You are on page 1of 20

JS 44'GrsPM¥ ~EV1 !

'20013,

..

-: .'".1:; -, ,

TE

PLAI NTlfFS Yeshiiva UnJversily

DEFEf,lQJ,lNTS

AiberrE.i rlg-tei'n U l'Ii'lt€lt'8ity

'rl)~")S""~~,,,,1 ~[j""r "!ie!U~d 'lMe it1fOfMII~~;;' ~oal'<l ifj~ hetein ~~iiN8r r:il'~'~i(iB n~' S~~PI8J~~Rk.lh~ ~1I!i'ie 1M){~,~r,~",,'~ol ~~:a>d;;'~~ ~t"jJoIMr.p.!,per~ ~~J1!~U!red b~j~:t« t!.~~,p!! ~~,.pfo"~.i~~ bl' ~~~i'r,~i~"Qf ~D~~ .. Th~~ ""'~, ~!'PrOv~a b~J~l!J.Jqdi~1 ':CO("(<<;In{~ ~f 1f1~ ~ n1liJl)d .S,",I~', i~ s.<J!i>i!';nl b~, fal-~. I~ r"'.<I';jl~~ f<),: ~~~ ·oHtiiO 'ClOk ~F ()~~!l·Mr !lIe ""fJI'il'9f1 or ;nlll!:!i'II~~ 'ih~ ci'{il d<id .. h.~(!(et.

. p,noRN.E,YS {FIRM.N_AME,· ADl;iRE.SS, /'!.I'm T~PI'lONE NU,,",6ER} B41g11!lifTlI'>k:J;"cI!tlt!gn UF'

~~9 Par~A~e

Niw ¥.;:a,'New York WUZ2

CAUS:"E OF ACTlo"r~c= fl-1EU.:S. CiVIL ~l)l..T'\,Jn JJtH:l!=R: WFlICH.'YOI,J·ME FiLaHG .hNti wRni; A IlRIEF-siATIO ... EHt Ql" CALI Si!;i·)

. (C'lot;1.t.i'OJ C'IT~·JI)J'I"i:sn~lI6'N~j:ST'J,.TIl:T"~$ui.u,E.SS.·!}iVEI'I"S,nl '. I .

~mA:n I. 1'1'~ 111i(j 111X:

L114(]

t J ~5r lll5:i1

[]-.tl!() [ ]ttoQ

f"'.J:!..&I\"Il'il !fYIJRY _. r 1 'Il'.IO .. ~m t,I_A_lf·t;I..AC.IIC~ I. ],~ F<E;R&ON~J)tuURY roROOOCi LI.MlILff'l' I I'~ ·~JOs~SoflAli.., INJlI:l~~.PIIDI:!Uc.T

.l.1A~Llry

~TOO~' aTHER F~0 &. ORLo3; I:l~G~rED :st;1~ijIl~O~ ~Cf'E:l1fr¥

~1 U3C;i1;!!1 l..!QiJOR'!.,!'lWS ~F!a ,RUCK .6.IRl.jNE.~S OCPJ"'A'T~Al SAFETYllf!E.<'oLJH

qrHE:R ..

l]62t) r J e.1O

Il·:

l'l~$J

I"ER5Ie,t>IA.~.PROP1iiI.fJ'Y I P70 OTHlEIR. f~1)

1 I~W T.Rl.JTi-I!N l!;NI:;tNI1> 1 1380 pnti!.Ii'ER5D~

I i~~ :g~~~~~'

. I":'lOOOCT L~JLiT'r

~'fI

I 1 1'10 ~ANHJ.'.B!DR S"!·ANf':[,o.);IDlS AcIT i ,11:~ L.jl;~mm~n RE~AT'tO~

.J

r~1 ,t~ . tlQNTR,o,c.l F'WX)OOT L~IJY

r HG6 i";t,'\!iICtl!SE .

1,1;:1:10' r ]l10 r '122a

I J 24>D [1:?AilI

r:J2.00

1;1i'W~~Y' ll,l.2~ APPE",t\L ~~'~1$

t 1 42~ v/ifflOR.!!,j,o(,jI,L ;l~~1~

[ 'I m; cor:(RI(;i'IT$ 1'.IIlQi;. .!'AJEr>.!T

!lfit aw'mliO.0~~

I. lilet" HI,I(fI3~fI) ,

,[ J E;q~ 1ll~"U,It{IO~)

L }~3; Dl\l'lCitiill<W·{~..Q"ll [.J ~4 . 'S~iO Vin(;.:l'>i! . .' ~ 1 s;J~ ~.i.i;ni .

[ 1 ~oo 5!ATf;

IlEAPPQRTIDt{!;,1ENT,

~ l~l1) AtmtfltJn· .

I. l~ 1lANt(S 'UA~I~ I.l'~ C~~RCE

i'14M creJ'O"UAT~ .

! 'j ~.~ ·p,tLCK~e~!t!i'1Lu, fiN'lJEIHCof;;F:!.lIF"T· ~TiQN . .<i,C' ~RI0Ell

Il,l!!l~ ,

I !A9~ Ij!l1(l

I. j,1!i5!I CS,E;ClJRl.J.IESt

CCl\lolt'@oIII~Si ~G'I'WJGE

I I~~ OUSK1M:m,

- OH.AJ.LENG~

j~IJSi;i,~41Q

IS$!! ':rATUIOf"

l ,eel ?GR1CliL"]B!;li\i.. Ji.Cf.> l ~'2.- EOOllCMIE; .

J~~.::~~~~::T

~"TTE.1't!l

f,!l94 , Et£FiGY" Al,I>,OC.t.TiOi,I ACT 1 ~~ FJl·!<El'lor.. ¢~ . .~QR~TIO~,p,ffi

1- APPF.AI...OF-FEE.

M~I,III'{I\'fIQtoI i,Jt.I~EFI eQlJiit MliE.Ssro ~lJSooe

I ]'tMo. ~s.TlTunotw,.m <3~ ~T""T~"$l""'1'IJTd;'

[ H~Q rJ.m!!

dMl

r<1m~RI!l..1"ro: SJjIU RAA-"".o/!' 6l>,mm.o!iCT .[ II$!Q :rM~a(W<$. ~:r.~tf.<;<

Q"[HER .LA50R ~JJ

una .... Tt>:»I- [l8~1. 1~.s.THIF;J~ ~

e).l~l Rqlltz; ',,~ ~7~

SEaJJI;!IY ACJ

IM1'!lilil'u;,Tlmi

.~~~PE:nVtON'"

I 1~IO J~t'.;l~STO V~~1E SOEtflENCE ·0l'1i.JS'!:::.l2'l'i5

I ]5,30 H,«ae.,r.s~f'U.5

1 ]~. D=,,"ffl ~~ttl'iL lY . 1]5<10 '~[)"'r.!US;S!9JiiQ. I J ~ C:ML RIG'!.IJS!

·t J ~ Pfi:H5Q(\1 OOt'!ll!lloti

I !~B2 I !~~ U~El5,

N,i"TUIW..IV,TloN A!"FIlK;AlidN ~~5r P!..I""e..I Q!rrAINEE: o:rHE~ l~nGRO<TION ACnoo~' .

~.Af,jp Qo~r.t:tA~iCtj FoFi;;aOSUFte ~.Ef.lT LEASE i!Ii. ~~~rsf

. T~S 1'0 U;t.II) TI;]R,['I"floo!:£T (I",i~_m' . - ALLOTHiOFI ~F'I1~ .. TY

L'14~' ~!3, IjHz~~Nr [jol4~~t«>i ...

