Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Checking a Drumshell
Checking the integrity and condition of the drumshell.
Irrespective of the type of drum you are working with, it is always good practise to take the
opportunity whilst having the heads off a drum, to give it a health check. Basic checks will
look at bearing edges and shell condition as outlined below, however it is also a good idea
to look at any hardware mounted to the drum, plus to look at the condition of the wood in
the drum and the hoops.
For the purposes of this exercise, we will look at two of those factors which most affect the
tunability and sound of the drum, i.e. the bearing edges and the shell.
Bearing edge
Strip the old heads and hoops off the drum to reveal both
ends of the shell. The bearing edges are the sharpened lips at the top & bottom of the
shell over which the head is stretched. This edge normally has a 40-50 degree main angle
and is offset toward the outer side of the shell so there is a long diagonal cut towards the
centre of the drum and a similar but much shorter cut on the outside. Some drum makers
have cut a double 45 degree bearing edge with the peak in the centre of the shells width
they say this is for improved accuracy in tuning and purity of tone. The bearing edge is
critical to a drums sound as it is the only place on the drum that the head is in direct
contact with the shell It forms the boundary of the vibrating membrane and therefore
defines the sound of that drum to a significant degree.
It should go without saying therefore that any untreated flat
spots, cuts, nicks or other damage to the edge will become
apparent in the tuning process and may be evident through
overtones, harmonics, rings, buzzes or general difficulty in
obtaining a single pure tone.
The only exception to that rule is by design and is the resonant
underside of a snare drum. Snare drums have a snare bed cut
into the bearing edge, this is a shallow flattened area of the
bearing edge indented so that the cable or strip ties can hold the
snares tight against the head. Because the snares muffle the
head to an extent anyway, overtones are not such a
consideration, the snares resonant bearing edge is still
important but not critical. These beds are compensated for in
the tuning process and will be discussed in the section on snare
tuning. See Ronn Dunnetts excellent piece on drumdojo.com
regarding the snare bed.
The edge should be very definite and sometimes can be felt to be sharp,
sharpness will have an obvious fragility. To check for damage, look
closely at the edge. run your finger round the edge (try with your eyes
closed, it helps), is it smooth & even? If not, then you have a potential tuning problem.
In my experience, this is usually due to the cumulative effects of stress / exposure to heat /
moisture, or just a poor quality instrument. Snare drums particularly or any drum where
the shell depth is much narrower than the width are particularly prone to this. Torsion is a
significant problem to deal with. Re-cutting the top and bottom of the drum and associated
re-cutting of bearing edges is a drastic measure that should be
avoided unless you are absolutely convinced it is necessary. For
the most part torsion can and probably should be left alone.
With the twist across the whole drum you may notice shorter
resonance in comparison with the rest of your drums, or a strong
harmonic. This can be adapted to in part by the use of
flanged hoops which are much more forgiving of shell
inconsistencies than die-cast hoops. Sometimes the torsion has
no audible effect, either way, consider your options carefully
before embarking on an expensive and destructive course of
work. Sometimes there are things you just have to live with!
The order in which you tighten the lugs is important, similar to tightening the wheels of a
car, you must equalise the tension across the drum at all times, so you should work in small
increments, back & forward across the drum. Depending on the number of lugs on the
drum, you will normally have up to 6 pairs (12 lugs) to deal with; from a tuning perspective,
the more tuning points the better.
The main reason for locating the logo at 12.00 is that
if you always start pair 1 (see two keys method) or
lugs 1 & 2 (one key) for example with the tension rod
1 immediately to the right of the logo, that means
in the event that you lose track of the next move,
you can track back to where you are in the procedure
and continue the process. Eventually you will become familiar with the pattern for your
drums and you will instinctively move in that pattern.
Following the appropriate tensioning pattern for your
drum, hand tighten both opposite lugs of pair one
simultaneously until you feel a slight resistance or
bite, move to pair two and subsequent pairs and turn
them until you feel the same resistance. Return to
pair one again and tighten again to a point of greater
resistance, do this for the other tuning pairs in
sequence 3 or 4 times around the instrument.
Tap the centre of the drum, do you hear a tone? If
you do hear a tone then you are at the low end of
the tuning range for that drum, it might be a bit Boingy but it is a note and the lowest
pitched note that the drum will support (useful tuning for the Indian Subsonic kick effect).
