Professional Documents
Culture Documents
June 2015
Table of Contents
Cluster Study Overview
Participant Overview
10
17
24
28
30
Organizations posit that if youth have meaningful engagements with their environment,
then they will be stewards for their environment, regardless of the pathway they choose
(e.g. they can seek careers in non-environmental fields and still work towards conservation).
This cluster hoped to explore how younger youth experience the environment through their
programs and how older youth/long-term participants and/or alumni describe the impact of
their engagement in programs. Understanding how youth define and experience their
environment and later continue to make meaning of their environment, will not only help
these organizations better understand their participants, the relevance, and effectiveness of
programming, but also help the field learn from the diverse audiences that these
organizations successfully engage.
We explored:
What are the ranges of ways that young
people growing up in diverse urban
communities engage with the environment?
Richardson Bay
Audubon Center &
Sanctuary (Audubon)
operates as a program of
National Audubon Society
and focuses on waterbird
conservation. Their
Audubon Youth Leaders
program engages high
school students in
environmental education
with an emphasis on
leadership
development.
Literacy for
Environmental Justice (LEJ)
is an urban park
revitalization and community
stewardship program in
Candlestick Point State
Recreation Area. Their Bay
Youth for the Environment
program is a science-based,
after-school environmental
education work program that
engages high school aged,
community youth in the
restoration project.
Our Approach
We started the exploratory study with focus groups of youth to hear in their own
words, how they engage with the environment and how they define their
environment.
Focus Groups We then created measures to explore meaningful engagement based on what they
shared in the focus groups.
Participant
Survey
The survey had common measures across all three cluster study organizations.
Each cluster study organization administered the survey to program participants.
Five programs are represented from the San Francisco Zoo, and one program is
represented from Audubon and from Literacy for Environmental Justice.
Limitations
Participant Overview
Kids in
Parks
The San
Francisco
Zoo
Richardson
Bay
Audubon
Center &
Sanctuary
Literacy for
Environmental
Justice
11
1
1
1
Photo Credit: SF Zoo
50%
One half of
youth invited
to take the
survey
submitted a
response.
12
100%
53 %
8
47 %
57
72
2%
68
29%
7
43%
38%
53
2%
26%
69%
57%
63%
72%
13
7
2%
American Indian/
Alaskan Native
Latino/ Hispanic
40%
13%
27%
15%
29%
14%
Latino/ Hispanic
Middle Eastern/North
African
Bi-racial/ Multi-racial/
Mixed Race
4%
14%
29%
53
American Indian/
Alaskan Native
American Indian/
Alaskan Native
25%
25%
Black/ African
American
Latino/ Hispanic
Middle Eastern/North
African
Pacific Islander/ Native
Hawaiian
Middle Eastern/North
African
Pacific Islander/ Native
Hawaiian
White/ Caucasian
White/ Caucasian
Bi-racial/ Multi-racial/
Mixed Race
14%
Bi-racial/ Multi-racial/
Mixed Race
Latino/ Hispanic
13%
43%
11%
Middle Eastern/North
African
Pacific Islander/ Native
Hawaiian
25%
13%
White/ Caucasian
Bi-racial/ Multi-racial/
Mixed Race
30%
15%
14
69
54
23%
29%
14%
86%
48%
Does not
know
Does
not
know
Receives free
or reduced
lunch lunch
Receives
free
or reduced
Does not
receive
free or
reduced
lunch
Does
not
receive
free
or reduced
lunch
The sum of the percentages may be more or less than 100% due to rounding.
15
13%
25%
26%
22%
63%
52%
<1 1-2
7
3+
<1
1-2
<1
57
<1
1-2 3+
17%
21%
43%
43%
33%
57%
40%
100%
46%
16
Environmentalism
means taking action
and helping a cause
for the environment.
-Audubon Participant
18
How
to
protect
the
environment and things in
the environment whether
its yours or not.
When youth were asked what comes to mind when they think
about the environment they shared how interconnected all
components of the environment are and how they affect each
other. Many shared specifically how humans have affected the
environment and how we need to protect and conserve it.
Youth shared that exploring or doing outdoor activities as the
main way they engage with the environment including walks
on the beach, exploring their backyard, skating through the city,
and walking in the city/nature.
