You are on page 1of 10

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

ScienceDirect
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

       !  "#  

$%& & '( )*$  ( + 


, )- )
+ %  .

     
        


$ # /#   00 #) ( + , )+,)# (( 1)
 1  ) )! (- ) 2  2)# ((  (   3$4  ## #2 
     ) #+,   20 2       12 (  (  
 0 (2 2 (3' (- )  #   &#(#0# ( 
 #) ) (0  - ) 2  20#00  (#0 (#
##  (+, - )2   3$0 01    (( # 05
 # 6' )& # )  00# - )2   3

7$8#3#1 1)" ,3
2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
   0
# 0 1 )$8    &"#   $  ()
$8 "$& 6 ) 
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi,
' &$#6)3
Turkey.
! " # $   %&  %' (   %' ( )" %  ( ' ( 


   
$  ( ()# ((   2   )+, 12  (  
 #2 (2 3   1 (121   2 2 (2# 0 2  )3  
  12  ( 1)1 ( 1  ) 02 2 ( 
# ##   
  # #3$&4  ## #29 #20 +, 
   1 1   1 :  0  ; # 1 )#;( !
1 ;1 # 2 )0 )  #  (#0&  # (2  2 ; 
/# 0    2<033
 #   0 0 2)# ((  1#= ( 2   1#
- )   )# (( 3' (- )  #     )2  )&(  

.0  ( #
*+(  #2 3(  >16#3 

1877-0428 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, Turkey.
doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.12.325

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

2823

#) )! (0  0 #  2  20#00  (#0 (# 1# 
+,& 1#& ) 20 6  /#&0 #  )   ( ? (
- ) 23+,6  000# )(  = 2 (   
#   (:  01 0 2  < #   2=%  &@&03@3
$&+, 1 ( #  22 2 ( 2#  # )  (1   
1)  %  &@3
$ (0 #)  #  0 1  #  )
  # (0)  00   &(  2) - )2    
=# )1   3 &0#00 0 )   12  
#3$   )  0# 2 - )   )# (( ? 0  
  3   9A 1   $ ( 9B9  2 #
0  #)  0 0 0 0   2   )  # 12
 2 3
 2 3, 
$#)=0   (/# * 2( 2   )6   0 
#  02    ( - ) 2( C


 )02= 2  ( /# ()   1)#   (#  ) ( (
1))( 3+,(# ) /#)   #2
020  &# 2  00# # #3+, 1  ) 202)
  26 3+, 1  &: 0 (() 0 #  )!
   2 (2 & # & 2  & 00#  2 =   (
2 ( 2 #<D E  &@&03F3+&+, # ( 
: # # #  =0  ) #&1 && 2 ( 2 
 <D E  &@&03F3
D    @#2 0 1(#=0  +,3+ )#  
1 ) )!1#0 2 &0 1( =0 0 3 &
+, #   ) )!=01(&1#  )1( 
#12(#  3$  # 1) 22  )1  0- ) 2
=0 1 # - )  &2 )   :21 (   
#02 )& 0 0  )& 2&201 & 00<D E  &
@&03B3

D    A  +,   ) #    2  # )
#2 &   2 0#  &1#  06   : 0 (! 
  2 6 # 22  20 0 0    <03@3$#
+, 12 (   #   0  2 =3$
20   26  1   (  0 6  (2
# #  1 (0 0 2 &# 1  (2 0 2  ( 
  2 )#   2 (  # 23$#   (  # 
6  (#(2  0   1 # =0   /#)  # 
 2   22#   3  12  (  02  0  &  (
2 # 5#&=0 &  #   1)3


2824

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831


  (   &  

%#=  6#((: 2  20  2 )(; 20# 
 )0 )  G  (2  ? 0## #<03F3$& 2 1
   (   &0 )1 #: 2# ( ( 20 )  
 # 6  (1#   # 6  (2 0 # 0 <%  &
@&03FA3$- )0   2 5)2     #2&  (- )
0    2 &6 2 1)0  34    
0   6     ) ) )!2 (01)- )3

