Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gerontology 2008;54:224231
DOI: 10.1159/000133565
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecologic Nursing, Florence Nightingale School of Nursing, and
Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Istanbul Medical Faculty, Istanbul University, and
c
Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Nursing, Marmara University, Istanbul, Turkey
b
Key Words
Urinary incontinence Bladder training Kegel exercises
Old age
Abstract
Background: Urinary incontinence is an annoying, uncomfortable and unpleasant condition affecting the elderly. The
problem of bedwetting and other urinary complaints are
common in rest homes. Objective: Our study aimed to determine the efficiency of bladder training and Kegel exercises for older women living in a rest home. Methods: This is
an experimental prospective research study. Through a randomization process, 25 women were included in the treatment group, and another 25 were included in the control
group. Participants were living in a rest home for women
aged older than 65 years with urinary complaints. The pretreatment interview form, Quality of Life Scale, Mini-Mental
Test, Rankin Scale, daily urinary forms and pad tests were
administered to the treatment and control groups. Bladder
training and Kegel exercises were given to the treatment
group for 68 weeks. The second evaluation was performed
8 weeks after treatment, and the last evaluation was carried
out 6 months after treatment. Results: The average age of
the treatment group was 78.88 8 4.80 years, and the average age of the control group 79.44 8 5.32 years. Urgency,
frequency and nocturia were common complaints. Pretreat-
Introduction
0.78
0.80
0.80
0.99
0.90
0
0.87
0.90
0.83
0.81
0.89
0.89
0.99
0.94
0
0.93
0.93
0.91
0.94
0.69
1
0.98
0.73
0.98
0.86
0.82
1
0.99
0.85
0.99
The problem of bedwetting and other urinary complaints are common in rest homes. Urinary incontinence
is seen in 30% of elderly patients in hospitals and in approximately 5070% of elderly persons living in rest
homes [2, 5]. In a prevalence study that was conducted in
rest homes belonging to state institutions in Istanbul,
Aslan et al. [6] found that 43.4% of females and 20.9% of
males suffered urinary incontinence with a mean duration of symptoms of five years. The majority of elderly
persons with complaints of urinary incontinence did not
seek treatment because of the thought that urinary incontinence is something to be ashamed of, and the perception that it is natural to experience it in old age [5, 7].
A wide range of treatment options are available in
terms of conservative treatment techniques for elderly
patients who are incontinent. These treatment techniques
may lead to a decrease in complaints of up to 3050%, and
this effect can last 12 months [2]. Independent continence
is the desired result in the treatment of urinary incontinence. Achieving this will not be as rapid as social continence (dryness with the use of tools). Dependant continence (dryness with the assistance of others) is an appropriate and realistic option for female patients. The patient
will be able to remain dry with various coping strategies,
such as realizing the need to urinate and finding a toilet,
mobility and skillfulness. When success is achieved, the
elderly person will feel self-confident and happy [2]. There
are no studies on behavioral therapy in women with uriBladder Training and Kegel Exercises for
Older Women
Methods
Our experimental prospective research study aimed to determine the efficiency of bladder training and Kegel exercises for
women of 65 years of age and above with urinary complaints, living at a rest home.
The study was conducted at the Turkish Republic Pension
Fund Nisbetiye Rest and Nursing Home between November 2002
and January 2004. This institution was selected due to its sufficient number of cases for the sample and the high educational
level of the cases. Permission to conduct the study was received by
the management, and ethics board approval was granted by the
ethics council of the rest home.
In order to obtain results for the study, the researcher administered the pretreatment interview form, Quality of Life Scale [8],
Mini-Mental Test [9] and the Rankin Scale [10]. The King Health
Questionnaire, which was adapted appropriately in terms of language in accordance with recommendations received from experts, and the Mini-Mental Test were administered twice to 25
women living at the rest home (between 1 November and 20 November 2002), with a 2-week interval in order to determine the
test-retest reliability (the changing of tested values over time) and
internal consistency (testing each concept in each item with the
same distribution). The results of test-retest reliability of the
scales are presented in table 1.
