IN THE SUPRME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL ORIGINAL JURSIDICTION \WRET PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 333 OF 2015, ‘Assocation for Democratic Reforms & ANF. Petitioners versus Union of Ina & Ors Aespondents (COUNTER AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF UNION OF INDIA-RESPONDENT NO. 1 TO THE WRIT PETITION 1, RK.Girdhar,S/o Sh. Ratan Lal, Aged about 55 years, Under Secretary, Department of Personnel & Training New Delhi, do hereby solemnly affirm and state as under: 1, That I am Under Secretary, Department of Personnel & Training,New Delhi and in my official capacity t am fully conversant with the facts and circumstances of the case. 1 nave been authorised to swear this Affidavit on bbchaif of Respondent No. 2, [have gone through the Synopsis, List cf Dates and Wilt Petition fled by the Petitioners and have understood the same, 2, Thay save and except those, which are matter of (GP rors, st the evermens,satemens ond submissions qe SeESS, mace by Patioers in the aboveienoned Synopsis, Us Sisees sae sete i‘of Dates and Writ Petition, unt and unless specifically ‘admitted, are denied by the answering respondent. 4. say thatthe present Whit Petition fed by te Assocation ‘of Democratic Reforms and another -Petitioner under Article 32 of the Constitution of India relates inter alia to bring Political Parties under the purview of Right to Information ‘Act, 2005, The Petitioners have prayed to:- (@)tssue an appropriate writ decaring allnational and regional politcal parties to be public authortes under ‘the Right to Information Aet, 2005 as per CIC orders ‘dated 03.6.2013 and 16.03.2015 and thereby full all obligations under the provisions of the sald Act (®) tssue an appropriate writ directing the Election Commission of India and Union of India to collect all Information concerning finances of poltial parties as mentioned in praver (e) below and put the same in public domain. (6) Issue an appropriate weit crecting all national and regional politcal parties to mandatory disclose the fallowing for publle scrutiny; complete details about their income as well as expenditure, entire detalls of donations and funding receives by them, lrespective Gao 88 ome coated an a dae of ceo eysere mae(@) Issue eny other appropriate writ that this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proger in the facts and circumstances of the case. 5. I further say that the Right to Information Act, 2005, (in short, ‘RTT Aet, 2005') was enacted by the Government of India for setting out the practice! regime of Right to Information for Chizens to secure access to information under the control of public authorities, In order to promote ‘transparency and accountability in the working of every public authority. A public authority Is defined In section 2 (hy of the Act of 2005 as under: ‘public suthority* means any authority or body or Institution of self government established or constituted- 2) by or under the Constitution; 2) by any other law made by Parilament: ©) by any other law made by State Legislature; ©) by notiication issued or order made by the “appropriate Government and includes any- 1 body owned, controled or substantially fnanced |. non-Government organisation substantially fnanced; directly or Indirectly by funds provided by the ppropriate Government6, I submit that the Central Information Commission, New Delhl vide Judgment dated 03.06.2013 in @ complaint filed by Shri Subhash Chandra Aggarwal and Shri Ani Balrwal, has held thet the political parties namely = niccyinc, xP, CPt (M), CPI, NCP and BSP are public authorities under Section 2(h) of the RTI Act. The Central Information Commission further directed the Presidents, General Secretaries of those poilical parties to designate CcPIOs and the Appellate Authorities at the headquarters in 15 weeks time, Further, It dlracted the Presidents, General Secretaries of those political parties to comply with the provisions of Section 4(1)(b) ofthe RTI Act, 2005 by way of ‘making voluntary disclosures on the subject mentioned in the said clause. ‘The true copy of the Judgment dated 03.06.2013 passed by the Central Information Commission, New Delhi in the complaint No. CIC/SM/C/2011/001386 flled by Shri Subhash Chandra Aggarwal and Complaint No, CCIC/SM/C/2012/000838 Shri Anil Bairwal Versus Indian National Congress/All India Congress Committee & Ors Is enclosed herewith as ANNEXURE 'R-1/1" [Pgs 14- 671, 7, further submit that while deciding that the said politcal parties are pubic authorities under Section 2(h) of “the RT! Act, the Central Information Commission, New Delhi eB i. Satpad relied on the following grounds:~ 4Political parties can be sald to have been ‘constituted by their registration by the Election CCammission of India, a fact akin to the establishment for constitution of @ body or institution by an aspropriate government, 1, Substantial (Indirect) financing of political parties by the Central Governments. This Includes allotment Gf lend to them at hugely concessional rates, ‘alotment of houses on rental basis on concessional rates, total exemption from payment of income tax from their incomes, free airtime on All Indla Radio, Doordarshan. Hh Performance of public duty by. the politcal parties. v. Constitutional/Legal provisions vesting political parties with rights and lables. 1 further submit that in the past, In a seres of decisons, Hon'ble High Courts and Central Information Commission have held @ number of non - Government ‘organisations as publ authorities under the RTI Act: T further submit that the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in theie Judgment dated 07.01.2010 in Wirit Ptitlon (Givi) No. 876 of 2007, Indian Olympic Association Versus \Veoresh Malik & Ors held that Ingian Olympic Assocation is ‘ets public authority on the grounds that it Is an Olympics ssports regulator in this country and is consistentiy funded by the Government, though for the limited purpose. Similarly, Central Information Commission has helé Chandigarh Lawn Tennis Association, Chandigarh Club, India International Centre and Delhi Public Schoo}, Rohini as = public autnortes on the grounds of substantia fancing by the Government 9. [further submit that, however, dn examining the sald decision of Central Information Commission, New Delhi in its Judgment dated 03.06.2013, observed that CIC has made very liberal interpretation of Section 2(h) of the RTI ‘Act, leading to an erroneous conclusion that Poitcal parties are public authorities under the RTE Act. Poltical partes’ are not established or constituted by or under the Constitution fr by any other law mace by the parliament. The political perties are constituted by thelr registration under the Representation of People Act, 1951 and this cannot be construed as akin to establishment or constitution of a body or stun yan appopte Goverment, aed byte cnr Ifermaon Commision, New Dat Furie, Seaton 2) of he At oes ot oie or cnn ich = perme of pible cry or coon (5,8, provers vesing any suinosty cr boy wt Hgts or {SESE pin tat ate eich asthorty or boa a8 pute ae FRBEtnorty forthe purpose ofthe RTL Act thoy 610. further submit that during the process of enactment of the RTI Act, & was never visualised or considered to bring the politcal parties within the amb of the sald Act. 1 the politcal parties are held to be public authorities under the RTI Ae, it would hamper their smooth Internal working, Further, It s apprehended that polticalrvals might file RTE applications with malicious intentions to the CPIOs of the politcal parties, thereby adversely affecting their politcal ‘unetioning 11, I further submit that there are already provisions in the Representation of the People Act, 1951, as well as in the Income Tax Act, 1961, which aad to necessary transparency regarding the financial aspects of @ political partes. Section 29C of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 provides that: asain aS Declaration of donation received by the political parties.—(i) The treasurer of a poltical party or any other person authorised by the peltical party In this ‘behalf shall, I each financial year, prepare @ report in respect of the following, namely:— yee ve somuen mene Fve eae ee Serie nue person in that financial year; %(©) the contribution in excess of twenty thousand rupees receives by such poltieal party from companies ether than Government companies in ‘that financial year. (2) The report under sub-section (2) shall be in such form as may be prescribes. — (@) The report for a financial year under sub-section (2) shall be submitted by the treasurer of a political party or any other person authorised by the poltical party in this behalf before the due date for furnishing 2a return of ts Income of that financial year under section 139 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1964), to the Election Commission, (4) Where the treasurer of any political party or any other person authorised by the political party in this boehaf fails to submit @ report under sub-section (3) then, notwithstanding anything contained in the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961), such polticl party shall not be entitled to any tax relief under that Act "further say that section 75A af the Representation of the People Act, 1951 provides for deciaration of assets and obities by each eleces candidate for 2 House of Pariament, Section 77 of the sald Act of 2951 puts an Sa Seaton fon every candidate at an election to keep @ PETE coparate and correct account of all expencsture incurred oF 8‘authorized by him in connestion with the election and also puts limit on the said expensiture, Section 78 thereot provides that each contesting candidate shall lodge @r account of his election exgenses with the District Election “officer, Section 125A ofthe said Act provides for penalty for filing false affidavit, ete further, under section 13A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, © political party c@n claim exemption from tax, provided that () auch political party Keeps and_maintains such books of account and other documents as. would enable the Assessing Officer to properly deduce its income therefrom; (0) In respect of each such voluntary contribution In ‘excess of twenty thcusand rupees, such political party keeps and maintang a record of such contribution and the name and address of the person who has made ges hte such contribution; and 8 (eth acount of sh poli! pry are aed by a ‘an accountant as defined in the Explanation below sub-section (2) of section 288: Provided further that if the treasurer of such political party oF any othér person authorised by that political party in ths behalf falls to submit a report BESS under sub-seaion (3) of section 28C of the 4{or a financial year, no exemption under this section shall be avallable for that poltical party for such financial year. The Relevant extract of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 is enclosed herewith as ANNEXURE 'R- 4/2! [Pgs 68-721. 412. I further say that the Election Commission, on its ovin, places the Information provided by the political parties under section 29C of the Representation of the People Act, 43951 in public domain through Its website. The above mentioned provisions ensure adequate transparency in respect of financial aspects of a poltical party. Declaring 3 political party as public authority under the ATI Act would hamper its smaoth internal working, which Is not the objective of the RTI Act and was not envisaged by the Parliament under the RTI Act. Further, the political rivals may maliciously file a large number of applications under RTL Act, 2005 with the CPIOs of political parties, thereby adversely affecting the political functioning of the political partes. Thus, it was felt necessary to annul the adverse effects of the erroneous conclusion by the Central Information Commission that political parties are public ‘authorities under the RTH Act. [say that accordingly, 2 ill was introduced in the Lok Sabha to amend the Right to Information Act, 2005 so as to te‘exclude such Political Parties from the defintion of ‘Public ‘Authority’. The Bill was referred to Parliamentary Standing Committee on 32.9.2013. The Standing Conmittee in its report recommended passing ofthe Bil by the Lok Sabha, Tne Bil could not be token Up for consideration by the Parliament and with the dissolution of the 15" Lok Sabha the Bill lapses. The true copy of the Right to Information (Amendment) Bil, 2013 is enclosed herewith as ANNEXURE "R-1/3" [P9573-76). 14, I further say that Central information Commission, New Delhi vide Its Judgment dated 16.32015 in a CCompiaint fled by Shri Subhash Chandra Agrawal and Prof Jagdeep Chhokar, Shri Anil Verma and Ms Shivani Kapoor (authorized representative of Shri Anil Balrwal) against Indian National Congress (INC)/AICC has, decided inter alia that (9) the respondents (poltical partis) are not in compliance with the Commission's order dated (03.06.2013 and the RTI Act. The respondents therein, ‘a5 public authorities, have not implemented the Girections contained In the Commission's order and there js no evidence of any intention to do 50;(©) the submission made by the complaints for the Imposition of penalty and the award of compensation ace not allowed in view of legal considerations; (© the prayer for making recommendations to public authorities, reference para 68(6), above, nt allowed; (8) @ copy of this order be sent to Department of Personne! and Training, Governmert of India, for taking action 2s deemes appropriate for addressing the legal gaps and Issues that have come to light uring the hearings, including these mentioned in para 68(7) above, with 2 view to ensuring compliance ofthis Commission's orders; and (©) the complainants are at iberty,Inview ofthe facts and circumstances of this case, to approach the higher courts for appropriate rellef and redressal. ‘The true copy of the Judgment dated 16.03.2035 passed by the Central Information Commssion, New Delhi in the complaint filed by Shri Subhash Chandra Aggarwal and Prof, Jagdeep Chhokar, Shei Anil Verma and Ms Shivani Kapoor (authorized representative of Shri Anil Barwa!) against Indian National Congress (i RICE Ors. Is enclosed herewith es ANNEXURE 'R-1/4’ [Pgs77-98]-15. 1 submit that in the facts and circumstances of the ase, this Hon'ble Court may pass appropriate order. Ge. DEP ONENT org VERIFICATION Sse EOI Vertes at New Det off ne skday ot August, legel advice which I receives and: 2015. ex tt a ATTESTED, be PE cone, eeRarer Eo eS ‘CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION Ang Kran haa, at Cama Pace New Debi 10066 ‘exo closswozon ven 386 Fee, close a:300088 ‘nals: 1 Sh Sieh had Agua 2 Stata esponems: Ina Nation Cope ni Compre Coie (AIC: harp aa PaO Cnn Fry onl (Maris) (CPM; ‘Camus Payot Rata Congas Pag NCP 208 Bien Saal PES Dates bearing: 25° Septmibe 1" Nove, 2012 aa ~~ cmp Sinh hada Agra (Sr SCs bs le Compa No, ieswennlunO1H6 and Camplin Shi An Baal, Comsat No. CICSWCROI1O0H, In bth he clas, he cmon te nig whe oh of he xcou el fond ical Pres a ben i, Hes wen ied apa of ae es daa comme rt le closaconas: 2. by hs RT aplcton ded 165203, compaan S.C aga a seus he fetowng itouaton fom te Prednis Secas of he Idan Natoma Cones {QNCIACC) sede rian Pay IPS: 1 Copies of Elton Meio by HIP or Lak Sabi elton in he yeas formed NDA pvenen th Si Atl iar Vapaye as Pre Minter. {2 Wer ll he promis mide I ese ection mane filed after BIP avin fred government the Cee,2 FF tat of promises biggie In IP econ manifest remained fle fer BP cameo power 4 ute of eens (opal by calincheque et) by BFP in bx sens separately foreach ya fer whi pated aco information ute payments party by eaeninelchequ ec) made by HIP st he years paral foreach ofr wich wpated acount nara may beers sicampory freer EP lpr itera Centro States rin cic Dodie tt coe ward party fade? hth yen plese provide compte 2nd. deed afrmaton tnddag abo Aetatersin making sch conus party fan athe Yeas. ‘te nrp are of any fs glares (nh at Centre and in Stasi boy ner ned in eran te alprcics nst he ? ye pee provide complete eta incl acto then y ary a ehers pine ach prs on 81 sogped any propa 9 Uson government ‘kee Coniston evar electoral rears? nates lee provide camped nding reply rece fom ccc nia 12 Anyther ated information; 1.Fe ncn on movement f hs ET pts and om al ape mene ‘HTT ptton” 4. Sh ea tal Vor Tsu, ICC, er ed 20° May, 20, ta voor comple ar AIC i eae te pare oh TEAS 4 she hn rid Aggarwal Rah ro of IP a hate ed 28° Ma, tal informed he compl at BUP is ot ub any an rhe ae oo ged polite eqs Infor, lee CICADAS Ss5 Complainant An si a is RT apleio ed 28102010 bd sagt he ‘etloveg ifort Ss he ude enone Pol Parte: + cries ce 1s) Soc of he 49 maximum veluntary contibuens rece by Your rt fom Fl Yar 2005 anil Year 208107 1) teed oem (Chey ct DD te)? Teams of hes dosatons? )—TheFiaocal Years in which the contin were ade? ‘You ay previe ths iafrmaton i the allen ormat: peer ue Pee ees [emrnem ene | — = 22 SoucesNames al Vetuntry Canibus ang with i ess io hae mad sige contro fore than 1k your ayo Final Year 206445 Fauna Year 2008-107 ‘You may proie his inrmason i the alloing oma: 46bps tr ded 19° Neves, 200, Shit Me a Vora, Taser, AIC ba ‘ate he compas a ICE A ce deh prio RTA 4. Sh Chandon Bort, PRO, Naot Cones Pay, n he Ibe ed 27° Nove 2018, hl fred cma os der se very Impartant to menton here tht NCP is 2 sangeet TYE SHECEe dh ee ach more runes wr sar sa ‘Spec unonlwrk ich ot i our one J ‘We sect fone from thy members drive and va ether ese NE Sateary oaratons rant weeiser, andor State 2am GENCE vt mjer soe i membership de fom wich we ae geting Fa Getta Se ui of Nh 2 doe lel lock tl and poop ‘a cms feu ad every te yas, we Be te ‘Seat rearing oor menbeniip snd al mecesoy reas in lectin ‘Commision ad ote gover ster However, Xl ke te ifm you that aus is Naoal Prey daly eer by Ein Comnision oid and that fv Oe day neti See we hove boca separ lig our rtm wae nce Tak Sa. te