Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Further information
For further information about the issues discussed in this publication
please contact:
Learning and Skills Network
Tel 020 7297 9000
For further information about the Learning and Skills Council
please visit:
www.lsc.gov.uk
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank all the college tutors and coordinators
who took part in this project, Lilian Soon for her assistance, and the
development and support team at Tribal CTAD.
Contents
Executive summary v
Introduction 1
Section 1 Mobile learning 2
2 Developing a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit 6
3 The pilot 13
4 Research approach 17
5 The tutors 19
6 Using the SMS authoring tool 23
7 Using the MyLearning games 28
8 Using the mediaBoard 32
9 Other uses of the devices by the tutors 35
10 Students using their own mobile devices for SMS and MMS 36
11 The impact of mobile learning on teaching 38
12 The impact of mobile learning on students’ learning 41
13 Integrating the mobile learning toolkit into the curriculum 43
14 Tutors’ views of the value of mobile learning 45
15 Tutors’ views of the cost-effectiveness 47
of using handheld computers for learning
16 Mobile learning – changing attitudes to 49
learning, teaching and mobile technology
17 Tutors’ feedback on technical support 51
18 Findings and lessons learned 52
19 Conclusions 60
20 Note for tutors who may be interested in 60
using the mobile learning toolkit
References 61
Further reading 62
Appendix A Examples of the SMS quizzes created 63
B Examples of learning games created 73
C Examples of mediaBoards created 85
References 61
Further reading 62
Appendix A Examples of the SMS quizzes created 63
B Examples of learning games created 73
Pairs games 73
Snap games 79
Quiz games 82
C Examples of mediaBoards created 85
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Executive summary
Introduction
Following completion of the m-learning project in 2004, the Learning and Skills
Development Agency (LSDA) and Tribal CTAD, with support from the
Learning and Skills Council (LSC), embarked on a new project, which
built on the mobile learning materials and systems previously developed,
to create a ‘mobile learning toolkit’ for teachers and tutors. The toolkit
development responded to feedback from tutors and mentors who took
part in the m-learning project. This feedback indicated that they would
like to be able to author or adapt the mobile learning materials provided
to cater for the specific needs of their students in their particular context.
The mobile learning teachers’ toolkit which was developed included
three tools, plus training, user documentation and support. The tools were:
n an SMS quiz authoring tool, which allowed tutors to prepare
multiple-choice quizzes on a PC that their students could respond to
using their own mobile phones
n a PocketPC learning games authoring tool that enabled tutors to
create small learning games using a PC, which were then downloaded
to PDAs running the PocketPC operating system for use by the students
n the mediaBoard, a system in which tutors upload an image to a web page,
in effect like pinning a notice on to a noticeboard, and mark areas of interest
on the image. Students can then send messages (text, picture and audio) to
the image ‘board’ or to specific areas of the image and tutors can send
SMS messages from the system to students. The mediaBoard is mostly
for group activities. The students can also access and add to the mediaBoard
online either from home or in the classroom.
The toolkit was piloted with 19 tutors from five further education colleges
in England and Wales, who had different ability levels in the use of
desktop computers, mobile phones and palmtop computers – some
had no previous experience of using palmtop computers. The pilot aimed
to answer the following research questions from the tutors’ perspective.
n How did the use of the mobile learning toolkit impact on teaching?
n How did the use of the mobile learning toolkit impact on learning,
and the students’ interest in learning?
n How did tutors integrate the use of the mobile learning toolkit
into the curriculum?
Information about the tutors’ experiences was collected, together with
data to inform the future development of the toolkit.
This report includes examples of the learning materials created for use
with groups of students in different curriculum areas in order to share
ideas and good practice. It also includes tips for tutors using SMS quizzes,
learning games and the mediaBoard.
In total, 36 SMS quizzes were developed, which were played 328 times;
31 learning games were created, which were played 288 times; and
28 mediaBoards were created and used by 57 students (NB: for the
SMS quizzes and learning games the number of times played is not the
number of students, because some students took part in several quizzes).
Mobile learning in practice
vi Key findings
Teaching
The tutors considered that mobile learning impacted on their teaching
in the following ways, ie it could:
n add another dimension or resource to teaching and learning
Cost-effectiveness
Tutors were not given detailed information about the costs involved
in the project. However, some volunteered comments relating to
possible cost effectiveness:
n The costs of sending messages were not considered to be an issue
when few SMS/MMS were sent, or where messages were considered
cheap to send in order to facilitate interaction with the learning activities.
n Costs were considered an issue when they might prohibit participation,
eg the cost of buying equipment, although it was expected that prices
would probably fall in the near future.
n Cost was also perceived in the initial preparation time required to set up
the learning activities.
Mobile learning in practice
Conclusions
This project offered tutors in five further education colleges the opportunity
to create mobile learning materials for their students which catered
for their specific needs in their particular context. A quarter of the tutors
had not used a palmtop computer previously. A wide variety of learning
materials were created with most tutors and students demonstrating
great enthusiasm for mobile learning.
Mobile learning was found to have an impact on teaching and learning
because it adds another dimension and additional resources to the
teaching and learning process. It has an impact on teaching because it is
a novel way to consolidate and assess knowledge. The personal nature
of mobile learning and the interactivity can encourage learner involvement
and engagement. Mobile learning has a positive impact because
students can study anywhere with immediate feedback and become
more autonomous learners.
The mobile learning toolkit, the learning materials and activities designed
with it were easily integrated into lessons and can be used for other
purposes, such as extended learning activities, formative assessments
to check that learning has taken place, question-and-answer sessions
and homework.
As a result of taking part in this project, most tutors (18 out of 19)
stated that they were keen to continue using the mobile learning
teachers’ toolkit with their students in the future.
One of the tutors who took part commented:
The use of the mobile toolkit brought about a change of mindset in how
the students could get involved. Mobile devices were, instead of being a
distraction, now being brought in by the students to the learning environment.
A useful device that could engage the student in learning.
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Introduction
The Learning and Skills Development Agency (LSDA) and Tribal CTAD
were two of the partners involved in the m-learning project. This was
a three-year pan-European research and development study, which
explored the use of handheld mobile technologies to provide literacy
and numeracy learning experiences for young adults (aged 16–24)
who were not in full-time education, and to promote the development
and achievement of lifelong learning objectives.
Following the completion of the m-learning project in 2004 (see Section 1.2),
LSDA and Tribal CTAD, with support from the Learning and Skills Council
(LSC), embarked on a new project, which built on the mobile learning
materials and systems previously developed, to create a mobile learning
toolkit for teachers and tutors. The toolkit development responded to
feedback from tutors and mentors who took part in the m-learning project.