Women filled in the urinary forms daily in Turkish. All stages
of the study were applied by an experienced nurse (the first author). She is a competent and experienced urogynecology nurse,
and is a doctorate student in obstetric and gynecologic nursing.
Women in the rest home were visited 34 times a week. The first
evaluation of women for the diagnosis of urinary incontinence
and their education took approximately 1 h and follow-up visits
lasted 1530 min.
The presence and degree of incontinence was assessed with the
ICS 1-hour pad test [11]. Digital palpation was used to assess the
pelvic floor muscle strength. Pelvic floor muscle strength was evaluated by digital evaluation using a scale from 1 to 5 where: 0 = unable to contract; 1/5 = trace contraction !2 s; 2/5 = weak contraction 63 s; 3/5 = moderate contraction 46 s, posterior elevation of
fingers, repeated 3 times; 4/5 = strong contraction 79 s, posterior
elevation of fingers, repeated 45 times; 5/5 = very strong contraction 610 s, posterior elevation of fingers, repeated 45 times.
Urine analysis was conducted to identify the presence of infection. Interviews with the elderly women were randomized by assigning 1 case to the treatment group and 1 case to the control
group according to the order of applications received (fig. 1). Both
groups were randomized using envelopes.
Criteria for the inclusion of the cases in the study sample:
To have lived in the rest home for at least 6 months.
To have regular complaints of urinary wetting, urgency, frequency or nocturia. Urgency was defined as a sudden compel-
Gerontology 2008;54:224231
225
226
Gerontology 2008;54:224231
Received intervention = 64
Treatment = 33
Refused to participate = 12
Control = 31
Treatment
Dropped = 7
Died = 1
Control
Dropped = 5
Died = 1
Analyzed = 25
Analyzed = 25
serving a schedule that was consistent with their current micturition interval. It was requested that the patients urinated only at
the times defined by the program during waking hours. It was
recommended that the patients try to refrain from urination until the scheduled time for urination came, even if they felt the need
to urinate. In addition, they were taught ways to overcome the
urge when the need to urinate emerged, e.g. taking deep breaths,
solving crossword puzzles, playing mind games. As the patient
gained adequate control in the periods that were determined, the
periods in-between were increased to 30 min each week and the
regular times to urinate were increased gradually to 34 h. The
procedure for recording on the continence card the times they
urinated or wet themselves was explained. During those 8 weeks,
weekly meetings were held with the women and the program for
the next week was scheduled. If there were difficulties using the
program, then the same program was administered unchanged in
the next week. The women were encouraged to abide by the program as closely as possible during bladder training. The bladder
training and the PFME were not mentioned to the control
group.
Eight weeks after the first meeting, the first follow-up was
conducted; the second follow-up was conducted 6 months after
the first meeting. In these visits, the urinary complaints were
evaluated, the monitoring form and the daily urinary form were
filled in, the quality of life scale and the pad test were administered, and measurements of the pelvic floor muscle strength were
conducted.