lon Common of insane Sabri St ons rected Ic perenne menos he ha ou al ‘Dan tward suri ar up ot Myo fel, ou may calle le nfrmatn you dese rm the above iaubari case you wan ny ican, plea el ret cata 6” 17Sh Bas of Cy ahs ner dtd 6 Nove, 2010, bl lard be copleoan eso fe sini vohmary coos ceed te Pa or ‘he ance 200435 200830, 9. mpi, Poi Pa hse ot spond eT pion 10, Swi sibhash Cann Aguval al led complaint ded 6*Sepenbe, 201, ‘aloe i Cmmision nw bed meno hi Al nda Congress Commie and Beaty Jat Pay, beg natn pars a ot emu land a DeNew Deh a onl vavnt inna rat whic wa much es than previ mack te hrf, vas cart part plea hy i oa der he ie (Be RTI Ac. wae his coment ath AICCING and IP dr seine of e RTA 1. Levis Sh Al Ba in comp dae th 1 Mac, 201, befot (0 Common aunt te repose ied fem INCAICC, NCP & CH, cong ‘hein ee Plc Pris, lg eis ofthe Goverment el wer hob of Sci 2) of he RIL Act 8 fr, hey were nda dc ant comple ermaa hin. 12, Ashe crs is band rad complex sts of i, the Chi femur Comme is Oder 91, 202 onda Full Bech cmpesing tt ‘Sh Sapannd Mit, Che nfaon Cems + So, Amigums Dis Infrmson Comer + Shei M, Shims fron Conisione 12, TB Beach eh fiat ing 08 26 September, 2012. Te allowing we 1a“oj $6 Apa along ith Shit Frsht huis and Pansy sucior, se An Bs, log wh a Jp 8. Cia Sh Tae ‘Sey, Ms, Shiva Kap, Sh a Kua AC Ane eons: ‘tu Ct Bost, PRO NCP. SiR, son Commision: eh. Weed, Panel Soeany, Su Cn, 14 Tee Pll bench hel ed ang on 1 Nove, 2012, The lira were ese Somalia. ssc Aga ‘Sh A Bao log wth Shap 8 Aba, Ms Sanh Rapes, is Man] Kama 8 Sk A At ‘sponds Adve tai Sra fo StS. RemiesdasPls of C00, Adora Shl Ka Dd GV Ra fo BSP. ‘Sh Cann Bet, FRO, NCP ad voce Ait Ard Tha or nee, “915, SiS.C Agra isk ten epee ere Cans ah he as eben fr declaring Pola Parra pble abies un ton 2) ofthe RT AL The alt pols made a pectin a mtd N= bet (© TePaie Paes al eto sans sd wl cnt ee der he Teh Scedl of he Cano nt ch a ay Bee powere= 3) aga eles om Parnes 1) ind legis in pecs nd ong ne te hase ©) decease mae (dee water Goverment mis a power or wick Goren © deep pois tae es of milion af pepe” (©) Aeper Arce 12 oe Cnn, etn cin be gait oe eg 2 weber of ther Hose of Pant under Tet Seba ad at sir prove fr Se Logos nr Arle 1912 of ‘he Consin, Fuhr er Arle 1020), fa member of Hose elon ea Poll Pay vos oases am ong he Hose esas to the ene ied bythe Pll Puy, be lable be uid fom being = Meer oft Hose, (0) TeePalse Parser ane ben ges tay sander Scion 294 fh — ‘Repent oe Ppl AC, 15 (8) Unde Seon 298) ote Rgesenon f eple Ac 15th Pea Pare ae gael 1 bar fh ad alae tte Constan of ad sb a esubibe (©) Te Pel Paes ge dees othe canes andthe pepe vue mb he Palle Par port unas ot 20fe) Te Peltcal Paies ae sbeoualy Gane bythe “spine ovens nlp was nd pee fom came Ta 16 Tecan St Agave as fused copy fete td 292011 of be ‘CPO of te Land and Devel OFRoHLRDO}, My of Utan Delo siesed «0 ton roving Inforaton vepiding alot of Ta by Land and Deve Oe ovat Puli aie, The eas of ean aan aos Pll aries fae by he LADO we raced w= “LISTOF POLITICAL PARTIES WHICH HAVE BEEN ALLOTTED LAND BY Tab 0 DEVELOPMENT OFFICE FOR THEIR OFFICE BUILDINGS, ‘sta ing CORRES | Pata aero fet Nev dow | at Heat Nev Da we | iby oe na Packer ois Ran, a= 08254 0. ‘asda 193207 aa aT et Nee 357, a Ka oad Rew DAT ihc 0¢q mated 37.207. a PR aT Ne 7 at Ma Rd TT ‘tants Nowe Dns 157 aed on 24141857 Ped Gi 1213 Kea od Dest 75g, ale ob 1123008 a Seer = rama Fag os — A er Bo = marmnias | Send Soa eaten noo Ser gc Alma 08 aa) An ia sn hares bars Sp RS eee | ao Se a ln a7 (acres oes aS en a (bo Setar deeneons i= Tg AT SIT Tr nts names Camger oNee Tot3 DDU a. Ne tetas lod on 1.032051 17. tn iin we ov, Si Agaval aa lhe oman epi he Nome! of acme ovaries Pil Pr n lbs ad he usta (ues apa hea exe yh om he Duero Ese vide el et ate 248201, Th eet lon text ioe as RT aan | fs — aa — ca Ar 2 cage eta | Fatma sear see aa ara [e Bharata Janata Party 3 — Pree a Sl Pt 1 | sh ra —Kaeat Game [Sieur cei ~~ 8 St An Baal as ae ld & ded preset ei is Came cone tht Plt Pris fall oe ant of seca 20) of he RTT ACL 10 i ‘epee Sh Bana made he flings p= (0) ie Plia Paies ve ee eaning a cin unde so A of hele Ta Ac. Aspe ptestatn, vaio Tlic Pris deed Income Tx exemption agen ne ll Tale: 22( Swnce 5 Compiatn from copes of Income Tax Rear eee fo Inca Tax Deparnen une RT A) (0) Sie es ee ety alg varios Pll Peis by wa ofa incom Ana Ra As pre cleation he moun Sey he Son je Tame oie eae Ra CG] Rowe pe] | ry for bende) by AUR nine by he State fe | Sethe AUR, stegaryfor| AIR ah) | dune 10 | Pala a Te Sa — a a ie a 36 a Ter 3 ‘aw 2a = oc i s Ke se a 2 % BaD. oo Zee Teal Ea oo aaa (Sowce + Compton fom Spot Buy Rats and Tn Abed various Pokal Pars resved from All nds Rao and Bina Commision of Ind der ais RTL appa (4, Tecoma hs sn eg! ht te Sata sem age aca ce Pats Pardes in esti fie tne ob Dosdanhan The ule given by hi is produced be ey Sos, Eee 23hes seo — asa free er — [sane [ rar — [2a —Taoor as afer —so—f eas 95 ioe as —— fo $e 30 — tear Toss [00s [oon eas Pe Neb ao — [se oo_[uas—[ eo — [saan ear Pas Sf —[¢ —[serfoas [as — [10m ost [0 Pisa 55 3 Ea (o) Theva oe operas ated by the Gave sma ye ‘olan Sh Bla vena seein in Fay [Oram ates [Bis] RG] Cony Crea th aamen es) Geamsia%e| Vaweotte | Vane afte Se Aine Pepe ples Hypa | Lndtedon| Pan Bie | atte "| Ineo Tae ano | Coning ye) | Repo @ Re foc pe fino} a} o Te ae iaeaseeTs Ysa TOHEAT w4 Pad Roo New| eto ‘nouua075) arahask Xenon, |emnsg.qerocesn | 22 ‘sion mF ten br Rama | Toreabanraa [mare | ST so ead Raha ayeaten ae moon) arcenece scorn | so60e0 | sseiear | 04s Rode Deni fabee | st on n.0s2010) Sa Fae NaD, RBA TT a TE | ie Dm New Dod a heise7) Piste 1.12852 |2596eqa) 277660 | 68 ta Rad Nw De (aod on 1122008) Pee Raivng | SoS | OGIO — | TAT ‘ev Dataloted oo Segara eee [ae Panam | [TT dens) I tN Vasa Var | Tad OO — PST ‘urna Are, et Deloned on 220 ar ADRK ] Peers ata DOU had TOES] oH — [SOT sei vo Tw OTERO] EE sary a Tae Ne es TFS ais — | SOE Poza Pusan ra] a o nde ess 12 of Relation of Bete: Rules, 1960, pes fe SecrlRs re sail oe ogni Pll Pars, fe of xt “Thr tweer insane finds ening of he ota Faery he Sa (ot) The Cooma Govt and ke Sie Governens tare alloted as uestlgalser ye of cence Vis Pt Pare fe foster tenner es, Ti ako amos nde acing of Peel Pain ie mspecive Goverment as(08) The Plc Parser ar cannon engage ne penance of ue ay and, elon, part they become aco te pale ‘Trmrecy i he very and fc pets of de Plc Paes 6 seat he agli. 1% Sear Adio, Sh Prshat Bhscas a8inael the Conmisin 2° ‘Site, 2012 on bela of angina Si S.C Agaval. He vbeeady come hte ep tm nis eed son he alse Pari, Tey per bl foton an hry, wate eae ub hy esac 2) of Sie RTI AG. namin oh sbove bdsm, has bared foi, — (© Te Seda oe Consncon ves undo pone wi be Pata aris nam hyn au laced ment = ste MP ar MLA en out of he Pay eso of pry Ine. The vs pow afte Pale Pres as en eng nS an, fof ui ineretion| fhe Ten Schedule td, th Poli Faria be devaed he ove ne Seon 2) ote RT Ack (As per Secon 296 of te Repeat of Pole Act 861, al ono fan shove Rs, 24000 de Pola Fas eed be ea nce Tax Deane. Ts bgton cto Potala pts er ule charac (i) By visu a powers confor under Ale 2 oft Cnstion seth nen 298 oe Reset of Pole Ac 151, a4 Rules San 10 of| he Condit of Flo Rls 196, ad ar ones voted 2 te Beton Comic of nd made ad poate te Econ Symbol (esata an = Alone Ore, 198, Under he Oster, Ein Commits ats smd ‘ros Pll Pres. The Eee Como ian insumealy of he Sat [Allmmant of leon syne by the Flton Cominon vine Dic Pats sgpsie of ule hacer of he ola Foie 26(0) Tae Pal Farge age ex exempts under Sc 13 A of se fncone Tx Act 91, which ano Sac of he Pb Pasa ems Scion 24) ofthe RTA (0) The Conta Goverment sd te Ste Goverment ae lol huge las of tage aceon pine aan al Pll Faris oe he SORE ar, foes 00 Doge conceal as Ti ho nurs nds ing oft Poel Pai (0) Doe fai ls a ee he oil Pris Ging oh losis, Th is ater nance te ecg of he Pali Pais (oi) Asthe Polk Pai ae eae of he mi onion ee {demo ply sd a ey ae nde fed by the Caz Gove th Sate Gone a asus wa cased hedabow,ePali Pres ee obec pbc ubry tke ete 2) oft RT A 20. Si AK Ang peeing ce ba a he compli nbs i sbisin has ‘exw Coniston ton 60S ot nee Tt Act wh rvs ‘toronto mae byt nv or Coping 02 Pll Pry i dee fos, he al ine fhe ana, Th provi i exclly apie the Plea Pes nd suas of ne Saco he Fel Pare be Sa, 24. Compan Ss Al Raval as ako Cd ald en soe belo ‘Comision aging ht te oa Paes sno be deca Pablo dr etna 2h fe RT Act, Hit fenton ht Poli Pare ave indg ‘se wih hppa’. He pn on ey a “A te Cat aston of aoc, hy cooly te wl ef he people ad ci ll er egecaons ta emocacy ll eu ‘pesve 0 ir ede and ely sale te st psig pols tat conn a ine aly ns 22. i scnd ston tare elf ccuniiy ad wasp i fanning fh Poa Par. ei cnteton hat eanguency nh facong of 27Poll aie wa cried by he Ly Commi of Ine a hr 170" Rego Rear f Era Lave S097. The ela an of he La Commo’ pe reac yin reel cu the parity ofthe above retain, must Be sid tha if demicy and exon nth coe fur cantante the sane ones mus (eval io and nd the Plies which re inegral © paramenry ena, I te Pla ares hat ora he Government ante Paranent tnd run the governance af the enum. It therefore ees to inode Inara democrats nd account In the wn fe. lia Bari A pol pory ch oes a rnpect democrats In eral king cane eect reps she pcp ne governece of the county, Icon be darahp internal ond democrat ts fanctnlng side” empbas added by the complias) 22, St Bal ao toh Commision eso ated 7.04208 in Fl No. ‘OLA N0RS & 0125-01270 when neue ae ony Palak Paes as ben deine. le aly dvs or semen opr 25 of he eon ‘acl Paes ae # wig Instat of he moder aston tat “Te are eel i sce leon and ae thereon goverment “Tne ques sn fc chat pte of being non governmental Palla Paris cae wl ayo nde infec, eco goverment wer th Unk between State power and Pla Pres tht ha sued lal gucci the context of th Right of Information ~ an At wich has ‘rough int feat the impratis of ansparncy Inthe fanctning of State aan 1 woul be feu argue tat wesprency Is god frail Sie ‘gs bu nas goed fo the Pala Pars which cna he mat ingot of seers. Fer example, kl be 2 lay old hat wansparency is ed for the bueacrcy bat ot god ens or he al Pars which cota hse barns th peal xen 28"Te Common a fart bad: 38, The Laws ofthe lind do aot mabe I manatry for Pla Fares te le the sources fe fading ad evens othe mane of expending hse funds, tn the sence uch a he aly way 2 cin can gl aces 6 he leas f funding of Paka Parts erg hi nce Tix Retr fe ‘muy with nome Ta ahr, Thi abot the cst he Pail Pardes fet acouming for te sures aod te extent of their Ging and ir spear, There email pub iterstnknawing tes ang tas ich would enable the nen to make a armed cece abut the Petal ‘ars o voter The RT Act emp hat “ory requires an informed Snr an tht traspatency of information ial to Navies fomconing of ‘ostiona democracy. imo ae tha wheal erga fhe Stat mst ‘ahi masimum wanarency, ae such eblgatin aches t FOB Fares (Given da Pall Pr infnce he exer of pial pe, osprey thir egeizaton,fncone and, more pricy, hl ees of funding a ems npr nk eer isin pub nee noi seand fh sisi di te Pub Attys find anderen 2) of te RT Ac er em han te ‘Se a5 tind ie Ale 12 f Const. Iter wi ost an ecty ay also a big Saad yet ray bea be Aut” td he RTL Ac Int, “aie Ant” ane Sn ae het ein om ec her. Sh sl a eel on ya 25 of he ges of Pah sd Heya High Coors WHE) No 10240006 slang wh 28 cer es a 25. Atoveal te dp abd pervasive conta reuted under Are 2 at required and eset ingredint for tveing the provi of KIT Ac. The primary purpose of isrumentaty ofthe States in react enforcement he fundamental vgs thpagh Cours wheres the RI Acti ended ac, cet matin and prove an effective framework fr ft the right © Information rcp der Arie 19 ofthe Canton, The complainant are rt aiming any Lind of monstary Daur or propery fron th exe f th 29+ pesos, Ty sd the ferment of damental ight though (Cours andthe queso ppb of writ jroo an strumentalty the Sate forte puro of deteminan of satan gh nies ofthe ats are get (ore feet han tha of the el ef RT Ac only ment tw impart he nfomasn. ence, my view, te ambi and spe of phrase of Insanity of he Stae under Arte 12 fhe Connon nie diferent nd sinc han ht the rine of RIT Ac If he Ineo of the Lge ‘rr erst he meaning tthe exgresion of public aur, srelhiactng he same hn he four coer of th Se defined wer Arise 12 then here ‘wn neces asign spc reader define publ our wer econ 2) of 7 Aan i reeont connate”. 25 The camp slo apd ht wh ees whet apr eniy& ble Aubry orc nro nares bjt fhe Ac The pn of is Ac i eanspry ad econ e eciog nes wich pact cen dy ve,‘ Pelt Pars ae sch eis. He bas ‘eed on pa of De gh Cnr juga ind by Sse Rains ht in (boi Ascaton Ve Verish Malka ers) No BT2007 a ected ow “the Ac ars 2 elave meson in the pst independence er fre dence. empowers ens ni information applicants to demand and be ‘ple wih norman aout pb rece. Primer ender end ie abe wo public eutories which ingot cies daly Tis. The Act mands (dacs of al manger of afro ab salshs the concep of lcs stand the infomation applicant: we jrticaton for appibing, or tformaton) peer; dein abd dein nang proces, whch afc Bs of ails nd poupe af cans are sow ope 9 examination. Pafomentry Inter porn was empower pope wih he ene sre goverment a uc rcres andere ansparen. Atte samen the eed feet aaa nd Govermnts wel 36d in partir, to ese that seve Intrmaco ept otf Hounds hive a been ccommedated under te A”Perse bein te compl tah Pell Pari ae ag icy fiance bye Sen vats wy aloe fad i of oot om ead eons fm te Inte Tax ee, Pass 31 037 of Ms preeacn ae ected ew = 31 Al Poli Puri aim owe fre pape in the nana iter Incame ta earns of Paltcal Pares aed by ADR wing th RT Ac revel ht oan average sly abt 20 percent afte acme of Pla a Parts comes tram donne tha they cee othe Eton Commision nde section 20 of he Represntatinn of People Act. The sores of the emsnng 90 percent th come a shrouded in mystery Thi what ‘resi ol Kinds of spect soa the peas uence of Weal $12 Aer various RT appa ed de centr pecs twas covered hat Pll Parts enjy umber of facies” proved them bythe everest This cla nance of eng financed nec by funds ‘movie by the appopriste goverment” which pus Pllc! Parties ‘surely der he inion of be story”a rovie for inset 24 lhe RTT Ac 3, aon te te 100% eampan an income under Scion 1A of the Ince Tax Act ll tbe jr Pal Pars have been provide folie” fr ride and fla we by Deca of Esats (DOD, Gvernment of Ina in New Dab They have Ben gen fics and esdeta ccommedatns prime latent in New Debits De) Soh ae Aba Rad, alan Res, Chanayapur. The etal charged are eto of he mart ret, The facies are not ust roid to he a nomial es but ter maitenance, wpgradton, moderation, enmvaton, eat ao done a Sate pene. Sin “axies” oa (rnide- sae Sate canals demi of wich ae extend i ie core SE,Many sl spent hy Election Como f ni om Paz Parte fo moving “facie” to Poll Pare rch at Gee detrei eordashan Al nds Rai ae prover roads aie tthe lic Pris tn he whe es ins of een nea of iene wie hr markt lu ‘sly moire and eld he tt of pee and spent on Pale Pare wed pst amount “Thre have ben several Jedi pronouncement and a deco bythe ‘ene naratin Commis hve hd hat allen of al sate, ena onsbidied rte, emp fom tax of various pe Inding Income ta amount indie nancag erm of section 20010 ‘We RTIAG A few af the mare seal cats ae pve belo: S61 Land Te cse hati relat he Chl Wo etn Ne 1750 200, The Sak) Cb oe Ste Information Commision and nthe decided 0 68052011, commonly rele to as CWP Ne. 1004 of 2006 slong 23 cnmeced ass. The Pans and Haryana High Cour ld a fs ‘72. Now adveting othe ian lp of petioner See Ci, diana Se NOI) ke concereed the SC mentioned tat sper ven rc, he Ind evaed by the Provincial Goverment is ‘hen the Clb whe aout ssa tnancl sistance by the Sate Government. The ot hate lanl and pon which (Cb ws cone. eos the Gone adn ea ny view the SIC hat record he erect ing 32fac bed onthe matron ecard by ita fag order aed 87200 sez [and.and income Ds casa: A directly relent case er eating wih both, land and acme tae ar deed by the Centra Information ‘Commision on 1.00201, Ite MrT Ro Tanwar vs Government of NCT of Del, Fle No. + CICADVABOLLONIGO, Afr camideing al aspect of he se, ce Common decided allows 12, The Common whe rdyng yp the vais a cals sven heriabove convict the Mant SU Mary's Stel may be core a Sing “ubsandalyfncel™ by the spree Goverment ees ine ad rae (eats ats an ine comes eng eed te hoa an ht erfor tan Be decir asa Publ aero sss ‘uempson fom Zin : The ct that selva here Chil Wet No. 1606 of 28, Punjab riche Anactn, SAS Nagar) vs Sute amino, Pj and ana, eed 09.5201 commonly refered {CWP No 18224 of 205 alngneh 29 connected aes ‘The Punjab and Haryana igh Court el allows 68, Now averting he cae of pede -PCA a NB Islet poston hati sng tempo rmenerannent oxi one financial bythe Se Alina SIC has pte the ple fhe cnpanant norman seeker, bt to ay mid he SIC as sipped nt deep lea err in hs regard canis the PCA ie ening hens anauat fn exemion of toot Which nan an inden flaca sh Geen ses ‘Tax cxemtion snd oma an: Another case reat hae ‘Board f ental fr Cricket Inka dant Neta Cricket Chb a thers 05 AIR (SC) 2, The Supe Cour sbserved flowsta, Te Beard ia sce regtered under he Tal Nad Sites Reghraton Ac 1 ene a menopaly sas 26 regard rept f the sper of cricket in ns ofits Memorandum of ‘Asai and Arles of Auocitinn, tank the sport of lice nd lays dn the law hereto. ater abies ei yay of mcematin ond ight seta ot elena re. 117 Wie ema wal be aged hat eave gute eons refer a stone sch a coal, lab wich, some characteris, are “teense ltl Parte at he dein resi, ep te eablh the principle that expo rom x ad alleen minnow land and ether rea sai san opted fer of "Snancing® hgh my be conrad nde” sis atin the ysl form of money And hs pela one of facts tat kes Poll Parts come under the fine of “pute utr” gen in secon 20) fhe RT Ac.” 2, More inpraey, e complimet Sas cotendel Gat Pic Pais ve ‘eat an anor se ee bs conenten i tpn of Anes 020) a 1912) dough te <2 Amendnet aid Qh 10 Sade he Cems has ten constrenl sane whe Poli Farle Acting oN 6 «ai 1 9 ht ny ind an fom ll py A bao ent oe sot become a poll pay ite eal ene mister byte Eon Commision of Is wd seston 298 of epee of he People Ac, 1551, ad epson lends the calor of Pu iy. 23, Lay, he compan sale coment at xref power te Beton ‘Conmison of Is aaer Elecione Sybls (Reservation and Amer) One, 168 rage wider at 24 fhe Corin an Rul 5 & 30 he Coda of lacion aes, 283, gran yt vss Poll Par fr econ pets re cobs of akc Pare an undo whe rgion of caged Plt Pas = oei tare eharve mode ale of conde et owing te Lea nets ad Inert ofte Commision reevaluate f Fle Pars, sa. maybe rer mend ht Sh 8. Saar Rey, Gena ecery, Cammet ry of ni sen er dtd 2482012 he Conmson anger ate Pla ars oot came ner ani con 20) be RT At. The eer pega of sear ae xm blow com AB, Bann, te oe Genel Secwry Bae wren a eter peg eines ee esa fur Pry tana, nove, Pali Paris (hoc come wade Scion MOOD oe RTT Ac. Nothing i, 8 ve ‘vas be prep ob nga nar acm. ‘We stmt curacao Cons of a ee yar ad vy yor we ‘tt ou aun 1 lama Tl egret so. The ass fr Pay at cd eal ut commine allo ty he Charere Acoutan Ti hn ‘abit or Pay Naioal Coun fr oso tape Weare pepe © te lt cone nd expat fou Pay rasp ‘1, a te ober id St AB, Ban Ger Seer, CP ea nd 21.3201. sacle Sh A Banh std CP Pa ty ude seca 20) of bt ETLAcL. Tvilvntperion ofits exzaced elo = (2) Ye, we are be Auboaly eke section 20401 “omgeeame spices beialy Snel drecly riety by ands prove ‘be sprite Gover. (0) Weave aria Arpt Ast “Cena Cota Commis. 