+20  )&- ) :( 1 # #  #   )#(( 02)  #
0#)2 #<%#=E 6&&0393- ) 02 ) # 
 # ( # # # ( 1;%#=  6#(( - )   )
#0   1 3%#=  6    :- ) 2 
 4 #      2  #2)# (00  6 1# # 
#  #2 (  202  (20  2  

 ( <03993H#2&- ) 2 0# )2 00  2  (
1 # = ) # 3$/##((  ) )!
:0 (2   (- )? 2  26(    20 # 0  #&
& #150   )# (00 0   ( )  01 )<
%#=E 6&&033$ ) 1 20 # 2   )&
     2: & (  & #2 <%#=E 6&
&033

$ 02 +,0 0   /# 2 (  (0  
- ) 23  2 )    /# &1#/#   6 
   ) 6 1#   2 ) =03$    (
:    )  1)- )&1# )    #2& 02#0 
2 (6 (2 00  2  ; 0- )< # E63+, 
  /# 00#0    #   0   ( 2  
01)- )3$20 +,    - )(
1 ;   0 /#  (3  2 ) 1    (  1 
 :00&<&+,  1   12  (  
 #  2  0  &#0 (  0 # 5#&0 
0  &  2 - ) 23

' (  
" 

$  2  1 #) &  : ) #   0) 
   2 ?220  & 2 ( 2 #   
2    <0 #  2   6
0)E% # !&&03@3$2  
1 #)  !    2  #  0  0) (  3$
00  0) )   # 020/# &#2 6 (22
  1   6 1 00#   # 3 6
0) % # !& (#
2  1 #)     (  (  00 0   0
15& #& #1 2 3 & ) 0 2 #   
01 #)12 (1 ##   20 (&  00 6
0)E
% # !&3  (  0  =2  1 #)  :  0   )2&

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

2825

2 6(  0#(      20   
2 ?#< 6
0)E% # !&&03@3' /# 1 )& 6
0) % # !
 2(#01 22 &=# &2 
 #00
 
2 ;  # &(#02 22  1 #) 2 5)0
   ? ) 3 6
0) % # !  #2#) )# (2  
 1 :1 ## &<:0)&<: <20  2 2    ? ) 3+
20  )& #  #2 &  # (  ?2 &  )2 ((
20 2  1 #)1)  )  (1 ##    2   &1# 2   (
1 #)#  (   ( 3 !! &# &I  &J( & + !##00
2  1 #)    ?2 1)#(( (:0  ##0    &
1#6  (  #( )<03FBB3$20    (   #
1)+)20 ! &:     )0/#  ); K 
   1 ##  6 & 0
 #( ) 6<03B3 6
0) 
% # !#((0   - ) 2  2    (00#  ) 1)
 ( (0#2     0: ( #)& )&  0  1# 0) 
  <03@3  - )2 )1 20 (0# 00  # 2 
  1)01 ) 0 ( ( 1 #&   2 
  2  # #3

2 
 

 +,20   #2 (  #6  (  3- )0#
0 (#(  &)# (  2 )  !  20  
2#1   3+, 20    )  (&/# & /#2 (#  
2 3# - ) 2# 
 0  ( 2 62 )& 2  1#
#   3- )   0  12 2 )# (  &1)
20 ! (20 +,3  (- )?   # #&20 
#    #    )# (  3

8 (&K - )0   ? (2  ( 2  2 #3$
K - )0     00=2  )L3B1  '    # &20  (
0- )  0 ( 38 (    (1 699A&- ) #21)2  
00 3H= 20 * 00=2  )2  00   - ) 20) &9A2  00   
- )
0#   6&2  00   - )0#2# 6&A
2  00  - )$20 60) & 2  00 0) 2 6 0#   - )
%#=&99A3K #  0 6   2# 0  2 299?&
   )2 (    0#   1#- )0  3K# 
 2# 1 &  - )0   0 ( ) #1) 2 3$
 2)- )0       ?2  062#=0 
(   ( (+, 6 ) 1#- ) 23