~.lO~'!K:+!S

[11M' Vl'EU"AAe: .

r '!,~<!5 ~~S:\"'lTH DI~'ll5S •. UiFLQy .... t<lJ

I !&4Il ~,~~~~

_ $AO 1J"t1E.~ -9Jl1~ I ~,440 01"H~~.0\!1L. ~~n

Chec~ {f'dfjmwiHrJ in qompI.affl;I:

[J .CflE~I'<1f .!~~S 15-"1, CLASS ACH¢N U~[IE;R F .F:t,i)::.~" 2S

co YOO CLAIM THIS CASE ~S RELA TEl) TO ,A. CIVIL CASE NOlN PENDING' IN S.D_N.'1 _ '? If·So. $.tA tE::

DEMAND$:_' .,OTHEH JUD'GE DOCKET NUM8.E:R,....., _

~~:VeSorl{ftl '1!t,- $_~" On .. ,~.pI,.:aim

JURY, DEMAND: U .~

'fPiJiU I\{'1 x IN ONEBCYX oNly)

I2] l' O~,~lri!l1 D·'2i'l-,R~~b"~o!I'ro'rn '03:

Pr[!iI:~~dir1I3,. S.mlB l~o.lLIrl

o 2h.R";o",'I!>d {, ... '" .~tD1C C our! AHIl I:;d ~~ta~t. I:iInitl. ~s;i~ ~ ~'" .. e..

a-RIGI'H

D ·5 T r~~;;t~rrt!~ frnm ID.6 '-lul~id'jo,rio.

~S,,~eifr Di~lr",l~ ~I!I!l~I.!on

,0 7' '''''~~'''116 OJ,'riot ~JlJdge rFQm "'e!jll~if300 J"~g"

J~~9I'n~~! -

(PLACE AN' x IN ON~Emx OM...,.,

o 1 U_S_ PI,Jl<INTIFF'. 'D 2: U_S_ DEFENDANT.

BASIS OF ,JURISDICTION

0'3 FEDERAl OOEsinQN . 04DI'VERSll'Y

(U.S. NOT A PAfUY) ...

IF DIVERSfTY:.INDlCA 1E C1TIzEIliS'HlP BELDW, ('28 USC 1322 •. 1'441)

CmZEf.JSH1P OF PRH1CIPAL PARTIE~.(F-OR DI\('ERSITY Ci:\SE$ ONl Y) tP1aqe an IXJI!1 000 bo~fQr f'1'afrniff ami 008 timo: f(!f ~faMan.I.}

Fori' 'OEF'

CtTltStfOF THIS ::IlAU 1 J t r.lt

I'T~ O~F

CITIZEH,QR SlJI!.,IE;CT $I""A i P r I~

~OFU;iG·r.j COUNTRY

iii OO~PORA;Teo- ilil! !'RIN CIP-AL F<Ur. E (IF SUS,IN,E1!S 11\1 ANO.THE~ al' .... JE·

CITIZ~H i!l_F "'t40THEF!:~TAtE !']2 I' 'I ~

iN CORI"OR:.io.,T€ [I~r PRlili CIP,U ,PUCE; I 1;1 I I ~

OF' !I~81I\1ES:$ 1t',iT'fU(;I' S1"~TE

I'TF OEF:
r 1~' r 1.51
I j ~ I 1 ~ 'V6$hiva University

WO We.sf 185th Street. New' YOrk, New York 10033 New York Count-y

AJbe-rl E.i nstain University 4352 Karahe,dy Blvd. Tampa, F.lorjdf!'.3J6(l9

DE·F.EN IJANT(S} ADDRESS VNKNOWN .

REPRES,E'Nl'ATlQN IS 'HERESY MADE 'fHAT"ATTHIS 'n~,.1 HAVE BEEN UNABLE. WITH REASONABLE DIWGENCE., To.A.SCERl'A!:N THE

RESiPENc;E AOOR~SEel OF'"rHE FOL.LOWI NO [!EFEN'DANT$:' . ..... ,

CheeK one: nus A.CTiON ·SHOULD iBE. ASSIGN,cD TO.: 0 WHITE PLAINS (00 'NOT !;.flecr.. e~r OO~ illllis a fIR'SONER. PEnnON,)

0MANHATTt'\N

AOM~TTEO TO pJiACTICe IN ytNtJ;DI3TRICT' tr NO

N'YES (CAiTE ADJiUTTED Mo. ~ 'tr: 2001 A.Hemey Bar ~e # 19210-5-

UN ITE,psTAT,ES.OISTR.lCr COU RT' (NEW 'YORK: SOUTH~RN)

John P. Son

BINGHAM McCUTCHEN'LLP 39,9 Park Avenue.

New York, NY 1002.2 212.705.7000

Joshua M. Dalton. (Pro Hac Vice to be filed) Lawreaee T; 'Staniey, Jr. (Pro-Hac.P'i'ce to be filed) BINGHAM McCUTCHEN LLP

One Federal Str--eet

~stilll,.MA 02110

A"tto.rneysfor Plaintiff "yq;r;Mva' _Um~rsft.y

UNITED~l'ATES D:JS,TIUcr COURT SOutHERN DISTRJCT or NEW YORK

YESHIVA UNIVERSITY} Plaintiff

. -~

ALBERT 'EINSTEIN UN.IV.ERSITY"~

Defendant.

D.EMAND FOR· JURY-TRIAL

NATURE OF THE ACTION'

2. Thisis ·an. aeti.bn at _law and: inequity ftjrqadernm infiingemem, Ja}se

designation ,of ori&in:, unfair ·oompetitio.n~ and ,cyiJe.rsq,uattmg. WJ4,g 'ood/er the Trademark Act of 1946,15 U.s-c. § ],051 ei'!ie:q, (theft'Lanham Act") arid. the common Jaw.

3. Bythis,action~.YU QJtdUs ,A~rlE:ins~R GoUege of M~icihe)~ed:: the

·assistance of'the Court·to address what appears to be n.othing more than a shamelesshoax perpetuated at the direc.~ end irreparab]e expense of YO's. good\Vil1:~

-4. At <www .. albertemstein.university.org>,.one'findspage after p~e lauding ..

. the benefits ofattenrlin8. the Albert Einstein University mediealschcol located on Q,rand Cayman Island. The: website has· sectiens about A]umni~Fina.ncial. Aid~ Student Lifi; and more. It shows .pbo;tos and quotes 1To:m current and former students". describing its history of n [p ]rovidin,g quality . education· focuS¢d anthe Sll~.ceSS; of [its] .smdents" and bOrui:ts th.at, II I sjinee 1997} more than one thousand. :iltudents have obtained th€::lr MDdegroo' from AEU.I. It even describestbe schoel's accredUadon"bythe prestigio:us Accreditation Commission on Colleges Q1j' Medicine; Thereis 'Only one problem: None: ef'it .i:Rl.'ieat Rather, II Albert Ems-tern: 'Umver&it.yll· doesnot exist, AU tlta:t in fact. exists is a. domain name and website making wholesale misuse of YU's ENS.rEINreiatedttademarks aed ,gOOdVlUi' to perpetuate a stunning deception furthering a:h~tofQfe .unknown.but obviously unemhorized.eadillegal $Chem~. These acts represene amest.grave and ~ weat to tbe.imp'eoca~!.e nmni~apdrep'U.tation.that Y1.J has worked decades to.deVelop, and repre-S,e~lt..a textbook et:amtd e 'of what. the .. LM.lham·A¢~. and ~tare ·llud· consumer Pr0t;ection laws were writteu to prevent,

. THE PARTIES

5. .PlaintiffY,eshl;va:'University is an education corporation duly organized

and existing under the laws ofthe State of N ew York, and has an- address at 500 West 185&. Street-;l.New· York e- New York 10033.

6. Upon. ioformatien and heJief~ defendant i1Albert Einstein U ai versity" is ·the

individual or ,entitY. operating. i;\' website ·.ar<v.'Ww.'albe.rteinsteinuniversuy.otg> for an an~ged n),edic·al school under. that name andelaiming to mahlta;in its principal placeefbusiness at 4152 Kennedy Blvd .• Tampa, FL. 33609 ..