52, wou a, pr ht CPL Ba cna sad in he mat, even whe BS38S Amba Rj Dis fd 3 ume da ied 1.10202 on bal of aban ‘Sams Ferg (BSP) in wc be hes tn hp ate Pain Prs are sr pbc storie ner sion 2) he RT Act. Taig tga ab be wl st at SP a pla ary Ht fas st bee acted ax pe aon by meas of ny Nedtaton of te appopie nena te elect hat BSP Ic under conte of or ban fance yh ppp goveme: He is ao contended ht Sieg (neler als dig eats i deve ely oan alguns ner be Reston of lon Rake, 192, Sit x xempsn de secon 19A of be Ac Ienibjec ee conplane of pov come Tat Act. Furr mot alse of evened te Pil Prt op concsi esds x ch th ary {ue oto wis he mening con 2090 he XT Act. Para 4,08 10 4 That ute abn hate compliant as had oes ight fe splcnin under Section 6) ofthe Right nermaon Act 205 apis the Sowerng respondent for hereon tht the Petal Ports ae nat he ple uberis ender Sec 20) te Right nfermation Act, 205, The Babu ‘Samaj Party being oe of het nna! Patc Pars dy recognized by the kon Commision of Inia therefore, nt a "Pale Author” within the ncning of evn 2) Right Intron At, 2005, Theelare the present Complain pena able be mised, “That | heey sl thatthe BSP a pola pry. 1 a bees ited ae 2 pulic anberiy by means of any netatin of arent vermont the fle! dat BSP eum, canoe or substan anced by ‘he appapriat government. Mery because sme cancesins eat and sty thas en ranted ke chs ee rated any er ail parte BSP des stomataly become aby ted otal or substantially ance by the soporte government a BEthe abuve, the preset camping pen agit the anevring repens ply aot mitaiuble oly on he grund that here 2 Stee unin ore stn tag datos Desrdarsban and Al Indl Ra “The Sate fondag onthe coral ll uring cos dane met sttuory dg under Reitratan of Electr! Ris, 196, which mandates that wo opis of the eecaal roll oe printed copy and antes in CD is spied coed Poli Parts, eof ast Furter Tax exemption wi 1A f he Inco Ta Act gun jet othe compan f the provisions ofthe Tc concen rent dns nt the the pall ary ots «pile aor within the meaning of Secon 200 Righ afrmation At 2005" ‘34, Sit Akt Anad ivi, cal for Naat Congr y(NC as aed ogo case tat NCP a= ui aus, He asa Fl deal reseton inhi Bicone hb NCP dos a wii he bi of ain 20) of he RTT Act e bis ed te iments evan by compiz te Pl ares stay edb the Gorn. Hi cnenon at eatin graed ‘© NCP ding he ton tne on stn levine inal oe ot ogee of erent fang in 8 ich tag lcs poplar pac amo of th temocaces, Hes efemed sect f Ca i is ote, Fay, cng i, ‘sly of eee ing tons o NCP, pe oa ene Saag hy ‘oven. is hs cnet tle (6) af be Rgoraton of Bec Ral, 196 he Repstaoe Ofc mnt pve To copie of Bc Rol, fe li Purs eid der aces 2 of he Repesaration of People Ac. Ths is sonar eect dante sod btn ang, Say, aboen ot pry offi NCP at comic not bens ntl ang in ech ‘th Gove kes hit vale sot ny Rate Pars cpa by be ese Commision ba 0 oe spent of poplaton such as oumaliss Fares ‘ov iS Tvars anteater noe Tax game deren 1A fe cme a Ac en doe sot mem Bi he NCP i bly faced by he ‘oven He hn tangle of nse Tax xem tthe fren bt by vito iste timer cnt te daa a pb arty under seco 20) othe RT Ac,55, Witt pe he shoe argument Ad Tha as ae hat even “site rie Gernot is eng he Fla! Fares ne manne manned ews ‘buna ani ee cnention he NCP ects ‘ove, ana be i es the 1556 of a dng om te Governed, haere, amore ead bc ony, Png 2 and 132 of peon mtb “13 tm Soha. Slr tina » Inn Fate of Wefre (Ased $1208, he ew’ Corson bd hh respoedent ate as a pc ater rainy ene raced ot war than 20% of rant al fram the goverment whic aaa be deve be staan. In Sh, Shane Paro vB ‘Gandhi Fouion (Deco Ne 612010, THI Hon Commision has. ‘asiered TAY Cale cs and ts on dct Mod. Sefer Iman” andl a since the espondent body reed a ery nominal mount gras om the Goverment amounting te arly 86, canna beat be pubic uri on account of Ling sus Gace by he Goverment. In DAV Cle ‘st ond Mnagemen Secieyv. Direc of Publ Instulons & Or (AIR 2008 ‘PAH 117) he Panab& Haryana High Court el that wre apolar sea rect 49% of gratia fam Government wat ning ebay (inane ye Government, 3 hr? wer stn 20) of th 132 From the above sated jul precedents ad dtm became et hat ery facing would wot bring 2 person win he puree a secon 28) ‘tc nani mnt be apparel considerable and doe trgh suering of ‘tars o advancing fons tH cater where ining hse than 20% oe oa ance te autor by organ, amet ed nto be seta ancl wn he mening of Seton 216)" 36, Ady Tha asd aoa subaisons ded 11202 for NCP in whi hs ade te owing sen pos © The power ec by the Poll Paris andr he 10" Sc of te ‘Ces coms b cos mas ta oll Pr plese ander>) ston 20) ns mocha hse powes can be nr ony when an laced Mee is veto eran tom eg aut he whi of Be policy ches ohne 1 te mandarin of sch pla any. ee i ich cs, pla any amok lagu 4 Maser of Lge A ht and © moe an gen song sition of sch ceed Member before th Chienaper of the Hie wh Bis csi ory deca such ected Meno be pif or ars, (0) ods, acl Pare ae pad gic en pbc Mea ae res so te stn fo decang bay inst a ube abort der sec yoke RTA. (1) Pela Pri ate dee be ile ores, ten de wl be Rodd ‘th pleios by paloma eso mally ena ary wake in png ote RT gplicons hy cag dette oi plication. Te Inlaid des by the Hie Cou se Ian Oye Asoc ene, Cmca Games Comte ase a: Saat chal ase tall the Pll Fas ns ck hr a sac hige ec nec by he Govern ahs Baden ich tein he of Pol Pats (09 Pate es een ot ald nails Paes ude cto 2 tf the RE Aa. Ih apenen acpi ee tenis of coer weld a ‘dala he otra ha happen, Schley xo a wast nd eas yee Poa Pas, © nde td 672009 of Sng Bea ofthis Colo a Campa No, Glomscamnstont & CICIMISCaIo800r was hl it Pola Paes ae oot vee ce secon 2 te RT AL, (0) tafe cis ted 5.22010 of Gos Sate Ifrton Commision (St Pads a Ver he Fide abr Gana Pay) wir Bld ht MGP was ost bled or coasted ne any ecu of Se Lesa by ay Noo oe nie tie Govern. Noe ws ewe ibaa anced by he Sexe Govern nd here, wast pc uot 39‘37. Sti Sasi Pas Aga fh BUF is er dd 20.5201, dese tt ‘ampli. Arh hen We tnd ate BI i ob abode RT1Aa. ‘38 Silty, So Mot Lal Vor sue, ALG nae ted 205201 asd 2 mpi SC. Apa hs when the snd at te INCIAIC des tie der te prvi bbe cls ees, at ables rove orate RTA. ‘3, Afra te puns he Common ied tas er dad 2022 othe owing Poe a= Navona Congres ay Baja Pay Bharata Pary Commu ay of nia oem ary of nda) 1¥C Alina Congres Comiee seckin fom ten he loving ration = A) Dee ndings ened by Got and stuns your Puy @ » © abet lesute opis) Die Ho: eon fama cages wise = (0 Yexofatoxmet © Posatadinss of plasbungs. G)Serofpeatusdes. (09 Whee ay inlrion plo Gamo Sete Gt 90, (©) Wher he andstlogs wee aod mack at oat ‘mens 4o. (09) Tess vale of plugs t peepee) ® Aout of cnn ee by ou Fay ig lit fie Sac yo. 207-89 2014-12 yee. (© tocomes ected by our ary fm any ter pues ig as fie ancl ease 207-09 201-12" 40. Only prs vi. NCP and CPIM) chose raped oe Conmion's it, “Teobe Paes Pre none 44. Sh SR. Kol, Plamen Secery, NC, oer ed 211201 arma he ‘Commision hath ay was x covered ude Scion 2) ofthe RTI Aca af, wot bond wo sep ey norman. 2 Howe, Si Pash Kat, Gen Secety, CQ wt 2 deed er at 21112012 Camino awh he give dea feo bug allo PIO) ‘ie: AK. Gpslan van Plt Nos. 27,284 29 Matt Rod masing 1873 Mis. neo 2211180 and Kot Re Po Nox 10, 31,12 & 3, masing 25946 9m, lowed on 11122008 As rege AK Gaps His pt, nod he Cn that te Pay ad peste sect no of 51.42 lc we eee foo Rs 70574, Aspe Kaa Road lhe arya pid rami ef RS ls Wi rd ent of 134512 per anu. Shi Kant ht red th he ay hs lyme ight the pounder fers. Sh Kata ao gn cal team oe ay os 2007 ont 2018-12. Bucs ead be gusting of a xn aay Pay, eno ie lloras “Patamen wok edie w ple aca of he Poe Fae nee “Tbe vet ano tegen ce docac poly athe couny 8 Pl Paes ed ete prt ogc” Heal and so fc a eons king conn ay la een nh amo canto Palate be eee wl43, eocds tobe uti! hat bas been the no af te rues sac by be ‘pans in hth Pali Fair rsa Sac, abe inde, by he sop CovernentCencal Govern ia) by Way + 5 Ame of ae a flan i pie aa of Db ihre of co ora concen : Aloe ous o a ion cen : xenpse fo Income Tak 3 of TA : esr ton All ad Rats 5 rear ine on Door Dasa, nd . Pring of re cecal (4 The Commision had stun 9 te Sey, Miiey of Ustan Delonas, Sovenmes of Ind, New Dei © caf he pation repaig te allman fa ros Plea Paes, daa Bye complas The Depa Land & Develop te his ete ad 2.5203 hs wet he Stay of te Cais ea ‘beam af wns ola Pes, Tope psn efor s reed “Tan dnc wmf your ee No, SeqyCIC201300 2 dated 7 Ma, 213 9816 Al, 213 one toe mwaoel jens rv atin aalite nts tice nespcof Table atu = a aa r= 1 Ads Goonine | be anda sa Rad] SST TE India Nene Cons | tokmonsetoatar | 2-9 Banven TK Ran, | emg must Fa Taba | a a 3 Tamas ay of Ps ed Paras Ta tain am seat ase pares hase | cae taeda ea Pa Na fe [aeaieca iat eee — We ees ee SSeS, Series ety eae 42Tama rE PRS ae) —[ Ves vie Poe — [poor 3] Bye te Pay Reta Ro Nat YL a (obi sae teats | ia A DE |p Vi Bad — Mamers Kasam | abr PiotNo 15 8.22 oT Dali Rade Cones Rowse Aves Fx od | TT 7] Stns sat —] BDU Wg PEROT ES — [OO ‘stfomed te noma prove ihe Tbe fc eared ie sles were mae se Plt Fart ox neon and aes of his fe, Copies of lin erin espe of bore meniooed Plc Parise eco be” 45. Thoms nd combo same AIOCNC re cone in the LADO" eer nd 197207. Pan 20) fel ete irae low = 4) The ee wl py the pf and @ Re a Lath per ace proven pus 25% cot a aml proend rent. Taste was val w 10 3132000 The alloc hl ave pa alferene fren nh ld a ae reve ompcely ytbe Covent wel. 14200, The ane sal nian ssdeling hse. ana ual samp per wor Rs 104" 45 The nds ee lol oe Felt Parr lo mora es ee same es 1d conn, However the ur loans mit aes Palle pare were 2 over ° “he Commision a ned ser ate dated 1552055 am he Dra Ee schning hr lone of overt romain varius Pali Pai co many ral arene bene [5 Samer [Ree | ea OT i ore [ister decd | marcy et ecoaae ‘ona a= T a 1 ae Naa ges A Sa RT ee Fine 2 aa oa oa AE SE ead Faia Shams 7 iar | Bear ]—— [eater i na a a TS oT] ene Fame a a Row 5 Rs a ayaa aad aoe May err oe foe ans | ais oad aaa ft Fare Diag roa SORE Ea Raa Sama Fam at 10 maha 1 Cope EET Tara, ates Genera ecw, art ian se 18 lorepoening fe in hs mater wool be point ve xk a he reson, cogniion 2d fancy of otal Paes a per he esing wines, The a ‘Te Pobicel Pres ae wae wh the Hhcon Conia Insc ander sein 208 ofthe Repent of Pee A, I 5 Fr epost aes, a scoot ge he sons of pla pry ooo esate wih be BCI under sen 28 ‘+ Pan 164 of he lain Spo Resevaton & Allowent) Orr, 196 ‘empowers ECL spend rte he again of pata pay fo ( 4fan ke vl decane tices of he Comision o aie AS per Sse Cot gent Common Cast -V> Union of Ini (AIR 1W98SC306, EC empower under Arce 24 fhe Csinsion we mae ch Pala ares i ele of emer cued by in oman ih {otha de Poli aren bt scx wii 90 ay ater onl esis nie of Lok Sats ad wn 75 days he eof AMeby Unde Stes 296 of te RP A 2 Pasa Pay mga pe ‘clin eps cnabans eed ys exces of 2000 ay ee +The comntos made oh Pale area sat fh case Tat, forte rand ene. 4+ Reson of Pll Pie vee yh provi of lc Spas (Resa and Alen), 186, ich an dere CI wc Ale 526 of Cos ad wh Re 5 10 of Be Ca of Eos al, 16,0 wore foe speci, eecien fe alltmet of ymin wed msgion of 49, The Poa Panes cost on fhe mos npr Mss a2 conser fepecry- Prof Hall) Last is clase et "Gar of Ps” has wed en rata, hugh oops Acsrog to him he eof orate Ste a pa the rary spe, Widoa Poll Paes, di woud be ao mene af elaine repr ens ina poielysusticery mane. T ute in Th et daca Sn bl pon tepid ingore these osc the papa by party the werangebent of ts Sty he part may bebo serie By saying tat pres arene he bac ton whch people ate te ote ovata nthe “nfs weer a he ‘thr Sa ere et be ame election poems moe ren than oh is cary ose theo rt and to preset nates othe ch a Se accepebie the csebdy esha leon the poe adits ascn Me Lowes pase, a hereof eas, From he mas fens 1am bl by white etre eves cones out hoe eg est ile meth general aceptance "I rps peso cabot Hot Mee i caning sas tant ew tthe ee pen sich be voter ao SL mind 1 per eae to put flrard or coon candidates who elton hemes with sie. Since opponents wal de the same, ‘Se Mumrae thertye bens yous ae 2 mas ad econ that woud ‘there echt sume sme cies and At “What a fast cera that without pares thee would be we mane ise w ening he popu decion sedr ow) a sear ns able Tig ineprned ar pais oastacry” , 50, Allon deosris peiton3pr yte sue Wwthvo3 in th USA. ad some es wih gle Pll Faris Ue ad, The Pate Paes mbilze bi olin acid ti sags an bb 20d cone es wo frm goverment. No enc cm xt oe ee Fei Pare. An ory ie doesnt hare de sce he ove igh lcd sete a hp be pao he gore eto eng @ membeo«Ful Puy Hs andes of lepre nso Ms bp of Pata ary Begin wt, as, aug he Pals Pars atte ces ofa danocacy opal te democrats. Tis ely esc Prof ih a aha ep a eaten of Pale eh ces cf acouy ale mais ge stipe Be pote spins a Bele by fring 2 severe fhe coke wil elo bean geen sy at 6 Pale, Pay, no esc fh cn imparts ht ey ej a te Pal Pars veto gs in ar eur ick caraes poe an ef, ug ath canons nd sory arangenens 50 Oat they cn FL tele st os repesntng el SL, Tee Poel Panes, or ample play aca ela he gullet of ges om pond of efocion. As pr paggh 2 of Th Seb, Member of» Hous nag any oil Par canbe sued cts cesses. Paap, 2 09 fA enact ao 2 Diagaiication om ground of defection. ~ (1) Subject the provsns of ‘aragrapn 34nd 3 member of Howe belonging ny poll pr) hal be ‘Eoquiied or ng member tie ose (i See 0(bea ylemary given op Be members fc pata party » AE he votes oats fom ving in mck Howse ener way ‘Bcian iad by he poe pat to whch belongs by any person arty bored by ln thirbba tna big I he atthe por pratson of Sch ple yorgr gen a aur and sch ing ar abtentin has ot bet ‘She yc ip, tony wn a ot slant ate perp of is sab parapraph @ an dicted member of 4 Hoe shall be dened to tog 0 the ic par any by wc ea et as cana for eon such mee » _sneminted member Hows sal, ~ @ where he a mene fay pail pry ent dat of i ‘minaton such member be deemed ebony to ch pol ar o in any ter cb dexmedtBlog tthe pal arty of ‘th became thee may Be int ems a member bore expo ‘Ron om te date on wie aks seat ster camping th he Fequecens oF [ile rath ene may bear 1. 