<..J 'i~J

;..~--! ',,'

;".

'-~:;':~\j~~t,~~~{
::'
-j

\ ,~!
...
jJ
".'\

"...

c-

.-!..J.::;. ..:J.......:

r .....
...r:r..!

...

,
.\J....~..~ ,;....c.;.~../>:

.....

".

''{l . if'::., __ s 'l.;


'
. -'\:'
,

""
\-\'

..~_.

\ .: ::

~
_\(
..
.1; .:'

i\_

J-

'.. ,,:':

.
'.J

\V'~

}'--'~.

~_~J

:'.

5-- (,\i,',,\ t'" j\\


il. 0

'--';L:"

j:

_':

I"

; -:>

)L;\

"

\)\Q.{~.'li~C.;

U'

,.'~

~~

"j

-.
'.

\.

'-

( - ..J\..X..,\:",-,
'\ \:'1(\ '.,'''''"\
C-1'. ')'
v \ , v...~' '.

28

J, . \
"\'-,

"0'

,-,

-'\''fu_; ,f\;J._p\Ci._~_(.
.

i ._-

l~~l.(~.
>~('

'\ ..'\(~'i...~--,~~:;.'<J""".,

~..,..

... '.')

..~:\:_

"

.1/).,,' -,...
. ;. I

\.

'\

--:..:./

,'-:

C _i).>r,<-.<t::>~,~;:::..J._:.,;../ ...:

~,_ \~'~'

!
!

"-.:.

'"

.\ -, -.1. .~ ~~'.~.:.

r_\~JJ>
- . ...,.i

.... ;
"

'--_c::.. "~'-<'--\:
-,

'1

r:::'1.~~-/L~'->.?
Ll...fv_:,;

-{Vv(\..I,-:.
I"'~',\

"

,.

y-.J'(~,.:;.s:.>(':.,.;-

l,y,;:::;~fj.'~'Y\~TiGh

r\(\:::.;~\

J2: Q~'

'" j

<-<'--I
.-'

u',
~'jF-'

UUI,/2'1,'iJ:.:.'
- ..(:'r~7

I\).

L-;::.-:J.,

_ .. ),

I Z_;Vy,\.r.::t-\...!
\ ,.

.\ J.J('~V'y'lZ__
c..
_

I .''(,if-+-.

I ')I-{)Ir_-;~

.... "\.",
\"'-

i"-(;\
'.:, '.,',',

c.

).-,L>..
r-

;Ut
\.
~

.:~Y'~.},~).
'-<,,' -,:

~.~.

',

'-.,',

t. \

<_.-'::....-:

29

C"\

~j'v\S,-

__
\;~
-l~;'

'\. ',,"\
<'.'j
"J

.-l.-~i)
c

t:

....

\)",

L-l'I",- ...-:

;),-- ('j.;~~~

i .,j

'.

-'\

\)NV::O~'L~,j\;"'.....
--:'"
.\
. '.
..:,.
(_,_\\:~/"--)

( "VJ
.j

( ....

........
1

'u.J~~'\;'y\.J-..\5..j',<".

C.vv---.,

.. ".\{

, ,

'-.:.~ \ --e.~~_;

"",

:"'\

.,,:.--..,,~.":.

\;...:)_j~~0:...-rA\)\S;:,;)1
\

:~j~'0...;
,...
,~~

'\~\\.Il-\~\1\}~'\~

C{{_\~J\\..~\
......i

\ ......j

(L~iliYv(~~;;7GrrYL;.
,J

..',
u....
./~,'I
J

(-..

~('/~1'u:~~;

, ~'. r
'\ \... ,,,, ..

...

./ i

(~.~
I

..-:.. ,\

\, ''\ \5> ;., .,,_>._~~.;~.-c, . <,


\

"

>..,.

30

.'1'

-i.

I
f

: /

...._

v..

.f\I~~
. \'t~.
'-._......

.....

,
\

\.\}~)\"{:'l~l_).
C'--I\\\.'~;.\...' L~h"Y\y_'<.Lv!.. ,

C::.,

J:u.",

"\

>-"'r'Y-

~~

'1/ t \ ,<S
r-',

'<,~C;"

<?~vy--

C5)i~~
"<n~~5(_
v

\Y~It;~~

v...

.\~r~_~t~i

'''~*~'''\''-~'~\-\~,
"'J

\"~

,,\~~~~"'--.J

C\(~~J~\,~