$      1#   M# #   )3$
#)#  (      (   0  &  
0 0  0 6 ( 1 3H#2&+, (  () 1 (20 2 
  2  )( 4  ## #23+)#) 1)  )+,
#   #    3  M## ( (  2#  
1   - )0  &2  6   - ) 1 (1  
2    3+)  1#   0  &  & 
)# (( &# (   - )1   2 ( ( 3

2826

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831



 - )?1 ) #)21 2   (  1 6  # )&A3
$1 )      )  0 10 ) :(< : 3< 
   #2 &- )  2) 2  )#(0 )   
2   3$2) #2    0# 0 3& - )&
0    (  (& &0 )  03$ #)21 2#00
2)1)   (1 60   (  0 )3$0# 
   0 )  0  &#  &2 & & (  0    
 #1 6; &0       #&  0 ) 
0  & &0)&  & # )12#0 2 3$2)1 0# 
0   20 !#(0)  00  3'# &+  & # N 
1 2  &  #0  #  & #&1 )&  000 
2 O  !&@
'# &6 21   $ ( 9B9) 
1#
0# 
2  )0 1)2 (- ) 3'# & #2 & 
0#& 0 )  11 6 0#0 /# :!   )<%#=E 6&
&033 20=0#    #2  23 21   
#2 &
2 
6 ###2 ! 20 !#(  3 1)?0) 0 
20 !2    3$0) 0 2 0 (2
  & 002 )   63-J! 
1'#   :(/#0 )&=0 &# &  2  (&#( )
2 <033'#     2)1 6  #0)   1 (  3
'# ?# =01)  3 2 0#  # (  )   3
'# ?2 #  6 (2  )1 1)) (D ($ ?# 3 
#(2 0#   #(&8 3'#  6   (8 ?1 
#2 & 8 = ( )#2  3'# ?2 0#   ( 
0 )   &  (#      3$#('# &- )
 # 0 ) 2 ( (2 03'#  1(   0# 2   - )
 2;#0 &  (3$0 0# 2 #  
 &#(( ( 0 6  P1 #) 2## )= # 2 -J &3
+  &2  5  , & 2 6     0#1)- )
 # )&A3     #(( 2)&# ( ) 00  3   & &
0 
( 6 2 ) )3       0  3   
!&1 6& 0#0 1&#1) 03+      
 &)21 ! 6& 2 (3 6 #( 1) 1 ) 0

3  0 (   21 (#2 ;  ( (0) 2
2 #  0  # )&A3) (&+  0 ) (=20&
 )#    3
H2 00  )    (  ( - ) 2  23$    
(# 1 )20# 2     2;0   0  &
) 0# ) 3- ) 6 00# 2   )# (( 13-# 
#  2 1 0# 2   60  2)#(#03 2      (
)# (( 00# 2  0      #( )  
00 3

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

2827


 
$#2)  0 0 )# ((  0   2 6
 &  01 #(/#   3##( 1  (@ 
#(#0#    3" 0 0   0# )2 0 00
   )3$ 2#0 0 0 6 0  #(#03$0 0 
 # (0  0   &#(06 (/# &  # ( 6
 /# &  3$#(#0 F2 # 
82
##/# (#    0 # 0 0 3$
 #(#0  #2  )- ) 2  23$0 0  6
0   2    #   0 0 ( 0   #*8
#   2 0& 0#0/#  6    #   ( 
   0(3$ 0#0 0  0 0   ) #(
)2 )    #(##(#03

6 ', ,5 

$#(#0  (  # - ) 0 )0 0 ?  
1 0  - ) 23$#(#0   2(   1 #   (
 ?0  - )1)=0  (0#  #2& #  &  )
0 0   3 2= 20 /#   #*K))# 6- )C- )
#   )   2  )C$/# 2  20#2 - )
  /# # *- )    #2 - )  CK) 0 # 
  )# #C$#(#0   #    #   20
/# 2     
#0#(#03$#(#0   =0 
2##   (0 0 ?   2 - )  3Q#   6
 2(0 #   (0 0 ? ( (2  ) )! (2 #( 
 /# 00 3Q#  #   6 (  #*K - )2C)#
#  (  ( 1#0  # )# (C$0 0  # 2
)0   #(#0& 2    0 
 2   )3