2 itl meer te or ec ere an ‘cana stp yan altel par hall aiid for beng a the Hoae the is yea party sich ele (3) A'mmiosiedmonteret «Howe sal edges fr beings meer of the net nan plea prey afer espa fs mont rom he ate eh eter het fer comping with he eens fie 3, thecasemay be aie 18" Wemyss neat of easy povisns ns egal Seton 24 of te Reese of pl (RP A 191, enone he Elec Camino EI wo reps Poa Pare fr se pups of hs Act tm her wordy tat such retain «Poca Party cannot pape athe decrease, Su cin 1) 0F 0) Any seca or ay of irda ces of nia allo eal pata par and lnteaig to aval sl ft rovsos of ths Fat sal ake ‘plctan to he Econ Commision for reir © pla rt or arSsh Rater nunc f is power ude Ariel 32 oft Cans ed ih secon 2A of te RP Ac 186, and es 0 an 10 ofthe Con of com Rae 16, te ‘lesion Commision as sued te Kena Sys Resereon& Alsen Orde, 1968 “Ts One a ben frp fhe locos he Lak Saba an the ete Asenbles of Sa and ine eat of coda f ich Hct oa ad cet vmhamer an fr "he spectienin, seri, ake 2 alloment of ambos fore eon of PP", Te ont ps down conons for recent Nats tes and Ste Fas ‘The Els Common ls sol Nana Stat Pica ares dep 8 of et Ti ne vides oe of sal 0 recog Pltod Pasi, Pa 16 of he ner nove be Commision sped Sethe pric of engin pol pay fs aurea the mal eo ‘Sodio li ltl econ an isos he Comision gor pra 7 of te ont, Eecize Conminon ci le Noto: int Gute of Ih eb trent it spelying he Neral FariuStte parts ant he symbok Teeny mac fr tem 1 cna ue Gaane Netconnect of econ Poll Pres an adds of er esd A At his ge wold be waft ays te com of icuion Me De tet. tour ew i fing ac ely emerge (@)LeptGenral (Go) athe Poti Foie ee bling Hacks of consi eo (0) ac uner Ten Sede af he Consinsoe, a Plt Pay ct ive 3 Menber ofthe Hose uf eet cheameaces, (© tata Flic Pay gud tbe eter ty he ElaionConnison f ia seer eon 208th agmatine At (@Socunder ton 28C of he RP Ac, 195, Pil Pury see bet ‘open frend Fl Year Econ Commis of na in eset of nmin ced by neces 2000 pes rm any pe Conmiaions i exces of 20000- pees eet fom nen-Govramt 4e(0 ati sume of i poe andr Ai 24d wth ection 294 tbe RP ‘he 1954 eS B10 ofthe Cond of lato Pa 1, he on ‘Commission has sed Becton Sebo & Alsen) Ore, 188, der wich een apo ae loud to varius Nase Tel (Sac Elesion Commision cn suspen or wih weogn of expat poll nity Jn he aunt of woltce of prveone of eon Symbols Anza) One 1965 (@ Conca Ifo Commins oder ued 2342008 dctg he ‘Poca ues lel nce Tax Rens lsh lad eg come ih. (ep inanca @ » © @ w hte Land &Dewhpmen Ofc of be My of itn Develo hase lange ens of fan in Delo vous Pt Faris ee of costo = at she Deore of ss, Minar of Uan Derdopman, bas abet sccm nD sos Pls Pare nil ba concn tat Poli Paes ave etn cing and ged wal wt eempon war seco 124 ofthe Icons Ts Act orl a name hse Sn bon nc aning Pcl Pus y way of fie ie ‘ml fa ad na Dowd fn Ging eos & that cosas Petal Paes eae eps of cra alls by she Het Commies, eof ie ie fects. Secon 20 fhe Ae die tea fv = pic uo meas ay autho dy ann “Ceernment abd cnet by or ander the Constnions yy ther aw made y Parana: ‘yay oer iw made by State eae: 49(W)——_yamienton ed or mae by the appropriate Goverment, ad ‘ds ay —_Badyed comraedor substan finned: ow Gomes rpnton mara anced (© Got bye pve the pepsi Goverment” 6 Tetsu bedi ewe eae poll are Ive ingen ‘eich wou guy tem be ab uberis in ang of 5c 2) of ‘igo nemazon TH Ack 17. ee qe obvi hat out of he many ways x lic ny cn be ela or one, ne prove (0 (and (8) above woud st elt ase oie ars, They have ot oneal consi ya under Cosson nr by say ara made yPatament oe Sue Lepore tbs ond ‘onal by any sepia govern. We hve 0 eamie the poll pries wud Gey nr te emai pooner Me ex bees wae a cnr by a) sei ain ld ker mae by 28 ‘npoptae govern a prove (his presen Hove, priest ‘> amanber ht they Dae Ben DOM no exsence it pliant onl level pale pre ye Eleon Como Ia hay eng am 1 ast of eels, pel te eng eg ac con fm ath Incl ens ad ete companies and ae get compte cee eG Ot ‘ber scams Ta cer ipa bate Bt Acoust te poll piso scout fi cognton by the Beton Commissa of ha eal eve pala asst commn sol on wi cms ca cote eos. Ths ‘sc wih he ter fis paar prove (bt ts, nts pale scan be ado ave ben conc yh gin ye Eee Commie of, 2 ft ada te eublshment contin of 5b) a ton by sprite vent Se Mavng dhs, he ot isin ander which pope cn be ined 1 what proved i ecm 2). Acorn w hs poi, ay 2am ‘ovenestleriuen Wh bean ne, dey or mee, by find oid by te agpcprategoveranen woud heme ee ary fe he apse of We Rg tfrnace Act Now he qurn whi ee oil pi ae ing sans Samed, acy oc ides, ty fds provided by the aeporne oovem Bo hep i the ae hae pe ose pn nor of dass posta, Whie he ons ve bse hth an ad alge vie hse pla partes ihe nto cpl at Del api eer a the Sins andthe complete nea tax exemdon oid em wood aan 0 sabsanal ste pac pes danas hve sen eu ht whee ene ey ghee ceed amb Cel Gave al Dayan ey ‘sbi uc. Whe tre hate xpreon seth ee eae in the Right notin Ac umber of econ the pes ct ve hd hat “abs ang’ edo be jy Eacig” Ines west as be idence af sae fang wih snot shad” of such noe-gonernea es © eng te oh teat of i pra provisn Kerpig hin ew, tse he ‘angle nd ingen oes end he lial pail ancl 9 sani as. 59, ‘The Deh igh uti dein dtd 145.2000 a Ka har Cooponve Lh Vi Rae Cand Boe (2 (6) 61292007 a W.2(C) 7702000) Ba epee he ‘The espzaon “and inde he Sec Maommnes de which nave he Soin flung hse word ed bot al bint dion ts tat pede tow nds The word lacs” general nested in ‘ty inno eae mening we prs ne a 60. ne ad dcr) High Ca a a cae 2 tm coma the RTT Atay el be hat dy wih ether for ‘he purpaes of Ale 12 aoe body charging pe fancies fore purpose ‘Are Za afte Cnn iat lb 4p schory” wn he meaning of ‘Een 20g) of be IT Act To state tera wie 2 “bedy” whch te ‘Saw or te pps of Artie 12s “hoe curing pb fans {urn of Are 2 iyo asver ie dsriptnn of ube sub wr of ‘ecb athe de RTT Ac the mere at at ac bod mer wl ake ot ‘ine defon o autriyeder Secon 20 ef eT Ace61. may ow be pene alle 6 eu decisis oft High Couns an hs “2 -coamision mis ep= (adios OlmpleAsoiton nd ahr Vs Verh Mak & cs (WINE) No. {702007 he Del gh Cou nsdn Ged Snr 2010, at nan Ode Assoc ie ple ary eden 2). Theva parguph ted eo satvng regard to the preeminent postion enjoed by the 10A, a the sl “eet ote tr or ring en bee ‘TEvObrmc operand wth he poner snposestnclonr gaint stds “en mai rests a ned or ba a ian ev uch ses spr pram, rae fr eeay nt 3 ‘vet factor The OA oh na regretted coy ate TOC heh gto a alfling bey whi tr et Sts cea spre emp a kan Opp er ea ib ‘ney iret a al erat dana ev eprs The eau rors fined yo ec ae yl at hog TOR satan ‘ema neremen naar nd mangement it horn ay pb font On cnr thang he rere net tga nce set. aod TOR ependh of ich mount id od nt A ‘en publ stor” under he mening o at epreion de he Ace™ (0) nthe same edge, th eh Cut ae all he San Schl epic sudo. The lent agp era aloe: as ace err, grat by the Government vain the aac a pc nds even en to rat organizations, unless roan be par af cera publi py af sme or Hee yal acount te ronan he ane a 21 ces were vn whe sol wou any sat rear A ely Privat toa! would have been ander an slain forum fhe me Some erst ‘The ones having admit cles emploer of he (Coal Government con hardly be horse m+n po de ‘ran wold ot maser ay perme casio or ude rile of he ‘Ccmancon “Te beth sols recerags en arturo 1% hh ‘Stars than commercial banks body rac asumed a ears te Dene ‘oe na fer omarion on comidraon ofa the above faces hs art shat the shal {ute seal ements of began oer organ ne Seton 2 a th ee whch anata Sane y the Cem Govern vearis department nd genie Ite therefore, covered by therein ofthe (wm dein nd 2242010 in Amaro Wile Chndigu Ln Tens Aon (Ge No. 111200690107, Canal lfraaon Comision ld Candie Lawn ‘emis Asoo be pals aubosy. a9 cf he adrenal low 1, ‘The gravure fue above Jets tha fr pate aye spay tc bc tr, tre cn Eran what thw be fang bythe oppropine Govereent ting cnet a secon o fe pablo sear rer Scala” Tera of te above Jedgnent puresary of Debi High Cour, sper te {sent caso al the freA age propery ha een placed 3 he perl of {ECiA‘Gy te Chandigarh Adminoaton a 2 mtn ren of S100 pet ‘tum Bese, rat af aoe apes was ae gent CLTA in F 20008. ‘Condy CLTA fast fle howd 2 scon of the tty by vay paring tel the Bedding ans ple there hl that CLTA sue hacer” (0) tn ster dain dated 2432011 fs Prep Banat Ver Cig Chi, (Caius (le No. CIOLSIA2010000100, te Cen Infamsce Cnn al at ‘be Chang Cb wa pul aur. The a fas hs se wr hat a plot ad msg 3085 es af ws led ot ote Clb oe et Re 08300 per moka wel, 2072005 t 1872010 wih wma ace of SK The Pace Depart of (Cash Adtran bat sid efor he Common at the nd a wt ot par wh he make rex Caney te wait of eansune, he Cooma tod ‘odd ht Chandi ah ws uc aor ander secon 2), Pas 8&0 fe “3. Weave no eee a epee rom the Face Deparment fhe ‘Chandigarh Admiisratn der the signature of te Jen Sees, 2. hi ear i afresh he bls he Chandi Ch eae rowing he pb seer saw fing ae ron sch es = Eerste conden tn ew he pb vies ting rod ip te boi, the sd bois can at be ema commerce Dat ‘ths reaon thereto Chanda Cab fed e200 per moth ‘th eet 2422000 wth aoa nese 33 a ou tle a Inet ere tha ober smarty sted ods ke Chandar Gal Cb and ‘Chandigarh Goll Asaclaon wich re ab prong be poe eres ane ‘een kept par wth Chandar hub whe eters theft ff ‘hoe we conser the Chandigarh Chip commerce en Ge reat come! ‘ ootbe ropes tS 460 per math Keeping in vow the ban care {Be iy ro bing charged om the Chaniarh Cio wt tp wh oe ‘asked et. Furher by charg the ena tver rat ll make ay ‘Sar tate Chandigarh Adnan indice soe the proton = Steet ing rendered the Chandigarh Ch frigate emt a he a a nd oh {lng nray danced for pmo of pbc sre the Chania ‘Rdsinaraon the same squarely covered unr the deo a pee ‘ary tied under ection 2 (0) a te RIT AC, 205" ‘Adminerao. In te view of the mat, ve hold tha the ‘Ghanigarh Clb pub auheriy” ws? (af the RT Ace. enc, he ‘Gib managnent & herby deed pat place 8 mecha fe ering et) ners, 2 Amt Matin Ves tad Inman Caac8 le ‘ICME 0090000615) dee 12201, te Coemie hel tnd Ietin) ‘Gees ube unt oder seibo 20). Tete fc a hee wre at 40D sre ‘of pine lan ws gen cn perp lest IC oat eps f Bs. 8A per ‘apenas on 2241960 been the Posen of nan The yy et yale ‘by co he Cn Goverment Re 4 wh is emaneducangd dog st fe cade, Inte oft tC a ald a flows = XVI, tn view f the sve dca i ey emerge that 3 ge chan of land measuring ares ws albedo UC i 160 0 2 ‘premium fa 14240 ny evi 22 cancion ra The agreement betwee the pats expres speak conceal laine nd Farther, THC ws reared ay rent fe 4 er yar nthe Cea Goverment hi sat ba eed unchanged dra ast 52ers. Tis a ‘ant nave of tern being wominlonesinal nar These ae ‘Geary eis the Central Goverment nde ane HC. Toe RTT Act deena define ub Hang The exponen {ani pin oto pic Ten Commins Puna) src se, Caren th a at ge ck ‘tian was lated IC 1960 he very eat of be cphal y f Dab at Spemiim of cea and se codring he aha HC pln ‘est a ny Re U2 per yearn the Corl Government ver hse ee,nour opinion, mans net substan ancig of 11 by he Cente ‘Govern oe ew of te mater ol hat IC a Pull Autry ‘de son 2 of che RT AGL (ot) Yer wir dacs of hs Common neko be aed ot is comes, 1800 Se Mis of Ind alta Du Pabe Sehoo, Rei by DDA wt a gly ssid ao Re. nr pe ace ebay, 187. Agee Paton mang 10,000 tas, a ln DP, Rein ray rsd o pay bn on aye eine goad rea of ely RS. 10 pr eam The ue bee te Commision vas ‘wheter DPS Robin an be Gemalto nts of sen 2) fhe RT ‘Ack Vide eson ded 2482011 a Fe Na, CICSGC2OIDOIISGAD, ths Commision el at he a ed cams fh DPS, Robina Pe Asbsiywdkr secon 20) The esa ger by he Commis ie mcpeta ah pa exc Coming te soe cal mat of st ind one an a pat 2 of hasbeen ie sl a ocean ae cf Ri et a nd "00005 ofl gly asd nol pnd ea of Re per Aan by ODA. The Seal cua he gree, cul and rego te Deh Sons Buca Ac 173, Rae 3 wel nde doa of frat i he farm of epost heDuecuro be Dette of An, the Adit and ‘coed ahr fm the Caz Govern, tad diced sive. ‘The inc of Edvaton hs spp wo noise ey Managing Cami ot te School tb eesring poston of ower of msing ao te Ses ving comet over be Reson Sts” (2, The question bf th Commie wha INCAICE UP, CPI, CP, NCP BSP can be ldo ePae Audorites under ecco be RT Act. The clas ane asad alowing he papal gous to pret Coinon bl tat be fet Poel Pe at ul boi vi; 0 w w Ind skal ace yb Cel Gover Pounce ie dy by te Pel as ‘Constante porns vesting Plc! Paes i ih a aes ss62 Nowe wi ne ese ae ony oe ‘Suan anc of aiid Presb the Cental Gov se Taecomplant he veep at Poca Fas ebay anced 1 he Conc! Government mile ways The tad foros method of mast mac aloeen of ge wos of lend in rine as of Deh te, eof 8 onceiceal ae lfomaon maple by cpt Shi And Banal sped in 3 ae frm a p18) of i der nfomaon ae Da sot de Comision by LD apr ete given inp hs ode, 65 Even along forte main of nar ne estima of we ofa aod 12 asus ol pane by comps Shana we Dave reese eee at ad as bon led tage canes ats The ee veo ae pope inthe pe aes nor he lade Eve, we soggy ele ht he emi and be se ret being chad fom he Pla Pre dare ft tee value oe opis. This, incr comedies, aan nd ica wen aed he locome a eng eye By ee pa pct, wou amput w ssl 55 Wemay so tet a athe cmplianstave prof oman Bf the ‘Commision eat the adele a Del by te Catal Goverment. We ae Infomedia ch slots Dave also been made ate Stile pile by te Sate Covent. fs. hs only refers th compo concn tt te aprpete ‘ovens haven sno Polite ais in bv, 7 ater met of fencing of Pcl Pare by he Cons Caveat i ones of fous etl bass on ene tes. Inman given by th empath Bava ois rp ened at pa 17 fs ar wh nw ote pee The Duct of te sas, Min of ta Deropmet hat lo cnbeted alloca ot ou popes Ge pol pasos el Ms. The et eng caged me clas shown nh at con lead le, Th eal af ee pee séathe open makes oo bss laced ere ws. Evens, sony ei ha he ek ‘ing charge om Pll Pare ost il tee a af thse opis. "Tseng al cons he det facing of Pata Pai. a Ofte vrs bent ite cleverness pli pat, the wal exeaptbn fom paymet fname ex ot et icomes, vey obvi, ‘oes theo pron bea Seton 1A oe come Tax Act eas lows ny cameo 1y which chargsbe under th ead come oust roveny a ince fom oe sare pl ge rn lca bY Way of ‘lua Couns reed ty pba par from at psen sa at be {fed teal icone te pris ear oh plc ar (sch plea party keg nd maintains such books of evan an ter dcuments ‘Suid enable de asesing lier proper dace sna her (yin snd ttn send of ck comin st ne nd reo (othe accounts of sucha pola party ar aude by an accountant define in he ‘Splnation bbw saeton of ec 20° Provided forter that Hf the eeasrer af sch paca party ony oer peas ‘Shoredy hat poll pris eal also sia repr ane subse $Teseeson Cathe Repeat he People A151 fa he ama en ‘rege under th cn halle tae fo that pla part fr such cal 62. Since thse poll preheat ail any cane he ect qn of ‘mney the Cena Govern! as foe in th pres ant bows worked a, spell, However sce he ll face of ll ee pla pais woo ace em in te igs bof ce a et 30% of tr a eae weal eB obec as acme ax bt for he wa exeapin ge eam by ew BY seple "be x police he xa oft asi hon aan och pee flowog le ey Tax Payable Tax pape Tax payable Tar payable Ll Mascon vee Most sea “ae s7‘awe Jerre) ear) .— ae co Lm Thny per cot fe nse wc hepa pai wl ive vise id by wy af noe tt as ben eu i el our te Catal Goverment No one cn pte Hat ts fe baotal Gncng, ough iin). Ad wo ise cocina lunes of ad ad bangs in re cos the ial pil 2d, ayn eee ete, ot dic ee, teal amount sd dc ancinpding of de poll prs useable, On bal of be lpi, hispid hace ence ama so berm ‘of Gig, ogo of he seme hy Save med at ck cae at xenon ae oly eee © many chrale sd sono wo green frvmiatons aoe couty, Toe, acon 1 de, Hf Ee MATE 2am eveemenalogiason ae 20cm! be pbc aubaies re 6 30| yh pli prs oud Decne a. We aot ep hire. Thre ba re diene beeen te ax Wempen ge 1 cacable sed nega ane fvennel ranistns and int gen he eps, The emp ao be mere ily cons fl or xem gen hae estes ely f ‘hey pre he bes col inh epee has, be te meer of stoi sd pen ee heya soci ts el hy ate prise tt, Tee eh cao a own nthe nae Tat Ae we ewes ‘mat comly iter wor ay se ne geemmet eatin ae fod st be righ betes rpg he wx exempt amount nas te ha bc ne ate recive chars ot comply wh ans, Ge Ince comes ajc 1 an soins Wid pay. On the exer and he ‘exeato nes be pel ass compli, eal codon beng hat they mask ‘ep ie Eaton Commision fn ee) yeu, deaf te census wo ome Rs, 20000 or et th pli ay concen Ths he ple pais sy en nc wfc exam tom py of come 3 ao je ‘ayer chars ne rit n- goverment easton. Se71 hr been ae ele tat Flr ii oe eon ‘Allinda Radio. Th mous spe ye State his ead AIR fr LoS cone = 2009 respec of aus Pll Parks epic in ps 4) of on. Sty he ee npr 18H). Tee acuta besa a hy cont ote ay of Palit 72 new ofthe sav, wea of he onc tat Conal Gover is coined sified sig of Pola aes ue, 7 owe, the qtetion rman wert om meng can be bald 1 be ‘sonal oxncog in wea of seca 2) the RTT Acer Rand Bh of eb igh Caen jogs hed 74.2010 nan ypc Auciton -ro-Veereh Male tnd Os (WC) No A760 as seve ae expen Tae Aur’ eto Be ‘nerd ean acter, Pus 4 of cera enna blo = 4. Now, if the parametary itn wa to capa the ee of the ‘tino pu ary od pot resets the far ates weaned in ‘etn pre bt compre ether die rane te et etn ‘carmen oe hohe ecw oe ad {Stn ‘cab te conaling nee “ante ref lf oreroment td “tai ty i” ic. a irenon Soy ved," eee {i NuwCoverpentorunizaonsesandally” nae) zeta Inteely by fnds “provide bythe prepa" Goverment” Seve be conse unde or sable by anodteaton, Sed by the ‘ent Er ne ch wre te nin vc inane comedy noon, hae by espritce tk a = nt Seale eaten oe Soyiieee Liseee ements ES oo ee eee Sat cathe eee pees eae Sat Sandel rca = 46 The em “omg>erent rnizaton*has not been wed a the A Ie 4 Commeny sept exrsin. Apparent, he expres wae ied he Est {inet the dfinton sf “ermal NGO” (NGO) im Rehan 2188) of [ECOSOC on February 27 1950 as “any nrnatal organi ht at fool tena eo Acoring mgs he {sovernmentl rguiatin (NCO) ert arse wey ace ‘tring to legally contd, son goverment paca een by Tatra or balers wid "ne parupaon or epracaston of Severe In cs ck NCOs ad yw rly Oy {everumenty te NGO mains ks Tomgmertenal ats on eas [verunent restates rom memberaip inte srgneaon Unite te {Su ltrgotmmental npn, "or qorranesta rgb erm general cbt tu tpl dln many rons te eso Seine nc tl sy on ed wy et Sepia a dpe germ cout See sa ot eaoneed wth Naty exece beng ms mst sco he {roa of hs stablsteent or cmon tvogh 2 gerne eid ulead st ae The sl ei cn wuld ete le the “asta ancing” eer pst Scion 20) New gv ‘rgunieatins could be ay in: restered vce, copra see, tts omnes ned by gare o ter ic al ete bt nt ‘Stblshed or contol in Wir menageneat or sdmintraon by Hat at blond” 74 AS he quoton of ‘nbs Gone, te De Hig Ca in fe sat udeneat Sa hel a ney et appopsine to dese wht ot 22 ‘Organs asaya, cy ins, by Iehaben cone tang i peentge ems a eon 0 tal dg of he <0. Tis cour heros, condudes that what amounts 0 “bran” {inncng asette sigt ated top Tormaan of tae icin, amin ih ea ee aie os ‘Tate prentage a Fd not major” Sania ae {i inpermanct one are ot sural Equal, that the san ‘tpanzaton notCoulledy and is autenomaar i relat Indy the ‘nce of magvenmet‘rfniraen meas that i lnspendest any ‘mano of govern! cote in evant management Tat testatin doe ao perlrm — ne e-dminunypeorms— “yb” sai, {wea ot be tera as og a eect or fntng acctageek ed sf jecian afte pbc or sear ger sce us To eno sek funn inde he osu may Bests vehicle rte eae oeanens fly fallen pls. Ths vw, bet eoeege ae ‘tomes, wou ny nian, lang thee pbb asa ‘Asin: vee tas btn len by he Kara lg Co io Baglre Teton ‘Aor Limit Vs ~ Renal Inoaes Cerin (WP 12076208) The operative rnb ope ed 92200 ext bo “et be oaied hat a6 sacred cater, wordag, “sn government fzatsaon tan fiancd recy onde” recall be op {no we. Whathr the no-geveroment ranean by subscntaly Roce cl that & the cach flow vould come free Govrent ape ot indir which woud cesar mean that he pin eae he ‘sugveromentoranisaton Inthe cate enh eb need tts Ent te greene wuld cancannly gui sn ths te peo ERC ei inert ch or ee ‘Srahhegurec eek fr nwt ee 0 res of rine agar an argue by ping errs aus Snot wld enn handed eer ‘The Lad ae bred at Sey eet tn aa itt ec Si yc rae ae ce ee Sunt cee eee Sonos eee Sri oee se eee Soe ete ‘The game of te aoe deme at or pia eit gly wo es abe hry, isan ecg dv ot ean msiyGnacng Wha stp ht be ‘nding by th appropiate Govern schoig fk edo ein of pubic sou ger social gut”. The tof he ove jatar of Dei High ‘Cer, pls he preset ise. Lge mace of es of eb av ben plc ate pon of he Plt Paves iguston a exon wi, Bees, ge ‘Gove ommodons hae ben lsd he pin of Plt Paes a ugly orchon ie they besoin ni eae em. Teaco Tax uae gana tad he fe ine AUR Donat he ne of sens ao hs stanly Conti the nig ofthe Boal Pars by te Cenzal Govern We