Using your fingertip, a drum stick or the end of your key, tap the head about 1 in from the
rim at each lug point. You should have the same low, flat tone at each node. If there are
any variances, finger tighten the appropriate rods to achieve a single tone. You should also
notice that:
opposite lugs of a pair will deliver roughly the same tone as each other and you
should adjust each lug of a pair evenly to maintain even tension.
Place your drum key on each tension rod of pair one and rotate them through 180 degrees
(a half turn), move around the drum following the pattern you have been using. When you
have finished the last pair, check again for evenness of tone. This time you will notice a
much more resonant tone. If the drum is in good condition, the tension rods move freely
and you have been accurate in your tightening of the tension rods, you should have the
same note at all the points around the drum but with a different timbre in the centre of the
drum.
When one tuning point on the head is at a different pitch to those adjacent to it, you will
also find that the situation is pretty closely
mirrored at the opposite tension rod of the
pair. If one pair is at a lower or higher pitch
than all the others then you need to adjust
the tuning at those lugs to bring them into
line, at this point, very small turns at each
lug should easily be enough; remember to
move each lug of the pair by the same
amount. If more than one pair are out of
sync, i.e. the drum produces 3 or more
tones, I advise tuning them all to match
the pair that has the purest note of them
all. You will find that in doing his you raise
the overall pitch of the drum, or that other
adjustments become apparent. Keep going
until you have consistent tone, were not
concerned about pitch at this point.
When tuning, you should tighten lugs
instead of loosening, as loosening
relies on the head slipping fractionally
back over the bearing edge which is not
always reliable. If you do need to
loosen a tuning rod, loosen to below
the required note and tighten up to the
desired pitch.
With the head evenly tuned, start at pair 1 again and give each rod a further turn using
the key, after working your way around the drum again, check again for pitch in the centre
and at each of the lug points and adjust as necessary. Repeat this procedure twice more
with turns or until the head is tuned well above where you would normally tune that
size of drum.. The glue in the head will probably be heard cracking on the way, this is it
settling and is perfectly natural and expected.This will give you a highly pitched drum for
your normal application, the idea of this is to place tension through the head which is
greater than the normal playing tensions, this sets up the drum for seating.
Seating
Seating for a drummer is similar to a guitar player stretching new strings to ensure that
they dont de-tune drastically under playing conditions. It takes up slack across the drum
head but in particular it shapes the drum head to the bearing edge of the drum. There are
two common ways of seating the head, weight and heat. Weight is by far the most
common.
Place both hands (as if you were giving CPR heart massage) in the centre of the drum and
gently increase the weight on the head until it starts to take your full bodyweight, bounce
gently 2-3 times. (NB if you are a more substantial guy or gal, kneeling in front and leaning
forward will suffice). The glue will very noticeably be heard to crack at this point if it has
not done so already, this is normal. When demonstrating the seating procedure to students
or at a clinic I make sure that the drum is on a carpet or other slightly cushioned surface
and I stand on the drum head. Make sure you have a sound drumhead first!
The second method is to use a hair drier and heat the edges. Heat is Mylars worst enemy
and causes it to deform, however given the tension under which you have placed the head,
heat will allow the Mylar to conform to the shape of the edges and give you a definite point
of contact between the bearing edge and head. To do this simply direct the hairdryer at the
edge of the head and move around the drum, it should take 10-20 seconds to complete the
circuit of the drum. This process should take maximum 2 minutes, do not overdo it!!
The act of seating the head fulfils 2 critical functions.
It stretches the head so it doesnt need constant re-tuning; and
It shapes the head to the bearing edge, thereby ensuring accurate and much easier
macro tunability.
If you tap the head now you will find that the pitch will have lowered markedly from the
pre-stretch tuning. Tune the head once more at the current pitch and re-apply your
weight. This time it will have stretched less and should probably remain very close to being
in tune.
Having seated the head, de-tune each pair of lugs in sequence by intervals of a turn until
it starts to get towards the low tuning range again. When you get there, ensure that the
head is in tune again and you are ready to progress to tuning.
interacting (beating) and this should sound like wah-wah oscillations or moving variations
in the pitch.
Compare the pitch at this lug to the overall fundamental or to the pure-toned lugs and using
very small increments either loosen or tighten the lug.