6', ,5 "

$ #(#0   ( 02- ) 2& 1) 6 (0 0 
/#  0   # 2   3$ 2 0    2
 2   9A$ 0  #0    ?0 1#  1 
20 3  ? 2   5#  02  20  
1         (1 3   6 
 5 0&#  )1 2     ? 1 2 #01  ( (3
$000    ?#   20  )0  #  
 (  1 3$02 0   &   #  (#0
 2) (& 0  #  )1 3

$  2 0 221   $ ( 9B9 2  20 0  '# &
  3$ 0 # (:' #  # < '# =0   
2  08 &0  )  ( (3$ 1( '# =0   (
0  # 00   0   0 &2    00 # 
'# ?  3'# =0  8   8 1(  &8 2#

2828

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

(#0'# 3$ ) )8 (1 6   # 6
  1   36  00 & '# 2 6       
8  )&  12'# ?2  3$ 0 8 1 (( 3

    
78    (  ,    4 ,   9 ( , ,( 5 5 4:0 ) )& (@
$(   0  #  #  (  1  - ) 2 
 2&0 )( 2   34 2  2 2)  #
= (  # 0# 2     # )    - )3& 
- )&0    (  (   6 (#  )# (( ?( 0 () 
 3$2  1 #) 0 #    - )2 0  & # (
    #  2 3
-# (#(#0&0 0  #2#   022   3
& 2      1 )#   '# 21   $ ( 
9B98    #&'# ?0) 0 2 0 (2
  &  (1)  (   2 #(# 23  (  
 ) )  1  (  #  8 &   #  1#:1 0 < 
1   $ ( 9B93   (  ) )= # 28    #
  &'#   63$= 20     6'#  2  (   
 2382  '# &  :2 1 0  R$, +2 3S<'0 
2  '# &  2 (# 20 2 0 0    :2  
 3<$0 0 0  )'#  : 2 0 <: 0 <  # (
  ? 2#(##  #(#03$0 0 ( 20   
 6 ('#   )0  2&2  )'# ?0 6  )8 ?
3 #0 0 0   1 # (0    6 ('# 
1 #  )  23
  )  )2'#          6 - ) 2 :
 0   K&1 #(  K0  00 3<I  5   
 :" Q# < ) (0  K&   (# :  #( )3<
8 #( #(#00 0      10# & 
 2 (0  (   2  #( )&  2    
 6 (23( !0 0 06#0 #   0   
   1 ( 63
$ #(#0 2#0 #  1#'# 0 )&   0
 022   9A$ #(#0  # ( 2 0
  0#   2  6 (1 #2 ( 
2 3 !   )2#0  (    #(#0 
1#0 ) /# 00 +,3
$ 00 0     2   9A3$ 0  # 
  ?00  (  ? ) (# #    1 3
 ) )&D  & ) I  20 )0 :2 <0  (  ?&
1# ( 2  3# # (0 0 #  2
   1#02   :2 3<#((0 0 ) 

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

2829

   02 (   38  #2  )/#60  
(  0   0?  :1# 3<$0 0  1 ( !0
21 1 0 0220   &1)0    (  2
 1# )&  1 (23$  # 00  ( 1 #   )# (
 0&0 0 1 021  #  )&2  
  1# ) ()# (  3 (#  #0 0 0 ) (  6 ( )
1 2 6   1  2 0 =0  2  
0 0  1 2 6    1)  23)# (1 #1# &
     ##  (00 ?     0 1 #   3$
0 0   ) ( )#   5)1  2 )   &  # 
#   ()  )  2 )3
H#2& 6)20  +, # ( (  12 2 &
#001)  (    (  1(  6 /# 3  ( )&# (
 #(#0&0 0 1(  ) '# ?     # 1(  6 (
/#     (#0# 3H= 20 & # ('# ?0  68 ?&
 ) )    (/# &  (: ? )(& R'# S 6  )R8 ?S 
(&R0     8 S (1 6C<D   5& 
# /#&:  '# &(1 6C< ) 0?
/# 1)#(( (   68 # (1 6&1 #:'# ?2  
2( (1 63<$& (# 1 0 0 2    6 (1)
 ( ( (   (#  (0  #2  0 )  23$0 0 
 = 0 #   ('# ?1 # #     #2
 #  00 8 ?3
$0 0 ?1   0    ( 2 01#  ( %  ?@
#   ( +,   #  22 2 (  2 2#  # )  (
1)  3$ )0 0  )#  #  00)1  2 2 
=0     9A 0&0 0 (   #   ( 021 
 #   (2 2 (1) ( (& 6)20   2 6#0
  +,D E  &@3D    @ #((+, # (
# !0  =0 1 2   &2 (0 0  1 
( 51 ( (  021):   3<4 &1  = (
 # 0# 2    - ) 2& (# 2)#(#0  #((  #(
)# ((   1  )    12 1 (#  & 1 )# (
( ?( 0 2 0   )/#  ( 3 1 0 0 2  
    6#   ( 20 !- )?#2 01 ( 31 
0 0  1 12    (0 2#  # )12 :#( )<
 (#0 0    20 #   (- )?##  2 ? 
#0   (  (3