bre tere ne hein acne ht INCIAIC BP, CIO), Ct, NCP and BSP have eon bsnl Gandy th Cea Goverment hare, ty hl be pbc sites voter ise 2) eT At Peformane of Pate Duy “Te Pll Pais eh bod of ur pliy- AS cbvedby Lsk “Tei of te deat se it gen east tons ae contd on ary st, The Pala Peis ele some robles ne emt han aes nd pee sion he ‘ehh ny be scoala cure The ing py rs eeopment game he Deo pal agend cone fr be goth an eeopme of ty fhe on otal ares afte Use of czas, dciy inne, ey Concenble wap and ee cot eniged tpevemig pie day. 1 if, pera thy bce ble tthe abl 17a olla! Pais oe he gu nso fhe mae cosinal St, Thee sey ple nn nd se-gversme. Th whee es he fc at inp af being non-government cameo wil econ lec xe cf govenml pw old be arb at easy ie od fr al Se rs tate got fo Pls Pris, we, ay cote al te il rps eS, 8, tne WP. NaA2076 of 200 dae 92200 he eof Bana inertial eenttn tSaaia nsemica Cotnios te Kea Hh abs a> “4 pubic auhoriy may beds pean oan ol nas wid inks ep ote bent ofthe pub and ot fr pvp, Kot ey ster bay's open aed at « pbc euhoriy o body and the ely ofa pac urd ray mary cringe story cnt oe coring femurs of an ary ab bing 0 pb ator, & Po cet cr camber ae dy merger tobe pac ady masta Be ce I sre dau or an sary ea pube etor” Ha Be mae ate or ele of lg eurced fre bret of he oe” 629, ‘The py olor atime era spon cane. a Unies fn Asecion af Deapeic Flos & AN (AIR 202 SC 212, Supe Cou as ‘soph one pty of esos ne ong wet ‘re maa the py of eins in parila lng amare a the ‘rot ose he Common can at the candida bee he expenditure [ure ty the Poca Pars atl thi anparency he poco ef econ ‘would net taney a ante ne mcs ction wt recom In ¢ ‘oul bv basset Hh ‘eoresot hint Psamet bre laws to ind hs Uber and oper may Be 1, Tee National Comision to Review he Waking of te Contin eu ‘uit nM 2002s canorde ht Poll aes wa ido canes ‘be mode bes a poperaneary ant fh amen hy send Camo Cate (A Red Sac Union In) (AIR 196 SC 3081) he Supreme Court as et th the cee ant expat acd by the Pals! Pate and a Il emphisis co smsprny ca econ ung 2 Theo ofa mat ow hese pnd cared Peel asd by te cates in he pct of acca These lel rooouncemenss usa commend rogsiely hgh lvl of tanpveny he anconng of Poi Fats ee tr dog ae 5, Wemay so ad hah pone be Cons of nds at sein alls ‘Stes: JUSTICE, ec emai anpoleal LIBERTY of gh een el, ath fd wei an EQUALITY of wns and of orparansy. Coedely he pe of TL Act ant orth rice ne fom of nsec ad acoy tn She whinge rye ay. Kl aso cent anode’ and oonin compscn a to Wt RvR sad ter seamen acount © the over Nedsy,Plicl Paes re impor pola isaoes tcanpay ‘ellen ering trmgncy a pabe Me Poca ares conics per eb fnctoe wich die rats of gvemsece ad sccm Gvpoet inthe coun. ee ae 634 nvlew of te ae lal feos rome by Plc Pas ante das of te igh Cou ext above, we cone at Pei Paes queen ae Pte Aube sede ton 2) the RT A ‘Constaonalegl provisos vn Poti Pores ih ihe a abe, 8ST pein fave abo amended th Poca Pres ve consol dea "ahs sn nbs nhc neo eel be ue Abate. Tee rien ae as, Pata Paes te ged beeps wih th BCI ude secon 294 of RP. ‘Aa 18518 Canal Legian, An acoso orb et taf pale Py on ‘ston, ECL evade Pla Pais ert Eeon Syl Rept sn Alcnen) Ore, 86, ahr eplraton, The BC lor et expen ae "oy ae Pet Pare in he crn Conus he le f Re 20800 above reced fom ay en ea Campy by Pals Fay ae ei bend Bt nde con 296 be RP et. ECL vn wh peiendenc, ton and cou of deco wie Arle 324 he Coton, ECI alo vested wt he aunty suspend or whe sop falta payin cen cotgeces. Mere agony, Poll Paes cn resauend daguiiton of Mantes ofthe Hose In cea oguces ender he Tosh Schade, The conten is that” loesald coiinlitansay powell Pues tng hem nh ambi fein 26). 6 Wein he ore nisions que comping and wena poling ova tie ‘Stand of Poital Parties , 1. temayb read at be INCAICC snd he BYP hve me dso they xv nec Pb Autores une he RT Ac. CPIM) hs cod ome fom oie \Conmsion gating loam of ad wo bythe Cece Gover neta ems ad codon abst conceded at is Pb Aurty under scm 208) of he RTL Ack ‘Toe comets te sow pris av be ejected nh igh of gs edd eis 648 neresispy, he Coffe Dares Bean 2 consi snd. Wie St A Suni ie ed 213.2011 ado Sit Al Baal as ted tht CP be Ata secon 2), os er hn St Saar Rady, view nd 2432012 set he Comino, has ken he sd st Poll Pa do sal ie he mbt ncn 20) Ase sand of CP ang ts elo comment, {8 Mower he bison made by Sh A.A Te, cousl fo Nanas Congres ary eed eda wid a sme gh ese caneion th ei grt oe NCP Ging he eens on Naot Teles anf National Radi dot at ecu t ‘Senet mig of NCP a I poplar pce Ine mona te we Accoting w him, fer proving of decor ole of Poll Parks» somary "erent ns cos 2 saan Gti. Slay, leet poof ‘ssdSovemmen sro Poll atest oon ant ome ao ‘anal fg, Sima, ex enema ander secon 1 glo Peed Paar neh ov fhe sane a cae cored ms hang of Pll Pa bp ‘he Cara Goverment 5% Theepunens of Sh Tvar cnt be ace ate pt os prvsns sd te ce a eee heen an iy ve be ct. We may er dha Ms coment NC hs ren ean 55 ft wl funding um he Govern ‘he cnt be ace y be as ut pede ny ges ee st hie ‘in, Fat, souing tat se gue te, i coed Lalo be moon ‘womd dt NCP, bsg» Poel Pay, poms pb cons, wich dog with aber ‘so meso toe listo be Pe Authory un son 2) Sh eco conten of it Tv ht if Pls Pahl w be Pate Autos ten be pala als woud mally fod ee CPI wh nue A roles a eof ens hy vig ee and ey and cing sen oir poll fntnig, te out view, the Wliy of «star clam be ‘etna nyo thts of respon of spore mis. Obi amy eof ‘pn at rg he Pala Paiste ao TY Ai aly bree ot proc net cng. Rees wool mat a senting dems and éstathesaknsin of Av. Tha and get ee 52, view afte stove eine al ht INC, BP, CI), CPO, NCP and BSP ae ben stanly ane! by he Carat Govern dr ein 2 ofthe KT ‘Aa The cay ofthe le ing piel by es Plt Paes ner dcr ep ed the mae of dis pao by en so pot towards tbl race, ging ‘tem nh ait of sean 2), The contusion and el previo cased een ove ao po wd tl eer pubes, The rer of he Suge Bench of ‘he Cmnison in Compl No, CICMISC24080001 ad CICAASC2080002 ky ‘case a sald hac AICOANC, BU, CPM), CPL. NCP and BSP pub ores nds 2) he RT Act 98, The Prens, GeneaSeceas of tee Pale Faie a by dtl to ees cmos an he Apple Atots at eeaurso 6 wks ie. The (cr10s so ype wil spond the RT apenas xc th tei wes tie Bess, he PesensGrearl Sects of te ahve seisoad Pla Paes ae aso ecto comly wih prone f secon (0) ) of RE Athy wy of making elma ices on he suhjos meton ate idie. 94 Thecoopans dpe priest ecto, (Asap is) 41 stam ‘sora Commer ‘sees Canmiene (Seymads den) Cie frat Camm Aten ey. Atal pin of re hl be epi get spc ad aot of the cps, pscbed under te Ac, t2 ie Adal Reger of hs 6(Atak Deo Chats) i Secrecy (in) Ab Rega 67Armen hola ASLESTRACT OF REPRESENTATION OF TE PEOPLE ACT.1951 29A._ Registration wih the Election Commision of associations and bodies os Police! paris. — [1] Ary associaten er body of nidvaletaons of Inia cali Il @ police! pory ana intencing To avot Ise of the prowsons of hs Pat shat ‘make on apicaion lo the Becton Commision fork regitaton a: @ patical Patty forthe purposes of is Act. [2 Evary such application shall be made, — [al i the sociation or body is in etence ot the commencement of the Representation ofthe People (Amendment) Ac. 1988 (If 169], tin say dys nox! folowing uch commencement: {b) I the ossocioton or body lt tomed ater sch commencement, within tht ays nex olowing ha date of ormation, '8) Evy application under subsection (1) ral be sgnad by the chief executive Cofcer of he associaon or body (whether ich crafexaeulve olicer i known ef + Secretary of By ony other designation) ond preseniad to the Secretary 10 the —COimmisson er sent o such Secretary by tagvered post. (4) Every such appicaten thal contin tn flowing particulars. namely (o) tne name of he association or ody, (b] tne Staten wnich tenaarl offs suc: (cl he adres to which eter and other communications mec! frit shoud be {al the nomes ofits resident secretary, acu and other oftce-beoren: [el the numerical stongin of fr members cow F there ee eslegores of Ms ‘mombor, ne numeicalsrenginin gach category IN wether has cay local units 20, af what eve [al whether it is represented by ary member of mambers in either House ef Petioment or of any State Legilatute: 10, the number of such momber et members 7 (5) Me opeiicotion under sub-section (I) shot be cccompaniag by @ copy ofthe ‘memorancim or rules and regulations of tha cuociaon or bouy, by whatever name cold, ond such memorandum er ules ond regulations shal conta & ‘pectic provision hat the essocaton ar body shal beer hue fain and elegionce fo the Constiuion of ina os by law estabined, and fo the pincpes of soci, {ecularim ond democracy, ana would vse the soveceignly. nity and Integy tints, (61 The Commision moy cal fr such other raculars of i may dam ft fam the ‘uosiolon or Body. IP Alter consdoting othe petculr af ofeetald ins posession ond any other Pecessary and relevent focters and alter ging the representatives Of tho ‘sociation o body reasanotle oppertunty af being heord. ne Commision shat {decide enero regiser he asocicion er Body a+ ¢ potcal parly fr the arposes, >.of this Port, or not 30 10 reget and ho Commision shal commuricate ts Geciean fo me asocition or sy Frovided Inat na axocition & Body shall be regstered os a palical pory under ths subsection uniete the memorandum or rules ond regulations of such ‘socialon or bady conform fo the provisos of sub—secton (3 [6) Te daction of he Commision shall be in [9] Attar on ostciaion oF body hes been teabtered as a polfical party oF ‘torarad. any chonge in is nome, heod office, ofice-bearers, adcres on cry ‘ther material matters nal be commuriceled Io the Commision without delay. 278. alice! pares eniieg to accept contovtion.—Subiect fo the pronons ofthe CComponies Ac, 1986 (I of 196), every pical pay may eccept any amount of Eontrouton volusarty ofered to # by any pean er company ether than o Goverment company Provided tnt na palicol party shall be efgble fe accept ary contibtion om any foreign souce detined under clause [e) ef section 2 of the Forlgn Contibuton (Regulation) Act, 1976149 of 1978). Expionatin—For the purposes of th section and section 29C,— {e1 “company” means « company as detinsd in secon 3 [b] "Government company" means a company wii the meaning at section 617; [c] "conmbuton” nos ne meaning crtigned to tuner sacton 2734, tne Companies Act, 1986 [1 oF 1956] ard includes any donation er subEpion| cferedby any person fo @policat por ane (2) "pesenr Pas tne meaning osigned tot under clause (21) of sacon 2 ofthe Income-tax Aci, 1961 [49 of 1961), bu! does not meuce Goverment company, local auorty ond every aiicialjursiea parson wholly er paral ured by the Government 27C. Decleration of donation receive by tte polticalpaties |The teaser of & politcal porty ©: any other person auihotsed by the paltcal pay In ths behal! shall in each tnoncialyeer. prepare arepatin respect of he folowing, namely (c) the contribution in excas of twenty heviand typees received by such palical Pty tom ony person in hat francial year (o) the contin in excess of hwentythewsand rpses receiv by such pottical party fom compant other han Gavemmant compari in ral fhaneta yor. [2) me oper under sub-tecon (I shot bein such fom a may be prescribed. (he mat tc Src yo ur ncn fl es tale 9 fan fo phe pry cv obs gare cobutea bye ome er tnbetal bebe ne ue eae knotty atelmts nea fe ea vou Uneaten 1? ot ha heone rae Hal (a a WO) Be Comte Qaeria 54 see ot{4} whee the treasute of any polis! patty or ony oer paion authorised by the poijeal pay in ins behelt fais to som! @ Yepor under su>section 3) then, Fotwilancg onyining contained inthe Income-tax Aci, 196! (48 ol TP, such polical pat shot not be entiad fo ony foxtele under hat Ack 78A, Declaration of extets ond Hobilies I} Every elocted condte for « House Gf Porlamen! shal, within rinely days fom the dato on which he makes and fubserbes an oath er afrmation, accering fo th fer sel ev for the purpose in the Thi Schedule To the Constivton, for toting hs sec! Rh etner House of Ptiorant, fuih he ineration, relate o— [the movable end immovable property of which he his spouse-and hs dependant chen ae jin oreveraly owner oF benefice Ui Ns aoites fo ary pubs francis insttton: an Ui hi abies he Cerra! Goverment or he State Govenmant to the Chatman of ne Council of States cx the Specker of he Hause ofthe Pace, ft the cose may be (2) The nfotmotton under subsection (1 shal be furished in sueh form andin such manner as may be prescribed in the rules made under subsectn (3). “Bite Chatman of the Counc of States or the Speaker of the House of he People, stn case may be, may make nies for he purpoter of ub-zecton (2) (41 The les made by the Cratman of the Counct a sates of he Speaker of ho House of ho People, under subsection (9) ft be Ii, often at may Be aller they e mode, before the Counc o tates oF ne House ofthe *eope, othe cate may be, or fel pei of nity days which moy be compised none session orn Iwo of mote successive sexions and shal tke effect upon the expy of the sid Prod of hity days unos they ae sooner approves win or wahout mostications {Sr dsopproved by the Counc! of Slates or he Houte of he People and where ney {2 19 approved, thay shail ote efecto such approval in the fan which they ‘were 16d on such moatie form, ot Ihe cote may be, and whare they ar #2 Gsappoved, thay shal be of no eect. [5] The Cnaiman of the Counc of States othe Speaksr of he Houte ofthe People, (05 the Saxe may be, may crect that any wild corraveaton ofthe rules mode Under sipsecion (3) by an elected conciate fora Hause of Psiament refered To Insvsoction (1) may be deci wh in the same manner oso breach of eivlage of the Counes of Stator ortho Hovte af the Paopia, cee cave mor be. Explanction—For the purport ot thi section — {)"emnevabie prepeny" mecns the land ond includes any buldng or other Situctus attached To the land or permanent fastened #2 anything whieh is lil “mevable property" mears any other property which Is nt the immovable Proper and riludes corporeal ana Incarpeeal propery of ever deseipon: {i "pLbIc Rranciolinsittion” means © puble financial ireltion win the ‘meonig of section 44 of the Companies Act, 1956 ot 1956], re inclades Bank fi] "bare refered tain claves fi means— Bes Gasser(0 soe tor fn conte unio sation 3 he Ste Bonk of in Ac toss [uence ben hain the aring ones 0 # coe lef con 2 fhe tle bon cngs taco ans] At 957 8! 959) : [c} Ragone! ual be eootned uncer econo he eponal Ra Ronis At tora 70 [er coverpondng new bank nog he mening aon oh ke (60) ot {sclon Sot he arin Ruston Ac 14 (Oo 39 end [s| cooperate ant noun nearing xg oH soe ee olsen S| (ne tokig Reguon nl 9 (0'! 197 1 moda by Sb-daie oF Sloe cotton Soot tot Act on (i scopondar csr mecrs or ond doghios who rave no eprte meses Searing ora sre anal pend onthe sacle candste lore ons ‘e5ten ono wana 177. Account ef election expenses and maximum thereat) Every cancidote ot fn electon shel. einer by Rinse! er by his fection ager, Keep a separale ond correct account ef al expenciue in connection with ne elecion incured of ‘uthorzed by him or by tis election ogent bstween the date on which ha has been nominated ond tne date of dectoroion of he reat eveot both daies neha. Explanation |For he removal of doubt, isherety dactered that (o) he expencive incured by leaders of a polical pay on account of rave by ‘or by any other means ef fanspat fer propagaten presamme ofthe soles Powy shal not be deomod fo be the exponaute in Eenrscton wih the election Incured o: authorised by @ concise of hal palical party erhi laclion agent fr ‘he purposes of I subsection, Ibl ony expendie incured in respect of ony arangements mode, feces provided or ony other act or tng done by any parson inthe service of the Government and belonging fo any of he classes mentioned in ciwse (7) of section 123 in he dscharge ot purpotiod dchaige of ir ofl cy es mentioned inthe Proviso fo that clovse shal nat be deemed fo be expendi in connerion with the election ncured or autnarsed by © candidate or oy hs election agent forthe Purposes of hi subsection, {Explanation 2—for the purposes of clause [al of Explanation 1, the expression ‘eacer of 0 potical peri in respect of any slecion, Moers 1) where such polical pony Is @ feecgrted pallica gary, such persons net fexceesing forty number, ont (i where such goltics!pety oher than avecogrived police pet, such persons not exceeaing twenty in numb, whe names have been commute fo the Secon Commision end the Chet ect Ofc of he State bythe pica per o be lader er he uteses ot such eecton, win @ ptod el veven dys tom he del of he elcston fer sven secon pubahedin he Genet cee Ocal Gavel of he Sate, ene ay Basen ee ee eaerovided hot © pliicalpaty ray n the case where ony ofthe peters refered 10 Frcloure [) 02 othe cave may be, clasa (i ces cx coaies fa Be a member of ‘ich poles pay. by father communication fo the Baction Commision and the ‘Shor ttecteral Oftces ofthe Stes, svoHlute raw nome csng he period ending Streosietely before ter-2ight hows ending wth the hour tked forthe concion of ‘he lit po for such election, far tne name of such parson ded or ceased Yo Be @ ‘remet,o: ne purpotee of Sesgraing ne new leader in place (2) he eccount sha contain such pariculas, os may be prescribed, [a] the tote of the sold expenciive sho not excaed such amount as may be roserbed. 