Who have you learned the most about the
environment from?
a. Staff from a program I participate in
b. Myself / exploring the outdoors on my own
c. Classroom teacher
d. Television or the internet
e. Books or newspapers
f.. My parent or legal guardian
g. My friends
h. Sisters or brothers
i. Other members of the community
j. Other
k. Grandparents
l. Other family members
19
Percentage
Checked
(n=72)
29%
19%
19%
8%
6%
6%
4%
3%
3%
3%
0%
0%
3%
No, I
disagree
(2)
0%
Yes, I
agree
(3)
36%
Yes! I
strongly
agree
(4)
61%
0%
6%
34%
59%
3.5
0%
4%
40%
56%
3.5
0%
3%
44%
54%
3.5
3%
11%
11%
9%
15%
17%
49%
33%
44%
48%
26%
30%
49%
56%
44%
43%
55%
50%
3.5
3.5
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.3
9%
44%
46%
3.3
17%
36%
44%
3.2
17%
37%
37%
3.0
No! I
strongly
disagree
(1)
Average
(n=54-70)
3.6
0%
e. Learned more about the environment around me
0%
f. Engaged in hands-on activities
0%
g. Created something or worked with my hands
0%
h. Expanded my sense of community
5%
i. Practiced being a leader
3%
j. Was challenged to get out of my comfort zone
k. Shared my experiences with others (such as pointing out a
plant or animal to a friend or parent, discussing something I
1%
learned in program, etc.)
3%
l. Worked hard to build something
m. Went on cool trips (such as hiking, canoeing, backpacking,
9%
camping, etc.)
The sum of the percentages may be more or less than 100% due to rounding.
When looking at the measure about challenging youth out of their comfort zone in comparison to measures about
the changes they experienced as a result of participating in these programs, youth report stronger agreement
with: being more aware of their surroundings***, understanding how the personal choices they make each day
affect the environment***, in speaking up and talking with friends and family about issues that affect the
environment**, in thinking about the things they want to change in the environment**, and in thinking about the
environment on a more personal level than they did before**.
* = p<.05; ** = p<.01; *** = p<.001
20
Percentage
Checked
(n=72)
Percentage
Checked
(n=72)
21
NOT AT
ALL
Valuable
A LITTLE
Valuable
2%
2%
a. Spending time in nature
2%
3%
b. Hands on learning
0%
4%
c. Doing fun activities outdoors
1%
3%
d. Exploring outdoors
0%
6%
e. Learning about the environment and different species
2%
6%
f. Creating or working with my hands
3%
6%
g. Trying new things
0%
9%
h. Learning specific skills
3%
5%
i. Becoming more familiar with my surroundings
0%
14%
j. Meeting new people/making new friends
5%
9%
k. Field trips
3%
16%
l. Spending time with friends
3%
19%
m. Sharing what I learn with others
5%
19%
n. Classroom instruction
5%
29%
o. Class projects
The sum of the percentages may be more or less than 100% due to rounding.
Valuable
VERY
Valuable
Average
21%
23%
27%
26%
25%
25%
24%
32%
42%
35%
40%
39%
52%
63%
47%
76%
73%
69%
67%
69%
67%
68%
59%
51%
51%
46%
42%
27%
14%
19%
3.7
3.7
3.6
3.6
3.6
3.6
3.6
3.5
3.4
3.4
3.3
3.2
3.0
2.8
2.8
(n=57-71)
22
No change
(1)
I feel A
LITTLE more
comfortable
(2)
9%
7%
a. Talking to others about the environment
9%
11%
b. Helping the environment
11%
12%
c. Observing nature
9%
14%
d. Talking to others about animals or insects
12%
11%
e. Observing animals or insects
12%
10%
f. Exploring nature
16%
14%
g. Handling animals or insects
16%
16%
h. Hiking
15%
21%
i. Gardening
23%
13%
j. Camping
16%
16%
k. Exploring the city or Bay Area
26%
27%
l. Exploring my local neighborhood
43%
16%
m. Exploring my front or back yard
The sum of the percentages may be more or less than 100% due to rounding.