,JURISDICTION AND VENUE.

7. This. is, a civil ,wet.ion for trademark. infrittgetneJ!:t. false des.igll·~ton of

origin, unfair competition and cybeffiquatfing arisingunder tlie 'Lanham Act and for unfair wmpeUtio.Q. and. trademark infringement erising under the common law.

2

8. This court has subject. matter "i?risaicUorl of this· arCHon f»JfSuimt to

28 ,=-,.S·.C. §:"§ ttn mid. BJ8'.and, the prln.cfples- of supplemental jlurisdiction.

9~ This ,Mtlit.naslier.snnai jurisdictiollCi'Ver Albert Eitlste1u Uruvexs.ify iile that,

it apd/O[ it~.aher oC1lg;qs an:dl:or"tt:s agents are doing.:1;imlnesS in the Stat:e. of New Yor~ arid it is oommittingtne aqtsherehu:J.tler ·al~;¢ge.d and c,aJ1$ing ha'lltl. h~ the State of New Y(lrk.

1 n Venue £(1.[ l'hi.s action ispto~ if! tlw SQuthein District o{ New ¥od,:

,BACKGROUND FACTS

A.. 'y'e.sbi.~:a University

J. l . YU is a world':'renown.ed :pri.vate, university in ;r~re\V Y Oi'k: Clty; .lvith six:

e;mlpJJ,.')esin NewY:o:~ka'nd onein br:ael.

12. Found,ed in 18~6.t ifQ. isthe oldcst:llst.it,:unp,o, ofhl~her learning. m,.the

.,Uri.itoo. Stat>es oom1;')iriing Jewish· scnolars;h,ip with.~smdi~ :jjnllieJLberal.arts~ Sc.ienoosi med,i.ci.ne~ law, businesS.· SiOciru, wb;rk~ JeWish ·smdies;,.m.d ~QciUcint and ·P'$yC1:tOI0gy~,

13. In the pastil.] yea.rs~Y[J hag·etpandeitro OQmPri~; sipm¢<tw~ty.OQu.eges~

schoo'ls!"affiliat~s., centers, and msti;tuHons.~ w~th seveml aU:11iatedtlO:spita1s and.heahh care .institutiens, in,eluding but not Jfmired· to Albert Biostein CoU:e;ge of Medicine (rctEinslcin~')"·

14. Emstein.~ established tu 19i~·~js. one ofdl.e Ul1itedS:trites' premier

institutions form~ica~ '~d:u~on~ ba~ljcres~r-ch: and~Uni~[ irrv~tig:atio:n (th:e'''S¢Mces''f).

]S~. Among itspioneeqng edu~tio,naI: inittati:'1t.';f~ EinsteinWl;l5· Pmong the.fi~t

oftbe'majow .$d'ical ~nq"]s' to{) i:1]~eg[ate ~bedsjd(f e){,perierice: willi :le<}mi1:tg, briogJJlS·firsl;.,Year ···s;~'Qn~ into·CQut;act-with·patients an<d[itOOrig:da~s.room stm:lyto ~eaperiMce.einitein alse ]~d"tb,e· way. in tb~.' d.evcl~pm,ent of ~jo~dyjcs '~'om, ap€:eP~ a;cademic dJ~cipHnedb .. medlCals-ch()sJ ,~.cu1a,. and it was the Jirst"priy&fe medica1oonoo.i in Ne.'WYo!)k'Ciuy ttre..~tabtfsh an. a-cademic D~mtment: of'F~mily Mtdioine ~: 'weUas. the 'firsUo, .create a. residenc¥ ,program in. in~em.Ai ,mediiclf1·ewitll.an .. eJ!nphaS:i/i ,on women's he-alth.

16.. The medical school is; affiliated with five hospital centers: MontMfore

MediCal Cenler~ Th.e AcademlcMedical Center and Univ·ersity· Hospital of"the Albert .Einste.n Cellege of~Medihlne;.Beth ISrael. Medical Center, the University Hospital and Manhattan Campusfor the Albert Binstein CoHe,ge ofMfd.icine; North Shore-Long 'Ialand Jewish Health .Sys.tem; 'the M,atlhasset and New Hyde P,tb:k can:t_p.us;es, ofth~ Albert. EiustehtCoJlege of Medicine; Jacobi Medical ·Cent~r;;; and:the BronX-:Lebrmon. Hospital Cen.ter. It is also affiliated with llireement:all1,eal1;h. facilities and. four long-term care facilities, Through its extensive affiliation netwod:~ Einstein nms:one o1'the·l.arg~st p08t-graduatem.OOiCllJ tJ:ajning pro~ in the United StMles, offering some 150 residency pregrams to more than 2~500pbyslcians in. training.

17. Einstein is regularly re-oo~bed as. a-tcp-tier-medical school. For el_w]?le)

it is current1yrank~d nationwide by U.S. News and World Repcrt as a top SO. medical schooi in. :~scitrcliand a tQ]l' 25·:m¢i.~ school in:pri'mazy C.nR.

B. The :EINSTEIN Marks

18. YU has boon. usmg the marks ALBERT ElNSTElN .and ALBERT

EINSTEIN .cOLLEG.E OF l'fiEDlClNE in. connection .with the· Services-since fill leastDecember of 195.5.

19. 'YU owns a:<l:egistranon. inthe domain name I'~einstein.yu,edu .. !'

20. YU O'WllS several federal trademark registratinns and apP'licatIO:DS. for marks containing tll~ terms .AL,.BRRT EINSTEIN and/or EINSTEIN. These include:

• ALBERT EINSTE:IN (U.S:,. Registration No .. 12]~li2).. for use in. connection with "educational services-namely, conducting a

. ",.F .J ·h ··1 0, mencarse . 00 ~.

• ALBE:RT EINSTE.IN COLLEGE OF MEDICINE (U.S.

R,egistrationNo. 28(14138), for use. in connection with "educational services, :nam.ely~ provid.h:~:g courses oimstru(?tiouand training in the field. of medicine-and biologioal.science aUhe. graduate and

scif{.l1tific -and .. animal trials;" and

. ,

• EINSTEIN (& Desigri) (U.~·~ App].icat.ion.·~~'f": 71"73$(69). f{lf .~"Se :W· eonneetien with. "clothing; ij"ron~1y~mfdl(ral mb .. pants. and fops'; LaneO W:riting pads :Ond binclu5 S()ld empty [and]' clothin'~ nam;dy:. t;;;sh~. ~nv¢atShirtsand c:aps~ [andJ ~uca.tiQnaJ *,ervi~~

runnei_:x;"prm'idllig. courses ofinsbllction and·'trmmng.l[l'ihe.nature '(!fOOllfSeS) lectures· and clinical elerkships in the field. of medieiae :andhiologica1.se,ienoo at the :graduate and professionaJ 'l~vels and distributing course r:na;terial in eennection -, therew;itb.; [and] m.ooical <research, n;ameJy; oo.nquoCti~g c1jnicm, scientific .and aru'maJ ttlSls.;"

. . '...' -

.(c~necdvdy~ the ALBERT EINS'~Em. AI,..BERTEINSTEIN

. ~ ..

,COLLEGE OF MEDlCIN"E and.' EINSTEIN' (&c. Desigti}mmks, 'ue

. . . ~. ~

C'. '. ~ ~ f,"1.,; . • .. ~L ·~E·'n7c""M~r'i ... r M' ,'. :-"-", ~l;

rererrec m .u:eIeJU' es rne : ..I.l'lO:>.J..C.u~ .. ar1!i..s: r-

;:n .' The' EINSTEIN Marks are 'noili-:fui1ctionaI aDd the public teoogniZ,e~s and.

understaads thatthe·EIN SmIN: Marb .distirlgWsli and Idenii£'y 'gtiGds,and srerVice~l proouced~ oold~ or spensored by ill.