178, Lodging of account with the disict election offeer—) Every contesting Gnaidate ot on sleefon shall win ney days fom the dole of election of the SGuined candidate or if there ore more than one reiumes candidate ot the SSecton ond the dotesof ther elacion ote dfron. the later of these hwo des ‘Gabe wth the csc! clacton eficer on sccount of hs ection expenses which thal be a tue copy of fhe account kepl by him er by Rs election agent under section 77 “125A, Pena for ing tate ofidovt, ete —A candidate who himsel or through his ~~ Reps wh intent f9 Be elected in cn election =— {half ur information relating to subsection (of secon 3A: ot {h gine tte information which be knows of has reason to blleve to be f8: oF Ia} conceats any information, ee nomination paper delvered under subsection (7) of secon 99 of in his Ghidav! wrich &vequied fo be dalvered under subsection (2) of section 38A, os {fo cove may be, shall nobwitstancing anything cantines in any oer aw fr the fine boing in ce. be punihable with mersonment for @ tam which may exer to skmants wih fine, or with both 72pemeenys ‘THB RIOHT TO MFORDUATION (AMENDMENT BI 2013 at epi arnt 0. many eto 8, se 5 pimps Aah mnan(h te Rig epannccal semana anaes aR eum. jayantartonemnanditcropens tats Taoetaeerite ener taiihal 774Seeman nites ames areas See fd cachet segmenting Reta mannan te ie 7STkCental Information Commision ‘Avgust Kran Bawa ikea Cama Place, New Del-110060 NA cIoCoCRasONE “resent: Complainant 1, Shi Subhash Chana Agrawal 2. Prof gdp Choa, St All ‘Verma apd Svat Kapoos, (Gute representatives of Stand Bawa Intervener st Jan Respondents 2, in Natonal Congres (INC) Allindla Congres Commitee ates): 2, Bhartiya Janata Pay (BP) 13 Commanis Pay of ina (ass) (com; 4 Commanit Pary of iia (CPD; 5 NaonalistConges Pay (NCEP): 6 Bahan Sama Pany BSP) (alti respondents were sen) Dates of Hering 21.11.2004 and 07.01.2015, ute of Decision 16.03.2015 Order 4, The ae was ard on 21.1.2014 and 07.01.2015 ae antic Suir sued on 05.2014 (ENo,CICSMC201/001586 and COU) Uhde seton 182) of te Right Infomation Act, 2005 (KEL Ac). Te (lao was tat te Commision order of 03052013 had uot bee plemented Submlsone were made byte compliant, Sts Sesh ‘Chacrs Appeal ad Pro. Jagaeep Chola ahead representa cf aieSit An Barwa), The inervener, Shr LK. Ja, also made sobsons “The sponds i at tend te bags Background 2. __ttimay be eld that Sri Aga in appletion dated 16452012 ‘ad asked the Presidents General Secreaes oftheINC/AICC a he BJP ‘0 sty infomation, in al, eating o elec manifests, flinent promises, recs apd payment, proposals o Government and Flecon Commision about elecoral reforms, ec. The Trastrer AIC, by later ‘ied 20052011 lafomed Shs Agra that INCIAICC id aot come Under the RTL Act The BUP by Iter dtd 76052011 informed Sh Agua that the BUF, ot beng 2 publ sun, was nt obliged to [wove infra sought 3. Shri Bava, a his appistion dated 29102010, bad asked hese onal politic paries, ey ING/AICC, BU, CPI(M), CPL, NCP and BSP {© provide information abou the sures, for acnia pod of the es lunest volonary connibatons. The Tesucy, AICG, by = lewer dated 151112010 informed Sn Batwa that AICC dw come nde he RIT At, The NCP on 27.112010laformed that NCP wae an NGO wiout "estes or ths ark while tating tha he iafomation be celled or the Election Commision andthe Income Tx autores with whom ty ‘were replaying eras. The CPI on 0612010 afrmed the applicant shout the sources ofthe en naimum Vlutry conbosa euesed ‘The ete pall puis id ot respond o Shi Blew 4S Ava nd Shs Baral fed complains in his Commision ‘entendngthat he sad ratenal plist parce cunewcer he deta plc authors in secon 2) ofthe RE Act The couplaas wee heat ty ils Commision on 260.2012 and OL-L-202. Aa or aed (03062013 was passed 5. ‘The onder eld hat the aforementioned national pala panies were publicauorses The Present! General Sera of these ares were fireced io designate Ceaual Public Infomation Offices (CPIOS) end ‘opel aubores at hedguares in ax week. was decd tae he {CPOs respond to dhe RFT apleans in ou weks time: The Presents General Secretaries of these pares wee also eed wo comply wih he provisions of section 48) a th RT Act Novice dated 05.1.2014 for engulry Sh Agrawal informed the Cam ion by represencations dated 7.00203, 10122013 and 2.122013 that none of te pola pres nd compli with he decuos in th ort of €3 082018 accordingly zetice seeing comments ofthe conceoed palit pats was sed on 17022034. Three polial pares (INC/AICC; CPM CPD) responded To the noice. Anoter nonce dhed 251722014 ws sent tothe pate (BP, NCP; BSP hat ad na responded of which, one py (NCE) response, 7.__The responses rcv were not sate terefore«sowscase ice wa sued ob 1082014 under section 18 of te RTA tl he sx pokical pares explain why an engly shoud ot be nated for ton-conplaice ofthis Commission's der ded (3.062013. Responses ‘ere received from four partes INCIAICC: CPM CPL NCP) was cleat That ome of he pres d taken spe to iplemeat the rer of (0306013. Therefore ths Commission dace old on ogy asthe mater under seion14(2) ofthe RTT Act Accntingly, = noe dated (0311304 was sed fining 211.204 ae date or eaing Hearing on 21.2014 The respondens were bse during the sasng on 21.11.2024 Submisions were made by the comgluatt, Si Agraval nd Prt Jog Chaka, and by he trvene, St Ri, 9. Daring the hering on 21.112014, hr Arava sibmited shat aly be inosed on the defuling pole! pares and xtplry ‘ompetston be awarded. Sit Agrval alo si tthe Common take icommendton for eninatingcealasate-funded pvlges end onessson being given tthe poll pares. Prof, Cla si hat the ‘ical partes hve delbertly not capped withthe Canin ‘er auth i ahsence rm proces Bs fu the Conon a Swan ‘tation. Po Chokar pressed formazan, pel sod ‘xemply compensation in accordant witha formula pean by Biss Shu sted ht the ede of 03.06 2013 ha at ben guesoned by he pal pares Defare any cou and iat he eco thein were ‘nd bsg on the pres: and sa hs hg thatthe ses penal Sd compensation ve ob dace, ‘Commbsin’s interim order of 28.11.2018 10, Dised on te bering on 2.112014, the Commlson sed an Inte de dated 28.1.201,hghighing te need ooking ino: ) the nature and scipe of tis Commision’ fctening 2s evisaged inthe RTT Ato Flow ponte complianeof sores ted ction (2 bow to aes sistion where the repondets do net engage Fath proces such she present inetnce whet th pod pares ‘ve or appeared ine ning sd 72@) the need co idenity he stops equte for ensuing Implemenaton of ths Commission's ones of 93062013. 2. The Commission deeded to provide anon opporuniy whe respondents to present tor case. Tis would alo bes cance forthe Ccmmlainans at iterveoer to make fuer sbmisins The inten one of 2.1.24 xed 7.012015 asthe date or teaig. Hearing on 07.01.2015 12, Therespondens were abot ring the aug on 070.2015 1th complanans, Sa Agawal nd Prof. gee Chios, andthe Jnkoveer She FJ ade submissions The sts on which ey {ypeared or or less tobe in agreement re () thee collusion betwen the responds nadonl pla ares for not appearing before the Comaissom ts persistent ‘Ignoring of nucee by Ue repoodens and ther keeping zane fom the proeengs as afesed the Commision’ effecivenes: (he Commissions order of 03.06.2013 i al, fl and tadog ‘one respondent aon poltical pres under the RT At () none of the respondents have sppesched the higher cous i peal or wit pedo, abd sa this was in scudance withthe Aaoey-Genr’s advice, which ecogataed te leg senth and fomativenss ofthe Cammision's ede of 03062013 (6 patlamentary omendnent Bilis under conieation ‘enor Kepng pola preset ft RTL Aes prion ‘neal ull hd Lapsed a the espendents id wor Pern a lepslave acion te nslate be pres fom infometonr tects 'wavoid giving the unpeession of eng oppsedowanspaency, (2) the willl non-compliance by te polica pares comes fom ‘Saunt defiance iad era) wk he Catmision: (6 the ed fr impesion of penalty and award compensation, 2 the eo insted nde secon 102) of he ET Act By the (Commisan’s notice of 03.11.2014 soul now be concluded. Subst by She agraval on 2.12014 and 07912015 14 Shui Agrawal sai ta the politica pares who lpltd the right © lnfrmation ae themselves ot respcig the law made by he, ich ts impacted edesely on the Image of In’ demaeracy. Sat Agra ssid tnt the’ absence of the respondents from the beng he oo “mprecened stan", wich was deeply motte and ud in he colours of ban detance tte Comisan’s shot." anda hs go“was an adveret respec of he Commis, to impede bly of he Commision wo peer is stay hc” 15. Sh Aga fre sid he + norrcomplane and the devia offafemation bas hut the proper crete of wong sighs: there i ily in making choice of the ph Candidate in th absence ofifomaton; any wes wil bat presse NOTA aoneof iene) baton ity bud ats nara Commission sould tke the "most stinget view” tn impose “waximun penaly” along wit exemplaty compensa” On the PresenuSecretay of the defaling plc pars thowgh at the eating progressed it was indeed by the copa tat be cold conser compensation forthe acl es aad weld lo te aly 0 ‘cepa token compensation =" Commission shuld mabe recommendations under seta 25(5) of ‘he RTT Act to the patent deparunents ad agentes for wna of ‘soveramee funded piles sich as acconmostion oh prim and, fe Ses ie, income tax exemption, ec the ned was metdoned for revenge ere fr registering political artes fr walg face 8s coples of voter sts tes wih View fo sceesig oat he "Mon Sevous® panies such 36 tose no complying wit i Conmisia’s rer of 03.0603, the Elecon Commission can provide substantial Ip 10 this Commission for geting th order f 03.06.2013 npleected the eres of 08062013 har not ben challenged ln higher cou, {nd hts binding a be pais +i ttn ofthe then Goverment ad ben pr atic of is Anumey-General nt To apes) agate Commons eee i ours and vals dss fom ping ay tendon to he FT Ac for ‘eping pola ares out of the defn of pai sehr f__henase noice fr penalty be Set to the Presiden) General ‘Secretaries ofthe ola pares, aking inte acount ha CPO apple stories had ot bees spond «att poll partes may dety cde to pay pony one pretext tur o0 CPO has beet ppd ‘Submissions by Prof Choa on 21.2014 and 07.0 16 Prof Cola si hat he generally aged wih Sst Agawal, bt ws not in onecence ob cern pla. Pro. Chola fathead hae suonly objected to he bsece om the pecs ofthe rapandat lool potical pares despite he sever oppruaiies iver yf Coniston, He Said tha Gis his not oly caused eaten fie cemlainay, bur has also imputed aveely othe epuaon he Se 15sms Car i dt ten ree, ed So Tiogmr ot ihe mepandent dnd ter wnseemly detace of te oumison Prot Chula eid hate nove fr imgosion of pealty wd ‘Sado coapenstion be ae othe Presiden” General Secretary ofthe ‘onl polieal pares. 17, Prof Cthokar futher elborted that 1 Resons 1819 abd 20, ll pa ofthe RT Act's chapter V, must be ‘eat cogete sa integrated whale and be “Interpreted and effected in ‘Cnjuneton wh th ste nis ere") Soja was ie aeed fo recnpze adsuntely the growing publi “ics am account of non-compliance by the tonal fla pes nd ‘Ber steting ofthe Commission's dzecves andthe detimenal tet ‘fatch an atte on te sae of emocy: rere ta public expecauon tat tbe Commission woud take Tlic eps to etre the fle of aw and espet or insaons hat has Fecived a serous back on scout of an-compliance of hearer of (062012 wile sands rated": ee sae bas vsed fice powers (a the Commision fr “uring complicit th allen he TTA STE te abwence of CPIO, penal be imposed on te Pride ‘Secrtay ofthe pails pares; and hx acorgly «noice be sud {hd snr commensurate action be ea for awaré of coapessaton; oN context of awarding compeosaen, de dene sued des nt fecesaly hive tobe specially ned eh 98 dvi compat, the decmenr suld be co the ces of damocacy, whic ath set fos serious and otal castophc’ and Ua Qs was case ‘thee exemplary punsent be avared Phe compensation shold Ue aul to Sve percet ofthe average of the anol icine at declared by he sx poll partes i hel Ina 1 pte complain has he legal standing to im cnepestion oa tela the democracy af the county; 17 atthe Commision ca exsreateadance ofthe respondents pet Section 180) ofthe REL Ac, which equips he Commission wat he owes fs cil cor under te Ci Procedure Code; uti is doubt f ‘nyu pupose would be served in polangng the ennizy, eT cs e edt the respnden for penaly and compensa, ‘ven f pat bshourndetes tt the wl igor the proces Sbmisons by She Jala on 211.2014 and 07.01.2015 Am ShL RK. a, sated te folowing+ she re of 3.0208 pasted ys Commision sal, binds dot tml re te rer of 0.009 ws cmp ai Wh = toe sen wos Geet be st op log wih con of = ‘Speronl nechansencing¢ PIO et the endear fhe sik ea poled pues wih epee aos, wach reped ‘MeenaiSesesing. splices in acordace wit te slated {ne dng wi taing acon on voluary score rovsions, see he ser not expae bt psd aller ge modes Spout ea ad a he moe of lato he eons Phas wrens Senate fs Commis nbn ene ipl press lenge he ce ele Hh ‘our Saree Cau eet tae at esome nal bd Dal {Sl sci fof te Ae SMEG usacton of the Commission to pass de sd ere of {3.062013 aot te qnsone at hs age efor Camis, 2 he stenent Oy te INCL ICC ee pare 22 Velo) abut te Conioung pendency fs mendeat Bil oKep poll utes use SSORE Aes purview ot ore tb on vey sch tht of 0 062083, cans ube psd aden 3 vacaun td that, dpe te lnc of dens ie RTL AC, Commins ert powers even nel nd acl 1 petis orden enfrce 8 Gow on acoplneof he rds psd by hs Commision an teva underoath RTI Act, wi efit SB pera nts of Commision 19. Reference Sut Aga’ propos io make recommendation vet fecton 259) of the RIT-AG, tf cease gaat of concessions and ‘bss ote plea pares, Shi Jai subated tht hs Commision Should not go beyond te directions given Ine ox cf 03082013. As fepans the sggeaton of Pat Chokar a compensa, Se Jan id thats complainant ant ask fr compensation on bebo al the izes of the coum, and ht the compensation has 1 be conned 10 the ‘Saterings of te fnormaion sect taking Ink accent ao that the ‘rer of 0082013 tine bound an ot n open ened dee Approach of the Respondents 20, The respondents notated the Bearing on 21112014 Another tie, 0701 205 a ned but the reposts, sai, So apes. 21,_Leners om the responds, resved io the Commision poe the notice of 03.11.2018, ave Deen Feleed on pass 6 and 7 above 63INCIAICC. The complainants imervener peesent 00 07.01.2015 forthe eating wate given cope of he eter 22. The aforementioned lever fom INCIAICC ste ha". Nothing in he RIT Act sugges thats pot pany i “public auto. The CIC has expanded som ction beyond the ltr and spt the TT Ac, whlch set fce legal. the oder dtd 03062013 in ‘exes ofthe powers ofthe CIC contemplate under Seton 1 ofthe RTT BRewoit the CIC so doses, ayo the sats of the Right to Infomaon (Aanendmen)” Bl 3013. is requeted that te Proceeding may citer be coeed or ajoumed sine die el the al cone of he rocetings blr Parliament” 2. Prof Cola abject to he suggestion of he INCY AICC ia her ier a records be sramoned othe Government he Raya Sab [ax Saba Seceurut to find ot he satus of the Right fo Tlormation (Asnendnen) Bl, 2018 along ith resssioning 3 copy of the Paalanentry Sandig Commitee’, perunet report Pro. Chott sd ‘hate sald Bl bad apse wih he dalton the Lak a 20, 24 The various reponse recelved fhm the responders, generly Speaking, ae along similar ines. Thy question the Commission's cimpeiice pss the fer of 3.06201. The respondents have ad at the order isnt accep to them a twas cour to wand ive witout jusicion. It was also sted by he sepondets at the Parliament i considering 2 Ito ameod he RT" Act fo keep the respondents outset purview ofthe Ac 25._ The nojusdicion agument by he respondents was dsb 3a terdought bythe complainants, The tspondent id ot chlenge the ‘Cormisions cede f 8.062013 in cout To question the Commison’s mptence o jrisicion now would be at edds with te sbaantve ‘weight ta hs sled come tobe asceaed wih he order taking ino ‘count the Satemen of Objecs and Reasons ofthe RIT (Amentnet) BL, 2013. The Stutement recognizes upon the onder njpeton td the raison dee of the ropostd amendment othe RIT Act. The ese ot he anendnct th CI is de er ners fon ol the sid Act" and at Delong lea any a Pu Seth ude the RIT Act woud hamper is oe ral wor, ‘The Commision’ arson sot de ues, 26, The plea tat be Commision is without ution snot cree, ‘his ana besasained in he ght of pra 28 sve I at al hee s 2 oe‘queson, 6 not ceased with json, The Commission has ‘Biresed a ouber of cases in wich ke mers hve bees adesed and ‘Secded, aclaing whether nett sa able auto His mendonable ‘hat there is 2 specie provi Gcton 19(Xey),exabling he ‘Commision to requre the public authority to applnt a CPIO. The ‘Rspondentnaloalpolical pares were decaed wo be pu suhertis, ‘Sn cnsequesty, the Comsalsion decd apoinent ofa CPIO in he ‘order of 03.2015. (Orde of 0262013 binding and final 27. The Commissions or is bindings yer secon 197) of the RTE ‘AGL The Supe Coun te case of Nami Sharma vs Unt of Ti in ‘WE{Cin) Ne 210 of 2012, held"An ade pasted by te Commision fia nd icing and can aly be questioned before he High Cou ofthe Supeome Cout in exercise ofthe Cou’ justin uler Aricle 226 ander 32 of the Cznsuioe, respectively” "The respnden national ital pri chow noo appa say cou. 28, The epondens have not questioned ie order of 506.2013 before any cou. Net nly ste oer legally come, i convincing from the Standpoit of the sims and cbjecves espoused by the RIT Ac wit Feference otanparency, scour and aces infomation. Twas 1 fal bench ofthe Common, wich ad held inthe eer at" ‘eld be oto are ta transparency good fer al Saw organs ut nt SS ocd Torte Pare, wt in sly onal lh logan of Ue State The cal ofthe role being aye by these Pic Paes in our deca setup and theatre of does perfor by tem also puke wars heir pubic character, bg the nthe ambit eton 2h). ao pit towards tir character plc storie." 25. No competent court has intervene in he mater. Th complainants Said hc naa the esjandets eat the cour he der was leg It was sald Ut naedesty posing the rer woald spar the el of pees and wansparency tht plcl pares and ober teks In publ Ife sek to promot for testes, The plicl pares i not wish o Be seen a bares 1 account, bence dd no questa th Commisoas der in any Mehr court. The KEI (amends) Bl 2013 ekg heey poll pars ouside te purview of be RIT Ac, was dso alowed to Fape, Thee fo Juda olga arveton inpactg ea header “The cum ist be oder of 03052013 val nding aod ial, as‘Closure of Englry [M_ The cimplaloens and intervenor sald thatthe respondents have Adliberately kept away fm the hsrings, and dit even ey weal have ome, was uaa tht any covbton wuld have emanated It was ‘Sid ht re resonable oasue Bat th spends wl nox inpleent the Cons’ dr, abd bat nethng weal be achieve in conunung tof date ater date for begs Inthe enquiry. Hence, cs pols prolong the emily taking int scout the persistent ack of engagement Eth esondees eth the proces. The nation emerging was tat the guy shuld pow be cone S31, The Commision, the apex ofthe RT Act's working mechani, Seeks w esa acest infor bel by public aborts, andl of Saiory safeguards, operon boas and mets. The jc i 10 Dromote wanspareny and acoualy fr enhancing governance and Ssaining campden. The provisns belp achieve opemes long wih protcon of contends where regret. Elsen and flecvenss re imgortant consists Publicaeres te gud gh 32, The Commission ands to: (a) complains about implementation ‘td insatonalshercainge ner aeton 16; abd () appeals der ‘Su 1 gana the decors aon pic authori onspplicaons Seeking norman In th pee cae, thehoeringe oo 2012018 and raids, folowing 2 nouce der stcuon 162) enguted. in mpl tat the mspondnts ha not implemented the Cams’ ‘ref 03.062013. 