Age, years
7079
8089
Education
Primary school
High school
University
Marital Status
Never married
Divorced
Widowed
Married and living with their partner
Time living in the rest home, years
The number of persons in the room
1
2
Presence of chronic illnesses
Yes
No
Treatment (n = 25)
Control (n = 25)
Total (n = 50)
14
11
56
44
12
13
48
52
26
24
52
48
12
8
5
48
32
20
14
8
3
56
32
12
26
16
8
52
32
16
2
8
12
3
8
32
48
12
8.2484.47
4
28
64
4
6.4484.45
3
15
28
4
6
30
56
8
7.3484.46
15
10
60
40
16
9
64
36
31
19
62
38
21
4
84
16
22
3
88
12
43
7
86
14
Results
1
7
16
1
2 = 0.32
SD = 1
p = 0.57
2 = 0.65
SD = 2
p = 0.72
2 = 1.97
SD = 3
p = 0.58
t = 1.425, p = 0.160
2 = 0.85
SD = 1
p = 0.77
2 = 1.66
SD = 1
p = 0.68
227
Treatment
Urgency
Yes
No
Frequency
Yes
No
Nocturia
Yes
No
Urinary incontinence types
Stress incontinence
Urge incontinence
Mixed incontinence
Continenta
Frequency of urinary incontinence
1 or more in a day
1 or more in a week
A few times in a month
Continent
a
Control
15
10
60
40
19
6
76
24
34
16
68
32
18
7
72
28
16
9
64
36
34
16
68
32
17
8
68
32
14
11
56
44
31
19
62
38
3
6
13
3
12
24
52
12
2
15
7
1
8
60
28
4
5
21
20
4
10
42
40
8
12
7
3
3
48
28
12
12
14
7
3
1
56
28
12
4
26
14
6
4
52
28
12
8
2 = 1.47
SD = 1
p = 0.225
2 = 0.37
SD = 1
p = 0.544
2 = 0.76
SD = 1
p = 0.382
2 = 5.08
SD = 2
p = 0.079
2 = 6.05
SD = 3
p = 0.109
Total
Gerontology 2008;54:224231
Comparison
categories and
time/result
Treatment
Control
Urgency
Pretreatment and 8-week evaluations
13
52
4
Decreased
1
4
3
Increased
Unchanged
11
44
18
Pretreatment and 6-month evaluations
Decreased
13
52
4
Increased
2
8
0
Unchanged
10
40
18
8-week and 6-month evaluations
Decreased1
Increased
1
4
Unchanged
24
96
25
Frequency
Pretreatment and 8-week evaluations
Decreased
16
64
3
Increased
4
Unchanged
9
36
18
Pretreatment and 6-month evaluations
3
52
13
Decreased
4
4
1
Increased
18
44
11
Unchanged
8-week and 6-month evaluations
Decreased
3
12
Increased1
Unchanged
22
88
25
Nocturia
Pretreatment and 8-week evaluations
Decreased
8
32
Increased1
1
4
3
Unchanged
16
64
22
Pretreatment and 6-month evaluations
56
14
Decreased
3
4
1
Increased
22
40
10
Unchanged
8-week and 6-month evaluations
28
7
Decreased
4
1
Increased1
25
68
17
Unchanged
1
2
16
12
72
2 = 7.45
SD = 2
p = 0.024
16
12
72
2 = 7.25
SD = 2
p = 0.027
100
2 = 1.02
SD = 1
p = 0.312
12
16
72
2 = 15.89
SD = 2
p = 0.000
12
16
72
2 = 15.89
SD = 2
p = 0.008
100
2 = 3.19
SD = 1
p = 0.074
12
88
p = 0.0042
12
88
2 = 19.50
SD = 2
p = 0.000
100
p = 0.0042
Discussion
229
Table 5. The distribution of the data for the pad test at pretreatment, 8-week and 6-month evaluations
Comparison times
Pad test
result
Treatment
Control
MannWhitney test
Av. rank
Av. rank
decreased
increased
unchanged
17
32
68
33.58
12
13
48
52
17.42
U = 110.5
z = 4.44
p = 0.000
decreased
increased
unchanged
5
1
19
20
4
76
36.10
21
4
84
16
14.90
U = 47.5
z = 5.47
p = 0.000
decreased
increased
unchanged
4
21
16
84
27.98
10
15
40
60
23.02
U = 250.5
z = 1.53
p = 0.126
Table 6. The distribution of the data for pelvic floor muscle strength at pretreatment, 8-week and 6-month evaluations
Comparison times
Pelvic floor
muscle
strength
Treatment
n
Av. rank
Av. rank
decreased
increased
unchanged
14
11
56
44
18.06
23
92
32.94
U = 126.5
z = 4.43
p = 0.000
decreased
increased
unchanged
15
10
60
40
17.60
23
92
33.40
U = 115
z = 4.56
p = 0.000
decreased
increased
unchanged
7
18
28
72
22.00
25
100
29.00
U = 225
z = 2.82
p = 0.005
Gerontology 2008;54:224231
Control
MannWhitney test
was concluded that the complaints of women had significantly decreased, and as a result the negative effects on
the quality of life decreased.