I feel More
comfortable
(3)
49%
41%
38%
42%
44%
52%
34%
43%
40%
34%
54%
30%
31%
I feel A LOT
More
comfortable
-LEJ Participant
Average
(n=56-70)
(4)
36%
39%
39%
35%
33%
27%
36%
25%
24%
30%
13%
17%
10%
3.1
3.1
3.1
3.0
3.0
2.9
2.9
2.8
2.7
2.7
2.6
2.4
2.1
We see highest ratings for increased comfort in observing nature, talking to others
about the environment, and helping the environment (avg.=3.1).
Youth who found it easiest to explore the environment when they have program
staff teach them about the environment were more likely to report feeling more
comfortable exploring the city or Bay Area (avg.=2.8)*.
* = p<.05; ** = p<.01; *** = p<.001
23
25
No Change
A Little Change
More
A Lot More
Average
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(n=65-69)
7%
6%
7%
7%
9%
11%
11%
12%
10%
16%
18%
15%
13%
15%
17%
12%
46%
43%
37%
43%
37%
33%
32%
38%
36%
34%
38%
35%
40%
41%
40%
38%
3.1
3.1
3.1
3.1
3.1
3.0
3.0
3.0
9%
21%
30%
40%
3.0
10%
13%
42%
35%
3.0
9%
13%
13%
9%
20%
20%
21%
20%
18%
15%
25%
12%
23%
21%
33%
31%
37%
38%
35%
31%
39%
38%
38%
35%
28%
33%
26%
19%
3.0
2.9
2.9
2.9
2.8
2.6
2.6
Youth who found it easiest to explore the environment when they have program staff teach them about the environment were more likely to report:
o Feeling safe being outdoors (average=3.0)***.
o Being interested in learning more about the environment (average=3.4)**.
o Being more aware of their surroundings (average=3.4)**.
o Understanding how the personal choices they make each day affect the environment (average=3.4)**.
o Speaking up and talking with friends and family about issues that affect the environment (average=3.2)**.
o Feeling a personal responsibility to help protect the environment (average=3.3)*.
o Being interested in helping the environment through whatever career they choose, even if it is not directly related to the environment
(average=3.3)*.
o Thinking about things they want to change in the environment (average=3.2)*.
o Being more aware of environmental issues facing their community (average=3.2)*.
* = p<.05; ** = p<.01; *** = p<.001
Meaningful Engagement Is
I have been able to participate in
the process of restoring native
populations in my community,
and observe nature and how it is
affected directly. This is very
important to me, because it
gives me an opportunity to step
up and participate, instead of
merely watching others do the
work.
-LEJ Participant
26
In focus groups, youth indicated an array of ways they will use what they have learned about the
environment in their future including going outside more, consider how their actions affect the
environment and changing their behaviors to support the environment, continuing to learn and
share environmental knowledge, and going into environmental careers.
In open-ended responses, many youth shared that they have plans to pursue majors that will teach
them more about the environment. Furthermore, youth report an expanded sense of future
opportunities and many are interested in using their career to care for the environment.
How interested are you in participating
in the following activities in the future?
Not at all
interested
(1)
A little
interested
(2)
Interested
(3)
a. Exploring nature
b. Helping the environment
c. Observing nature
d. Hiking
e. Handling animals or insects
f. Exploring the city
g. Camping
h. Talking to others about animals or insects
i. Talking to others about the environment
j. Observing animals or insects
k. Gardening
l. Exploring my local neighborhood
m. Exploring my front or back yard
0%
2%
0%
2%
3%
3%
4%
3%
2%
4%
5%
6%
14%
9%
9%
12%
16%
15%
9%
15%
16%
19%
13%
20%
22%
24%
20%
27%
37%
24%
25%
36%
23%
29%
29%
38%
36%
39%
41%
The sum of the percentages may be more or less than 100% due to rounding.
Very
interested
(4)
71%
63%
52%
58%
58%
52%
58%
52%
50%
45%
39%
33%
21%
Average
(n=63-69)
3.6
3.5
3.4
3.4
3.4
3.4
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.2
3.1
3.0
2.7
Youth who found it easiest to explore the environment when they have friends to explore the
environment with were more likely to report wanting to explore the city in the future
(average=3.5)*.
* = p<.05; ** = p<.01; *** = p<.001
29
31
www.learningforaction.com
170 Capp Street, Suite C | San Francisco, CA 94110