33. The Commision’ powers and functions ae defied ln ater V of the Rr Act. Tare could be many stations rearing te Coamisoa to Sep in, eg, gnevancs agaist tbe CPO Tor blag evasive or dlying information The working mechanism may be mallbcaing or may Dot have ben setup all a inte peso nsance, ‘There ca be desea ‘nowt nrc te exemption from dle cates nthe RT Ac, the sgh and bation ead, a the scape of deinions sch "afoaton’, "public aut, “recor, “right lnformaae”, “Bird pany" etn 2100011X0 344 What has happened inthe prses ese star the respondent ave {akea no acon 2 the dectons given bythe Commision 6903062013 SJ deseried thst be a “comple, compressive and compost ede” etig he eng op ofa working apart” wit eles a6fn exeion, Shs Ji ad that te order had dhe following compooens (DAICCING, Bm CPN, CP, NCP and BSP dered publi bois {eer seton ofthe RT Ac () Presiden! General Secreaies ofthe ‘Dove pli prtes ected to designate CEO and spelt utes ‘tbe beaéquaners; appoints to be doe in six wees; (@) CPIOs terespond othe RIT splations exacted athe ode of 03.05.2013; "sponse to go In four weeks; and (f) Prades General Seceates of ‘ove pliel pares wo comply with secon (1) ofthe RTT Act by ‘ey of volun dicosires ‘5. The sic ston politcal pares, as pubic authors, ware directed ‘comply withthe cliguions siplaed inde RTE Ac. Accodiag wo ‘hope of he RT Act be public autores have o mata al ecards “hy caloued and indesed prserbed,pblish formation abet it working wit deals about budge, organizational suc, decision making processes, cxtegry of documents hl, etc. CPOs and appeliae lores have o be appt, and systems pu in place or dss af ‘us ng poi ion Hwee x PUN a Be i ‘ake ay acon, 2% neff if chien under the RIL Act was hnow he en gst “nor to any polical par, ot wheter apart as ea any propel for scr ears tote Heston Camimisson, or abs te Pome made ln electon manifesto the infoenatea-selar woul not know what © fe the aplication. There is no aides to seod an infomatonseeing ‘Dpleton a be CPIOs an polite auberes ave not been appa “he complainants, dating the beings, said that noo-ompllance bythe rspondens cal’ for consequence, including postion of pel (tans 19(() 20), the award of compension (econ 19((0) sh ‘ommendations (ection 255) sbout the withdawal of fetes and ‘Soceitne grt the poli partes 3, Howe wo proceed fanher would hae to be dcermed fom capes V fe RIT Acting th poets ad facons of he Commision The Ae ses, 18 19 a2, he chape fs nce ape be ell jones an anal for eng gowped together Po. Chlar Biel all ese secons "must be read’ top as an negated ‘te. ” Hower in cette, te case for dng bees le tlre and scope of the tho aeons, 16 ad 1, hat seme Sencance,undeind bysome sore. appess ha te const tetween conan and appeal us beume tae maid Secon 191 Eon pel wg fay eo fh CO ed apelate sures, whos secon 18 bow co sda operon ees oe 47Si, The preset cate subecrbes to section 18, uaer which the noice fr Iarings was ated Complain, eleeace econ 18CX2MXKXANND, ‘eter to stuns of no PIO. having been appoined dens of {Blamaton truco otmnee, nrsronble fe, IOcanple oF ‘seni information, restos on accessing eat Ley a Yange ‘tissue fen othe ystems se ofthe Commission's ansioaDy Section 18, arguably, has 9 wder canvas tan secon 1% de ater Foneoning ins singly fotead way eh reference to splicaons for Infomavn, gel spesking for vesling dyson nda sues. Secon 18 is sopervtory in mare, under whch detions can be ve ‘lst sppong CPI, ar war donee present stance 30, the const berwee the ral ofthe two sects is bought ot by the Supreme Cout’sJodgmet, dated 2.122011 In Chit lnfomaton {Comnsaner ve, Sate of Manip (Cv) Appeal Nos. 10787-10780 of {oT ba been contended beloe us that under Section 18 of the ‘Ac be,.Commsson. fas ao power to provide acces ote infomation ‘etch is ben regu for by any person but which hasbeen denied 0 Ti The only ore wich canbe pasted y the. Commision. .ndet Seton 16 nore of ply provided under Secon 20... We upd the eld contention abd do at any earn tempus adgment of the High cour whereby i has Ben held ht the Commision whe meranng. » complaint ubder Seton 10 of the sad. ACL has 0 Sistine pss an rer powding for access tthe information.” In ‘ther words wile sev IB ca be tbe rote for addressing coplas ‘hat the pty to ot foro, 40. isin fom sacton 18 he Common’ oe unr section 19s Tato the second fina appellate authonty to decide appeals agaist te tries of te fist appellate aubory,the level higher than the CPO. ‘Appeals ae also beard ino orders ae peed by the fist appellate futberiy within te sulted timeframe. Ia te preset Insane, the esponest did ot act onthe oder of 03.06.2013 chat directed the Sppinimet of CDIOs apd fst apelae autres, hence no mechan i lnexstence tenable any ston 0 information seeking applicators. 444. Secon 19) give gudance aboot the dlecons thatthe ‘aumison can cone so stuatns sucha hs where information be being provided in scronance with the noma oF where the trecaniam fot ben pat n place. However, ts ease of pre-CPTO "Sage Wihou a CIO fist ape auhory these no conte for an ppl otha Compson spite the Cosmas order of 3.062013 (BE Coto hae oot been appointed This not ease ofthe CPIO being at tes ee eefale ethene ofthe pa autacty wh has ome o appoint the C10. Can ihe Comuision's cursive and peal powers be made ‘Splat tothe head ofthe pblc suey for compeling compliance ‘th order of 08062013 ana the provson ofthe RTT Act 42. The comldnms, sskig noma, ave ted land Sema nc er flr ony as te Saree ct mle ty pede ae, i sa ies fo rng aps nd opti fever to git ho pu sheny topes sgt ys a her denen sale Seco 3400 sas tt ams Sh we aps in fe oss pe ae Ser ac Bt scorn seen Spe pred ot oF be Cros gh goss ie ute coat de ‘Span of poly td eid seoopeice ematy The complananis have prayed for inposton of penal. Section 2B) ofthe RTL Act provides ta fhe Commission I of he pio ht te CPIO has, witout reasonable cause, refed to ecleanyspplenton fe informant bs nt fished Infomton within the sped ne (has muladaly denied the information sought or nowngly given Imconeat ele or misleading tnfrmation = penal of io Be 2500 cha ipod by the Comin, 44 Shit Chor, the complainant, sid at pena be impo on te Peside General Secery_ of the politcal pres ho bad’ the pansy to appoint the CPIO. Ba, the RT Act sca hepenaly ‘be imposed only on the CPIO, Section 20 lavaked when th CPIO "fal Thee bo mention of inposion of enaly on te fist appeate ‘ory who very often flout he rin of te RT Act by nt ping trder ot the appeals o doo in breach ofthe preserved tine lis, TRE inti ofthe eisai, tbat the esa can be posed nly on {Re CPIO. The RTT Act has made the CPIO the ceatplce on tater of peal. The provisions speci thi the CPIO Is ened to beng heed ‘alr any penalty is imposed. The oct son the CPIO to pove tat be sed easenbly and dig “#5 Inte Insane case, the pares declared at pile autores Rave ado appoin CP1Os so, wat do he CPO hat et eee spol, on wham wo impose he penal The aw slo ti postin of pialy'on the polial parts o ter Present General Seceaes aos we ‘would no be comet aking nto account sci 20 ofthe ft Act ‘pes of impaion of pray 0a te CPIO aay. Secon 20 als allows ‘he Comma to secommend ctinary action agaist» CIO who bas ‘este faled to full his respoasblies under he RTD Act The ‘Commission sinble to sort ths section because he 0 CP. ‘Compensation 46, Compensation i award under secon 19(0)0) of the ETT Ac ‘wich empowes the Commission orders pbc stan 0 compensa The complaast for any les or any ster deinentsulred How 10 prone the faue of eoapetsation, keeping In view the variance in he [Mbpssons ofthe two complains, She Agrawal and Prot coh “hey tle one nature abd Sope of compassion under te RTA and 47 Prof Col sated har noncompliance bythe polit eis bis ida deuimenal fet of sero proportions on the sate of demacacy the county geeaing cycle ad pesmi, while giving ce © the premise atthe espndens, bowed by the people wih pli ower aid auto, are above the Ive Prof Chola sad that ich no omllance wil make citens lowe fai in he legal estos and ‘democrat vates In ths liga, Stl Cabokar sought compenstion ox etal of indin democracy” snd “sci as «whole ro. Chaka as prayed for awd of compensation, equal to five peer of te aera al acome as diced ty te separ in heinous, © tepid in th ame Masters Rie Fund. 4, Shi Agaval onthe other hand, eos compensation for elas | “decent feed by him advil a5 2 compl. Shi Aga, 0 ‘hentia saps of te Hern, pest for “exemplary compensation” He Idd, le be nee for making good the los and dexmeat eelly fered by hi, bt towards th ose fhe arin ated hat would te satisfied wl token compensation fone rape pe pla ar In hs eonecor,Sht Agrawal ted ht is eas ad an averse elect on I health on acoant of metal pressure and agarvaedtensan dt 10 tavng oper for the ase ue and api 48 Refere Prof. Choka’s views on compensation, Shi Jan {Shauted ats compan ass ak for compenstion on bla ofall the cllzens ofthe county the compensation has to be conned to de Silene ofthe lfommavon sok Sit Jai sald tat che mean ofthe ‘wor “compensa abe udesioed na mae wich compat ‘thie ter and spit ofthe RIT Act Unda he eee ofthe state, TRoulbe rated sly en the compensaon-seekr Jats the loss, A ae “ rvs ig 90injury oc any ote detriment steed by him on acount of any acto fmisin om fe pref the CPIO a aby ar oticere the public aux ‘meee 50. A question is whsher compensation ander che RTT Act can be himed om behalf a etaen for ny loss ober dimen to democracy ‘roy ae whole resalng fom ben-complace of te Commissions ‘Sit of 83062013 Each nance of nom couplance by a publ ubarty [Sdettmenal odeacracy, however, ftom a eading af season 190) {sparen tht tte complainant Wo hasto be compensate. The TL ‘Act ste atthe pie ators wl “conpeaste te complaint fr Sy loe or oe detent sured” Si. Seco 18s uncer about te seen far the Commission can ake nthe igs emanating fom an eng. Section 1 doesnt meson ‘cous o een 15()() consequent o eng ang. On the sue of ‘he oom avlableto the Commision foc hang camps, eleva s Sn onder of the High Cou of Deh in Ua of tna. PK Srasava, {EPA 1952041, of 6.042013. 1 was sated eda: “compensation to the compat foray loss or eher denen seed by hum canbe ‘Headed by tbe Commision cay while deldig an apeal fed before ‘The aforesaid Secon does ot provide for gan of compensation merely oa te bas of» comple mage othe Conlin, wit at appeal ving ben prefered i.” Discusion on the pints aed in term order of 8.112014 52. The quesions case in the intri, onder of 2.112018 are ‘eouooed above, in pura 10. These aed tobe comsseted upas de 0 thee relevance fora perspective onthe working of chapter Vote RELA ‘eh view to ming ook oe what do et aking it sexo The fact ta the respondents have oot comple with he Commision’ ore of 03062013. 53. respec of the poet para 101), above, Le, following up oo Compliance Kis the Commission's resonsbilty 0. emue Implementation of seeders. Mates velatg to nemcamlance af the Commisos's rer may be conse nr soton 16. a ode of 11062009" in Radhika Arora or Cic, complaint noe Clcrwa'c200085s, tc, te Commis sad: “we ave areal cided alow upon complace of desons of the Camison. that Secretary ofthe Commision il now assume responsi for sung complance with all decane mabeby the Common, Forts Pupose, a Regiser of Non-Compliance wil be opened which wil be 97esd by the Office of Sertay, CIC and on cialsion of the "plat Ne complain vil eer be closed or ese as a complaint ‘SREES under con 161) and proceeded upon by the Bench ofthe Infrmaton Commision! concer.” S&The Commision ls expected to gat its odes complied wih The teh com of Anche Pradesh inorder dated 05032012 in WE. ‘Net3002012~ Kady Sher Babu vs Chairman, AP. ble Service Cooma in he cootat of an order by the Sue Infomation ‘Commision, cserved "to cate the respondents ad oot comply with thence passed by the APLC, ten remedy of the plone sander Staion 20 before the sad infornaon commision,” The Cut sa that “The Rit Information Ae, 2005 [2 second enacmes! 24 fwovide for singe uu for eforemeat of Be ores of the “ntories for proviig information. Ifthe requre information i nt Femi peter instead of poaching he autores unde. Sit Ac, approached ti Cou ubde Ale 26 ofthe Cansei Cou enor exec Court for mplemenizion ofthe odes pase by ‘nous autores nde he Right nfrmation Act, 20 S5._The High Cou of Karta order date 27.01.2009 nthe mar of Cec. Nesis2008 (Cd) = set G. Bava vs Sm Ards ‘reset Ananda Cooper Bank Lid, hs eld hat .3.20f RITA ‘ovis for pelts confers powers co the Comasson oo the ass tbc it rn enforce rrr i aaa penile of lnerpreton Gf Sut, walauted by. dion of the Apex Cou, Dat, Couts of ‘ean, muse belt poses power to eect is ov ede. Farber, the RET Act, whch st seltconained Cade, even If hs bat beet Sectaly splat, mut be deemed. have ean cnfened. the paver t0 make order elective, by having recourse to S20” io bean Deld dat". provions of 520"can be exersed by the Commision slot ener sade" The pot Sn pra 10@), above, frst a stuaon where the frpandenns doce engage im the proces, and keep away fom the emrings. The RT lepton had come wo fulion because of acs oar sppon. wear not expeceed hat the epaadents would avo the Sroceengs, The trumpton tha elds of information wll engape It the proceeds sf te Ac tulascescompeung coaseraoas. snd ‘icing Inerest, Paes do not shy say dram ecoueng each ‘her's stand to are at pina outcome. The dfn inthe RE ACL, the exemption frm diclosire caves and cher povsions ensure at Wwovtale clone ae reached. A suntan, where che respenden, Tenoing he Commission's noe, dsance themselves fo te sto) 92proceedings in 2 mater of such wide plc imere, has come abot, eas, forthe ist ume 57. The pio in pra 10), above, resto the need to nly ways ed meu for pementng the Cormissin's cde Ins coancton, ‘rious actions cae to be proposed dring the besng oo 2111-204 and ‘7012015, which were (a) acon under secon 169), Le, recs Dowels aba cll cout with a lew wo geag the respondnt sana Foal patie puri the higs ante contin proses, (action under section. 256) giving recommendaons to be pees Public actoaues for wihdradag facies to the poles! pais 0) [pasion of pealy eer sections 18()) and 20; and (award of compensation dade Scan 190). Si Secon 18) equips the Commision wit be powers ofa cl cou forte purpose of ensuiagatendance and evidence nan ea In this onnctn tbe cmpaiants ald ta novi purpose wil be served even ifthe presence of the detanking pas ensred nthe eng a thy ae uly oso any mtr eter hi what as ley bo pvc by them, The mater under discussion ene United a2 onetime daposl of Specie complains and 2 decison on penaky and comperstin, The ‘ater goes beyond te complaint chs fel nstnce cere would te varius aplcatons ine pipeline an demands for nfrmaton nde ‘he RIT Act Hence, he aes or he espondets fo setup amopersbonl ‘ecans a er te Commies onder of 0 062013, 58, Secon 25(5) was ced by Sha Agrwal, when be feed tos laters the Commissie, dated 21.11.2014, 02:122014 and 05122018, ‘oposing that recommendations be made t0lasittons ich he Ministry of Utan Development, Elton Commission of India, Pasar Dhar, Cental Bourd of Dect Taw, ety for teat cela lsvemmet funded conesians othe espondeis. The rile inde Prime acommedaton, fee media te, income tax extntios et Si Aral sad htt was ne cay abou plying presse fer npemeating the Commision’ ara, ba se ls shut recognizing tat defers wece not deserving of any Saeed beef. Sh Agra sous 3 part ore onthe subject: Sit ante irene, Sal tha tit ‘oposlis extraneous othe dro 3.962013, ed et he Cotsoe ‘otld nt go beyond ie decors conalned thin 1. Secon 25(5) doesnot apply hee. Accord to section 258), the Commission cn recommend 3 pole ator he tp at age be ‘akeo far prometng conlormiy with the RIT Act it appen fo the (Commision thatthe pracice of'« public aubery in reson tothe 9Furls of functions under the RTI Act does not coaform wit he povisons or spit of te RTT Ac. Ths Commision has tena sila ‘ew in ease No. CICSMUCI2011901285 (on 4.082014) ~ Cl Kasia ve IO, High oor of Maras: We ar ofthe view tht ay recommendations ‘made to artes ht ae aot pres before the Coniston woul nt Stand julia seri. 6k, Reon ls b ind iro he COs nt be it apo suey ore pbc anthony Seton 20 of the RTT ‘Report ft CPO ts eed to eve a spain fr {nfrmation or has flo fish fmt within he plated ime ar hs ace malfiely to deny ifornaton or as ver sncomect internat, 2 peal can be imosté onthe CHO eens tht be leg nea as been to pre oer pally oo tbe dealing {CO and node Ut pnay spond os poli uo wil ‘omen eT 2. Reference compensten, the expssions ‘to compen’ ‘any oss ‘oer datimentsfered' have nt been defied inthe TY Act o is ‘ules, The ward ‘compensation’ means anything given oak amends for Tes damage, nury or sllering Io be pd bya person whose aot ‘zision Bs cused los or ifr to acter. THe ea Yo ae tit he ‘eon sfferng secuves eq value for hs los. Ip oie ‘weds, Senpensation cana be awarded fr any remote pony of Joss sutecng Prot, Choirs view (pr 47, above) had bees tat compensation ‘awarded, egal ove per cnt ofthe average of be anual ear of ‘he pla pates. Pot Chtokar als sid athe Gevinent dd wor have (0 te conneced with an individual cpa, and tat be dient ‘ould be to democracy implying that leans were alec, calling for ‘exemplary compensa. Tis wasnt aie to by Sh Agrawal wb ald that compensation ander the RTT Act may be Gite aly when the

