You are on page 1of 8

)Human Rights Alert (NGO

"
" ,33407" 6133301
Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org

Joseph Zernik, PhD


PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel
Fax: 077-3179186

][Englishbelow
122015,

"<sar@justice.gov.il>:
02-6285438:
:""
!
14!
,
!

,
[1].
"",
,""
,.
, ,":
..."[24].
"".
, ,.
:
?
""."",
,.
.
"" ,,:
' ,,
[5]".
" "
,,
,.
:,
?
,,,
.
,,
,,
.
!

1/8

'
HumanRightsAlertNGO
"
,,,, :
.,
:
June12,2015
MinisterofJusticeAyeletShaked
Byemailandbyfax
RE:LegalAdvisersandChiefClerkswithnolawfulappointmentscriminalsunder
thecoloroflaw!
Yourresponsewithin14daysiskindlyrequested!
DearMinisterShaked:
Greetingsuponassumingyourhighoffice!
MediareportapubliccontroversybetweenyouandAttorneyGeneralYehudaWeinstein,
regardingtheauthorityofLegalAdvisersingovernmentoffices,whoareprofessionally
underhisauthority.[1]
NoneofthosewhopretendtobeLegalAdvisersinvariousgovernmentoffices,regarding
whomIhavefiledaFreedomofInformationrequest,hadalawfulappointmentrecord.
MostnotablewastheEnforcementandCollectionAuthority,agovernmentunitunderthe
MinistryofJusticeitself,whichnotedinitsreply:TheofficeofLegalAdviserinall
governmentoffices...doesnotrequireanappointmentrecord.[24]
Thosewhopretendtobelegaladvisersaresupposedtosafeguardcompliancewiththelaw
ingovernmentoffices.Inpractice,theyareroutinelyinvolvedinperversionofthelaw,
startingwiththeirconductwithnolawfulauthority.
Thebeggingquestionis:ShouldAttorneyGeneralYehudaWeinsteinbedeemedthehead
ofanorganizedcrimegang,operatingingovernmentoffices?
TheLegalAdvisersarenotalone.NoneofthosewhopretendtobeChiefClerkinany
courts,regardingwhomIhavefiledaFreedomofInformationrequest,hadalawful
appointmentrecordeither.MostnotablewasformerPresidingJusticeAsherGrunis,who
respondedregardingappointmentofChiefClerkoftheSupremeCourt:MsSarah
Lifschitz,ChiefClerkoftheSupremeCourt,wasappointedaccordingtothecustomaryrules
oftheStateServiceforpersonsofherrank.[5]
ThosewhopretendtobeChiefClerksaresupposedtobechargedwithsafeguardofthe
integrityofrecordsandprocessofthecourts.Inpractice,theyareroutinelyinvolvedinthe
perversionofrecordsandprocessofthecourts,startingwiththeirconductwithnolawful
authority.
Thebeggingquestionis:ShouldPresidingJusticeMiriamNaorandDirectorof
AdministrationoftheCourtsJudgeMichaelSpitzerbedeemedtheheadsofan
organizedcrimegang,operatinginthecourts?

2/8

Many,Iincluded,viewyourappointmentasJusticeMinister,whoisnotanattorney,a
uniqueopportunityfortheinitiationofcorrectiveactions.Suchactionsshouldstartby
reviewofthelegalityoftheappointmentsofallseniorofficersoftheMinistryofJustice
itself,includingtheSeniorLegalAdvisersintheAttorneyGeneral'soffice,intheState
Prosecutionoffice,andinthePublicDefender'soffice.Alsoallseniorofficersinthecourts,
inparticularallChiefClerksofthevariouscourts.
ThejusticeandlawenforcementsystemsarethecruxofpubliccorruptioninIsraeltoday!
Wishingyousuccess!
Truly,
JosephZernik,PhD
HumanRightsAlert(NGO)
OccupyTLV
CC:Activists,AssociationforCivilRightsinIsrael,MovementforQualityGovernmentin
Israel,lawprofessors,MembersofKnesset,localandforeignpress
LINKS:Below
_________________________________________________________________________
:
[1]Currentcontroversyre:authorityofLegalAdvisersingovernmentoffices