  
8 0 #  #   #)    0  0 2      0   )# (
( 1 ( #   (  0  - )2   #(
#+,38 1  ) ( 2 - ) 2&  )# ((  #)
 1   1    1)  ( /#       0  23 - )    2#
0      22  0    # #      #  2 6 - )  )
20  0  2 )   ? ;    # &   20        1    ) 

2830

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

- )    0     # #3 +,   20      1 ( 20 2    
4  ## #2 0  2   )#   1#  2 
121 2  )3+,20 2   4  &1# 20  +,
#   )   3$1 +,     1 12 
2 &#1) (2 1 (2   2   00 3
$ 2 )#(( ##   03$ 2  +, 
- ) 0     2 )( 0=0 2  
2 3 H#2&   20    #)   ) 2  2( #&   (  2
  20  #  1 1   0#   #  2   0   3 4 &   ( )
22    0   P (#   ( !  20   +,&  #       ?
2  2   2   1)#  20 )1) 6 (/# 3
!
" #$ 
#  6= 2)( #2) -3  # 2 ! 6' )
#   #00&  #  & 0  3+# 00 T
% 
82 & 3E+#6&I3#&E 2 &J3E+#6&I39B931   $ ( R+

0#S3' 8*K - )#

 6
0)&,3&E% # !&,33$0   0 2  1 #) 

  ? ) 3  ;   A&@
@F3

 !! &-3&# &,3&I  & 3&J( & 3&E+ !&-33- 2 - )  0 ) 

021 #)
( )0C<,= 55   ) 6&FB@
@93

- )&K3#&E%2 &3&I 6 &K3&E,#6& 3-39A3   R+

0#S3' 8*K - )#

-J! &J3833$0  + (D (2*)   ( &#  - )

 3>( 9  ,  ((,  ?&
A93

%  &I3@3  /# 0  #* 2   )00# # #=3,   

@&F
3

%#=& 399A38 2  (M#*-     U# #3   2
"6&03
AA

%#=& 383&E 6&%331 $,   2 #&    *=8  ' D (2*

J2 E,  #1 & 3


# )&-3,3A3  (K*   # - ) )
 0 3<, =A 

*, ?6&
3

D &-3&E  &I3@3 2   )&2 )&  # #  3 -3

+ E 3J3  1("3&$   #   03
3M6*, (#1  (3

Michelle Garofalo / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 2822 2831

2831

D  &I3,3&E+,  &33J 6 ( ) /#   3 M3O#E"3$3



$#1 "3&* 5   #B, 
55     ,= , B@
@3

+ ) *J2 E,  #1 & 3

+)&-3%33  0) ()@"33 *+% 
 

4  + )"#  393$4  ## #2( 
B*, (# (3J2*

0*PP3#3(3 3 P (P## #2P 2  )P (# (B#130

# &3H3&6&+3&E+ "#  H#   33$  $, (53 20 &+8*

+ "#  H#   3

O  !&,3%3@3-2 61 6C$ # - )?' ((  993 1*A* ?&
AA
FA3