2:2. FOE m:any.~. I'll has extensivdy ;;wd'co.nMoous.Ly· used ~d promoted

the EIN$TEIN ~b in ooim~9~·with. its "$ooiI~\ an4. services,

,2"3.. YU' h~ 'e%p'en¢ied~gre~'effOrt'~nd lar,ge:sOOl,softtl.()neyjn,'m~~·'it:s:,

EINS'rnINM.ark:swen-k:DJ~wn to ~e·pU.blic. YU hu,est@b[i.s\he~l a reputation (,gr exqttllbJiet;,. q1Jal~ty and. ·re.l~bjUty in. connection with.tl'fe: goCl.d~ ~d .~viges t~ provid'¢.S in 'oonj~11ction wi~

7\4. As a.resuIt o:fYU's ·e·ffortSand.,sub,8tru-:iiial·ex:p,@diluf~s:. and es'aresultof

YU'-s superior 'IepuJatioi;l: lM u:rumng ~me 'antler llat~tm's:,'m,oot pfoesngious. ,d,oc.tors, atid.1l1e(lical

5

_ .. _ .. --------------~~~~~~

researchers at its .Alber'l:Einstew to:lle~e QfMooiclIu;,W -enjoysvirhlaHy uuiversal '[eoo~it~on 'ants .E1N"..8TEIN Mmb ht oorm.ootion with its Services.

.. .

. -

25.. The EJN8TEm MMb :have beOOm:e weU':.kriowl"tmd are-:i.nstatly

recQ:gl:lj~able: ,to file ptibl'i<: as 'being ,asS9ciated withfhegD_ods .aQd ~erv.j~~< :p~Viil¢ 'By 0~ . affiU_ed ,,;'it1l YU..Conseque,iltly, ·YUs· EINSTEIN: :Mar~ 'art: ;famom;' ,amO:J:lg; oons_umerSf

C;\'lb!rtEi:u.stein.. nmve(rSi:ty~sU.nla;wful Adlvities

26. On'mforrnatiQn",~d belief. an il)div.ldual or entity clrumlngto be uMb:eri

:E.:mstein. Univej"sizyll -basoo~s~ewd thed0main,name, ~www+alb.e,rl'ems,teul1.mivetsitY>,or.gil in thename of 11J.il;~' web. hosting oo.mpany,Oneanoone ·Private Registrstien,

21. Deimdant·lL_a;s·liilked.n website to that aomain.name promouingthe

medical scllooi ·g~!Oes o-f an IIAlbettEins~em Utll.V.lefSi1y~:iit Whlth services ~akin ~th9se .provided py Ein$le:in.

2$.. The .A,lbM einstein Uni\1\efSUy we.bsit,~.gue~s 'in.~O. ·gre3it qetail. des<idbi~,

wltat stlldoots. (;00. ~p.e~. at .A]be;n; E.ins:te{n Un,h:,er~]ty medical 'SCp:ooI..Ws hom'ep3,ge cla.ims the. 'schQoI was fquEldedld. 1991l liq awariJW.over l~OOO I\IDs~ f-eatutesp·~rted quotes. front .:fornIer students CltSuch a' great education is rare to find! .ABU hasreally e.xce®ed~y -.e.xpectations .. 'Thank Y.Q:ur~ ,~ Anna Crofl~"M.D.·I'I) ,and even. has the- schoel's motltl-J. uEnoouragiDg .the. m:ooical ccrmm'lJ.Ilitr one doct:o:( ~t :a:time. !!

29. Tbe'bome·page·UnkgtO several Qther areas ofthe'website; in¢lu4iUg II nAlumru,i (di~iCUSSinl&t- th~ Alb.ertEin,f't:e:~n Univ~ty Sdlooi of 1'¥te-tJj.¢~fie Alumni )\s:s,oci~ion:1~);

• I1Finari~ia:1 AidO'j (F1".rhe·eofiltnitnl~n.t, tim,e- and: m~ey YO.ll invest at AI.~rt », mris·~n Un:iJiC,"'f.Sity durirrg..the :nfixt.rew y~rs Win sure.1y pay o"ffl")~

• i~ Student Lifell (describing: Jii¢<Q~'the ~~llan . .Islands. ana hqw II Albert Elnste111 o~ .smdents" a quality ,of Ii:OO· that' £e.w ~nJver:s,itje'sjn an), part orthe 'world 'Qan match. ,t and

6

• i! ApplyfRequ~MQre. Infonnatiffil ~ (provi,di~g.:OO orume, .1O;nDtQ<fiU (lut:illfytHl' would. Hk.¢ to CClnsidef appUc.1tiorrJ;o ABU (;if. you. M;Ve .' questions" mId· providing a mM.lfug·'~i;Mrjess jn TmiJ,pa~. Florida (or

!I Albert Einst:eJ,o' UniVerSity. it}.

30~ The websiteru.$,Q claims that U Alb.erlmfistein Untve:rsityt basbeen'

aoc.tedited by 'the prestigiQlUs: AO(,-redit~ti.on tOo'm.mtss~o:n Q~ CoUeges ofMiedicine tC~ ACCMII) •.

31. Upon inf<mnatiol1 ;i;md belief~' 'non~ of the abovtfi-listed claims from the

w~bsit~ me ,true .. 'The~ is lloruum:rii:3SSodiati:on.beca-.ooe t~ere are noalum:pi. Thet<:: Isno s.rudoot lire; beeaese thei:e are:]:lo·:stwimts. In :faot~·. there d.oes.llJob~lip])ea[ to be ~y mOO,i<;all ,sc.booi Whatooever. or evenal':s.at:f\nit~ canipus.'of: a medical scllool~ on Grand CaYmMl'opem:t~ng under the name 11 Albert .Emstein Unl:vetsity.."

32. Up'on 1I1'fonnation,and beliefr"the, omy,medic-al g,choolop,eratingon Gtand

Ga;ym,an, 1s -, &L Matthews University,

33" In41ca;tiy;e ofd.efend~antls ftmldulent scn.W\e,.a OOm,pariSQDAZif St.

'Mauhew'g UniversitY$. website (aYa;i1abh1:' .at. <WW.W .sttnattbews .. ecl.u»reveal~ th~t Al~ert BjnStC]ll.uWy~ity ]:tj's cbpied se\'efilts~ti(llJ.S· o:fSt MattheW~8 website 'Verbal,lm. By, waycif exrum,pte only;;

PooViditlg 'qDruftyeduooUou focUsed 0:11 U1e B'Q~~s$of.our stlident.sas wellas patieriJ:oo:nt~ed care is Hie l'Qundatioln.,o:f Albert 'Eh:I~~hl"The Mediea~ g,Ghool~ founded is'J, 19:91 ~~as the.Q.myhospita1~inte~ated

educaliOn: ~a'.l1d roOO,"eh program.In the C~bbea:~t Our s:tud¢llt~ 3,Chieve exceplional scholastte afidpoofessional. suecess, with recent U.S. 1jc~jng e;amiiHfti.on(la!!s -rates O:lI .pan ty with IL:SL schools and :fur above the :a:V'erage;'of 'OthN non- U ,.s,. schools,

Providing quality eclu,catioo fuoos.ed 'on ~he ~uOceS~ :~itour ~tud.~nts as wclI 38 p~ti!en,tcenterm careis the fi::nmdation .o,f Sl

. ~«ttJ.'l.evls:-pl]iyersity. The _Me4jcal S:cllool"

fo,unded in 1 ~¥97~ ·has· the -only hospital- .

integrated. edueaticnend research program ,in ,the Caribbean, Our- students achieVe ~ te:x.cepti{Ul.al schotas~c.:Jind.professiof];ru. success, wifhr't:~t U.S. _licenstng

t!';b:.~iruitioo ~s rates on, p\a:n,ty.with G.'S. Ji:chedis;and far above :the ;3}Vefil;$e o-~f other nonU .s, sc:hooJ$~

Providing q_:uaJ'ity e-duClIuoil foCused, on the success of our students. is the, foundation of St. , ·Matthews University.. Our faculty and staff are

'as committed 00' your dr~~ms as, you. are, .