20150421WhoexpandstheauthorityoftheAttorneyGeneral?TheAttorneyGeneral,Arutz7
7,"?"
http://www.inn.co.il/News/News.aspx/296964
20150607WeinsteinvShaked:GovernanceinIsraelisnotunderthejusticesystem,Calcalist
,"":
http://www.calcalist.co.il/local/articles/0,7340,L3661163,00.html
20150607WeinsteinvShaked:Tyrannyofthemajorityisnotdemocracy,NanaNews
,"":
http://news.nana10.co.il/Article/?ArticleID=1130573
20150607WeinsteinvShaked:Simplisticandunfounded,News1
,:
http://www.news1.co.il/MemberLogin.aspx?ContentType=1&docid=365221&subjectid=1
20150607WeinsteinattacksShaked:Simplisticandunfoundedperception,WallaNews
,"":
http://news.walla.co.il/item/2861265
20150607CrossedallboundariesWeinstein:Incitementandpopulism,News1
,:
http://www.news1.co.il/MemberLogin.aspx?ContentType=1&docid=103338&subjectid=3
20150608AttackingShaked:Weinsteinturnedintoapolitician,NRG
NRG,:
http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART2/699/256.html
[2]RegulationsofStateServiceregardinglawfulappointmentofseniorstateofficers

20040300BasicPrinciplesinSeniorStaffEmployment_StateServiceAdministration
,_
https://www.scribd.com/doc/249850506/
[3]Lawfulappointment,orlackthereofofLegalAdvisersingovernmentoffices
"",
"" .

3/8

',"".
":...".
',
.
',
.
'"""".
,',""
,','.
20150110FreedomofInformationrequestontheEnforcementandCollectionAuthority,Re:Lawful
appointmentrecordofMsAnatHarEven//
)'('
https://www.scribd.com/doc/256486149/
20150126FreedomofInformationresponse(no#assigned)bytheEnforcementandCollectionAuthority,
Re:LawfulappointmentrecordofMsAnatHarEvenreceivedbymail//
)'('

https://www.scribd.com/doc/266097931/
20150222Complaint()filedwiththeFreedomofInformationUnit,MinistryofJustice,againstMsRivka
Aharoni,inre:ResponseonFreedomofInformationrequest(no#assigned)AppointmentrecordofAttorney
AnatHarEvenLegalAdviseroftheEnforcementandCollectionAuthority
(),,',:
)'("""
.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/256570667/
."":,

,"".
"".
,
.
"".
,.,:"
..."
,...
20150225FreedomofInformationrequest,filedwiththeStateComptrollerandOmbudsman'sOffice:
AppointmentsandComplaintProcedures//
:.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/256898878/
20150428FOIAResponsebytheStateOmbudsman'soffice(no#assigned):Appointmentrecords,complaint
procedures//
25)2015,'(:
,
https://www.scribd.com/doc/265888110/
20150519ComplaintregardinginvalidApril28,2015ResponsebytheStateOmbudsman'sofficeonApril16,
2015RequestpursuanttotheFreedomofInformationAct,inre:Appointmentrecords,complaint
procedures.//
16,2015,
:,.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/265904270/
20150520GrowingconcernsofcorruptionintheStateOmbudsman'soffice//

https://www.scribd.com/doc/265988494/
20150520ResponsebyFOIAEnforcementUnit,MinistryofJusticeonComplaint(76/15)regardinginvalid
April28,2015ResponsebytheStateOmbudsman'sofficeonFreedomofInformationRequest,re:Appointment
records,complaintprocedures.//
,(76/15)
28,2015,:,.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/266006814/
.""