In conclusion, bladder training and PFME administered to elderly women are very effective in decreasing
urinary complaints, increasing the strength of the pelvic floor muscles and increasing the quality of life at a
rest home. Behavioral therapy can be used easily as an effective treatment for urinary incontinence in elderly
women.
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by the Research Fund of the Marmara University. Project number: SAG-078/12052003.
Appendix 1
Instructions for the Pelvic Floor Muscle Exercises
Empty the bladder before performing the exercises
Wear comfortable clothing
If you do the exercises lying down, you should elevate your
head with a pillow
Lie down with your knees bent
Take a deep breath first
Focus on relaxing the body and concentrate on the muscles in
the vagina-anus area
Contract the muscles around the vagina-anus as if you are trying to prevent yourself from urinating or breaking wind and
pull the muscles inward
References
1 Abrams P, Cardozo L, Fall M, et al: The standardization of terminology of lower urinary
tract function: report from the Standardization Sub-committee of the International
Continence Society. Neurourol Urodyn
2002;21:167178.
2 Fonda D: Management of the incontinent
older people. Int Continence Surv 1995; 2:
29.
3 Grimby A, Milsom I, Molander U, et al: The
influence of urinary incontinence on the
quality of life of elderly women. Age Ageing
1993;22:8289.
4 Ouslander JG, Schnelle JF: Incontinence in
the nursing home. Ann Intern Med 1995;
122:438449.
5 Weis BD: Diagnostic evaluation of urinary
incontinence in geriatric patients. Am Fam
Physician 1998;57:26752684, 26882690.
6 Aslan E, Kzlkaya Beji N, Erkan Ayyldz H,
Yalcn O: Incontinence and its effects on
quality of life of older people living in residential and nursing homes. Joint Meet Int
Continence Soc and Int Urogynecol Assoc,
Paris, August 2004, poster No. 428, pp 23
27.
7 Minossion VA, Drutz HP, Al-Badr A: Urinary incontinence as a worldwide problem.
Int J Gynecol Obstet 2003;82: 327338.
8 Kelleher C: Quality of life and urinary incontinence; in Cardozo L, Staskin D (eds): Textbook of Female Urology and Urogynaecology. London, Isis Medical Media, 2001, pp
4858.
9 Folstein MF, McHugh PR: Mini-mental state
examination: a practical method of grading
the cognitive state of patients for the clinician. J Psychiatr Res 1975;12:189198.
10 Wade DT: Measurement in Neurological Rehabilitation. New York, Oxford University
Press, 1992, pp 90, 239.
11 Pierson CA: Pad testing, nursing interventions, and urine loss appliances; in Ostergard
RD, Bent EA (eds): Urogynecology and Urodynamics Theory and Practice, ed 4. London, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 1991,
pp 251269.
12 Thomas TM, Plymat KR, Blannin J, Meade
TW: Prevalence of urinary incontinence. Br
Med J 1980;281:12431245.
13 Adams C, Frahm J: Genitourinary system; in
Myers RS (ed): Saunders Manual of Physical
Therapy Practice. Philadelphia, Saunders,
1995, pp 459504.
14 Amuzu BJ: Nonsurgical therapies for urinary incontinence. Clin Obstet Gynecol
1998;3:702711.
15 Bo K, Berghmans LCM: Nonpharmacologic
treatments for overactive bladder-pelvic
floor exercises. Urology 2000; 55(suppl 5A):
711.
Gerontology 2008;54:224231
231
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.