They indicated that they would like to be able to author or adapt the
mobile learning materials provided to cater for the specific needs of
the students in their particular context.
The development of the toolkit is described in Section 2. This section
describes the tools developed from the point of view of both the authoring
tutors and the students, and also includes some technical details for readers
who may be interested in the underpinning technologies.
This publication aims to:
n report the tutors’ experiences of using the toolkit, including how they
considered it impacted on their teaching and on their students’ learning
and interest in learning, as well as how they integrated the use of
mobile learning into the curriculum
n provide examples of the materials created by the tutors so that others
interested in mobile learning can see what has been developed in
various curriculum areas for diverse groups of students.
www.m-learning.org
Mobile learning in practice
Section 1
Mobile learning
In the final phase of the project, the learning materials and systems
which had been developed by the partners were trialled with 249 learners
in the UK, Italy and Sweden. (They were called research assistants
in order to emphasise their role as helping the project with its research
and to avoid the use of the word learning, which for some may have had
negative connotations as a result of past experiences.)
Some key messages from the m-learning project include the following.
n The learners were mostly enthusiastic about mobile learning and
62% reported that they felt more keen to take part in future learning
after trying mobile learning. Of these, 80% expressed a future preference
for learning with mobile devices.
n Just under a third (29%) were assessed by their mentors as having
developed a more positive attitude towards reading after taking part
in the research.
n 82% of respondents felt the mobile learning games could help them
to improve their reading or spelling, and 78% felt the games could
help them improve their maths.
n 88% of the learners who used the collaborative learning tools
enjoyed using the mediaBoard and felt it could help people learn.
The data also suggested that mobile learning could make a
positive contribution in the following areas, as it:
n helps learners to improve their literacy and numeracy skills and
to recognise their existing abilities
n can be used to encourage both independent and collaborative
learning experiences
n helps learners to identify areas where they need assistance and support
n helps to combat resistance to the use of ICT and can help bridge the gap
between mobile phone literacy and ICT literacy
n helps remove some of the formality from the learning experience and
engages reluctant learners
n helps learners remain more focused for longer periods
Full information about the project’s findings can be found via the LSN
and m-learning websites and in Attewell (2005).
www.LSNeducation.org.uk
www.m-learning.org
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Section 2
Developing a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit
2.1 Framework
The importance of iterative development was highlighted in the original
m-learning project, ie trialling different technologies and approaches
with students, collecting and collating feedback, using that to shape
new ideas, implementing those ideas, and going back to trialling again.
This approach is especially useful in ‘development and research’ projects
when the exact end goals are not known, as it empowers all the parties
involved to discover them together. This worked well, and one of its
many benefits was that towards the end of the project, the partners
started evolving some fairly stable approaches to both using the
technology and the accompanying pedagogy.
This stability, both in the structure of the learning and in the technology
platforms it was based on, enabled a layer of abstraction to be created
between the content and the technology used to display it. Having these
two separate is one of the basic building blocks of reusable, extendable
or scalable learning resources. In the original m-learning project the
development team used this separation to help themselves – making
it simpler and more efficient to create a greater number of materials.
In this project we used the same concept to extend these features
(authoring) to a wider audience: tutors themselves.
As will be appreciated, and as already highlighted by some authors noted
in Section 1.1 when seeking to define mobile learning, it is impossible to
separate the technologies from the learning entirely – especially when
the term ‘m-learning’ embraces so many different media and devices.
For this reason, we will now describe the development of three separate
tools in the toolkit: the SMS authoring tool, the MyLearning PocketPC
learning games authoring tool and the mediaBoard.
Figure 2.2
SMS quizzes –
the tutor’s view
What the tutors see, should they wish to, is a password-protected website
(Figure 2.2) that they can use to create new quizzes, edit existing ones,
and look at summaries of the students’ use of the quizzes.
Tutors are asked to pick a unique ‘keyword’ for their quiz and tell the
website what feedback to send for the various different answer options.
The rest of the technology set-up is taken care of automatically.
Tutors can also use special codes to create dynamic answers, for example:
You got ### out of 5. Answers *** were correct
may send a reply of:
You got 3 out of 5. Answers 1, 2 and 5 were correct
Tutors can also send a series of up to five daily SMS reminders to students,
if they want to.
To find out more, view the SMS quiz page on the m-learning portal.
Technical corner
The front end of the website is built with Flash and php. There is
a MySQL backend that tracks all activity: the authoring of the
quizzes and the SMS sending and receiving.
The SMS sending and receiving service is hosted externally
by a commercial supplier. Our server uses SOAP/XML to
communicate with the external server. This took a while
to configure, but has been running very robustly ever since.
There are cheaper ways of doing this though we found the
inconsistency of delivery speed very inappropriate, which is
why we ended up using a commercial service.
http://portal.m-learning.org/sms_quiz.php
Mobile learning in practice
These issues are also addressed by the tool. We know from other trials
that tutors have also solved some of these issues with good training
and other creative ideas.
The real aim of the development of MyLearning was to embed many of
the lessons learned about mobile learning materials during earlier trials
into the fabric of the software, so that tutors would automatically get
features like:
n short, sharp focused pieces of learning
Figure 2.3
Learning games –
the author’s view
10
Figure 2.4
Examples of some learning games which have been created
Technical corner
There are two distinct parts of the MyLearning games:
the MyLearning Author (on the PC) and the MyLearning Player
(on the PDA).
MyLearning Author is Microsoft Windows-based, developed in
Delphi. It uses an open, extensible template system to generate
learning materials. All data is stored in external, XML and data files.
Oversize images are automatically resized to fit the smaller screen.
To preview the materials, we use a small Flash player that is
based on the PocketPC player mentioned below but compiled
in a ScreenWeaver shell.
To build the PDA-installations we use CabWiz, automatically
triggered by the MyLearning Author. This creates full installations
for the three different PocketPC processor types, so it will therefore
install on almost any PocketPC.
MyLearning Player has a multilayer architecture. The outer layer
is built in C, and provides the communication between the player
and the operating system. The next layer is provided by the
internal browser. We wrap this, so we can use the free-to-download
Flash plug-in to display the visual parts. The third layer is what
you see. This menu layer (level 3) provides the login, bookmarking,
tracking, dynamic menus and the top bar and navigation. The
final layer is the content itself. This is also Flash-based, but is
loaded dynamically based on the tutor’s choice of page type,
and is easily extensible by adding new Flash players (and
xhtml templates to match in the Author).
http://portal.m-learning.org/ppc.php
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
www.nestafuturelab.org/showcase/savannah/savannah.htm
Mobile learning in practice
Technical corner
The front end web pages have been streamlined to display
smoothly both on a mobile device and on a full-size PC. The
back end of the website is built using Java and all data is held in
a MySQL database.