4/8

,"".
"".
",.
,.
20150210Attorneyswithoutwhomthegovernmentdoesnotmoveastep,TheMarker//
,
http://www.themarker.com/law/1.2561080
20150218AttorneysthatinluencethemostsensitivemattersinIsraelisociety,TheMarker//
:,
http://www.themarker.com/law/1.2568209
20150304Request(5215)pursuanttotheFreedomofInformationAct(1988):Appointmentrecordsof
personsintheAttorneyGeneraloffice.//
(5215):(1988).
https://www.scribd.com/doc/257635724/
20150331FOIAResponse(dubiousvalidity)byMinistryofJusticeonappointmentrecordsofsenioradvisers
oftheAttorneyGeneral//
)(

https://www.scribd.com/doc/266106274/
20150521RequestforavalidFOIAResponseonrequest,inre:Appointmentrecordsofseniorstaffofthe
AttorneyGeneral'soffice.//
.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/266111389/
[4]Lawfulappointment,orlackthereofofTelAvivDistrictprotemPublicDefender
,")("
.,
,:")("?
.
"
.
20140919FreedomofInformationRequestinre:AppointmentrecordofProTemTelAvivDistrictPublic
DefenderElkanaLeist
:)("
http://www.scribd.com/doc/240288716/
)byMinistryofJustice,inre:AppointmentRecordofProtemTelAviv 20141106FOIAresponse(142/14
DistrictPublicDefenderElkanaLeist
)(142/14:
)("
https://www.scribd.com/doc/249881952/
20140913StateofIsraelvRotem(10740213)requestforimmediateactionbyNationalPublicDefender
AttorneyYoavSapirtoensureDefendantRotem'srights
(10740213)"

http://www.scribd.com/doc/239627102/
[7]20140918StateofIsraelvRafiRotem(10740213)intheTelAvivMagistrateCourt:Responseby
NationalPublicDefenderYoavSapironnoticeofevidenceforperversionofjusticeandfrauduponthecourtby
purportedPublicDefendersasreceivedbyfaxsuspectedfraud
:(10740213)

http://www.scribd.com/doc/240466856/
[8]20140915StateofIsraelvRafiRotem(10740213)intheTelAvivMagistrateCourtreplytoNational
PublicDefenderSapiron:a.FalseSeptember15,2014responsebyTelAvivPublicDefenderElkanaLeistinre:
FailuretoappointCounselforDefendant,b.Ongoingperversionofcriminalprocedures,c.Failuretofileapre
trialmotionper149(10),d.OngoingdenialoftheDefendant'saccesstopapersheldbyattorneys.
(10740213).
",)(,152014,
,.,.

5/8

,(10)149 .
.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/239794048/
20141001WhistleblowerRafiRotem:RepeatrequestforclarificationsbyStateOmbudsmanYosefShapira
andNationalPublicDefenderYoavSapirregardingthenatureofdubiousrecordsfromtheiroffices
:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/241519313/
[5]Lawfulappointment,orlackthereofofChiefClerksinthecourts
,""
"."
"
".,:'
,,
".
.

/.
20131015CriminalfraudcomplaintfiledwithIsraelPoliceagainstPresidingJusticeoftheSupremeCourt
AsherGrunis,andrequestfiledwithAttorneyGeneralWeinsteintoinitiateinvestigation//

https://www.scribd.com/doc/176398650/
"."
" ",
.
',:""?
20150105FOIArequestonAdministrationofCourts(10/2015):OfficeoftheClerkandITsystemsofthe
SupremeCourt//
):(10/2015
.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/256372182/
20150304FOIAresponsebyAdministrationofCourts(10/2015):OfficeoftheClerkandITsystemsofthe
SupremeCourtnoappointmentrecordsforChiefClerkMelul,noresponseonITsystems//
):(10/2015
,
https://www.scribd.com/doc/257699682/
."/"
,,"",
:.
""
.
20150225Rotem'srequestforacertified,authenticatedcopy,TrueCopyoftheOriginaloftheJanuary15,
2015DecisionoftheStateOmbudsmaninComplaintofMrRafiRotem(byhisCounsel,AttorneyHaiBarEl)
againsttheIsraelTaxAuthority.//
""15,2015,
)""(.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/257001377/
20150303IsraelStateOmbudsman'spurportedresponseonrequestforacertified,authenticatedcopyofTax
AuthorityWhistleblowerRafiRotem'spurportedJanuary15,2015ProtectionDecree//
:
15.2015,
https://www.scribd.com/doc/258924994/