Providing.quality education fu~used on 'the success of our students is the found.ation- of AI~eltJUn,S:tein University. Our faculty. and staff are m;'oonnnitted to yoUr dreams as.·yuu. me.

Since 1997 ~ more than ODe thousand students have' obtaine4 their MD and DVM degrees fr-om SMU., Our graduates haveeamed resid.enciesandlor: pennanent .licensure i:n, mere thlmAO stares in the D.,S and numerous other countries, OUf stedents achieve exceptional scbOilastic success, with. U.S. Ucens:i1lg eianllnaiion'pass rates comperable '0 U~S, sclJools and. far above the a:verage of other nQ.D-

U.S. s~ools. .

S;ince 1997;MO.re :than·one thousand studen,ts: have obtained. their ,l\;Ip degree" from AEtr~'Our gr~uates have earned residencies and/or pentla.nent ~~icensure lumorC. than 4(l s,tates in. the' U;S and numerous (lthef countries. Our students: achieve exceptional. sch.olastic

. success, with U.S. Iicensing examination pass rates, cm.np~l~" to u. S~ schools 8!ld far ahorve the. average of other non:..U.8. . .s~]s.

St, Matt:hevls Universi~y Schoolof Med~ci.De was'esfablisb~d in 1997 by Board. Certified U. S. pb.ysiclan:s .. Our geal was, to:~tab1iS:h a medical sChool based Qfl solid principles-and in~grity fbat would .p.rovid,e. a medieal education of the highest quality~

Albert Einstein, 'University Schno:l of Medicine, was e8ra~]isbed in 1997 bjt Board Certifi.ed

U. S, ph~iclans", Our geal was to estabHsh a medical school based 01'1. solid principleS and integrity that ·wo.utd provide a medica] eU;u,c'ation of'the highest quality.

The University is based in:'fue "Gayman Imands. Our location, provides II safe :island environment, a. eommhment to' quality health care fur its "citiU!:ls", high speed Internet, and residence 'housing for-our ·students. We,'ar:e encouraged by the Cayinan gcvernment and the hl;:ispital facilftieS "on. tmr island: and oontll1uc to receive their full' support today"

'The Uniyersityi5":'b;a~e4 in.'tl;ie Ca)mat1 Is.lands. "Qur location provides a safe island eevironment, a commitrnefit to··quaHty· h~a1th' care for its' citizens. higb speed Internet, and residmw".housing fOor,Qur students. "W'e ,are eneouraged 'by the Cayn,l~n govemmentand the ho,spltal f~ci1iti,es (In the island and oontinu¢ to receive their full. support. today.

St. Matthew!s received. accreditation by the Accre,di t ali on Commission, on Colleges of Medicine" (ACCM) in rWl'~'t 2002" The 'stand~ that wereusedto'accredii St. .Marthew~$ University are endorsed: by the United States Department ofEduca:tiori and aresimilar to the st~ o:fU.S., Medical Schools,

AlbertEi:llsb~ill received aceroo'llation by the Acer,editatipn, Commission on CoUeges 0 f Medicine (ACCM)' :in June; 200:2. The; standards that were used to' ,!I;cc-(;edit Albert EinStein -Uwvetiity are: endorsed 'by the" United. StatesDepartmentofBducation and are.simUar to l:he's:t~d'aro$ of U.S., M~ca:) S¢hqofs,·

heard.of "A.lbert Einstein University,"

~. . . '

J5~ Ids oot surprising, then, that ACCMb.as"a,[oo advised that theyhave never

heard of 1'i Albert' Einstein University, Fr, and oertrun:l;y have not accredited any sllch, mstitution.

8

36. On November 16~ 2009:,· RaYIrnlnclFi~geraldt Chai1'Dl.a(l.ofACCM. sent a

letter 'to Aibert Einstein University at the contact address listed an the· website (4352 Kennedy Blvd.~ Tampa, FL. 336(9) demandingtl:mi AI'ber:i:; Einstein Universityremove any referetliCe to aocreditation by ACCM..i.nduding anyreference Oil Alben' Binstein University's website and from all lit~hJ]Ie~ bl'Oicbures~p[o8:pcctuseSJ' ,md the like.

S1. Upaninformatl.cin.- and belief, the letter sent by. FedEx. wasreturned as

undeliverable because the address does not"exist Sincellien, ACCMsent tbeletter to the ~lmW address pro:vid'edby the domain name registrar ,ProX'y2.021701@1 and l-pnvate..registnltk:in .. enm, Uponmformanon and belief, Albert Eiti:sb:~:in- University has not tesponded to AOCMs letter. 'Further, desp,te ACCM's demands to remove the references, Albert Einste.in Universitys Vfebsit~ still retlects Albert Enrstcin Universitts Claim that it received accreditatiou from. AC"(jM.

3,$. AUrea Einstein University and the (apparently :ficti'tlous) goods and

services matteted~ S9ld. distributed., and' offered, tor sale by 'Ute defen4ant under the neme HAlbert Einstein Vnwersity~ " ·using·the domain. name <www;alb~emun.i,V'ersity.org> and in eoanecticn willi. Qih,e.r coafbsinglysimilarimitafioas of'the EINSTEIN Marks, are-in no way 'associated with'or ICQ~ectJedtOYU~ nor liceased, au.thorized~ sponsored, endorsed, or arpprovttl by YU 'in 3._ny.way.

39. YO . used. the 'EINSTEIN Marks Ii.liX.tensivelY and. cQf:l.tin.uousl:y for many.

years before Albert Einstein Uni versitybegan marketing, selling, distributing and offering for 'sale geodsand services in eonneceionwith coniuslD,glY'similar'il1ribrtio!fls offue EINSTElN

'40" ~Albert EiJ.i$tei!n UriiverSiry's" use of ~llfusijlgly $:imiIar hllita;H~n~ cf the

EINSTEIN Ma..rk~d~ likely te.deceive, COJ;l.Mf; and misleadprospective p1,!r~.e'r8.;and' p\u:cbase# in·~9 believin.g that th~ goods,an~ services m.Mketoo~ sold; disttibuted;.and offered fur sale by ''''Albert Einstein University'are-prodneed by,.3utboriie:d.by, or in some manner tl.s.sociat~ with yu~ which they are not The Ukellhocd. ofcdnfusiO'l1~ :m~stake,: and 'deception engendered by this wholesale andorazea misappropriarion of the EiNsTEiN Marks has oo:U~tro

itreparabl:e harm. to the. ~odwHi symb.olized by th~ EIN STErN Marks cap_d ·th.~nepl;l~tlo:n for quality and exoeUmce .that they' embed:y, . and th.at huini" ls&ng:Oing .