To receive MMS messages, we use the phone provider’s own
internet gateway to collect the MMS message directly from
the web, via e-mail. An advantage of this method is that we are
able to collect any MMS worldwide. A disadvantage is that the
providers often add advertisements or promotions to these e-mails,
thus we need to have an up-to-date filtering algorithm to extract
the message data dynamically.
mediaBoard supports pictures, audio and text. It does not currently
support video because the format sent from phones is not yet widely
playable from PCs, but when this is possible, it will be supported.
To receive and send SMS, we use the same commercial provider
as we do for the SMS quiz, above.
An internet forum is a facility on the world wide web for holding discussions
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_forum, accessed 15 August 2006).
A blog is short for a weblog, or a web page which has short and frequent
updates to it, eg it could be about links and commentary about other
websites, news or ideas, a place to write stories or show photos etc.
10 http://portal.m-learning.org/mboard.php
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Section 3 13
The pilot
One tutor used the mobile device provided, but not for anything
connected with the project.
Thus the final research group consisted of 19 tutors, all of whom
returned at least partial research data (see below). The subjects taught
represented a wide range of curricular areas (a list can be found in
Section 5.1), and students of different ability levels took part. It was hoped
that tutors working in different colleges, but in similar curriculum areas,
would consider sharing their resources and work collaboratively with
their students.
Therefore, the main focus was on the experiences of the tutors involved,
rather than that of their students (although any data received from
students was incorporated). While addressing the specific questions
above, it was necessary to collect information relating to the use of
the toolkit in order to provide a context for the findings.
Mobile learning in practice
The tutors were provided with a ring binder containing explanatory guides
to each of the tools (also available online on the extranet), and to the PDAs,
as well as background information about the project.
Section 4 17
Research approach
n their perceptions of their use of desktop computers, mobile phones and PDAs
Section 5 19
The tutors
The tutors were asked for background information about themselves which
would help to provide a context for describing their experiences later in the
project. They were asked about their teaching responsibilities, their use of
digital devices (desktop computers, mobile phones and palmtop computers),
if they had taken part in a mobile learning project previously, where they
prepared the learning materials, if they had collaborated with others in their
colleges on the project, and if they wanted to undertake further mobile learning
after the project had finished. The responses received are shown below.
5.2 Gender
The tutors who volunteered to take part were predominantly female
(14 females, or 73%, and five males, or 26%).
20 Tutors’ 6
perception
of use 5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Tutor number
Figure 5.1
Tutors’ use of desktop computers before and after the project
Tutors’ 6
perception
of use 5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Tutor number
Figure 5.2
Tutors’ use of mobile phones before and after the project
Tutors’ 6
perception
of use 5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Tutor number
Figure 5.3
Tutors use of palmtop computers before and after the project
Section 6 23
Using the SMS authoring tool
Quiz name Course of study Level of study Method of working † Curriculum fit
Accounting 2 AS Accounting and Level 3 + 2 Independently Revision
Certificate in Administration
Camera ND Media Production Level 3 Independently Half-term homework
LTDWOOD2 Numeracy national test course Level 1 Independently Revision
M-learning †† Various Various Pairs —
M TEXT †† M-learning E3–L1 Independently, Revision
pairs and groups
M TXT †† Various Entry level – level 2 — —
Parasite SMS Quiz 1 ND Animal Management Level 3 Independently Testing learning during
teaching session
PembILT Learning technology Level 3 Independently As an example of technology
Pemshardware – pemhw Applied ICT year 1 (Edexcel) Level 3 (FE) Pairs Quiz based on the
hardware and software unit
Personal Protective Preparation for work Entry level Independently Reinforced teaching about
Equipment health and safety
Sentences Literacy national test Entry level 1–3 Independently Homework
Table 6.1
SMS quiz examples, at a glance
† Independently, in pairs or in groups
†† One quiz was created by three tutors and used with different groups of students
Tutors were also asked to make comments about how the SMS
quiz games helped their students’ learning and interest in learning,
and to reflect on how they prepared the students to take part.
The following is a summary of the main points (from Appendix A)
noted by the tutors.
n The quizzes were stimulating, promoted student interest and
had a novelty value.
n Students could undertake the quizzes a number of times and
receive feedback without being in the classroom.
n The students seemed to enjoy answering the questions and
using their mobile phones to do it.
n Multiple-choice questions encourage participation, and help the
assessment and evaluation of learning, but should not be overused.
n The accompanying quiz review sheets were useful, and allowed
the students to revisit previous topics. It also meant that students
could still take part if they did not have a mobile phone, did not want
to use it, or could not use it.
n It cannot be assumed that all adult learners know how to send and
receive text messages.
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Pedagogical issues Concise, unambiguous and relevant questions (SF1, noted three times)
Contextualised content (SF1)
Interesting subject/task (SF1, SF3)
Clear instructions to students (SF1, SF2)
Right level for students (SF1, SF2)
Clear and appropriate questions (SF2, noted twice)
Quality of questions (SF3)
Relevant feedback (SF3)
Give encouraging feedback (SF3)
Helpful responses (SF3)
Good revision tool (SF3)
Include an element of fun (SF3)
Operational/technical issues Students understand how to reply (SF1)
Reception (SF1)
Access to a mobile phone (SF1)
Accessibility (SF1)
It works (SF1)
Easy to author/use (SF2, SF3)
Attractiveness (SF2)
Try quiz before students/check it works in room beforehand (SF2, SF3)
Understanding what to do (SF2)
Answers correct in the system (SF2)
Skill with device and mobile phones (SF3)
Support students to overcome problems/queries (SF3)
Interesting formats (SF3)
Cost issues Cost (SF1)
Students’ credit (SF2)
Other comments Makes learning interesting, captures imagination (SF1)
Fun (SF1)
Reinforces important principles (SF2)
Good ‘hook’ (SF2)
Prizes (SF2)
Fun for students (SF3)
Table 6.2
Tutors’ rating of the three most important factors of success for SMS quizzes
SF Success factor
It can be seen from Table 6.2 that there are a number of common
important factors, the main one being the importance of the questions
that are used (which also need to be relevant, concise, unambiguous,
easily understood, appropriate and at the right level for the students
taking part). It is also important that the task is contextualised
and interesting, and that the feedback is encouraging and helpful.
