Farabee, Allen
W
Esq P.O Box 139 Bualo
NY
4213 Name: PERSAUD MTILAL
of
Executve Oce r Immigration Review
oard �mmigrton ppeas O c of h Crk
5 /07 Leesburg Pike, Sue 2000 Fll Cuc Vn 0530
HS/ ICE Office of Chief Counsel -BUF 130 Delawae Avenu, Room 203 Buffalo
NY
1202 A 03909797 Date of this notic: 2/6/ 205
closed is a copy of the Board's deisio and order in the above-rerenced ase. cose
Mb: P A
Sceely, Dona Ca Cef lerk
k
For our Index of Unpublished BIA Decisions Visit www.irac.net/unpublished/index
Cite as: Motilall Persaud, A039 091 797 (BIA Feb. 6, 2015)
partmnt of Jutic
Deision of he Boad of Immigation Appeas Executive Oce r Immigation Review Falls Chrc, Virgna 20530 ile: A09 091 797 -Bualo NY In re MOTILALL PERSAD
MAL PROCEEDNGS PAL O BHALF O SPOD Aen W. arabe squre O BEAL OF HS C Denis C oc Snior Atoy Dae: oice e 2
2a)7)( A))(, I& N Ac 8 UC
82a)7) A)((] -Imigran -o valid imigan vsa or etr docuent
FEB 6 25
e respodet a native and citize of yana timey apeals an Immigration Judg's Ooer 1
S,
2012 decision ng te respond o adissle as cargd Te recor wil be remaded to e Immgaon udge r ter poceedings and r entry of a ne decision e responden was amied to te nited States as a lawl pemanent resident on anuar 22 195 In 2005, t res
p
ondent aried a Canadian citien Tr at 35 Wen te respoden attemptd to rtu to t nted Stats o aada at te S/Canadian order crossing at Buao ew ork on Frry 1 0 a rview o te rspondents gration e sowed tat e ad copted ad sged a or -40 andont o aw rannt esident Status on Spemer 15 009 we previousy atptd to ross t ordr o Canada nto t nted States aer visiting s E 2 a D otic to Appear was issued on ebruary 11 2011 arging t responden wt inadissiit under setion 2a7)AiI) of te Act SC
§
12a7iI
an immigan not in te possession of a vaid igan visa or enty docment
(x.
1 ) In a decision dated October 18 202 e Iigraio udge ud at e Deame of Holn Secui "DS) ad cie is urde of provig b cear ad convincing evec te responent was inadmssie as carged ndng tat te respoent ad aandoned is prior aw pemaent resdent status n ain a admitted r pannt rsdenc n e nited States is not regarded as seing admission ness among oter tngs t aien as aadoned or rlnqised tat status
ee
section 01a3C of t Imigration and ationaliy At SC
l
10a3C Were an appicant r admission to t nited States as a colorae caim to retig residen status, te burdn s on te Depme of Hoeand Securit HS to sow y clear unequivoca and convicng viden ta te applan soud e deprived of er LP
Cite as: Motilall Persaud, A039 091 797 (BIA Feb. 6, 2015)
.
A039 91 797 stas.
Matadin
v
Muksey
546 F3d 85, 9 (2d Cir. 200);
Mater of Huang
19 I&N Dec 49 (B 98) n deeining whehe he DHS has me i brden of proof, we look to wehe he aen reuning o an unenquhed lawl ermanent resdene aer a emporay vsit abroad
d
a 753 Te nenon of he aen, when an be aserned, l cono
Id; atter of Kane
15 &N Dec 258 (B 975) Suh nen may e deened by exang e ocaon of famy es, propery hodngs, jo, and wheher he aen inended o re o the Uned Saes as a place of empoyen or busines or as an aual ome
Id.
We hae aso conidered he appican's prpose n depng om he Unied Sate, wheher he vs abroad can be expeced o einae wihin a reavey sho period of me, and wheher e ermnaon dae c be xed by some ey even
ate of Kane, supra
aien's proed nen o re o he Uied Sae wou more no uen o uppor he aens e.
Matter of Huang supa
a 7 55 In ndng ha e respondent aadoned hs
R
satu, e mmigraon Judge eed on e -47 sgned by he respondent nd rejeced e reonden aim ha e execued he n a er ha wa kowng, negen, and vounay (J a 67) However, even assumng, whou decding, ha e mgraon dge was corre n s anayss as to e 407, ths doumen, aone, s no dposive of the abndoen ie n order o determne wether an
LR
has abandoned su aus, he
totali of the cicumstances
inudng e ors lsed above, mus be onidered
See eg, Hana
v
Goales
40 3d 472, 476 (6th 2005) (saing ha, at eas n the conex of excluson oceedng, a cou houd consder he "oaty of he rcumsce in deenng whether a py has abandoned
R
au)
oin
v
Ashco
335 3d 415, 41 (5 Cir 23)
ng
Reno
13 3d 1512 (9h . 99). n s cae there ae a number of cor hat, f rue, woud ape o spo he reondens aeron at, deie e gnng o he 407, e dd no nend o abandon his
LR
saus, but rahe inended to reu o a einquied domie n e ned Sae aer a shor p o Canada oaby, e heng ranscpt n atemens om e resondens ousel accompyng evdeniy submssons ndicae not oy ta he responden has een a
LR
snce 95, but ha he ha away mantaned a resdence n te Uned Sae, a he ow ropery n he Ued Saes, incudng a ome in lorda, land n New Yok, d a bnes n New or, at e as aiy n he Uned Sae, and a he te aped o ecome a naurazed Uned Sae cien, ncudng n 2006 (Tr a 113, 2122, 3 Uared evdenty bmission daed May 22, 22) He also asser hat he wa smpy ving hs Canadian wfe r a w day at her home n 2009, d away nended o e o h oe n orda hory ereaer ( a 35) s conderaon of he veracy and mor of these serion nvolve tnding, we nd aroprae o remand ths maer to the graon Judge o asess hese cors, d o reevauae he ue of whether, under he oa of he crcmaes, the eponden ha doned s
LR
saus
ee
CF
R
§
3
( d)3 )(v) povdng , ube ern excepons no appcabe o he resen cae, the Board w no engage n facndng n he couse of decidng apeas)
so dong, te graton Judge shoud consder the addona evdence e reonden a sbed on aeal, ad shod alow he es o oe addona argment and evdene
Cite as: Motilall Persaud, A039 091 797 (BIA Feb. 6, 2015)
Reward Your Curiosity
Everything you want to read.
Anytime. Anywhere. Any device.
No Commitment. Cancel anytime.