.:U . Purchasers). prospective J?ur:cimse:rsruidothern"'Yle'Wing" tb,e Albert Einstein

ulii verstty w,ebsitetg oonfu"S~y similar imitations (If the-B1NSTEIN Marks 1D oo~tiD:P with i\l:llert Einstein' Unive_rsi~'S"' good.$.and·.serrices ar.e 'likely to ·.mistakenl y attribute the go:ods and ~ervi.cpsto ill. T.he,ge. aLiivities'. are ~erefore .likely. teeause ~tmfu8~on. befere, duringt 'Mel a'frer the lim-c· of purolu13e 'o,w use .(oratt(1i1ptoo 'p:utchase o,r ·WJ~)o.( Albert, Einstein Uwvcrshy:s, g~s ·,i!Jnd services .. Thi'S. isp.~rticil1ady dam.aging wi,tn'respect Ito those per~cni.s.wl10·ma:y per~eive ~. defect or .hick Q:f.quaUty ·h.Albe~ £i:nst~in Unfyenity'ls re,ntanQ,ft,.·"Flrodt;lcis" or s~TVitesJ'sucb as the :fact that themoofc.al school d<Jes; not spp~·to .3.(;tmJJ;y eESL . .By ca.us.io,g weh a Iikelihocd of ronru&i~;; ,Intstak~ ami. deception!, .AIbetl Ej'nstein .u.rniversi~l has .1nfHct'fld 'in:~arable "bmn.. to YUs guodw.in ill the .. EINSTEIN Marks, and the reputa:th:1:1l for .quality· and excelleace tWr.t,they.· eJnbody~ andther lmf:ln is o~:oin.g;.

. .

4:l:,,AJbertEi.nst:eifl- Uni v~ity'-is. us;i~g ·,ooRfusjn~.ysimilru- .in~ita,tiong..ofthe

E~~TErn Mafb in C!J1IDectip;ll With goods .. -:md· setvI'~s tJ:1;atare:djn~ct1y l1!lattld, 'In YU.'g goods .and s~ces or yri~n -YO's ll:~ml ro.ne o( ex.pari$iQn.

43, On Itl:frirm;ation' and.heH~:f; Albert Btl1stf11;1 ~Univ~tYkllQwhlgly.wiUMfy

and intOOtio~lly adO'pred and l]~ed, CQ[tfilsi.ngty similar imUatmns of the EINST.E[N· Marks; ill trade OR the: gil1~dwiU s;ymbolized by the .E.1NSTEINMaiks afld',tJ:te :r;eputatio.ufor qaa11~yand excellence that ilier embody,;

44;. Upon in'IDml.ation &:Id. belief, Aibert .. Einsmin. U tti~.ty d;eUb.erateJy

eJnploys themarks ALBERT"EINS.TEINUNIVERSITY and ALBERT EI_NSTEIN '~d registered fhe domaln.name 'Ma]hert:einstei.nu.JJiV'em ;y;.o~gor :C0 misle3_d and confuse consUmers Jhat

. .

A1.bW: Einstein; Uni vemily's gtlQds and services ,are. pwvided~. spo.nsored~ ·.:!.ffiUa;t~ with" licensed

'or approved, byyU.AlbertEinstein U niv~ty thu~ \ilif.air1y'·benefits' from. the ,goodwiU ~d .exceUent1'q)lJ.tation of ~e EINSTEIN Marks ~3jbnBhed by Y'UfurolJghoqt the United· State$, ood i:o.le£natiij,Jially ~t great .e:ff'OrtMd ·¢xl'~nse ..

10,

45. Albert, Ei:n~n 'Uw·· . , ·t··,'1. ',"'" .:

. .., ..... t ' ',. venny ilJa8 not now. a:nd.has~evet'beeJlj a'u'tho.rized, by

YlJ'to use the marks ALBERT EINSTE-Iji.,.. UNIVERSITY or: ALBE~T E:INSTEIN~, the ,domain"

name iV.alberteinsteinuniver't·. " J! ,'. . . '. ," , '.. '. '.. .

. '., '.' .. , 8:1 y.Ol'g. t or an>" otb.er c;:olarahle(nnt:atlO,ru;: oCthe EINSTB.IN Marks in

connectioh with .any.giQOds or sei--Vices~nO'r'has yo oonsen:ted to 4IDY Buell use.

46,. Through Albert EUist-ein UniversItyTs- use of colorable' imitations of.the

EINSTEIN Marks, inchlding the,tn,ams ALBERT EiNSTEQIf UN,lVERStrY aad ALBERT

'-RINSTEf,N and ,tlle.domru.o name fT~bertei03tcii1Univ~l"$iitY.Qrg".; IDs goodwill ~s sUffered irreparable harm I wmcfl,. harm wHl continue as .long.M Albert, Einstein University's uses: continue.

·47. Given the nearly :iqell.tiool-natl1i'e oftbe ;itUeg~~BERT .EINSTEiN·

UNlVERSl1Y medical scioootservices to the.Serviees and related goods provided· under YU's EINS'fE1N· Maiks. the·above-describOOoondtict Is a clear attemptto ~-ade. off (tithe. extensive .gQod~n YU .has d,evetoped in. itS famous EINSTEIN ~ru:ks",

4$. Qn or abOut: ~COO1ber 1 ~ 200:9'~ 'Ct?Wlsel for YU sent a lettee to Alben

Einstein Univer.sit}1 ,at both Jhe known mail addres.~ antlctnaU address, puUing Albert lijU$tci:h University on notice of i~ Violanonofa :variety of federal, stati; and common law :in .connection witb its use ofth~ rn:aiks.AlBERT EINS"lEIN UNIVERSITY . and. ALB:ERT ElNSTE1N:and '-d:em,Mdin,g; .inter alia. that AJbertEioste:in University immedlal-ely cease and deSist from psing th.e marks ALB.ERT EINSTEIN UNIVERSITY emd ALBERT ElN"STEIN, d.isMle tm:. website

Ua1berteinsleinuniversity.o~f1 and. ~n.y o.ther damain names .confusingly siinilar'to the EINSTEIN Marks to ,yv. The,Dec~em,bet Lletter-demanded a responseby Dec,ember .11; 2009.

49. Albt~rt: Eiru:tein' University failed to' .provide any substanttve response 1Q

YU's letter and has oo~npJ.eooly ignored YUs demands :in that letter. Albert ·Einstein Universi~y . continues touse (he lrutrks ALBERT ElNS:TEINIJNlVF,RS1TY'-and ALBERt ElNSTEINami tllf: "alberteinsteinunivmity.,orgr! damain, name. Such use 1ni8 Cfnlood irreparable aarmto YU, and that harm 'is en-going,

·FIRST. CAUSE OF ACTION,

(Feders!l Trademark IDfrin~ment or the .EINSTEIN 'Marks ~ Lanha.m. ACE: § 32) SO.W realleges and. incarporates paragraphs 1 ,through 49,

51., YU O'~IlS· mUltiple· valid, and lenfor~l~ Federal Trsdemark .RegistratIons,

for the 'EiNSTEIN Marks C'{IIveri~ 11 variety ofgoods artq services".

~'2. Alb~rt Einstein UnivefsityslJse, ofthe~ m.lb:ks ALBEltT-EINSTE.IN·

·UNIVERS[TY' and. A.~E;RT EINSTEIN arid. the domain name "alberteinstelnuniversity.org" in oonnection. 'with. its goods, and services is· likely ti.)i cause 'conmsioh; deCeption and. mistake' by ~ng, the false Md' ·mislea.diug llilp:~ion that. Albert Einstein Universlty's. goods and services are produced ;or distributed by "YU ~ er are assoeiated or connected with ytj~ or have. the sponsorship, endorsement, or.appecval ofYu';, and as, such constitutes In~m__ngement of the EINSTEIN' Marks. in violation of Sectioo32 o'rthe Lanham. Act!, 15U;S,C •. § 1] 14.

53. Unless enjoinerl",.A.1bert Etns:te.tn Umve;rsit;y:w:iU ,continue tQ: cau~Le.a

l'ike~i'hooo, uf·ooufusion.and. d~ep:tion_of'm.emoors of the' public a:nd,:addi~ionany, inJury to, yuts .goodwill and ~putation. as embedied 'in the EINSTEIN Marks; forwhich YO' has. no adequate remedy-at law.