Mobile learning in practice
26 As the questions are devised by the tutors and may be used without
the students being located in the same space, this would seem crucial.
The tutors also placed importance on operational and technical issues
such as the system needing to be attractive and easy to use and also
needing to work both as regards network reception and on a local basis.
Other comments included that students regarded its use as fun and
interesting, and it could capture their imagination.
Thus the tutor could see the answers to the learning materials received
from each mobile phone number. Seven tutors stated that they made
use of this feature. Those who did commented:
I found this excellent as I could monitor the learners’ progress and
evaluate which learners were using the service.
This was great!
I looked at the report for the first quiz but didn’t print it out.
This is an interesting feature.
[I] need more practice.
Tutors did not use it because:
I was with the students as they got feedback.
There was not much point as most had used my mobile device.
I found the reporting tool a little confusing.
However:
Although [I] did not use [it], I feel that this is an important functionality
as [we] could use [it] for NVQ evidence as long as candidates were
monitored [to ensure] that it was their work.
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
28 Section 7
Using the MyLearning games
Game name Course of study Level of study Method of working † Curriculum fit
Different Organisations Business Retail Introductory Independently Well – covering this in unit
Pairs games
and Administration
Hardware Applied ICT year 1 (Edexcel) 3 Pairs Yes – they were doing hardware,
software and web development
Job Skills Preparation for work Entry Pairs Reinforcement
PPE1 Preparation for work Entry Pairs Reinforcing work done on
health and safety
Special Needs Childcare NVQ 3 Independently Used while waiting for others
to finish a task set
Superstitions (Game 1) †† EFL Elementary Independently Brilliant (British culture)
Superstitions (Game 2) †† ESOL Level 1 Pairs Summary of work
previously covered
Guess Who? ESOL Level 1 Pairs Learning about British culture
Snap games
session
Editing ND Media Production 3 Independently Used as a question-and-answer
session
Web Development Applied ICT year 1 (Edexcel) 3 Pairs Yes – they were doing hardware,
software and web development
Table 7.1
Learning game examples, at a glance
† Independently, pairs or groups
†† Game played with two groups of students
Tutors were also asked to make comments about how the learning games
helped their students’ learning and interest in learning, and to reflect on
how they prepared the students to take part. The following is a summary
of the main points noted by the tutors from Appendix B.
n Students can become competitive when playing the games.
Meaningfulness of the game – relevance to course (SF1) Need good images (SF2) Visual (SF2)
Games need to be relevant (SF2) Good clear images (SF2)
Relevance (SF3) Good ‘hook’ (SF2)
Keep it simple (SF1) Shorten time to view cards (SF3)
Needs to be a challenge (SF1) Having time to download to various PDAs (SF3)
Level of difficulty/level of difficulty not so easy as to be trivial (SF1, SF2)
Appropriate (SF1)
Appropriate subject (SF1, SF2)
Accessibility (SF1)
Interest (SF2)
Needs to be used briefly, as part of a lesson (SF3)
Occupying task until others have finished (SF3)
Understandable (SF3)
Clear words (SF3)
Good revision tool (SF3)
Needs to be a challenge (SF1) Photos need to be the right size (SF1) Fun (SF1)
Snap games
Meaningfulness of the game – relevance to course (SF1) Good ‘hook’ (SF2) Visual (SF2)
Relevant (SF1) Have more cards than less (SF3)
Needs to be made to students’ level (SF1) Stop running all the other programs first (SF3)
Don’t be too specific as limits use (SF2) Have time to download to various PDAs (SF3)
Level of difficulty – not so easy as to be trivial (SF2) Easy to use (SF3)
Best as an introduction or plenary (SF2) Easy to create (SF3)
Made to fit into existing lessons (SF2)
Good revision (SF3)
Feedback needs to be relevant and useful (SF1) Clarity of instructions (SF1) Fun (SF1)
Quiz games
It can be seen from the above that there are a number of common 31
important factors, the main one being to ensure that the use of the
games is appropriate and relevant, in terms of the level of learning and
the subject studied. In some cases it needs to be a challenge, in others
simple, but it is important to watch out that it does not become trivial.
The feedback given automatically to the students also needs to be useful.
Learning games can also be used as an introduction to a subject, used in
a plenary session, or used as an occupying task or a revision tool.
The tutors also placed importance on operational and technical issues
which have been noted in the tips section below.
32 Section 8
Using the mediaBoard
33
mediaBoard name Course of study Level of study Method of working † Curriculum fit
C24 NVQ Childcare 2 Pairs It was part of an underpinning
knowledge lesson for a
unit relating to communication
Haverfordwest EFL Elementary Pairs Very well – it was
an orientation exercise
ILT Learning technology Level 3 Independently As part of the curriculum
LTD Learning Centre Not applicable as mediaBoard created as example for staff only
Original Creations Young enterprise Level 1 Independently It allowed them to communicate
and groups about their business
Selby1 ND Media Production 3 Groups Added to Single Camera 3 project
Table 8.1
mediaBoard examples, at a glance
† Independently, pairs or groups
Tutors were also asked to make comments about how the learning games
helped their students’ learning and interest in learning, and to reflect on
how they prepared the students to take part. The following is a summary of
the main points noted by the tutors from Appendix C. It will also be seen
that many tutors experienced problems with sending MMS messages,
and these comments have not been included here.
n It was a fun and practical way to present learning.
n The students enjoyed getting out of the classroom and using ILT.
Section 9 35
Other uses of the devices by the tutors
The tutors were asked to use as many aspects of the toolkit (but a
minimum of one) with their students as possible. Three tutors used
the PDAs specifically for other things not associated with the toolkit,
which became clear as the project unfolded, and a separate questionnaire
was included to capture these data. The following are the findings.
36 Section 10
Students using their own mobile devices
for SMS and MMS
10.1 The students’ use of their own mobile phones to take part
Nine tutors stated that their learners used their own mobile devices
when taking part in the project. Of those who did, three offered
further comments (NB: the first comment is in relation to the tutor’s
use of the mediaBoard):
This was sometimes difficult due to the different types of phones and
features. Because I had to give students instructions on how they should
type the text in to get to the right areas, I found that it took a while or
we were not able to send the information because I didn’t understand
how their phones worked. Neither did some of the more mature students!
I used SMS quizzes as all students had and regularly used mobile phones.
This ensured inclusive practice.
The majority of students did not have any credit on their phones,
which limited their ability to participate.
And two tutors whose students did not use their own
mobile phones commented:
They said they didn’t have enough credit.