As you loosen or tighten, tap the tuning point on the head and listen to how the beating
of the waveforms changes, if they get faster / closer together then you are going
the wrong way, if they slow down or flatten out then you are going the correct
way. Be sure to change each lug of the pair by equal amounts.You
may find that the waves get flatter and then start to become more active again, this is
because you have one or more further pairs out of tune, just ensure that each pair has the
flattest possible waveform and continue working around the drum. This takes practise and
the development of your ear, the more you do this, the better you will hear the beat
frequencies and the better you will be able to tune the drum.
Depending on how even you have the base tuning of the drum,
it may take you to work at several of the lugs to get a single pure wave, the best teacher is
experience and you will likely need to tweak the original pure-toned lugs as they will have
changed because of your working with the surrounding tensions.
You know that the drum is in tune when no matter where you hit the head you get
one single solid resonant note that sustains.
Ok so now you have tuned the batter head on your drum, next on the agenda is to repeat
the process on the resonant head.
Resonant Heads
Resonant heads
The resonant head is appropriately named according to its
function. Although not a head that is struck, it is critical to
how your drums sound and the tuning of the resonant
head affects pitch, duration & movement or pitch bend of the
sound.
Rest the drum with the existing head surface (in this case the
batter head you have just fitted) face down on a small cloth
or tissue when seating & tuning the resonant head, this stops
the heads freely resonating together when you are working
solely with one of them. Dont push the pre-existing head too
much into the drum with this damping either, it should still be
almost flat. Pushing the head into the drum will affect the
internal volume of the drum and therefore the overall pitch
and fundamental because of changes in volume and air
resonance.
The resonant head is fitted in exactly the same manner as the batter head and all the steps
outlined above in seating should be followed. The real decisions come when you have to
decide upon the relationship between the two heads which will defines the movement and
duration of your drums sound and decay.
Relative head tensions
Both heads can be tuned to identical notes, this means that
the vibrations moving through the column of air inside the
cylinder are reflected back off the resonant head at the same
frequency as they are generated at the batter head.
Tuning both heads the same gives you the maximum
sustain and resonance, however for many drummers
this may be considered too resonant without some
form of treatment, it is however perfect for playing live
and unamplified as your drums will sing and cut
through the music. The other instruments provide all
the muffling you need.
A second option is to tune the resonant head to a higher pitch
than the batter, this will give a slight pitch bend as the sound
decays. This bend is caused by the vibrations being reflected
off the resonant head at an accelerated rate.
However it is not particularly discernible especially with toms
12 & smaller. One of the features of tuning away from the
same pitch as the batter head is a decrease in resonance.
The higher or lower you take the bottom head the less
resonant the overall sound becomes. A third option is to tune
the resonant head lower than the batter head. This also
gives a pitch bend. This bend is more noticeable and is very
clear on larger toms. Again, the pitching down of the
resonant head serves to reduce the amount of resonance or
duration of the tone.
I use the same single ply heads (Remo clear ambassadors) as
both batter & resonant heads, however putting a double ply
head such as a pinstripe or one of the hydraulic heads on the
batter side will give a lesser amount of initial resonance
thereby damping the sound of the drum somewhat. A resonant head should always be a
single ply unless you want very dull sounding drums.
Really, the best way to find out what works best for you
tuning wise and finding the optimum relationship between the
batter & resonant sides for your applications is by
experimentation. Try different situations with & without
musicians or with different musicians, see how each tuning
fits your playing styles. One kit can have a hundred voices if
you have a drum key and a stock of heads.
The resonant head of a snare drum is much thinner than a batter side head do not mix them up! This
thin-ness is the key to a good snare sound. Because of the [usually] higher pitched nature of the drum
and also with the addition of the snare cables there is a degree of choking inherent in a snare. Choking
occurs where conditions where the drum is tuned so tightly that it resonates inefficiently, this is
acceptable and desirable in a resonant head of a snare drum.
If a snare resonant head were to be allowed to resonate freely, the snare wires would be constantly
buzzing. I recommend that you tighten the snare side head high, or as one of the regulars on the RMMP
drumming newsgroup said until its screaming for its lawyer.
To compensate for the dip in the bearing edge on the snare side to accommodate the snare bed, slacken
off each of the tension rods on either side of the snare wires a further turn, this helps the snares sit
lower against the drum skin and will help alleviate buzz. I have heard arguments to loosen also so the
best advice is to adjust it until you get a sound that suits you.