$4'. Albert' Ei1l$teiil Univeiliityts acti'ons demonstrate .an inten,tional, willful,

and.maljcimis intent to trade (:In the goodwill associated witb 'ytJ's federally registered EINSTEIN' Marks. to YUs. great and irreparable injury.

. .

.55... Albert Einstein University has caueed and is Likely to continue. causing

substantial injury to the public and to YU t and YU is' entitled to- mjl,mctivetelief and. to recover Alben. Einstein unt versit~)l,spmfits; .aetual damages, enhanced profits .and damages, costs, an£l reasonable attorneys' fees under 15 U.S~C.§lll ~4, 1116 and: 1117.

SECOr.-m CAUSE OF A.crION-

(ll' edera:1 Unflth' ,Com.petlti.QD· and False :Desi:platioD ar OrlgiD. as to tbe .EINSTEIN M,a.rru ,-

Lanham Ad § 43(a» .

56. YU realIeges and Incorporates by reference paragraphs lthrough 55.

12

:57. Th£OQgiI extenstveuse afthe ·EINSTEIN Marks for several years. YU has

d~velopcd ·ext~nsivegood.wiU rights rnsaid, marks, which good will is .protected by,int~,. Q'lia~ Section 4J{a}oft'.be Lanham Act'. 15 u.S.C. §.l125(a).

58. Albert Einstein University's use' o;foonfusingly simi~ar"imi:mthJ\rul'oftbe

EINSTEIN M3:rks~su~·c@s the :marb ALBERT ElNS T.E IN UN.lVERSITY and Al..BERT EINST'Ern'and the domain name 'rralberte~nsteiD!u:niv¢mjty"org~l, haseaused all,d/or is likely. to cause confi;&sion, deeeption~ and mistake by creating the false and mislead'ing ·impr(:ss.ion that Albert ,BitlStein UtMvet'3ity\~ goods .and senices· are produced 01' distributed by YU~ or are assoeiated.er connected with YD. or have the sponsorship. endorsement. or appro'val ,ofY{).

5,9. A1bert.:£,instei.n University has made falserepresentations, false

descriptions; and false designations of ,origin ofthe.ir goodsand·senrices in violation of15 u.s ,C. ·§.112:5(a); .W1d Alben EinsteinUriivemhts activities have caused and, unless enjoined by this· .eourt, win oo.n.tmue to' cause a likelihood of'ccnfusion and deceptinn ofmembers,afthe.pu:bHc, .and, ad,djtkm.aUy~ injury to Y.lPs. goodwill ~a.reput;ati.on as embodiedin the·EINSTE.lNMarks~' for wb:icll YU.h~ no q.deq~te remedy at law.

!SO: Albert Emstein. UniverSity':!) actions demonstrate an intentionWt willful,

andmaUci,ous iuiept totrade on ,t~ goodwill ,aI~;s:oc.'ra:ted.·with th~ .EINSTEIN Marks to the ~g:re.at Md. irreparable. inJury toYlL

61. Albert EiDslein University's coaduethas cml-"d, and is .likely to eentinue

causin&, 'Substantial inJUIY to the public and to YIJ, and YtJ'is entitled to ifijunctlveT,elief~~"to recover Albert Einstein Univer:sitY .. g p. ron. Is" actl.lW damages, enhanced p'tofits and damages,

. . . ' .

costs, and reasonable atto.mqs! fees pursuae; to 15 U.s.C. §§ I I 14i I I 16.;m-d 1117.

THIRD CAUSE CfF ACTION

(Violation. of.A.nticybenqgatting·C~ll'Umel:' PrcJ~ectlon Aef§,Lanbom Ad § 43(d»

62. YU ~Ueges ·and.incorpOrates .by reference p~agraphs 1 through ~1, +

13

6,3. With a bad faith intent to profit therefrom, Albert Binstein Univers.ityJms .

registered and used' th~ 'domain: nanw. "slberteinsteimimversity .. org" which is confusingly similar to \'Us djst:inl~t m:td famous EINSTEIN Mru'~s.

64. ~Ibert Eil1~tein UniveT8~ty has'~OOwD-its had faith -intention to pro.fit from

yur~ name .and goodwiH thrp'U.gh. its registration ofa domain name fhat, 00 infonnatien and belief, it knew 'was strikingl y aimilar to the ,EINSTEIN Marks.

65. Suel'!. eondnet is in violation of the Anticybersqmutl:ng ConSumer

'.rotecti(ln.Ac~. Section 43 (d) .ofthe: LaDham. Act, 1.5 U,S .. c. § 1125(d)~:an:d such violat.ions.are ongoihg.

66, Through such. conduct, Albert Einste'inUl1iversl:ty has caused .and

continues to cause i1'f~parable harm to YU~ ~ts EINSTEIN' Marks, and. its,··glZl.odwi,(l and reputati~n~ an.d bas th.by damaged YU.

FOU~TH CAUSE OF ACTION:

(COi.mmOD. .La:w Unfair CompetltloD .and Trademark Infringement)

61. YU·.re,al1ege.f and incorporates ·oy.reference paragraphs 1 dtroU.gb 66.

·GB. . For many years, YU has made e-x.clu ... si veuse of the BIN'STEIN' Marks on iii

wide variety of goo.cIs and services.

69. Albert Binstein Uwversitys; use of confusingly similar imitations ofthe

EINSTETN M.arks,$uch.a:s the marks ALBERT EINSTEINUNIVER$.ITY and.ALBERT EiNSTEIN' and the domain name "alberteinsteinuaiveraity.org", hascaased .l,lndis U~ly to cause 'oo:nfnsiQ:~, decep~i,~n~ and. mistake.by creating th~.£a]iSe· and. misle:admg impressi~n thal Albert Eim,tein University's goods 'and services ar.e. manufacturedor dis·tribut.ed by vu, orare associated-or ctinn~cted with YU, 91" have the sponsor~hip. endorsement, or' approval (If YU. TIle ErNSTEIN Maries are uni,qlie.; distinctive, and have acquired secondary meaning.

7o.~ Albert einstein UDiveisity~ by virtue of itsaets.as alleged above, has

WillfuUy, kriowingly> ma1jciously.a»d i:nte.fltiomd.]yen:&ag~ in acts 0funfair c:o,mpet[t~onufider the.common law of the State of New York.

14

71. Albert Einsteia Un,iver.sitYs~·,conduct·has causetL and.ifnol: enjoined) wiU

continue. to cause irrepar-able damage to YU in amarmef 'that 'cannot be. calculated or ,co:mpensat¢d :~n money d~. YU has 0.0 ,ad.eq.uateremedy at law.

1'2~ As a result of Albert Einstein Undvmity's 'acts, YU has be~ damaged in

an. amount not as }ret deeermined or asoertainabl,e At aminimum, hewever, yu 'is entitled to injunctiverf!lie~ to an. accou.ndng of Albert Ein.s.te.in Umv·~~~tys Pr.otitSi to damages, and to costs, In. light. Qfihe deliberate.andmalicioYs use (If confusingly similar imitations of the EINSTEIN Marks, .Il!:ld '~e need t~}" deter Atbe:tt ·Eiu$tein University ftom similar cOnduct' in' the future, YU addi.ti()D4l1y is: entitled to punitive damages.

WHERE,FORE, YLT pray~ forju:dgmerit against Albe,ct Einstein UniversitY as-follows:

A. Alben·Einstein University, ·byits·a.doptionand usage of the marks ALBERT

EIN.S1'EIN UNIVERSITY WId ALBERT EINSTEIN and the dcmaiuname ua1berteinsteli:nmive·rsity;;org"~ has-infringed YU's tradem.arkdghts w.lhe·EINSTEIN Marks"ln violatloJi of 15 U.s.C. § 1114.

B... Albet1>Binstein University, bY'i'~ adoption.and usage oftbe·m~ks ALBERT

. . ' .