I don’t agree with having to make learners use own devices.
Many of my students barely have enough credit/money.
Regarding the last point above, it was never the intention of the project
partners that the students would be required to meet the costs of
their participation in the project when sending SMS or MMS messages.
Section 3.7 details some of the different ways of reimbursing the students
which were discussed with the tutors before the project took place, and
Section 10.2 below notes the feedback from the tutors after the project
had finished. However, the above does underline the importance of the
students having prior credit on their mobile phones in order to take part.
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
37
38 Section 11
The impact of mobile learning on teaching
The teachers were asked how the use of mobile learning impacted on
their teaching. It can be seen below that, while some tutors gave answers
directly related to their teaching and their students’ learning, others
concentrated more upon the use of the technology.
The tutors who answered in relation to their teaching (and students’
learning), and with different groups of students, responded:
It added another dimension/ It was a novel way to consolidate
resource to my teaching. and assess knowledge. However,
It was useful in consolidating it took a long time to set up and
language structures and explain to learners how to use.
vocabulary particularly.
Due to it being new and different
It allowed me to investigate the it took some thought on how to fit it
viability of using mobile learning into the lessons. Some felt artificial
to teach students with SEN because I had to shoe horn it into
[special educational needs]. a lesson where it would have been
better used at another time.
I found the quiz aspect of
the PDA especially good for Added an extra dimension.
question-and-answer sessions. Took the students away from
It was also a new piece of the computer screen.
technology to use as a treat
with the students. The SMS quizzes were great as
a review on previous topics. One
The idea of being able to get learner loved the fact that she could
instant feedback was great – no get instant feedback at home.
need to mark it – it was automatic. The majority of my learners were
aged 35+ and therefore most
Students enjoyed interactivity – were still getting to grips with
good hook – helps establish text messages. One learner said
initial engagement with learners. that she couldn’t text at all and
The use of the mobile toolkit most of the learners preferred to
brought about a change of mindset write their answers down and hand
in how the students could get the sheet back to me. In the end
involved. Mobile devices were, all of them had a go on the text.
instead of being a distraction, now Mary, the lady who said she
being brought in by the students couldn’t text, did send me a
to the learning environment. message at the end of the course
A useful device that could saying thank you, which was from
engage the student in learning. my encouragement of using text.
Enabled the introduction of I did use the XDA units for the
bilingual learning in a subtle way. learning games as a break from
the teaching activities, which the
Increases engagement when it works. learners enjoyed. I find that the
It helped to broaden the learning units/games support the learning
in the class room, but it needed process in a fun way. I also used the
a lot of prep [preparation] time camera to create learning materials
and reception for sending quizzes using photos of everyday objects
was an issue. for fractions, for example.
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Some tutors related it directly to their use (or not) of the technology 39
and that of their students:
Students really enjoyed playing Because of the technical problems
with the phones and on occasions there was very little time to
it was difficult to keep them try them out and then they
focused on the task/learning! didn’t always work with students.
I spent so much time preparing the This was very frustrating. But when
games and it was over so quickly! they worked they were good fun.
(Noted by two tutors)
I think the industry day would have
been more successful had we had My discussions with students
more points [electrical sockets] on the access course would lead
in the cabin that we were given. me to the conclusion that with
The learners that we had enjoyed this group and their level of skills,
working with the devices and the use of SMS would be the
I think that they could be an asset most suitable. It is the technology
to the learners for revision. However they are the most comfortable with,
they are expensive and the and were excited about the
practicality of them taking the possibilities. Many students
devices home and then returning taking this module would not
them undamaged would be slim. had have a great deal of experience
The devices are quite delicate of the use of technology (hence
and also the daily charging can the reason to take the module)
cause a problem to ensure that and linking it to technology that
the memory is not lost – you know they have become aware of
what forgetful teenagers are like! would be extremely beneficial.
(Noted by two tutors) (The group involved in the discussions
were in their late 20s early 30s,
It made it easier instead of and were wishing to take up learning
using cameras and tape recorders, after leaving school at 16/18
but it was difficult to have only without many qualifications.
one, and some classes found it All of the students were female.)
too small to read.
Thus it can be seen that most tutors did not answer this question
in a general way but related their answers to their specific use of
the toolkit. It can be summarised as follows.
Mobile learning impacted on the tutors’ teaching because it can:
n add another dimension or resource to teaching and learning
n it can take time to set up activities, particularly for the first time,
and explain to students how to use them
n reception for sending responses to SMS quizzes can be an issue
Section 12 41
The impact of mobile learning on
students’ learning
The tutors were asked how the use of mobile learning impacted
on their students’ learning. It can be seen below that some tutors
gave answers directly related to their students’ learning, others
concentrated on the associated issue of their students’ interest in
learning, and others more on the mastery of the technology.
The tutors who answered in relation to their students’ learning responded:
It helped them cement structures The learners enjoyed using the
worked on in class. It motivated them XDA/PDA units in the classroom.
to do activities set as homework. They are good to use as a 10-minute
Using SMS quizzes meant they break session from worksheets.
could do their homework anywhere, The SMS review sheets were
even in the canteen at work, very useful and the learners learnt
without embarrassment from a lot from them as they reviewed
their peers. Receiving immediate previous sessions. The learner
feedback from the SMS quizzes who did use the text messages
enabled them to become more did find the instant feedback very
autonomous in their learning and useful and it allowed her to try again
able to monitor their own progress. if she got an answer wrong.
Learning was now taking place and They enjoyed the new learning
linking to the student’s activities environment but completed the
outside the classroom and in tasks very quickly. It’s ideal as a
quite a direct way to the students plenary, to confirm that learning
themselves. The mobile quiz has taken place.
reminder, for example, brought the
student’s mind back to that week’s It added a further dimension to the
activities when they may have had learning experience of the students.
completely different things going on They saw it as a novelty and it
in their mind! Is this harassment would have been better if I had
or learning? – I like to think that it is introduced it at the beginning of
a useful memory-jogging technique! the course – as part of learning,
I believe that the use of SMS rather than because it is a project.
at revision-type questions, and
technique reminders would be
beneficial [for a new course module
running from September 2006].
Section 13 43
Integrating the mobile learning toolkit
into the curriculum
The tutors were asked about the ease with which the mobile learning
toolkit was integrated into the curriculum. It can be seen below
that some tutors gave answers directly related to its integration
into the curriculum, while another noted that the timing of the
research had an effect on this, and others noted technical issues.