6/8

20150318Rotem'srepeatrequestforacertified,authenticatedcopy,TrueCopyoftheOriginalofthe
January15,2015DecisionoftheStateOmbudsmaninComplaintofMrRafiRotem(byhisCounsel,Attorney
HaiBarEl)againsttheIsraelTaxAuthority.//
,2015,15""
.(")"
https://www.scribd.com/doc/259327831/
".
20150105FOIARequestontheAdministrationofCourts(9/2015):AppointmentrecordofChiefClerk
DanielZinati//
"":(9/2015)

https://www.scribd.com/doc/256364175
20140215FOIAResponsefromAdministrationofCourts(9/2015):AppointmentrecordofChiefClerk
DanielZinati//
"":(9/2015)

https://www.scribd.com/doc/256364236/
"".
20140919FreedomofInformationRequestinre:AppointmentrecordofClerkoftheTelAvivMagistrate
CourtMrRahamimAsher
":
http://www.scribd.com/doc/240296838/
[5]20141126AdministrationoftheCourts'FreedomofInformationresponse(NoP79/2014)no
appointmentrecordfor"ChiefClerk"oftheTelAvivMagistrateCourtRahamimAsher
""(79/2014)
"
",",,
..",
20140424FOIArequestChiefClerks,legalfoundationfortheirappointment,authoritiesandduties,their
names,andthoseauthorizedtocertifyrecordsTrueCopyoftheOriginalintheBureausoftheEnforcement
andCollectionAuthority
,,,,
.""
http://www.scribd.com/doc/220060584/
20140707FOIArequestChiefClerksintheBureausoftheEnforcementandCollectionAuthorityResponse
byRivcaAharoni,HeadofPolicyandStrategicPlanningDivision
,'

http://www.scribd.com/doc/232862835/
20141029MinistryofJusticeDecisiononComplaint68/14againstMsRebeccaAharoni,HeadofPolicyand
StrategicPlanningDivision,theEnforcementandCollectionAuthority,inre:Invalid,unauthorized,untimely
FOIAresponse.
,,'68/14'
.,,,
https://www.scribd.com/doc/244861837/
20141109RepeatunsignedresponsebyMsAharonionApril24,2014FOIArequest(nonumberassigned)
withOctober30,2014appointmentrecordasFOIAofficer//
),2014,24'
,(
https://www.scribd.com/doc/249341357/
20150224FreedomofInformationRequest,inre:a.LawfulholderofChiefClerkstampintheTelAviv
Debtors'Court;b.Variousmagistrateslawfulappointmentrecords.//
.;""".:
.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/256720800/
20150310FOIAresponse(unsigned,unnumbered),inre:a.LawfulholderofChiefClerkstampintheTel
AvivDebtors'Court;b.Variousmagistrateslawfulappointmentrecordsasreceivedbymail.//
"".:(,)
..;"

7/8

https://www.scribd.com/doc/266097318/
(1961).
20150220FOIARequestonMinistryofForeignAffairs():CertificationofIsraelipublicrecordsApostilleI
(Courts)//
()I:()
https://www.scribd.com/doc/256392666/
20150419FOIAFinalResponsesbyMinistryofForeignAffairs(no#assigned):Certificationofpublic
recordsApostilleI(courts)andApostilleII(justiceagencies)refusaltorespond.//
:()"
()II()I
https://www.scribd.com/doc/266129092/

8/8