EINSTElN'UNI'i:ERSITY ~d.ALaERT EINSTEIN and tbe domain name Ualbertein$te.~nunivetSl:ty;org·~~. has' inftin.ged YU':; common taw -ri,gbts to the' EINSTEIN Malks and has eommitted ecmmon. law .trild,e.m~k. infringement.

C.. Albert Eins.tein.· University. byn::ason of its a<lfuaJ knowledge of YlrS'·p.riO-f use

an4. a:PP:f>Opriat;ion. of the ElNSTEIN Marks, and. by suhsequmtly adQ.pliuS and. oorwtinuing louse the marks ALBERT EINSTErn UNIVERSITY and ALBERT EfNSTEtN and. the domain name 'ralb.eneinstei.nUfij~lers"ity.cfgi1 bas mte:n~ioml]Jy ,~t:nd·wi11ftdly committed unfalr competition urub;x

1.5 U.S.C. § 1125(a.).

D. Albert Eimitetu Un(versit.y~ byreason-of'its actual knowledge ofYUspriorwe

and. appropriation of the EINSTEIN Marks. violat~d YU's tIademark rl,ghts .kn,oiWfu.$:!.y and willfully.

E.. Albert Einstein.University, byr.egi,s.t~g. a demaia n.ame know~i tobe associated

IS

. i1l!~t"lij profit :fr~ the I\tMberteinst~,nuni vemity.org"'domain name, and .113,\'3 .~n[t~ed 'cybewimcy in '~io]ati"On ,(1'1' IS V.RC .. § L m2S(d)~

lNJ:uNcrl\'E RELIEF'

E. Albert Enlistei;n UDivers.lcy;, 'il?$ Q,ffi~~. agent.~~ '&erv~lts" emploY=:tAjttCmle~

'parents, subsidiaries~ affi~iates and related companies ami ;aU persons acting fur, wi:ili,. by~

: .". .

~ugh' Of' u:mader tbern, and eac.h of them, 'be temporarily enjoined::Wum, and preliminat:l1y a_nd lBer"fiatter petm~entl y e.nJojned.Jmd restrained from:

1. nsin~·in any marmer·the m;vb ALBERT ,"EINSTEIN UN~V~RSIT¥ iO];

ALB1;ItT EINS-TErn.the (J.rin1'ain name fj aIMrteinstein.u~n(v.emi.ty.org~ ~ or any. Cl,ther trade. :nan~e,." tr~~ark~ tr.ade·dress.~(jr si~rV:i(;einark lli.at l,s oonfusin"g1y' ~intilM tp YU's RfN'STEIN'Maiks~ in' "oonnootipn with thesale, -otJecirog (o-rsaJ~:~ d~strlbri;tion~ mw:kelin& advertising o.r 'promotion df

'goods erservises;

ii, using .3fi~trndemar:k,-.trad.e. dress; set·Vice mark, name, "logo~deS.rgn or

source d!esl$fl'ation of;any kind. OllI.codncmm.oot1on wlfh'AlbeJ.i E:inst,e:in·Uru.vetsJtY's sa;Ie~; ,offering. fGf's..me~. dismbutiolJi.~ ~:ke.ti:n,g~ ,acl.viert:i:sing or prom.otion of .goods or services .that is a copy;. reprtld:u.ctioo, oolorable i~tation, orsimulation6f~. err confusingly .similar to the, EIN_$TEIN Maiks:~,

m; ll$i:ng 'any t'r_ad.~Mk~ trm:l"e dress, s.er~ioo;maf:k~ name, logO"~.desigJ:l or

. s:o~de&i,gnati.6n of any· kind o~ ()1.(ill ootmootl(l_B with A:fhert EinSJein. U n..i~ity's .sme~ .. o'ff:erill,gJ~r sale,. dismh:uti"Onima:rketln.§~ advertising or promotion of.,gotlds Of services :fh~ is' li:ke~y ·to:: cau$e. oonfuSi(1n, .. m~sr;ake:} deceptien, IQr pribfic; rrlisn:n,d.el;1lt.andin,g. that sucb. goOd.S'Of seiW~"l.' are·prQd.uced by YU~ QI~: s~nSo:red ,:9.r, a,utho:rized.'by ll). (Jr' ~:in M~rway ¢oM.0cte;d errsl . ated to'YU; ~

IV.. !enga.ging in·miy.uitner acttvity oonstimting'an inm:ng~.ent of iStP g.

trooem.aik rights or.ofuerWlseun:faidy.oo:mpetlfi.$ with YU,in anyway;

O~ Albert E.i:rJStein Umversi.tf and. Oneandone Private llegistration he ordered to

16

immediately transfer to VV' ,th~ domain name 1'Ia]~~insteinunivers.ity.or&" and any either domain names, confus1ng~ysimilarto ·my·pf the EINSTEIN Marb~ and be further 'p!r:eliminilry and permanently enjoined from the registl,ation or use: of Wly dQm$n name¢Dnsisting of a eQl~[ahle imitation (If any of the EINSl'.EIN ~.

H Albert· Einstein University sh~] file with, the, Court aad serve. upon. YO's counsel

'within thirty (3"0) days after entry' ,of Judgment a report in writing'und,er oath setting forth in detail the manner and. form in whj.ch Albert :Einst~in UnIversity ~ompHed ~ith the fL"'quir~l1;lents OfthCi _junction and O~;er ..

DAMAGES,

I" Albert Einstein. Urn VCfflf1yhe required to 'aooount fur.and ]1i3r over to yu ,~]

profits realised by ~lbertEcjnstcirJ[ UUlvemtfby reagan of its unlawful acts alleged' berel(l~ in. an amount to be -proven antial.

I, 'YO.·be awarded an damages caused 'by-the acts fo1l'l1ingtne bashJ, of this,

,Cmnplai'nt

K. Based on Albert Einstein Umversityls, ~lowing andirttentiQnru us:e·of~onfu.slng1y·

similar imitations. of th . e EJNSTElN Marn~ the damages award' be trebled Mdthe award ef Albert Ein-stein, U:nh/ersi.tY..s. profits be enhanced as provided for by 15 U. S·.C. § 111 i(a)~

L. Albert Einstein'Uwversity be re.quired to. pay to YU an of its costs,

dj.sl;rlJrsem.en.ts~ andreasonable atto.meySr.fees that yu. has aad will incur :in :this .action pursuant to IS; U.S.,C. § l1l7(aJ.

M. Based 011 AJbert Einstein University's willful m1ld de.Jibe:rateinftill.gement o'fth.e'

ElNSTEIN Marbt and to detersuth rondtlct in the ftdlJI'~~ ,YU be awarded puni livre damages, OTlIER .RELIEF

N. FQf such other and further relief;as t~e COurt may' deem apPropriate to preventihe

imnhgement d.isparagement, or dilution of the EINS)"EIN Marks~ andto'p1W_ent further ~d/or addmonal acts {If unfair competiiionby Albeq E.i:nstcin Qniversit~ ..

o. For prejUd~ent-intet-est

17

P,. F.or ,ltom.~ys~ fees .and. costs.

Q.,. .For such Dtb« relief as theoollf1 doom.s proper ..

. WRY TRlALDEMAND

Datep:: N¢w· :Y"'?fk~ New YOlK ~cemhiCi: 17 •. 2009:

By. liLt 4.-£

.!fol' - .. ' .. S,cur

'.399~Aveoue:

. NewYork~ NY' 10022 212.705,700'{) john,W,n.@bingham, . .oom.

Joshua M . Dalten. (p.ro Hac vroooo, be 'filed) La:wterlOO ;T. 'Stafi):eY~ Jr. (Pro Hac Vieero be ~filed) On,eF ederal Street

Boston' M:A 0.2;'110:

~.. . , .' ..

. At!.;or,~,eYi~·fr;lt plaintiff Yes,hi~a Un.footsilJ1