The tutors who answered in relation to curriculum integration responded:
No problems with integrating the I found it quite easy to integrate
use of the toolkit into the curriculum, the use of the mobile learning
with specific examples. toolkit into the curriculum except
for the time factor involved in
No difficulties in integrating this creating the activities.
at all – fits easily into any lesson plan.
As I teach media production, the
Fine – integrated with ease. camera function of the PDA fitted in
Easily, because you could tailor naturally. Using the quiz aspect to
the games to the class subjects. find out how much the students
had learnt was a more novel way
It was easy to integrate the quizzes of question(s) and answer(s).
into the curriculum, as I used the
XDA games as a break from The aim was to produce an
traditional learning methods and e-learning module to develop
the SMS quizzes as homework ICT skills for mature students
and extended learning activities. wishing to progress on to university.
This is, in the majority of cases,
This was one of the easier things a culture change for the students.
we had to do. I can see no reason It is therefore beneficial for them
why these activities can not be used to experience various forms of
easily with Health, Social Care and learning, and the SMS [activities]
Childcare students. would be fully integrated into
Apart from the prep [preparation] the module.
time and reception signal, it was It was only introduced into the
easy to use the toolkit. curriculum when the games were
The amount of time it took to create created to help with revision or
the m-learning activities meant help students understand a topic
that it was difficult to create lots – more clearly.
but thinking of tests was not too bad. SMS – useful for quick formative
assessments and testing that
learning had taken place.
Due to [previous] m-learning project,
[the] integration of [the] toolkit was
not an issue.
Mobile learning in practice
Section 14 45
Tutors’ views of the value of mobile learning
Section 15 47
Tutors’ views of the cost-effectiveness
of using handheld computers for learning
48 Yes if you just have one per department rather than individual.
It would be difficult to get top-ups as you would end up having
to pay for these as a tutor. As a substitute for cameras/recorders,
it would be cost-effective, but if an institution already has these
I don’t see how it would be cost-effective.
Concerns re cost. However, this may become less of an issue
as services become cheaper.
Difficult to comment. The initial outlay of the equipment may be
expensive and I wonder how often the equipment would become
outdated and need updating?
In regard to prep [preparation] time, sadly no, it’s not cost-effective,
as so much time is needed to set them up. This may reduce as
it becomes familiar.
I think that for what they do they are expensive. You could buy
a basic laptop and digital camera which would be able to do
nearly all the same functions.
Not sure of costs involved here, so can’t really comment on that.
As technology advances though, prices tend to fall, so likely to be
more cost-effective.
Two tutors linked their answer to one noted previously in Section 14
about technical issues (‘they have huge potential…’) and also that they
would like to plan to use mobile learning in the future but ‘only if funding
were available as more devices are costly and we would need the
IT department to support us’. However, these tutors also stated that it
is cost-effective because it ‘can reduce paper! However if the technology
lets you down then you have to resort to [a] paper base.’
Thus in summing up the tutors’ perception of the cost-effectiveness
of mobile learning, the following points can be made.
n Once mobile phone technology catches up with other handheld
technology, it needs to be creatively used in the learning process
to achieve cost effectiveness.
n Costs were not considered an issue when few SMS/MMS were sent,
or where messages were considered cheap to send in order to facilitate
interaction with the learning activities.
n Cost was considered an issue when it might discourage participation
(eg in SMS quizzes), and it was observed that the learners could be
involved in similar activities via virtual learning environments while
in college without incurring extra costs.
n The price of the PDAs were of concern to some tutors. However,
it was recognised that such costs would probably fall in the near future.
n Cost was also perceived in terms of the preparation time required
to set up the learning activities.
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Section 16 49
Mobile learning – changing attitudes to
learning, teaching and mobile technology
Section 17 51
Tutors’ feedback on technical support
The aim of the helpline function was to ensure that any problems were
addressed and resolved before having a possible negative impact upon
the experiences and enthusiasm of tutors and learners. Support was
available by telephone, e-mail and mobile phone. Help was also available
via the project’s extranet. Here tutors could place messages asking
for assistance, upload files for others to view or share problems.
In addition to the help offered by LSDA and Tribal CTAD, a consultant
worked with three colleges to assist with any device-related problems
where it was difficult to resolve these remotely. Five tutors also contacted
network providers for direct assistance. Such help was almost entirely
required in relation to the difficulties experienced with sending and receiving
MMS messages and the settings required for this to happen.
In the final questionnaire the tutors were asked for comments
on the support provided. The following comments were received:
Good/excellent assistance by LSDA staff.
Always extremely helpful, instantly.
I received a response very quickly.
I contacted LSDA / [Tribal] CTAD and got prompt responses.
The service was very efficient by both LSDA and [Tribal] CTAD.
They were very efficient in dealing with any queries and support required.
Excellent. Very helpful, tried very hard to resolve any issue promptly.
Staff always available and helpful. Good response time, thanks. (Two tutors)
Other tutors commented specifically on the extranet:
Excellent backup via messageboard with prompt responses.
Discuss[ion] board is good but getting time to post a message was
a problem. Participants responded quickly.
And other tutors who noted the role of the coordinator in their college:
The assistance given was fine, but some problems took a while to
sort out, which was frustrating. I did rely on [name of coordinator]
to iron out the problems and give me the up-to-date information.
[Name of coordinator] passed on any advice she was given
in relation to the toolkit. This was very helpful.
One tutor had more complicated problems which took some time
to sort out:
The assistance given was fine, but some problems took a while
to sort out, which was frustrating.
From the above, it would seem that the tutors were largely happy with
the help service offered by LSDA and Tribal CTAD, although one tutor
noted a lack of technical assistance at one of the training events.
Mobile learning in practice
52 Section 18
Findings and lessons learned
The overall response from tutors was very positive. They were able to
use the toolkit to produce learning materials which were relevant
to the specific needs of their students in their particular context.
A wide range of games, activities and quizzes was created for students
of different ability levels (from elementary or entry levels, to NVQ levels
1, 2 and 3 and AS and National Diploma level) in a variety of curriculum areas
(Accounting and Certificate in Administration, Animal Management,
Applied ICT course, Childcare, Business, Retail and Administration courses,
English as a Foreign Language and English for Speakers of Other Languages,
Learning Technology, Literacy, Media Production, Numeracy, Preparation
for Work and Young Enterprise), Samples of these games can be found
in the appendices.
These resources were created by tutors whose experience and
competence with handheld ICT devices was very varied, ie a quarter
had never used a palmtop computer previously while others were
regular users of such devices.
n It can take time to set up activities, particularly for the first time,
and explain to students how to use them.
n Reception for sending responses to SMS quizzes can be an issue.
n The students help one another to use the PDAs, thus reinforcing their learning.