Basically thats it for the tonal tuning of the snare drum, however there is the small matter of adjusting
those wires to (A) make them sound great and (B) minimise their rattling caused by other drums or
instruments
Adjusting snares
Put the snare throwoff in the off position and turn the strainer adjustment to about 75% loosened. Fix the
snare wires to the throwoff & butt using cables or strips as supplied with the drum. Ensure that the snares
hang cleanly away from the resonant head.
Engage the throwoff and adjust the tension so that the snares sound mushy. Keep tapping the centre of
the drum and adjust the strainer by tiny increments until you hear it snapping cleanly against the head.
Stop! This should still be just above mushy. The largest killer of snare drum sounds is over
tightening the snare strainer to try and offset unwanted vibrations.
Lets take a second to think about this. We have an instrument that works [in part] using the principles of
resonance. We then go and put a really thin, ultra-sensitive drum head on this particular drum, ostensibly
to help it become more sensitive, we then add some curly wires designed to vibrate against the ultrasensitive head and then we complain when they start to do exactly what they are intended to do LOL
Sympathetic resonance
The final consideration is that of sympathetic resonance. This occurs when the fundamental tuned tone
of one drum shares pitch with the fundamental or harmonic of another drum, another instrument or other
sound.
This is not normally a difficulty with rack toms unless you are in the studio, however with your snare drum
its a different beast.
Over-tightening the snare wires will help to reduce resonances sympathetic to other sources but after a
point it starts to make the drum lifeless and may give difficulty for snare rolls. On the other hand, undertightening the snares will give you a drum with annoying buzzes from itself and from the drums and
instruments around it -clearly the whole question that you should be considering is one of balance.
The BAD news is that this resonance is impossible to get rid of totally so dont go worrying about trying to
eliminate it totally or you will be in for a whole lot of headache for no potential gain.
The GOOD news is that it is normally masked at playing volume by the sounds of the other drums in your
set and the sound of the other musicians who surround you. Think about it, apart from practise, how often
do you really proparly hear your drums on their own?
If you do find that a particular drum in your set is triggering the snare buzz, then that issomething that you
can do tweak, however you should try to eliminate it by changing the pitch of the snare and not the toms.
Toms generally are tuned to relative pitches with matched sustains, you dont want to adjust each tom.
Re-adjusting the tension on the snare wires also works within the parameters discussed above, but if you
have set the snare up independently, this is drastic and you should re-tune the pitch of the snare batter
head away from the offending frequency or harmonic that is causing the problem.
Often 1/8 turn at each lug is sufficient, if you do tighten the snare side head, you will have to tighten the
snare strainer to achieve the same degree of crispness as before.
Experiment!
Kick Drum
The kick drum is the drum that about 95% of drummers muffle. With the advent of Powerstroke 3
(PS3) or equivalent heads onto the market, you need no longer stick an assortment of
pillows/clothing/blankets into the drum. The PS3 has an integral O ring that removes a lot of the sustain
yet leaves the note, which is exactly what you want in a kick drum sound. The muffling on my own kick
drum consists of a PS3 on the kick drum batter side, a PS3 on the front and a small Protection
Racket pillow that lightly touches both heads, again this is not a recipe written in stone, a producer or
anyone else who is in a position to demand, may insist that you give him a particular sound, if this is the
case, do what you are told but dont kill the drum totally!
You need to consider also what happens when you strike the head with the beater, most commonly a
heel-up player will leave the beater in contact with the head (generally termed burying the beater), this
is a very effective muffler and is controlled automatically by the player.
With an un-muffled kick drum you can also play it like a tom letting the beater rebound and with the PS3
you have a warm sound with a short sustain. Leaving the kick drum unmuffled gives you many new
timbres of sound to experiment with but its not everyones cup of tea.
Snare
Again no muffling is the recommendation.
If you have a ringy snare (snares are particularly susceptible to torsion because of their shallow depth),
you might want to find out which of the lugs are causing the ring by lightly placing your finger at each
tuning point on the head until you find out which stops the ring. Placing a blob of moongel or blu-tack
there should remove the ring.
To treat your drum to bring out a more dry sound, a famous tool is to use your wallet. A less subtle way is
to apply an O ring, however this will practically kill all resonance in the drum.