You might also like

• Press Release On Dr. G.N.Saibaba-2nd Jan 2016

  

  Document3 pages

  Press Release On Dr. G.N.Saibaba-2nd Jan 2016

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Caste Card-Frontline

  

  Document10 pages

  Caste Card-Frontline

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Response To Bibek Debroy: and Why Jamalpur Will Still Have A Hold For Quite Some Time To Come-April 11, 2016

  

  Document4 pages

  Response To Bibek Debroy: and Why Jamalpur Will Still Have A Hold For Quite Some Time To Come-April 11, 2016

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  100% (2)
• • Magazines
  • Podcasts
  • Sheet music
• Detailed Comment On The SC Judgment For Compulsory Education For Panchayat Elections-Dec 11, 2015

  

  Document5 pages

  Detailed Comment On The SC Judgment For Compulsory Education For Panchayat Elections-Dec 11, 2015

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• BBC-Transparency in Political Funding-Feb 03, 2015

  

  Document3 pages

  BBC-Transparency in Political Funding-Feb 03, 2015

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Print and The Mint!-Paid News-GovernanceNow-Sept 1-15, 2010 PDF

  

  Document6 pages

  Print and The Mint!-Paid News-GovernanceNow-Sept 1-15, 2010 PDF

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• 22 Sep 2015-Writers Withdraw Statement After Sri Rama Sene Threatens Attack

  

  Document1 page

  22 Sep 2015-Writers Withdraw Statement After Sri Rama Sene Threatens Attack

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Representativeness of Elections in India-May 2015

  

  Document3 pages

  Representativeness of Elections in India-May 2015

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Abrar Kiratpuri-The Poet-17 July 2015

  

  Document2 pages

  Abrar Kiratpuri-The Poet-17 July 2015

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Education Is Not Just About Jobs: Jagdeep S. Chhokar

  

  Document2 pages

  Education Is Not Just About Jobs: Jagdeep S. Chhokar

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• 2 Jun 2015-New CIC Appointed-Hindustan Times

  

  Document1 page

  2 Jun 2015-New CIC Appointed-Hindustan Times

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• One Year of Modi Govt-Vaayade Poore Hone Ka Intezaar-May 18, 2015 PDF

  

  Document1 page

  One Year of Modi Govt-Vaayade Poore Hone Ka Intezaar-May 18, 2015 PDF

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• For A Thriving Democracy-Comment of 255th Report of The Law Commission PDF

  

  Document9 pages

  For A Thriving Democracy-Comment of 255th Report of The Law Commission PDF

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• For A Thriving Democracy-Comment of 255th Report of The Law Commission PDF

  

  Document9 pages

  For A Thriving Democracy-Comment of 255th Report of The Law Commission PDF

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Ei Samay-The Political Funding Imbroglio-Feb 06, 2015

  

  Document4 pages

  Ei Samay-The Political Funding Imbroglio-Feb 06, 2015

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• For A Thriving Democracy-Comment of 255th Report of The Law Commission PDF

  

  Document9 pages

  For A Thriving Democracy-Comment of 255th Report of The Law Commission PDF

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Too Hasty To Interpret The Results of The Election-Feb 15, 2015

  

  Document3 pages

  Too Hasty To Interpret The Results of The Election-Feb 15, 2015

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Print and The Mint!-Paid News-GovernanceNow-Sept 1-15, 2010 PDF

  

  Document6 pages

  Print and The Mint!-Paid News-GovernanceNow-Sept 1-15, 2010 PDF

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• KP Manu v. Chairman, Scrutiny Committee For Verification of Community Certificate PDF

  

  Document43 pages

  KP Manu v. Chairman, Scrutiny Committee For Verification of Community Certificate PDF

  Bar & Bench

  No ratings yet
• Delhi CM Letter

  

  Document2 pages

  Delhi CM Letter

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Why Should One Vote-Governance Now-March 16-31, 2012

  

  Document2 pages

  Why Should One Vote-Governance Now-March 16-31, 2012

  Jagdeep Chhokar

  No ratings yet
• Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  

  From Everand

  Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  Phil Knight

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (537)
• Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  

  From Everand

  Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  Angela Duckworth

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (587)
• Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  

  From Everand

  Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  Margot Lee Shetterly

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (894)
• The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  

  From Everand

  The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  Sarah M. Broom

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (98)
• The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  

  From Everand

  The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  Meik Wiking

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (399)
• On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  

  From Everand

  On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  Naomi Klein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (73)
• The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  

  From Everand

  The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  Mark Manson

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (5794)
• Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  

  From Everand

  Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  Chris Voss

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (838)
• Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  

  From Everand

  Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  Ashlee Vance

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (474)
• Yes Please

  

  From Everand

  Yes Please

  Amy Poehler

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1891)
• A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  

  From Everand

  A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  Dave Eggers

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (231)
• Principles: Life and Work

  

  From Everand

  Principles: Life and Work

  Ray Dalio

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (599)
• The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  

  From Everand

  The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  Siddhartha Mukherjee

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (271)
• The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  

  From Everand

  The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  Brené Brown

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1090)
• The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  

  From Everand

  The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  Thomas L. Friedman

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2219)
• Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  

  From Everand

  Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  Doris Kearns Goodwin

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (234)
• The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  

  From Everand

  The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  Ben Horowitz

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (344)
• Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  

  From Everand

  Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  Gilbert King

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (265)
• Fear: Trump in the White House

  

  From Everand

  Fear: Trump in the White House

  Bob Woodward

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (738)
• Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  Frank McCourt

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (440)
• Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  

  From Everand

  Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  Jay Sekulow

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (137)
• Steve Jobs

  

  From Everand

  Steve Jobs

  Walter Isaacson

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (806)
• John Adams

  

  From Everand

  John Adams

  David McCullough

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2409)
• The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  

  From Everand

  The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  George Packer

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (45)
• Bad Feminist: Essays

  

  From Everand

  Bad Feminist: Essays

  Roxane Gay

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1015)
• The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  Jeannette Walls

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1712)
• Wolf Hall: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Wolf Hall: A Novel

  Hilary Mantel

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (3811)
• The Outsider: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Outsider: A Novel

  Stephen King

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1839)
• The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  

  From Everand

  The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  Stephen Chbosky

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2099)
• The Woman in Cabin 10

  

  From Everand

  The Woman in Cabin 10

  Ruth Ware

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2322)
• The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  M.L. Stedman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (789)
• The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  

  From Everand

  The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  Viet Thanh Nguyen

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (119)
• Little Women

  

  From Everand

  Little Women

  Louisa May Alcott

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (104)
• Brooklyn: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Brooklyn: A Novel

  Colm Toibin

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (1937)
• A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  Fredrik Backman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (4609)
• The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  Garth Stein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (4200)
• Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  Jennifer Egan

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (792)
• A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  

  From Everand

  A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  Betty Smith

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1929)
• Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  Jesmyn Ward

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1103)
• The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  John le Carre

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (104)
• Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  

  From Everand

  Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  Carmen Maria Machado

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (821)