However, two tutors stated that they considered that the use of
the toolkit did not help their students’ learning.
Question 3 How did the tutors integrate the use of the mobile learning toolkit
into the curriculum?
Section 13 of this report has noted the tutors’ responses to this question.
These can be summarised as follows.
n Most tutors considered that mobile learning could be integrated with ease
into their existing curricula.
n Some tutors noted that preparation time was a factor limiting
their use of the toolkit.
n SMS quizzes could be used for extended learning activities, homework,
question-and-answer sessions and quick formative assessments
to check that learning had taken place.
n Games were created to help with revision, or more clarity in
understanding a topic.
n The integration could be affected by the timing of the curriculum,
eg useful for exam practice.
n Tutors should have alternative ways of presenting lesson materials
in case of technical problems.
Mobile learning in practice
n Costs were not considered an issue when few SMS/MMS were sent,
or where messages were considered cheap to send in order to
facilitate interaction with the learning activities.
n Cost was considered to be an issue which might prohibit participation,
although it was expected that this would be lower in the near future.
n Cost was also perceived in terms of the preparation time required
to set up the learning activities.
The tutors were asked to rate the three most important factors 55
contributing to the success of SMS quizzes. The main factor was found
to be the questions used. These need to be relevant, concise, unambiguous,
easily understood and appropriate, as well as pitched at the right level
for the students. Also, contextualised and interesting tasks are necessary,
and feedback must be encouraging and helpful. The tutors commented
on operational and technical issues, for example, stressing that the
system needs to be attractive, easy to use and working (in terms of
both network reception and resolution of any local technical problems).
They also felt that the quizzes should be fun and interesting for
the students in order to capture their imagination.
Learning games
Authoring learning games was found to be ‘very easy’, ‘easy’, or ‘fine’
by tutors, who in total created 31 games which were played 288 times
(124 for the pairs game, 92 for the snap games and 72 for the quiz games).
The tutors reported that:
n the students can become competitive when playing the games
n playing the games captures their interest and can be challenging
14 http://forum.xda-developers.com/viewtopic.php?t=24779
15 The newest PDA/PocketPC devices (that run Microsoft Windows Mobile 5)
do not suffer from this problem.
Mobile learning in practice
60 Section 19
Conclusions
Section 20
Note for tutors who may be interested in
using the mobile learning toolkit
References 61
62 Further reading
Appendix A 63
Examples of the SMS quizzes created
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped It was revision and they had to work it out although it
the students’ learning was multiple choice – I don’t think you should overuse this,
as multiple choice is unrealistic in their exams
How the use of the quiz helped —
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on I would have preferred this if you were not reliant
A how s/he prepared the students on the students’ mobiles. The only way you could do
to take part, B how s/he organised that is if they used the PDA, although you wouldn’t know
the use of mobile devices and what each person had achieved
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped It did help
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped The students seemed to enjoy answering the questions
the students’ interest in learning and using their mobile phones to do it
Reflections by the tutor on I was quite aware of the cost implications, although
A how s/he prepared the students the students were less so! It perhaps would have been
to take part, B how s/he organised more effective to get them to undertake the quiz on
the use of mobile devices and the XDA’s SIM cards. Although it was an effective task
C whether this was appropriate for them to undertake in half-term
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped The SMS quiz review sheets were extremely useful to the students’ learning
the students’ learning as they were able to revisit previous topics. They liked the fact that there were
only five questions and multiple choice so it encouraged them to have a go.
Not all of them did the quiz on the SMS, most of them kept answering the
questions on paper and giving it back to me the next week
How the use of the quiz helped Some students enjoyed the SMS part but most of the students either didn’t know
the students’ interest in learning how to text or were reluctant to use SMS. In the end all of them had a go on
the SMS quiz but they said they preferred to answer the questions on paper
Reflections by the tutor on I showed the learners with my own mobile how they answer the questions and text
A how s/he prepared the students their answers. The learners used their own mobile phones to answer the quizzes.
to take part, B how s/he organised I think [if] I was to do it again I might ask them to try it first on the XDA unit,
the use of mobile devices and free of charge for a trial run, so they know how to do it on their own phone,
C whether this was appropriate as some of the learners got confused at first as to how to send the messages.
and any changes they would make Due to the learners’ age most of them were unfamiliar with texting.
if this was to be repeated With a group with younger learners they wouldn’t have had a problem as they are
used to sending messages and answering questions via quizzes using their phone
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped I couldn’t say
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped The session was more engaging
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on Used it to check initial understanding and then again
A how s/he prepared the students to check that they had learned something
to take part, B how s/he organised
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutor’s comments
How the use of the quiz helped The students managed to get 4 or 5 out of 5 the first time,
the students’ learning then they all got 5 out of 5 if they got 4 before
How the use of the quiz helped They were excited by the thought of using the PDA to text,
the students’ interest in learning but not so much in the content of the SMS quiz
Reflections by the tutor on I assumed that the students would know exactly how
A how s/he prepared the students to enter the SMS message, considering that many
to take part, B how s/he organised television programmes use SMS to enter competitions.
the use of mobile devices and But many of them had problems
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
1 2 3 4
C If you are a fast-food operator, which
piece of protective clothing or equipment
would you use?
1 2 3 4
D If you are working on a building site, which
piece of protective clothing or equipment Automated answers
would you use? Number of
correct answers
0 1 2 3 4 5 Feedback
n Oh dear!
1 2 3 4
n n You wouldn’t be very safe
E If you are welding, which piece of protective n Not too bad, but you need to
clothing or equipment would you use? find out the correct PPE
n Good. You should be safe
most of the time
n Very good
1 2 3 4
Tutor’s comments
How the use of the quiz helped It would have helped if students had a lot of difficulty
the students’ learning and then found out the answers
How the use of the quiz helped The students enjoyed using their phones,
the students’ interest in learning which made them more interested in learning
Reflections by the tutor on A I asked them if they would like to use mobile phones
A how s/he prepared the students in the classroom and explained how the quiz worked.
to take part, B how s/he organised B The students that had credit used their phones
the use of mobile devices and and the rest used my PocketPCs.
C whether this was appropriate C To use it again I would need to ensure that
and any changes they would make I had enough mobile devices for students to use,
if this was to be repeated either individually or in pairs
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped They did not learn from doing the quizzes, however I used it
the students’ learning as a way of assessing the learning
How the use of the quiz helped Yes, they really enjoyed the novelty of using the texts
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on Introduced at the end of a session for homework.
A how s/he prepared the students Not enough time to individually demonstrate.
to take part, B how s/he organised Learners confirmed their understanding, however
the use of mobile devices and [I] didn’t receive any texts this week. Had to then spend
C whether this was appropriate a lot of time explaining again how to do it
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Appendix B 73
Examples of learning games created
Pairs games
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped —
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped I think it helped with interest – this group has
the students’ interest in learning a short attention span at the best of times,
new things enhance their interest
Reflections by the tutor on They had already done a task with the PDA.
A how s/he prepared the students So they had a go with the PDA individually
to take part, B how s/he organised whilst doing another task
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped The students learned new terms
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped The students were competitive and found it challenging
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on —
A how s/he prepared the students
to take part, B how s/he organised
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped —
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped —
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on —
A how s/he prepared the students
to take part, B how s/he organised
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped Reinforcement
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped Raised interest by allowing another form of learning
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on A We talked about how to play pairs with cards
A how s/he prepared the students and then related it to the mobile game.
to take part, B how s/he organised B My device was passed around the class.
the use of mobile devices and C I would have liked a device for each student
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped The images in the game helped them to remember
the students’ learning the information
How the use of the quiz helped They enjoyed using the equipment and playing the game
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on A Showed them the XDA and demonstrated how
A how s/he prepared the students the game worked.
to take part, B how s/he organised B Used the mobile device with one student at a time
the use of mobile devices and while the group was completing a different activity.
C whether this was appropriate C This was appropriate for this group at level 2, but
and any changes they would make it may not be as useful to use more than occasionally
if this was to be repeated with a level 3 group. It worked well for differentiation
Mobile learning in practice
Snap games 79
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped This was a fun recapping activity on their
the students’ learning learning of previous weeks
How the use of the quiz helped
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on A Explained with a demo.
A how s/he prepared the students B Had PDAs for them to use.
to take part, B how s/he organised C Yes, appropriate
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped This was a fun recapping activity on their
the students’ learning learning of previous weeks
How the use of the quiz helped
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on A Explained with a demo.
A how s/he prepared the students B Had PDAs for them to use.
to take part, B how s/he organised C Yes, appropriate
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped The students learned new terms
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped The students were competitive and found it challenging
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on The students found the concept difficult at first
A how s/he prepared the students but then found it interesting
to take part, B how s/he organised
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
82 Quiz games
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped It was used in question-and-answer sessions
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped I feel the XDA made this question-and-answer session
the students’ interest in learning more attractive to the students
Reflections by the tutor on I initially tried this by passing the XDA around the class.
A how s/he prepared the students All the students took to this and there was a bit of
to take part, B how s/he organised a competition about who was going to use it next
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
83
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped It was used in question-and-answer sessions
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped I feel the XDA made this question-and-answer session
the students’ interest in learning more attractive to the students
Reflections by the tutor on —
A how s/he prepared the students
to take part, B how s/he organised
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the quiz helped The students learned new terms
the students’ learning
How the use of the quiz helped The students were competitive and found it challenging
the students’ interest in learning
Reflections by the tutor on —
A how s/he prepared the students
to take part, B how s/he organised
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Appendix C 85
Examples of mediaBoards created
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the mediaBoard This was a fun way to look at verbal and
helped the students’ learning non-verbal communication
How the use of the mediaBoard They enjoyed using the technology so enjoyed the learning
helped the students’ interest
in learning
Reflections by the tutor on We were looking at verbal and non-verbal communication
A how s/he prepared the students with children. The learners were asked if they would
to take part, B how s/he organised take part in the activity. It was decided that one group
the use of mobile devices and could use the tutor’s XDA and the other groups their
C whether this was appropriate own phones. The students found it fun to take the pictures
and any changes they would make but we struggled to use their own phones to send the
if this was to be repeated messages. I was not familiar with them so we found it
difficult to attach the MMS messages to send. In the end
we re-took the images and sent them via the XDA
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the mediaBoard No
helped the students’ learning
How the use of the mediaBoard No, but that is because it didn’t work
helped the students’ interest [MMS is routed via network providers, and was not
in learning always reliable – Section 18.2.4 discusses this point]
Reflections by the tutor on Use of the mediaBoard was difficult to explain.
A how s/he prepared the students A printout of the board with precise details
to take part, B how s/he organised of how to send messages to each zone
the use of mobile devices and alongside each zone [would have helped]
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Piloting a mobile learning teachers’ toolkit in further education colleges
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the mediaBoard —
helped the students’ learning
How the use of the mediaBoard —
helped the students’ interest
in learning
Reflections by the tutor on It was created to show other people in the college
A how s/he prepared the students how useful it would be for induction, but I did not
to take part, B how s/he organised try it with students
the use of mobile devices and
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the mediaBoard It would have helped if it had worked
helped the students’ learning
How the use of the mediaBoard I think that it would have increased the students’ learning
helped the students’ interest if they had found it satisfactory
in learning
Reflections by the tutor on A We talked about the use of the internet and mobile phones
A how s/he prepared the students in their business (they were keen to take pictures
to take part, B how s/he organised with their phones and send them to the mediaBoard).
the use of mobile devices and B The students chose to use their own mobiles.
C whether this was appropriate C This would have been good as they could have sent pictures
and any changes they would make that they had taken to share with the rest of the group
if this was to be repeated
Mobile learning in practice
Tutors’ comments
How the use of the mediaBoard —
helped the students’ learning
How the use of the mediaBoard As it didn’t work, it didn’t really add anything
helped the students’ interest
in learning
Further comments This tutor stated, ‘I created a mediaBoard and tested
it and it worked. My students’ pictures did not appear,
and I did not have enough time to chase it up’
Reflections by the tutor on I borrowed an XDA (so I had two with SIM cards). I had
A how s/he prepared the students real problems and the images did not get to the website
to take part, B how s/he organised [MMS is routed via network providers, and was not
the use of mobile devices and always reliable – Section 18.2.4 discusses this point]
C whether this was appropriate
and any changes they would make
if this was to be repeated
UK college tutors taking part in the mobile learning
teachers’ toolkit project authored their own mobile learning
materials (SMS quizzes, PDA learning games and mediaBoard
activities) to cater for the specific needs of their students
in their particular learning context. This publication reports
on the impact of these mobile learning activities on
teaching, learning and students’ interest in learning and
on how tutors integrated mobile learning into the curriculum.
The challenges of setting up the project and some lessons
learned are also discussed. Examples of the learning materials
created and tips for using these tools with students are
included to inform teachers who may be considering
mobile learning for their students